Campbell v. Air Jamaica Limited/Caribbean Airlines

Filing 34

FINAL ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/17/2012. (jw)

I TH E U NI
N
TED STATES DISTR I CO U R T
CT
FO R TH E SO UTH ERN DI
STR I T O F FLO R I A
C
D
M I M ID I I O N
A
V SI
C as No. 11 C V e : - 23233- I G
K N
A LLAN CAM PBELL,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

A l J A I LTD .a
R AM CA
nd
CARI
BBEAN AI NES,
RLI

De e nt .
f nda s
/

FI
NAL ORDER O F DISM I
SSAL W I PREJUDI
TH
CE
TH I M ATTER comesbe or t Cour upon Def ntAi J m aca Lt ' M o i t
S
f e he
t
enda
r a i
d.s ton o

Dimis( #20 a Dee ntCai a Ailne Li td' M oi t Dimis( #22)
s s DE ) nd fnda
rbbe n ri s mie s ton o s s DE
,
fld J 22,201 andJ 27,a01 r pe tvel Theen,Defnda Ai J iaLt (i r
ie une
2
une ' 2, es ci y. ri
!
e nt r amac d. ç
Ai

Jmac ' se sd s s a oftea o esye a to f rlc o s b e tmatr u idcin whl
a ia' e k imis l h b v -t ld cin o a k f u j c te j rs ito , ie
)
Dee n Cai n Ailne Li td Cd rbbe n Ailnes' s e dimis lof t a ve
fnda t rbbea ri s mie ca i a ri ' e ks s s a
)
he bo syl a ton a tm e ba r d. The Cour i f l bre e o t m at r a d pr ee wih t
t ed c i s i - re
t s uly if d n he te 1 n oc ds t he
be i ofor a gum e .2U pon car f co i er ton oft alega i ofPli if Campbel'
neft
al r
nt
he l tons
antf
ls
e u1 nsd a i

Ame
nded Compli ( #9)and t a gume ss tf t i t Pa te 'brei a atorl
ant DE
he r nt e orh n he ris ifngs nd
a

a g me t t e Co r fn s i mu tds s te a o esye a to f rlc o s be tmatr
r u n, h u t id t s imis h b v -t ld cin o a k f u j c te
J rs c in.
' idi to
u

lPli ifCa
antf mpbel fld hi Res e ( #23,24)onJ y 9a J y 1 201 r pe vel
l ie s pons s DE
ul nd ul 6, 2, es di y,
a Defnda sildRe is( 126,3 o J y 1 a J y24,201 r peci l
nd e nt e ple DE / 2) n ul 8 nd ul
2, es tvey.
2The C o t a d or a gum e s on A ug t 1 2012.
ur he r al r
nt
us ,

The a
bove-t e aci a ies fom Def ndan s a lge r f a t a l Pl i if
syl d ton rs r
e
t ' le d e us l o low antf
Ca
mpbel t boar a fi f whi h he wastc td,whi h Pl ntf Ca
lo
d lght or c
ikee
c ai if mpbe lal gesca e
l le
us d
hi t s f r a hea ta tck.Pl ntf Ca pbe l pr e ngpr s fld t i talCompli t
m o ufe
r ta
ai if m l, oce di
o e, ie he nii
an

( #1 on Se e r7,2011 Bef es r cewa efcuaed,t Cour s s e dimis d
DE )
ptmbe
. or evi
s fe t t he
t ua pont s se

t e Co litwih u p eu ie f rfiu e t sae a cam a d f r fiu e t sae a e uae
h mpan t o t rj dc o alr o tt li n o alr o tt d q t

go n s f r s b e t matr j rs ito ( # ) Plitf Ca el fld t Ame d d
r u d o u j c te u idcin. DE 4 . an if mpb l ie he
ne
Compli ( #9)onDe mber1 2011 whihi now t o rtvepladng.
ant DE
ce
2, , c s
he peai e i
I t Ame d Com pli ,Pli ifCa pbe lal ge t the ha atc f a ti hton
n he
nde
a nt antf m l le s ha
d iket or lg
Ai J i s hed e t de r fom t Nor
r amaca c uld o pa t r he
man M a ey Aipor i Ki t J i a o
nl
r t n ngson, ama c n
Se e be 8,2009,a a vi att For La r l l olywood Aipor i For La r e,
ptm r
nd ni ng he t ude dae-l l
r t n t ude dal

