Montgomery v. Brickell Place Condominium Assn, Inc.

Filing 54

ORDER granting 12 Motion to Exclude EEOC Letter of Determination. Signed by Magistrate Judge Jonathan Goodman on 4/11/2012. (eg)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SO U TH ERN D I
STR I O F FL O R I A
CT
D
M I M I DI I O N
A
V SI
C A SE N O .1124316- l - M H A M / O O D M A N
C V G
G

TORI
ANO J M ON TGOM ERY,
.
Pl i i f
a ntf ,

BRI ELL PLA CE CON D O M I I M
CK
N U
A SS ,l C .
N N ,
Def nt
enda .
/
O R D ER O N M O T I N T O EX CLU D E EEO C LETTE R
O

l t s e oyment dic i i i c e, t De e nt Brc l Pl c
n hi mpl
s rm naton as he
f nda , i ke l a e
Condomi um As oc ai l , ha fld a M oton t Excl
ni
s i ton, nc. s ie
i o
ude EEOC Le t of
ter

Deemi ton and Notce of Sui Ri s ( 1 . The moton i i t naur ofa
tr nai
i
t ght DE 2)
i s n he t e
m oto i lm i t e ude t EEO C l te f om co i r ton a e denc i t s ca e
i n n i ne o xcl
he
e tr r
nsde a i s vi e n hi s .
Pl i if Tor a J M ont m e y, w ho i pr edi pr s di not r s
a ntf
i no .
go r
s oce ng o e, d
e pond t t
o he

m o i howeve ,t m o i i caest tt de e
ton,
r he ton ndi t ha he f ndantdul c e r d wih t pl ntf
y onf re t he ai if
be or f lng t m oton a t the i oppos d t t r
f e ii he
i nd ha
s
e o he eque t r le .
s ed e i f

I t eElv n hCic i,
n h e e t r ut EEOC lte so d tr n to aeprmaf cea misbe
etr f eemiain r i a i d sil
unde t e e i t t hea s y r e t tpe m is Si a ci l c e ...f c ualfndi
r he xc pton o he r a ul ha r t çn
vi as
a t i ngs
f om a l aly a hor z d i s i to ' Fe R. d.8 8( (i (or ry Fed.
r
eg l ut i e nve tga i n.' d. Evi 03()A)ii f mel
)
R.

49 1 t r 990) t s lEvi.8 3 8 Bahed v Or n CW@. 91 F. 644,6 ( 1h Ci.1 . I i wel
d 0 4 :; r l . a ge
, 1 2d
esa ihe t tEEOC dee m i tonsa e a isbl i be ti s butt s m e lbe a
t bls d ha
tr na i
r dm s i e n nch ral,
he n i r l

sa d r o a misb l y d e n te tnd t j r til. Wa k rv Na in Ba k o Fl.
tn ad f d siii o s o x e o u y ras
t
le . to s n f a

i
N A. 53 F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.1 . I t s cas bot partes have demanded a
,
3d 548, 554 1 t r 995) n hi e, h

j r til
u y ra.
The a s i ofa EEOC r por ...may bem uc m or lkel t pr s nt
dmi son
n
e t
h
e i y o ee

t ed n e o c e tngu f i p eu iei t emi so t ej r ta i t
h a g r f rai n ar rj dc n h nd f h u y h n n he
mid o t etil u g ,wh i wela r o te lmisa d va a isof
n f h ra j d e o s l wae f h i t n g re
ad i sr tve de e na i
m nita i
t nni tons a be tr abl t as i n t r por
nd te
e o sg he e t
a opr a e w e ghta no m or
ppr i t i
nd
e.

