Atabayev et al v. The United States of America et al
Filing
32
ORDER Granting 23 Defendants' Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint and Closing Case. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 6/12/12. (tp)
UN I
TED STATES D I I COU RT
STR CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.11 22256- V- TZ/ M ON TON
CI SEl SI
SH ERZA D A TABA YEV ,
Pl i if
antf,
VS.
UNI
TED STATES OF AM ERI e a .
CA, t 1,
Def nt .
enda s
/
O RDER GM NTI DEFENDANTS'M OTI TO DI I FI
NG
ON
SM SS RST AM ENDED
COM PLAI AND CLOSI CA SE
NT
NG
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour upo Def nda s M oton t Dim isFis Am e d
S
s f e he
t n
e nt ' i o s s r t
nde
Co an ( 2 ) i whc De e d n sse t d s s Plitfs e tr c mp an .Th s
mplit DE- 3 ,n ih fn a t e k o imis an if' nie o lit i
a i ars soutofPl ntf,Sher a At ba v' a r s and eev da detnton by t Unie
cton ie
ai if
z d a ye s re t
l en- y e i
he td
Stt a isa nci . Pli ifsAme
aes nd t ge es a ntf
nded Compl i a lge f l c am sa ns t Unie
ant le s otr l i gai t he t d
Sae ,pu s a to teFe ea To t amsAc (
ttsl ru n t h d r l r Cli
t FTCA)f r ()ne lg n efrt ef i r o t
o : 1 gi e c o h al e f wo
u
CusomsAge st a
t
nt o dequa ey s a c Pl i ifsc ra r pe t d f iur t a c ran Pl i ifs
t l e r h antf' a nd e a e a l es o s e ti antf '
lwf li g ain saus ( ne ie f t fiur ofanI gato a Cusoms
a u mmir to tt ;2) glg nce or he al e
mmir in nd t
Enf c me Ofie t i tgaePli ifsi gai saus;( itnto li lcton of
ore nt fc r o nvesi t antf' mmirton tt 3) ne ina nfi i
e to a d sr s a an th Cu t msAg ns a ()itn in lnlci no e to a
mo in l ite s g is te so
e t; nd 4 ne to a itito f mo in l
dites a i tUnknown l i a i a Cuso sEnf ce ntOfie s De e nt ha
sr s ga ns
mm gr ton nd
tm
or me
fc r . f nda s ve
l heAm e d Co pl i na esasDe e
'
r
nde
m ant m
f ndan st Unie St es De tton Ofi e
t he t d at , pora i
fc r
Lau a Per z,Cus o s A g tW iln M a r Cus om s A g ntM a he M aht i n,U nknow n
r
e
tm
en
li m
ye , t
e
t w
es a
l i a i a Cuso sEnf c ntOfk e sa Unknown Cusom sa Bor rPar
mm gr ton nd
tm
or eme
t r nd
t
nd de tol
Age s De enda sa guet t unde t Fede a Tor Cl i sAc ,t Unied St t si t onl
nt . f nt r
ha ,
r he
r l t am
t he t
a e s he y
pr pe pa t D e e
o r ry f ndan . Pl i i fconc st spoi i hi r pons t t M oton t D im i s
t a ntf
ede hi nt n s es
e o he
i o s s
Fis Am e d Com pli .SeeDE- a 12.
rt
nde
a nt
26 t -
move t dimispurua t Fedea RulsofCi lPr ed el b)1 a 1 b)6) Be aus
d o s s s nt o r l e
vi oc ur 2( ( ) nd 2( ( . c e
Cou s1and1 a eba r by t dic e i
nt
1 r red he s r tonmy f ton l l a Pl i iff ist alege
unc i ' e nd antf a l o l
u
S r eous'c
s ag ' onduc i Count lla I t M oton t Di misi gr nt d.
out
tn
s l nd V,he
i o s s s a e
1 Fac sA le d i t A m e d C o pl nt
.
t l ge n he
nde
m ai
Pli if She za At y v,i ana i a ctze ofUzbe sa Pl i if who lve i
antf , r d aba e s tve nd ii n
kit n. antf ,
i sn
Ke W e t Fl i ,i ar i ntoft Unie St t , ng bee gr nt d as um on M a c 1
y s , orda s esde
he t d aes havi
n a e yl
r h 5,
200 Pl ntf ha now be om eal wf pe mane r sde oft Unie St t , ed on hi
7. ai if s
c
a ul r
nt e i nt he t d aes bas
s
as eesa us Thei vi l na e De e nt we e e oy byt Unie St t , ta 1
yl t t .
ndi dualy m d f nda s r mpl ed he td aes a 1
r e
el vanttm e
i s.
