Nyesa Costa Rica et al v. Wilson Capital Group Holdings, LLC et al
Filing
22
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 10 Motion for Default Judgment as to Liability against defendant Northern Ridge Capital Partners, LLC. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 4/26/2012. (ls)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
CASE N O.11 22036- V- TZ/ M ON TON
Cl SEI Sl
N YESA COSTA RJ
CA,
NYESA GENERCI S. ,a
A, L. nd
NYESA VALOM S CORPOM CI ,S. .
ON
A,
Pl n if ,
aitfs
VS.
WI
LSON CAPI
TAL GROUP HOLDI
NGS,LLC,
AYANNA J ES,
AM
WI
LSON CAPI
TAL GROUP LI I
M TED PARTNERSHI LTD.
P,
,
ROY A.LAUESGHOLSTON, d
M
NORTHERN RI
DGE CAPI
TAL PARTNERS,LLC.
Def nt .
enda s
/
ORDER GRANTI ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGM ENT AS TO LI LI
NG
ABI TY
THI M ATTER i bef et Cour on Pl ntfs Applc ton f Enty ofDef ul
S
s or he
t
ai if '
i a i or r
a t
J d me tAg is Dee d n , rh r Ri g Ca ia Pa tes LLC (d rh m Ri g ' (
u g n an t fn a t No ten d e ptl rn r ,
t te d e' DENo
)
1 .Norhen Ri a oa he Pli if a aprposd l n f de l ntofLaRoca
0)
t r dge ppr c d antfs bout o e oa or veopme
Re or.Howeve , he muc dea a num e ousf ler pr s nttons t tans c i ne r
s t
r a r h ly nd
r
a s e e e a i , he r a ton ve
cl ed a Norhe n Ri f ie t rt n Pl i if 'f ,de piede a f i t do s
os nd
t r dge a ld o eur antfs unds s t m nds or t o
o.
Be us Norhe n Ri f iedt e f c i y a we t c pli , a Pl i if s fcenty
ca e t r dge a l o fe tvel ns r he om a ntl nd antf s ufi i l
alg df css p o t gcamso fa d c n eso cv lh f, n u j s e rc me t g is
le e a t u p ri li f r u , o v rin, ii te ta d n u t n ih n a an t
n
No t r Ri ,t Cour wile e Def ul J m e a i tNorher Ri e.
rhe n dge he
t l nt r a t udg nt gans
t n dg
1 e e nt Laue - sonans r t ec I nton be fofhi s fandNorhe n Ri
D f nda ,
hal
m el
t r dge.Becale
ts
sGholt
weed h omp ai
No t r Ri i acomor tonandLa sGholt i notlce e t pr ci l i Fl i ,t a we onl
rhen dge s
ai
ue - son s
i ns d o a tce aw n orda he ns r y
perai d t Laue - son i hi i vi c pa t
t ne o
sGholt n s ndi dual a ciy.
1
.
B ac ound
kgr
Thi a to ars soutofPl ntfs Ny aVa or Cor acon,S. .Nye aGe rc
s c i n ie
ai if , es ol es por i
A , s ne i a
S. , Nye a Cos aRi sale tonsoffaud a mi a opra i of$1645, USD .
L.and s
t ca' lga i
r
nd s ppr iton
, 099
2
Nyes Va or sCo por c on,S. . sal nd de l rand ma eme fr t i publcal
a l e r ai
A i a
veope
nag nt im hat s
i ly
ta d on t Spanih soc m a ke .I i i or r t i Spai whe ei hasisprncpa pl c of
r de
he
s t k r t t s nc po a ed n
n, r t
t i i l ae
busnes . Ny a Ge rc S. i aSpa s c
i s es ne ia L. s
nih ompa t tf tonsa as i a yofNye a
ny ha unc i
s ubsdir
s
Va l e i No t Am e i a.Nye aCosaRi ai a CosaRi n c pa t i a s i a y of
ror s n rh
rc
s
t c s
t ca om ny hat s ubsdir
Nye aGe rc t tove s sisi sme si CosaRia.