Bahed, 1F.da 6 .Ac o dngy t eElve t Cic th si tu tdtilc u t t
r l 91 2 t 51 c r i l, h e nh rui a nsr ce ra o rs o
e mi EEOC lte son a c e- c e ba i a t c i rwhehe t lte sco an
xa ne
e tr
as by- as ss nd o onsde
t r he e tr nt i
l ga c usons r ie que tons oftusworhi s orpr s pr e unde Fe r l
e l oncl i , as
si
r t t nes
e ent obl ms
r de a

Rue o Evd n e 4 3. Bahed 9 1 F.d a 65 Rul 4 3 pemi tilc u t t
l f ie c 0
r l , 1 2 t 0. e 0 r t ra o rs o
s
l xc ude r e t e denc i is pr tve va ue i s t ntaly out e g d by a dange
ç l
e
el van vi e f t oba i
l s ubs a i l
w i he
r

o ... nfi p eu ie c n u ig te is e ,mila ig t jly,u d edea ,wa tn
f u ar rj d c , o f sn h s u s se dn he t n u ly sig
r
tm e, nee es l pr e i c ul tve evi nce. Fed.R . d.403.
i or dl sy es ntng um a i
de '
'
Evi
The EEOC l te he e c a ns a c
e t r r ont i
over notc s a i t t t EEO C f m d
i e t tng ha he
ot
C e onabl c us ' t beleve t ta vi a i of t a i s i i ton sat e oc ur e
t as
r
e a e' o i
ha
ol ton
he ntdi crm na i t ut c r d.
The EEO C l te cont ns s x pa a a
et r
ai i r gr phs of s m a y a a l i ne te be wee
um r nd na ys s s l d t n

s ve a pa a a
e r l r gr phs of f m lnguage Pa ag a t des rbes t al ga i of
or a
.
r r ph wo
ci
he le tons
dicrm i ton. Pa agr phs t ee t ough fve de c i t def nda ' postons
s i na i
r a
hr hr
i
s rbe he
e nts
ii .
Pa ag a
r r phs sx a s n c ai s e addii
i nd eve ont n om
tonal dic son and m a s ve a
s us i
ke e r l
c l or saeme s t tdic i nai occ r e bas d on t r or e de e. The
oncus y t t nt ha s rmi ton u r d e
he ec d vi nc
EEO C l te not t t t def nda has adva d non- s rm i t y expl tons f
e t r es ha he e nt
nce
di c i na or
ana i
or
is be or butt n conc udes t t di pa a e t ea m e occ r d w ihoute a ni w/
t havi
he
l
ha s r t r t nt ur e
t
xpl i ng l
y

i rj csted fnd n ' e pln to .
t ee t h ee a ts x a ains

2

Upon ac r ulr viw oft EEOC lter t Underi d fndst tispr bai
a ef e e
he
e t , he
sgne i ha t o tve

v le i s b tn il o t ihe by a da e o u f i p eudc ,c n u ig t e is e
au s u sa tal uweg d
y
ng r f n ar rj ie o f sn h su s

a dmila igtej r
n se dn h u y.
The EEOC lte c ans lga c usons by a ofk i lg r
el r ont i e l oncl i
n t a ove nmen body t t
t
ha
t pl ntf wa a vi tm ofdic i nai butgve ltl i cai ast wha e de
he ai if s ci
s rmi ton
i s ite ndi ton o
t vi nce

i c n iee a dh w i weg e t a e d n e Th sc udha eas b tnil rj dca
t o sd rd n o t ih d h t vie c . i o l v u sa ta p eu iil
e fc o tej r sutmaea s sme to t er lv n wi e ss c e i l y.S eB d v
fe t n h u y' li t se s n f h ee a t t se ' r dbit e yr .
n
i

