Alexander v. Hall, Ferguson and Hewitt Mortuary, P.A. et al

Filing 21

ORDER denying 19 Defendants' Motion to Dismiss Second Amended Complaint and Incorporated Memorandum of Law. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/27/2012. (tkn)

UNI
TED STA TES DI
STRI C OU RT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i iD i s on
am
vii
C as N um be 11- 38- I - O R EN O
e
r: 231 C V M
PETR A A LEX AN D ER ,

Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

H A LL, FE R G U SO N , A N D H E W I
TT
M O RTUA RY , A .and TON Y E.
P. ,
FERGU SON ,
D e e nt .
f nda s

O RD ER D EN YI G DEFEND AN TS'M O TI N T O DI I SEC O N D A M EN D ED
N
O
SM SS
CO M PLAI T AN D I C O R PO R ATED M EM O R AN D UM O F LA W
N
N

THI CAUSE c mebef et Cour uponDe e nt ' otont Dim isSec
S
a
or he
t
f nda s M i o s s
ondAm e d
nde

Co anta l portdMe a
mpli nd nco ae morndum ofLa ( E. 1 ,iedonAprl30. 2.Pli if
w D. No. 9) fl
i 201 antf
Pe r A l xa rbr
t a e nde oughts ta ns D e e nt H a l Fe gus and Hew itM or ua y,P. .a
ui gai t f nda s l, r on,
t
t r A nd

To E. r on f vi a i oft FarLa Stnda dsAc .I r s
ny Fe gus or oltons he i bor a r
t n e pons ,De e nt fl a
e f nda s ied
m o i t dim i s cl i i t t Pl i if s com pl ntf ie t of e s fci t f c ua s ppo tt
ton o s s a m ng ha a ntf
ai a l d o f r uf i en a t l u r o
de onsr t a pl us bl a i ton oft Ac . Thi Cour di a e w ih Def nda s a gum e s
m t a e a i e pplca i
he t
s
t s gr es t
e nt ' r
nt ,

fndi i t a t tPli ifha i l d an a uae f c ua f
i ng nse d ha antf s nc ude
deq t a t l ounda i f i vi lc r e
ton or ndi dua ove ag
unde t Ac . Cons que l t Cour de esDe e nt 'm oton t dim is
r he t
e nty,he
t ni
f nda s
i o s s.
1. FA CT UA L BA CK G RO UN D

Pl i ifA l xa
a ntf e ndera l ge t the e pl r ,Hal,Fe gus a H e itM o t r a
le s ha r m oye s
l r on nd w t r ua y nd
'
Tony E.Fe g on,de e he ove tm e c pens ton f w or e ks l rt n f t hotr .
r us
ni d r r i om
a i or kw e onge ha ory ls
She c e t tt sde a wasw ilulon t pa tofD e e
ont nds ha hi ni l
lf
he r
f ndant ,a w a c e nty
s nd s ons que l

u a ulunde t Ac .
nlwf
r he t
I . LE G AL STAN D A RD
l
: s vi a m oton t di m i s pl i if m us do m or t n m e e y s a e l ga
$ ur ve
To
i o s s , a ntf s
t
e ha
rl tt e l

co usons' Jacs v Bel hTelc
ncl i . kon . lsout e omm.372F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.
'
,
3d 250, 263 1 t r 2004) I ta
. nse d,
pl ntf sm us Salege s e s fc f ualbass f t e concl i orf di i aloft r
ai if
t s l om pecii act
i or hos
usons ace sm ss
hei
cl m s.'1 l r i on a m oton t di i a courtm us vi t com pl nti t lghtm os
ai ' d. n ulng
i o sm ss,
t ew he
ai n he i
t
f abl t t pl ntf and ass e t veraciy ofwel- eaded f ualalegatons. Speake v.
avor e o he ai if
um he
t
lpl
act
l i
r

US De 'o at d Hu nS r s Ctsf rDie s Co to d Pr v nin, 2 F.d 1 71
. p t fHe l r ma e v . r .o s a e nr l r e e t 6 3 3 3 ,
h
o
1 ( 1hCi. 1 .Howe rt stne doe no a yt lga c usons a s h
379 1 t r 20 0)
ve,hi e t s t ppl o e l oncl i , nd uc
c l i S tbes poredb fcualal ai . As rjtv I ,556U. 662,679
oncusons t
mus up t y a t leg tons' hc o . qbal
'
S.
( ) Thoughaprpe c mpli çd notne ddeaie fcualalg tons'imus c an
2009.
o r o antkoes
e t ld a t le ai , t t onti
'
S o e t n l b s a con usons a a f r ul i r cia i oft e e e sofa c e ofa to
d r ha a el nd cl i , nd o m a c e t ton he l m nt
m
aus
ci n

wilnotdo.'Bel l i Cop.v T
l
' lAtantc r . wombl 550U. 5 55 (
y,
S. 44, 5 2007) Atami mum, pli if
.
ni
a antf
m us pr e te gh f c st s a e a c a m t r i t ti pl usbl on is f c ' I a 57
t es nt s nou a t o t t l i o elef ha s a i e t a e. d t 0.
'
1 1 DI
1 . SCU SSI N
O
Und rt Fa rLaborSt nda ds A c ,i e pl rs l e pl a ofhi e pl ee
e he i
a r
t s m oye ha l m oy ny
no
s m oy s
w ho i a wor e k i e ag i c m e ce ori t pr
n ny
kw e s ng ed n om r
n he oduc i ofgoods f c m e c ori
ton
or om r e, s
e pl ed i a e e prs e ag i c m e c ori t pr
m oy n n nt r i e ng ed n om r e n he oduc i ofgoods f rcom m er e, or
ton
o
c f

awor ekl rt f t ho s' e shepr de a quaecompe ai 29U. C.j
kwe onge han ory ur'unls
ovi s de t
nston.
S.
207()1.Onewa t r or t esa ihe oye la lt unde t Ac i t s t tt
a( )
y heef e o tbls mpl r ibiiy
r he t s o how ha he
e pl ye wasd
m o e
t ge i c m e c ori t pr
enga d n om r e n he oduc i ofgoods f r c m e c ' ot r s
ton
o om r e, he wi e
'
known a i vi lcove a
s ndi dua
r ge.

