HTC Leleu Family Trust v. Piper Aircraft, Inc.
Filing
29
ORDER GRANTING 13 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 10/17/2012. (rg1)
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Cas No.1 1 c 21l1 KM M
e
: 2- v- 8-
HTC LELEU FAM I TRUST,
LY
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.
PI
PER A I
RCRAFT, l C.
N ,
Def nt
enda .
/
ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI I
NG
S
ON
SM SS
THI CAUSE ca ebef et Co tu De e ntsM o i t
S
m
or he ur pon f nda ' ton
oDimis( No 1 )
s s ECF . 3 .
Plitf fldaRe pons ( No 1 )a dDee d n fldaRe l ( No 1 ) The M oton
anif ie
s e ECF
4 n f n a t ie
py ECF . 5
i
.
.
i now rpe f r viw . UPON CONSI
s
i or e e
DERATI oft M oton, t Res e t Re y t
ON
he
i he pons , he pl he
,
pe tne pori oft r cor , and be ng ot r s f l a s i t pr mies
ri nt tons he e d
i
he wie uly dvied n he e s
,
t s Cour
hi
t
e t r t f l ng Or .
n e s he olowi
der
L BACKGROUND l
Thi i a a ton a ii fom Pl i ifs pur ha e of a ar r f m a acur d by
s s n c i rsng r
antf
c s
n ic a t nuf t e
De e nt Pl i ifi atus e t ihe t
f nda . antf s r t sabls d mdera i a cor n
nd n c da
cewih t lwsofSout Afi .
t he a
h rca
De e nt i a co po aton or nied unde t lws of Del
f nda s
r ri
ga z
r he a
a r wih is prncpalpl e of
wa e t t i i
ac
busne s i Fl rda
i s n oi
.
Plc ( y) Lt (é a ' i a i enztona de lr of arr t
a o Pt
d. tP1co' s n nt ai l ae
)
icafs
m a ac ur by Def nda . Plc i or ni d undert lwsofSout Afi wih isprn
nuf t ed
e nt a o s ga ze
he a
h rca t t i c pal
i
plc ofb i si Sout Afia.
a e usnes n
h rc
'The f t he en ar tke f
acs r i e a n
r Pl ntf Co ai ( No.1) Def nts M oton t
om ai ips mpl nt ECF
Dim i s Pl ntf Res
enda '
i o
,
e nd
e nt s pl
f s s , ai i fs pons , a Def nda ' Re y. Al f t a e c tued i a lg mos
1 ac s r onsr
n i ht
t
a abl t Pl ntf .
vor e o ai i f
On Aprl23,2008, Pl ntf e e e i o an a e m e wih Pl o t pur ha
i
ai if nt r d nt
gr e nt t ac o c
s a Pi r
e
pe
M erdin ar r f m a a t e by De e nt The agr em ent
i a ic a t nuf c ur d
f nda .
e
,
wh c wa s be t t te
ih s u j c o h
a ova by t mana m e ofbot Def nda a Pl o s c fe t tt aic a twa t be
ppr l he
ge nt
h
e nt nd ac pe ii d ha he r r f s o
,
ne wih a sa r f cor wa r nt . The a ee nt howe r
w t tnda d a t y ra y
gr me ,
ve , wa neve a ove by eihe
s
r ppr d
t r
c
ompanyand ne rt e f c .
ve ook fe t
Afe l a ni ofPl ntf si e es i pur hasng a ai
tr e r ng
ai if ntr t n c i n r
c af,De e nti t He wi
r t f nda nvied r g
Til Co n lu Lee (i 1u' atu teo P an if t vii ism anuf ct i f ciiy i Ver
l r ei s lu t e ', r se f litf, o st t
o
Le )
a urng a lt n
o
Be h, Fl i . Def nda e e d t s i t ton be us i ha a h
ac
orda
e nt xt nde hi nvia i
ca e t d not
e Pi r M e i a
r pe
rdin
ar rf (heS rr f't wa t s modelt tPl ntf prvi l atmpt d t pur se.
icat t l caf ) hat s he nme
Ai
ha ai if e ousy te e o cha
On Novem be 1 , 2008,Le e viie Def nda ' f ciiy i Fl i i or rt
r 7
l u std
e nts a lt n orda n de o
e mi
xa ne
t Aic a t Durng hi vii, Lelu had dic sons a
he r r f.
i
s st
e
s us i
bout t Aic af wih s ve a
he r r t t e r l
r pr e ai s a ofi al of Def nt i udi J m e Bas De enda ' Pr i nt a
e es nt tve nd fci s
enda , ncl ng a s
s f nts esde nd
,
Chif Exe utve Of e . Pl ntf a lge t t Bas %e es l
e
c i
fc r
ai if le s ha
s txpr sy r pr e e t and pr s
e es nt d o
omied
Lelu t tt Aicr f woul gi Lelu ma yea soffyi
e ha he r a t
d ve e
ny r
l
ng s ts a ton. Compl, ! 1 On
a if c i '
'
.