SF Fo d I c, 6 S 3 6 0 6 7 ( a 4h DCA 20 9 (e e sngj d me tf lo n
o s n .2 o. d 0 , 0 F1 . t
0 ) r v ri u g n o lwi g
j r vedc b c u e t tilc u' a u e isdicein by a mitn a d tr nain
u y r it e a s he ra o t b s d t s rto
t
d tig ee mi to
l te fom t Br r Count Ci lRi ht Di son bas on t lte ' potntalt
et r r he owa d
y vi g s vii
ed
he e tr s e i o

ce t s bsa ta p eu ieo tej r sce iii d tn nai n )
rae u tn il rj dc n h u y' r db ly ee ni to s.
t
i a s worh notng t t Til VI a tons a e de noT W oc di - nO
s lo
t
i ha te I c i
r
o
ee ngs - t
a nita i a a s - a t tal r l va evi e s d t r f e be c i r d
dmi sr tve ppe l - nd ha 1 e e nt denc houl he e or
onsde e

a e b tej r C An e s n v Na ia o No.0 - 0 4 ,2 0 U. Dit LEXI
n w y h u y. / d r o . pol n ,
t
9 6 7 4 01 S. s.
S
1 422,a #23( D.Fl Fe 8,201 Ct teVI cl msar entte t denov rvi '
0
t
S. a. b.
0) Til I ai e ild o
o e ew.)
'

(ii Ch n lrv Ro d b s 4 U. 8 0 8 ( 9 6 ) Th s t ej r h r wilb
ct
ng a de . u e u h, 25 S. 4 , 45 1 7 ). u , h u y e e l e
a e t hea f om t r e ntw ine s sand t m a is ow n c edi lt a s s e s.
bl o r r he el va
t se
o ke t
r biiy s es m nt

Th r a o wh t EEOC a p ast h v rj de t ed fn a tse pa to
e e s n y he
p e r o a e ee d h ee d n ' x lnains
outihtt t ha ac e e t pli ifsve so ofe nt)mayaloha t do wih
rg and o ve c ptd he antf rin ve s
s ve o
t
t dif r ntsanda dsofpr i a cvi ca everusa EEOC i si ato The EEOC
he fe e t r
oof n i l s
s n
nve tg i n.
i s i ton yi l
nve tga i
e ded a tndi t t t r w as t ea ona e c us t bele ' t t
i ng ha he e
û s bl a e o
r
i ve ' ha
di c i i ton oc ur ed. The r as na e ca e s anda d - c m onl r e r t a
s rm na i
c r
e o bl us t r - om
y ef r ed o s

pr bl c e - r fr t çl!ras bl beifi t exitnc offct on whih a
oba e aus - ee s o ça e ona e le n he se e a s
c

cli i ba e a i t l lvaldiy oft cai is l.' BLACK' LAw D I ONARY
a m s s d nd n he ega i t
he l m te f '
S
CTI

1 1( h e 2009 . Bec us t ssa r ofpr i ls t n aprpondea e oft
32 9t d. )
a e hi tnda d
oof s e s ha
e
rnc
he
e de e,t s a r ne es a y t pr va l i a c vi t i l t EEOC lte m a s
vi nc he t nda d c s r o e i n
i l r a , he
e tr y ow

c n u in a t t p o e bu d n o p o fa mila t j r a t wh tweg ti
o f so s o he r p r r e f r o nd se d he u y s o a ih t
s o l gv t eEEOC lte is l. C Uni d Sttsv Lihto r ,3 7 F. px 25 ,
h ud ie h
etr tef / t a e . g b u n 5 Ap ' 9
e
263 ( 1h Ci. 2009) ( c i ng pr ba e c e as r quii ls pr t
1t r
desrbi
o bl aus
e rng e s oof han
prponde a oft evi e .
e
r nce he denc )
On t ot rsde oft e i n,t pr i vaue oft lte i si . The
he he i
he quato he obatve l
he e tr s lght
lte m a s nume ous r er nce t t t vi nc ' but o he t n m e i ng one
e tr ke
r
ef e s o he ' de e,' , t r ha
e
ntoni
a fda t doe noti ntf t e de i t r or . For e m pl t l ter doe not
fi vi, s
de iy he vi nce n he ec d
xa e, he e t
s
m e i w hom t EEO C i e vi w e w ha doc e s w e e r vi w e or wha t
nton
he
nt r e d,
t
um nt
r e e d
t he

EEOC acualy di t i si t t c r sofdicrm i ton. Se Rud v M i iDade
t l d o nve tgae he ha ge
s i na i
e y . am -

Cn@. No.016354,2002 U. Dit LEXI 28265,a #24 ( D.Fl Fe 6,2002)
,
S. s.
S
t
S. a. b.
(
EEOC lte wa ofltl pr tvevauebec ei wa concus y a di notouti
etr s ite obai l
aus t s
l or nd d
lne
t e de ir ba i f isc usons;fe v.Exec ieAilne,I . 31F.Su 2d
he vi nta y ss or t oncl i ) e
utv ri s nc,
pp.

