Alvarez v. United States of America

Filing 4

ORDER DISMISSING ONE CLAIM OF PETITION FOR WRIT OF HABEAS CORPUS. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/26/12. (dge)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRJ CO U RT FO R TH E
CT
SO U TH ERN DI
STRI O F FLORI A
CT
D
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i

Cas Num be 1 20687- V- ORENO
e
r: 2Cl M
AN A ALV AREZ,

Pe ii ne ,
tto r
VS.

UNI
TED STA TES OF AM ERI ,
CA
Res nde .
po nt
/
O R DER D I I N G O N E C LA I O F PETI O N FO R W R I O F H A BEA S C O RPU S
SM SSI
M
TI
T
Pe ii rr ques st Cour gr ntt Pe ii f W rtofH a asCor c ai i he ti
ttone e
t he
t a he tton or i
be
pus l m ng r ral

c el si fe tvebe us hedi notfl am oto t r c et unde s g d.Now, tto
ouns wa ne f c i
ca e
d
ie
i n o e us he
r i ne
Pe ii ner
cai r c alwasa opra e cli i t tbe us t J
l ms e us
ppr it , am ng ha ca e he udge sda e wor d f t Unie
' ughtr ke or he t d
St t De rm e of us iei W as ngt DC, a nc ha e oysalr num be a t ne
aes pa t nt J tc n
hi on, an ge yt t mpl
a ge
rof tor ys
nai wi t J
ton de, he udge s d ha r c e i aca epr e ut d by t s me de t
houl ve e us d n
s os c e
he a
parment Be us
. ca e
t r we enogr
he e r
oundsf r c a i t sca e ti l
or e us l n hi s ,ra couns c dno ha be n i fe i f f iur
el oul t ve e ne f ctve or al e
t fl t moto t r c e.Ac or ngl t Cour fndst tt Peii ' fr tgr
o ie he i n o e us
c di y,he
t i ha he ttoners is oundf r le
or ei f
f is t s tsy t sanda d f a fndi t t c
al o a if he t r or i ng ha ouns was i f c i The Cour or r t
el
nefe tve.
t de s he

Go r ntt r s
ve nme o e pond t t s co c am f i fec i a ssa e ofc
o he e nd l i or ne f tve s it nc
ouns lby no l trt n
e
ae ha
M ay 30.2012.
L BA CKG RO UN D

Dr AnaA l r asa m pl e a St J Re biia i n Ce er a H l tea m e c nt r
.
va ezw ne oye t . ude ha lt t o
nt , n V r t nt e e ,
t tw a es a i he a a f on f ra m as i M e c r s m .D r A l r z wasc
ha s t bls d s r t o
sve di a e ca
. va e
onvi t f he r e
c ed or r ol

i t fa Shef s ydi nos HI postveM e c r be i a i wihac ton t twoul
n he r ud.
alel ag ed V
ii
dia e nefcires t ondii ha
d

j siyte t nso W i lho a e p n ied gt a M e iaewo l te ri u s t S . u e
u tf rame t f nk , n x e sv nl h t dc r ud h n emb re o t J d .
Be us t pa int di nota t lyne W i t t c i cwoul pur has onl as a lfaci n
ca e he te s d
c ual ed nlho, he lni
d c e y m l r to

oft dr gs f rwhih i ha bil M e c e.Durngt ss m ,St J r ei d m or t n $8
he u , o
c t d led diar
i hi ca
. ude ec ve
e ha

mil nfo M e iae A j l c n ce Dr Al r zf rh rr l i t i s a f rc ns ia yt
li r m d c r . uy o vitd . vae o e o e n h s c m o o p rc o
o
defaudt Unie St t s t c us t s
r he td a e ,o a e he ubmison off s cli ,opa he t c r ki kba ks a
si
ale a ms t y alh a e c c , nd
co piac t c
ns r y o omm i he t ca e fa
t alh r r ud. The Cour s ntnce Dr Al r z t 30 y r '
t e e d . va e o
ea s
i ionme . The Elven h Cic tha afimed bot t conviton a t s nt nc Unie
mprs
nt
e t r ui s fr
h he
c i nd he e e e.
td

