Palmat International, Inc.,et al v Attorney General of the United States of America

Filing 41

ORDER GRANTING RESPONDENT'S MOTION TO DISMISS 27 . Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 2/14/2013. (lbc)

UM TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO U TH ER N D I
STR I T O F FLO R I A
C
D
CASE NO.1220229- V- TZ/ M ONTON
CI SEI SI
PM M AT I
NTERNATI
ONAL, NC. a
l , nd
ROBERTO W ELLI
SCH ,
Pe ii ne s
tto r ,

ERI H .
C HOLDER,Ator y Ge r l
t ne
ne a
oft Unie St t sofAme ia,
he t d a e
rc
Res
ponde .
nt
O R DER G R AN TI G R ESPO ND EN T' M O TI N TO DI I
N
S
O
SM SS

THI M AW ER i be or t Cour on Res
S
s f e he
t
ponde ErcH . de ' M o i n t Dim is
nt i Hol r s to o s s
Peii ne s Pe ii f W rtofM a mus Deca aor J
tto r ' tton or i
nda , lr t y udgme ,a Vi ai of
nt nd ol ton
ns e t he
nmentof
Admi srtvePr e eAc ( 271 Thi cas concer ar ques by t gover
nitai oc dur t DE- . s e
Ar en i f t ba ac ountr c dsofPeii s Pa ma l e na i , nc. Ro ro
g tna or he nk c
e or
ttoner , l t nt r tonal l and be t

W els h Pama' mao i s a e od r Th r q s, d p rua t oaM uua Le a
l c , l ts j rt h r h le . e e uet ma e u s n t
i
y
t l gl
As it nc Tr ay be wee Ar entnaa t Unied St t s c er Pe ii r 'a oun sa
ssa e e t t n g i nd he t
a e , onc ns ttone s cc t t
Re onsBa Peii saleg t tt r ea e oft si or ton wilvi aet i i e e ti
gi
nk. ttoner l e ha he el s
hi nf ma i
l ol t he r nt r s n
a di t dicl ur ofc i nta i or ai a m ant i ng t rpe s la f isprva e
voi ng he s os e onfde i l nf m ton nd i ani hei r ona far i t
pur ua t t Fit a Foure t Ame e soft U. Consiuton. Pe ii r s e
s nt o he fh nd
ten h
ndm nt he S.
tt i
ttone s e k

ij tvea de aaor r i unde t W rtofMa mus 28U. C.j 1 ,heDe aaor
nunci nd clrt y elef r he i
nda ,
S.
361 t
clrt y
J
udgme Ac,28U. C.j 22012202, ndt Admi srtvePr edur Ac,5U. C.j701e
nt t
S. j
a he
nitai oc e t S.
t
s q. The e f c oft s r le w oul be t i pede t e uton ofAr tna' r
e
f e t hi e i f
d
om
he xec i
gen i s eque tf t
s or he

ba rco ds TheGove
nk e r .
mmentmo dt dimisf f l et saeacai a lc ofs j t
ve o s s or aiur o tt l m nd a k ubec

matr mi dcinpls a t oRue 1 ( )1 a 1 ( )6 o teF d rl lso Cii
te j s ito t u n t ls 2 b ( ) nd 2 b ( ) f h e ea Rue f v l
r

P o e u e Ba e o ar ve o temoint d s s , tto es r s o s @ 2 )t e
r c d r . s d n e iw f h to o imis Pei n r' e p n e DE- 8 ,h
i
Go e n ' r py g 3 ) a wel st rc r a dt a p ia elw,h sc s i d s se
v mme ts e l DE- 3 , s la he e o d n he p lc bl a t i a e s imis d
wihp eu ieb c u ePeiinesd no h v ac n z b ec nsi to a rg t nd rt eFit
t rj d c e a s t o r o t a e og ia l o t u in l ih u e h fh
t
t
Ame e ove fna i lr or hed by at r pa t ba
ndm nt r i nc a ec ds l
hid- ry nk.
1.

Fact B ackground
ual

The f l i f c s a e t ke f om t Pe ii n unl s ot r s not d. Pal a i a
olow ng a t r a n r he tt o
es he wi e e
m ts

Fl rdac por ton wih isprnci lplceofbusnes i Fl i W elich i a f ein i sor
o i or a i
t t i pa a
i s n orda.
ls s or g nve t

a P l tsmao i so k od r l 2 0, g n ia sM iityo Fo eg Afar is e
nd ama' j rt tc h le . n 01 Ar e tn ' nsr f rin fis s u d
y
s ver lr ques st t U . De rm e ofJ tc f t pr
e a e
t o he S. pa t nt us i e or he oduc i ofPe ii s fna i l
ton
ttoner ' i nc a

r or f ba a c shel i t Unie St t s Ther sswer madea pa tofa
ec ds or nk c ount d n he t d a e .
eque t
e
s r
n
ongoi c i i li tga i s e m i f o a l ga i t tPa m a ,al wih ot
ng rm na nves i ton t m ng r m le tons ha l t ong t her
co pa es pai brbest A r ntne gove n e of i al i c
m ni , d i o ge i
r m nt fci s n onnec i w ih t s l of
ton t he a e
ag i ulur le pm e t t Ve uel n gove m e .A r ntna r ue t d t fna i r c ds
r c t a qui nt o he nez a
m nt ge i eq s e he i nc al e or
unde t U . - ge i Tr a y on M ut Le A s i t e i Crm i lM a t sbe w e n
r he s.Ar ntna e t
ual gal s sanc n i na
ter t e
A r e i a t U nie St t s s gne on D e e be 4,1
g ntna nd he t d a e , i d
c m r 990. Se Tr a y Be w e n t
1 e e t t e he
G o r e oft Unie St t ofAm e i a t G ove n en oft Re
ve nm nt he t d a es
rca nd he
r m t he publc ofA r en i
i
g tna
on M ut lLeg A s it nc i Cr m i M a t r ,Si ne a Bue A ie on D e 4,1
ua
al s s a e n i nal te s g d t nos r s
c. 990,S.