On Oc obe 4,2009 Cusom sAge sM a ra M ahts a a Un
t r
, t
nt ye nd
e i n nd known Cusom sa
t
nd
Bor rPar Age swer c
de tol nt
e onduc i a s r h i M a at Fl i . Aspa t t s a c
tng ea c n r hon, orda
r of he e r h,
M a ra M a e i n quesi d Pl i ifa
ye nd ht sa
tone antf bouthi i i a i sa usi t Unie St t s
s mm gr ton tt n he t d a e .
Pli ifi cae t the wa g a e as eesa usa hi pr ofa yle sa uswasi ane r
a ntf ndi td ha
s r ntd yl tt nd s oof s e tt
n
a by
ve c e.Alhough Pl ntf w a as f pr ofhi lwf sa us hewasnotpe m it d t
hil
t
ai if s ked or oof
s a ul tt ,
r te o
l a ehi pr i t tunkofhi ve cl Age sM a ra M a e i n co
oc t s oof n he r
s hi e.
nt ye nd hts a nduceda s a c o
t
e rh f
t ve c ebutf l t l ae Pl i ifspr ofsauswihi t tunk.A sar ul,Pl ntf
he hil
aied o oc t antf ' oof t t
t n he r
es t ai if
wast ke i o c t y bewe n t hour of1100 p. .o Oc obe 4,2009 a 1: a. .o
a n nt usod t e he
s
: m n t r
nd 00 m n
Oc obe 5,2009.
t r
On Oc obe 5,
t r 2009a 1: 9 am .whiei cusody,Pl i ifwa s ve wih aFonn 1
t 1 . , l n t
antf s er d t
8 No i ofRi ht and Re tf rDiposton,whih i ca e t tPl ntf wasar se
26, tce
g s
ques o s ii
c ndi t d ha ai if
re t d
be us im mi ai ofi e sb i veyou a eil lyi t Unie St t . Att s tme,
ca e <
i gr ton tc r ele
r legal n he td aes'
' he nme i
Pl i ifwasalo s v d wih aFor 1200,W a r n f Are tofAle TheFor 1200 saes
antf
s er e t
m r a t or r s
i n.
m tt
t tPli ifû swihi t c r i vi ai oft i i a i l ws' TheFor as
ha antf d t n ht ounty n ol ton he mm gr ton a .
i
'
m lo
i c t st tda ea tme whe Pli ife e e t Unied St t s On Oc obe 5,
ndia e ha t nd i
n antf nt r d he t
ae .
t r 2009,
Pl ntf wasas sr edwihaNotc t Appe r whi c r d Pli ifwihha ngvi atd j
ai if
lo e v
t
ie o
a, ch hage antf t vi ol e
21 ( )7 ( ()l o tel gaina dNain l yAc b c u ePli tf wa no i p s si n
2 a ()A)i() f h mmir t n to ai t e a s anif s t n ose so
o
t
ofavai une r doc e ofi ntt orna i lt The s m eday,Pl i ifwasalo s r ed
ld, xpied um nt de iy
tona iy.
n
antf
s ev
wih aFor 1286, o i ofCusody Dee m i ton, c i caed t tPli ifwoul be
t
m - N tce
t
t r na i whih ndi t ha a ntf
d
deai d by t De rm e ofHomelnd Se iy wihoutbond.
t ne
he pa t nt
a
curt t
Durng t tm et Pl ntf wasi cusody, heAge sM a ra M a e i n we et
i he i hat ai if
n t t
nt ye nd ht sa
r m
notc ofPl ntf sc r c na c r c dae ofbit c r c c r ofbit and c r c ale
ie
ai if ore t me, ore t t
rh, ore t ounty
rh,
ore t in
numbe .l or rt pr pa et For s1 8 1200, r n de o e r he m - 26, 1862,a 128 Age sM a rand
nd - 6, nt ye
M a e in e e edva i pe s
ht sa nt r
rous r onali or ai a
nf m ton boutPl ntf i o adoc e c e to
ai if nt
um nt r a i n
daa s Acc di t Pli if t sdaa s a s woul ha pr de Age sM a ra
tba e.
or ng o antf ,hi tba e lo
d ve ovi d
nt ye nd
M a esan wih Pli ifsl wf sa us
ht i
t a ntf a ul tt .
