Etkin & Company, Incorporated v. SBD, LLC

Filing 95

ORDER on Informal Discovery Conference. Signed by Magistrate Judge John J. O'Sullivan on 12/8/2011. (tro)

UNI
TED STATE S D I
STR I T CO UR T
C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI N
AM
VI O
CA SE N O . 1: c 21321 JAL
: 11- v-

ETKI & COM PAN Y, NCORPOM TED ,
N
I
aDea r Cor ai
lwa e por ton,
Pli if
antf ,
V S.

SBD,
LLC,aFl i Li ied Li lt Co pa
orda m t
abiiy m ny,
De enda .
f
nt
O R DE R

Thi Ca e c m e bef e t Cour on Nove be 29, 2011 on a Dic r Hea i
s us a
or he
t
m r
s ove y
rng
r ltng t t Sufi inc ofPl ntf sAns r t l e r a oresa t De ii Daesofa
ea i o he fce y
ai if
we s o ntr og t i nd he poston t

Rul 30( ( De ii of t Dee nt a De iins of Arhur Agason a Sai
e b)6) poston
he fnda nd posto
t
tt nd r
Agas o a t Cour,ha ng hea i ar um e oft Pa tes a m a ng or lr i a t
tt n nd he
t vi
rng g nt he ri nd ki
a ulngs t he
tme of t Hea i wih t pa tes t e fe a eeng t t f m of t wrte Or r
i
he
rng, t he ri her a tr gr i o he or
he it n de
co prs ng t Co ts r i her by e er t f l i Or :
m i i he ur ' ulng, e nt s he olow ng der

ThePl i ifs lame isl e r t y Ans r t I t roga or Nos 5,6 a
antf hal
nd t nt roga or
we s o n e r t y
.
nd
t pr d t na e a a es e of a l busne s / usomer whi h we e ge al
o ovi e he m s nd ddr s s
1
i s esc t
s
c
r ner ly
r f r nc d i hi o i na a we s t l e r t i f s h busne s scusome s i whih i
e e e e n s rgi l ns r o nt roga ores or uc
i s e/ t r n
c t
hasha a busne sr l i hi wih f t pa t 1 y r . Sai Am e e s l be s r d c
d
i s eatons p t or he s 0 ea s
d
ndm nt ha l e ve m

o b f r De e e 1 , 01 . De e d n ,t c u e, n a y n a t g i c n u to wiho
r eo e c mb r 5 2 1 fn a t is o nsl a d n o e ci n o j ncin t r
n
on be fofDef nts lnotcon a ta oft i ntfe i vi l ore ii ,die ty or
hal
enda hal
t c ny he de ii d ndi dua s
nttes r c l

i r ty, wihoutt Pli ifspro wrte c e o Co ' Or . Prort c aci a
ndiecl
t
he a ntf
i r it n ons nt r ul der i o ont tng ny
t

(1 3400237855.)
01 /
1

s h busne s or c t s of EC1 f de ii ( he t n de ii of Str ks
uc
i ses
usomer
or poston ot r ha postons
abuc '
i vi l dicosd i t Pa tes r pe tve Ans r t l er t i ) Defn n '
ndi duas s l e n he ri ' es ci
wes o ntrogaores,
e da ts
Couns s lfrtcont tCouns f Pli tf t a s ofDef nda ' de ie t c a and/
el hal is
ac
el or a n if o dvie
e nts sr o ontct or

sh d es c p ro f rd p sto s l tee e tta Plitf h sa yo j cin Co n e fr
c e ul u h e s ns o e o iin . n h v n h t an if a n b e to , u s l o
Pli if s l c l Cha r wihi one we k t s he e a He rng on t r que t f t
antf ha l al
mbe s t n
e o c dul
ai
he e s or he

d so e yo a yo j cin wi bed e dwav d.
ic v r r n be to l e me ie
l
2.