6.
N o mbe 1 2008, a umn d ofiilof e t(hel fcil'unl ke t Aic at
ve r 8,
n r me fca Defndan t s i a' oc d he rr f and
of
)
a l d Le e t i pe t i. Le e aleg t tt Ofii l a fr e t t al ts gs wih t
lowe
l u o ns c t
l u l es ha he fc a fim d ha l çna
t ht
Aic a thad be c r t .' Compl, 1 TheOfkil he ga Lelu at ofDee nts
r rf
en oreced '
.! 7.
f a t n ve e our
fnda '
f eiiy. Durng t t , t Ofi als
a lt
i he our he fci howe Lelu a ope wi s c i a a l d L
d e n n ng e ton nd lowe e e t
lu o
i pe t c tu ton a s alng of t wi tnks Lelu a ke i t s m e met of
ns ct he onsr c i nd e i
he ng a .
e s d f he a
hod
s ai t nkswa us on t Aic a ta t Ofi a a wer d i t afim ai
e lng a
s ed he r r f nd he fcil ns e n he fr tve
.
aleg t tot rr pr enttve ofDe e ntCe es l
l es ha he e es a i s
f nda txpr sy
Pl ntf as
ai if lo
r pr s nt d t a pr ie Lelu t t
e e e e o nd om s d e ha
t Aicrf wasi ( e c ton, entr y wihoutdef ds, and t tno pr em shad arien
he r a t
n njw ondii
iel t
e
ha
obl
s
durng t c zs oft m a a urng pr s .
i he olr e he nuf ct i
oce s
' Compl, 1
'
.! 9.
Pli if s e nty pur ha e t Aic af a i was dei r d t Pl i if on
antf ubs que l
c s d he r r ' nd t
t
lve e o antf
De mbe 1 2008 i Ge son, Sout Afi The Pa tes
ce r 8,
n nnit
h rca.
ri , howe ,di noten e i o a
ver d
t r nt
wrten c r tf t s l oft Aic a t Pli ifal ge t tç hem a
it ontac or he ae he r r f. a ntf le s ha s
t
nage tofbot Pl c
men
h ao
a d ( fn nla p o e t s l o t eAic ata d t r b e trd it as l contactwih
n Dee da t p r v d he ae f h rr f n hee y n ee n o aes r
t
( an it a t etmeo d l r o teAic at' mpl !2 Plitf f rh ralge ta t e
Plitfl t h i f ei y f h rr f 'Co . ( 4. anif u te le s h t h
ve
,
.
t r of t c r ctwer e s ntaly t s
e ms he onta
e s e i l he ame as t tr of t
he e ms h
e ag ee e t pm c s t
r m nt o
ha e he
pr vi ar r f m a uf c tr d by De e nt Addii nal Lee a Pl i ifs rpr s nttve
e ous ic a t n a tle
f nda .
to ly, lu, s antf e e e ai ,
sgne aLi t d W a r nt a Pl o' ofi i Ge son
i d
mie
ra y t ac s fce n nuit
,
Sout Afia whi wa f wa de t
h rc
ch s or r d o
Def nt
enda .
Afe mi malus oft Aicr f, Lelu obs r e a f ll a unde t rg wi oft
tr ni
e he r a t e
e v d ue e k
r he i ht ng he
Aic a durng a ti on J r 1l 2009. I was s e nty dicove e t t a
rrh
i
lght
anua y ,
t
ubs que l s r d ha
ma at i e
nuf curng nor oc r d i t us of a s a a on t Aic
cure n he e
e lnt
he r
r ts wi a De e nts
af' ng t f nda '
f c lt Due t t s rous s oft lak, t Aic a tc d notbefown
a iiy.
o he e i ne s he e he r r f oul
l
.
Pli ifal st t
antf lege ha
i i me aey i or
t m di tl nf med Def nda of t de e a t a i was ca elng t agr e e
e nt
he f ct nd h t t
nc i he e m nt
.
Defnda r f ed t honor Pl ntf s r ques f r siuto of t pur ha e prc a
e nt e us o
ai if e t or e tt i n
he
c s
ie nd
c pe a i f t da
om ns ton or he mage i ured.