s ne i a ha
r ee t nve t nt n t c
Def nda , t r Ri ei almie la lt co pa i por t i andha ng is
e nt Norhe n dg s i t d ibiiy m ny ncor aed n
vi t
prnci lplc ofbusne si Ohi No t l Ri c
i pa a e
i s n o. rhe' dge onduc sbusne si Fl i a hed is f
n
t
i s n orda nd l tel
outa a l n unde wrt randpr e s rwih ove $900, 0, U SD a ia ei i t e
s oa
r ie
oc s o t
r
00 000
va lbl n nvesm nt
f
unds.Dee nt W is Ca tlGr Hol ngs(1 CG' i almiedlabiiyFl i
fnda , lon pia oup di $W ' s i t i lt orda
)
c
ompa t twa a i sr tvel dis ve by t Fl i De rme ofStt f f l et fl
ny ha s dm nita i y s ol d he orda pa t nt
a e or aiur o ie
aa
n nnualrpor.lsr seeda nti Dee ntAya J me ($a s'.Dee ntRoyA.
e t t egitr ge s fnda , nna a s ç me '
J
) fnda ,
La - son(: ues'wa amana ngme
uesGholt (La ' s
)
gi
mberofNorhenRi ea age r pa t of
t r dg nd neal rner
W CG NRC,almie parne s p cr aed s ii aly t hol W CG a Norhe n Ri '
i t d t r hi e t pec fc l o d
nd
t r dge s
itr s i fn ncn tep oe th t a s dti d s u e
nee t n i a ig h rjc ta c u e h s ip t .
Begi ng i 2008,Pl i if c
nni n
antfs omm e ed plnst de l LaRocaRe or i CosaRi a.
nc
a o veop
s tn t c
l Se e r2009,La sa oac d Pl i if , l t we e at mptng t s c e f ng
n pt mbe
ue ppr he antfs whie hey r te i o e ur undi
f t r o t Dur ng a fna i m ee i La a J m e pr
or he es r .
i
i nc ng
tng, ues nd a s opos d a l n t oug W CG a
e oa hr h
nd
N o t r Ri e f r$330, 000 USD. Att ttm e,he r pr e e t tNorhe n Ri
rhe n dg o
000,
ha i t y e es nt d ha
t r dge
z f t ba kg oundwastkeneniey fom Pl ntfs'ale tonsi t c
The acual c r
a
tr l r
ai if lgai n he ompl nt
ai .
2
wo d c
ul onduc t ope ai sdue dii nc a pr es t l ldocu e si i ntt t
t he r ton'
lge e nd oc s he ega
m nt nc de o he
l
oan. The a s t d Pl ntfst tNorhe' Ri ha t r quiie e riea e incei
y lo ol ai if ha
t l dge d he e st xpe ts nd xpere
n
n
i e a i lfna ng t unde tke s h ts . Pl i if we et adva t c t oft swor
nt m tona i nci o
ra uc a ks antf s r o
nce he os s hi
k
t Norher Ri
o
t n dge.La sa J m e pr de Pl ntfswih aJ M o ga Cha e Bank fna a
ue nd a s ovi d ai if t P r n
s
i ncil
sae e t de
t tm nt o monsr eNorhe n Ri and W CG ' pur re pr off
tat
t r dge
S po td oof undsi M ar h 201
n
c
0.
On J 2, 0, t nzRi ,tuoug La ,pr d Pli if wih a Es r
une 201 Norhe
dge l h ues ovi ed antfs t n c ow
Agr eme ,whi h r quie t t a nc $20, USD ofa$100, USD DueDii e e
e nt c e r d hem o dva e
000
000
lg nc
Fe Afe r pr ent i t f ng woul be s e sula De e nt coul f t
e. tr e es atons hat undi
d
ucc s f nd f nda s
d und he
p oe tPlitfswie $ 00 0US t ad sg ae J M o g nCh s Ba ka c u t Th n, n
rj c, anif r d 2 ,0 D o e in td P r a a e n c o n . e o
J 25, a J y 7, 0, t r Ri t
une 28, nd ul 201 Norhe n dge, hough La ,pr e e Pl ntfswih a
ues es nt d ai if t
Confr ton ofLoa Te m s r tf ng t ta a to Spe fcal t sdoc e r ie a e t t
ma i
n r , a iyi he r ns c i n. cii ly, hi
um nt et r t d ha
Nye aowe $80, USD oft Due Dii e eFe and aComm ime Feeof$1 000U SD.