Pli tf wa de aned f at a ofelve da . Durngt ttm ePl ntf wasno gi
a n if s t i
or ot l
e n ys
i ha i
ai if
t ven
a opporu t t ca iy hi lwf as e sausa no ofi e i tgaed Pli ifssa us.On
n
tniy o lrf s a ul yle t t nd
fc r nvesi t
a ntf tt
t e e nt da o hi de anm e t Pli tf m e wih Ofi erPe e a t e fe , sr l s d.
he l ve h y f s t i n , a n if t t fc
r z nd, her a tr wa eea e
Count1o t Am e d Compl i a lge t tAge sM a rand M a t i n a
f he
nde
ant le s ha
nt ye
h esa nd
Unknown Cusom sa Bo derPa r Age sbr ac adut t r s bl i si at
t
nd r
tol nt e hed
y o ea ona y nve tg e
Pl i ifslwf sa usby f lngt pe mi Pl i ift l a ehi pr ofsauspro t t ng
antf a ul tt
aii o r t antf o oc t s oof t t i r o aki
hi i o c t y, r o m i an i deq t s r h ofPl ntf svehi e, nd f ii t a ce ti
m nt usod pe f r ng na uae ea c
ai if
cl a a lng o s ran
Pli ifslwf sausafe e e i Pl i ifsi or ton it a daa s Count1 oft
antf a ul t t tr nt rng antf' nf ma i n o
tba e.
1 he
Am e
nded Co pl ntalege t tOfi erPe e a Unknown l i a i a Cusom s
m ai l s ha tc
r z nd
mm gr ton nd
t
Enf r e
o c mentOfie swe ene i ntbe us t y di notr s bl i si t Pl i ifs
fc r r glge
ca e he d
ea ona y nve tgae antf
l ulsa us f ld t as rai Pl ntf' l ulsausafe r vi wi Pl ntf fl a f ie
awf tt , aie o ce t n ai if s awf t t tr e e ng ai ifs ie, nd a ld
t m e twih Pl ntf be or t e e nt da ofhi cusody. Co tl1al ge acli f
o e t ai if f e he l ve h y
s t
un l le s a m or
i e i li lci n ofemotonaldites byAge sM a randM aht i n a Unknown
nt ntona nfi to
i
sr s
nt ye
esa nd
Cusom sandBo de Par Age sbypr bii Pli iffom verf ng hi lwf sat a t
t
r r tol nt
ohi tng antf r
iyi
s a ul t us t he
s e oft a r s,co
c ne he r e t nduci a i dequae s r h ofPl ntf vehi e, r c e sy
tng n na
t ea c
ai ips
cl and e kl s l
p e rng t Fo m s18 1200,1862,a 1286 wihoutve iyi Pl i ifsl ulsat .
r pa i he r - 26, nd t
rf ng antf awf t us
Cou I alege i entona i lc i ofe otonaldite sby Unknown l mi a in a
nt V l s nt i l nfiton m i
sr s
m gr to nd
CusomsEnf c ntOf ie sby f bi ng Pl i iffom ve iyi hi l ulsa uswhiei
t
or eme
fc r
or ddi
antf r
rf ng s awf tt
l n
c t f ii t comm uniat Pl i ifscli st t Of ie i c r ofhi fl,Ofier
usody, a lng o
c e antf
am o he fc r n ha ge
s ie fc
Pe e no pe m itng Pl ntf t m e twih Ofk e Pe ezprort t elvent day ofhi c t
r z, t r ti
ai if o e t t r r
i o he e h
s usody,
a no s e ng a at m a i mehodt c i Pli if scli soflwf saus
nd t e ki n le tve t
o ontnu antf
am
a ul t t .