' M ut las i t e t e te s h ast M LAT a i s he e have bec e i r as ngl
ua s sanc r a i s uc
he
t s ue r
om nc e i y
c m o i r c dec desasa t t f c lt t l galpr ee ngsi vi f ei pa te or
om n n e ent a
ool o a iia e e
oc di nvol ng or gn r i s
e de e. G e r l t e a e m e st ovi f bia e a ,m ut la s s a e i t ga he i
vi nc
ne aly, hes gr e nt f
pr de or l t r l
ua s i t nc n he t r ng
of l ga e de f us by t r que tng s a e i c i i li s i tonsa pr e di . I
e l vi nce or e he e s i t t n r m na nve tga i
nd oc e ngs' n
'

r Pr s sLoc e at840140hWve NE,Belv ,Was , F. 557,56 (t Ci. 1 .
e emie atd
t .
le ue
h.634 3d
4 9h r 201 )
2

Tr ayDo . .1 2 1 ( 9 )( een fe ç LAT' .
e t c No 0 - 8 1 91 h r ia tr 1
M
'2
)
Ac o dn t Peiin r,h Ato n yGe ea rj ce Ar e tn ' iiil e u s o te
c r ig o tto es te tr e n r l ee td g n ias nta rq e t n h
g ounds t tS twasnots cii a t t c i e pr um ptve y b ng i s i a e a di not
r
ha l
i
pe fc s o he rm
es
i l ei nve tg t d nd d

sat how t pr ton oft r quese doc e swoul adva e t c i na i si a i
te
he oduc i
he e t d um nt
d
nc he rmi l nve tg ton

tki pl ei Ar ntna. Pe.! 1
a ng ac n ge i ' t, 3.Thee tr af r dititcour a ntda Asitnt
'
rafe, edeal src
t ppoi e n ssa
Unie St t sAtor y a c
t d a e t ne s omm iso rt as iti obt i ngt r se doc nt .The
s i ne o ss n ani he eque t d ume s
c m i s one i s d a s
om s i r s ue
ubpoena t Regi B a de a ng t pr
o
ons nk, m ndi he oduc i n o Pa m a ' a
t o f l t s nd

W e ls h' ba a ountr or . Pe ii r as e t ha t Gove me ha notye pr de
lic s nk cc
ec ds ttone s s r t t he
m nt s
t ovi d
t s doc e s t A r ntna. On t f ce oft Pe ii how e r i i unc e rwhe he t
he e um nt o ge i
he a
he tton,
ve , t s l a
t r he

s
ubpoe e doc
na d ument ha be n pr
s ve e oduce t t Gove m e orr m an wih Re onsBa
d o he
nz nt e i t gi
nk.

Peiin r fldat rec u t eiins e n ij nci a d caao yr l f n e t e
t o e s ie h e -o n p tto e kig nu t nd e lrt r ei u d r h
t
ve
e
W rtofM a mus 28U. C.j 1 (
i
nda ,
S.
361 Count1,t Decart yJ
) he l aor udgme Act28U. C.jj
nt ,
S.
22012202(
Count1) a t Admi srtvePr dur Ac,5U. C.j7 ets q.(
1, nd he
nitai oce e t S. 01 e Count11.
1)
Peii scli t tt Gove n e ' e uton ofAr ntna' r ss- he e,t pr ton
ttoner am ha he
r m nts xec i
ge i s eque t
r he oduc i
offna a r or t t gove n entofAr i a pa tofa On- ng c i i i tga i
i nci l ec ds o he
rm
gentna s r
n goi r m nal nves i ton

2Pur ua t t Aril loft M LAT,e c c r i oblga e t g veas it nc ,
s nt o he tc e
he
a h ounty s i t d o i
ssa e
i l ng ç ovi ng doc e s r c ds a a tces'i col e ton wih ongoi c i nal
nc udi ' di
pr
um nt, e or , nd ri l , n m c i
'
t
ng rmi

i si tonsa pr e ngsi t r si sae.MLAT,Ar.1 j2..Aril Ipr de
nvetgai nd oce di n he eque tng tt
t , a tce ovi s
t tt teay d si t nded s ey f mut llgalas itnc be we n t Pa tes' S halno
ha he r t t n e
i
oll or ua e
ssa e t e he ri 'and ç l t
s
gi rs t arghto t pa tofa prva eperon t obt n, uppr s ore udean evi nce,
ve ie o i n he r
ny i t
s o ai s es , xcl
y de

ort i det e utonofar uet' 1 , .,j4.TheAto ne Ge rloft Unie
o mpe he xec i
eq s.' d.Art1
tr y nea he td
St t ,S rt pe s de i t d by hi ,' st Ce r lA ut iy r po i e f m a ng a
a es t he r ons s gna e
o
m ' i he nta
hort es nsbl or ki nd

rc vi rquesspurua t t Trat f ,Ar.I j2.TheAto ne Ge rlma ptrua
e ei ng e t s nt o he e y. #. tI,
tr y nea y, ls nt
t 1 U. C.j3512,akadititcour t çis s hor r asma benec s ayt e ut a
o 8 S.
s
src
t o ûsue uc de s
y
e s r o xec e
r ques fom a f e gn a hor t f a s s a i t i s i a i n o pr e uton ofc i i
e
tr
or i ut iy or s i t nce n he nve t g t o r os c i
rm nal

ofe es' 1 U. C.j351 a( ) l e csngt sa hort aditi cour ma a nta
fns . 8 S.
'
2()1 . n xerii hi ut iy, srct t y ppoi
pe s ço die t.t pr to ofdoc
r on t r c ..he oduc i n
t
umen s'i l ng by is ng or r ç eq rng t
t ,'ncudi
s ui
de s t uii he
r

a rnc ofapes ort pr uci ofdoc nt orot rt ngs orbot ' 18U. C.j
ppeaa e
ron, he od ton
ume s he hi ,
h.
'
S.
351 b)1,( .
2( ( ) 2)