s
d
000
he
lg nc e
t nt
00,
On J y 8, 0, t r Ri s ntPl i if a Adde
ul 201 Norhe n dge e
antfs n
ndum t t Confr a i of
o he
im ton
Loa Te m st tr pr e e t DueDii enc Fe woul i t adbehel a Ba ofAme i a
n r ha e es nt d he
lg e e
d nse
d t nk
rc
(%OA')i a Es ow M a eme Re EsaeAc ount Theea t ,onJ y 1 201 W CG
$
' n n cr
nag nt al tt c . r fer ul 2, 0,
a J sc im e i wrtng t tNorhe n Ri c plt d t unde wrtng pr s a
nd ame ontr d n ii ha
t r dge om e e he
r ii
oce s nd
ap ove Pli tfsf al n.Furhe , a e r quesedt balnceoft f esa t d Pl ntfs
pr d a n if or oa
t r J m s e t he a
he e nd ol ai if
t l n woul c os onA u t1 201
he oa
d l e
gus 7, 0.On J y 30,201 Pli if ta f re $180,
ul
0, antf s r ns e r d
000
U SD, heamountdue ont DueDii ncea Com mime Fe s a n r yi on De e nt '
t
he
lge
nd
t nt e , gai el ng
f nda s
r pr s ntto .Howe r on Se e r5,201 Def nda snotte Pli if t tt l n
e e e a i ns
ve ,
pt mbe
0, e nt ii d a ntfs ha he oa
cl i wasde a d duet mi ope ai lis butt d t m t ti woul c os by t e
osng
l ye
o nor r tona s ues
ol he ha t
d l e he nd
of Se e be 201
pt m r 0.
Ba e on Def nda sc
sd
e nt ommunia i t tans ton woul c os ,Pli if publc l
c tng he r ac i
d l e a ntfs
ialy
t ai if
he oa osng l
d sl e t eLaRo ap o e t Jamesand Lauesmetwih Pl ntfsaboutt l n cl i eary
icos d h
c rj c.
i Oc obe 20l Durng t s me i ,J mesa La sr ve l d W CG a Norhe n Ri '
n t r 0. i he e etngs a
nd ue e a e
nd
t r dge s
i e i t r sr t ef ng. Def nda swoul wor t t rt . ur f ng a pr pa e
ntntons o e tuc ur undi
e nt
d
k oge he o s e undi nd e r
ec
t doc e s s t ta a ton woul cl e byt end of201 J mesand La pr de
he um nt, o he r ns c i
d os
he
0. a
ues ovi d
Pli if aBi ngLet rofI e a apur re Es r w Ag e m e , c r quie t t
antfs ndi
te
ntnt nd
po td c o
r e nt whi h e r d hem o
de i a a tonal$1, 000 Eur i o t BOA a cou .Pl ntfsta f redt f
post n ddii
000,
os nt he
c nt ai if r nse r he undsi
n
t a ount of$500, Etr e h, le ngt l n wo d cos
wo m
s
000 los ac be ivi he oa ul l e.
De e
f ndant we et dibure f
s r o s s undst Pli if bewe Nove
o antfs t en
mbera De mbe of
nd ce r
ve ,
he s s nt r ve de.
201 i t ees pa a etans tons Howe r noneoft dibur eme swe ee rm a
0, n hr e r t r ac i .
Pli tf si r d a
a n if nquie boutt delys a La a J mesr pea e y a s e t m t tans to
he a , nd ues nd a
e t dl s ur d he he r aci n
woul s c sulycl e.The dea c i d t ough J nua y a Fe uar 2011 durng
d uc es f l os
lys ontnue hr
a r nd br y
, i
whi h tm eDe e
c i
f ndant c i d t ma f leas ur nce .Ahernum e o deaysa l c of
s ontnue o ke as s a s
r us l nd a k
t ta ac i cosng, antfsma am 't n de a ofa i
he r ns ton l i Pl i if de
i e m nd n mmedit cl i orr t n of
t
a e osng e ur
t if
he r undso Fe u y24, 1.De e n sne r s nded t Pl ntfs lter
n br ar
201
f nda t ver e po
o ai if ' et .