Flrd o t e smed y.( Co .! 1 ) W h n ç litf p o e d d t e ak o s i
o ia n h a a Am. mpl ! &2 . e i an if r c e e o mb r n ad
p
tih ...ge wa r c l d b c t te b adng g t ...(n lt l t the wo l n tb
lg t
h ) s e al a k o h o r i ae
e
a d od ha
ud o e
a co moda e on t fi a s d r ur t t c k-n cot ert a r nget de r on t
c m
td
he lght nd houl et n o he hec i mt o ra
o pa t he

n x fih . (d ! 8 ) Plitf Cn elalg st a t ee d n lja td n g ie ty'b
e t lg t' 1 . ! &9 . anif mpb l le e h t s fn a ts ce e lg n l' y
'
d
k e li t pli if t t boa di ga e whie t pli if wa e ba ki ' d
i calng he antf o he r ng t
r
l he antf s m r ng,' t
bumpi t
ng he

pan iffo t fi h, d lyn P an ifCa b l' ta e t Ft La ed l,deu ln )t
litf r m he lg t' ea ig litf mp els r v l o . ud r ae t f sig o
'
r
ac
c ommodae t pli if a a hot ,gnd)l vi pli if srnded a t aipor untlt
t he antf t
el a ea ng antf ta
t he r t i he
f l ng da ' when he c d e nt ly boa d a fihtt Ft La r e upon pa e ofa
olowi
yr
'
oul ve ual
r
lg o . ude dal
ym nt

$1 00 c a g fe (d ! 1 -1 ) Plitf Ca b l s e s $ ,0 0 00 i d ma e f ra
5 .0 h n e e , 1 ! 1 3 . anif mp el e k 50 0,0 .0 n a g s o
h a tatc h s fee alg d y a a r s l o te d ly.Asa b ssf rf d rlj rs ito
e r ta k e u fr d le e l s e ut f h ea
a i o e ea u idcin,
Plitf Ca bela srst a f d rlj rs ito i p o e u d rAril 3 o t e M o te l
an if mp l se t h t e ea u idcin s r p r n e tce 3 f h
nr a

Con nto be aus he as e t c am s f d ma e f r p ro a ij r . ( m.compl j
ve i n, c e
s rs l i
or a g s o e s n l n u y3 A
.
!

1 9) Con nto frt Uniiai ofCe ti RulsReltngt l enai lTrns rai
8&1 . ve in o he fc ton
ran e ai o ntr tona a po tton
byAi a t 33,donea Monte on 28 M a 1 I
r r.
t
ral
y 999, CAO Doc No.9740 (ntrd i o f ceon
.
e ee nt or

No 4 2 0 ) rprn e i S.Tr ay Do .No 1 6- , 1 9 W L 3 2 2 3 geen fe
v. , 0 3 , e itd n
et c
0 45 9 9
3 9 7 4 h ri a tr
d n ra Co v nin' o ç n e to ' (o ern s be t matr j rs ito o c u t
t te l n e to ' r s v n in' c nfrig u j c te u id cin n o rs
Mo
co
)
l a e i t l ai oft pli ifs pe m a tr i nc i cai i da es f de h or
oc t d n he oc ton
he antf
r nen esde e f l m ng mag or at

pes na ij r ) Be o et Co r n w i De e d n s M o in t Dimis ( / 0 2 )
ro lnu y . f r he u t o s fn a t' to s o s s .DE / , 2 .
2
W ih t i t nt M otons De e nt pr s nt c r c or a g e s a t why t s
t he nsa
i , f nda s e e ontadit y r um nt s o
hi

Co r s o l d s s tea o e sye a to wi p eu ie Dee d n Ai J mac ag e ta
u t h ud imis h b v -t ld cin t rj dc . fn a t r a ia r u s h t
h

t i Co r lc s b e tmatrj rs ito ,b c u e t Ame d d Co litf i t alg a
hs u t a ks u jc te u id ci n e a s he
n e mpan al o le e
s
cai unde t Monte lConve i ( /20) By co rs,Defnda Ca i a Ailne
lm
r he
ra
nton. DE / .
nta t e nt rbbe n ri s

c n e e t a ti Co r h s s b e tmatrj rs it n u d r te M o te lCo ve to ,b t
o c d s h t h s u t a u j c te u idci n e h
o
nra n n in u
ag s t tt a
r ue ha he bove syld aci s d be dim is neve t es unde t lmia i '
-t e
ton houl
s s ed
rhel s
r he i t tons

pe i ofAri e35 oft Conve i 4( /22) Upon c r f c i rton oft pladi ,
rod
tcl
he
nton. DE / .
a eul onsdeai
he e ngs
t pr e alhit y oft s ma t ,a t Pa te 'ar um e s t Cour fnds t ti mus
he oc dur sor
hi ter nd he ri s g nt , he
ti
ha t
t

d s s t a to f rtelc o s b e t te j rs ci n.
imis he cin o h a k f u j c matr u idito