-

woul vi l t Pe ii r c tt i li er ssi t ba r c dsunde t Fi a
d o ae ttone s' onsiutona nt e t n he nk e or
r he qh nd

Foure t Am e
ttn h
ndm e soft U . Cons im i n. Spe ii aly,Pe ii ne s c e t tt
nt
he S.
tt o
cfc l
tt o r ont nd ha he

r c ds i r e s d, l bem a a ia et t publc.Peii r a s r t t% heGove nme
e or , f ela e wil
de val bl o he
i
ttone s s e t ha ç
t
r nt
ofAr ntna ha m a publc a lt i or a i t ti hasbe a e t c pie r a di
ge i
s de
i l he nf m ton ha t
en bl o om l eg r ng
Pe ii r , a t ti C ilm os lke y m a publc a ba r c d' obt i d pur uan t t
ttone s ' nd ha t ç l
'
w
ti l
ke
i ny nk e or ' a ne
s t o he

M LAT s
ubpoe is dt RegonsBank.f , 1 Peii r f t alget tsvea ne
na sue o i
#.! 5. ttone s urher le ha e rl ws
oute si Ar ntna ha publs d a tc esdicl i de a l a
l t n ge i
ve
i he ri l s os ng t is boutt bank a count , i udi
he
c
s ncl ng

co r ponde ebewee t Unie Stt a Ar ntnaco e i t M LAT r ques f t
res
nc t n he t d a es nd ge i
nc m ng he
e t or he
ba i or ton, we la docl ss
nk nf ma i as l s lment howi Pe ii r '% c mtnlmber a r tng
ng ttone s f ot
ac
l
s nd ou i

c s. I ! 1
ode ' d. 7.
'
Pe ii r c a m t ta a r s toft s publc di c os es t i cons i tona l
ttone s l i ha s e ul he e
i s l ur , he r
tm i ly

pr t c e rght t t co i ntaiy oft i ba r or ha bee a wilc i t be
o e t d i s o he nfde i lt
he r nk ec ds s n nd l ontnue o
vi a e l a ton, tto r al get tt y ha be omet t r t o ( t nta c i i l
olt d. n ddii Pe ii nc s le ha he ve c
he a ge s f t e il rm na
po
a tvii ,i l ng t pos i lt ofki na ng, a km a l a e ori s' i l ng,i one
c i tes nc udi he s biiy
d ppi bl c i, nd xt ton ' nc udi n

i t nc t ki pi a mur ofW e ls h' t os f m iy r l tve .'f ., ! 1
nsa e, he dna ng nd
der
lic s t e a l e ai s' #
cl
8.
l.
I

Le St
gal andard
The pur e ofa m o i t di m i s fl pur ua t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr dur
pos
ton o s s ied s nt o de al e
vi oce e

1 b)6)i t t tt fcils t e y ofac ant Ther epe misdimis lofac ant
2( ( s o es he a a ufkinc
ompli .
ul r t s s a
ompli
t tf l t s a e a cl m upon whi h r i c n be g an ed. I s ul be r d al i Fe r
ha ais o t t
ai
c elef a
r t
t ho d
ea ongs de de al

Rul ofCi lPr edur 8a( , c r quiesaç hor a pli sae ntoft cai s ng
e
vi oc e ()2) whih e r t t nd an ttme
s
he l m howi
t tt plade i e ildt r le.'Alho hac antc lnge b aRul 1 b)6 moi
ha he e r s ntte o eif' t ug ompli hale d y
e 2( () ton
t dimi sdoesnotnee de a ld f c ua a lga i ,apl i ifi silo i a e t pr vi t
o s s
d t ie a t l le tons
antf s tl blg t d o o de he
û ounds'f rhi e il e t r le , nd a ç or ul i r c t ton oft el m e s ofa c us of
s
gr
' o s nttem nt o e i f a
t m a c e ia i
f
he e nt
a e

a tonwilnotdo. BelAtantcCor v.Twombl 550U. 5 555(
ci l
' l l i p.
'
y,
S. 44, 2007)
.
4

Wh nac mpliti c aln e u d rRu el ( )6 , c u t lp e u ta al l
e o an s h l g d n e l 2 b ( ) a o r wil r s me h t 1 wel
e
pla al gai nsa e tueand vi t pl di i t lghtm os f a et t pl ntE
e ded le to r r
ew he ea ngs n he i
t avor bl o he ai i

Ame ia Un tdL# Is Co v Ma t e , 0F.d 1 43 1 6 ( 1hCi. 0 7 .Howe e ,
rc n ie
n . . . ri z 48 3 0 , 0 6 1 t r 2 0 )
n
vr
onc a c tti ntfespl di t t be us t y a eno m o e t n c usons a enot
e our tde ii ea ngs ha , ca e he r
r ha oncl i , r
e il t t as um pton oft u h,' tm us de e ne w he hert w el- e f c s ç t t a cl i
ntted o he s
i
r t 'i
t t nni
t he lpl d a t ç a e a m
s

t r l ft t splu il o isfc . As c o v I al 1 9 S Ct 1 7 1 4 ( 0 9 .A
o ei ha i a sbe n t a e' h rh . qb , 2 . . 93 , 9 9 2 0 )
e
'
c ai ca onl s vi a1 b)6)motont dimisi i c ai fcua algai t ta e
ompl nt n y ur ve 2( (
i o s s f t ont ns a t l le tons ha r
l no t r s a r g t r i above t s c a i l ve ,o t a s pton t tal t
t ugh o ai e i ht o elef
e
he pe ul tve e l n he s um i ha 1 he

(a tal algai i t c antaetu ' Twombl 550U. a 555.Howe r awelpld
fcu ) le tons n he ompli r r e.
'
y,
S. t
ve, l- e

c mp an s r ie amo int d s s i v ni i srk sas vv u g t a a ta p o fo t e e
o lit u vv s to o imis ç e f t ti e a yj d e h t cu l r o f h s
e
f c si i oba e,a çha ar ove y i ve y r m o eand unlkey.' Twombl 550U . a
a t s mpr bl nd t t ec r s r e t
i l ''
y,
S. t
556.
111
.

