Abreu v. Alutiiq-Mele, LLC

Filing 64

ORDER ADOPTING IN PART REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; denying 43 Motion for Sanctions; adopting in part Report and Recommendations re 58 Report and Recommendations. Certificate of Appealability: No Ruling Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 9/24/2012. (cqs)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.11 20888- V - TZ/ M ON TON
Cl SEI SI
NADJA ABREU,
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.

ALUTIQ- ELE,LLC,
I M
Def nda .
e nt
ORDER ADOPTI I PART REPORT AND RECOM M ENDATI AND DENYI
NG N
ON
NG
M O TI N FO R SA NC TI N S
O
O

THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on M a sr t J e Si on on' Re t a
S
s f e he
t
gitae udg
m t s por nd

Re o n ai n Re De yn Dee d ns M o in f rS ncin ( 58 , ih r c mme d
c mme d to : n ig fn a t' to o a to s DE- ) wh c e o n s
de ngDef nt 'M otonsf rSa tonsm a pur ua t Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e 11
nyi
enda s
i o nci
de s nt o de a
e
vi oc dur

a 28U. C.j 1
nd
S.
927.TheRe ta Rec
por nd omme ton ( por)f t tt rcor doe not
ndai Re t ound ha he e d s
s ppor aba i f s nctonsa i tPl i if Thef usoft Re ti t c
u
t ss or a i
ga ns antf.
oc
he por s he onduc ofPl ntf '
t
ai ifs
c
ouns ,Er n Ros nber The Re tconcudest tc
el wi
e g.
por
l
ha ouns ' aci alo do notwa r ntt
els tons s
ra he
i
mposton ofs nc i .
ii
a tons

De e d n sh v fldo j ci n t t eRe r ( 5 1 t wh c M r Ro e b r ha fld
fn a t a e ie be to s o h po t DE- 9 ,o ih . s n e g s ie
ade l'( 6 ) a dDet d n sh v fldar pyb if( 6 1 Ha i c rf l rv e d de
t py'DE- 0 , n fn a t a e ie e l re DE- 3 . vng a eu l e iwe ,
r
y
nov M agita eJ
o,
sr t udgeSi
mont st r hRe r a Re om menda i a her c d,heCo t
on' ho oug po t nd c
ton ndt e or t
ur
a fr sa adopt t Re te pta s touthe enast pa tc a Gndi ofunr as
fim nd
s he por, xce s e
r i o riul r
ngs
e onabl a
e nd
ve i us be vi by Pl ntf couns l Appl ng t r e ntc s l w t t t t lt oft
xato
ha or
ai ifs
e.
yi he el va a e a o he o aiy he

cr um sa s M r Ros nbe g' a i ns whi h bor ron i
ic t nce , . e r s cto , c
de
ncompe e ,do no wa ts nc i .
t nt
t nan a tons
The e o e De e nt ' o i f Sa tonsi denid.Howe r t r cor i hi c er te t t t
r f r , f nda s M ton or nc i s e
ve ,he e d nt s as el c s ha

M r Ros nbe gne dsr medila ssa e.The ef e, wil r e r d t t Ad HocComm it e
. e r e e
a s it nc
r or he l be ef re o he
te
on Ator y Adm isons Pe rRe e a Ator y Gre nceoft Sout r DititofFl i
t ne
s i , e vi w, nd t ne i va
ht
he n src
ordal
f me orng,s r ii a moniorng t e ur t thi flngsi t Sout r Dititof
or nt i upe v son, nd
t i o ns e ha s ii
n he
he n src
Fl i e t hesa r ofpr e sona im t t heCour e c sfom at e p a tcngbe or
ordam e t t nda ds
of s i ls ha t
t xpe t r tom ys r c ii
f e
1
*.
t

