Hermoza v. Aroma Restaurant, LLC et al

Filing 23

ORDER denying 13 Motion to Dismiss. Defendants shall file an Answer to the Amended Complaint by 2/10/12. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 1/30/12. (mg)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SO UTH ERN DISTRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .11 23026- V - TZ/ M ON TON
CI SE1 SI
CESAR HERM OZA,
Pli if
antf ,
VS.

A RO M A R ESTA UR AN T, LC,a Fl i
L
or da
Li i e L i lt C om pany and
m t d abii y
M AR K ENG E LH A RD ,i vi l
ndi dualy,

De e
f ndan s
t.
/
O R DE R D EN YI G D EFEN DA N TS'M O TI N TO DI I
N
O
SM SS

THI M ATTER i beor t Cour on De e nt'M otont Dimis( 1 ,i whi
S
s f e he
t
f nda s i o s s DE- 3) n ch
Def nt s e t dimi sPl ntf scli pur ua t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur
enda s e k o s s ai if a m
s nt o de al e
vi oce e

1 b)6 .Pli ifsFis Ame
2( () antf rt ndedCo ai alege avi ai oft FarLaborStndar
mpl nt l s olton he i
a ds
Ac (
t FLSA)a avi aton oft Fl i M i mum W a Ac.Bohcli aeba e on
nd ol i
he orda ni
ge t t ams r s d
D ef nt 'f iur t pa Pl i ifm i m um w a Def nda ss ek t di m i s t A m e d
enda s a l e o y a ntf ni
ge.
e nt e o s s he
nde

Co pl ntbec us Pl i ifwa atpped e oye and waspad a vet mi mum wa f
m ai
a e antf s i
mpl e
i bo he ni
ge or
tppe e o s Be a et bur n i onDef ntt esa ih t tan e pl e i atppe
i d mpl yee . c us he de s
enda o t bls ha
m oye s i d
em pl e,t M oton i de e
oye he
i s ni d.
Fac sA leg i t A m e d C om pl nt
t l ed n he
nde
ai

Pl ntf algest thewasemplye byDee tAr Retur ,LLC ( oma
ai if le ha
o d
fndan oma sa ant
Ar )
f om Apr l22,2008 t ough A pr l22,2011. A r a e pl ye Pl i ifasan S t w il' nonr
i
hr
i
om m o d a ntf
l - l,'
a
exe pts r r W hie e pl yed b A r a Pl i ifdi notha a cl runde s a ng ast
m e ve .
l m o
y om , a nt f d
ve ea
r t ndi
o
ho he w ast be c pe a e f hi w or D urng t tm e hew a e pl d,he w aspa d
w
o
om ns t d or s k.
i he i
s m oye
i

$3. a houra ass h di notr e vet r quiedm i m u wa undert FLSA ort
50 n
nd uc d
ec i he e r
ni m ge
he
he
Fl i M i m um W ag A c .
orda ni
e t
I.
I

M ot on To D i m i s St
i
s s andar
d

Thepu os ofam o i t dim isfl d pur ua t Fe r lRul ofCi lPr dur
m e
ton o s s ie
s nt o de a
e
vi oce e

1 b)6)i t t tt fca s fci yofac ant Ther epemisdimis ofa
2( ( s o es he a il ufi enc
ompli .
ul r t s sal
c
ompli t f ist sat a c am u whi h r le ca begr ntd. l s d ber d a ongsde
a nt hat a l o t e l i pon
c e if n
a e t houl
ea l i

Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e8( ( ,whihrquie adhor a pli saeme oft cai
deal e
vi oc dur a)2) c e rs t t nd an tt nt he l m
s
s i t tt pl ade i e il d t r i f' A lhoug a c pl i c le d by a Rul
how ng ha he e r s ntte o ele ' t
h om a nt ha l nge
e

l b)6)motont dimisdoesnotne ddealdfct algai ,apli ifi siloblgae
2( (
i o s s
e tie a ual le tons antf s tl i td
t pr vi t t ounds'f hi e ilm e t r le , nd ai or uli r iai oft eeme s
o o de he s
gr
' or s ntte nt o e if a
' m a c ect ton he l nt
f

ofaca eofa i wilno do. BelAtantcCor v Twombys550U. 544,555(
us
cton l t ' l l i p. .
'
l
S.
2007)
.