A nal s
ysi

The Gove n e r s ss r la gume si s ppor ofdim isng t ca e. Thefr ti
r m nt aie eve a r
nt n u
t
s s i he s 3
is s
t tPe ii sca
ha ttoner nnotsat a c ai undert M LA T be us ,by isexpr s t r s t te y
te lm
he
ca e
t
e s e m , he r at
f e os s a prva e pa t srghtt a ca e ofa i u rt te y. M ot,a 5,7- . ee al o
or cl e
i t r y' i o
us
cton nde he r at
. t ' 9,
s
s

M LAT, t1 j4.Se ond,heGove n
Ar.,
c t
r mentco e t Peiines'ma mus de lrtr
ntnds hat tto r nda , caaoy,
a A pA- ed c a m s a e ba r d by t doc rne ofs ve e g i m uniy,a t tPe ii r f l
nd
bas l i r r e
he ti
o rin m
t nd ha ttone s ai

t i ntf ava i wave ofi muniy.M or s cii a l t Gove nm e as e t t tt Cour
o de iy
ld i r m
t
e pe fc ly, he
r nt s rs ha he
t

lc s j c matr l idcinbe a e ( ) tto e sf it ie tf aç la rg t orle ' s
a ks ube t te jz s ito c us : 1 Peiin r al o d niy l e r ih t eif a
r
c
rquiedt obt nma
e r o ai ndamusrle;( t DecaaoyJ
eif 2) he lrtr udgmen Ac doesno pr dea
t t
t ovi n

id p n e t a i f rteCo r' jlid ci n a d ( ) u iil e iw u d rteAPA i p e ld d
n e e d n b ss o h u ts t s ito ; n 3 j d ca rv e n e h
r
s r cu e
3 TheGove m e ' moton a s r quesst tt Cour de Peii r 'Ve iid
m nts i l o e t ha he
t ny ttone s rfe

Emeg n yMo inf rPrlmi ayIj n to ( 5 .Be a et eCo r h sar a yd n e t i
r e c to o ei n r n u cin DE- 1 c us h u t a le d e id h s
moton (c DE- ,heei none dt a es ihee.
i - c 301 t r s
ç
e o ddr s t r

byt M LAT' tr ,a i i y ba r d bec us Pe ii r 'c a msr a et ma tr of
he
S e ms nd mpledl re
a e ttone s l i elt o te s
f ei a f is whih t Consiu i ha e nlt d t t poltc br nc sofg r nt
or gn far , c he
tt ton s nt s e o he ii al a he
ove nme .

I rs n e Peiin r a sr ta teCo r h s u idcint d tr n q e to
n epo s , t o e s se th t h u t a j rs ito o eemie u sins
t
r ga di t c tt i lt oft Gove n e ' aci t ke pur ua t ate t s h ast
e r ng he onsiutona iy he
r m nts tons a n s nt o r ay uc
he
M LAT.Addii ly, he c end t tt c amsa is i t sc e a ieno unde t M LAT
tonal t y ont ha he l i t s ue n hi as rs t
r he
-

whi Pe ii r a
ch ttone s ckno ldgef e os saprvaepa t sc us ofa ton- butr t rund r
w e
or cl e
i t ry' a e ci
ahe
e

t Fit a Fouree h Ame e ' pr eci ofa i vi ' i e essi a di t
he fh nd
t nt
ndm nts ot ton n ndi duals nt r t n voi ng he
dicl ur ofpe s
s os e
r onalma t s4 Fo t r s s tf t bel , t Cour a e w ih
ter . r he ea ons e orh ow he
t gr es t
Pe ii r sfr ta g
ttone ' is r ument buthol t tt Consiuton oft Unie St t sdoe notpr e t
,
ds ha he
tt i
he t d a e
s
ot c
Pe ii r 'i e e t i mai ani t c i nta iy oftna i r cor hed by Re onsBa ,
ttone s ntr ss n nt i ng he ontde ilt i ncal e ds l
gi
nk
at r paryt t sca e.Ac or ng y, ttone sf i t sae ac am f rwhi h c n beg a ed.
hid t o hi s
c di l Pe ii r a l o t t l i o
c a
r nt
A.

The C o thas Juri di t o t Ent r ai Pe i i r 'C ons iut o Cl i s.
ur
s cin o
e t n tt one s
tt i nal a m

The Go r en s ndsur e es a y pa ron t a gum e t Pe ii r c nnots a e a
ve nm t pe
m c s r pe
he r
nt hat ttone s a
tt

cai unde t M LAT be us ,asPeii r a knowl , t e i no prva er ghtof
lm
r he
ca e
ttone s c
edge her s
i t i
e o ce ntoft te t
nf r me
he r ay.Se ,eg. M ot, t4- M or ove , he i t ntpe ii doe notaleg a
e . ,
. a 9.
e r t ns a
tt on s
l e
vi a i oft M LAT a t bassf isc am s Ra he , c coun i pr m ie o t a lged
olton he
s he i or t l i . t r ea h
t s e s d n he le
vi ai ofPe ii ne s c tt i na rg ofprva y ove t i ba a ounti o mai . See
olton
tto r ' onsiuto l iht
i c
r her nk cc
nf r ton

P t,I 2 , 7 47 AsteS p e Co r ha o e v d,r ayo iain aet u j c . t t
e .! 9 3 , . h u rme u t s bsr e te t bl to s r û b e t . o he
!
g
s
.
Cons iuton' g r t esofi vi ua rg s' Am . I . s' v.Gar
tt i s ua an e
ndi d l i ht .
'
ns As n
amendi 53 U . 3 41
, 9 S. 96, 7,

n. (
9 2003) s ealoI r Pr mie Locatdat840 1 hWv NE,Bele ,Was ,634F.d
;e s n e e ss
e
40t c.
lvue
h.
3