s nc r
On M a c 20,201 , Pli iffl t i t taci . Pli if a lgest tt f lla
rh
2 a ntf ied he nsan ton a ntf le
ha he ue e k
r uled fom Def nda ' e r s i t us of a s alnt whe De enda uns e s u l
es t r
e nts ror n he e
e a
n f nt ucc s f ly
a tm ptd t r parf ell a dic r d i t manuf c urng pr
te e o e i u e ks s ove e n he
at i
o
ce s Pl i ifcli st tatno
s . antf am ha
tm edi Def nto Plco inf m i ofany de ecsorr i a tmpt r ai t t f lS
i
d enda r a t or t
i
f t
epar te s eltng o he ue nnks
or t s l nt . Com pl ! 35. I is Co ai ,Pli if alge cli of fa i t
he ea a s'
'
.,
n t mpl nt antf le s ams rud n he
i e nt(
nduc me CountI;fa e c al nt(
) rudulnt once me Count1) neglge mi
1; i nt
se es ntto t
rpr e ain count
3
11;be c o c nr d ( u tl ;b e c o e prs war nis( u tV) a d a vi aton of
1) ra h f o ta Co n V) r a h f x e s ra te Co n ; n
ol i
t Ma
he gnus on- os A c , 1 U. C. 23016)(
s M s t 5 S. j
( CountVI.
)
I .LEGAL STANDARD
I
A moton t dim is f f iur t sa e a cli me el t t t s fcincy of t
i o s s or al e o tt
am
r y ess he ufi e
he
co pli t i doesnotde i t me isoft c e M ibu v.Unied Stt
m an; t
c de he rt he as .
l m
t
a es 734 F. 762,765
2d
,
( 1h Ci.1 8 ) On amoi nt ds s, t Courtmus acceptt f ct lalegatonsmstue
1t r 9 4.
to o imis he
t
he a ua l i
r
a co tu t c
nd nsr e he ompli i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pli if SEC v.ESM Gr
a nt n he i
t a a e o he antf .
p.s I ,
nc.
835 F. 27 , 272( 1hCi.1 ) $ s vi amotont dimis
2d 0
1 t r 988 . % ur ve
To
i o s s
,
a c pl i m us c ai
om a nt
t ont n
s fcintf t ma tr ac e e astue t itt a cai f r le t ti pl usbl on isf c '''
ufi e acual te , c pt d r , o sa e l m or ei f ha s a i e t a e
-
As r tv.I l 1 S. Ct 1
hc of
nba , 29
. 937,1 (
949 2009)( i Bel At. v.Twom bl 550 U . 544
quotng l l
v,
S.
,
5 0 (0 7 çf eplu iii sa d r i no a i t a ûr b bit rq rme t'butas f
7 2 0 :. t' a sb ly tn ad s t k n o p o a l y e uie n,
-h
t
i
ks or
mor t n a s e pos i lt t ta de e ntha a t d unlw f ly.' I l wher t we l
e ha
he r sbiiy ha
f nda
s ce
a u l ' d. ç
But
e he l
pla f t do notpe mi t cour t i e m or t n t me e pos i lt ofmico uc
e ded acs
r t he
t o nf r
e ha he r
sbiiy
s nd t
,
t
he
c
ompli ha aleg
ant s l ed buti ha not Shown' çha t plade i e il
t s
s
t t he e r s ntt
e t r i .' I a
d o elef'' d. t
1
950. A c
ompli mus as co an e
ant
t lo nt i nough f c s t i cae t
a t o ndi t he
pr e of t r quie
es nce
he e r d
elme s W at v. Fl I ' Uni ., 49 F. 1
e nt . ts
a. ntl v
5 3d 289,1 ( 1h Ci.2007 . Howe , ça
302 1 t r
)
ver ç )
g
pla ng t tofe s i f m ul c r cia i ofeeme sofa e us ofa i wilnotdo
e di ha f r a or ai e t ton
l nt
a e
cton l
.' l
' qba ,
' l
1 S. .a l ( tng Two y, 550U. a 555) Scl l oy algai unwarant d
29 Ct t 949 quoi
mbl
S. t . t oncus r le tons
g
r e
,
de uci ns o f c or lga concusons m a que a ng a f
d to
f at
e l
l i
s r di s
ac s wil no pr ve dim is .''
t l t e nt s s al
Oxf d As e M g .. Lt v.J ha i,297 F.3d 1 82,1 88( 1hCi.
or s t mt d. a rs
1 1 1 t r 2002)
.
4
1 1 ANALYSI
1.
S
De e ntsM oton s kst dim isCountIf fa i t i
f nda '
mt 1 or
i ee o s s
or r ud n he nduce ntzCot 1 f
me
,
fa e conc al nt3and Count1If ne i ntm ir pr e ai 4 De e nta guest t
r udulnt
e me ,
1 or glge
s e es nt ton.
f nda r
ha
t ee c u t s o d b d s se b c u e ( )te camsa eb re b Flrd ' e nom i l s
h s o ns h ul e imis d e a s 1 h li r ar d y o ias co c os
r l;()t ealg d misae n sa emeep fr a d ( )t e fa d alg to sae notpl
ue 2 h l e sttme t r r ufey; n 3 h r u l ai n r
e
e
ed
wih s fce pm iul rt t m e tt r quie e s of Fe r
t ufi int
c a iy o e he e r m nt
de
a Rue o Cii Pr c d r 9 b .
l l f vl o e u e ( )
SeeDef M ot t Dim is a 3. Thi Cour a e s se ch oft e a gument i tun
. .o s s, t
s
t ddr s e a
hes r
s n t'
.