3Th M o te lCo ve to c n ese cusv s be tmatrj rs ito i fd r lc u to e
e n ra n nin o fr x l ie u j c te u idcin n e ea o r v r
tre t p s o cams f r d ma e a an ta itr aina c rir 1) ij r t p se g r
h e y e f li o a g s g is n nen to l a re : . n u y o a s n e s
( tce 1 ;2. da gel sofl gage ( tcl 18 ;a 3. dea t pase r orl ge
Aril 7) ) ma /os
ug
Ari e ) nd ) ly o s nge s ugga
( tce1 .Monte Conve i a t 1 -1 24.
Aril 9)
ral
nton r. 7 9,
4Def nda Ai J m aca make t lmia i 'perod a gum e i t aler tve i t e nt
e nt r a i
s he i t tons
i r
nt n he t na i , n he ve

ta ti Co r fn j rs ito p o e u d rt M o te l n e to ( /2 )
h t h s u t ids u id cin r p r n e he nr a Co v n in. DE / 0 .
3

I t Ame d Compli ,Pli if Ca
n he
nde
ant a ntf mpbelpur rs t a s r cli s f da ag
l po t o s e t am or m es

und bot Ari l 1 a Ari 1 oft Conve i .5Ari e 1 pr desf c r irla lt
er h tce 7 nd tde 9 he
nton
tcl 9 ovi or a re ibiiy
f or da
i
f
mage oc asone by de a i t c ri ge by ai of pa s r , bagg
c i d
l y n he a ra
r
s enge s
age or c go.
ar '
'
M ontea Co nton,a t 1 Da es f de a under Aril 1 a e lm ied t e
r l nve i
r. 9. mag or l y
tce 9 r i t o conomi
c
dmna , s h a t xi f r t t a pas e er mus pa i he i f c d t fnd a tr e
ges uc s a a e ha
s ng
t y f
s or e o i
le nat

ta po tto fo t ax r d t fi dea See ge aly Vumbac v Ter nal One
r ns rai n r m he ipo t ue o lght lys.
ner l
a . mi

Gr u As ' L. , .1 - 5 5 2 2 W L 1 7 07 ,# 6( D. Y. r 2 ,2 2 (tt t a
o p sn P.No 15 3 , 01
3 7 4 1 E. N. Ap . 0 01 ) sai h t
ng
t t
he ypesofda a r ove a eunde Ari e 1 a eec
m ges ec r bl
r tcl 9 r onomi l s occ i d by dely s h
c os es asone
a uc

astxifr orr plce
a ae e a mentofpes liems;Sobolv Cont1Ailne ,No.05 992,2006 W L
rona t )
.
ri s
-8
2742051 * ( D. Y.Se .26,2006)(ttng t tAri e 1 onl a ist S onomi l s
, 5 S. N. pt
sai ha tcl 9 y pple o ç
ec
c os
oc asone by dea i ta porai ).I ohe wor ,da sf e i ldites c usd
c i d
ly n rns tton' n t r ds mage or motona sr s a e
by d a a e notr c a e unde Ari e 1 See e. ,Le v Ame i Ailne I ,Ca eN o.
ely r
e over bl
r tcl 9. , g. e .
rcan r i s nc. s

CI A.3 CV1 7 P,2 0 W L 1 9 0,a * ( D.Te J l 2,2 0 )( e yng e to a
V. 01 1 9 0 2
461 2 t 3 N. x. uy 0 2 d n i moi n l
da a s c us by dely t t r s td i among ot r i onve e s pa s nge s ( i
m ge a ed
a ha e ule n,
he nc
ni nce , s e r t ng
be
ta d i a ç di a ea'wihouta qua ef
r ppe n hol ng r
t
de t ood, t ,r sr
waer e toom f c ltes a ... i f ce
a iii , nd beng or d

t s e dt eng ti s bsa d r ,dry, ndu a emo es....) af' 35 F.d 3 6 (t Ci.
o p n h ih n u tn ad it a ns f tl
' , f d 5 3 8 5h r
'
200 .
4)
He e, antf Cn
r Pl i if mpbels ks$5, 000. i da esal dl i ur e asar s tof
l ee
000, 00 n mag lege y nc r d
e ul
t de a of hi ta fom Ki t n,J i a t Ft La dae,Fl i M o e s c fcal
he l y
s r vel r
ngso ama c o . uder l orda. r pe ii ly,

