H. v. Oxford Health Insurance Inc. Freedom Access Plan et al

Filing 152

ORDER Denying Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/9/2014. (bnt)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU THERN D I
STM CT O F FLO RI
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
Cas Num ber 11e
: 23948- V- O RENO
CI M
ALEX AND M H .
,

Pl i if
antf,
VS.

OXFORD HEALTH W SURAN CE W C .,
D e e nt
f nda .

ORDER DENYI PLAI FF' M O TI FOR RECONSI
NG
NTI S
ON
DERATI
ON
THI CAUSE c m ebef et Cour u Pl i if M o i f
S
a
or he
t pon antfs' ton orRe onsde a i of
c i r ton Cour'
ts

RulngonOr rt Show Ca e( E.No.149) tldonM a 23.2014
i
de o
us D.
,ie
y

.

THE COURT hasc i r dt m oton, r pons a t pe tne pori oft r c d,
onsde e he i es e, nd he ri nt tons he e or
a beng ot r s f l a s i t pr mi e , i i
nd i he wie uly dvied n he e s s t s
ADJUDGED t t t moton i DENI . Pl ntf c
ha he
i s
ED ai if omm e d t s a ton undert
nce hi c i
he
Empl eeRe ie ntl om ea Sec iy Ac of1 , a a nded(1 SA', U. C. 001
oy
tr me nc
nd urt t 974 s me
ç
ERI ' 29 S. j1 ,
)

e s q. s e ng pa ntofmentlhe t c e be is unde he e oye St Ann' Sc '
/ e , e ki
yme
a alh ar neft
r r mpl r .
s hools

emplye wefr be ftpln(het a '.St Ann' Sc ,t e oye andPln s or i
o e la e nei a t $ n' . s hool he mpl r
P1 )
a pons , s
l td i Ne Yor The e or , t Pln a t Ce tfca eofCover ge is by Oxf d t t
ocae n w
k. r f e he a nd he rii t
a s ued
or o he

Plnpatcpa saegovenedbyNe Yor 1 (ot e e not e e byERI Consitnt
a rii nt r
r
w k aw t he xtnt premptd
SA)
se
.

wiha i bl New Yor St t lw , i Oxf dr nder afna a r edetr i i n c e ni t
t pplca e
k ae a f or e s i l dve s e m nato onc r ng he
media nec s iy ofanys r i eorte m e f whih pl n be isa e s
c l e st
e vc
r at nt or c a neft r ought t Pl n pr des
ovi
, he a

me
mber wih t rg t e e naly a a Oxf d' deer nai t ough t N e Yor St t
s t he i ht o xt r l ppe l or s t mi ton hr
he w
k ae

De a t n o Fn n il e vc s(ç '. cN. I LAW j 91 N. PUB H EALTH LAW
p rme t f ia ca S r ie ç
DFS' & Y.NS.
)
4 2; Y.
.

j491 Ne Yo k 1 a t e es t msoft Pln pr det ta s h e ena a al
2. w r aw nd he xpr s er
he a ovi ha ny uc xtr l ppe
de e m iaton i bi ngon Oxf d a t m e r
t r n i s ndi
or nd he mbe .
l t s c s ,Pl ntf purued a vol a y e e nala al t DFS r e r d t e e a
n hi a e ai if s
unt r xt r
ppe , he
ef re he xtm l
a
ppea t ani pende a nc whih i t n, s e t aboa dce tfe ps hitit
lo nde
nt ge y, c n ur elc ed
r riid yc a rs whor vi wed
e e
Pl i ifs te t ntr or a u l Oxf d' a r e de e m i ton i hi ext r a pe l
antf ' r a me ec ds nd phed
or s dve s t r na i n s e nal p a
decson.Pl i if t n co me e t s a ton alegi a c am f be ft unde ERI
ii
antf he
m nc d hi ci
l ng
l i or ne is
r
SA

