Gucci America, Inc. v. 2replicawatches.com, et al

Filing 54

ORDER GRANTING 41 Second Ex Parte MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order and scheduling hearing on Preliminary Injunction for 5/31/2012 at 2:00 p.m. in Courtroom 13-1, United States Federal Courthouse, 400 North Miami Avenue, Miami, Florida. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 5/22/2012. (rg1)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E SO U TH ERN DI
STRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
C a eN o.1: 2- vs
1 c 2115 K M M
4-

GUCCIAM ERI m C. aN e Yor
CA,
, w
k
c por to
or a i n,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
V S.

ZREPLI
CAW ATCHES.
COM e aI,
t .
D e e nt .
f nda s
/

O RD ER G M N TI G SECO ND EX PA RTE A PPLI A TI N
N
C
O
FO R A TEM PO M R Y R ESTR M N I G O R DE R
N

THI CAU SE ca be or t Colr on Pli ifsSe
S
me f e he zt
antf
condExPareApplc ton f
t
i a i or

Enr o Te rr Re tanngOr e a dP ei ne Ij n to (heç c ndAp lc to f r
ty f mpo a y sr ii d r n r l
mi n u ci n t ç o
se
p iain o
TRO' ( No. ) UP CONSD EM TI o teMo in,hep rie tp rinso t
' ECF 41 . ON
)
ON f h to t e t n o to f he
n
Re or a bengot r s f ly a s d i t pr mies t Cour entr t f lwi Or r
c d, nd i he wie u l dvie n he e s , he
t e s he olo ng de .
1
.

BA C K G R O U ND I

Guc i t r git r d owne of nume ous ta m a ks us d i c
ci s he e se e
r
r
r de r
e n onne i wih t
cton t he

ma a t e a diti i n ofhi qualt ha
nuf cur nd srbuto
gh
iy ndba ,wal t,s de ba ,bels ke rng ,
gs le s houl r gs t , y i s
wac s s tr ,s rs s ,e a s s s as e ,te ,dufl ba , j wer , uta e ,a d
the , weae s hit, hoes yegls e , ungl s s i s
fe gs e ly s ic s s n
ca . Am ong t s ta m a ks a e ta m a ks a s it d wih Unied Stt s Pa e a
ps
he e r de r r r de r s oca e
t
t
ae
t nt nd

Trde r Ofi CC
a mak fce USPTO' No. 0, 338, r see on M a 22, 1
'
)
959,
egitrd
y
973; USPTO No.
1 1 311 r gitr d on Nove r 28, 1
, 07, , e se e
mbe
978)USPTO No. 1 1 780,r git r on J y 2 ,
, 22,
e se ed
ul 4

1Thef t heen aetke fom Pli ifsFis Ame dCompli ( No 4 )a d
acs ri r a n r
antf rt nde
ant ECF
0 n
Pli ifsSe ondApplc tonf TRO ( No.41.
antf c
iai or
ECF
)
.

1
979, USPTO No. 1 1 477, r se e on Se e r 8, 1
, 68,
egit r d
pt mbe
981; USPTO N o. 1340,
, 599,
r gitr d o J 11 1
e se e n une , 985;USPTO No. 039,629,r it r d on J nua y 1 2006;USPTO N o.
3,
eg se e
a r 0,
3, 5 M a c 28,2006; SPTO No.3, 1 , r git r d on J nua y 29,2008;USPTO No.
072,49, r h
U
376, 29 e se e
a r
3, 75 r gitr d o Fe u r 5,2008;U SPTO No.3,391739,r git r d on M a c 4,2008
378, 5, e se e n br a y
,
e se e
rh

(ol ciey te ç c M ak '. Dee da t 1 8 - 3 2 ae u k o p rn rhp o
c l tv l, h fuc i r s) fn ns 7
e
2 r n n wn a tes is r
uni r a e a s i tons who a e bele d t us , o as itot r i usng,t co me ci
nco por t d s oc ai
r
ive o e r s s he s n i he m r al
I e e we ie ope ai t r t dom an na es i ntfed o Sc
ntm t bst s
r tng mde he
i
m
de ii
n hedul % ' he e o
e $
A' r t