Plitf Ca b l alg s t t tth d fn a t a td n gie ty d e t t e d ly a d
anif mp el l e ha il e e e d n ce e l n l u o h ea n
e
g
g
5 Alhoug Pl n if Ca
t h aitf mpbe ldoes not s cii a l al ge da a s u r Aril 1 of t
l
pe fc ly le
m ge nde
tc e 7
he
Conve i n,t ki t a lgatonsoft Am e
nto a ng he le i
he
nded Compl n i t lghtm os f a e t t
ait n he i
t avor bl o he
pr s Pli if t Cour' a ysswiladdr s Ari l 1 a wel a Aril 1
o e a ntf, he
ts nal i l
e s tce 7, s l s tc e 9.
4

a ndonme oft pl ntf who had t r mai a t aipor ove ni outi t tr nal
ba
nt he ai if
o e n t he r t r ght sde he e mi
buidi whih wa unde r par , unde a r e weahe a be m e i1 a t ar t i
l ng, c
s
r e is
r dve s
t r nd ca
1 t he ipor n

Kig t n, a ia' ( Co l ! 1 ) Heas alg sta heh d t nxeyt ma t efih
n so J mac . Am. mp . 2 . lo le e h t a û it o ke h lg t
'
a
s nc hi pe m a nt r s dent a i n c r w oul e r on Se em ber 9, 2009 a he w oul
i e s r ne e i
le a d
d xpie
pt
nd
d

e c u trpr be wihi g ainu o arv li teUni d S ae . (d a ! 1 ) I wa n t
n o ne o lms t mmirto p n ria n h
t tts' 1 . t 5 .t s o ,
e
'
ho ve ,un i Pl i if Ca
we r tl antf mpbe l a rved a t For La r l Holywood Aipor t t he
l ri
t he
t ude dae- l
r t ha

s htmedia atnton.(d a ! 1 .Furhe,Pli ifCampbeldoesnotalgea physca
oug
c l te i 1 t 6) t r antf
l
le ny
il

ma ie tto so hi a xey a de t na d srs u tl i ( o lp g)a ho i M i s a
nf sain f s n it n moi l ite s ni h s d la se t me n mni' nd
o
c
'
s b e u n S d lso t J c s n Me ra Ho ptl(n M imi F o ia s fe ig fo a
u s q e t l misinq o a k o
a
mo il s i i a , l rd j u f rn r m
a
h atatc . (# a ! 1 &1 ) Up n c r f c nsd rto o te Ame de Co lit te
e r ta k' f . t ! 2 6 . o aeul o ie ai n f h
'
n d mp an , h
Cour fnds t tt Am e d Compli does not s fc e ty al ge t t Pl ntf Cn
ti
ha he
nde
ant
ufi i n l le ha ai if mpbel
l
s f r d anyphysc m a f t to ofhi e o i dite sand a e y untlhi ta t So h
ufe e
ial niesai n
s m tonal sr s
nxit
i s r vel o ut
Fl i wa c
orda s ompl e and he ha s es f l bee admit t t Unie St t s wih hi
et
d ucc s uly
n
ted o he
td ae t s
pe m a ntr sde ale ca d.Ac di y,t Co tfnds t tPl i if Ca
r ne e i nt i n r
cor ngl he ur i
ha antf mpbe li s ki
l s ee ng
da a s f t s f rng ofpur e o i na dite s a a ey,whih a e no r ove abl
m ge or he uf e i
e m to l sr s nd nxit
c r t ec r e
unde A ri e 1 oft M ontea Conve i
r tcl 9 he
r l
nton.

Plitf Ca b l' sc d a s re g o n f r j rs ito u d r t e M o te l
an if mp els e on s e td r u d o u idcin n e h
nr a
Conve i n i unde Ari e 1 To s ts y Ari e 1 s care la lt pr son f pe s na
nto s
r tcl 7. . a if
tcl 7' rir ibiiy ovii or r o l

ij r ,a p an ifmu tpla a d etb ih t re rq ie n s () a C c ie t mu th ve
nu y litf s e d n sa ls h e e ur me t: 1 n t cd n ' s a
a
'
o c re ()ij r o d ahmu th v o c re a d( )t eprc dn t c n iinsmus h v
c u rd; 2 nu y r e t s a e c u rd; n 3 h e e ig wo o dto
tae
o ure whie S mba ki ord s mba ki 'o durng t ti is f M ar t v.
cc r d
l s
e r ng
i e r ng' r i he lght tel. ote Am.Ailne ,
ri s