Des t Pli if 'wrte de a La pr de t apur re ABN AM RO Ba
pie antfs it n m nd, ues ovi d hem
po td
nk,
N . lte ofc edi s ai t ti hada ove a $500, 000U SD c e tf iiy t a e iy
V. et r r t ttng ha t
ppr d
000,
r di aclt o n ntt
as oc ae wih De e nt i Aprl2011.TheABN lte ofc e tca ld f rPl i if t
s i td t f nda s n
i
et r r di le o antfs o
de i $7,00, Eur mor
post 5 000 os e.Upon i r Pl ntfscontc edt ABN a unc r d t
nquiy, ai if
a t he
nd ove e he
doc
umen wa f g
t s or ed.Pli if de a d t r t n ofis$200, U SD a $1000, Eur
a ntfs m nde he eur t
000
nd , 000 os
t no aval Subs que l t y br htt saci n f rda
o
i.
e nty,he oug hi to o mage s h a t l sofm one
s uc s he os
y,
di n to o so kvau , i n t o vau , n d ly i teLaRo ap oe tr s ligi
miu in f t c le dmi ui f le a d ea s n h
on
c r jc e utn n
ec
onom i dn
c mage .
s
II.
Di
scussi
on
A Co r ma e trd fu tu g n wh n$ p rya an twh m aj d me t o
u t y ne ea lj d me t e G a t g is o u g n f r
a
afima i r i i s
fr tve elef s oughtha f ie t pla orot r s defnd,a t f iur i s
s a ld o e d
he wie e
nd he a l e s hown by
afi vi orot r s ' Fed.R.Ci P.55()
fda t hewie.
'
v.
a .Howeve,adefnda ' dea taonedoesnot
r
e nts ful l
warn e tyo ad f ut u g n .T oFied Se . LC v Alo e , 8F. p' 8 0 8 3
ra t nr f e a lj d me t yc r r c L . c c r 21 Ap x 6 , 6
( 1h Ci. 0 7 .F rh r Sth d fn a ti no h l t a mi fcsta a en t l pla e o
1 t r 2 0 ) u te,f l e e e d n s t ed o d t a t h t r o wel e d d r
g
t a tc l i of1w .. def ti no teaed a a a ol ec e son b t def ntof
o dmi onc usons a .a aul s t r t s n bs ut onf s i y he enda
hi la lt a oft pl ntf rg t r c r' Nihi s Consr Co.v.
s i biiy nd he ai ips iht o e ove . s matu
'
t.
Houson Nat1
t
'
Ba k 51 F.d 1 0 1 0 (t Ci.1 75 .
n , 5 2 20 , 2 6 5h r 9 )3
l i a wel- t bls dprncpl t t(ac po a i camotr pr s ntis l a mus be
ts
lesa ihe i i e ha 1 or r ton r
e e e te f nd
t
rp e e tdb c u s l' Pa a z v GufoiCop.7 4F.d 1 81 1 8 - 6( 1h Ci. 9 )
e r sn e y o n e. lz o . l l r , 6 2 3 , 3 5 8 1 t r 1 85 .
'
He e,Def ntLaue a wer d t c
r
enda
s ns e he ompli onbe l ofhi s fa Norhe n Ri
ant
ha f
m el nd
t r dge. W hie
l
La m a r pr s nthi s l a apr s pa t hem a notr pr s Norher Ri e,be aus i i
ues y e e e m e f s o e ry,
y
e e ent t n dg
c e ts
a lmie la lt c or ton,a he i nota ho ied t pr ctce1 i Fl i . Ass h,
i td ibiiy om a i nd s
ut rz o a i aw n orda
uc
Norhe n Ri e di note f ctvel a we t c
t r dg d
fe i y ns r he ompl ntorc e tany ofPl i if 'f c ua
ai
onts
antf s a t l
alg t n , n e r o d fut u g n i a p o it i tec mpan e tb ihe e c c u e
l ai s a d nty f e a lj d me t s p r prae f h o li t sa ls s a h a s
e o
of cinf wh c i s e s u g n .
a to or ih t e k j d me t
3 n Bonne v ci o ih r , 6lF.d 1 6 1 0 ( 1hCi.l 81,h Elv nhCi uta o e a
I
r . t fprc a d 6
y
2 20 , 2 9 1 t r 9 ) te e e t r i d ptd s
c
bi ngal c esdecde bef eOct r1 1
ndi l as
i d or
obe , 981.
5
A.