A.Ec
. onomi Los Rul
c s e
Un e F o ialw,n t a s n eo pes n lij r o p o ry d ma e tt econom i
d r l rd a i he b e c f ro a n u y r r pet a g , the
c
l sr e ope a e t ba t tcli f pur y ec m i l si c s i vi a de e n who
os ul
r t s o r or a ms or el ono c os n a es nvol ng
f nda t
i ama a ur rorditi orofa p oduc orwhe et pa tesh
s
nuf ct e
srbut
r
t
r he ri
a contac u prviy. To
ve
r t al i t ' pp.
'
2 t nde Fl i l , t sa e a ca e of
t
U r orda aw o tt
us
aci f fa i t i e e , a pa t m us
ton or r ud n he nduc m nt
esa ih t f l
t bls he olo
ry
t
wi g ee ns 1 a fle sae n rgadn a mae ilfc;2 te p ro
n lme t: ) as ttme t e r ig
tra a t ) h e s n
m a ng t sae e kne ors d haveknown t t r pr e a i
ki he t tm nt w
houl
hat he e es nt t
tep ro ma n t
h e s n kig h
o wa fle 3 itn b
n s as ; ) n e t y
j
e sae n t id c a to o rla c ;a d4 ij r s fe e b c u e o
ttme t o n u e cin r ein e n ) n uy u fr d e a s f
usii bl r la e on t r e e ai n.' Rube a v.Bul Run J
tfa e ei nc
he epr s nt to '
s
l
umpe s LLC,N o.09r.
811
07
CV0
6320, a * ( D. a J n 2 , 01 )(iain o te )
, 201 W L 37
t 3 eal Fl. a . 6 2 0 ctto s mitd .
S.
3F
l m offaudulntconc
ai
r
e
o ac
r
me t ap ry mus alg t 1 aflesae n c nc mig a
n, a t
t l e % ) as ttme t o e n
e (
maeil at()k o e g b tepes nma igt sae n t ttergrsnaini fle
tra fc;2 n wld e y h ro kn he ttme tha h e ee tt s as;
o
()t eitn b tepes n ma i gt sae n t tt rp e e tto wlli uc
3 h n e t y h ro k n he ttme t ha he e r s nain l nd
a t ni; 4 r l n eo te
c o t ( ) ei c n h
a
ea ohe t
n t ro
rp e e tto t t nu y f h te a t
e
a oh
d sl s ' Fribelv.Paradier snesinBay eij r o teoh rp ry . (n ( ) ad t t
ico e ' e
a d 51 uy o
s Shor of
Cnt .. LLC,No. I CVv
O- IZORSEM T, 201 W L
91
3247
2
, a * ( D. a.
t 3 N. Fl Ma .1 201 (neralciai omit
r 9, 2) it n ttons ted)
4tl or rt sae a cli f ne i ntm ir pr e a i
sn de o t t
a m or glge
s e es nt ton, apanifmu talge( )t eei a
mirp e
se r
litf s l
e 1 hr s
s ttonofmaeilfc;( t pa t ma ngt mirpr s ntto eiherkne oft
enai
tra a t 2) he ry ki he se e e ain t
w he
.
.
.
m ir pr s nt ton, made t mir pr e a i wihout knowldge of is tuh o
se e e ai
he se es ntton t
e
t r t r f liy, or
s ul h
ho d
a st
aanot rt t trpr e ai wa f s ( t r prs nttonwasma wih t i ent
veknown ac e esntton s ale; 3) he e e e ai
he
de t he nt
t i uce
o nd
he o
o t mirp e e tto ; n ( )tepanifs fee ar s lig ij r
n he se rs n ai n a d 4 h litf u fr d e utn nu y
whl a tn i j siiberla c u o temirp e e tto ' Tyco Saf t Pr Canada.Lt
i cig n u tfa l ein e p n h se r s nain '
e
e y ods
v Abr on Cor
d.
ac
p. No. 08- 8
CV- 0604, 2008 W L 475
,
3728, a * ( D.Fl Oc.28,2008)
(iaton
ct i
t 2 S. a. t
somitd)
te .
.
.
.
I v.Uni Am . Cor ,51 F.Su 2d.
nc.
den
p. 3
pp.
1 45 1 48( D. a 2 0 )( i to o t d 5 I
3 , 3 S. Fl. 0 7 ct in mit ) n
a
e
.
I mniv I ur nce Compmw of Norh Amerc v. Amerc Avi ton. I
nde t ns a
t
ia
ian
ai
nc t Fl i
orda
., he
Supr Cour e anedt tt e onomi l snze a isi t
eme
t xpl i ha he c
c os l pple n
w o dif r ntcicl tnc s 891
fe e r lmsa e .
