Peavy v. Carnival Corporation et al
Filing
40
ORDER granting 7 Motion to Dismiss( Amended Pleadings due by 11/14/2012.); denying as moot 31 Motion for Hearing Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/25/2012. (yha)
!
U N I ED STA TES DI
T
STR I C O U R T
CT
SO UT H ER N D I RI T O F FLO R I
ST C
DA
(
CA SE:1: 2- v1 c 20782- S
PA
7
(
J
OHN M .PEAV Y ,
Pli if
antf ,
(
t
t
E
vs
.
.
(
CARNI
VAL CORPORATI ,
ON
JOHN POR TER , . . a
R N , nd
VA L VA LEN CI ,M . .
A
D,
)
'
)
De e
f ndan s
t.
t
(
.
/
!
O RD ER G R AN TI G DEFEND A N T
N
CA R NI AL CO RPO M TI N ' M O TI N TO D I I
V
O S
O
SM SS
J
ë
i
Thi m a t i be or t Cour on Def nda Ca ni lCor r ton' M oton t D i m i s
s ter s f e he
t
e nt r va
po a i s
i o s s
:
1
)
Plitf sCo litg 7 lPl i ifJol M Peavy slpped and f lw hieapass ngeron a
an if mp an DE- 1 antf m
i
el
l
e
f
T
cuies powne a ope ae b Deenda Ca ni Cor ai tt nAva'l Pe s
r s hi
d nd r td y f nt r val porton lca i l'. avy ought
)
.
.
)
;
m e c lca ebyt s p- r nure,J hn Po tr a dodor ValVae i Pea fl a
di a r
he hi boa d s o
re , nd
,
lnc a. vy ied
'
@
.
.
c
ompl i agans Ca ni l Valnci and Pore .Ca ni movest dimi sCount l,11 a
ant i t r va , e a,
tr r val
o s s
s 1 1, nd
)
1 .
V
t
Fo terao sstfrhb lw,h moint ds s i ga tdwihpeu iea t Co n
rh e s n e ot eo te to o imis s rne t rj dc s o u t
1 a wih l a t r pl a a t Co sl1a I i s fcintf c sexitt s ppor t t ore
1 nd t e ve o e e d s o unt I nd V f ufi e a t s o u
t he he i s
.
t
)
J
ofa r nta nc a ne i en hi i a r t nton,r pec i l .
ppa e ge y nd glg t r ng nd e e i es tve y
:
1.
Background Fact
s
)
,
;
'
A c di t t Com pl i ,Pe vy w a a pas e r a r Ca i l s c i e s p on or
cor ng o he
a nt a
s
s nge boa d m va ' nls hi
a
boutSe e be 27, 0 w he he s i d a f l on t s p' Li Dec . Compl, 9 (
pt m r 201
n
lppe nd e l he hi s do
k
.! DE-
y
i
)
'
à
)Pli ifmove f orlagume ont moton ( 31.Tha motoni de e a
antf
d or a r nt he i DE- )
t i s nid s
m oot.
'
.
'
F
t
.
.
)
-
(
1
1.Pe vywe t t s p' i i r a desrbe t a i ntt Pore,whos me ur nt
1 a
nt o he hi s nfnnay nd ci d he ccde o tr
e as eme
i
(
o P a yslf k e , ihwa ij r d wa 15ic e lr e t a h srg tk e .I .! 1
f e v ' e t n e wh c s nu e , s . n h s ag r h n i ih n e d, 0.
;
Pe v alg st td s iece rsg so p i a dij r ,h s i ' d co ddn t e wiho
a y le e ha e pt la in f an n nu y te h p s o tr i o me t t r
t
(
e m i Pe vy. 1 l t d,Pe vy a l ges Po trt l hi t a t eewa n sro sij r a d
xa ne a
d. ns ea
a le , re od m h t h r s o e iu nu y n
.