Fra
ud
A plitf mu te tbihtef l wi ee n st p o a alg to o fa d:$1 a
anif s sa ls h ol ng lme t o r ve n l ai n f ru é )
o
e
(
f lesae n c n e nn amaeil a t ( )k o e g b t p ro ma i t esae n
as ttme t o c r ig
tra fc; 2 n wld e y he e s n kng h ttme t
t a t erp ee aini f le ( )t itn b tepes nma n tesae n ta te
h t h e r sntto s as ; 3 he ne t y h ro kig h ttme t h t h
rp e e tto wi id c a oh rt a to i; n ( )rla c o t erp e e tto t teij r
e rs n ai n l n u e n t e o c n t a d 4 ein e n h e r s nain o h nu y
l
oft ohe pa t ' fanc v.Wade, So. 1 08,1 1( a.1 .
he t r ry.
'
e
457 2d 0 01 Fl 984)
W ih r pec t t scli Pli if a lget tNorher Ri m a numer f le
t es t o hi a m, antf s le ha
t n dge de
ous as
sae e son whih t y derme alyr le De e nt r pr s nt N o t r Ri hadt
t tm nt
c he ti nt l ei d. f nda s e e e ed rhe n dge
he
a ii t j ityfnda$ 3 ,0 0 0US l a ,h e p rierq ie t pef r d dlg n e
b ly o on l u
t
3 00 0,0 D o n te x e t e u rd o ro m ue iie c
s
pur ua t t l n,t i e tt unde wrt t l a t tNorhe n Ri woul hol t
s nt o he oa he nt n o
r ie he oan, nd ha
t r dge
d d he
DueDii nc a Comm ime Fe i a es r w ac ountuntlt l n cl e Pl ntfsalo
lge e nd
t nt es n n c o
c
i he oa os d. ai if s
al geNo t r Ri kne isr pr e a i we ef s a t s f le sa e
le
rhe n dge w t e ts nttons r ale nd he e a s t t ment i ed
s nduc
Pli tfst ac . Spe fca l Norhen Ri pr e e Pl ntfswih f le pr off
a n if o t
cii ly, t r dge es nt d ai if t a s oof undsi
n
s
uppor ofiss venc aco ma i ofl n tr ssa i Pl i if 'f
t t ol y, nfr ton oa e m t tng antfs undswo d behel i
ul
dn
tus,a r pr e e m i ope a i de a we et r as dibur eme swer notbei
r t nd e es nt d nor r tonal l ys r he e on s s nt
e
ng
ma a t ta a ton woul uli a ey c os
de nd he r ns c i
d tm t l l e.
Reyi on Norher Ri sc i d r pr s nttonsa a Norher Ri e' r ss
l ng
t n dge' ontnue e e e a i
nd t t n dg s eque t ,
Pli tf sta f red f
a n if r nse r undss ve a tm e t alng$200, U SD a $1, 000 Eur , i vi
e r l i s ot i
000
nd 000,
os bele ng
t tNorhe n Ri c d f fl isoblgai ba e upon t pa tes co r a i a
ha
t r dge oul ulil t i tons s d
he ri ' nve s tons nd
a e m e t .N orhe n Ri kne Pli if woul uphol t i e oft a e ntbe aus
gr e n s
t r dge w antf s
d
d her nd he gr eme
c e
t y di s fom t oute oft pa te 'de lngsa awa ta f r e f
he d o r he s t he ri s a i
nd l ys r nse r d undswhe as d t
n ke o.
Asar s toft ta f r , ai if s f r d t de rm e all soff
e ul he r nse s Pl ntfs ufe e he ti nt os
undsa delysi
nd a n
c tu ton ofLaRoc a a r s tofNorhe n Ri sr pr e a i . Thus Pl ntfs
onsr c i
a s e ul
t r dge' e es nt tons
, ai if
s fiin l alg dfcsi s p r o isfa dcam.Asar s l, ea t u g n i
u fce t l e a t n u po t f t r u li
y e
e ut d fulj d me t s
appr pra ewih r pec t t scli .
o it t es t o hi am
B.
C onve s on
ri
Unde Fl i lw,c
r orda a onve son i a S ctofdom i on wr uly a s td ove a he '
ri s n s
a
ni
ongf l s ere
r not rs
pr ryi onssen wihhi owne s pt ri ' Warhal v. ie,629So.2d903,904( a.
ope t nc it t t s
rhi heen.
' s l Prc
F1
4t DCA 1 ) Thus convesonocc swhe apes wihargh ofposesi ofpr ry
h
993 .