I c.296 F.d 1 1 ( 1h Ci.2002) Uponr viw oft Ame d Compli ,t Cou t
n,
3 255, 259 1 t r
.
ee
he
nde
ant he r

fnds t t Pl i if Cn
i
ha antf mpbel ha not s fcen l a lged t oc urenc of a l ci nt't
l s
ufi i ty le
he c r e
n s de ' o
ac
i
nvoke Ar i l 1
tc e 7.

t n ç c i nt unde Ari l 1 i t n unexpe t d orunus e ntorha ni t i
i a c de '
A.
r tce 7 s a
ce
ual ve
ppe ng hat s
e e na t t pa s nge ,' ElAlfztc Ailne ,Lt v.T Yuan Ts ng,525 U. 1 1 n.
xtr l o he s e r''
é z / ri s d. sui
e
S. 55, 65 9

(999)(ii Ai Fr e v a,470 U. 392,405 ( 985 ) Fori tnc t Ni h Cic t
1
ctng r anc .Sak
S.
1 ).
nsa e, he nt rui
Co tofAppeasha he d t tt s z e a f c c ki ofa pa s nge ' ca r on bagt t
ur
l s l ha he eiur nd or ed hec ng
s e r s ryha
co aned a br ahi de c a m e ca i c tt e a E cdent'unde Ari e 1 whie
nt i
e t ng vie nd di ton onsiut d n d i '
ac
r tcl 7, l
t Sec Cic tCour ofAppea sha hel t tt s a chi ofa pas e rbef e boa di
he ond r ui
t
l s d ha he e r ng
s nge
or
r ng

doesno.Compar Pr s od v AMR,I . 383F. 8 ,868( h Ci.200 ,wih T n v ElAl
t
e ec .
nc,
3d 61
9t r 4) t se g .
Ir lAilne ,Lt ,1 F. 99,1
sae ri s d 22 3d
03-04 ( Ci.1 ,r ese on ot rgr
2d r 997) ev r d
he oundsb 525U.
y
S.
1 ( 999 .Tha Pli if Ca
55 1 ) t antf mpbel s fr a heatatc does noti is fconsiue t
l ufeed
r ta k
n tel
ttt he
oc ure eofa ka ci nt'unde Aril 1 Se ge r l Sak ,470U. a 398('Tl txtof
c rnc
n 'c de ' r tce 7. e ne aly s
S. t
1g he e

Aril 1 r fr t a a cd n whc c u e t e p se g rsij r ,a d n tt a a cd n
t e 7 e es o n c ie t ih a s d h a sn e ' nu y n o o n c ie t
c
whc i tep se g rsij r ' ; e ,eg. Ca d z v S rt rie I c, .1 - 6 8 2 1
ih s h a s n e ' nu y.l s e . , r o a . piiAil s n .No 0 61 6 , 01
'
n
W L 2 4 5 3 * n. ( . Fl. u 1 , 01 )(ç s Cad z -s r' c r icar s,ao e d s
4 7 2 , 4 2 SD. a J ne 5 2 1 ç . r o a o is a da ret ln , oe
M
notc tt e a iccde 'unde t M onte lConve i '.l a to t r i a ge a
onsiut n a i nt
r he
ra
nton.' n ddiin, hee s nerl
)
c e us t t net r t dely of a ti nor t S
ons ns ha ihe he a
lght
he é
bumpi 'of a pas e r c tt t a
ng'
s nge onsiu e n
é ccde 'unde Aril 1 Se ,eo ,l reDep Ven Thr osi Lii i No.04- 606,2007
i i nt'
a
r tce 7. e g. n
e i
omb s tgaton,
1