j 0 ()1( , 9U. C. l 3 ( )1( , se t gt tOx o d' d tr n to wa ab taya d
5 2 a( )B) 2 S. j 1 2 a ()B) a sri ha f r s eemiain s r irr n
n
c prcous Unde t t r soft Pln, be f a epa bl f s r c t ta eno tM e c l
a ii .
r he e m
he a no ne ks r ya e or e vies ha r t t dialy
Ne es a y,'a t extm a r viwe ' de ii fndi t tt s r i eswe e no dmed c ly
c s r ' nd he e l e e r s c son
ng ha he e v c
r t t ial
nec s a y'i bi ng on t Pl a t m e r Thus asam at rof1w Pli tf i note il
e s r ' s ndi
he an nd he mbe .
,
te
a a n if s
ntted
t t be t s s ks
o he neks he ee .
Howe r t i t ntM otonunde r e i a t ly Pli if st r at m pt osde t pt
ve ,he nsa
i
r eviw s cua l antf hid te t i se he
bi ng naur oft extm alr viwe ' dec son. Pli if tr tm ove t srke t e e na
ndi
t e
he e
e e rs ii
antf i s
d o ti he xt r l
r vi we ' de son fom t a nita i r co df herbenei c am . ( 1 1 . or move
e e rs cii r he dmi sr tve e r or
tt l i DE 1 ) Oxf d
d
f r c i r ton oft tdec son r l ng onRu h Pru i HM O, l .v. or 536U. 355
or e onsde a i
ha
ii e yi
s
dental
nc M an,
S.

( 2) a arui t tt Ne Yoke enalrviw lw wasnotpre e b ERI t tt
200 , nd g ng ha he w r xtr e e a
e mptd y SA,ha he
extm alr viwe ' de son waspa toft admi sr tver or a t tt ext na r e rs
e
e e r s cii
r he
nita i ec d nd ha he er l eviwe '
de e m i i wa bi ng on t pa te t a ERI e pl e wef e be i pln. Pl ntf
t r naton s ndi
he ri s o n
SA m oye
lar neft a
ai if
a gue i opposton t tt e e na r vi we ' de son s dno beco i r d be a eNe
r d n
ii ha he xt r l e e rs cii houl t
nsde e c us w

Yok' Ex e l p a La s re tdY ERI A a dta t e tr a rve a e ts e iin
r s tma Ap e l wwa p e mpe
S n h the x en l e iw g n ' d cso
i notbi ng on t pa te . ( E.1 pp. 11, 8 . sCour g a e Oxfr smoton a
s
ndi
he r i s D. 26, 4- n.) Thi
t r ntd o d' i nd

rve s isoi na or r( E. 11 . Court nis da Or rt Show Ca et Pli ifo
e red t rgi l dt D. 1 ) The
the sue n de o
us o antf n

Aug s 6 2 3saig:tb e a s t ee tma rve rsd cso i p e u bl ds o i v o t e
u t , 01 ttn t l c u e h xe l e iwe ' e ii n s r s ma y ip st e f h
l
i
cam, anifh str ewe kst s o c us wh j dg n s o d n tb g a td i fv ro
li Plitf a h e e o h w a e y u me t h ul o e r ne n a o f

Dee d n . ( 1 ,p 1.l se d o r s o dng t t e Co r' o d rt s o c us , Pli if
fn a t' DE 27 .) n ta f e p n i o h u ts r e o h w a e antf
'
e s ntalys htr a gz e oft Cour' Or r agui t t( ) heNe Yor Extr l
s e i l oug e r lm nt he
ts de , r ng ha: 1 t
w k e na Appe
al

La doe not e l t Co tr ove t ni t ext na rviwe ' de son;2)t e ena
w s pr cude he ur fom rur ng he er l e e rs cii ( he xtr l
rviwe ' de son wasi c ur e;a ( Pli ifi e ild t dicoveyt prveafna a
e e rs cii
na c at nd 3) antf s ntte o s r o o
i ncil
c lc ofi e e tbe wee t e e nal e e ra Oxf d. ( E. 30, 37)ByOr r tdAprl
onfit nt r s t n he xt r r vi we nd or D. 1 1 .
de dae i