-

2-

F0ra e oy t be ( nga d i c
n mpl ee o t ge n omm e c '
e
r e'unde t fr tpr ofi vi
r he is ong ndi dual
c r ge, m us
ove a he
t

die typatci te i t a t lmove ntofpe s ort ngsi
rcl ri pagq n he cua
me
rons hi n
i esaec
ntrtt ommeceby()wor ngfra i t menalt ofi esae
r
i ki o n nsnz t iy ntrtt
co me c ,e. ,ta porai o c
m r e g. r ns tton r omm u c ton i tye pl es o
nia i ndusr m oye , r

(i byrg al usngt i tu t iisofi e saec
i) e ulry i he nsr menalte ntrtt ommec i hi
re n s
wor e. ,r ul ra r c r us ofi e sa et e
k, g. eg a nd e urent e nt rt t elphone, e e a
t l gr ph,
m a l ,o t a l
is r r ve .

Thor v A1Re or i Se v .I .448F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.2006)(ii 29C. R.j
ne . 1 st aton r s, nc,
3d 264, 266 1 t r
ctng
F.
776. *4 ;29C. R.j77 24) Alenai l unde t s c pr e oye e
23( 2)
F.
6. . tr tvey, r he e ond ong, mpl es ngage i
dn
t S oduci n ofgoodsf c
he t
pr
to
or omm e c 'i udea e oye t
r e' ncl
ny mpl e d
whos wor i c os yr lt d
e k s l el ea e

a diecl e s nta t t pr ton o goodsf c
nd r ty s e il o he oduci f
or ommec ' I a 1 (ii 29C. R.j
re. d t 269 ctng
'
F.
7 1 .
76.8)
l herc pl i ,Pl i ifa s t la lt unde t Ac pur ua t t fr tpr of
n
om a nt a ntf s ers i biiy
r he t s nt o he is ong

i vi lc r ge. Specfca l s sae t ts wa a e oye û
ndi dua ove a
ii ly, he tt s ha he s n mpl e s ge i c
enga d n omm e c '
r e'
ass i e a l a on a r cur e bas spa tci t i t a t lm ove e ofper ons or
he s gul ry nd
r
e r nt i r i pa ed n he c ua
m nt
s
t ngs i i e s a e com m e c by r gul r y us ng t i t
hi n nt r t t
re
e a l i he nsnune altesofi e s at c m e c i
nt ii
nt r t e om r e n

he wo k. He j bd te icu e .
r r ' r o u is n ld d'
'
r gul a r c r ntus ofda l i e s a e t l phone c l a f s a
e ar nd e ur e
e
iy nt r t t e e
als nd axe nd
maii t a r ngef ne al,a r ngef tans r ofc ps sf f r l ,
lngs o ra
' r s ra
u
or r po t or e or ' a s
une
t or rgoodsus d r s l f t ope atonsofDe e nt 'busne sa
o de
e e ae or he r i
f nda s
i s nd
t c i t e s e e ofi ur nc cove a a t s tup i ur nc
o onfnn he xi t nc
ns a e
r ge nd o e
ns a e
c a m sw ih v i outofs a e i ur e c pa es
li
t arous
t t ns anc om ni .
A s um i t t u h oft e f t a vi i t m i t lghtm os f r bl t
s ng he r t
hes ac s nd ew ng he n he i
t avo a e o
Pl ntf , he c pl i pr desa ade t f c ua bas sf is l alc us on t tt A c
ai i f t om a nt ovi
n qua e a t l i or t eg oncl i ha he t
a i st De enda s unde a i vi lc r ge t y. Pl ntf s a e t ts die ty
pple o f
nt
r n ndi dua ove a heor
ai if t t s ha he r c l

-

3-

pa tci t d i t m ove e ofco s a goodsf r s l i i e sa eco me c by r gulry
ri pa e n he
m nt
p es nd
or e ae n nt r tt m r e e a l
usnga i t m e aiy ofi e saecommer e, m ey i e sa et e
i n nsnz nt lt
ntr t t
c na l nt r tt elphonec l .Thi pr de
als
s ovi s
e
nough ofa f nda i n f a pl us bl c a m ofi vi lcove a la lt t s r ve
ou to or a i e l i
ndi dua
r ge i biiy o u vi
Def nd t 'm oton t di m i s
e an s
i o s s.
I . CO N C LU SI N
V
O
Fort a ve r a ons i i
he bo e s , t s

ADJUDGED t tDef nt 'M o i t Dim isSe
ha
enda s ton o s s cond Am e d Co pl ntand
nde
m ai
l r a e M e or um ofLa i DEN I .
nco por t d m and
w s
ED

D ON E A N D O RD ERED i Cha be s a M i i Fl r da t
n
m r t am , o i , hi

A
'
..

' da ofJ
y une,201
2.

.

F ERI
. OR EN O
M
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U

Co e pr de t
pis ovi d o:
Co e ofRe or
uns l
c d

4-

-