(olci ey,heç o p 1 S b e tDo i Na s).
c le tv l t ç u 1 u j c man me '
Gr
Re e l Pli ifbe n e a r oft potntals l ofcot eretve so ofPl i ifs
c nty a ntf c m wa e he e i a e
mt f i r i ns
antf
pr t by Def nda s178 -322.Thi i a lge t ha be n a compls d by Defnda s1
oduc s
e nt
s s le d o ve e c
ihe
e nt 78
-

3 t oug t o r ton ofco m e call e ne we ie o r tng underdom an na e s h
22 hr h he pe a i
m r i nt r t bst s pe a i
i m s uc

a 36oknoc f . m , guc i l es a e.c , a guc ha
s
kof sco
c outet s l om nd
e o
ci ndbags
hopsco . I r s
. m 2 n e pons t

De e nt 178 - 322' a lge ta m a k i rnge e ,Pl i if a n r ane l si tve
f nda s
s le d r de r nfi m nt antf gai eti d nve tgai
Cons tnt ,a lc ns d prvae i si tve fr ,t i si t t s l ofc e f i ve sons
ula s i e e i t nve tgai im o nve tga e he ae
ount ret r i
ofPl i ifspr t byDefnda s1 -322.
antf
oduc s
e nt 78

M a e i M a o,a e oye ofl si tve Cons t nt,ptr ha e s ve a dif r nt
l re ggi n mpl e
nve tga i
ula s lc s d e r l fe e
pr
oduc s bea i t G uc i M a ks a i s vi t va i
t
r ng he
c
r
t s ue a he rous I e e w e ie o r t d by
nt m t bs t s pe a e

De e nt 1 -3 Se Se nd De l ofM aei M a o at! 4. Att c uson oft
fnda s 78 22. e co
c.
lre ggi
he oncl i
he
pr es , M s M aggi f wa de de al d we pa ca lr s of t Guc br nde g
oc s
.
o or r d t ie
b ge ptze
he
ci a d oods
plr ha e t Guc ' r pr s nttve,Niol M ara f i pe i n. J SM s M ar pes ly
zc s d o
cis e e e a i
c e
r , or ns cto J. . ra ronal
a yz d t de a ld we pa ca ur oft Guc br nde goodspur ha e by M s M agg o
nal e he t ie
b ge pt es he
ci a d
c sd
.
i
a de e mi t pur has d goodst be no ge ne una horze Guc br nde pr t .
nd t r ned he c e
o
n- nui ,
ut i d
ci a d oduc s
2
The c pl t ls ofw e ie i l
om e e i t
bs t s nc udesoneht e , f t f ve dom a n nn es Fo a c pl t
mdr d ory- i
i m . r om e e
ls,s eSc dul A oft sOr r
it e he e
hi de .
2

S eSe o dDe lofNio eM ar a ! 1 ,1 .Ad iin l ,M s M ar c n u td ar ve o
e c n c. c l ra t ! 2 5 d t al . ra o d ce e iw f
o y
t va i Guc ibr nde pr t ofe ed f s l by Defnda s 1
he rous
c a d oduc s f r or ae
e nt 78

-

322 vi t I e ne
a he ntr t

we ie o eaig u e e c o t e Gr u 1 u j c Do i Na s a d d tr n d t e
bsts p rtn nd r a h f h o p 1S b e t man me , n eemi e h
pr t we enotge ne a ora horze Guc ipr uc s L.a !I1 ,1 .
oduc s r
nui nd/ ut i d
c od t. d t ! 3 5
a
I.
I

LEG A T STA ND A RD
,

l or rt pr va lon am oto f a e
n de o e i
i n or n xparet mpo a y r tani or r Pl ntf m us
t e r r esr i ng de , ai if t
s
how t t
ha