,
ri
ur n ron t i t
s son
ope t
de a isr t n a t de a i no me .Pe r on v. dM ot Co. 694 So. 61 69
m nds t eur nd he m nd s t t a s
For
or ,
2d ,
( a.1tDCA 1 .
F1 s
997)
Pl i if 'al tonse tbls t tNorhe n Ri i a s la ef co r i
antfs lega i
sa ih ha
t r dge s lo ibl or nve son.
Pli tfsde ie f
a n if post d undsi owha i bele d we e e c ow ac ount f s ii pur e
nt
t t i ve
r sr
c s or pecfc pos s.
Pl ntfsdi no a horz a ot rus soft f .Norhe n Ri de i d Pli if of
ai if d t ut ie ny he e
he unds
t r dge prve a ntfs
t i pr perywhen i f l t r t n t rf ,de pie Pli tfs r quesst do s Furhe ,
her o t
t aied o e ur hei unds s t a n if ' e t o
o. t r
N o t r Ri e di not a doesnot ha a owne s p i t r ti t f .N orhe n Ri e
rhe n dg d , nd
, ve n
r hi n e es n he unds
t r dg
ha no rg t ke p t f
d i ht o e he undsbe a ei f ie t pe f m t ag ee upon t s whi h wo d
c us t a ld o ror he r d
a ks c
ul
ha e il d i t t f
ve ntte t o he unds- c
ompl tngt l n unde wrtng pr es ,pe f r ngt due
ei he oa
r ii
oc s r o mi he
dii nc a pr pa i t lga doc e si de t t l n.Fa l et r t n t f ds
lge e, nd e rng he e l um nt nci nt o he oa
iur o e ur he un
c tt escon r i be us N o t l Ri ha a s redi e e t o rPl ntfs pr pe t t
onsiut
ve son ca e rhe' dge s s e t ntr ss ve ai if ' o ry o
n
whih i i note il Thus Norhe n Ri e i la ef c
c ts
ntted.
, t r dg s i bl or onve tng Pl ntfs f .
ri
ai if ' unds
C.
C i lT he t
vi
f
Und rFlrdalw, p an ifmus alg a ij r rs l n i v oainofheci n l
e o i a a litf t le e n nu y e ut g n i lto t rmia
i
t et ttt .S e iial ,$1 ()p ro c mmi t e tfh o s ek o n l o tiso u e ,
h f saue p cfc ly 1 ) a e s n o t h f i e r h n wigy b an r s s
(
s
7
o e avo st ob an o t us ,t pr ry ofa he wih i e t et rt mpor rl or
r nde r o t i r o e he ope t
not r t ntnt o, ihe e
a iy
pema nl ()glp ieteoh rp ro o arg t otep o e t o ab n ftfo t
r ne t a d e rv h te e s n f ih t h r p ry r e ei r m he
y:
p o ry i ( )(qp o raetep o ryt h so h ro u eo t teu eo a yp ro n t
r petlj b ap r p it h rpet o i r e wn s r o h s f n e s n o
entte t t us oft pr ry.'Fl Stt jj722.1 81 01 1 .
ild o he e he ope t ' a. a.
1 , 2. 4( )
Theco pl ntalege e chelm e nec s r t pr ci lt toc r d.Norhel
m ai l s a
e nt es a y o ove vi hef cure
t .
n
Ri sr pr e a insa a tonsesabls isi entt knowi yobt i orus t pr pe t of
dge' e es nt to nd c i
t ih t nt o
ngl
an
e he o ry
a herwih t i e t de i t m ofpr pe t orapr ry be ft Norhe n Ri 1 d
not
t he ntnt o prve he
o ry
ope t ne i.
t r dge e
Pl ntfst belevei wasc pa eoff ng La Roc a pe f mi t ksi de t t l n.