)
.
ta Pe v c udc niu t ec us a da pyiet t eijle k e .1 .! 1 .P a ya srs
h t a y o l o t e h r ie n p l c o h n t d n e d, 1 e v se t
n
r
C
t a sv r l e sa trhsij r , i lgg v wa wh l h wa wakn 1 , 1 .P a y
h t e e a we k fe i n u y h s e a e y ie e s lig. d ! 3 e v
v stda o to dcs r o a dla dt a heh dij rd hsq a rc p tnd na dk e ,
iie n rh pe i u ge n n e me h t a nu e i u d ie s e o n n e
è
r qui i s ge y a r ha lt ton. 1
e r ng ur r nd e biia i
d.
.
'
(
Pea fld t sxvy ie he i countc pl nton Fe u y27, 201 The Compl i a lge f ur
om ai
br ar
2.
ant le s o
1
(
t
.
'
y
c sa i tCa ni :Coun lf ne i nc Count1 f vi a i usla lt f t ac sof
ount gans r val
t or glge e;
1 or c ro ibiiy or he t
'
Va e i a Po trbas o a t lag y;CountIIf vi a i la lt f t ne i nc of
l nca nd re
ed n cua enc
I or c rous ibiiy or he glge e
)
T
t
Va e i a Po trbas on a r nta ncy;a Coun I f neglge hii a r t nton.
l nca nd re
ed
ppa e ge
nd
t V or
i nt rng nd e e i
(
)
'
j
Ca ni lm o st di m i sCount I ,11 a l .
z va ve o s s
s l 1, nd V
)
l.
I
(
t
:
Le St
gal andar
d
t
'
A pary m a m ove t Cour t di m i s a c a m f ç aiur t s a e a cl m upon w hi h
t y
he
t o s s l i or s l e o t t
f
ai
c
r i c nbegrntd. Fe R.Ci P.1 b)6) s eI r Sout as Bankig Cor ,69F.d
elef a
a e ' d. v. 2( ( ; e n e he t
'
n
p.
3
(
.
:
j
;
.
'
1 9,1551( 1hCi.1 .Suc amoin doe no decdewhehe t pli ifwiluli tl
53
1 t r 995) h
to
s t i
t r he antf l tmaey
pr vai o t m e is buti t adwhe he s h pl i ifhaspr ry sa e a ca m a s d
e l n he rt,
nse
t r uc antf
ope l t t d li nd houl
(
:
.
t r f r bepe m itd t ofe e de ei s ppor t e .Br
he e o e
r te o f r vi nc n u
t her of andtv Bas e t 69 F. 1
.
s t,
3d 539,
è
.
1 ( lhCi.1 ) Tos vi amotont dimis ac ai mus c anale to
550 1 t r 995 . ur ve
i o s s , ompl nt t onti lgains
(
a desdt e c maeil lme tç e esr t s sanarc v r u d rsmeva elg l
d rse o a h tra ee n s c say o u ti e o ey n e o ibl e a
n
)
J
j
.
t or ' Roev Awar WomanCt. Choi ,I .253F. 678,684( 1hCi.2001.Thi
he y.'
.
e
rfor ce nc,
3d
1t r
) s
!
'
t
2
l
.
i
7
è
)
k
(
.
:
)
(
i
m a era c n be eiherdie tori er nta , s e i a 683,buti m us be f t l BelAt. Co p.v
t il a
t
rc
nf e i l e d t
t t acua . l l r .
'
Twombl l S.Ct 1 1 (
y, 27
. 955, 965 2007) s aloRoe 253F. a 683.Thus Sgl l or
; ee s
,
3d t
,fconcus y
i
è
alg to s u warne d d cin o fcso lg lc n lso smaq rdnga fcswi n t
le ain , n ra td e u to s f at r e a o cu in suea i s a t l o
l
t
t
.