S 2 5 2 5 6( a 2 0 ) Fis,ûift epa t sh v c n rcu lp iiy and a cl m f t t
o.d 3 , 3 F1. 0 4 . rt sl h ri a e o ta t a rvt ,
g
e
ai or or
smpl r sa e acl m f br ac ofc r ct t t tcai i ba r .
i y e t t s ai or e h
onta , he or l m s red
' I (ii Eci eM e .
' d. ctng lps d.
I .v. r sur c ll tume s l ,26 F.Supp.
nc Hyd o- gi a nsr nt . nc. 2
2d 133 1 ( D.Fl 1 ) Se ,
4, 354 S. a. 999). cond
t e onom i l sr l % r at tc us ofa on whe eapr uc i i ve whe t pr uc
he c
c os ue ç s or a e di
ba
r
od t s nvol d, n he od t
da gesonl is l, and t l s s a e pur y e
ma
y t ef
he os e r
el conomi .' Sa Fi Gr
c ' xon n. oup
.
I v.Ra h,No.
nc.
t
1l CV- 0646,201 W L 3278662, a * ( . F a Au . , 01 )(iaino te l6
- 8
2
t 5 SD. l . g 9 2 2 ctto mitd
.
Sd- t tt de e m i i t ec
ilhe es o t r ne f he onomi l sr e a i si t a k i t efa al ge i a
c os ul pple s o s f h r ud le d s n
a tofpe f ma or i a t m oft bar i .' Tyco Sa et Pr . Ca da.Lt ,2008 W L
c
ror nce n er
he gan '
f y ods na
d.
47 3 28 a * ( u tn D&M J ptr l v.Frdopf ,853 So 2d485, ( a.Dit Ct App.
5 7 , t 3 q oig
u ie s nc. i er
487 Fl s. .
.
2 0 :. l t e fa d i i a tr o t b r an i i notbared by t econom i l s rul
0 3 f h r u s n em f he ag i, t s
r
he
c os e;
howe r i t a lged faud r a e t a a tofpe f
ve , f he le
r
elt s o n c
ronna e t n i i ba r d by t e onom i
nc he t s r e
he c
c
,
l s r l A le v. St pha Co. 784 So.
os u e. l n
e n ,
2 4 6, 8 9 ( a Dit Ct Ap 2 0 )(ttn t a
d 5 45 -5 F1. s. . p. 0 0 saig h t
wih cli s of fa ulnt i
t am
r ud e nduce
ment a ne i nt m i
nd glge
s
r pr e a i t r t fa
e es nt ton, t e he r ud
whe
c
ompli ofr lt s t t pe f ma oft conta , t ec
aned
ea e o he ror nce he
r ct he onom i l s docrne willmi
c os
ti
l i t
5The e no i l s r e evol e be aus ltontac prnci es a e m or a oprat t n t t
co m c os ul
v d c e ç r t i pl r
c
e ppr i e ha or
prncpl t r ol pur l ec
i i es o es ve ey onomi cai s''Eye Ca e l e n.s l v.Unde hil 92 F
c l m .'
r nt r nc.
r l,
. Supp.
2d 1 0
31
, 1 4 ( . Fl 2000)( t
31 M D. a.
cii Fl Powe & Li Co. v.W esi
ng a.
r
ght
tnghous El .Cop
e ec
51 So. 8 90 ( a. 1
0 2d 99, 0 Fl 987:. Addiinal, Spari s t a contact have alocat t .
to ly ç te o
,
r
l ed he
e onomi rs ofno ror
c
c iks
npe f manc t ough t ba gai ng pr e s' Topp.l . 51 F
e hr
he r ni
oc s . '
nc , 3 . Supp.
a1 .
t 348
2d.
ç pa t t aconta twho a tmpt t cic ve t conta uala ee e by m a ng
t ry o
A
rc
te s o r um nt he
r ct gr m nt
acl i f econom i l s i t ti
a m or
c os n or s i e f c ,s e ng t obt i abe trba g n t heorgikil
o an
te r ai han
i naly
, n fe t e ki
ma4)'1 ( ii l m.l .Co.ofN. A m .v.A m .Avi tom I ., 891 So. 532,53 ( a
de. d. ctng nde ns
'
ai
ne
200 )
2d
6 F1.
.
6Si t Pl n if a lge t tt
nc aitf le s ha h
e
r ual i
camsu d rteeo o cl seul rtesr er cn contualprvly t , t sCo r wila ay ete
li n e h c n mi os rPari w ng i r tact iJrviy hi u t l n lz h
!
e e di ontac
ga
t . Se e 2. Com pl
e .,
.,
6
!7 .
7
t pa test t rconta ualr m e es' (ii Gr e il v. a Cae
he ri o hei
r ct e di . ' ctng e nfed M nor r
)
.
l ,705 So. 926
nc.
