Rice v. United States of America

Filing 23

ORDER OVERRULING in part and AFFIRMING AND ADOPTING in part Report and Recommendations, Closing Case and Denying Certificate of Appealability re 15 Report and Recommendations. Certificate of Appealability: DENIED Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 7/30/2012. (yha)

U N I D STA TES DI
TE
STR I C O U R T
CT
SO U TH ER N DI
STR I T O F FLO R I A
C
D
C A SE N O .11 2217 CI - TZ/ H l
2- V SEI W TE
J ES ROBERT RI
AM
CE,

M ova ,
nt
UNI
TED STATES OF AM ERI
CA
R e ponde t
s
n.
/
O R D ER O VER R ULI G I PAR T AN D A FFI M I G AN D AD O PTI G I PAR T
N N
R N
N N
M AGI
STR ATE ' R EPO R T A ND R EC O M M EN D A TI N .CL O SI G C A SE
S
O
N
A N D D EN Y I G C ER TI C A TE O F APPEAL ABI TY
N
FI
LI

THI MATTER i b fr teCo r u o teRe o t fMa itaeJ d e(1 po t)(
S
s eo e h u t p n h p r o gsrt u g d r' DERe '
1 1is e b teHo o a l Parc A. h t, ie S ae M a itaeJ g , e o n i t e
5 su d y h n r be tik W ie Untd tts g srt ud e rc mme dng h
d a ofJ sRobe tRie' moi t va at ptrua t 28U. C.j2255.M a sr t W hie
enil ame
r c s ton o c e ls nt o
S.
gitae t
c l
onc uded t tRi e' m o i w a s c s ve,a be us he f l d t fr to a n t El ve h
ha c s ton s uc es i nd ca e aie o i s bt i he e nt

Cic i' a p o a t fl as c siemoi n t eCo r lc s u id ci no e h ss c e sv
ruts p r v lo ie uc e sv to ,h u ta k j rs ito v r i u c sie

moin.Rieflda o j cint t eRe r o M ac 1 , 01 .F rt er a o stfrhb lw,
to
c ie n b e to o h po t n rh 5 2 2 o h e s ns e o t eo
t Cour wilove r et a l i c aned i t Re t bu afim a a
he
t l rul he nayss ont i n he por, t fr nd doptt f c ua
he a t l
fndi and uli t c uson,al i f dif r ntr as , o de Rie' motont va t
i ngs
tma e oncl i
bet or fe e e ons t ny c s i o cae.

Ried e n t b e t oa yo M a itaeW ht ' fcu lfn ig , nyt lg l
c o s o o j c t n f gsr t ies a t a i dn s o l he e a
c us ons he r a d i t Re r . The s i tf c s a e asf l s Folow i a t i l Ri e w as
oncl i
e che n he po t
alen a t r
olow . l ng ra , c
co c ed ofa lf cou s he ha be n c r d w ih,i l ng CountOne oft l ct entnvi t
l our nt
d e ha ge t nc udi
he ndi m

posesi wih i en t diti ec i i vi ai of21U. C.j841a( )a 1 U. C.j
s son t nt t o srbut ocane n olton
S.
()1 nd 8 S.

2.Re , 2. The u g n , o v r idc tdt a Rieh db e c n ce o i rai no
p.p.
j d me t h we e ,n iae h t c a e n o vitd f mpo tto f
c i i Count1 Or rpp.11 1 ( 1 1 .Riet rafe fld amotont vac t puruan
ocane n
. de,
- 2 DE 2- 1 c hee tr ie
i o ae s t

t 28U. C. 2 5a srign me o sg o n f rrle ,n l igt theCo r' j d me ti
o
S. j 25 se t u r u r u ds o eif icudn ha t
n
u ts u g n n
Co ler o ous y r tec ed a c c i f i por a i ofc i 1 a pp.5,1 M a s r t
unt r ne l el t
onvi ton or m t ton
oca ne. d t
2. gi t a e