4 Asat e hol mate ,Peii ne sf lt sa ea cai unde t Foure nt Am e
hr s d t r tto r ai o t t l m
r he
te h
ndme .
nt
t istr s t Fo te h Ame e onl a i t sae a ton.' Qu lsv Vt, 01 W L
i t e m , he ure nt
By
ndm nt y pples o t t c i ' ie . it2 0

5559507,6( . Pa. 0) Be aus t scaei lmie t t a tonsoft Unie Stt
M D. 201 . c e hi s s i td o he ci
he td aes

J tc De rm e , pa toft f r lg l e , t Foure nt Ame m e i i pplca e.
usi e pa t nt a r he ede a ovemm nt he
te h
nd nt s na i bl

5 7 5 (t Ci. 01 )(s e te , iesau e , r s be t oc nsi to a l t,n ldn t
5 , 71 9h r 2 1 d ais lk tt ts ae u j c t o tt in li s icu ig he
Tr
u
mi
s pa ai ofpowe sa t gua a e ofduepr es .' .Theeor t Cour ha fdeal
e r ton
r nd he r nt e
oc s '
)
rf e,he
t se r

q e to u idcinp ru n t 28U. C. 1 31o e acam t t te t o lg to d e no
u sinj rs it u s a t o
o
S. j 3 v r li ha a r ay bi ai n o s t
c mp r wi ac n ttto a g a a te S eI r Re e tr m Un tdKigd m, 8 F.d 1 1
o o t t o siu in l u rne . e n e qu s f o
h
ie n o 6 5 3 , 5
( s Ci.201 (xecii jlidito unde 28U. C.j 1 t rviw a algaint tt
1t r 2) e r sng trs cin
r
S.
331 o e e n le to ha he
pe ii r Fis Amendme rgh swoul bevi a e bas on as
ttone s' r t
nt i t
d
olt d ed
ubpoe is d puruantt
na s ue
s
o

a M LAT)
n
.
B.

Pe i i r' Alege Cons i ut ona V i at on Faist St e a Cl m .
t tone s l d
t t i l ol i
l o at
ai

The Gove nme ar ue t tt Pe ii s d be dimis d bec us Pe ii ne sf lt
r nt g s ha he tton houl
s se
a e tto r ai o
sa eavald lbe t i e es i t rba r c ds The Supr meCour ha r c z d a
tt
i i ry nt r t n hei nk e or .
e
t s e ogni e
c tt i na i e es çn a di dicl ur ofpe s
onsiuto l nt r t t voi ng s os e
i
r onalma tr .' Bur v.War ,USP
te s ' ns
den

Be nt482Fe Appx. 4, 7( 1hCi. 2)( i r/l/w v. 429U. 589,599
aumo ,
d.
41 41 1 t r 201 quotng ' l E Roe,
F
S.
( 977)5 Therg t prva ye mpa s t ditncti eess ( )t i vi li e eti
1 ).
iht o i c nco ses wo si ntr t' 1 he ndi dua ntr s n
.
a di dicos eofpe s matr ;a ( t i ee ti i pe ncei ma ngc ran
voi ng s l ur
ronal te s nd 2) he ntrs n nde nde n ki e ti
ki ofi pora de s ons ' Whal n, 429 U . a 598 .
nds m tnt ci i .'
6
e
S. t -600. Thi cons iutonalr g i
s
tt i
i ht s

naro y c t ed a i lmie t rgh swhih a ei u m e al' (mplci i t c e of
r wl onsnz nd s i t d o i t
c r û nda nt 'or ç i t n he onc pt
f
i
or r lbe t 'Paulv Davi,424 U. 693, 71 ( 976 .TheFi Cic t
de ed i ry.'
.
s
S.
3 1 )
hh ruiCour ofAppe s
t
al

h sh l t a fti a ca p ia yd e n tfl'wi i tea tn mysr n o terg to
a ed h tçln n il rv c o s o al' t n h uo o ta d f h ih t
l
h

5I i t c ea w het rt r g t i or a i na prva y e e t cor a i . Se
ts m l r
he he i ht o nf m t o l i e xt nds o por tons e
U S.v M or on Sal Co. 338 U . . 6 2 6 2( 9 0 (çcj r rto sc n cam n e uaiywih
.
t
t ,
S 3 , 5 1 5 ) s opo ain a li o q l
g
t t

i dvd asi tee j y n o arg tt p ia y'; D. C. . r e ,1 F.d 1 38 1 45(t
n iiu l n h no me t f i h o rv c ' F. f v Ga n r 26 3 1 , 1 9h
)
Ci.1 )Cdcl ai poses muc we rprva yi eesst ni vi s'(iai
r 997 g omortons s s h ake i c ntr t ha ndi dual' cttons
)
o t d .Ho v r be a s t eb n r c r sa is i t sc s aeno s b e t oc nsi to a
mit ) we e , c u e h n k e o d t sue n hi a e r t u j c t o tt in l
e
u
pr t cton asa ma trofl w, heCour lave t sque ton f a he da .
oe i
te
a t
t e s hi
si or not r y
The et ditnc sr ndsha be n r e r d t a t t onfde ilt sr nd' a t
s wo si t ta
ve e ef re o s he ' i nta iy ta ' nd he
c
û ut
t onom y s r nd.'Se Pl e v Gon e , F. 1 1 1 28(t Ci.1 )(ntr l
a
ta ' e ant .
zalz 575 2d 1 9, 1 5h r 978 i e na

ciai omit )
ttons ted .

prva Pl e,575 F. a 11 7 Pe ii s ca e r t on t a l ga i t tt r e e oft
i cy. ant
2d t 32. ttoner ' s es s he le ton ha he el as
he
ba r cor w ilvi a e t rc tt i lr g d n m a n ai ng t i per o lafaispr va e '
nk e ds l ol t hei ons iutona i ht t
i
i t ni he r s na f r i t .'