2d
( a.Dit Ct App.1997) Thi ca bedeemi d by l ngatwhehe çt acton i based
F1 s. .
). s n
tr ne
ooki
t r she i s
upon fa i pe
r ud nde nden oft c r cua br c .
t he onta t l ea h
' L0 a 4 8(iain o te l7Ad i o al ,
' 4, t 5 ctto s mi d . dt n ly
t
i
snc HTP.Lt v. Li sAe ea Cosa ce e . S. ,685 So. 1
i e
d.
nea r s t ni ns s A.
2d 238
,
1 9( 1.1 9 ) c u t
23 F a 9 6 , o rs
i Fl i ha f
n orda ve ound t t'çtt ment or mir e e ai ma t i e a i vi lt
ha ksa e
s
sepr s nt tons de o nduc n ndi dua o
e e a c r c ,i l tr conti d wihi t t r s of t a ualc
ntr onta t f ae
ane
t n he e m
he ct
ont
r c ,cn
a t nnot c tt t a
ons iu e
bass on whih t brng t fa c am .'' Be Yiha v. M ase c a tDe sLLC
i
c o i he r ud l i ' n- s y
t r r f v.
, 553 F.Supp.
2 1 6 1 7 ( D. a 2 0 )( u tn Fa n a m v OrentLi s.l ., No.03- 22549
d 3 0, 3 0 S. Fl. 0 8 q oig lme b u
i
ne nc
CV.
,
2004 W L 1
773207, a *7( D. a. ul 20, 4).
t S. Fl J y 200 )
He e,De e nts oblgai unde t a lge co r c
r
f nda '
i ton
r he le d nta t
wa t delve t Aic a t
s o i r he r r h o
Pli if Pl i ifa lgest tt r pr e ai ofDe e
antf. antf le
ha he e es nt tons
f nd
an ' age s f m e t ba i f t
ts nt or d he ss or he
condii oft Aicr f upon d i r unde t i a e m
ton
he r a t
elve y
r her gr e
e t S e Co .! 7 . A1 o t
n . e mpl 7 l f he
,
a lga i t t Pl n if us t s
le tons ha aitf es o uppor is c am s f
t t li
o fa i t i e e , faudulnt
r r ud n he nduc m nt r
e
c eam e ,a neglgen m irpr e ai n r ae t wheherD e e
onc l nt nd
i t s e es nt to elt o
t
f ndanta qua e y pe f m e
de t l ror d
unde t c r c- t ti , whe he Def nda br c t ag e m e by pr vi ng a d
r he onta t ha s
t r e nt ea hed he r e nt
o di
e e tve
fci
Aic a t Se e.g. Pr m i a bltt M f . Cor v.SKW Che s
r r f. e , e x-M r e ie c
p.
m .. I ,1 F.Supp.2d 13 ,
nc. 45
48
1 5 ( D. a 2 01 (ttn t a i e t ea to sc mpan d o rlt dr cl
3 8 S. Fl. 0 ) saig h t t n h cin o lie f eae ie t
wh
yt t s be t
o he u j c
ma tr oft pa tes a e nt or a e i e ove wih t ag e m e
te
he ri ' gr eme ,
r nt m
n t he r e nt no i epe nt t t
nd nde or
,
exit andt e onomi l sr l a is';Hot sofKev La g . l v.1 HIHot lsl ,694
ss
he c
c os ue pple '
l el
r o nc. 1
e s nc.
.
So. 74,78 ( a.Dit Ct App 1 (ttngt twhe t mirprs ntton i çnsparbl
2d
F1 s. .
997) sai ha
n he se e e ai s s e a e
i
.
fom t es e e oft pa tes ag e m e , t e onomi l sr ea is'
r he s nc
he ri ' r e nt he c
c os ul pple '
)
.
Thus t cli si
, he am n
1t( t l i d p n e tc u eo a t n f rfa d lntmir pr entton wher t a lt of
çA) nzy n e e d n a s f ci o ru u e
i
o
e he biiy
se es a i
o he e o o
ne t
ta e a r e m s
mi d
he he ' r udulnt , vi r s
by tpary t nego it f i t r si under ne by t ot r sfa e beha o ,i notba r
c
red
nom i l sr e.''
c os ul 'Rube a 201 W L 376320, a * ( tngHot s 694So. a 77
s, 0
t 4 quoi
el,
2d t )
.
t s c mt a e i si s bl fom t ca ms i t b
he e ot s r nditnguiha e r he li n he
r c of c r tc am a a e no
ea h
ontac l i nd r t
i pe en t t. Se Rube a 201 W L 376320
nde nd t ors e
s, 0
, a * - ( imisn camsf rf u i te
t 4 5 d s s ig li o r d n h
a
i
nduce nt a neglge m ir pr s nt ton as ba r d by t e
me nd
i nt s e e e ai
re
he conomi l s r e whe e a
c os ul
r
pu c s r s d a m e c t be us a hor e pur ha e wa
r ha e ue
r han ca e
s
c sd
s not s tbl f co pe ii a
uia e or m tton s
prvi l rpr s e byt merha )
e ousy e eentd he c nt
.