1 B ac ound
.
kgr

TheRe ts t outi de a l hef t a pr edur lhit yoft sm at r t whi h net r
por e s
n t i t ac s nd oc a sor
hi te ,o c ihe

sd h s b e td. rf r ,h Co rwi no rieaet ef csgv n rs t t s n to moin
i e a o j ce Theeo e t e u t l t etrt h a t ii g ie o he a cins to
l
a a t t Re tsr ct ton oft f csa pr ed alhit y. De e nt M oton s ks
nd dop s he por' e ia i
he a t nd oc ur sor
f nda s' i ee

sncinsba e onsvea ditnc a i Mr Ros nbe gt i ltgai t sc e: )hena d
a to s d e rl si t ctons . e r ook n ii tng hi as (1
me
Alti M ee a Al iq Gl laspa tes de piet f c t tPl i ipse o rwa Al iq
u iq- l nd uti oba
ri , s t he a t ha antf mpl ye s uti

3SG;( he ne r pr ry s r d Al iq Gl lorAl iq 3SG;( he unr s bl a
2)
ve opel eve uti oba
uti
3)
ea ona y nd

ve aiu l mutp id t p o e d n s a d ( )t S c n Ame e Co an wa fioo ,
x to sy lile he r c e i g ; n 4 he e o d
nd d mpli t s rv lus
unr as bl a wihout ou aton.l a es i t s a g e s t Re toundt t ai if
e ona e, nd t f nd i n ddr sng he e r um nt ,he por f
ha Pl ntf
hadawe butno fi o , ssf nami Al iq- el a aDef nta a s ha aba i f
ak,
t rvol us ba i or
ng uti M e s
enda nd lo d ss or
na ng Al iq Gl lasaDe e n . The Re talo f
mi
uti oba
f nda t
por s ound t tPli ifha awea butnot
ha antf d
k,

fi ous a gum e r gadi whe he t gre nc pr ed e i t c l ci ba gani
rvol , r
nt e r ng
t r he iva e oc ur s n he ole tve r i ng
a e m e we e manda o y. Fi ly,t Re tf
gr e nt r
tr
na l he por ound t Pl i if sf l e t pr l s ve
hat antf ' aiur o opery er

De e d n sdd n twarn s n to u d r j 1 2 a d c ud n ts r a ab ssfrRul 1
fn a t i o ra t a cins n e 9 7 n o l o eve s a i o
e 1

l ' Cour wilalo s nd ac oft sOr rt The Fl i Ba smpl f is
'he
T
t l s e
opy hi de o
orda r i y or t
i or a i
nf m ton.
2

s nc i be a eDefnda sha f l t c
a tons c us
e nt d aied o ompl wih Rul 1 ' s f ha borpr sonr r ng
y t
e 1s a e r
ovii ega di
t si s
hi s ue.

I .Obj tons
I
eci
Dee d nsr ief u o j cin t teRe o t( )t Re o t p ist ewr n sa d r
f n a t as o r be to s o h p r: 1 he p r a pl h o g tn ads
e

f ra r n â1 2 sn to a dRue1 sncins ( ) h Re o t o sn t iep o r ih t
o wadig 9 7 a cins n l 1 a to ;2 t e p r d e o gv r pe weg t o
t sCour' n r a
hi
ts umeous dmonii t Pli ifsc el( t Re ti opel c i r t t
tons o antf ouns ; 3) ht por mpr ry onsde s ha
Pli ift o ht s mecouns lhasfldas co lws t ai t fndant;nd( t Re t
antf,hr ug he a
e,
e e nd a uiag ns Dee
sa 4)he por
f is t c i t t a iy ofPl ntf' c
al o onsder he ot lt
ai ifs ouns ' a tons a i t d,a l es e h a ton
els ci
nd, nsea na yz ac c i

idv d al .Th Co r wil d r s e c o te eo j cins i o d r
n ii u ly e u t la d e s a h f h s be to ,n r e .
W. TheRe t
por Appled t Cor e St
i he r ct andar
ds