'
eve
s s al'
y, 27 Ct t 965. Pl adi t tç r no m or t n co l i ,
e ngs ha d e
a
e ha nc us ons
Pr ntdi m i s .' Twom bl 1 S. . a 1
ar note ildt t asumptonoftuhglt ymus bes pporedb f t algai .'
e ntte o he s i
r t , he
'
t u t y acual le tons'
i
J
As c o v I b l 1 9 S Ct 1 3 ,1 5 ( 0 9 . Fial, e ac mp an i c aln e u d r
h r? . q a, 2 . . 9 7 9 0 2 0 ) n ly wh n o lit s h le g d n e
Rul 1 b)6 , c twilpr umet ta1welpl de ale tonsaetuea viw t
e 2( () a our l es ha l l- ea d lgai r r nd e he
pl a ngsi t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl i if Ame c Unie L( l .Co. . t z,
e di
n he i
t a a e o he a ntf .
rian td # ns v Mari
ne
q
:
y
'
j
y
è
r
480F. 1 1 ( 1h Ci.
3d 043, 066 1 t r 2007)
.
11
1.
)
:
D i c s on
s us i
)
A.
Count1 i Dimis d wih Prj c .
1 s s se t eudie
Coun 1 alege t tCa i li la e f V a e i a Por e ' ne i nc u ra t y
t 1 l s ha m va s i bl or l nc a nd
t r s glge e nde heor
:
ofvia i la lt ba e on a t la nc Ca ni ls e t dim ist scli on t g ot
c rous ibiiy s d
c ua ge y. r va e ks o s s hi a m
he r md
t
t a amao i o c u t h verj ce h li gas io e l bl u d ra yte r o r s n e t
h t j rt f o rs a ee td od n hp wn r i e n e n h o y f epo d a
y
a
s pe i f t neglge eofm e c pe s
u ror or he
i nc
dial r onnel Bar t v. S Be mu St ,8 F.2d 1
. beta S/ r da ar 48
364,
13 ( hCi.1 2 s eCar valCor v Caril,95 So. 461( a 2007)(olo ng
71 5t r 988); e
ni
p. . lse 3 2d
Fl.
f lwi
y
Bar ta a ctng f r lc s shol ngt tas p owne i notvi a i l la ef t
bet nd ii ede a a e
di ha hi
rs
c rousy ibl or he
t
'
medc lne i nc oft onboadphysca .Thi r ei pr mie ont fc t tc us lnes
ia glge e he
r
iin) s ul s e s d he a t ha r ie i
i a c r o rt hi y pe s lz doc or pa i ntr a i hi ,' a w e la t S
û ck ontol ve he ghl r ona i ed t - te el tons p ' s l s he t ri e
l
expe ts
)
:'
)
:
:
(
.
2 Fed a m a ii e 1 co r st s t ntve i s s i t sc e See Everet v.
er l rtm aw nt ol he ubs a i s ue n hi as .
t
Car v Cr s Li s 91 F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.1 (ç nwhe t pa tesalge
nial uie ne , 2 2d 355, 358 1 t r 990) t
Eve
n he ri le
dvest o ctz n hi a t eba i o t ef d rlc u t j rs ito .i teij r o c re o
i riy f iie s p s h ss f h e ea o r' u idcin,. h nu y c u rd n
s
.f
na ga ewaes fdealmartmelw govens..'.
vi bl tr, e r
ii a
r ..'
)
è
'
.
f
E
3
l
)
.
'
:
.
f
;
.
t s r iea docori hi orhe pr c i ofmedi ne.' Sut r v Car v Cor ., 2007 U.
o upe v s
t n s
r a tce
ci ' e . ni al p
S.
Dit LEXI 95893,* 9( D.Fl 2007)(ntma cttonsomit ;s ealoBar ta, 848
s.
