Pineda v. PRC, LLC

Filing 38

FINAL ORDER OF DISMISSAL Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/24/2012. (jw)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STR I CO UR T
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STRICT O F FLO RI
DA
M I M IDI I O N
A
V SI
CA SE N O .11 cv- 20894- LK
J
NAN CY PPG DA ,

Pl ntf ,
ai if
VS.

PRC,LLC

dbaP E SONRES ONS COR OM TON,
// R èII
P E P I
Def nt
enda .
/
FI AL O RD ER O F DISM I
N
SSA L

TH I C AUSE c es bef e t Cour upon D ef nts M oton f Summ a y
S
om
or he
t
enda '
i or
r

J g n ( #3 ) tldJ y 1 201 Th r i De e nts e s mmayj dg n i
ud me t DE 2 ,ie ul 6, 2. e en, fnda e ks u r u me t n
isfvo a ds s a wih p eudc ofPlitf Na yPi d s($ n a' Co an .
t a r nd imis l t rj ie
an if nc ne a' $ ed ' mplit
Pi )
Pl i ifdi notfl a r pons On Augus 23,2012,D e enda tl a Re y i Furhe
a ntf d
ie es
e,
t
f
nt s ed
pl n
t r

Su r o 1s M oin fr S
ppo t f t to o ummay J me t ( #3 . The Co tha rviwe
r udg n DE 7)
ur s e e d
D ef nda ' M oton, el ntcas l w and t r cor e denc s it i s
e nt s
i r eva
ea
he e d vi e ubm ted n uppor oft
t he
M oton. Bas upon a t ough r vi oft r d,t Cour fnds t tt r a e no
i
ed
hor
e ew
he ecor he
ti
ha he e r

ge ui is sofmaeilfc t p e l es mmayj me ti Dee a tsfvo .
n ne sue
tra a t o r cud u r udg n n fnd n ' a r
0n M a c 15, 201 Pl ntf Pi
rh
2, ai if neda fl a Com pl i alegi ge r
ied
a nt l ng nde
di c i i i r ala i ne i nts vii and r t i and br ach of i ple i
s rm naton, et i ton, glge uper s on
e enton,
e
m id n

fc c nta t Plitf alge s wa c ni ly s j ce t as x l hosiewok
a t o r c. an if le s he s o tnual ube td o e ual
y tl r
e vio n b af lo e o e , l Wrgh (( rg t';s wa tr nae b c us
n r nme t y el w mpl y e Kel i t d i h ' he s e mi t d e a e
y
W
)

s com pl i aboutt a l
he
aned
he leged s xualha as m e ;t D ef nta ed neglgenty by
e
r s nt hat enda ct
i l
not s r s ng is em pl
upe vi i t
oyees s as t i ur compla
o
o ns e
i nce w ih lw s a i t s
t a
ga ns exual
ha as m e ; a t t Def nda br che an or l em pl e contac t i uded
r s nt nd ha
e nt ea d
a
oym nt
r t hat ncl

tr pr hi tnghaa s n a d dsrmi to Co .DE #1 ! 8,38 51 5 ) On
ems o bii rsme t n ici nain.( mp1,
, ! , , 4.
J y 22, 2011 t s Cour di m ise Pl ntf cl m f Br
ul
, hi
t s s d ai i ps ai or each of I pled i Fa
m i n ct

Co ta t ( de o Pa ta M o .t Dimis DE #1 ) De e da ttld a Ame e
n r c . Or r n ril t o s s ,
3 . f n n le n
nd d

Ans ra dAf mai Dee e ( #1 )o Aug t8 2 1
we n fr tve fns s DE 4 n us , 01 .Thec s t np oc e d
a e he r e de
al w ih di cove y.
ong t s
r

On t fnal da of m oton pr tc J y 1 2012, Def
he i
y
i
ac i e, ul 6,
endant fl t i t nt
ied he ns a
M oton f Sum m ar Judgm e . Couns f Pl ntf fl a M oton t W ihdr t
i or
y
nt
el or ai if ied
i o t aw he

f l wig da ctng ir c nclbl dif r n e .( o .t W i r w,DE #3 . S x d y
olo n y, ii re o ia e fe e c s M t o t a
hd
4) i a s
lt ,t Cour gr ed Pl ntf' couns l
a er he
t ant
ai i fs
el eavet w ihdr and s a a lm a t s i t
o t aw
t yed l ter n he
cas f f t n days t gi Pi
e or ouree
o ve neda t t am ount of tm e t fnd s tt e couns .
ha
i o i ubsiut
el