Dee a t d n tral t k is wi t e j 1 2 sa ad sto ti t Re o t b t
fnd n s o o e l a e sue t h
y
h
9 7 tnd r e u n he p r, u,
i t d, a i s wihhow t M agita eJ eappledt sa r t t cr
nsea t ke s ue t
he
sr t udg
i he t nda d o he icumsa soft s
t nce
hi
c e. De en s do tke is wih t Rul 11 sanda d a i d i t Re t s c fca l
as
f dant
a s ue t he e
t r pple n he por; pe ii ly,

De e d n stk is ewiht sae n t tf to a oi Ru e1 sn to s ho v r Plitf s
fn a t a e su t he ttme tha s l v d l 1 a ci n , we e , an if
E
a g nt)mus bemor t n fi ous' Dee nt aguet tt si hol ngt Pli ift a
r ume s t
e ha rvol . fnda s r ha hi s di he antf o
'
l rsa r t n i r r d.De e nt ,
owe t nda d ha s equie
f nda s howe r appe t m ic tuet ssa e e t W hie
ve , ar o s onsr hi tt m n .
l

a mi e l usn a wadp r sn teRe o ti l sae ta Plitf i n t u j c t s n to s
d t dy ig wk r h a ig,h p r smpy tts h t an if s o s be to a cin
t
i he a to ar notfi ous Thus t Repor di notappl a i r tRul 11sa r a
f r c i ns e
rvol .
,he
t d
y n ncorec
e
tnda d nd

De e d n s o j ci nr g r i gt eRul 1 sa dadi o e e
fn a t' b e to e ad n h e 1 tn r s v nuld.
Assto ta v , f n a t o j c t t e M a itaeJ d e sa pl ai n o t e j 1 2
e u bo e De e d n s be t o h g sr t u g ' p i to f h 9 7
c
sa r Unde j 1 acour Sma 'i ee es coss expe es a at ne 'fesonan
tndad.
r 927
tl y' mpos xc s t, ns , nd tor ys e
y
at ne t
tor y d s m uli est pr e di i a c e un eas bl and ve tousy. 28U . C.
who o
tpl he oc e ngs n ny as r ona y
xai l '
'
S.
3

j1 27.Thed yf unl ki 'heCour' powe t s nci unde 28U. C. 19 i afndi
9
t or oc ng't
ke
ts
r o a ton
r
S. j 27 s i ng

of dfih. a esv NASCO, n .5 U. 3 , 5 4 ( 9 ) No eu v De n ' I c, 28
ba at Ch mb r .
I c, 01 S. 2 4 - 6 1 91 ; r ls . n y s n .6
,
F.d 1 7 ,1 8 ( 1hCi. 01 )Th b dfihsa d r l o sa t eat r e so j ci ec n u t
3 2 0 2 2 1 t r 2 0 . e a at tn a d o k t h to n y' b e tv o d c.
Nor l s, 28F. a 1
eu 6
3d t 282.Eveni aCour fndsana t ne a t dwihba f ih, hei
f
ti
tor y c e t d at t mposton of
ii

sn to u d rj1 2 rman amatro ds rto 2 U. C. 1 2 Ch mb r , 01U. a 4
a cins n e 9 7 e is te f icein. 8 S. j 9 7; a e s 5
S.t 4.
De e nt a guet tPl ntf sc
f nda s r
ha ai if ouns lunr s na y a ve tousy muli id t pr e ngs
e ea o bl nd xa i l
tple he oc edi

by c i ng t na Al iq- el asa pa t f ii t pr pe l s r t ot rDe e nt ,a
ontnui o me uti M e
ry, a lng o o ry e ve he he f nda s nd
by ne rs ti f lh acl m t co d wihsa amoton t dimis.
ve etng o'
t
ai hat ul t t nd
i o s s
Addr s i t l tie frt no de e m i ton was made r ga di whe he Pl ntf
e sng he as t m is ,
t r na i
e r ng
t r ai if

e nt ly sa e acli upo whih r le c dbegr nt da t Co t l no dos now .Thus
ve ual t t d a m
n c ei f oul
a e nd he ur wil t o
,
t s a g e does no s
hi r um nt
t uppor s tons Furhe m or t Cour ag e wih t Re tt t
t anci .
t r t, he
t r es t he por ha