The De ii of t Rul 3 b)6) De ii of t Dee nt a t
postons he e 0( (
poston
he fnda nd he

De ii ofArhurAgason a Sa iAgason s lnoto uro De e be 7 a 8,2011a
postons
t
t t nd r
tt hal
cc n c m r nd
s

p e iusy o d r d ( E.5 1 By Tu s a ,De e e 6 2 1 te P riss ala r eu o
rvo l r ee . D. 8 .
e d y c mb r , 0l , h a t h l ge p n
e
da e f t t ng oft s de ii ,as we la t de ii of W ila Et n. Unl s
t s or he aki
he e postons
l s he poston
lim ki
es
ag ee ntf at m a i daesi r c d, hede ii s l oc urasf l
r me or le tve t s ea he t
postons hal c
olows:

J r 1 201
anuay 7, 2

Rul 30( ( DepostonofSBD LLC;
e b)6)
ii

J nua y 1 201
a l 8, 2

D r Art A gat on
. hur
st

January 19,2012

Sa iA ga s on
r
tt

d. J nua y 20, 2
a r
201

W ila Et n
lim ki

I c
n onne ton wih a gume c
ci
t r
nt once ni t s fc e y ofDef nda ' doc e t
r ng he ufi i nc
e nts um n
pr ton r r ng ESI whi h wa not notce f hea i t Cour or r t Pari s
oduc i ega di
, c
s
i d or rng, he
t de s he te '
Couns l a t r r peci elc r c dic r expe t t m e t on Nove r 30,2011 t
e nd hei es tve e toni s ove y
rs o e
mbe
o
dicus t is s r ga di t doc
s s he s ue e r ng he
umen pr ton oft Def nt SBD i a e f tt
t oduc i
he
enda ,
n n for o

rs v teds ue wi u f rh r u iilitr e to
eole h ip ts t t u te j d ca ne v n in.
ho
The Def nt s l ca ego i e t C r c
enda hal t r z he i d opy pa ' por i of is docum e
ha
per' ton
t
nt

pr ton t co r po t t Pli if sRe ss f Pr uci unl s i i a e t pr de
oduc i o res nd o he a ntf
que t or od ton, es t s bl o ovi

afda ts fom t c t a s oft r or pr e a quael de
fi vit) r he usodinl) he ec ds oduc d de t y monsr tng t ts h
tai ha uc

poduci ( a ia e pori t r wasma a s r or wee kep i t us l
r ton or pplc bl tons heeog
de s uch ec ds r t n he ua
c s ofbusne sand,i s t tpori oft d m e pr uc i s l be e us fom t
our e
i s
f o, ha
ton he ocu nt od ton ha l xc ed r he

c tgorzai rquie nt purua t Rul 34( ( ( () of t Fe a Rul of Ci l
ae i ton e rme
s nt o e b)2)E)i
he derl es
vi

Pr e e. The Pa tes have ag e d t t t dha d c
oc dur
ri
r e ha he s r opy pa ' pr ton m a pror t
per' oduc i
de i o
Nove r 28,2011 has be i ntfe as 58D 1 4- 5307,581 61 68
mbe
,
en de iid
428 1
7 047- 304,SBD817
0291 9 a SBD 1
95 nd
39288- 400 a t r quie e of Ca e i ton i lm ie t r t The
1 40 nd he e r m nt
t gorza i s i t d he e o.
Ca e i to s l be pr ded t Pl ntf ' Couns lo orbe or D e m ber31 2011
t gorza i n ha l
ovi
o ai i f s
e n
f e ce
,
.

I t Conf r e des i d i Pa a a 3 a
n he
e enc
crbe n r gr ph bove Dekndanta ee t pr e
, t
gr d o oduc
N a i Fie For a f al ES1t tw asnotpr ry r ac ed ordes g e a prvie d a was
tve l
m t or l
ha
ope l ed t
i nat d s i l ge nd
pr vi l pr
e ous y oduc d as TI i ag , a lnki t N a i Fie For a t t pr vi l
e
FF m es nd i ng he tve l
m t o he e ousy

e a
f e
e
,
pr
oduce TI l a of t ESI De e nt s lpr
d FF m ges he
. f nda hal oduc s me on or be or Dec mber31
2011,
DON E AN D O RDERED , i Chambe s a M i ' Fl i ,t s
n
r , t a i orda hi
,
.

2011
.
.

da of De embe ,
y
c
r

)

'
.

/'
;

.- -

--.'
.

ê-

J 1 J
OIY 7O

LI
VAN

UN I .; S
TE TATES MAGI TRATE J
S
UDGE

Co e f ni he t
pi s ur s d o:
Unie St t s D it i tJ
t d a e s rc udge Lena d
r
A1 Couns lofRec d
l
e
or

(1 3 00237855.)
01 4/
1