( de Gr n i Le ve t W ih a DE # ) Pu s n t t Co r' Or r Gr n i g
Or r a tng a o t drw,
35 . r ua t o he u ts de a tn
Lea ng t W ihdr w ,bot t tm e f Pl ntf t obt i s tt e couns a t s a
vi o t a
h he i or ai if o a n ubs iut
el nd he t y
oft pr
he oceedi expied on A ugus 6,201 d. To da e,Pl ntf hasnotr t i new
ngs
r
t
2.1
t ai if
e a ned
couns and t r or i pr edi pr s Pl i if s Re pons w asdue on A ugus 17,
el
he ef e s oce ng o e. a ntf
s
e
t
201 As overf t da ha pas e snce t flng ofD ef nda ' M oton,t Cour
2.
ory ys ve s d i
he ii
e nts
i he
t
declnest alow any f hertm e f Pl ntf t fl a Res
i o l
urt i or ai i f o ie
pons
e.

S
ummayj me i a r praewhee te pla ngsa s pori maeil
r udg nt s pp o it
r h e di nd up t
ng tras
es a i h t tt r i no genui i s ast any m at ralf ctand t tt m ovi pa t i
t bls ha he e s
ne s ue o
ei a
ha he
ng ry s
2

e tte t j me a amatroflw.Se Fe R.Ci P.5 Ceoe Cop.v Catet
nild o udg nt s te a
e d. v. 6; ltx r . r t,
4 U. 31 32 ( 9 ) f c i d t ra' i i ma dee mi t ou c meund rt
77 S. 7, 2 1 86 .A a t s t e i l' f t y t r ne he t o
ma
e he
a i e s t ntve l w .Ander v.Lf / Lobb I ,477 U .S. 2, ( 98 ) l
pplcabl ubs a i a
son
:ery
y, nc.
24 248 1 6 . f
t r d asa whol coul notl a r tona f tfndert fnd f t nonm ovi pary,
he ecor
e
d
ead a i l ac -i
o i or he
ng t
t e i no genui i s off tf ti . SeeM atushia El I
her s
ne s ue ac or ral
s t ec ndus.Co.v Zenih Radi
.
t
o
.

Co p. 475 U. 57 5 ( 9 6) The n mo ng pa t mus s ow s c ûc f c s t
r,
S. 4, 87 1 8 .
on vi
ry t h pe i a t o
s
uppor t tt ei a ge ne di put 1
t ha her s
nui
s e. d.

By notr pondi t Def nts M oton f Sum m ar J
es
ng o
enda '
i or
y udgm e orD e e
nt
f ndant s
'
St t m e of M at r al Fac s Pl i i f f l t contadi t any evi nc s it d by
a e nt
ei
t , antf ais o
r c
de e ubm te

De e n .Pu s ntt Rul 5 e ,t Co ti pe mitd t c nsde f cs ct d wi
fnda t r ua o e 6( ) he ur s r te o o i r a t ie t
h
s
uppor by a m ovantbutl tuncontove t d by t nonm ovantasundiput d f pur s
t
ef
r re
he
s e or pose

o r lng o a s
f ui n ummayj me moin.Se Fe R.Ci P.5 e ;s eas He d v
r udg nt to e d.
v. 6() e lo a .
Cor r one Re dentalM anagem e ,A c. N o.05ne st
si i
nt
,
80280- V ,201 W L 3781288,a *
CI
0
t 2

n. ( D. a. pt 22 2 0 (i ngt tu rLo a Ru e7.( ) dl nls apa tc a
2 S. Fl Se . , 01 ) fndi ha nde c l l 5 d ,tul e s riulr

un s td fc fo ( va ts sae n i die ty a drse b ( n va tq t
dipue a t r m mo n 'q ttme t s rcl d e s d y no mo n s, he
( va t ' sae nt whih a e s p re b e de e i t r c r a e de me
mo n sl ttme s c r u po td y vi nc n he e o d, r e d
a mit d' .
d te .)
'

De e n c tn ta s mmayj d n i a pr p it i t smatrbe a e
fnda t one ds h t u r u gme t s p o rae n hi te c us
t undiput f ct s
he
s ed a s how t tD ef ndantdi nothave ac ualorcons r tve know l
ha
e
d
t
tuc i
edge
t ts xualha as m e w ast ng pl e butdi not ng abouti;Pl ntf hasnots n
ha e
r s nt
aki
ac
d hi
t ai if
how

ta s e ag d i prtci a tvt a Plitf c nn ts w a y ph ia ij r
h t he ng e n oe tve ciiy; nd an if a o ho n ysc l nu y
3

s t ned as a r s toft ale ha as m e . D ef
usai
e ul he l ged r s nt
endantr i upon t De ii of
eles
he poston
Pl i if t D ec a aton ofM a Rodr gue ,lt D e a a i ofCl rce Cam pbelz a
antf , he
lr i
bel
i z he cl r ton
ai
l, nd
t D ecl a i ofM a ga ia Fi i i s
he
ar ton
r rt ducc a3 n uppor ofisSt t m entofM a eralFac s. (
t t ae
t i
t DE