Pl ntf sc
ai if ouns l daba i t na emuli eAl iqe ii sa Def nda sba e ont cop or t
e ha
ss o m
tpl uti ntte s e nt s d he
ae
r rss
epo t howi i e l ki me be s pa owne s pofheLLCSa t f c t t hedocu e s
ng nt roc ng m r hi nd
r hi t
nd he a t ha t
m nt
a i s - t c lc i ba g ni a r me a Pl ntf st nni ton lte - ha t na e of
t s ue he ole tve r ai ng g ee nt nd ai if e na i et r d he m s

dif e Al ti e iison t m t n t e tt t tac ua l e oye Pl i if W hiePl i if
fer nt u iq ntte
he ha he n iy ha t ly mpl d antf .
l antf
f ied t do a dic y t s
al o
ny s over o uppor he c e ton t tal oft A lti en ii we e pr r
t r ont n i ha 1 he u iq ttes r ope
pa te ,t tdoe notm e n t tnami t m wasunr as na eorve tous
ris ha
s
a ha
ng he
e o bl
xa i .
Fi ly,heCour doe a eet t antf sat mptt s r Al iq Gl la Al iq 3SG
nal t
t s gr ha Pl i if te
o e ve uti oba nd uti

b c ri edmai wasurr as bl a ve tous.Ast Cour not di isOr rGr ntngM o i
y e tt
i
l
le ona e nd xa i
he
t e n t de a i
ton

t Dimis( 37) çher i nor a diput t ts r ceby c ri dmaldoe notcompl wih
o s s DE- ,s e s e l s e ha evi
t
e tfe i s
y t
f de a r e orFl i l ' The 1w i t Elve h Cic ti cea on t si s Pl ntf s
e r l uls
orda aw.
'
a n he e nt r ui s l r hi s ue. ai if

c
ouns l eledonc esfom Ka a a
er i
as r
ns s ndpem s va at s
l yl ni o uppor hi postont t e viebyc riid
t s ii hà s r c
e tfe
4

maii a c a e.Howe r t t ela ewasunr as bl gi nt t he ei Elve hCic tlw
l s c eptbl
ve ,ha r i nc
e ona e ve ha t r s e nt r ui a
die ty on poi a t t i a herc e be or t sCour i whi h Pl i ifsco e ha be n
rcl
nt nd ha , n not as f e hi
tn
c antf
uns l d e
i ve t Cour ha r a he t exa ts mec uson.W hiet Cour r cogniest tapary
nvol d,he
t d e c d he c a oncl i
l he
te
z ha
t
m a m a a g e st ta tmptt modiy orc nget lw , r e ofPli ifsr s et
y ke r um nt ha te
o
f
ha
he a a eviw
antf e pons o

t M oi t Dimi s doe noti c t t tc
he ton o s s , s
ndi a e ha ouns lwasa gui f ac
e
r ng or hangeormodiiato of
fc i n
t lw .l f c , ouns doe note nr ogni wha t l i ont sis i t scr ui.Thus
he a n a t c
el s
ve ec ze t he aw s hi s ue n hi ic t
,
c
ouns l
e doesnota guet tt 1w i i ore tors dbemodii Cons nty,heCour fnds
r ha he a s nc r c houl
fed.
eque l t
ti
t t a n ifsco e ' a gum e sr ga di s r c byc rii dma l ndhi s r c ofAl ti 3SG
ha Pli tf
uns ls r
nt e r ng e vi e e tfe i a
s e vi e
u iq
a Al iq Gl lby c rii ma lwe eunr s bl a ve tousa ma i bad f ih.
nd uti oba
e tfed i r
ea ona e nd xa i
nd de n
at