The c uson t t Pl i ifs c am s a e not i pend
oncl i ha antf ' l i
r
nde
e c es of a ton c be
nt aus
c i an
s
uppore snc t f t ne es a y t pr t tDe e
td i e ht acs c s r o ove ha f ndan br ac d t Pa tes a e m e a e
t e he he ri ' gr e nt r
t s m e f c snec s r t pr al ofPli ifst tcli s Se Expora onesTe ie
he a
at
es a y o ove l
a ntf or am . e
tci
xtl s
.
S. .
A
De C. v.Or nc Cl hi Co., No.09- 22967 2010 W L 1
V.
a e ot ng
CV25771 , a * ( D.Fa M a.
0 t 3 S. l. r
,
2 ,2 0 . ld e ,Pli t fsb e c ofc nr c cam i b s d u n t e rpr ent tons by
9 01 ) n e d ani r a h
f
o ta t li s a e po h e es ai
De e d n ' a e t t talo f m t bassf Pli tf sot rcli S eCo l, ! 1 - 98
fn a ts g n s ha s or he i or a n if he a ms e mp .! 6 1 .
.
F r e n l, Plitf alg s t t SDee a t a i a e t a d rp e e atves m ade
o x mp e an if l e ha t fnd n) nd t g n s n e r snt i
e
l
a fr ai off c and pr ie r ltng t t Aic af a whih be a e pa toft bassof
fim tons a t
om s s ea i o he r r t nd
c cm
r
he i
t bar ai oft e . . . (l r e n .Th eafr to so fc a dpr mie c n tttde p e s
he g n h
a ge me t os fimain f a t n o s s o siu e x r s
warnis' Co .! 7 . To f rh rs p o theb e c o c n rc cam , Pli ifstt st t
ra te . mpl 7
'
,
u te u p r t ra h f o ta t li antf a e ha
S Dee d n)b e c e t e gj p e sg arn isb e u e att mom entoft delver oft
l fn a t ra h d h ex r s wlra te e a s , he
l
he i y
he
Aic a t Aic a tdi notpos e st qualte a fnned a
r r h, he r r f d
s s he
ii s fi
n p o s d b ( fn a t a dis
d r mie y De e d n ) n t
a t a r pr s nttves' Co l, 7 . Ad iin l Plitf alg ste smer to l f r
gen s nd e e e a i . ' mp .! 8
d t al an if le e h n ainae o
o y,
is br a ofe es wa r ntes cai .
t e ch
xpr s ra i l m
S e Co l, 9 ;se as P vltc v Bertam Yacht
e mp .! 3 e lo a ei
r
I ,No.11CVnc.
- 60484, 2011W L 3475394,
.
a * ( D. a Au 9 2 1 ( imisn camsfr
t 6 S. Fl. g. , 01 ) ds sig li o
'A1 oft s c am sr a et he lt
1 he e l i elt
he r r f
c
o he r
he r
ag ee en . See Ale 784 o t quaiy oft Aic a twhi h goest t hea toft Pa tes
r m t
l n,
So.2 a 45 (tt t ta cam i b re i isSnu y wa in'
d t 8 sai ha li s ard f t ç j r so e
ng
i
whih fo d fom t f iur t pe f m t he r of t
c l we r
he a l e o ror he a t h
So2d 7 ( a.Dit Ct App.1 ) Sta Ca t Cor e a re n )( ing Hoes o 6 4
g
i
4 F1 s. .
997 ; rub pial p v.L.e me f' ct P tl f 9
Fr Chopi A. 724 So.
ank
ns
577( a D it Ct A pp 1 ).
F1 s . .
,
2d
998)
.
.
.
.
8
.
fa i t i e e a neglg ntm ir pr e a i unde t
r ud n he nduc m nt nd
ie
s e es nt ton
rh
e e onom i l s r l be us
c
c os ue ca e
none of t a t we e inde nde fom t a t alege i t br c of wa
he c s r l pe nt r he c s l d n he ea h
i
ra t cam'.
r ny li )
Thus t f cs ne es a y f t t tc am s bas upon t r pr e a i
, he a t c s r or he or l i
ed
he e es nt to
ns a e ûi e wove '
r sntr
n'
wih t e ne s ar f Pl ntf br ac of c r t cli a t
t hos ce s y or ai ifs e h
ontac a m nd h
e t t cl ms a e not
or ai
r
i pe n c esofa i n. HTP.Lt ,685 So. a 1 .9
nde nde t aus
cto
d.