J
udgeLlr naSno r omm e d de ng a1t cli e ptt mert i c am -t tt
za
w ec
nde nyi 1 he a ms xce he iorous l i ha he

j d me tia c rtl rfe t dt a Riewa c nvce o i o tto o c c ie S e
u g n n c u aey elce h t c s o itd f mp rain f o an . h
co l
ncuded, ve ,ha Ri wasnote il t rle unde j
howe r t t ce
ntted o eif r 2255f t smitke.J
or hi sa udge
Snow s cii al f
pe tc ly ound t t ç heonl r le t whi t m ova i e il d i aco r ci ofhi
ha ,t
t
y ei f o ch he
nt s ntte s r e ton
s

j g n l '1 . t 1 .Untd Sae DititJ d eJ me C. i afnne ta
ud me t.' d a p. 2 ie tts src u g a s Pane fi d h t
l
rc mme d to a de trda a n dj d me t u s a tt Fe e a Rul o Ci l o e u e
e o n ai n n n ee n me de u g n p ru n o d r l e f viPr c d r
3 Or e o J n 21 1 9 , . 9 01 01g 5 ; n e J d me tg 1 3 .Rieflda
6. d r f u e , 9 9 No 9 - 6 DE- ) Ame d d u g n DE 2-1 c ie
s c moi purua t 5
e ond ton s nt o 2255onJ 7,1 whiht Cour dimis da s esi
une 999, c he
t s s e s ucc sve.
Re , 6- Ries e ntyfl a tonal52255motonsaswela motonsunde 1
p.pp. 7. c ubs que l ied ddii
i
l s i
r8
U. C.j358 a 28U. C.j
S.
2 nd
S. 2241a awrtofau t quer a.Al oft emotonswer
nd i
dia
el 1 hos
i
e
de e
ni d.

On J 24,201 t Unie Stt sSupr me Cour i s d M agwood v Pate s
une
0, he t d a e
e
t s ue
. tr on,

wheent eCo r h l ta wheeth r i an w j d me titr e igb t e . t h be s
ri h u t ed h t r s ee s e u g n ne v nn ewe n . wo a a
t
.
p tto , na pl ai nc aln i t er s lign w j d me ti n ts c n o s c e sv a
ei ns a p i to h l gng h e utn e u g n s o e o d r u c sie t
i
c
e
a1' 1 S. . ,28 ( 0) Ri pr l fldt i t tj
l.' 30 Ct 2788 02 201 . ce ompty ie he nsan 2255moin,agui t t
to r ng ha

M a o p o d sta hsc alng t t a n e j d me twa no s c e sve Ma itae
gwo d r vie h t i h l e o he me d d u g n s t u c si . gsrt
e
J
udge Pa rc W hie de e t Pe ii fndi t ti w as s ce s ve a t ti o y r i e
tik
t ni d he tton i ng ha t
uc s i nd ha t nl a s d

camsta we edrce a t o ii lu me t n tt n n e j d me t camst t
li h t r ie td the rgna j dg n , o he me d d u g n , li ha
Magwoo woul notrvi .Re ,pp.1 1 Rieob e t a aguest tMagwoodr rsa
d
d e ve p.
2- 3. c j cs nd r
ha
equie

dfee trs t Rieman ansta u d rMa o hi a n e j d me ti at e 'u g n
ifrn eul. c iti h t n e gwo d s me d d u g n s s w'j d me t
n
t te bl hi t fl a t rj
ha na es m o ie nohe 2255peii t twilnotbede
tton ha l
emeds esi
ucc sve.

TheCour fndsno s
ti
uppor f Rie' e nsver di ofM agwood. I t tc s ,t
t or c s xpa i ea ng
n ha a e he

peii rtldapeii f wrtofha ascopuspurua t 28U. C.5
ttone ie
tton or i
be r
s nt o
S. 2254c le nghi
halngi s
c c i a de t s nt nc daysbe or hi e cuton. The dit i tc tg a ed t tw rtof
onvi ton nd a h e e e
f e s xe i
s rc our r nt ha i

habe sc pus va a e hi de h s nt nc t sae c tafe r e ngt evi nc a w,
a or , c t d s at e e e; he t t our, tr eviwi he de e ne
r e e ed t hi t dea h. 130 S. .a 2793. The pe ii rt n f l d a s ond pe ii f
es nt nc he m o t
Ct t
ttone he ie
ec
tton or

wrto h b a c r u c aln igtene sn e c a dj g n , c t lwe c u t al
i f a e s o p s h l gn h w e tn e n ud me twhih he o r o rs l
e
dee e s ce s ve f The Supr m e Cour r ve s d, i ng t s c pe ii f w rtof
m d uc s i . J.
e
t e r e f ndi he e ond tton or i

h b a c r u c aln e aS e 'u g n a dwa t ee o n t u c si eu d r28U. C.
a e s o p s h le g d t w'j d me t n s h r f r o s c e sv n e
n
S.
j
2244.1 a 2803.
d t

