In Re: Seaboard Spirit Ltd

Filing 158

ORDER entitling Petitioner Seaboard Ship Management, Inc. to petition for exoneration from or limitation of liability under the Limitation of Liability Act. Petitioner Seaboard Marine of Florida, Inc. is dismissed from this action. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/22/2014. (rtn)

UN I
TED STATES DI I COU RT FO R TH E
STR CT
SOU THERN DI
STRI OF FLO RI A
CT
D
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i
C a e N um be 11s
r: 23841 CI - O R EN O
- V M
I RE:
N

M N SEABOA RD SPI T,SEA BOA RD SPI T
RI
RI
LTD a Owne ndSEABOARD M ARI LTD a
s
ra
NE
s
Ow ner Pro Hac Vi of t M / SEA BOA RD
ce
he V
SPI T, f e er i fom or lm ia i of
RI or xon aton r
i t ton
labiiy,
i lt
Pe ii er .
tton s
/

O RDER EN TI N G SEABO AR D SH I M A NA G EM ENT.I C.TO PETI ON
TLI
P
N
TI
FO R EX O NER ATI N FRO M O R LI I TI N O F LI BI TY
O
M TA O
A LI
UND ER TH E LI I TI N O F LI LI A CT
M TA O
ABI TY

Peii er,t o r a ma ge sofve s lM / Sea r Spii, oug t sa ton f r
tton s he wne s nd na r
se V
boa d rt br ht hi c i o
e
xone a i fom orIm ia i oflabiiy oft cl i s a i i f om aM a 4, 1 i ci ntr s tng
r ton r
i t ton i lt
he a m rs ng r
y 20l n de e uli

i t d t ofI hor ma Os i Hy
n he eah ongs e n se man. Cl m a t ,a r es nttvesofM r Hy
ai n s s epr e a i
. man' esa e
s tt ,
t r a r fld a cl m f wr ngf de t a ai t Pe ii r . On c os - i f s
he e he ie
ai or o ul a h g ns ttone s
r smotons or umma y
r

j me , tdSaesDititCourJ eRobi Ros um ga e s
udg ntUnie tt src
t udg
n enba rntd ummayj me i fvor
r udg ntn a

o Peiin r, e idCli ns MoinfrS mmayJ d me ta de trdfn lu me tnfv r
f tto e sd ne ama t' t o u r u g n, n nee i aj dg n i a o
o
o P t in r.Cli nste mo e teCo r t atr a n tefn lu g n .
f eio es ama t h n v d h u to le or me d h i a j d me t
t
On M a 8,201 J e Ros nba is ed a Or rGr ntng I Pa tCli t 'M o i t
y
4, udg
e um s u n de a i n r aman s ton o

Ale Ame dJ me t( E. 1 . Aspat heOrerJ eRosnba or rdPeii r
tror n udg n D. No. 45)1
roft d ,udg
e um dee ttones
t s w c us w hy Pe ii r Se boa d Shi M an e e t l . a Se
o ho a e
ttone s a r
p
ag m n , nc , nd aboa d M a i of ord I ,
r
rne Fl i a, nc.

s d n bedimisd fom t saci TheOr rsae igl Cour a ee t tlmiai of
houl ot
s se r hi ton.
de ttd,dthe
t gr s ha i tton
1TheOr rva ae t pro g a igo s mmayj dg n a t efna j g n i fv o
de c td he ir rntn f u r u me t nd h i lud me t n a or f
Pettoner . The Or alo i tuct t t a i pr d wih r pectt Pe ii s't noverdut as
ii s
der s nsr ed hat he cton ocee t es
o ttoner ur
y
çt owne oft M / Seaboa d Spii onl '
lhe
r he V
r
rt y.'

la lt c nnotbeextnde t Se boad Shi Mana ementI .)wihoutfcsesabls ngt tis
ibiiy a
e do a r p
g
, nc( t
a t t ihi ha t
r s nsbiiis a du is wa r n ownerpr h v c sa us'wara i pr t ci unde t
e po i lte nd te
ra t
o ac i e tt '
r ntng o e ton
r he

