Gentry v. Carnival Corporation et al

Filing 53

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 39 Motion to Compel; granting in part and denying in part 40 Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman on 5/8/2012. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B) (eg)

Noah Si man
l
ver

-*'
*

<Nsi er @fe l om>
l man f ga.
v
l c

,

04/ / 2 06: PM
30201
03

To 'oo ma @f du c d a v'
' d n l .s ou sgo '
g
s
< o dma @f du c d .o >
g o n l .s ou sg v
s
c 'a o Mar l s < Maruis ic nc m>,
c ' s n gui ' l g l @l o ao
J
e
e p

' -n s l c .o ' cLia @l c nc ml
Ctia @ i onc m'< l s i o .o ,
l
p
n p

b ' c a d @ h mio mie lw.o '
c h r on a l n l r c m'
t la
cc
Su j c Apr Ge tyv Ca nv l My t Mo nai, s No:
be t i n r . r ia & si u t n Ca e .
l
c
111-v- 580: c 21 JG

Hit y:
sor

sghseno ae. )
aeabefwrd
rd

* Thi mes
s
.

DearM agit at Goodman,
sr e

Atthe hearng on Pl ntf M oton t Com pelDicover on M onday, Aprl23,2012 i t
i
ai irs
i o
s
y
i
n he
above-ef enc m at er yourHonoras ust i r i o t isuesw ih r pectt Pl ntifs
r er ed
t ,
ked o nquie nt wo s
t es
o ai f'
M otont Com pelDicover . Fis ,wih r pectt Pl ntifs I erogat i No. 21and Requestf
i o
s
y rt t es
o ai f' nt r ores
or
Pr ton No.47,yourHonorask ust i r asto t I s i ofs chi f i or aton
oduc i
ed o nquie
he ogitcs ear ng or nf m i
r di com pl nt r ati t the Bobsl excur on. Car valhasadvied usthata c put sear
egar ng
ai s el ng o
ed
si
ni
s
om er ch
can be r t det m i i ther wer com pl nt r atng t t Bobsl excur on. Second,wih
un o er ne f e
e
ai s el i o he
ed
si
t
r pectt Pl ntf Reques f Pr
es
o ai irs
t or oducton No.31,yourHonoras ust det m i whet
i
ked o er ne
her

Ca nial s e i s ee c sond rmentmai aisme igmi t and ormemosrf rn t
r v ' hor sde hor x uri epa t
s
nt n etn nu es /
e erig o
t s j ts eex uri Ca nial a a s ust a t eyd no ha e r ponsvedo umen a i
he ubec hor c son. r v h s dvied h t h o t v es i c
t ton
.

Respec f l
t uly,

Nooh Siver on
l m
Par ner
t
F eman Fredm an,P
or
i
A
2 Sout Bic
h s ayne Boul d
evar
Suie 2300
t
Mi i Forda 331
am , l i
31

TeI:( )358305
6555
Fa ( 374x: 305) 9077
Em ai: l- Web t
lmai
sie

M I A M I * C H IC A G O
ATTf RN 'Y A T tAW
)
S
.

The i or aton t an it her n i i ende onl f t per on or en iy t whih i i addr s and may
nf m i r sm ted ei s nt d y or he s
tt o c t s
es ed
c ai c i i and/ prvi
ont n onfdental
or i l
eged mat i .An r ew,r r sm ison, dis i i or o herus of or
eral y evi etan s i
t
s em naton
t
e ,
aki ofany ac i i r i e upon, t s i f maton b p s oren ii ot t t i ended r i en i
ng
ton n el
anc
hi n or i y er ons
ttes her han he nt
ec pi t s
pr bied.I you r eied t s mess ge i eror plase c t ctt s
ohi t f
ec v hi
a n r , e
on a he enderand del e t m at i f om any
et he
eral r
c
omput .Un appl abl U. Tr
er der
i e S. easur Regultons we ar r quied t i f m you t tany advie c aned i
c
y
ai ,
e e r o n or
ha
c ont i n
t e r c l s
hi
or
ta
et s nt
o
ed
t selctoni mai mes age ( any a tchmenther o)i noti ended t be us , and c
annot b us t a d
e ed, o voi
ax pen te i pos d undert I t nalRe
alis m e
he n er
venue Co .
de