Icon Health & Fitness, Inc. v. IFITNESS, INC.
Filing
20
ORDER denying 15 Defendant's Motion for Bond. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/2/2012. (mmz)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i
Ca eNum be : 12s
r
20125- V- O RENO
CI M
I
CON H EA LTH & FI ESS,m C .,
TN
Pli if
antf,
I TNESS,I C .
FI
N ,
Def nt
enda .
O RDER DENYI DEFENDANT' M O TI FOR BO ND
NG
S
ON
THI CAUSE c mebefr t Cou tu t Dee ntsM oi f Bond( .E. 1 ,
S
a
o e he r pon he fnda ' ton or
D No. 5)
5l don Januar 24.201 The De enda a kst sCour t r quiet Pl i ift pos abond of
e
y
2.
f nt s hi
t o e r he antf o t
a las $ 000t i mniyt De e ntf a da
te t 400, o nde f he f nda or ny mage im a i uri de e ngis l a i t
s t y nc n f ndi te f gans
t Pli ifscai f de ptvea u aita prctc sbr
he antf l m or ce i nd nf rr de a ie ought rFl i Stt ej501204.
unde orda aut
.
A motont rquieaPli ift pos abondi pemitdu rj5 . 13)oft Fl i
i o e r antf o t
s r te nde 0121 (
he orda
De eptve a Unf i Tr Pr c iesAc whi h sa e :
c i nd
ar ade a tc
t c tt s
l a a i br htu rt ss c i , upon m oton oft pa t a i tw hom s h a ton
n ny cton oug nde hi e ton
i
he r y ga ns
uc c i
i tld a lgi t tt a ton i fi ous wihoutlgalo f c ual e i, orbr
s ie le ng ha he c i s rvol , t
e
r a t m rt
oughtf t
or he
pu pos of ha as m e ,t c tm a , a t hea i e denc a t t ne es iy t r or
r e
r s nt he our y fer rng vi e s o he c st he ef
,
r uiet pary i tt i t a i t pos a bond i t amountwhi t cour fnds
eq r he t ns iutng he cton o t
n he
ch he
ti
r s na e t i mniy t de e nt f r any da a i ure , i l ng r s bl
ea o bl o nde f he f nda o
m ges nc r d ncudi ea ona e
a t ne sf s
tor y' ee .
Fl rda c t have f
o i ours
ound t bond r quie nt a opra e whe ne de t d ovi
he
e r me ppr it
n e d o s de
pr
de e n sa op t t f r dr s f r s
f nda t n poruniy or e e s orha as ment ahe t nt dic a pli if fom s e ng
r t r ha o s our ge a ntfs r e ki
a c st t c t .'- it v Pal Chev oltol mobie I ., 366So. 1
c es o he ouvs bl am lon . m
l
r e - ds
l, nc
2d 233, 234( a Dit
1 Fl. s.
CtApp.1 .nor rfradee tt de
.
979)l de o
fndan o monsrt t ne esiyfrabond, t def ndantm us
tae he c st o
he e
t
pr s nte de eidie t d t r t m e isoft c us ofa i whi i be n pr e ut d.'1
e e vi nc t r c e owa ds he rt he a e cton ch s i g os c e 'd.
a 1 3 . l panif t os s t a pe r ob wi o t rt r s be t ot er q ie n '1
t 2 5 Ony litfs s e ui p a t e t u meia e u j c t h e urme t' d.
wh
s
h
.
l is M o i f a Bond,t De e
n t
ton or
he f ndantar ues t tc
g
ha ountf ofI
our CON ' compl nti
S
ai s
fi ous a wihout me i bec us t De e
rvol
nd t
rt a e he f ndant r gita i of is'FI
' e sr ton
s
t ' TNESS'ta m a k
I
' r de r
pr de acomplt de e et t sc . TheDe e
ovi s
e e f ns o hi ount
f ndanta gue t tt r gitaton i prma f i
r s ha he e sr i s i ace
evi nc oft m a k' va i t a oft Def nda ' exc usverg t us t ma k underbot
de e he r s ldiy nd he e nts l i i ht o e he r
h
t La m Ac a t Fl i De ptona Unf i a Pr ctce ActThe e or t De e nt
he nha
t nd he orda ce i nd arTr de a i s .