Ree a t ot ds u so h r ,h mao iyo ii ni Ma o s e iial a d e sd
lv n t he ic s in ee t e j rt pn o n gwo d p cfc l d rse
y
t f l w i conc r voi e by t di s n :
he olo ng
en c d
he s e t
U nde t Cour ' ne l c e t d exc pton t t ts ond ors c sve '
r he
ts w y r a e
e i o he dec
uc es i '
a i a i ba ,a de e ntw ho s c ds on e n t m os m i r a di c e e
pplc ton r
f nda
uc ee
ve he
t no nd s r t
i s r a i t hi s nt ncng woul bea et r s 25 or5 new s nt nci
s ue eltng o s e e i
d
bl o aie
0
e e ng
cli si hi s c ha spe ii n,a lba e on a gz e she f ie t r iei hi
am n s e ond bea tto l s d
r lm nt
a ld o as n s
frs petton.
i t ii

I a 2 0 ( nn d , .disn ig .Th mao iye p e syds g e dwiht ds e ts
d t 8 9 Ke e y J, se tn ) e j rt x rs l ia re t he is n '
s g eto ta t mao i o i inwo l r s l i awi d alod fn a tswh s c e do
u g sin h the j rt p no ud e ut n n fl t e e d n ' o u c e n
y
e t m os m i i s The Cour no e t ts e s o a m i i s i a fr tha s
ven he
t nor s ue.
t t d ha ucc s n
nor s ue n i s bea

pe ii woul notgi rs t t rghtt a s cond pe ii 1 a 2803,n. 7.Ra he ,t
tton
d
ve ie o he i o e
tton. d. t
1
t r he

S
f
AEDPA pemisr i Snl o t gr t tghepeii r i i c t yi vi atonoft
r t elef o y n he ound ha t ttone q s n usod n ol i
he
Consiuto orlwsorte tesoft Unie Stts''1 ( i 28U. C.j 4( )
tt in a
rai
he td ae .' d. quotng
S. 225 a).
The i t ntc s pr s nt t pr ci e s e i t tconc r t di s nti M agwood.
ns a a e e e s he e s c naro ha
e ned he s e n

W hieJ Panegrnt Ii rle asar s tofhi j2255moton,t r le wa no oneof
l udge i a ed tce eif
eul
s
i he eif s t
t grundsunde j
he o
r 2255( t te il amova t rle .Purua t 5
a) ha ntte
nt o eif s nt o 2255,aprs ne i
io r n

c t cam i t rg t ber e edm a movet s nt nc ng c t o va t s ta i or
usody li ng he i ht o elas
y
he e e i our t cae, e sde
c r c as ntncewhe ei hes nt nc wasi pos d i vi a i oft Consiuton orlwsoft
ore t e e
r é e e e
t
m e n olton he
tt i
a
he

UntdS ae , rt a t ec ur wa wih u j rs ito t i o es hs ne e o t the
ie tts o h t h o t s t o t u idcin o mp s uc e tnc , r ha t
sn e c wa i e e so t ema i m a to ie b lw, ri oh r s s be t oc lae a
e tn e s n xc s f h xmu uh rz d y a o s t e wie u j c t o ltr l
at k.'28U. C.j
tac '
S. 2255() Neihe MagitaeJ
a. t r
srt udgeSnow norJ Panec ude t t
udge i oncl d ha

Riestsida yo te eg o nd f rr l f lse d t yfu t a tej d me tc n an da
c aife n f h s r u s o ei . n ta ,he o nd h t h u g n o tie
e
clrca erora us Rul 3 notj2255,t core tt ter .Thi i prcieyt tpeof
ei l r nd ed e 6,
o rc ha ror s s e s l he y