1
355, 1 7 ( D. Fl 1
35 S.
a. 998) ( l ng EEOC lte t t di t t outi e n
excudi
etr ha d s
no
lne, ve
sl rl t e de euponwhihi r i f isc usons'.
tmmaiy,he vi nc
c t eles or t oncl i '
)
Acc di y,t de e
or ngl he f ndan ' m oto t e ude t EEOC lte ofde e m i ton
ts i n o xcl he
e tr
t r na i
i GR ANTED . The pl i if who i pr s , i ca i d t t he m us de l p an
s
antf,
s o e s utone ha
t ve o

i
ndepe ntevi nta y r cor wihoutr e e t hi EEOC lte ofdee m i ton,
nde
de ir e d, t
efr nce o s
et r
tr na i
whih s t i t hi cli ofdic i i ton,i or rt s v ve a de e e moton f
c ubsantaes s a ms
s rm na i n de o ur i
f ns
i or

sl r j d me to t p e ala til Th Co r sr n l e c u a e t p an ift
l
mma y u g n r o rv i t ra. e u t to gy n o r g s he litf o
a t m pt t r t n l ga c
te
o e ai e l ouns a f ii t t t dii nty r s a ch how t pr e ut
el nd, a lng ha , o lge l e e r
o os c e

4

t s c e a a pl ntf i f de a c t As sa e i t Or rofI tuc i t Pr Se
hi as s ai if n e r l our.
t t d n he de
nsr tons o o
Lii nt :
tga s

A pr s pl ntf be sr ponsbiiy f a tvel purui hi orhe c e
o e ai if ar es i lt or c i y s ng s
r as
and mus obt n any e s nta dic r fl alne s a y pla ngs a
t ai
s e il s ove y, ie l ce s r e di
nd
motons c
i , ompl wih al s he i o de s and pr pa e t c e f ti l
y t 1 c dulng r r ,
e r he as or ra .
Fal et c
iur o ompl wih c tde dlne m a r ul i dim is f lck of
y t our a i s y es t n s s al or a
pr e uton.
os c i

( 31 ! ) Th o d ras me to e ta rr s p risaerq ie t c mpl wi te
DE , 7 . e r e lo n in d h t / e a t r e u rd o o y t h
e
h
Co tspr e alr l s Thi i udesnotonl t Fede alRul sofCi lPr dur but
ur ' oc dur u e . s ncl
y he
r
e
vi oce e
as t Fe r lRuls of Evi e. The e r e a e wi y a ia e o t ope we
lo he de a
e
denc
s uls r del va lbl n he n b
a c n a s be ac s e t ough t Cour ' webst w ww. s us ours.gov,unde t
nd a lo
ce s d hr
he
ts
ie,
t d. c t
l
r he
he ng tLoc Ruls a Pr e es' whih c n be f md unde t E tor y
adi l al
e nd oc dur ,' c a
ot
r he W t ne
Re our es' a
s c 't b.

D N ad REE iCabraMi il d,pll 2
O EnO DRDn hme,t a ,o aAr f .
s mF
i
-

,

J
on
G oodm a
n
Unie St t sM a sr t J
t
ae
gita e udge
Co e f ni he t
pi s ur s d o:
Hon.Donad L.Gr m
l
aha
Cot e ofRec d
ms l
or
Tor a J M o gom e y
i no . nt
r
P. .
O Box 4508
45
M i mi FL 33245
a ,
PR O SE

5