W L 3027351,*1 -1 ( D.Ca.( t 1 2007)(ttngt tdea i ai ta aearaiy a
4 6 N. l )c. 2,
sai ha lys n r rvel r e lt nd
c r ra ona ybes i t beunus oru xpe td) Weisv ElAllr Ailne,Lt ,433 F.
amot e s bl
ad o
ual ne ce ; s .
s. ri s d.
Supp.2 361 363 n. ( D. Y.2006) (sBumpi i by now a weletbls d ari
d ,
3 S. N.
çç
ng' s
l-sa ihe ilne
i ty pr c i wher by pa s nge s a e de e s a s d t i e i lo r e lng,whi h i
ndusr a tce
e
s e r r nid e t ue o ntntona ve s li
c s

ie
ntndedt mi miet numbe ofe ys asduet c eltons' .Acc di y,co tui
o ni z he
r mpt e t
o anc lai .'
) or ngl nsr ng

t Ame
he
nded Compli i t lg m os f vor bl t pr s Pli if Ca pbel none of t
ant n he i ht
t a a e o o e antf m l,
he

fcs alg d c n tt t a t c ie t't iv k j rs ito u d rAril 1 o t e M o te l
a t l t o siut n d cd n' o n o e u idcin n e t e 7 f h
e
a
c
nr a
Conve i Ast Cour ha de e mi d t tt a ve syld a ton doe c e wihi eihe
nton.
he
t s t r ne ha he bo -t e c i
s om
tn t r
Aril 1 or Aril 1 of t M o r a Conve i n,i nee notr c Def nda Ca i n
tc e 7
tc e 9
he nte l
nto t d
ea h
e nt rbbea
Ailnes lmia i 'pe i a g e .
ri ' i t tons rod r um nt6

Ac r i y,a tra c r f r viw oft r c d a bei ot r s f l ad s , i i
co d ngl fe a e ul e e
he e or nd ng he wie uly vied t s
ORDERED,ADJUDGED a DECREED a f lw s
nd
s olo :

Dee tAi J maia' M oto t Dimis( #20)be a t s mei,hee
fndan r a c s in o s s DE
, nd he a s rby
G R AN TED .
2.

Pli if Ca
antf mpbels Amende Compl nt ( #9) i DI I
l'
d
ai DE
s SM SSED wih
t
pr j c ast bot Dee ntAi J mac a Defnda Cai n Ailne
eudie o h fnda r a ia nd e nt rbbea ri s

f rlc o s b e t te j idcin.
o a k f u j c matr urs ito
3.

TheCl r s lCLO SE t sc s .
ek hal
hi a e
A l pe ng m otonsar DE NI asm oot
l ndi
i
e
ED
.

DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe s a t J mes La e e Ki Fede a J tce
n
r t he a
wr nc
ng
r l usi
Buidi i M i mi Fl rdat s 1 t da ofAug t 201
l ng n a , o i hi 7h y
us, 2.

a..'
'

g*
r

z?

/

z' J

ES LA W RE CE KI G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UD
SO U THERN D I
STRI OF FLO I A
CT

6 The Cour nots ho
t e , weve ,t t i t Ame
r ha f he
nded Com pli ha saed a cli under t
a nt d t t
am
he

Montea Co nto t Coul woul be i lne t rj tt lmiains pei ag nt
r l nve in, he
d
d nci d o eec he i tto ' rod rume ,
bec us i woul bepaenty unf i'o ba apl i ifss ton t ba i oft lmiai 'pe i
a et
d
t l
alt r antf ui
he ss he i t tons rod
whe e t i ta Compl nt was tl d wihi t a ia e pe i a dim is d wihou
r he nii l
ai
ie
t n he pplc bl rod nd s s e
t t

p eu iet r -ie S eg neal Mo te lCo ve to a t 3 (s e to sa t c lu ai n o
rj dc o e fl. e e r l nr a n n in r. 5 d si n s o ac lto f
y
ou
t pei oflmiai ar l tt t c toft f u '
he rod i ttons e ef o he our he or m.l.
7

CC;

Pl it
an t

A lan C a pbe l
l
m
l
20601NE ls Ct
t .
M im i FL 331
a ,
79
3 65205- 7452
PRO SE

Co ns l o De nd n s
u ef r fe a t

Va s a Sit Snyde
ne s s i
r
Hoga LovelsUS LLP
n
l
200 Sout Bic yne Bl Suie400
h sa
vd, t
M im i FL 331
a ,
31
305- 66
459- 20
Fax:[phone]
459-

Emal v n sas y e @ho r lv l .o
i: a e s .n d r g o el c m
s
John M aggi
o
Condon & For yt
s h
7 Ti e Sq r
m s ua e
18 h Fl
t oor
Ne Yor NY 1
w
k,
0036
21 8 6792
2- 94Fa 894- 93
x:
67

Emalj g i@c n nlw.o
i:ma go o do a c m
R ober C.O w ens
t
1
8890 SW 264 h St
t
Hom e t a FL 33031
se d,
305- 681
245- 3
Fa 305 2 6403
x:
45

Emalb b we s vlw.o
i: o o n @a a c m

8