I . M ot on t D i m i s St ndar
l
i o s s a
d
Thepur eofa moton t dim isfld pur ua t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr ed e
pos
i o s s ie
s nt o de al e
vi oc ur
1 ( ()i t ts tefca s fiin yo ac mplit Ther l pemisd s sa o ac mpan
2b)6 s o e t h a il u fce c f o an .
ue r t imis l f o lit
t tf ist s a e a cl i upon w hi h r lefca be g a ed. l s d be r d a ongs de Fe r
ha a l o t t
am
c ei n
r nt
t houl
ea l i
de al
Rueo Cii Pr c d r 8 a( , ihrq ie ai h r a pli sae nt ft cam s wi
l f vl o e u e ()2) wh c e ur s d o t nd an ttme o he li ho ng
s
t tt plade i e ildt r le.'Alhoughac antc le
ha he e r s ntte o eif' t
ompli halngedbyaRul 1 b)6)moton
e 2( (
i
t dim isdoe notne deaie f c ua al to , pli ifi siloblgaed t pr det
o s s
s
ed t ld a t l legai ns a a ntf s tl i t o ovi he
Sr
t ounds'f hi entte e t r le , a S or ul i r c t ton oft el m e sof a c us of
g
' or s il m nt o e i f and l m a c e ia i
f
he e nt
a e
a tonwilno do. BelAtantcCor v Twombl, U. 544,555(
ci
l t ' l l i p. .
'
y 550 S.
2007)
.
W h nac mpliti c aln e u d rRu e1 ( )6 , c u t l p e u ta a1
e o an s h l g d n e l 2 b ( ) a o r wil rs me h t 1
e
4
we lpl de aleg to a et' a viw t pl di i t lghtm os f vor bl t t
l- ea d l a i ns r l nd e he ea ngs n he i
ue
t a a e o he
pli if Ame can UniedL# I .Co.v. tne ,480F. 1 1 (1lhCi. )
antf. ri
t
ns
Mari z
3d 043, 066 t r 2007 .
Howe r onc acour kde ii pla ngst t be a et a eno m or t n co l i ,a e
ve , e
td ntfes e di ha , c us hey r
i
e ha ncusons r
note ild t t a s
ntte o he s umpton oftut 'i mus de em i whe he t we lpl d f c sl t t a
i
r h, t t t r ne
'
t r he l- e a t i a e
s
cli t r i t ti plusbl onisf c ' As rjtv.l ,1 S. .1 1 (
am o elef ha s a i e t a e. hc o qbal 29 Ct 937, 949 2009) A
'
.
c mpan c no l s r iea1 ( )6 mo int d s s i i c n an fcu l le ainsta ae
o lit a ny u vv 2 b ( ) to o imis f t o tis a t a alg to h t r
d nough t r s arghtt r i fa
k
e
o aie i o ele bovet s c a i l ve , t as umpto t ta 1t
he pe ul tve e l on he s
i n ha 1 he
(a t l alegai i t c antaetue.
fcuaj l tons n he ompli r r '
'Twombl 550U. a 555.Howe r awel- ed
y,
S. t
ve,
lpl
c mplits r v samoint d s s ç v ni i srke as v yj d et a a t a p o fo te e
o an uvie
to o imis t e f t ti s a v u g h t cu l r o f h s
e
f ct i i oba e,a Ghatar ove y i ve y r m o eandunlkel ''Twombl 550 U. at
a s s mpr bl nd t
ec r s r e t
i y.'
y,
S.
556.
1 D icussi
11. s
on
A.
Count 1and 1 ar Ba r d By t D icr tona y Func i Exe i t t FTCA
s
1 e re
he s ei r
ton mpton o he
TheUnie St t s e t dimi sCount la 1 be a et y a e ba r b t
t d aes e ks o s s
s nd 1 c us he r red y he
d sr to r f n to e e to t teF
ic einay u cin x mp in o h TCA.S e i al 2 U. C. 26 0a e c p sfo
p cûc l 8 S. j 8 () x e t r m
y,
c r ge oft FTCA :
ove a
he
Any cai ba e upon a ac oro ison ofa e o e oft Gove mne ,e r ii
l m sd
n t m si
n mpl ye
he
r nt xe c sng
duec r ,i t e c i ofasat e o r gulton,whehe ornots h sa ut o
a e n he xe uton
t ut r e a i
t r
uc tt e r
r gulto bevai orbas d upon t e r ieorperor a ort f iur t e r ieor
e ain
ld,
e
he xe c s
f m nce he a l e o xe cs
pe f m adic e i r fmc i ordut on t pa tofaf der lage oran e oy of
ror
s r tona y t ton
y he r
e a
ncy
mpl ee
t Gove nme ,whehe orno t dic e i i ve bea e
he
r nt
t r
t he s r ton nvol d
bus d.
