H. v. Oxford Health Insurance Inc. Freedom Access Plan et al

Filing 191

ORDER Adopting 189 Report and Recommendations. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/24/2015. (whl)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O U RT FO R TH E
C
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO RI A
CT
D
Cas N um be : 11 cve
r - 23948- OR EN O
M
ALEXAN D R A H .
,

Pl i if
a ntf ,

OXFORD HEALTH W SURANCE m C.
,
De e nt
f nda .
/
O R D ER A D O PTI G M A G I
N
STM TE ' R EPO RT A N D R ECO M M EN D A TI N
S
O
A ND G R ANTIN G D EFEN D AN T' M O TIO N FO R SU M M A RY JU D G M EN T
S
TH E M ATTER w a r er e t t H onor bl J m J O ' lva U nie St t s
s ef r d o he
a e ol . Suli n,
td ae

M a sr t J e f a Re t a Re m me ton on t Pa tes M otons f r Summ a y
gita e udg or
por nd co
ndai
he ri '
i
o
r

J me ( E.Nos 1 1 . The Ma srt J
udg nt D.
. 64, 72)
gitae udge fld a Re tand Re
ie
por
commendain
to

( E. .l 9 o M ac 5 2 5 rc mme igt a s mmayj d me tbee tr di fv ro
D. No 8 ) n rh , 01 , e o ndn h t u r u g n
nee n a o f
D e e ntO xf d H e t l ur e,l The Cour hasr vi
f nda
or
alh ns anc nc.
t
e ewed t e i e f l a r c d,a
he nt r ie nd e or nd

teCo r h sma ead n v rve ofte is e t a t eo j cin t t M a itaeJ d es
h u t a d e o o e iw h s u s h t h b e to s o he gsrt u g '
Re ta Re omm e i n pr s nt trc i rng t Pa tes c os - i f s
por nd c
ndato e e .Afe onsde i he ri ' r s motons or umm a y
r

j g n ,t s
ud me t ii
A DJU D G ED t t U nie St t s M a sr t J
ha
td ae
gi t a e udge J
ohn J. O ' lva s Re t a
Suli n'
por nd
Re m m e ton i A FFI M E D a A D O PTE D . A cc di y,i i
co
nda i s
R
nd
or ngl t s
A DJU D G ED t t D e e nts M oton f Slm m a y J
ha
f nda '
i or z
r udgm ent i G RAN TED , a
s
nd
Pl i if s M oton f Sum m a y J
a ntf '
i or
r udgm enti D EN I . The Cour ale
s
ED
t r ady de e m i d t t t
t r ne ha he

ex e na r e r s decson was dipostve as t t m e ca ne es iy of Alxa r H.s
t r l eviwe '
ii
s ii
o he di l c st
e nd a '
r ques f pari hos t lz ton,s t Cour i now pr e ed wih t lm ie i s ofw he he
e
t or tal pia i a i o he
ts
es nt
t he i t d s ue
t r
t ex e nal r vi w e of A l xa a H .s m e c f l o r t d unde a fna a co l c of
he t r
e e r
e ndr
'
di al ies pe a e
r i nci l nti t
i e es w he he m a hi de e m i to ofm e c lne es iy.
nt r t n
de s t r na i n
di a c st

Afe r vi ng t r cor t Cour agr eswih t M a sr t t tt r i no evi nce
tr e ewi he e d, he
t e
t he gitae ha he e s
de
s
howi t tt de a oft Pl ntf s c am woul r ul i a fna i lgan t t e e nal
ng ha he nil he ai if l i
d es t n i nc a i o he xtr
r vi we ,nori t r e denc i c tngt tt e e a r vi rwa ot r s bi s ag ns
e e r
s he e vi e ndia i ha he xt m l e ewe s he wie a ed ai t
t Pl i tf . The Cour i per uade t tN e Yor s r ndom as i nm e pr es of ext r
he a n if
ts s
d ha w
k' a
s g nt oc s
e nal
r vi w s el t r vi
e e hi ds he e ewer f om pr s ur f om i ur nc com pa e t de de i t i f vor
r
es e r
ns a e
ni s o ci n he r a .

The r ma nde of t Pl n if s a g e s i a at mpt t r ltga e t is of me c
e i r
he aitf
r um nt s n te
o e ii t he s ue
dial

n c siy b tti Co r h sara yp o li d i a j d c to o t i is et b t e1w o t
e e st , u h s u t a le d r came t du iai n f h s su o e h a f he
s
c s . Alx n r H v Ox o d He l I s,I c, .1 - 3 48C1 201 W L 1 5 9 9 a *1
a e e a d a . f r at n . n . No 12 9 - V, 4
h
693,t
( D.Fl.Apr 25,201 (;T1 Cour fndst tt e enala luphol ngPl ntf de al
S. a .
4) d( he
t i ha he xtr ppea
di ai ifs ni
ofbene isi c l i ast t i s ofm e ca ne es iy,bu Pl ntf m a c uc di c r
ft s onc us ve o he s ue
di l c s t
t ai if y ond t s ove y
as t whe he t e e nal r vi w e ha a c lc of i t r t t t m a ha bi ed t
o
t r he xt r
e e r d ny onfi t
n e es ha
y ve as he

decson.) I i t r o e
ii ' . t s heefr
'

ADJ
UDGED t a t sCa e i DI SSED wi p eu ie wih e c p ry b aig is
h t hi s s SMI
t rj dc , t a h a t e rn t
h
o fesa coss Fe R.Ci P.41a( )A)i) Furhe,alpe ngmotonsaeDENI as
wn e nd t. d. v. ()1( (i. t r l ndi
i r
ED
M O OT w ih l ve t r ne i a o i t .
t ea o e w f ppr pra e

) oy r
.
da
rh
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a M im i Fl i ,t s/ Z y ofM a c , 201
n
mbe s t a , orda hi
5.

F D
. OR EN O
TED STA TES DI
STRI J DG E
CT U
Co e pr de t
pi s ovi d o:
U nie St t s M agit a e J
td ae
s r t udge J m J O ' lva
ol . Suli n
Cou e ofRe or
ns l
c d