( )i ce ry a p asfo s cfcfcss o by a fd vto by teveiid
1 t la l p e r r m pe ii a t h wn fi a i r h rfe
c mp an t ti d aea d irp rbl ij r ,ls , rd ma ewil eul t
o lit ha mme it n re aa e n u y o s o a g l r s t o
t a i ntbef r t a r e pa t ort tpa t s a t ne ca be hea d i
he pplca
o e he dve s ry ha ry' tor y n
r n

o p iin a d ( )t a p ia tsatr e c riist tec u ti wrtn t e
p osto , n 2 he p lc n ' to n y etfe o h o r n i g h
i
e f rs i a whih ha bee ma t gi t notc a t r s ns
fo t, f ny, c
ve
n de o ve he i e nd he ea o
s pori t c am t tno i s d notbe r quied.
up tng he l i ha tce houl
e r

Fe R. v. 65 ç c pa t r srii go d ri a e te rme yo l t b u e wih
d. Ci P. 09.ç x re etan n r e s n x rme e d n y o e s d t
M
t ut tc uton. Le nev. Co o . d.7 F.d 1 91 1 9 ( 1h Ci. 9 5 .
he mos a i ' vi
'
mc a Lt , 0 3 1 , 1 4 1 t r 1 9 )

On e te mo i pat me t te t s od rq ie n so Rul 6 1)t sc r a e
c h vng ry es h ke h l e ur me t f e 5 o e u e n x
pa t tmp rr rsr ii o d r Plitf mus de n tae ( ) a s bsa ta lk lh o o
re e o ay e tanng r e , anif t mo srt 1 u tnil ieio d f
s c e so t emeis ( )ta irpaa l ij r wil s fee u ls t ijmcin is e ; 3
u c s n h rt; 2 h t re rb e n u y lbe u frd ne s he nt t su s ( )
o
t tr ae d ij r t te mo n o t ih whae rda g t epr p e ijmcin ma
he h e tne nu y o h va t u weg s tve ma e h o osd n t to y

c us te o p sng p ry a d ()i is d t e ij n t n wo l no be a v ret t ep bl
a e h p o i a t; n 4 f sue , h nu ci
o ud t d es o h u i
c
itr s i od rt o ti ij nci er l f F u Se s n Hoes& Reo t.B. v Co s r i
n eet n r e o b an n u tv ei o r a o s tl
e
s rs V. . n oco
Bar S. ,3 0 F.d 1 0 ,1 0 ( 1h Ci.2 03 ;M c n l sCo .v.Ro e to 1 7 F.d
r. A. 2 3 2 5 21 1 t r 0 ) Do ad' p
b rs n, 4 3
13 1 ( t Ci.1 )
01, 306 11h r 998 .
11
1.

AN A LY SIS

Thedeca ai Pl i ifs
lr tons antf ubmit i s ppor ofisSe ond Applcai n f at mpor r
ted n u
t t c
i to or e
ay

r sr i ngor r(ç ondTRO' s
etani de ç
sec
' uppor t f lwi c usonsoflw:
)
the olo ng oncl i
a
3

1. Pl i ifha a ve y sr pr ba lt ofpr ng a tilt tc nsl e s a e lkey t
antf s
r tong o biiy
ovi t ra ha o lm r r i l o
be c us d by Defnda s 1 -3 sa rie e ,pr o i s l , ofe f s e,
onf e
e nt 78 22' dve ts m nt om ton, ae f r or al
a or diti i of ha
nd/
srbuton
ndba ,wal t, s de ba ,be t, key rngs w ac ,
gs les houl r gs ls
i , t hes
s ea e s s r s s s e a s s s a s ,tes dufl bags j wer ,s ic ss
w t r , hi t, hoe , yegl s e , ungl s es i , fe
, e ly uta e ,

a ca be rng co e f t,r pr uci ns a o c o a ei iai nsoft Guc i
nd ps a i
unt reis e od to , nd/ r ol r bl m t to
he
c
M aks,a t t t ha ba ,w alt , s de ba ,bet , ke rngs w a c s
r
nd ha he nd gs
les houl r gs ls y i , t he ,

s aes s it,s o s e e lse ,smga s s te ,d fe ba s jwer s i a e ,
we tr , hrs h e , y g as s t lse , is ufl g , e ly, ut s s
c
a ca Def nda s 178 - 3 a e s li c es of Pli ifs pr t t tbe r
nd ps
e nt
22 r e lng opi
antf
oduc s ha a
m a kswhi h a e s tntaly i si iha e fom a orc or uli iai nsoft
r
c r ubsa i l nditngu s bl r
nd/ ol f m t to
he
Gucc M a ks
i r .