Se ,e. ,Pe.!29.M orove ,Peii r ma nocam t tt r l s oft rrcods
e g. t,
e r ttone s ke li ha he eea e hei e r
i plc t a a onom y i er s s The ef e,onl t rghtofconfde i lt s r nd i a i s
m i a e ny ut
nt e t .
r or
y he i
i nta iy ta s t s ue
he e.
r
The a l ge f ct do notpl us bl es a i h a vi a i ofPe ii r 'rgh t
le d a s
a i y t bls
ol ton
ttone s i t o
c i nta iy ove fnanc a r cor he d by Re onsBa
onfde i lt
r i i l e ds l
gi
nk. The s v va ofPe ii r 'c ai s
ur i l
ttone s l m
hi s o w he he a c tt i
nge n
t r ons iutonalrghtofprva y e s s ove fnanc a r or . Long ag t
i
i c xit
r i i l ec ds
o, he
Fi t Cic tCour ofAppe l de e ne t tt prva y ofpe s lfna ali or ton f ls
fh r ui
t
a s t nni d ha he i c
r ona i nci nf ma i a l
die ty w ihi t s ope oft s l i t c i nta iy.' Pl e,575 F. a 11 2. Tha c e
r c l t n he c
hi t ght o onf de i lt ' ant
r
2d t 3
t as
conc r d a l w s tfl d by a gr ofFl i s a e s na o scha l ngi a a e
e ne a ui ie
oup
orda t t e t r
le ng n m ndm e t t
nt o he
sa e co tt i r qui i publc ofi i l t fl s or s a e e s di c osng t i ne w orh,
t t nsiuton e r ng
i tc a s o ie w n t t m nt s l i he r t t
as e s a la ltes
s t , nd i biii .See i ,a 11 23. W hie r ogni ng t tt s na or ha a pr ec ed
d. t 22l ec zi ha he e t s d
ot t
rghtofprva y a i tdi c osng fna i li o m a i t c tofappe s c l d t tt s
i
i c ga ns s l i i nc a nf r ton, he our
al onc ude ha hi
rghtw a out e ghed by t s a e' i er s i t publc di c os e ofis r pr e a i 'a s t ,
i
s w i
he t t s nt e t n he
i s l ur
t e es nt tves s e s
a he d t am e en t be c tt i l See i ,a 11 8
nd l he
ndm t o
ons iutona
d. t 36.

Neihe t Pa tesnort Cour ha f
t r he ri
he
t s ound aca eaddr s i t i s ofwhe he t
s
e sng he s ue
t r he
ç i htofconfde i lt ' tand a i s t fna i r or he d by a t r pa t H o e r i
sg
r
i nta iy' s r
pple o i nc al ec ds l
hid ry. w ve , n

US.v. ilr 425U. 435( 976) t SuprmeCour hed,i t cont toft Fo t
M le ,
S.
1 ,he
e
t l n he ex he urh
Am e
ndm e , ha a ba c t e ha no pr ec e i e es i t c es ofc c a o he
nt t t nk usom r s
ot t d nt r t n he opi
he ks nd t r

7I Bo n rv Ci o ih r ,h Elve t Cic i a o tda bidn p e e e tal
n n e . t fprc a d te e nh rut d p e s n ig r c d n 1
y

de ii nsoft f m e Fit Cic tha d down prort Ocober1 1 1 661F. 1
c so
he or r fh r ui nde
i o t
, 98 .
2d 206,1
209

( 1hCi.981 .
1 t r1 )
8 U nlke t ca e a ba ,Pl e doe notdi e ty a y t c r um s anc i w hi h ba
i he s t r ant
s
r c l ppl o i c t es n
c nk
r cor ar obt ne f om a t r pa t - i t sca e,Reg onsBank.
e ds e ai d r
hi d ry n hi s
i
8

rc r rtie b h sb n a dte eo ec u dn t se t c aln et ag a dj r s b e a
e o ds ean d y i a k, n h r f r o l o a sr a h le g o r n u y u po n
t t ba f t e r c ds 1 a 440- 96.The Cour de e ne t tba r c dsa tnot
o he nk or hos e or . d. t
43,
t t nni d ha nk e or r
t ac
he c ounthol rsprva epa r butr t rd hebusnes r cor oft banks' i whi h a
de ' i t pe s
ahe ç
t
i s e ds he
'n
c
,

c t e d an a s r neihe owne s p no pos es i .' 1 L a 440, s ealo U S.v Ghi ,
us om r t
c s et t r
r hi r s s on ' 6 t . e s
g
. doni

732F. 81 81 ( 1hCi.1 4)( di t tbnnkrc dshel byat r pa t ba wee
2d 4, 7 1 t r 98 hol ng ha
e or
d
hid- ry nk r
notéei bl f pr e ton unde t Fit Ame e ,' a co l ng,unde M ilr t ttit
tlgi e or ot c i
r he fh
ndm nt ' nd ncudi
r le , ha il
g
i we le tbls d t tba r c dsa enotpr ec e fom dicl u eby an co tt i l
s l- sa ihe ha nk e or r
ot t d r
s os r
y nsiutona

p iie e' (mp a i a d d ; f r Ch re Co p. .U S, pto ra uy, 1993 W L
rv lg .) e h ss d e ) œ o d a tr r v .De . fT e s l
'
2 8 0 , 3( . F1 .Apr 2 ,1 9 )(1 i wels tldt a ap ro h sn lgtmae
6 5 7 * M D. a, . 3 9 3 it s l-et h t e s n a o e ii t
l
e
e pe t ton ofpr va y i t cont nt ofr cor vol arl co ye t a t r pa t . Thi
x cai
i c n he
e s e ds unt iy nve d o hi d ry
s

prnci e i l sr c dshe d b aba . .. .' .Bas ont fr goi a hort no
i pl nc ude e or
l y
nk '
)
ed he o e ng ut iy,
c tt i l pr eced prva i e es e ssf Pe ii r ba a c
onsiutonaly ot t
i cy ntr t xit or ttone s' nk c ountr c dshel by
e or
d
Reg onsBa
i
nk.