The Supr Co tha s toutat pa t e tf dee m i ngwhe he an a tf l wihi t
eme ur s e
wo- r t s or tr ni
t r c als t n he
dic einayfnci e pton.Unie St e v Gaube t499U. 31 (1 ) Fis,ac t
sr to r u ton xce i
td ats .
r,
S. 5 991. rt our
mu td tr nei t a tiv v sa S lme to j d me to c o c - I .a 3 2.Th r i n
s eemi f he c n ole n d e n f u g n r h ie' d t 2
e
'
ee s o
j d me to c iei v le i tea t ss e iial p e cie b afd r l tt t, e uain, r
u g n r hoc n ov d f h c i p cfc ly r s rb d y e ea saue r g lto o
pole be us t empl eha no c c butt a r t t die tve.1 Se ond,i t
iy ca e he
oye s
hoi e
o dhe e o he r c i
d. c
f he
c aln e a tivov saj g n o c ie ac u t s d tr n i t ea ti C r u d di
h le g d c n le ud me t r hoc , o r mu t eemie f h c s l o n e n
g
t s i l ec
he oc a , onomi orpoltc lg l oft saut a r ul tons' 1 a 323.S he
c,
ii a oas he tt e nd eg ai . d. t
'
s n
W
e t bls d gove nm e alpolc a e es e ori pled by saut r ulton, a
sa ihe
r nt
iy, s xpr s d m i
t t e, eg a i or genc
y
gui i , l aGo r men a ntt e c s dic e i i mus be p e umedt tt
delnes alows
ve n t ge o xer ie s r ton,t t r s
ha he
a entsa t a egr
g ' c s r ounde i polc whe e r ii t tdicr ton. f a 3
d n iy
n xe c sng ha s e i ' #. t 24. I bot pr ngs
'
f h o
a emet t a tf lswihi t dic e i r f ton exc pton.1 a 323.Thus f a
r
,he c al t n he s r tona y unc i
e i
d t
, or
c
ompli t s vi am o i t di mis Pl i ifmus ha alege f c swhi h woul s
ant o ur ve
ton o s s , antf
t ve l d a t
c
d uppor
t
afndi t tt c le ed a tonsa enott ki ofc
i ng ha he ha lng c i
r
he nd onduc t tc n bes i t begr
t ha a
ad o
ounde
d
i t polc oft r gult y r gi e.1 a 3 25.
n he iy he e aor e m
d. t 24TheUnie Stt as e t t ta 1oft c le d a to i CountI- Age sM a ra
t d a es s rs ha 1 he ha lnge ci ns n
nt ye nd
M a esa f ii t pe tPl n ift l t hi pr o sausprort tki hi i o c t
ht i n a lng o nni aitf o ocae s oof f t t i o a ng m nt usody,
pe f m i a i de t s a ch ofPli ifsve ce,a f ii t as e ti Pli ifslwf
ror ng n na qua e e r
antf
hi l nd alng o c ran antf a ul
sa usa tren e i Pli ifsi or i n i o a daa s - a Coun 1 - Pe e f lngt
tt fe t rng antf nf mato nt
tba e nd
t1
r z aii o
r a ona y i si t Pl n ifsl ulsaus f ii t a c ran Pl i ifslwf sausa r
e s bl nve tga e aitf awf t t , a lng o s e ti antf' a ul t t he
r vi ngPl i if sfl ,a f ii t me twih Pl i ifbe or t ee t da ofhi cusody
e ewi
antf ie nd a lng o e t antf f e he lven h y
s t
-
c tt edicei r a to be us t yi ve anelme ofj
onsiut s rtonay cins ca e he nvol d
e nt udgme o c c
nt r hoie.