r f e,he f nda
a g s t Pl i ifscl m f ta
r ue , he antf
ai or r dema k i rnge e i pe s fi ousa wihou me i. s
r nfi m nt s r e rvol
nd t t rt Thi
a gumen f isf t r as sa e be ow .
r
t a l or he e ons t t d l
The Def nda ar ues t t is r gita i of t 'FI
e nt g
ha t e sr ton
he ' TNESS' m a k pr des i wih a
I
' r ovi t t
c
omplt def et t Pli ifsdec ptveandunf rta pr c iesc am t ma ngt e cl i
e e ens o he antf
e i
ai r de a tc l i hus ki h a m
fi ous l m a ng t sa gume , t Dee
rvol . n ki hi r
nt he fndant el upont lngua ofs ton33()oft
ri
es
he a ge eci
a he
Lar m Ac whih esa ihe t tr sr ton ofa m a k l hal be prma f i e de e oft
l
ha
t c t bls s ha egita i
r ' l
s
i ac e vi nc
he
va i t oft r git e m a k a oft r sr ton oft m a k, oft r sr ntsowne s p of
ldiy he e ser d r nd he egita i
he r
he egita '
r hi
t m a k, nd oft r gita ' e l i rg t us t r git r d ma k i co m er e. 1 U. C.
he r a
he e sr nts xcusve i ht o e he e se e
r n m
c ' 5 S.
'
j 111 a)Howe r t Deenda fie t r og zet tt pr sonc i sf t rt sat
5( .
ve,he f nt ald o ec ni ha he ovii ontnue urhe o t e
t tt e de ir efe tofr sr ton S halnotpr cl a opposng pa t f o pr ng a
ha he vi nta y f c
egita i i l
s
e ude n
i
ry r m ovi ny
lgalore t bl d e e orde e t whi h mi ha be n as e td i s h ma k ha notbe n
e
quia e ef ns
f c ... c ght ve e s re f uc
r d
e
r git r d. I The Def nda ' a gum e t tr gita i i ac
e se e ' d
'
e nts r
nt ha e sr ton s omplt def
ee e
ns t t Pl ntf s
e o he ai if
cai as f l be a e t La m Ac s ii ly pr de f t c nc la i
l ms lo ais c us he nha
t pecfca l ovi s or he a e lt
on ofr git r d
e se e
ma ks whih ha not be om e i ont sa e. See 1 U. C.j 1 4 (' peiin t c e a
r
c
ve
c
nc e tbl
5 S.
06 ' tto o anc l
A
r gita i ofama k, ttng t gr
e sr ton
r sa i he oundsr i upon, ma . fld a f l by a peron who
eled
y.. ie s olows ny s
be
-
2-
bei st hei orwil da ge '. Defnda 'rgitatonofis'FI
leve hat s
lbe ma d.)The e nts e sr i
'
t ' TNESS'makdoe
I
' r s
notmak t Pl i ifsc am fi ousbe aus r gitato i notacompl t defns a t r o e
e he antf l i rvol
c e e sr i n s
ee e e, nd he ef r
t Dee thasfie t me t sa r rquie t obanabondunde Fl iaj5012113)
he fndan
ald o ethe tnda d e r d o ti
r ord
. (.
C O N CLU SI N
O
THE COURT ha consde e t moton, es ea t pe tne pori oft r c d,
s
i r d he i r pons nd he ri nt tons he e or
andbei ot wie f l a s i t pr m ie ,i i
ng her s ' y dvied n he e s s t s
ul
A DJUD G ED t tt m oton i D ENI .
ha he
i s
ED
D N A DO D R D
O E N R EE
W
u dyf c,02
aoe h21.
i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi
FED ERI
REN O
CH I
EF I
TED STA TESDI
STRI JUD GE
CT
Co espr de t
pi ovi d o:
Cou elofRe or
ns
c d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?