Li ttonofLi lt Ac,4 U. C.j30501
miai
abiiy t 2 S.
.
I t r s ons t t s
n he e p e o he how c eor r Petton sar t t s nt o t r e nt a e i
aus de , ii er gue ha pur ua t he el va m t ral
ag e m en s b t en t pari sa t t tm on ofva i i vi s Se oa d Shi M a ge e
r e t e we he te nd he es i y
rous ndi dual, ab r
p na m nt

h s ife t lga r quie nt ne e s y t i et e Li t i Ac . Pe ii r as co d
as atsi d he e l e r me s c s ar o nvok h miaton t ttone s lo nce e
t tPe ii rSe boa d M a i e ofFl i ,I .t san e iy w ih t r qui ie con a t w ih t
ha ttone a r
rn
orda nc t
i
ntt t out he e st
t c s t he
ve s ,M / Se oar Spii, o b e i bl f t b eft oft Li ia i A c ' a s d t r or
s el V ab d rt t e lgi e or he en is he m t ton t' nd houl he ef e
be di m i s d a a Pe ii rfom t sa ton.
s se s
ttone r hi c i
l t ei r pl cl i a sa gu h tSe boa d Shi M an e en ( un tone s el saman ge
n h r e y, a m nt r et a a r
p
ag m t i c i d ol ya
f
a r

an wa nota c re e ,own pr h vc oro he wieope a i M / Sea d Spii a isown
d s
ha tr r
er o ac ie, t r s
r tng V
boar
rt t t
exp ns an orf isown ac oun ,' nd t ef e h notm e isbu de of m ons r tn e il m e
e e d/ or t
c t'a her or as
t t r n de
ta i g ntte nt
t pr e ton un rt Li ia i ofLi biiy A c .
o ot c i
de he m t ton
a lt t
The Li iaton ofLi lt Act
m t i
abiiy

Th p r i sdo notdi p eJ
e a te
s ut udge Ros nba ' ana ys soft Li ia i ofLi biiy A c i
e um s l i
he m t ton
a lt t n
t Or rGr ntn I Par Cl i a s M oto t A le A m e J gm e .The l is wihr s c
he de a i g n t a m nt ' i n o t ror
nd ud nt
one s ue t e pe t
t t e Or ert Sh Ca e i w he he Se boa d Shi M a g e thasale d orca ale e s fci n
o h d o ow us s t r a r
p na em n
l ge
n l g ufi e t
f c st de onsr t i i e il d t pr t c i n unde t A c .
a t o m ta e t s ntte o o e to
r he t
A ss a e i J dge Ros nbau ' O r ,lm ia i ofla lt un t e A c ge r l a i
t td n u
e
m s der i t ton i biiy der h
t ne aly pples

t t own oft v s .Se 46 U. C.jj30505a) 3051 Howe r t Acti u i t
o he er he esel e
S.
( , 2.
ve, he
ncldes n he
defnii ofSowner'ia charer t m ans supples,and navi es a vesselatt charer s ow n
i ton û
'i
t er hat
,
i
gat
he
t er'
expens orbyt chart er sown pr em ent' com m onl r eredt asan Sownerrro hacvi '1
e
he
er '
ocur
,'
y ef r o
i
ce.' d.

a j3 01 Seci 305 i riswihit S gai i iai t te ptf t o ronl t
t 05 . ton 01 i re t t he ne tve mplc ton ha xce orhe wne y he
ca

t e ofc re e w ho d a , c ual a na ga e 'ca cl i t pr e to oft e Li ia i Ac .'
yp
ha t r r
d ns vi t s nd vi t s ' n a m he ot c i n h m t ton t''
m

Co aitfch s pe k S ipig I c, 7 F S p .1 3 1 5( D. Y.l 91 ( i t nO te )
mpl n o e a a e hp n , n .7 8 . u p 5 , 5 S. N. 9 ) ct i mi d .
ao
t
Thet r ( n ' i t b i t m r t d i aSlbe a wa ' a doesno r r tte owner hi
e m i er' s o e n e e e n si r l y,' nd
ow
t equie il
s p.

Dikv US.671F.d 7 7 ( Ci.l ( ttonomitd) Rat r i whoi s jce t a
c . ,
2 24, 27 2d r 982) ciai
te . he,d
one
s ube td o
s p ersla lt be au eof(t)execieofdomi onovera(. r ai hi t avesels d
hiown ' ibiiy c s is r s
ni
ie.eltons p ol s houl
bea et lmi(tlIa lt t tatofanown . I r Hou e St s p #,2005WL 34 788,
bl o i t is ibiiy o h
er' n e s boat arhi
'
40 at