Plitf do sn ta p a t d s u eta te ea to siv l da ee n of u g n o
anif e o p e r o ip t h t h s cin n ove n lme t j d me t r
choie. I t ad,Pli ifa g t tt s a tonsdi noti veas a ,e ono i o
c z nse
antf r ues ha he e c i
d
nvol
ocil c m c, r
z e i Plitf i ag igt t h s a to ddn tiv l aj d me t rc o c s
Ev n f an if s r un ha t e e cins i o n ove u g n o h ie
Pli ifhasnotal ge t soral ge a f ct t s
a ntf
le d hi
le d ny a s o how t exitnceofa saut orr ul to
he se
t t e eg ai n
t ts c fcal pr c i st a to t bet n by Gove n e a nt i ast ton lket
ha pe ii ly es rbe he ci ns o ake
r m nt ge s n iuai i he
6
poltc polc
ii al i y.
Pl i ifa guest tt a t a i s do noti ve publc polc c
a ntf r
ha he c s t s ue
nvol
i
i y once ns a t ,do
r nd, hus
notm e tt s c pr ng oft e e i
e he e ond o
he xc pton.Pl i ifa s m a nt i t tt polcy c
a ntf l o i a ns ha he i once ns i
r n
t ca e t Unie Stt sct d a e notpr e he e.Howe r t Unied Stt sdi notciet
he s s he t d a e ie r
es nt r
ve ,he t
ae d
t o
t ca e a e m pl oft s m e polc c
he s s s xa es he a
i y once ns pr s nther . Fu t r or ,t Su e e Cour
r
ee
e r he m e he pr m
t
ha s dt ttl he e t ihe govenme alpolc ...al aGover nta ntt e rie
s ai ha iwj n sabls d
r nt iy
lows
nme ge o xecs
dic eton,i m us bepr sume t tt ag ' a t ar gr
sr i t t
e
d ha he ents c s e ounde i polc when e r ii t t
d n iy
xe csng ha
diceton. Gaube t499U. at324(mphassa d)
sr i '
'
r,
S.
e
i dde .Thegovenme alage si t smatr
r nt
nt n hi te
wh r al ci gwihnt erd s rto wh ne e csn t ij d me ta o twheh rt ars
ee la tn ti h i icein e x r iig her u g n b u
te o re t
Pli ithow t s ac Pl ntf sve ce whehe t begn de t inpr ee ngsa i thi
antfl
o e rh ai if hil, t r o i porato oc di gans m,
whe t i e iw Pl ntf,a whehe and whe t c c Pli ifsl ga saus Thus i i
n o ntrve ai if nd
t r
n o he k a ntf e l t t .
,t s
pr s e t t e a tonsa e g ounde i polc Pl i ifsAm e
e um d hat hes c i
r r
d n i y. antf
nded Compl i doe no
ant s t
a lgea f c swhih woul s
le ny a t
c
d uppor a fndi t tt c lng a tonsar nott ki of
t i ng ha he hale ed c i
e
he nd
c
onduc t tc n be s d t be g ounded i t polc oft r ul t r r i
t ha a
ai o
r
n he i y he eg a o y eg me. Cons que l
e nty,
Pli ifhasf ie t esabls t tt e mpto doe no a y.
antf
a ld o t ih ha he xe i n s t ppl
Pli iff t ra guest t si $ ca e ofi fcenc and unne s a y dea whiet
antf urhe r
hat hi s 1 s
a
nefi i y
ce s r ly
l he
Pli ifr i d i cusody.'W hiet sm a betu i doe notr m ovet Unied Stt '
antf emane n t '
l hi y r e, t s
e
he t
aes
a tonsfom t dic etonay f ton exc pton.Ast El ve h Cicui ha notd,t S
c i r he s r i r unc i
e i
he e nt r t s e he C
FTCA
e p e syp o ie t a t ee c p ina p ist p iyj d me t e e t to ec n t uig a u e
x r sl r v d s h t h x e to p le o ol u g n v n o h s o si t b s
c
t n
o sceto ' Aut y r UniedSt e ,99 F. 15 1 28( 1hCi.1 (mphassadde
fdi r in.' er . t ats 2 2d 23, 5 1 t r 993) e
i
d
o he e. Thus Pl ntf ha f ie t es a i h t tt c le d a i nsw e e a hi ot r
ne r
, ai i f s a l d o t bls ha he ha l nge cto
r nyt ng he
t n dic e i y.
ha s r tonar
7
a i enalquottonsomitd) Thus, l t go r nta nt ma ha unne sa iy
nd ntr
ai
te .