S
8- S. a.
i e l iai
ted) e s
bet
F. a 1 (çti pur s sr t ase tt tas p' matri c pa eofçupe vsng'he
2d t 371 $ s e ophity o sr ha hi s se s a bl s r ii t
l
me ia te t n rn e e b (no b ad ph iin.)
dc l rame t e d r d y a n o r l ysca '
'
Pe v e sn il t g steCo r t a o tami rt ve t a rj csBa b t a d
a y se tal l e h u to d p
yr
no i iw h t ee t r et n
y
a
i t a hol t ta s powne ma behel vi a i l la ef t neglge ofonboa d
nse d ds ha hi
r y
d c rousy ibl or he
i nce
r
m e c pe s
di al r onne . I a yi m a ii e l w , t cour m us f l t prnc pl s ofha m ony
l3 n ppl ng rtm a he
t t olow he i i e
r
a unior iy.SeeDoev Celbrt Cr s s I . 3 F. 8 902 ( 1hCi.
nd f m t
. e iy uie , nc, 94 3d 91,
1 t r 2004 (ihe
) çt
p p o ebe idtee ec s o t i Co r' a miat j rs ito i t p o d f rt eu io
u s hn h x r ie f hs u t d r l u idcin s o r vie o h n fnn
s
y
applcai ofg r maii lw.) na cor no wiht s prncpls t Cou trafsms
i ton eneal rtme a ' .I c da e t he e i i e ,he r e tr
'
Bar t ast s tld l w a hol t tCa ni ma notbehel vi rousy la ef Po tr
beta he e te a nd ds ha r val y
d ca i l ibl or re
a V a enc a' aleg m e ca ne i ne unde a t or ofa t a nc . Se al Ri e v
nd l i s l ed di l glge e
r he y
c ual ge y e so dly .
NCL ( amas Lt , F.Supp.2 1 1 ( D. a. 0)(iti welr ogni dt ta
Bah ) d.824
4 355, 362 S. Fl 201 C s l ec ze ha
l
c uielnec nno bevi a i usy la ef t ne i nceofiss p' doct i t ca ea
r s i a t
c ro l ibl or he glge
t hi s
or n he r nd
te t n o p se e s' .Ac o dngy, u t1 i ds se wi p eu ie
rame t f a sng r.) c r i l Co n 1 s imisd t rj dc .
'
h
B.
Countlli Dimis d W ihoutPr j c .
l s s se t
e udie
Cou I Ii a c ai f vi a i la lt f t ne i nc ofVal nci a Po t rbas d
nt l s l m or c r ous i biiy or he glge e
e a nd r e
e
ona rnta nc Appae a nc i esa ihe whee:( )t alge prncpalma ss
ppae ge y.
rnt ge y s tbls d r 1 he le d i i
ke ome
s tofm a f t ton c usng a t r pa t t bele t tt a lge a ntha a ho iy t ac f
or
niesai a i
hid ry o ive ha he le d ge
d ut rt o t or
t be ttoft prnci l ( t t r pary'beifwa r as bl a ( t t r pat
he nei he i pa; 2) he hid t s le s e ona e; nd 3) he hid ry
See eg. N i t s v. e i an Pr s de L i s Lt , 188F. pp. 9( D. l 1
, . , e e Am r c
e i nt ne d
Su 21 N. Ca. 959)
;
Elz et Fail y v Car v Co p. 1 A .M . 1 ( D. a. 993) Hu ly v Car v
iab h r e . ni al r , 993
C. 633 S. Fl 1 ; nte . nial
Cor ,307F. p.2d 1 ( D. a.2004 .
p.
Sup
372 S. Fl
)
4
r a ona y a edon s h beleft hi orhe derme . Se Gol hv NCL (
e s bl ct
uc
i o s
r ti nt e dbac .