S n ris e'h t e ul i ane u g n ta teM a o c u t o cu e wo l n t nil
t o su 't a r s t n wj d me t h t h gwo d o r c n l d d ud o e tte
mi
s
amo a t oaS e ' eiin.1 0 S. . t 0 n.7 Ha n rv e dRieso jcinsd
v n t l w'p t o 3 Cta 28 3, 1 . vig e iwe c ' be to e
n
t
n v t eCo r o e r e al be to a dc n ld sta Riesmo int v c t i s c e sv
o o,h u t v ruls l o j cins n o cu e h t c ' to o a ae s u c sie
a t eCo r t eeo elc j rs ito o e Rie scam.
nd h u th rf r a ks u idcin v r c ' li
The Cour w ila s de i s nce ofa ce tfc t ofa a a lt f Ri e' M o i t
t l l o ny s ua
rii a e ppe l biiy or c s ton o
V a a e. Pur uantt R ul 11oft Rul sG ove ni Se ton 2255 Cas , he Cour , vi
ct
s
o e
he e
r ng c i
es t
t ha ng
es a i he gr
t bls d ounds f e erng a ttna o de a r e t t a i a ' on t s m oton,S us
or nt i
' l r r dve s o he pplc nt' hi
i
i t t
m
i s orde a c r ii a e ofa al biiy.'l or rt o a n a c tf c t ofa a a lt Ri e
s ue
ny e tf c t
ppe a lt ' n de o bt i erii a e ppe l biiy, c

mus ma $ s t i s ngoft de alofaco tttona rght' 28U. C.j2253()2)
t ke ( ubsantal howi
a
he ni
nsiui l i .'
S.
c( .

Th ssa d r i stsidû yd mo tai t a j rsso r a o c ud ds g e wiht ed src
i tn ad s aife s e nsr t h t u it f e s n o l ia r e t h itit
b
ng
c u tsrs lto o h sc nsiu in lcamso t tu it c u dc n l d t is e p ee td
o r' e ou in f i o ttto a li r ha j rss o l o cu e he su s r s ne
a e ade t t des r e e our em e t pr e f t r' Jone v Se et y 607 F. 1 46,
r
qua e o e v nc ag nt o oce d urhe .'
s . cr ar
3d 3

1 ( 1hCi. l t ai omit .He e Riehasnotma t ss ng.
349 1 t r 20 olquotton ted) r , c
de hi howi
Acc di y,i i
or ngl t s
ORD ERED THA T

Magsrt J W hie' Re r g 1 i OVERRULED t t e e i
itae udge t s po t DE- 51 s
o he xtnt t

r commendsde ngt i t ntm o i ass e svesmpl be us J mesRiepr ousy fl
e
nyi he nsa
ton ucc s i i y ca e a
c evi l ied

aj 2 5moin o J ne7 1 9 , ta kigtea nd dj d me t Th Re o t sohewie
2 5 to n u , 9 9 atc n h me e u g n . e p r i t r s
AFFI ED and ADOPTED a i por t dby r e e i o t sCour' Or r
RM
nd ncor a e
ef r nce nt hi
ts de .

()
2

TheCo r f rh rfn sta teNo e e 5 1 9 a n e ud me t o sn t
u t u te id h t h v mb r , 9 7 me d dj g n d e o

c nsi t an w j d me t nil Riet fl an n s c e sves c n j 2 5mo inu d r
o tt e e u g n e t i c o ie o -u c s i e o d 2 5 to n e
u
t ng
Magwoodv Pate s 1 S. .
. tr on, 30 Ct2788, 2 ( 0)
280 201 .
(
3)

J sRie' ts motont vac t purua t 28U. C.j
mne c srrp e i o ae s nt o
S. 2255 ( I i
DE- I s

DI M I ED f rlc o j rs ito
S SS o a k f u id cin.
()
4

A1ohe p n i gmoi n a eDENI ASM OOT.
1 t r e d n to s r
ED

()
5

Pu s a tt Rul 1 o t Rue Go en n Se to 2 5 Ca e , c ri c to o
ru n o e 1 f he ls v r i g cin 2 5 s s a e ti ain f
f

a
ppea a lt i D EN I .
l biiy s
ED

(
6)

Thi ca ei CLOSED.
s s s

DONE AND ORDERED i M i mi Fl rda,hi
n a , oi t s

2 * - d yo J l, 2012.
a f uy
=.

c M a sr t J e W hie
c: gita e udg
t

PA T C1 A .
A
Z
UNI
TED S TE D I
STRI J G E
CT UD