whie he venme ge s y ve
ce srl
delye Pl n ifsr e e, ai ifha nots
a d aitf elas Pl ntf s
hownt tt de ii nsm a byt ag swer
ha he c so
de he ent
e
a yh n oh rt a p lc j g n s Ac o digy Co t Ia d1 aed s se wi p eu ie
n ti g t e h n o iy ud me t. c r n l, un s n 1 r imis d t rj d c
h
be a et c l nge a to f l wihi t dic e i r f ton e
c us he hale d c i ns a l t n he s r tona y unc i xempton t t FTCA .
i o he
B.Co nsI1a d1 i t Ad qu tl Al geteElme o ta o s es
u t 1 n VFa lo e aey l h e nt four ge u n s
e
The Unied St t m o st dim isCount lla l f i entonali lci n of
t
aes ve o s s
s l nd V, or nt i
nfi to
emo i ldite s f f iu et sa eacl m upon whi r le c begr nt d. Spe fcal t
tona sr s , or al r o tt
ai
ch ei f an
a e
cii ly, he
Unie Stt a s rst tPli ifha no pld ou r eousconduc , ne s ar elm e of
t d a es s e t ha a ntf s t e tag
t a ce s y e nt
Count lla d I by a oft go r nta nt .Thee e nt ofac am f i t ntona
s l n V, ny he venme ge s
l me s
l i or n e i l
i lci ofe ina dite sae:()delbe aeorrc e si lcto ofmenals f i ()
nfiton moto l srs r 1 i r t e kls nfi in
t uferng; 2
outa ousc
rge onduc;()t c
t 3 he onduc c us dt e i ldite s a ( t dites was
t a e he motona srs ; nd 4) he sr s
s v r .T o sv Hopia Bo r o r co so e Co ny, S 3 2 , 5 ( a 2 DCA
e ee h ma . s t l a d fDie tr fL e u t 41 o. 4 46 2 6 F1. d
201 .Thec
0)
onduc a is dmus bes o rge i c r tr a s e r mei dege t t
t t sue i t o uta ous n haace , nd o xte n re,ha
i i c n iee ar co s( a u tryi tlrb ei acv lz dc mmu t ' 1 (ne n l
ts o sd r d to iu ) nd te l no ea l n iiie o ni ' d. itr a
y.
q o ai n o te ) Asars l,h s b e t rs o s o t ep ro wh i t tr e o t
u tto s mi d .
t
e ut te u j ci e p n e f h e s n o s he a g t f he
ve
c
onduc doe notc r .fiery MutalI ur Co.v Stadman,968So. 592, ( a.
t s ontol b t u ns ance
. e
2d
595 F1
2dDCA 2007) Thedeemi tonofwhehe conduc i o rgeo enought s
.
tr nai
tr
t s uta us
o uppor acam
t li
f i e i li lci ofe o i dites i a q ton of1 w f rac tt dee m i I
or nt ntona nti ton m tonal sr s s uesi
a o our o t r ne. d
TheUnie St t sa gue t tt ewasnot ng outa ousi t conduc ofAge s
t d a e r s ha her
hi
r ge
n he
t
nt
M a a M a e i n i f ii t pe m i Pl i ift l a ehi pr ofsa uspro t tki hi
yer nd ht sa n alng o r t antf o oc t s oof tt
i r o a ng m
i ocusody, alng t l a ePl ntf spr ofsa uswhe t y s a c d hi ve cl and
nt
t f ii o oc t ai if oof tt
n he e r he s hi e,
f ii t a c ran Pl i ifslwf sa usa trentrng Pl n ifsi o ma i i o a daa s
a lng o s e ti antf a ul tt fe e i
aitf nf r ton nt
tba e.
