Navarro v. BJ Retreader Tires, Inc. et al

Filing 20

ORDER DENYING 16 MOTION for Reconsideration re 14 Order on Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/19/2012. (mmz)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
C as N um be 1 21
e
r: 2- 005- V- O R EN O
CI M
M I EL A . A VA RRO ,
GU
N
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

BJRETREADER TI
RES I
NC.a LORENZO
nd
BUI
TRON ,i vi l
ndi dualy,
Def nda s
e nt .

ORDER DENYI DEFENDANTS'M O TI TO RECONSI
NG
ON
DER ORDER DENYI
NG
D EFEN DA N TS'M O TI N T O D I I C O UN T I
O
SM SS
V
THI CAUSE ca be or t Co t upon t Def nt 'Cons i t M oton t
S
me f e he ur
he
enda s
oldaed
i o
Re i Or rDe ng M oton t Dim isCou I an M oton t Sti Pl ntf Res e
consder de nyi
i o s s
nt V d
i o rke ai ifs pons

t Mo int Dimisf rF a dUp nt eCo r ( E. .1 ) fldo Ju 5 20 2
o to o s s o r u o h u tD. No 6 , ie n ne . 1 .
TheDef nt ha a gue t CountI s dbedim is dbe us i ne rr ce ve t
enda s ve r d hat
V houl
s s e ca e t ve e i d he
notc lte t tPli ifwa r quiedt s nd t m bef e tlng acl m u
ie e tr ha antf s e r o e he
or ii
ai nderFl St .
a. at

j448. 1 6)a ( 11.
1 0( ()20 )Howe rt Pli ifalgest ipr de Def ntwihnotc a ha
ve ,he antf le hatt ovi d enda t ie nd s
fld ac oft sa lge notc wiht cour.' he consde i am otont dim isunde Rul
ie opy hi le d ie t he
t' n
W
i rng
i o s s
r e

1 b)6)oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr e e,t c tmus a ce al oft pl ntf
2( (
he de a
es
vi oc dur he our
t c pt 1 he ai ips
al gai astueand co tuet
le tons r
nsr hem i t lghtm os f or e t t pli if'Gome r Ke n,
n he i
t av abl o he a ntf.
'
z . r

201 W L 1 86*1( D. a. a . zol t tngPil v M c
2
0691
S. Fl M r29, zlcii eage . connel, 6F.d 1 1 4
l51 3 282, 28
( 1hCi.
1 t r 2008).'nt i tntc e,heCourmus ac e t aleg i oft Compli astu
)' he nsa as t
l
t t c pt he l atons he
ant r e
a t Pl n if a l ge t tt y ha pe f r e a lc tonspr c ntt flng a a ton unde
nd he ai t f s le ha he ve r o m d 1 ondii
e ede o ii n c i
r

t eF oi aM ii m W a eAc .Me av Ag- rpr du e I c, 0 W L2 9 2 4*1 ( . F a
h lrd nmu
g t' s . Ma t o c ,n .20 8
'
7 0 2 1 M D. l .
J y 18,
ul 2008)
.
Be us t Pli ifdiput t alegai t ti f ie t compl wih t saut ' notc
ca e he antf s es he l ton ha t al d o
y t he t t es ie

pr son,hem i m um wag cai c r tbedim is un i t Pl ntf ha ha a opporuniy
ovii t
ni
e l m a mo
s s ed tl he ai if s d n
t t

t pr dee denc ofiscompla e.'Iti sile l i t dicoveyperod, ndt Def nt
o ovi vi e t
inc ' ) s tl ary n he s r i a he enda s
(
ha no de i i l demonsr t dt tt Pl ntf c nnotpr c
ve t c svey
ta e ha he ai if a
ove ompla wiht pr s tnotc
ince t he e-ui ie

(ore mpl t Pli ifmaybea et e gei dic r oft Def nt'ec dst obt n
f xa e,he antf
bl o nga n s ovey he enda sr or o ai
a c y oft pr s tnotc algedl sntt t Dee ntl'Cury v.Hi S i Famiy
op
he e-ui ie le y e o he fnda s . r
'
gh prngs
l

Pr tc Clni and Di si Ct.l . 2008 W L 51
acie i c
agno s r nc,
57683 #1 ( D.Fl De 9,2008) l t
0 N. a. c.
. f he
Pli ifi unabl t pr vi s h e de eoft De e ntsr ei oft notc t De e nt
antf s
e o o de uc vi nc
he f nda ' ec pt he i e, he f nda

ma b a l t o ti s mmayj d me ta an tt ePli tf o t scam.' twi o tmo e
y e be o b an u r u g n g i s h anif n hi li '
Ye t u r
h
e de e orafi vis t Pl i ifsde a oft De enda s r quese a s i t tpr - ui
vi nc
fda t , he antf
ni l he f nt' e t d dmi sons ha e s t

n tc h dn t e np o i e i n te o g t p e e tteg a to s mma yj d me ta an tte
oie a o b e r v d d s o n u h o rv n h r n f u r u g n g is h
Pl i if' I
a ntf . d.
'

THE COURT ha c i r d t m o i a t pe tne pori oft r c d, ndbeng
s onsde e he ton nd he ri nt tons he e or a
i
ot ie f l a s d i t pr s ,ti
hem s uly dvie n he emies i s
ADJUDGED t tt m o i i DENI .
ha he ton s
ED

D ON E AN D O RD ERED i Cham be s a M i m i Fl i t
n
r t a , orda, hi

FEDE
CH l
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Col s lofRe r
m e
co d
-

2-

da ofJ
y
une,201
2.

. O REN O
I
TED STATES D I
STRI J GE
CT UD