#3( . Te n. c l , 0 5 (in Co anf r o e ad no rLi tt no a ii o el
M D. n De . 2 2 0 )ct g mplito Ex n r o fo miai fLib ly fsh l
i
o
t
OiCompa y,e al, F.
l
n t .780 Supp.1 ( D. l )( tti bot ownera S fcoopeaor
086 E. La. 991 enilng h
nd i a t rt
de
oît ve s 't lmitei Ia ltl.Th eoe,dft peii rma behel labl b a eof(tl
he sel'o i t h r ibiiy) erfr ii he ttone y
d i e ec us is
ownes p orconr oft v s ,(t c n mant n apettont lmi (tlla lt 'Che a ak
rhi
tol he esel ij a i ai
ii o i t is ibiiy. spe e
'
Shi n 778 F.Supp.a 1 Sttd dif r ty,dhe a ti desgne t c rone who i a fiel
ppig,
t 56. ae feen l d c s i d o ove
t
s lk y
t r e 'f rla lt c ai 'pr di a e on iss a usast e tt d r psuli a el r s
a g t o i biiy l ms ' e c t d t t t
he n iy d ha
pe
tm t y e pons bl f t
i e or he

ves lsmaitna ea opeai 'Hous boat arhl 2005WL 3440788a *3.
se' ne nc nd rton.' e St s p,
t
Th e s e ng t i voke t Im ia i ofIa l y oft Ac b art e bur n ofpl a n f c s
os e ki o n
he i t ton i bii
t
he t e h
de
e di g a t

etbihn h ie tt me tod s Nof l e gn . . VA.: sn r 2 4F S p . d2 5
sa l igter nie n t o o. rokDr d igco vM/ P Ka te , 6 . u p 2 6 ,
s
l
267( Md.
D. 2003) Meeal ai t ta e iyi ama ge oîav s i is fci t e tbls
. r leg tons ha n ntt s na r
esels n ufi ento sa ih
owne pr hacviesaus I r T rel t 201 W L51
r o
c tt . n e ou tlote, 0
40000 a *3( N. De 9, 1 ) Rahe,
, t D. J. c. 20 0. t r
t e tt s e ng pr t c i oft Ac m us s tf t t dutesa r s
he n iy e ki
o e ton he t t e or h he i nd e ponsbiii sa m an e oft
i lte s
ag r he

ve s .Norol Dr gig, F.
sel f k ed n 264 Supp.2da 267t 68.
Cours fnd t a ve s m a ge s c n be c i r owne s pr hac vi w h t i
t i h t s el na r a
ons de ed
r o
ce en he r

rs onsbiiisi ldeSml ngt v s l;vit i t v el, ovi ngf na gai whih
e p i lte ncu i anni he eses cualng he es s pr di or vi ton, c
l
i ved pr
nvol
ocuri and pr di t deck,engi and cabi sor ;m ai enance and r r f hul
ng
ovi ng he
ne
n t es
nt
epais or l
and m achi y;pr di spar pars,m ai enance and r r f com m uni i and navi i
ner
ovi ng
e t
nt
epais or
caton
gaton
-

3-

e ui nt.. c
q pme .and ommuni tngwih(h o r a t ve s s tmechatrr.f eChe a ak
cai t te wne) nd he sel'i
rees' ar s pe e
'
Shi n 803F.
ppig,
Supp.8 8 74( D. Y.1 2)(ntti s pmana me c an t p tton
72, 73- S. N. 99 e ilng hi
ge nt omp y o eii
frlmiai duet ç oa rngeofma e i rs nsbiiy) i cor s haswhopa sf sorg
o i tton o s d a
br
nag rale po i lt .t t s uc
Fa
y or t a e

ofteve s a whos pp st ve s ,a wel( )whohaspose sona c r oft ve s ,
h sel nd
ki er he sel s las
s s i nd ontol he sel
m us be t ke i o a c
t a n nt c ounti d e m i n who i a owne f pur e oft A c . Coursalo l
n et r ni g
sn
r or pos s he t
t s ook
t t de r e ofa lonom y f om t a t alowne s t e m ana er e r s . Tour e l t ,20l W L
o he g e
tt
r he c u
r h
g s xe ci e'
'
t lote
0

51 00a * (iai somitd)
400 t 2 ctton
te .
Seaboard Shi M anagem ent lnc.IsA Proper Pettoner
p
,
ii
Undert Li iaton ofL i lt A ct
he m t i
abiiy