Howe r Pl i ifs f iur t pr pe l s r Al iq 3SG and Al iq Gl
ve , antf a l e o o ry e ve uti
uti obaldi no
d t
e ul he m ope e vce
e nt nc ude n he r i n
muli yt pr ee ngs.Asar s toft i pr rs r i ,Def nda si l d i t i m oto
tpl he oc di
t di misas ton a gui t ts r c wa i ope Ha Alti 3SG a Al iq Gl ba bee
o s s ec i r ng ha e vi e s mpr r. d u iq
nd uti o l n

pr rys r d,
ope l e ve howe r t ysilwoul ha fl amotont dim isr ii t o he a g e s
ve ,he tl
d ve ied
i o s s a sng he t r r um nt
t tt y di r ie i t rm oto The onl a to lpr ee ng t tf l wed t m o i t
ha he d as n hei
in.
y ddii na oc di ha olo
he ton o
dim iswa Al iq 3SG a Al iq Gl ba ' r s
s s s uti
nd uti o ls e pons t Pl i ifsM oton f a Ext nson o
e o antf
i or n e i f
Ti e a Lea t Ser Per o Pr es . Thus Al iq 3SG a Al iq Gl ba onl ha t
m nd
ve o ve s nal oc s
, uti
nd uti o l y d o
r s ndt oneflngt whih t y woul noto he wieha ha t r pond.Thi doesnota o t
e po o
ii o c he
d
t r s ve d o es
s
m un

t s h a muli iaton of t pr e ngs t t woul wa
o uc
tplc i
he oce di
ha
d nunt s nci unde j 1 27.
a tons
r
9

Co e u nl,hi o j cin i o e e
nsq e t t s be t s v nuld.
y
o
#. T eRe r Do sNo I n r t sCo r 'Admo to st Pl it ' Co n e
h po t e t g o e hi u tJ
ni n o an t s u s l
i
Basd ont sCour' wa ngst Pl nifsc elDee nt ob e tt t Magitae
e
hi
ts mi o aitf' ouns , fnda s j c o he
srt
J
udge sco l i t ts nc i a e notwa r e The r c d i cla t tt s Cour wa ne
' ncuson ha a tons r
rantd.
e or s e r ha hi
t r d
5

Pl ntf sc uns ls ve a tm e i t Or rGr ntng M o i t Ame a Denyi M oton t
ai if o e e r l i s n he de a i
ton o
nd nd
ng
i o

Dimisa M o tg 1 )t tc un e n e e t e s r ta t ef css p o td p s n cams
s s s o DE- 8 ha o s l e d d o n u e h t h a t u p re uruig li
agans a lDef nt a t tc
i t 1
enda s nd ha ouns lnee d t e ur t t Pl i ifhad c
e
de o ns e ha antf
omple wih t
id t he

ma t y gre ncepr dur be or t i a ame d compl i . Howe r ass ou i t
ndaor iva
oce e f e slng n
nde
ant
ve , et t n he
Re ta a
por, nd bove Pl ntf couns hadaf ct ba i onwhi t r s t c a m sa i tAl iq, ai ifs
el
a ual s s
ch o e t he l i ga ns uti
M eea Al iqGl .Furhe yhe ewasnoe de es it dt esa ihedt Pli if d
l nd uti obal t rt r
vi nc ubm te hat t bls hat a ntf ha
acua l f l d t c
t ly aie o ompl wih t m a t y gre nc pr edur s s t ou i t coleci
y t he nda or iva e oc e e t n he l tve
ba gani a e nt Thus t Cour' wa ni t Pli if sco e,whiepl i y u e d,
r i ng gr eme .
, he
ts r ngs o a ntf
uns l l anl nhe de

a eno abai t warn t ei o iino s n to sa dti o j cin i o er ldz
r t ss o ra t h mp sto f a ci n n h s b e to s v ru e .