ai if o i t
a bl
undi
a nd ror ng as nci nt o he oa
Asar s t Pli if ta f re a s t tala ountofm o y f rt DueDii nc a
e ul, a ntfs r ns e r d ubsan i m
ne o he
lge e nd
Comm im e Fee . Subs que l a trN o t r Ri r sr t edt de , ai if
t nt s
e nty, fe rhe n dge e tucur he al Pl ntfs
ta f re a addii na $1000, Eur ba e upon De e nt 'r pr e a i ,
r ns er d n
to l , 000 os s d
f nda s e es nt tons
Atal tm e , t n Ri kne t tPl ntfswoul ta f rt f
1 i s Norher dge w ha ai if
d r nse he undsbec us t y
a e he
di s o num e ousoc asonsa trDe e ntr quese t f . Fu t r t ta ac i ne r
do n
r
c i
fe f nda e
td he unds rhe , he r ns ton ve
cl e a ass h, t n Ri wasnote ild t ke p Pl i if f . Des t de
os d, nd uc Norher dge
ntte o e antfs' unds
pie mands
t r t t f ,No t r Ri e ha f ie t r po cos t ta ac i orr t t
o eum he unds rhe n dg s al d o es nd, l e he r ns ton, e una he
m one Thus N o t r Ri ha a opratd t f
y.
, rhe n dge s ppr i e he undsf isown us a has
or t
es nd
smula ousy de i d Pl ntfsoft i pr ly a be ist tow fom t owne s p
i t ne l prve ai if
her ope' nd neft hat l r hat
t
rhi
i er s .Asa r s t Norhe n Ri i lab ef c vi t f.
nt e t
e ul, t r dge s i l 0r i l he t
D.
Unj tEnrchme
us
i nt
Th e sn ilee n so a u j s e rc me t li a e ( 1 ab n ft o fre u o a
e se ta lme t f n nu t n ih n cam r :t ) e ei c n erd p n
(
defnda byt pli if ( t de e ntsa ecai oft be ft ( t dee nts
e nt he antf,2) he f nda ' ppr iton he nei, 3) he fnda '
ac e a e a r t i n oft be k unde cr umsa e t tmakei i quia ef rhi t
c pt nc nd eento
he net
r ic t nc s ha
t ne tbl o m o
8
rti iwiho pa ngt vauet r of' Roli ,l v.Bul 951So. 860,876( a.
ean t t ut yi he l he e . lns nc. tand,
'
2d
Fl 2d
DCA 2006)
.
Pli tf sc t r d a s t nta be ttupon De e ti t f m of$1, 099 USD.
a n if onf r e ubsa il nei
f ndan n he or
645,
Pl ntfsde iedt smone it a es r ac ountf wor Norhe n Ri ew a t
ai if post hi
y n o n c ow c
or k
t r dg
so
unde tke.Norhe n Ri a e a e t sbe ftbe aus i r a ne Pl ntfs f , t
ra
t r dge ppr cit d hi ne i c e t eti d ai if ' unds wihout
pe f r i t t ksf whi h t mone wa ta f red.Be a eNorhe n Ri e di not
r o m ng he as or c he
y s r ns e r
c us
t r dg d
pe f m t et k,i i note tte t t sm onear be t Pl i if a l dt tt y ha
ror hes as t s
n ild o hi
t y nek. antfs lege ha he ve
r c ve no be t fom t tanse r f .Asar s t i i i quia ef Norhe n Ri et
e ei d
nek r he r f red unds
e ul, t s ne tbl or t r dg o
c niu r ti igPlitfs f nd , n No t r Rig h sb e u j tye rc e b rti n
o tn e eann anif' u s a d rhen d e a e n nusl n ih d y eanig
t f .
he unds
Ha ngr viwe t M oto a dee mi ng t tPli tf ss fcinty aleg f c s
vi e e d he
i n nd tr ni ha a n if ufi e l l ed a t
etb ihigfa d, o v rin cvit eta du j s e rc me ta f rtera o ss t o t
sa ls n ru c n e so , i l h f, n n u t n ih n , nd o h e s n e f rh
ab
ove,i i ac or ngl
t s c di y
ORDERED t t
ha
( )Pli if Applcai f EntyofDea tJ
1 antfs' i ton or r
ful udgme Ag ns De e ntNorher
nt ai t f nda
t n
Ri g Ca ia Pa tes LLC ( I Ji GRANTED I PART a t l blt
d e ptl rn r,
DE- O s
N
s o i i y.
a i
()TheCour wiltyt is oft a
2
t l r he sue he mountofda ge a t smetmet smatri
ma s t he a i hi te s
ti d a i tt r
re ga ns he emai ngDe e
ni
f ndant.
s
DONE a dORDERED i MimiFlrd ,hiN C d yo Ap i, 2.
n
n a , oia t s
a f rl201
r
*
<
r
PATRI I A .S l
A
TZ
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
c
c:
A1 Couns ofRe or
1
el
c d
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?