Pe ii rSe oar Shi M an emen e t r d i o at a ge e A g ee e 'w iht ve s
ttone ab d p
ag
t n e e nt t na m nt r m nt' t he s el
M

owne,u whi iwoul a ta t ma ge f t s be tvese a pr deva i s r iesas
r nder ch t d c s he na r or he u jc s l nd ovi rous e vc
defne i t age t Thos s r c sicl d,i e ala:( ma ngt ve s ;vit lngan
i d n he remen.
e evie n ude ntr i a) nni he sel cuai d

i urngtece D. 1 Ex. j2.;b)pr di a s per sngmai e nc a rpar t t
ns i h rw, E. 47, A, 1( ovi ng nd u vii
ntna e nd e is o he
vesel1 , 2. 3. ()arangi f t s yt t ve s l vai pa tands vie ,d,j2..
s ,d.jj 2, 2 c r ng orhe uppl o he s e of rous rs er c s1
2,
an ( manani a opraea a quaefna a r or ,d.j6. l ad ton, ttonesct
d d) iti ng ppr it nd de t i ncilec ds1 , 5. n dii Peii r ie
s n t si y ofva i ( gh r nki me r 'ofSe oa d Shi M an eme tt c s' t e
wor e tmon
rous t
hi a ng mbe s'
ab r
p
ag n o onfl h
m
a or m en i e c r c u r s on i ltesaswel asot er .Fore pl ,t s i di dua st tfe
f e ton d onta t al e p s biii
l
h s
xam e he e n vi l es ii d
t t Se oa d Shi M a ge e wa en ie y r s
ha ab r
p na m nt s tr l e pons bl f ha i ço a i ,c e i a
i e or ndlng k per tons r w ng, nd

a c i 'S cha fnglwh e rwa rquie '% ki s et maitna ewa c ie ou on
c ountng, i
' pur si
atve s e rd,'d ng ur he ne nc s an d t
ma
a r utn s he e ' i het c c ope a i oft e ves el' a hii t ca t n a c e ofi erof
o i e c dul ,'k e hni al r ton h
t
s , nd rng he p ai nd hi f fc
'

t ve s .D. 1 a 7- ( po. . Se oar Shi M ana eme tViePr sde t DougEwi a
he s el E. 47 t 9 De Tr of ab d p
g n c e i ns
ng nd

Nai e W a waa Se orTe c lM a g Miha Mas l)
rnd r dh nd ni chnia na er c el rhal.
Cl i an s d n r ut Pe ii er ' a gum e t r ar ng is r s
a m t o ot ef e tton s r
n s eg di t e pons biii s unde t
i le
t
r he

-

4-

M a g e tA g e e , d s m iary do not s e t s n t s i ony. l t a Cl i a sar ue
na em n r em nt an i l l
diput he wor e tm
ns e d, a m nt g
t t a r Shi M a g e wasno ope a i M / Sea r Spii tf isow na oun , s e y
ha Se boa d p na em nt
t r tng V
boa d rt sor t
cc t but ol l
a a m a ge f t ow ne . D. 1 a 2,4. I s
s
na r or he
r' E. 52 t
'
n uppor,Cl m a t poi t pr vi i ns of t e
t ai n s nt o o s o
h
M a ge e Agr m e whe ei va i r s
na m nt ee nt r n rous e pons biii ofSe oa d Shi M a ge e , s t be ng
i ltes
ab r
p na m nt de pie i
c r i d out y-o- y by Se oa d Shi M ana m e , e e c r i ou a t ownerse ns a f
a re
da t da
ab r
p
ge nt w r a red t t he
' xpe e nd or
t owner' uli at beneft Cl m ant al ciet TheAmeri ilngcompany,L/ , F. 1
he
s tm e
i. ai
s so t o
caM li
J 409 3d 005

( hCi. )f s
8t r2005 or uppor.l t t as t Ei t Cic thedt tt o rAmeiaMilng,d d
t n ha c e,he ghh rui l ha he wne, rc li d
di

notrlnquihs fcintc r t W itr le( ve s ma ge!t i r o rsaus( rt
ei s ufi e ontolo nevil as sel na r o mpa t wne tt unde he
Li ttonofLibiiyAcl'1 a l 7.
miai
a l
t t. d. t 01
'
Eve ac e i g Cl i a s a gu en sa t u C l m a s ha none hel s f ied t r ut or
n c ptn a m nt ' r m t s r e, ai nt ve
t es a l o ef e,
e na es t a
ve ddr s , he bund ce ofc e Iw fndi t ta ves e m a ge c n be c r d un rt e A c :
an
as a i ng ha
s l na r a
ove e de h t

()duet is' wnes porc r oft ve s , Che a ak Shipig, 78F.
a
o t ' rhi ontol he sel' s pe e p n 7
o
'
Supp.t1 6;b)whee
a 5 (
r
i i a ti y t g t'f la lt cl ms se i fom t ves e ' mait na e â ope a i
t s d kel ar e' or ibiiy ai t mm ng r he s ls n e nc nd r ton,
l