#3 . I isRe y,De e a ta g st ti t a e e o a y o posto no g n n
2) n t pl
f nd n r ue ha n he bs nc f n p ii n, e ui e
i s ofm a eralf sexi tw a r ntng a ti on a ofPl ntf cl m s ( f' Re y,
s ues
t i act s r a i
ral ny
ai ifs ai . De.s pl

DE #3 a 2) Th Co t g e s
7, t . e ur a r e .
Th Cou ttnd t tt u o to re Sae n o M ae ilFa t ( # )a
e r i s ha he nc nr vetd ttme t f tra cs DE 32 nd
t e de
he vi nce of e ed i t r cor i udi t undiput depos ton t tm ony of
f r n he e d, ncl ng he
s ed
ii es i

Plitf,ho t tDee a ti e ildt s mmayj g n i isfvoro al li .
anif s w ha fnd n s ntte o u r ud me t n t a n 1cams
A c di y,i i
cor ngl t s
OR DERED ,A DJU D GED and DECREED as f l s
olow :

1
,

De e a ts M o i n f S
f nd n '
to or umma y J gme (
r ud nt DE # ) i h r b
32 s e e y
G R AN TED .

Pli tf Co anti DI M I
a n ifs mpli s S SSED wih pr j c .
t e udi e
3.

A l pe ng m otons a e de ed asm oot
l ndi
i
r ni
.

4.

The Cl k s lCLO SE t sca e.
er hal
hi s

l b l d iu ziDee a tsS nirViePrsde t fCl n S rie , tr n tdPlitf o p o j b
Ma e Ro rg e s fnd n' e o c e i n o i t evc swho emiae aniffr o r o
e
pefr n eo Oco e 27 2 0 ( f' Sae n o Fat, # 2, t 2 )
ro ma c n tb r , 0 9. De. ttme t f csDE 3 a : 2 .
s
z a i Ca
clrce mpbelwasPli ifst m ma ront oc so whiePli ifwa as inedt De e tsSals
l
antf' ea
nage
wo ca ins l antf s sg o f ndan ' e

De at n.( f' Sae n o F cs DE # 2 a !1 )
p rme t De.s ttme t f a t: 3 , t 0 .
3 r rt Fi ci i De e ntsHuma Res lc r es t tve,who c
Ma ga ia duc a s f nda '
n otr es epr en ai
onduceda i si toni c ci
t n nve tgai n onne ton

wi a alg di ie t ewenPlit f ndW rg t ( f' Sae n of csDE#2 , t 4 )
t n l e ncd n b t e ani a
h
e
f
ih . De.s ttme t Fa t,
2 a! 0.
4

DO NE and O RDER ED i Cha ber a t Ja es La r e Ki Fe alJ tce
n
m s t he m
w enc ng der usi

Buidi and Unie St es Courhous M i i Fl i t s 24t da ofA ugus , 201
l ng
t d at
t e, am , orda, hi
h y
t
2.

YM ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J GE
CT U
CC:

Pl ntf pr s
ai if o e
Nanc Pi
y neda
1
4854 SW 1 Stee
40 r t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
96

Cou e f Dq e a
ns l or f nd nt
A l xi M ahs e Dow ns
e s
hi
Epsei Bec & Gr
t n, ker
een,P. .
C
250 Par Ave
k
nue
N e Yor N Y 1 1
w
k,
0 77
21 351 4500
2- Fax:[phone]

Emal a wns e glw.o
i: mdo @ b a c m
Arnol R i
d chard G elm an
l
4090 La
guna Stee ,2nd Fl
r t
oor
Cor Ga es FL 331
al bl ,
46
305774- 700
1
Fa 305x:
774-1
705

Emala el n@ e a c m
i: g lma bglw.o
Cl H .Rho
ara
Epsei Bec & G r n,P.
tn
ker
ee
C.
O ne Gat w a Cent
e y
er
N e a k,N J071
w r
02

Emal cho@ e lw.o
i: r bga c m

PRO HA C V
ICE

5

Pat i G .Brady
rck
Epsei Be r& Gr ne,P.
t n cke
ee
C.
One G a e a Cent
tw y
er
Newar NJ 071
k,
02

Emalpb a y@ e glw.o
i: r d b a c m
PRO H A C VICE

6