St e v Matos, F. 1 ( 1h Ci.201 .
ats . e 623 3d 350 1 t r 0)
No , f et Cour,i Dr Al r sPeii f W rtofHabe Cor . Dr Al r z
w be or he
t s . va ez' tton or i
as pus . va e
ca mst the c
li ha r ouns wasi fe i i f ii t fl a moton t r us t underi ne duet
el
ne f ctve n a lng o ie
i o ec e he
sg d
o
hi da e , itnaM or no' e pl
s ught r Crsi
e s m oyme a t De rm e ofJ tce agove m e ag nc wih
nt the pa t nt usi ,
m nt e y t
o rf t s vii a a t ne t tnum be i t t a .Se Atac d Or ni a i l
ve ory ubdi sons nd tor ys ha
r n he hous nds e t he ga z tona
Cha t TheCour not st tdurngt pende y oft sca e Crsi M or noha no i ve e
r.
t e ha i he
nc
hi s , itna
e
d nvol m nt
i t pr e uton ofDr Al r z,die ty,i r c l o o he wie.Crsi M or wasas i d
n he os c i
. va e r c l ndie ty r t r s
itna
eno
sgne
byt De rmentofJ tce' Or ni e CrmeUni, ch s e
he pa t
usi s ga z d i
t whi ubs quen l wa c
ty s ombi d wih t
ne t he
G a U ni t ty c s s i t Ce r lD it i tof Ca i om i She ne r a
ng
t o r a e n he nt a s r c
lf a.
ve ppea e i t Sout r
r d n he
he n
D it i t of Fl i norw as s a s g
s rc
orda,
he s i ned t a he lh c e f a c e i t Sout r D i ti t of
o
a t ar r ud as n he
he n s rc

Flrda.Sheha nota a ed i a ca e be or t unde sg
oi
s
ppe r n ny s f e he
r i ned.
l .LEGA L A NA LY SI
l
S

The i s i w he he t f iur t t l am oton t r c e a ount t i f c i as it nce
s ue s
t r he a l e o i e
i o e us m
s o nef e tve s s a

ofc
ouns l To e t bls i f ec i a s s a ofco el t Cour a i s t t o- r t s of
e.
s a i h ne f tve s i t nce
uns , he
t pple he w pa t e t

Stikandv.Wa hi on, U. 668, 7(1 4) TheSuprmeCour rc l r t aedt st t
rc l
s ngt 466 S. 68 98 .
e
te enty eiert hi es

i fa lrv Co pe , 01 W L9 2 9( a . , 01 ) Is i :s'ep ro ma c p o go S ika d
n je . o r2 2
3 01 M r21 2 2 . t ad tf e fr n e r n f tc ln
-h

r q rsa d fn a tt s w th tc u s lsrp e e tto f l b lw a o j cie sa d r o
e uie ee d n o ho ta o n e' e r s nain el eo n b e tv tn a d f
r ao a ln s .' alr 2 2 W L 9 2 9 a * (ii Hi v Lo k a t 4 4U. 5 , 7( 9 5
e s n be e s' f je , 01
'
3 01 , t 5 ctng l . c h r, 7 S. 2 5 1 8 )
l
a d q oig Src l d 4 6 U. a 6 8 .To e tbls t s c nd p r o t ts,p eu ie a
n u tn tikan , 6 S. t 8 )
sa ih he e o a t f he e t rj dc ,
de e ntm us Ss
f nda
t çhow t tt r i a r a ona epr biiy t t butf couns lsunpr es i
ha he e s e s bl oba lt ha,
or
e'
of sonal

efr ,her uloft pr ee ngwoul ha be ndifrnt'f , 2W L 93201 a * ( i
fo st es t he oc di
d ve e fee .'#.201
9, t 5 quotng

Stikand, U. a 694) Theis i t sc ei whehe co elsfiur t fl amotont
rc l 466 S. t .
sue n hi as s t r uns ' al e o ie
i o
r c ewoul mee t ssa r f i fe tveas it nc ofc
e us
d
t hi tnda d or ne f c i
ssa e ouns l The Cour fndsi doe no
e.
ti t s t

me th sa d r a f d rla o u iil iq lfc to i ce rh t e u a wo l n t a eb e
e te tn ad s e ea lw nj dca ds uaiiain s la ta rc s l ud o h v e n
a opra ei t sc s
ppr it n hi a e.
A . St i k and sPe f m a e Pr
rc l
r or nc ong