2 , 01 ,t i Co r a an rj ce Plitf sag me t a dr ieae isp irh l igt a t
5 2 4 hs u t g i ee td an if r u ns n etrtd t ro o dn h t he
extr r vi age ' de e mi ton i bi ngon a1pa te .
e nal e ew
nts t r na i s ndi
1 ri s
Pli ifslt s m o i n t t e r 't eve ys m el alis sa
antf a e t to o s a gue' hes r a eg s ue ppea st bea efor t
r
r o
n f to

e p oth fc t t n wj g ha b e a sg e t t i a to i t eh p ta peh ps d fe e t
x l ite a tha a e ud e s e n sin d o h s cin n h o e h t r a a if rn

j d ewil iw h rrg me t i amoefv rbl l h . eCo r n t s h t anif ie t fl
u g lv e e u n s n r a o a e i tTh u t oe t a Pli tf watd o ie
g
t i moinu tlh a sg dj d e U. Ditit u g Ho . b nS. s n a m, sa p itd
hs to nit e sine u g , S. src J d e n Ro i Ro e b u wa p on e
t t U. Cour ofAppe sa t sm a trw a r s i ne t J
o he S.
t
al nd hi te s ea sg d o udgeHon. Fede i A . o eno.I
rco M r
t

i c i ust t c i rng t Pl ntf pr lm a y be ivedt the poi spr de avai bass
s uro ha, onsde i he ai if esz bl le
ha r nt ovi d
ld i
f pur ui amoton f r c i ai n, hedi noti
or s ng
i or e onsder to s
d
mmedit l m ovef t sr if r t rt n
aey
or hi ele , ahe ha

watn f ran w j d et b a sg e t t ematr
ii g o e u g o e si n d o h te.
Thi Cour now fnds t t t Pli if ha once agan f ie t mee he bur n of
s
t
i
ha he antf s
i a ld o
t r de
de o tai a ba i f t Cour t o rum ist pro Or r . l e Pli ifsmotoni
m nsr tng ny ss or he
t o ve t t wo i r de s nde d, antf
i s
e s i l a r pe ii oft s
s entaly e tton he ame a gument t twe e o i naly pr s nt d i opposton t t
r
s ha r rgi l e e e n
ii o he

Co r' Or e t S o Ca s .l f c,s v rlo Plitf a g me t a ej s r-mp a ie
u ts d r o h w u e n a t e ea f an ifs r u n s r u t ee h sz d
r ie a i ,lt r l c fo he prorbre si r pons t t Cour' Or rt Show Ca ea
e tr tons ie aly ut r m r i if n es e o he
ts de o
us nd

pase i ohe motonf trconsdeai '(
td nt r i orle i rton'.Compar D. 130, 5- 20- wihD. 1 pp
e E. pp. 9, 21 t E. 46,

.

3- 5) AsLt W enbeg s e y obsr di $A Fe GoodM e 'me eatempt b Pli ift
1 .
. i r hrwdl e ve n t w
n', r t s y antf o

mo eç te uo l o j c'd n t r v d c us fr h s u torc nsd rt d cso s a Plitf
r ' rn usy b e t o o p o i e a e o t i Co r t e o i e is e iin , s an if
s
'
f l t i ntf a cla e r of1w o f c o pr de a ba i upon whi h t sCo ts d
ais o de iy ny e r ror a r a t r ovi ny ss
c hi ur houl

re a n isp irt Or es ( u i P cu e ,1 9 ) Ac o d n l, h Co r DE ESt e
e x mie t ro wo d r. Colmb a itr s 9 2 . c r i gy t e u t NI h
M oton.
i

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r atM im i Fl i , t s
n
mbe s
a , orda hi

da ofJ m e 201
y
t , 4.

..
M

FED ERJ
.M O
UNI
TED STAT
I
STRI J
CT UDGE

Co e pr de t
pis ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d