C T eRe r 'Co sd r ino h S c n La utIW.No I o r
h po ts n ieat fte e o d ws i I C t mprpe
o
Dee da t o j c t t eRe o tsrla c o t ef c t tP an ifha fldan w lws i
fn ns be t o h p r' ein e n h a tha litf s ie e a ut
a i tAl iq 3SG a isc l i t tDef nda sac eve apr dur vi or notavit y
gans uti
nd t onc uson ha
e nt hi d oce al ct y,
cor
o t me is W hiet Re tdi not t tPl ntf ha fl d as cond l ws t i di s i t
n he rt.
l he por d e ha ai if s e
e
a ui, t d o n he
c e ofnotngt t ai it cli agans Al iq3SG a Al iqGl ba we ene rdeat t
ont xt
i ha Pl ntf's a ms i t uti
nd uti o l r ve
lwih

on t m e isi t i t ntc s Thus t Re r di noti pr ry r l on t e sene oft
he rt n he nsa a e.
, he po t d
m ope l ey he xit e he
l t rl w s t
a e a ui .

Dee a t frh ro j c t t ec n lso t a t eDee d n so ya he e ap o e u a
fnd ns u te b e t o h o cu in h t h fn a t nl c iv d r c d r l
vco yg v nt a Alti - l wa g a tds mmay u me t e a eiwa n t rpe p ry. e
it r i e h t uiq Mee s r n e u r j dg n b c us t s o p o r a t Th

z an ifsc u e s udn t e t i r ln a c n o n hi j dg n o a to si
plitf o ns l ho l o viw h s u ig s o d nig s u me t r cin n
ti c s .Hi j d me t c o c s a d a to rte t o l o hm a alwy r Heh sb e a
h s a e s u g n , h ie , n cins el c po ry n i s a e.
a en
membe ofTheFl i Ba snc 1
r
orda r i e 999. Thef i,i ri l s edy,a c tefi i nt
a r mpa ta , pe
nd os- tc e

a mi srto o j sien c s i tsta e c me e o TheFlrdaBa c mmi h ms l o
d nitain f u t e e st e h t a h mb r f
c
a
o i r o t i ef r
he s l t pr e sona e e lncea altm e . Thus hi ow' pr e sona prde s d motva e
r ef o of s i l xc le
tli s
, s n of s i l i houl
i t

hm t s e a ssa c t i r v hsj d me th su d rtn i o p oe so a r s o sblt
i o e k s itn e o mp o e i u g n, i n e sa dng f r fsi n l e p n ii y
i
t opposngpa tes hi lgalr s a c a hi unde s a ng oft nzesofpr e e.
o
i
ri , s e e e r h, nd s
rt ndi
he l
oc dur
6

Co l a r e t a Alti- eeo tie aj d me t ntemeis Ho ve, b an n a u me t
u' ge s h t uiq M l b an d u g n o h rt. we r o tii g j dg n
t
on t m e isdoe not by is f e t bls t tPl i ifscli a ns Al iq- e ewa fi ous
he rt
s , tel, sa ih ha antf' a m gai t uti M l s rvol

o a u td t av x to smut iai n o te p o e dn s Co s q e ty ti o j ci n i
r mo ne o e ai u lpl to f h r c e ig . n e u n l, h s be to s
i c
ove r e
rul d.

D. Cou e ' Lii ton Condu tDoe NotWar antSanc i
ns ls tga i
c
s
r
tons

Dee d ns ls o j cin a p ast b mo e o a ag ntt a a o j cin t a y
fn a t' a t b e to p e r o e r f n rume h n n b e to o n
s c fcpori oft Re t Def nda sa gue t ti de i ng whehe t s ton Pl ntf s
pe ii
ton he por.
e nt r
ha n c di
t r o anci
ai if

co el t Cour s d c i r Pl ntf c e ' a tons i t s as we las ot r c es
uns , he
t houl onsde ai ips ouns ls c i n hi ,
l
he as .
De e nt not t tprort t sc e, not rc t d ar dydee m i t tc pla ewih
f nda s e ha i o hi as a he our ha lea
tr ned ha om i nc t
t cole tveba ga ni a e m e ' gre ncepr edur swa mandaor prort brngi s t
he lc i
r i ng gr e nts i va
oc e s
t y i o i ng ui.