W h nac mpli i c alng du d rRu e1 ( )6 , c r wil r s meta a1
e o ants h l e n e l 2 b ( ) a ou t l p e u h t 1
e
wel- ea d ale tonsa etuea vi t pl a ngsi t lghtm os f r bl t t
lpl de l ga i
r r nd ew he e di n he i
t avo a e o he

pli if Ame c Unie LfeI .Co.v. ari z, 0F. 1 1 ( lhCi.2007)
antf. rian td / ns
'
M tne 48 3d 043, 066 1 t r
.
Howe r onc a c tdde ii spladi t t be aus t y a e no mor t n c usons a e
ve , e our di ntfe e ngs ha , c e he r
e ha oncl i , r

note il d t t as umpton oftut ' i m us dee m i whet rt we lpl d f ct ( tt a
ntte o he s
i
r h,' t t tr ne
he he l- e a s t a e
s
cai t r le t ti plusbl on isf e. hcr.j r I , 29 S. .1
l m o e if ha s a i e t ac '
'As o t . qbal 1
Ct 937,1 ( ) A
949 2009 .

c antc n o ys vi a 1 b ()moto t dimisi i c nt nsfcua algai t tae
ompli a nl ur ve 2()6 in o s s f t o ai a t l le tons ha r
ç nough t r iearghtt r le a vet s ultve lvel on t a s
s
e
o as i o ei f bo he pec a i e , he s umpton t ta1 t
i ha 1 he

(a t l algai i t c antaetue. Twombl 550U. a 555.Howe r awel
fcual le tons n he ompli r r '
'
y,
S. t
ve, lpld c ants r ve amoi t dimist ni i srke as vvyj dget ta ua pr of
e ompli uvi s ton o s s s f t ti s a u ha ct l oof
eve
t e f c si i oba e, nd dha ar cove y i ve yr
hes a t s mpr bl a t t e
r s r emot a unlkel '' Twombl 550U .
e nd i y.'
y,
S.
a 55
t 6.

1
11.

D i cussi
s
on

De e
f ndant a guet tt Ame d Compli s d be dimi s d be aus Pli ifwa
s r
ha he
nde
ant houl
s s e c e antf s
a tpped e pl e w ho w a pai t r quied m i m um w a f tppe e pl yee a t ,
i
m oye
s d he e r
ni
ge or i d m o s nd, hus

c r saeaca eofa i unde t FLSA.Seci 203( oft FLSA st outt ma r
amot tt us cton
r he
ton m) he
es he nne
i whih a e oye maycompe aeatppede oye 29U. C.j203( .Howe r t
n c n mpl r
nst i
mpl e.
S.
m)
ve ,he
e oy ma onl utlz t sm a rofc pe a i c c ai i is h e oye ha be n
mpl er y y iie hi nne
om ns ton alulton f çuc mpl e s e
i or by t e pl rof t pr so oft ss e i a a 1tpsr ceved b s
nf med he m oye
he ovii ns hi ubs cton, nd l i e i
y uch

e o ha be nrti dbyt emplye ' 29U. C.j203( .Pli ifsAme
mplyee ve e eane
he
o e.'
S.
m) antf'
nded
Compl ntalege t thet d notha acla unde sa ng a t how hewast be
ai l s ha
i
di
ve e r
rt ndi s o
o

c mp nstdwihr s c t h swo k' DE- a !1 .Be a et eb r e i o tee o e t
o e ae t epe t o i r .
' 7 t 3 c us h u d n s n h mply r o
e tb iht a h i e tte t t etpce tBar eln v T n En ihPu , n .5 7F.d
sa ls h t e s n i d o h i rdi, c lo a . ta y gl
l
s b I c, 9 2
464, ( t Ci.1 ,Pl ntf ha sae ac us ofa ton.Ta ngt aleg i i t
467 5h r 979)1 ai if s ttd a e ci
ki he l atons n he
Ame d Compli a tue t Pl i ifha s fc e l pld t De enda sdi noti or
nde
ant s r , he antf s ufi i nty e hat f nt d
nf m
Pl i ifoft pr sonsoft FLSA r r ng compe a i f tpped e oye a t t
antf he ovi i
he
ega di
ns ton or i
mpl es nd ha
Pl ntf wasnotpa d mi mum wag f t hour hewor d. Acc di y,i i he e
ai if
i ni
e or he
s
ke
or ngl t s r by

ORDERED t t fnd n ' M oint Dimisg 1 1i DENI Dee da t s al
ha Dee a ts to o s s DE- 3 s
ED. fn ns h l
f l a A ns rt t Am e d Co pl ntby Fe uar 1 201
ie n
we o he
nde
m ai
br y 0r 2.

DONE

a dORDERED i MimiFlrd ,hsY
n
n a , oia ti
v -

'
.

(

,

N

d yofJn ay 2 2.
a a u r, 01
%
.

PA T CI A .SEl Z
A
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI T CO U RT JU D GE
C
c
c:

Al c
l ouns ofr cor
el e d

1nBonnerv. Ci o ih d, F.d 1 6 1 09( 1hCi. 981 ( nba c ,he
1
t fprc ar 66l 2 20 , 2 1 t r 1 ) e n ) t
y
Elve h Cicui adopt asbi ng pr
e nt r t
ed
ndi
ecedentt decii oft f m erFit Cicui ha
he
sons he or
fh r t nded
down prort Ocobe l,l 1
i o t r 98 .