To d tr n wheh r t o n e' rp e e tto fl beo a o j cie sa d r o
eemie
te i u s l e r s nain el lw n b e tv tn ad f
c
s
ra ona ene s't Cour e mi rc allw.Twofdealsaues 28U. C. 455a 1
e s bl s , he
'
t xa nes e us a
e r ttt ,
S. jj
nd 44,

g v r rc s l n c u t mu t o tu te i r matra.Ra v Eq f If r t nS r s,
o en e u a a d o rs s c nsr e h m npa i e i y . u ax no mai e v .
o
L C, 0 9W L 9 7 3 * ( 1hCi. rl1 , 0 9 .Un e t e esaue ,u g saeprs me
L 20
7 31 , 3 1 t r Ap i 3 2 0 ) d r h s tt tsj d e r e u d
t b i a t l n t mo a t e r t eb r e o d mo tai ga o j cieyr a o a l b ss o
o e mp ri a d he v n b as h u d n f e nsr tn n b e tv l e s n b e a i f r
a
q eto igtej d esi ril y rp v fx c O hc o h Pr sd nt 1 4F. p . d3 3
u sinn h u g ' mpatai .T ip . e . f e fte e ie , 0 Su p 2 0, 4
t
( D. 2000 . 28U. C. 455( ()r rsaUniedSt esJ
D. C. )
S. j b)5 equie
t at udget rcus i a' ro wihi
o e e f ' sn t n
pe

tet idd ge o r lto s i t gh j d e . .sk o b tej dg t h v a itr s t t o l
h hr e r e f eain hp o t e u g l . i n wn y h u e o a e n ne etha c ud

be s t tal af td by t outome oft pr e ngll'M or ge r ly,s ci 455()
ubsanily fece
he c
he oc edi .' e ne al e ton
a

rq ie ad src j dg t r c s 'na yp o e d n i wh c hsi ril ymih r a o a l b
e ur s ititu e o e u e ' n r c e i g n ih i mpatai g t e s n by e
i
t
q eto e '28U. C. 4 5 a .
u sin d.
'
S. j 5 ()
Fe a c t ha a yz dt is oft efe tofada e 'empl ym e i t con e
der l ours ve nal e he s ue he f c
ughtrs
o nt n he t xt

ofwhehert rcus unde et rjj455and 1 Routney,c t have fund t taDitit
t oe e
r ihe
44.
i l ours
o ha
src

J d es a g trs mpo me t i n t r vd ara o a eb ss oq eto t e u g 'i a t lt.
u g 'd u he 'e ly n dd o p o ie e s n bl a it u sin h j d es mp ri i
ay
N Am. .o Lt an al I s, . h 3 4Fe Ap x. 8 , 8 ( t Ci. 0 )(i dn ta
Co f r # dHe t n .v Ho , 3 d. p 5 6 5 9 4h r 20 9 fn ig h t
h
j d esd u h e'p os e tv e o me t t lw fln rp e e tn ap ryi ac s i ' o hn
u g ' a g tr r p ci e mply n wih a i e rs n ig at n a e s ' t ig
s
n
n
mor t n t s tof' g y tnuouss c ai t tfist me i rcus l'. 'El oyme
e ha he or hihl e
pe ulton ha al o rt e a.) ' mpl nt
' l

rlto s i b t e ap ry a d aj d ess n o d u h e d e n tpe s n c siaeaj d es
eain hp ewe n a t n u g ' o r a g tr o s o r e e e stt u g '
diq iiai ' I r Kans sPub.Emplye sRetr me Sys,85F. 1 1 ( h
s ualfc ton. n e
a
o e ie nt .
3d 353, 364 8t

Ci. 9 6 .l I r KPERS,h EihhCic i atr daj d e sd cso no t r c s wh nhs
r19 ) n n e
t e g t r ut fime u g ' e iin t o e u e e i
da t ra e e a empl ymentofe fom a l fr ,whih r pr entd a pa t i t a ton
ugh e cc pt d n
o
fr r
aw im
c e es e
ry n he c i

b f r hm.l a fr n ted cso ,heEi hhCic i n tdt a t ej dg ' d u he wa n t
eo e i n fimi g h e iin t g t rut o e h t h u e s a g tr s o
i ved i t c s and wa a s a i d as oc ae wih ta tonale pl e be ft s h t ts
nvol n he a e
s alre s i t t r dii
m oye neis uc ha he
woul notbes t ntal be itd byt o c eoft ca e.1 , F. at1
d
ubsa i ly nefte
he ut om
he s d. 85 3d 364;sw #e/Te .
' / l

Co.v Fe Commc'sComm ' 1 F. 520,522( hCi.1 .
. d.
n
n, 53 3d
8t r 998)

Re u a i as n t uo t al rq rdwh r t e u g ' c idi e o e b ap ryt
c s ls lo o a tmai ly e uie ee h j d e s hl s mply d y a t o
c
t diput I ,1 F.da 522( i Dat e,nc v He etpac 4 Co.941F2d8 871
he s e. d 53 3 t quotng agat l . . wlt- kar
,
64,