W he Age sM a ra M a esa soppe Pl i ifhewa notc ryi hi pr ofofsauson
n
nt ye nd ht i n t d antf
s
a r ng s o
tt
hi peron,a r r by l w,a Pli ifadmit d t the wa an a in.Thus tki Pli tf
s s
s equied a nd antf
te ha
s le
, a ng a n if
i ocusody, trs r hi hi tunk f rhi pr ofsa us a r sedby Pl i if a no
nt
t afe ea c ng s r
o s oof t t , s eque t
antf, nd t
tndi i, noto r geo co
i ng t was
uta us nduc .Norwa i o r ge f Age sM a ra M a esa
t
s t uta ous or nt ye nd ht i n
t b gnde o tto p o e d n sa an tPli t fwh c wo dalw a i g ainj g t
o e i p rain r c e i g g is ani , ih ul lo n mmirto ud e o
f
dee ne Pli ifslwf saus Age M a randM a t s a sa tonssmpl dono rs t
tnni
antf a ul t t .
nt ye
h e i n' c i i y
t ie o
t l lofouta ous s ne es a yt s t i ac am . Co eque l Countl1i dimi s d
he eve
r ge ne s c s r o usan l i
ns nty,
I s s se
wihprj ie
t eudc .
TheUnie Stt alo a gue t tt r wa not ng outa ousa
td aes s r s ha he e s hi
r ge
boutt a tonsof
he c i
Ofi rPe e a t Unknown I i a i a CusomsEnf c m e Ofi e s TheUnie
fce r z nd he
mm gr ton nd
t
or e nt fc r .
td
St t ur t tt i ac i we e notouta ousbe us Pli ifwasl wf l de a ne unde
aes ges ha he r tons r
r ge
ca e antf
a uly t i d
r
t a to i o 8U. C. 1 26 a, c p o i e t a ço nawa rn is e b t eAto n y
he uh rt f S. j 2 () whih r v d s h t' l
y
g
ra t su d y h t r e
Ge r l a ai n m a bea r t d a de a n pe ng ade son on whehe t a in i t be
ne a , n le
y
rese nd t i ed ndi
cii
t r he le s o
r m o d fom t Unied St t s' Pli ifr pondst ti w a ou r geoust thewa hed f
e ve r he t
a e . antf es
'
ha t s ta
ha
s l or
elve da whe hewaslwf l i t Unie Stt .Howe r unde 8U. C.j
e n ys n
a uly n he td aes
ve , r S.
1 ()2)B) i ar movalpr ee ng,hebur ni o t aint esabls t thei l uly
229ac( ( ,n e
oc di t
de s n he le o t ih ha s awf l
pr s nti t Unie St es Pl n ifha no s wn t tOfk e Pe e ora oft Unknown
e e n he t d at . aitf s t ho ha f r r z ny he
l i ai a Cusom sEnf c m e Ofi r we er quie t i tga ePl ntf ' cli
mm gr ton nd
t
or e nt fce s r e r d o nvesi t ai ifs am
t thewa l wf l pr e i t Unie St t s Pl i ifhasnots
ha
s a uly es nt n he t d a e . antf
hown t ta ofPe e or
ha ny
r z'
a oft Unknown l i ai a Cusom sEnf c m e Ofi r 'a tonswe eunlwf .
ny he
mm gr ton nd
t
or e nt fce s c i
r
a ul
Thus i t age t w e eal aci lwf l Pl i ifc nnote tbls t tt i conduc wass
, f he n s r 1 tng a uly, antf a
sa ih ha her
t
o
ou r ge i c r t r a s e r m ei degr e, ha i i co i r d ar i a ute l
ta ous n ha ace , nd o xte n
e t t t s nsde e tocous nd try
i olr l i a cvii d c muniy. Cons nty,Pl i ifhasf ie t pl ada c us ofaci
nt e ab e n i lze om
t
eque l antf
al d o e
a e
ton
f i e tona i lc i ofemotona dite sa CountI mus bedim is
or nt n i l nfiton
i l sr s nd
V
t
s s ed.
A c r ngl i i
co di y, t s
ORDERED ta Dee da t'Mo int DimisFrtAme d d Co litg 2 Ji
h t fn ns to o s s is
n e mp an DE- 3 s
G M N TED ;
A.Pli tf sAme d dCo liti DI M I ED wi p eu ie
anif
n e mp an s S SS
t rj d c .
h
B.A1 pe ngm oto notot r s r e upon ar DENI a moot
1 ndi
ins
he wie uld
e
ED s
.
C. Thi ca e i CLO SED .
s s s
r
&
DONEAND ORDERED a MimiFlrd ,hs / d yo J ne 2 2.
t a , oia ti W a f u , 01
U
ATRI A A .S TZ
CI
UN I
TED STATES D l RI J GE
S CT UD
c
c:
A1 c
l ouns lofr c d
e
e or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?