2d t 240
Thus eve t
, n hough Pli if a g s t t is c am s ar ditnct t ca
antf r ue ha t l i
e si
one nnot a d t
voi he
, û
e o o cl sr l b meey lb l g a cam a fa i t id c me tgroh rsmia tr
c n mi os ue y rl a ei
n li s rud n he n u e n o te i lr o t
cams)t efa d mu tb s p r t a d d sic fo t eb e c i g p ry' p ro a c o te
li i h ru s e e a ae n itn t r m h r a h n a t s ef nn n e f h
c r c . Rubes 201 W L 376320, a *4 ( i M e i v.
onta t'
'
a, 0
t quotng dale FSC Se ssCop ., 87 F.Supp.
c.
ai or r
2d 1
295, 1 ( D.Fl 2000).0 H ee, Pli ifs cl ms f faud i t i uce nt
305 S. a.
)1
r antf
n he nd me ,
fa e c eam e , and ne i nt m ir pr s nt ton a e al bas upon Def nda '
r udul nt onc l nt
glge
s e e e ai
r l ed
e nts
de e tve peror a e unde t a lged a e m e . l1 The e or t s Cour fnds t tCot 1
fci
f m nc
r he le
gr e nt
r f e, hi
ti
ha
mt ,
I,a l1ofPl ntf Compli a eba r d by t e onom i l s1 l . 1
l nd I
ai ifs
ant r r e
he c
c os ' e 2
u
9 Alho h not dipostve t s Cour no es t tQt pot nta r c y unde e t r t pe of
t ug
s ii hi
t t ha the e i l e over
r ihe y
,
cli fa or br c of c r c- woul be' i ntc l Or nge Cl hi Co.
am- r ud
ea h
onta t
d ' de i a . a
ot ng
1
25771
0
0
, 201 W L
t
r ihe c i , antf
, a *3. Unde e t r a ton Pli ifwoul r ove t
d ec r he pur ha e prce oft Aic a t
c s i
he r r f
a a i de a da a . See Com pl, a 9, 1 1 1 1
nd ny nci nt l m ges
.
0, 2, 4, 5, 6 se ng esiso r
c ncelaton oft contactand ot rdam agesft ever counti Pl i 1f (e ki r csin o
a li
he
r
he
or y
n antf
i
1 s 1o M axcess l v
0
s
ant
)
. nc. . Luc tTe h. l ., No.04- 204OR131 sCompliL. 25471
e a
e
en c . nc
CV, DAB 2005 W 61
a * ( . Fl J n.5,2005) (ttng t twih çegad t a lr e c , r a tans ton
t 6 M D. a. a
sai ha t s r o a g ommecil r ac i y
r
c
ove e by ac r c t pu porst e
rd
onta t hat r t o mbody t pari s e ie t rt ndi i apa t a s rs
he te ' ntr mde sa ng, f ry s e t
at tcli be i die ty on t qualt . . . o g o ta a ea o j c o t ta s cin te
or am arng r c l
he
iy
fto ds h t r n b e t f he rn a to , h
st ton i die ty and s tnta l algned wih c e a pol
iua i s r c l
ubsa ily i
ont xt nd i
(cnmils)ue)cttn o td
eoo cosrl'(i i s mie)
ao
t
ce ta gv ret te
is ht ae i o h
s
'Thi Cou twilnotgr ntPl i ifl .
s
r l
a
antf
e t a e t e cou s be us a a t m ptt r vi e
ave o m nd hes
nt ca e ny te
o e s
t s a lga i wo d lkey be ba r d by t e
he e le tons ul i l
re
he conomi l s
c os
376320
r e. Se Rube a 201 W L
ul
e
s, 0
,
a * ( s s i wih prj c apl ntf cli f fa i t i
t 4-5 dimisng t eudie ai ifs ams or rud n he nduce nta
me nd
ne i entm ir pr s nt to unde t e onom i l s r l bec us a
glg
s e e e ai n
r he c
c os ue
a e
f i
m l
ny ame m e woul be
nd nt
d
1 e)
2 .
Si t s Cour fnds t Pli ifs c am sar ba r by t e onom i l sr l ,t sCour
nce hi
t i hat a ntf l i
e red
he c
c os u e hi
t
de i t add e sDe e
clnes o r s f ndan ' ot rar
ts he gume st tCount 1 11s d bedim is d
nt ha
s 1 houl
s se
-
.
I CONCLUSI
V.
ON
Fort f r ng r as , i i
he o egoi e ons t s
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t De enda ' M ot
hat f nts
i
o t Dimis ( No.1 )i
n o s s ECF
3 s
GR AN TED . Co m t 1 I,a llofPli ifsCompl i a eDI I
t s , l nd I
antf
ant r SM SSED W I PREJ CE
TH
UDI
.
DON E AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i Fl rda,hi
n
m r t ami o i t s
,
da ofOc o r 201
y
t be ,
2.
!
v*
K. I
CHAEL M OORE
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
c
c:
Al c
l ouns lofr cor
e
e d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?