Be us of t i rnge e of t Guc i M a ks Pl i if i lkey t s f r
ca e
he nfi m nt
he
c
r , antf s i l o ufe

i daea d irp rbl ij r i atmpo a yr sr ii o d ri n tg a td.
mme it n re aa e nu y f e r r e tanng r e s o rne
a Thr h t ope ai of o hu e f t fve I e e we ie ,
.
oug he
r ton
ne ndr d, ory-i
nt m t bst s
D ef nda s 1 - 322 a e o r tng l e ne bus ne s s whi h a r i e
e nt 78
r pe a i nt r t
i se
c dve ts ,

pr ot ofe f s l,a s l,ha
om e, f r or ae nd el ndba ,wal t,s de ba ,bet,ke
gs le s houl r gs ls y
rngs w a c s s e t r , s rs s , e gl s es s a s , tes d fe
i , t he , w a e s hi t, hoes ye a s , ungl s es i , ufl

b g , j wer , s ic s s a c ps b aig c u tret a d i rn ig
a s e ly u ta e , nd a e rn o n efi n nfign
ta m a ksi vi a i ofPli ipsrg s
r de r n olton
a ntf i ht ;

b. The e i g d ca et bele t tm o ecountr eta i rngi ha ba ,
r s oo us o ive ha r
e f i nd nfi ng nd gs
w alt , s de ba , bet , ke rngs wa c s s a e s s rs s s
le s houl r gs ls y i , t he , we t r , hit, hoe ,

e e lse ,s n lse ,te ,d fl ba s j wer ,s ic s s a d c p be rn
y g a ss u ga s s is u fe g , e ly u tm e , n a s a ig
Pl ntf s t a m a ks w ila
ai i f r de r
l ppea i t m r ke pl c t t c n e s m ay be
r n he
t a e; ha ons m r

4

m il d,c us d,a dia nt by t qualt oft s pr t ;a t t
se onf e nd s ppoi ed
he
iy he e oduc s nd ha
Pl i ifma s f rl sofs l f isge nepr t ;
antf y ufe os
aes or t nui
oduc s
Gi n t e s wih whi h D e e nt 1 -322 m a ta f ra o r die t
ve he a e t
c
f nda s 78
y r ns e nd/ r e r c
c
omm e c a a tviy fom oneI e e Dom an N n t a he , t r i good
ril ci t r
ntm t
i me o not r he e s
ca e t bei ve t t i Pli if pr e ds o notc t De e nt on t s
us o le ha f antf oc e n
ie o f nda s
hi

Se nd Applcai f TRO,Pl ntf s a lt t obt i me ni ulr i
co
i ton or
ai if biiy o an a ngf elef
wil t
l be hwm e
d;
d. The balnce ofpotntalha m t De e nt 1 - 322 i r sr i ng t i
a
e i
r o f nda s 78
n e ta ni her

ta i c e f t a i rngi br nde pr uc s i t Se ond TRO i
r de n ount rei nd nfi ng a d od t f he c
s
is d i f rout i he by t potntalha m t Pl i if isr put to a
s ue s a
we g d
he e i r o antf, t e ai n, nd
goodwil a a m a a t e of hi q lt pr t , i s h r i i not
l s
nuf c ur r
gh uaiy oduc s f uc elef s
is d'a
s ue , nd
e The publc i e e tf vor is nce of t Se ond TRO t pr e tPli ifs
.
i nt r s a s s ua
he c
o ot c antf

ta ma k i e essa t publc fom beng de r ude by t pam i of of
r de r nt r t nd he
i r
i
fa d
he l ng f
c mt retpr t a ge nepr t ofPl i if
ot e f i oduc s s nui
oduc s
antf
I
V.