Hou e oatStrhi,20 W L 3
sb
a s p 05
440788,a * ,or()wheeisdute c itofi erala, nig
t 3. c
r t is onss ,nt i man n
t ves e s vit ln t ves e s pr di f na ga i m ai t na e a r is f hul a d
he s l , c ua i g he s l , ovi ng or vi ton, n e nc nd epa r or l n
m a n y,a p ovi ng s r pa t.Che a ak Shi ng,803 F.
chi er nd r di pa e r s
s pe e ppi
Supp. t8 74.
a 73-

Furhe ,heCour a e swihPe ii r t t
t rt
t gr e t ttone s ha AmercaM ilng i i ppost Not ydoe t
i
li s na
ie. onl s he
Ei ht Cicui m a c e t tt defnii ofo ne orc re e u rt Ac hasb n d xpan d'
g h r t ke l ar ha he i ton w r ha t r r nde he t
ee s
e
de '
t i cl t e w ho e r s dom i on a c t olovera ves e ,40 F. at 1 4,butund t
o n ude hos
xe cie
ni nd on r
s l 9 3d
01
er he
M a ge e Agr e e b t n Sea r Shi M a g e a t ow ne , Se boa d Shi
na m nt
e m nt e wee
boa d
p
na em nt nd he
r a r
p
M anagementhad s alkey r ponsi ltesnothel by t m anageri Am eri M ilng. Undert
ever
es
biii
d he
n
ca li
he
M anagementAgr entand i pr i Seaboar Shi M anagem enthad hii aut iy,m ai ai
eem
n actce,
d p
rng hort
nt ned
i ur
ns ance,and wasr ponsi ef m ai enanceoft ves ,w her t m anageri Am eri M ilng
es
bl or nt
he sel
eas he
n
ca li
-

5-

di no ha s c r pons biii s M or ov , he c ti Am e i a M ilng not d s ve alc s swhe e
d t ve u h es
i lte .
e er t our n
r c li
e e r ae
r

ve s ma ge swe e e il t owne saus e n i no de
s el na r r ntted o
r t t , ve f t emed a owne orc tr r due t
n
r hare e ,
o
r s ons biii si l n m a n a ni g i ur nc , ovi ngm a n ena ea r is pr di s i s
e p i l e nc udi g i t i n ns a e pr di
t
i t nc nd epa r , ovi ng upple

a d p t, di
n ars an i ngde sonsa ovea be dt enor al e r td t ac pt norpiot'1
maki cii b
nd yon hos m ly ntuse o a ai
l . d.
'
at1015-1
6.

Cl m a sa ec r t h tPe ii r be rt bur n ofpl a ng f c sesabls ngen il m en
ai nt r orec t a ttone s a he de
e di a t t i hi
tte t

t lmiatonofla lt Howe r wh e Pe ii r ha ale ed fc sa s f rhl g a gume s
oi ti
ibiiy.
ve , er ttone s ve lg a t nd et o t e al r
nt
de onsr tn i i e il d t pr t c i a Cl m an sha f iedt r f e o I ga l c l nget e
m ta i g t s ntte o o e ton, nd ai t ve a l o e ut r e ly hale
hos
f c sorot r ie pr e e de e a t s sag t s por t rar e , he Cour fn Pe ii r
at
he w s oduc vi nc t hi t e o up t hei gum nt t
t i ds ttone
Se bo d Shi M a ge e s oul notbe di m i s d fom t s lm ia i ac i Ac di y,i i
a ar
p na m nt h d
s s e r hi i t ton ton. cor ngl t s
ADJU DG ED t :
hat

( )Petton Se boadShi Ma g ntlc.i e ildt peii f e rton fom or
l ii er a r p na eme , n s ntte o tton or xoneai r
lm ia i oflabiiy un t Li ia i ofLi biiy A c .
i t ton i lt der he m t ton
a lt t

( Peii rSe ar MarneofFl i ,I i dimis fom t sa ton.
2) ttone abo d i
orda nc.s s sed r hi ci

J>
/
DON E AN D ORDERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl r da t s
n
m r t a , o i , hi'

da ofJ y,201
y ul
4.
M
..
.

/
r
'

.

e

.

,.

.A
.y
.F
;

::'
-''
;à
-î
:

r
Lèw . ,.
.,
'
q
.
e
e

.
.'..-. .
.
.
.
.

.

.
.

-.
$
'
... .

y . ..ya. - ..
z .;.e . .>
k
.u y

FED ER O A .M O
O
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI JUD GE
CT
Copi pr ded t
es ovi o:

CounselofRecor
d

-

6-