( t Ci.1 91) ( lig t a ato g j d ess n p riiae i a p o i-h rngpln o te
9h r 9 ), hodn h t lh u h u g ' o a t p td n r fts ai a f h
c
de e
f ndan Hewlt- ka d,Co.neihe hi fna a i e e tnorhi e pl e sa uswoul be
t
etpac r
, t r s i ncil nt r s
s m oym nt t t
d

afe tdbyt r oltonoft ltgainbef ehi ft r.I t c e ofadaughe wor ng
fce
he es ui
he ii to or s ahe) n he ontxt
tr ki
i a l r gove m e ala nc i a dif r tdi ti tt n t J
n a ge
m nt ge y n
f e en s r c ha he udge, he a gum ent f ar us lof
t r
s or ec a
a Pa e J
r nt udge a C C Wea r
r ven
ke .

M i uloft spr ce nt t sCour c
ndf
hi e de , hi
t nnno c udet tSt c l spe f ma epr
t oncl ha rik and' ror nc ong

i m e on t sis off iur t r s t J et r c e. TheJ
s t hi s ue al e o eque t he udg o e us
udge' da ersempl
s ught '
oyme
nt
a a a t ne wiht De t
s n tor y t he parment J tc i W as ngt DC i asas lre empl yee Shewa
of us ie n
hi on, s
aa id
o .
s
no a a1i vedi t pr ec i oft sc s , wa t Or niedCrm eGa Uni i ve
t t 1 nvol n he os uton hi a e nor s he ga z
i / ng t nvol d.
Att tm eoft sti l t J
he i
hi ra , he udge' daugh e wasas i d t ti wor i t Ce r lDititof
s
tr
sgne o ral k n he nta src
Calf i M or ove , he D e m entofJ tc e pl per onne i t t a a ha o
iom a.
e rt
pm
usi e m oys s
l n he hous nds nd s ver

fry s b i so s Su ey,a i o me ,r a o a l o s r e wo d n t d u t te j d es
o t u dviin . rl n nfr d e s n be b e v r ul o o b h u g '
i rilt es ci l whe ea he e, def nda wa a te a t ot rconvit dwihDr
mpa ta iy, pe aly
r s r one e nt s cquitd nd he he
ce t .
Al r zs nt nc d wihi t g delnes . va e wa t onl def nda s ntnc d a
va e e e e t n he ui i .Dr Al r z s he y e nt e e e bovet
he
g de i sf t r as saed i ope Co ta l tra fnne by t Elve h Cic tCour of
ui lne or he e ons t t n n ur nd ae fi d he e nt r ui
t
Appe s Unie St e v M atos 623 F. a 1 0. To puti bl l i t Cour we er quied
al. td ats . e ,
3d t 35
t unty, f he
t r e r
t r c e i t s ca e due t Cr s i M or no' em pl ym e a t D e t ent of J tc i
o e us n hi s
o i tna
e s
o nt t he parm
usi e n

W a hn tn DC,h Co r wo db rq ie t rc s i al rmi a p o e u ins S ud ewh
s igo , te u t ul e e u rd o e u e n lc i n l r s c to . t g o
Aj
c nnot e c e t r m an i
a
be xpe t d o e i mpari lhr hti a ma tr s h a t ss dnot sti e
ta t oug rvil te s uc s hi houl
be itng ven
whe hi f m iy i unafeced. I r Nat1 Uni FieI .Co. 839 F. 1
n sa l s
f t 'n e
'
on r ns
,
2d 230.
H a ng f
vi ound t r us lw a notwar a ed i t sca e t f l e oft i co el o m ove
hat ec a s
r nt n hi s , he aiur
ral uns t
f r cus ca
or e al nnotbe co i r d é nef e tve a s s a e of couns . Couns l s f iur t fl a
ns de e i f c i s i t nc
i
el'
'
e ' a l e o ie

mo int rc s ddn tflb lw a o j ciesa d r o ra o a e e s Th rmanngcams
to o e u e i o al eo n b e tv tn ad f e s n bln s . e e ii li

wihi t Pe ii wil r f r dt M a sr t J
t n he tton lbe e ere o gita e udgeAlci M . a Re st is aRe t nd
i a Ot zo- ye o s ue
por a
Re m enda i
com
ton.

D N A O D RDiCabraMin,liats U aoAr,02
O E ND R EE n hmest mi od,i dyfpi21.
Fr h
l
F

Copi spr de t
e ovi d o:

Couns ofRec d
el
or

E
A . OREN O
M
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U