Ho ve ,a t Cour hasnot t r i nor c d evde t tPli ifdi notc
we r s he
t
ed, he e s e or i nce ha antf d
ompl wih t
y t he
g i va e pr e es
r e nc oc dur .

Def nda sa s not t tc
e nt lo e ha ouns lcontnu t pur uet wr pa t des t notc fom
e
i ed o s he ong ry pie i e r

De enda sa wa ni fom t Cour a Pl i ifsc
f nt nd r ngs r he
t nd antf ouns li o ry s r dAl iq3SG a
e mpr pe l e ve uti
nd
Al iq Gl by ce tfe m a l des t ho di r ga di s r ceby ce tfe m a li t ot r
uti obal
rii d i, pie l ngs e r ng e vi
rii d i n wo he
c s si whih Pli tf c
ae n
c a n ips ouns lwa i ved. W hiet Cour fndst tPl i ifsc
e s nvol
l he
t i ha antf ouns ls
e'
be ors bor r on i m pe e t ti l dt Cour t c c co e ' c e tas, sam at r
havi o de s nco t nt ha t e he
t o he k uns ls r den i l a
te

o lw i doe notme tt sandadsf t i ii ofsnci unde j l
fa t s
e he t r or he mposton a tons r 927.Howeve,a
r s
sa ed e s whe e c
tt l e r , ouns lscond tdoesnotm e t lvelofpr es i im e c e by t
e'
uc
et he e
of sonals xpe t d
he
Cour.Thus M r Ros nbe g i r f re t t Ad Hoc Com mit eon Ator Admisons Pe r
t
, . e r s e e r d o he
te
t ney
si , e
Re e a Ato ne Greva oft Sout r Diti ofFl i . Ac or ngl i i he e
viw, nd t r y i nce he
he n srct
orda
c di y, t s r by
ORDERED t t
ha :

1Th Re o t n Re o n ainRe De yn Dee d ns Mo inf r n to g 5 j
. e p ra d c mme d to : n ig fn a t' to o Sa cins DE- 8
i AFFI ED ast t r c me ton t tDe e
s
RM
o he e om nda i ha f ndant 'moton be den e a i ADOPTED
s
i
i d nd s
exc ptt t e e ts tou a
e o he xt n e t bove
.

Dee d n s Ve iid M oin fr Rue 1 n Se to 1 2 Sa cins L 4 ) i
f n a t' rfe
to o l 1a d cin 9 7 n to DE-3 s
DENI
ED.
3. Er n Ros nber i r f re t t Ad Hoc Co m it on Ator y Admi sons Pe r
wi
e g s e e r d o he
m tee
t ne
si , e
Re e a Ator yGreva eoft Sout r DititofFl rdaf rm e orng, uper son, nd
vi w, nd t ne i nc
he
he n src
o i o nt i s vii a

mo ioig.
ntrn

%

Do and oRoslEo i M im i,Fl ida,t sX M dyos e e,02
xs
a fe mbr21.
t n a
or
hi
.

N

PATRI A A.SEI
CI
T
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
c
c:

A1 Couns lofRec d
1
e
or
Cln on Pa ne,
it
y Chai
r
Ad HocComm it ofAtor y Ad isons
tee
t ne
m si ,
Pee Re e a Ator Greva e
r vi w, nd t ney i nc
Hi ha & Cul rs
ns w
be ton
2525Ponc De Le Bl ,4h Fl
e
on vd. t oor
Cor lGa e ,Fl i 331
a bl s orda 34

Are Sa l ChifBr nc Di cplneCo el
lne nkt , e a h s i i
uns
TheFl i Ba
orda r
Suie M 1 Ri r t Pl a
t
00, ve ga e az
444 Brc l Ave
ike l nue
M i mi Fl i 331 - 404
a , orda 31 2

8