CONCLUSI
ON

Fo t f e ng r a ons i i ORDERED AND ADJ
r he or goi e s , t s
UDGED t tPl ntf Se ond Ex
ha ai ifs c
PareAp i to i GRAN TED. I i f rher
t plcai n s
t s ut

ORDERED M D ADJ
UDGED t t
ha
Ea h De e nt t i ofie s die t s e pl es a nt ,s bsdires diti or ,
c
f nda , her fc r , r c or , m oye , ge s u i a i , srbut s
a a1 pe s i a tve co e torpa tci ton wih t m ha ng notce oft s Or r
nd 1 r ons n ci
nc r
ri pa i
t he
vi
i
hi de
a ehe e t m por r l r t a ned:
r r by e
a iy esr i

5

a. Fr m m a a t i i
o
nuf c urng, mpori ad rii pr otng, ofe i t s l,s lng,
tng, ve tsng, om i
f rng o e l eli
diti i o ta f r i a pr t be rng t Guc i M aks or any
srbutng, r r nse rng ny oduc s a i he
c
r ,
c u i y sm ia tade aks ohe t n t e a t ly m a a t e or
onf sngl i l r r m r , t r ha hos c ua l
nuf c ur d
diti e by Pli if a
srbut d
antf ; nd
b. Fr s c ei c
om e r tng, once lng, desr ng, s li of, ta f ni or ot wie
ai
toyi
e lng f r ns e ng,
her s

d s o ig o : () a y p o u t, n tma ufcu e o d srb td b Plitf
ip sn f i n r d cs o n a tr d r itiu e y an it
be rng t Gucc M aks or a c usngl smia ta maks or (i a
ai he
i r , ny onf i y i lr r de r ; i) ny
e de r a i t t m a a t r i rai , s l ,ofe f rs l ,diti i
vi nce eltng o he nuf c u e, mpo tton a e f r o a e srbuton,
orta f rof a pr t be dng t Gucc M aks o a c usngl sm ia
r ns e
ny oduc s a
he
i r , r ny onf i y i lr
ta m aks
r de r .
2. Ea h De e nt t i ofi r ,diecor , empl s age s s i a i , diti or ,
c
f nda , her fce s r t s
oyee , nt, ubsdires srbut s

a a1 pe s i a tve c
nd 1 r ons n c i once torpa tci ton wih t m ha ng notce oft s Or r
r
ri pai
t he
vi
i
hi de
s li
hal mmedit l dicontnue t us of t Guc i M aks or a c usngl sm ia
a ey s i
he e
he
c
r
ny onf i y i lr
ta m a ks o or i co c i wih a 1 l e ne we ie owne a ope a e ,
r de r , n
n nne ton t 1 nt r t bst s
d nd
rtd

or

c n r l db te icudn t eI en twe i so eaig u d rt Gr u 1 S be t
o tol y h m, n l ig h ntr e bst p rtn n e he o p 1 u j c
e
e
Do an Na e ;
m i m s3
3. Ea h De e nt t i ofi e s die t s e oye ,a nt ,s i a i s diti or ,
c
f nda , her fc r , r c or , mpl es ge s ubsdire , srbut s

a a 1pe s i a tve co e torpm ii ton wih t m ha ng notce oft s Or r
nd 1 r ons n ci
nc r
cpa i
t he
vi
i
hi de
s l i e ael dic i t us oft Guc M a ks or a conf i y smia
ha l mm di t y s ontnue he e
he
ci r
ny
usngl i lr
t a m a ks w ihi dom ai na e e e i , m e a ags or ot r m ar r w ihi w e ie
r de r
t n
n m xt ns ons t t ,
he
ke s t n bst

s lr code on a we ge (ncl ng a t tte ofa we pa ) a a rii
ozce
, ny bpa i udi s he il
ny b ge , ny dve tsng
lr t ot rwe ie ,f o s r h e ne daa s sorca hem e or , a a ot r
il o he bst s r m ea c ngi s' tba e
ks
c
m y nd ny he
f m ofus ofs h t r s whi h i vi i e t a co put r us rors r est die co put r
or
e uc e m
c s sbl o
m e e
e v o r ct m e