9 To t e entRi htt Fi i Prvac Ac , 1 U. C. 3401 et e , e og z a
he xt
g o nanc al i y t 2 S. j
, s q.rc nies n
i vi lsrghtofprva y ove he ba a ountr c ds t s rght ar notofac tt i na
ndi dua ' i
i c
r r nk cc
e or , he e i s e
onsiuto l
di
menson. Ase aned byt Fi Cic ti Unie St e v. Ki on, F. 733( hCi.
i
xpl i
he hh r ui n
td ats
ngt 801 2d
5t r

1 )
986 :

TheRih t Fia ca P i a yAc Ssac n rs in l epo s 't g le'
g t o n n il rv c t t o g e so a r s n e'o Milr )
i
s
hol ng,f rGti cea t Congr sma pr depr e ton ofi vi rg s
di o t s l r hat
i
es y ovi ot c i
ndi dual i ht
be
yondt ta f de i t Co tt i n.' H. P. 1
ha for d n he nsiuto ' Re No. 383,95t Co ,2nd
h ng.
Ses . r prn edi 1 U. CodeCong. & Ad. ws9273,9306.W hie i i
s 7, e i t n 978 S.
Ne
l ts
evi ntt tCongr s ha e nded i vi s rghtt prvac i ba r or
de ha
e s s xpa
ndi dual' i o i y n nk ec ds
oft i àc ount ,
her c s appe lesar mit ke i t rco e i t tt e
le
e sa n n hei nt nton ha he xpanson i
i s
ofc tt i ldi
onsiutona mensons The rght c e e b Congr s ar s at or , not
i .
i s r at d y
e s e t ut y
c tt i .
ons iutonal

Ila 737(mphassa
d.
e
i dded) s ealo US.v.Cor e, 220F.3d 11 , 11 ( h Ci.2000)
;e s
mir
03 08 9t r
(- t
i

f eke f t 't t1d t t Supr m eCour i M il dee m i ngt taperon doesnotha
' y acor' ha e o he
h
e
t n ler tr ni ha
s
ve
ar as bl e ca i ofprva y i ba r co dsçi t tape s doe notpos e sa
e ona e xpe tton
i c n nk e r ts ha
ron s
ss
r s bl expe t ton ofprvac i a ie i whih hehasno pos e s r orowne s p
ea ona e
c ai
i y n n tm n c
ssoy
r hi

i er t' .Nohi i t Ri tt Fi i Prva Ac ceaesi ade iorapose s r or
nt es.' t ng n he gh o nancal i cy t r t n post
)
s s oy
owne s p i e es i ba r cor .
r hi nt r t n nk e ds

9

!

l

l

M or over e n as umi t ts h a i e es e s s i i out g d by t Unie
e , ve s ng ha uc n nt r t xit, t s weihe
he t d

Stt s c
a e ' ompe lng i e essi f fli iste t oblgai . E T) ec n ttto aiyof
li nt r t n ulilng t r a y i tons $ h o si in l
(
u
t

!

go en n a to lalg dt h v voae t i rg t oc nfd n ilt mus b d tr n d b
g v r me t cin l e o a e ilt d h s ih t o ie tai
e
y t e eemie y

i

us ofabaancngt s c
e
l i e t ompa i t i er sst a ton s r eswiht ei hi r .' Hest v.
rng he nt e t he c i e v
t hos t nde s '
er

,

1

'

q

Ci o le ge il, 7 F.d 1 9 ,1 9 ( 1hCi. 98 )(ne n l uoain a dctto
t fMild vle 7 7 2 4 2 4 7 1 t r 1 5 itr a q tto s n i ins
y
a

'

o te .Peii r aleg t tt Gove n ntsc i ewiht M LAT rques wil
mitd) ttone s l e ha he
r me ' omplanc t he
e t l

vilt t i c nsi to a rg t b c u etej d eo e s en t iv siaino Pama i
oae her o tt in l ihs e a s h u g v re ig he n e tg to f l tn
u

)

'

(

Ar entna ha ma publc a1i or ton a
g i
s de
i 1 nf ma i boutPeii ne sr c ve fom t Unie St t .
tto r e ei d r he t d aes

t

Pe ii ne sbeleve t tt pr vi di cl ur oft s i onna i has a r d 1 d t t
tto r i ha he e ous s os e hi nf
ton
lea y e o he

l

'

ki pi a , i one c s ,t mur rofW els h' r l tve i Ar entna ast s c i i l
dna ng nd n
a e he de
lic s e ai s n g i , he e rm na

y
(
t

a tvii t k plc a t t i or a i wa m a publc. Re p. a 8.0
c i tes oo a e fer he nf m ton s de
i
s ,t 1

(
'
t

y

(
)

Ra g da ansti itrs iteUntdSae'itrs i c o eai wihfrin
n e g i thsneets h ie tts neetn o p rt t oeg
ng

7
t
i
(
.

7

c r e i c i i m a t r tuough t e
ounti s n rm nal te s l
he xcha ofe de . l r tf ng t U s- r ntna
nge vi nce n a iyi he
A ge i

E
i

)

'
(
(

M LAT,Co r s r cog z d t tim ut l alas i t e t e tesha be e i r asng y
ng es e ni e ha ç ual eg
s s anc r a i
ve com nc e i l

t

i pora t si t U nie St t s wa on c i e,' i pa tc arf ta na i lc i e t t
m t nt ool n he t d a e y r
rm ' n ri ul or r ns tona r m s ha

i
g

d eq r t cos coo r ton ofl e or me a hortest oug utt word.' S.Exe
i uie he l e pe a i
r
aw nf ce nt ut ii hr ho he
l'
c.

l

::
:

(
.

t

Re No 1 2 3 , t1 s eas I r Re u sf o UntdKig o 68 F.da 1 (n en l
p. . 0 - 3 a ; e lo n e q e t r m ie n d m, 5 3 t 8 itr a

;

(

quottonomit ;andI r Commisoner'Sub oena 325F. 1 ,1 ( 1hCi.2003 ,
ai
ted)
ne
s i s p s,
3d 287 290 1 t r
)