Bahamas L/f,
) f
2 0 W L 3 8 7 5 a *3 ( D. a 2 0 ) A pan ifma se t h l ac us ln vc ro sy
06
7 0 0 , t S. Fl. 0 6 . litf y e k o o d r ie i e iaiu l
la e unde a t r ofa r nta nc . Se Sut r 2007 U . D it LEX I 95893 a *1 1 .
i bl
r heo y ppa e ge y
e e,
S. s ,
S
t 4- 5
He e,Pea ha f ie t sa ea c am f Ca i lsvi rousla lt ba e on t
r
vy s al d o tt l i or m va ' ca i ibiiy s d he
m e c sa fsa r age y. Pea a lgest tCa ni he d Vae a a Pore asis
dial tf ppa ent nc
vy le ha r val l lnci nd tr t
e o e sb c u eVae caa P re ( )p o i e ters r ie i Ca v lsifr r ; 2
mply e e a s ln i nd o tr 1 r v d d h i e vc s n mia ' n imay ( )
wor unior a prs rbedbyCar va,a ( )wor ba sorna t i ntf ng
e f ms s e ci
ni l nd 3 e dge
me ags de iyi
t m s ve a Ca ni ' e pl ee . Compl, 1 Howe r t Compl ntc ansno f t
he el s s r vals m oy s
.! 9.
ve ,he
ai onti
acual
aleg ton t s
l a i o uppor t concuso t tt em a f t tonsl Pe vy t belevet tVa e i
t he
l i n ha hes niesa i ed a o i ha l nca
a Pore we e a horz d t a tf t be ttofCa i l o t ti w a r s bl f hi t
nd tr r ut i e o c or he nei
m va , r ha t s ea ona e or m o
a tont sbe ift hi derme .Be aus Pea f ist pl d f t s
c
hi le o s ti nt c e vy a l o ea ads o uppor acli ba e on
t am s d
appa e age y,Count1 1i di m i s d. I t e ntt e a e f c st s
r nt nc
l s s s e n he ve her r a t o uppor s h a c a m , t
t uc
l i he
dim is i wih l a t r pla
s s al s t e ve o e e d.
C.
Co ntI i Dimis d W iho Pr j ie
u V s s s e t ut e ud c .
Ca ni lha a s m ove t dim isCountI f f iur t pl d f c st s ppo ta
r va s lo
do s s
V or a l e o ea a t o u r
ne i nthii cli Pe vy a ee wih Ca ni lt tt f t lalegai s
glge rng a m. a gr s t r va ha he acua l tons uppori Count
tng
I aei s fiin a dr q ssla t a n t c mpan a t ti c u t( 1 , p.1 1 1
V r n u fce t n e uet e ve o me d he o lit s o h s o n DE- 7 p 4- 5 .
Upo r e oft Co pl i , heCo ta s ag e s The e or C o I i di m i s d w ih
n eviw
he m ant t
ur lo r e .
r f e, unt V s s s e t
la t r pl a i s fcen f c st e s t s
e ve o e e d f ufi i t a t o xit o uppor ane i nthii cai .
t glge rng l m
U pon c i r ton,i i he e
ons de a i t s r by
ORDERED t t
ha
1.
Defnda Cani lCor ai sM otont DimisPli if'Compli (
e nt r va porton' i o s s antfs
ant DE-
7 i GRANTED.
1s
2.
Co n 1 i DI M I SED wi p eu ie
u t1s S S
t rj d c .
h
3.
Cou 1Ii DI I
nt I s SM SSED wih l vet r pl d.
t ea o e ea
4.
Cot tI i D I I
m V s SM SSED w ih l ave t r pl d.
t e
o e ea
5.
M y Ame
nded Compl i mus be fl no lt rt n Nove be 14, 201
ant t ied a e ha
m r
2.
6.
Pli ifsRe tfrOr Ar me ( 31 i DENI a M OOT
antf
ques o al gu nt DE- 1 s
ED s
.
*
D ON E A N D O RD ERED i M i m i Flr a ti
n a , oi ,hs d yof tb r2 2.
d xs a Oco e, 01
<'
PATRI A A.SE1 Z
CI
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
CC'
Al c
l ouns lofr or
e
ec d
6
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?