C
.

ov r uldonot rgr ndsb I e Cor v. ance Mir De c s I .542U. 241( 4)
er e
he ou y ntl p. Adv d co vie , nc,
S. 200

t

F

j
'
.

y
'
.

r

)

. Re a kabl a r f om alegi t tt rba a co a r utng i or a i w a
0 m r y, pa t r
l ng ha hei nk c unt nd o i nf m ton s
r e e t t publc,Pe ii r pr de no s c fcsast t contntoft ç i nc a
elas d o he
i ttone s ovi
pe i
o he
e
he i na i l
f
i or a i 'hathasa r a be r l a e i Ar ntna. l a e nt a s ngt tt s
nf m ton't
le dy en e e s d n ge i n ny ve , s umi ha hi
fna i li o m a i c
i nc a nf r ton once nst s m ea ount a is i t sdiput Pe ii r 'c am of
r he a
cc s t s ue n hi s e, ttone s l i
c tt i lvi a i f ist s a e a c a m f t a tonalr as n t tt fna a r or
ons iutona ol ton a l o t t l i or he ddii
e o ha he i nci l ec ds
ha ar dybee madepa toft publcr or a a e, defnii no l rc i nta .
ve lea
n
r he
i ec d nd r by i ton, onge onfde i l

)

SeeUS.v Pos r 59 F.
. ne , 4 Supp.930,936( D.Fl 1 4)( di t t(onc ce t n
S. a. 98 hol ng ha . e rai
:

'
f
(

i or a i i i t publc dom a n.. he e il m e t prvac i 1 t' .
nf m ton s n he
i
i . t ntte nt o i y s os . '
)

r

2
'
#
2
'
?
,

)
'

'
r

10

)

)
.

.

(û
ç
MLATs.ha t de iedquaiyofc
.. ve he sr
lt ompuli a t yco rcualyoblgaet t
son s he nta t l i t he wo
c re t pr det ea h ot re de e a ot rf
ountis o ovi o c he vi nc nd he onnsofa ssa ne d i crmi l
s it nce ede n i na
c eswhie sr mlni a e nci t efe tve soft pr es f obt ni nee d
as
l tea i ng nd nha ng he f c i nes
he oc s or ai ng de

e ie c .
vd n e'
).
Notbl Pe ii r do notco a n t tt Govem me ' f flme ofisteay
a y, ttone s
mpli ha he
nts ulil nt t r t
oblg tonsvi aest i c tt i rght , butr t rt t r e s ofPe ii r
ia i
ol t her onsiutonal i s
a he hat he ela e
ttone s'

i o maint t ep b i, ya Are t ej d ei c a g o a o g igi v siain i
nfr to o h u lc b n g ni u g n h r e f n n on n etg to n
n
Ar ntna ma l d t f t eat cksa ns Pe ii r by uni ntfe t r pm is W hie any
ge i , y ea o uur ta
gai t ttone s
de ii d hid
e.
l
c izna a t agans Pe ii ne sa Peii ne s r ltvesar de or bl , Pe ii r s cul ton
rn i l c s i t tto r nd tto r ' ea i
e pl a e ttone s' pe a i

a
boutt pot nta f t ec
he e i l uur omm ison oft a ulacsby t r pa te i a f egn c r
si
mlwf t
hid ri s n or i ounty
c nnoto wegh t Unie Stt sc
n
ut i he t d a e' ompeli i e e ti c
lng ntr s n ompl ngwih t M LAT.I1
yi
t he
IV .

C oncl on
usi

TheFit Amendme oft Unie Consiuto doe notpr dea c z erg t of
fh
nt he t d
tt i n s
ovi
ogniabl iht o
c i talt f ba r c dshed by at r pary bal . M or over e n i s h a r g e s s
onfden i iy or nk e or
l
hid t rk
e
, ve f uc i ht xi t ,
t U nied St t 'i e es s i f fli is oblg tonst de a m ut la s s a e t ea y f r
he t
a es nt r t n ulilng t
iai m r
ua s i t nc r t a
out ei h Pe ii r i e e t i kee ng t r cor pr va e. Pe ii r f i t sa eavai
w g ttone s' nt r s s n pi he e ds i t
ttone s al o t t
ld

co tt i lcli . Acc di l i i
nsiutona am
or ngy, t s
ORD ERED THA T

Res nde ' M o i t Di m i sPe ii r Pe ii n f r W rtofM a m us
po nts ton o s s ttone s' tto o
i
nda ,

De aao yJ
clrtr udgme ,a vi ai ofAd nitai Pr ed eAc k 27)i GRANTED.
nt nd olton
mi srtve oc ur t DE- s

1 TheCour i a s unconvi ed,ba e on t s s cultve a s ri , t tt fna a
1
t s lo
nc
s d he e pe a i s e tons ha he i nci l

if r t nwil eusd i af r inj d ca p o e dngt a d p rsfo teUni d S ae '
n o mai lb e n o eg u iil r c e i h t e a t rm h
o
t tts
e
S o c p so f n n n a d ep o e sa d fi s't j siya ij ci nprv n igt
i n e t f u d me tl u r c s n ame s'o u tf n nun to e e tn he
c
gove nme fom f lilng iste t oblga i .I r Pr mie , 63 F. 557, 2 (t Ci.
r nt r
ufli t r ay i tons n e e s s 4 3d
57 9h r
2011.
)

Thi c s i D I I
s a e s SM SSED W I PREJ I f f iur t s a e a c a m f r
TH
UD CE or a l e o t t l i o
w hi h r i fca be gr nt d.
c elt n
a e
A 1 pe ng m otonsno ot r ie r ed upon a e D EM ED a M O OT.
1 ndi
i
t he w s ul
r
s
4.

Thi ca e i CLO SED .
s s s

&

D N A DO DR DiMai li,i / dy ferr 21
O E N R E E n i , od ts / aoFbuy 03
m F rah
a,
*

PA TRI A A .SEI
C
TZ
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U

c Couns ofRec d
c:
el
or

12