3see sc dul A oft sOr r
he e
hi de .
6

s a c st we ie r git r d by,owne o ope a e by e c Def nt i l ng t
e r he o bst s e se e
d, r r t d
ah
enda , ncudi he

l tm e we stso e ai gt rteGr u 1 S b e t manNa s
ne t b i p r tn mde h o p 1 u j c Do i me ;
e
4. Ea h Dee d n s l n tta se o es i ofte Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na s
c fn a t hal o rn fr wn rhp h o p 1 u j c man me
durng t pe ncy oft sAci o untlf t rOr roft Cour;
i he nde
hi ton, r i urhe de
he
t

5. Th d man na Re itas f rte Gr u 1 Su jc Do i Na s ae dr ce t
e o i me gsrr o h o p 1 be t man me r ie td o
ta f rt Pl i ifs c
r nse o antf ouns l f r de i wih t s Cour,dom an na e c rii t s f
e, o post t hi
t
i m e tfca e or

teS b e t manNn s
h u j c Do i me ;
6 Up n Plitf srq e t tep ia y p oe to s r ief ra y oft e Gr u 1 S b e t
. o an if e u s, h rv c r tcin evc o n
h o p 1 u jc
Dom an Nn e whih t Re sr ntus st co e t Regita ' i ntt a c a t
i m s c he gita
e o nc al he
sr nts de iy nd ont c
i or a i i or r t di cl e t Pl i i ft t ue i ntte a co ac i or a i
nf m ton s de ed o s os o a ntf he r de ii s nd nt t nf m ton
oft Reg sr nt
he
ita ;

7. Upon e r of t s Or r Pli if s lpr de a c
nty
hi de , a ntf hal ovi
opy oft Or r by e a lt t
he de
m i o he

r gsrro rc r fre c o teGr u 1 Su j c Do i Na s s t tt er gsrr
e ita f e o d o a h f h o p 1 b e t man me , o ha h e ita
o rc r o e c o t Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Nn s ma i tr ,n tf e c
f e o d f a h f he o p 1 u j c man me y, n u n oiy a h
r gita of t Or r a pr de notc of t l ng of t do an ns e t t
e sr nt he de nd ovi
ie
he ocki
he m i m o he
r gita ofr c d.Ahe pr di s h notc t t r gita s s t do an na e
e sr nt e or
r ovi ng uc
ie o he e sr r o he m i m s
m a be l ked,Pl i if s l a s pr de notc a a c
y
oc
antf ha l lo ovi
ie nd
opy of t s Or r t t
hi de o he

r gsrn ofe c Gr u 1 Su jc Do i Na vae i t t ee i a d e sp o ie
e ita t a h o p 1 b e t man me i malo h mal d r s r vd d

a pato te d man r g srto d t fre c o te Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Ns s
s r f h o i e itain aa o a h f h o p 1 u j c man me
i ntfe i t Sec
de ii d n he
ond Applca i n f TR O .l a e a la e s w a notpr ded as
i to or
f ny m i ddr s
s
ovi

p r o t d man rg sr to daaf raGr u 1 Su j c Do i Na ,Plitf s al
a t f he o i e itain t o
o p 1 b e t man me an if h l
pr de no i a a c oft sOr rt t o r t s oft l e e w e ie vi a
ovi
tce nd opy
hi de o he pe a or
he ntm t bst s a n
e a la r s a oronlne s i s on f m spr de on t I e tw e ie o r tng
m i dd e s nd/
i ubm s i or
ovi d
he nt nw
bst s pe a i

u d rs c Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na s Aûe fry eg t( )ho r ha e ea e
n e u h o p 1 u j c man me . r o t-ih 48 u s v lpsd
aûe t e alng oft s Or t t r gita s ofr c d a t r gita s Pli if
r he m ii
hi der o he e sr r
e or nd he e sr nt , antf

s alprvie a c p ofti Or e t t e r gsre fr te Gr u 1 S be tDo i
h l o d o y h s d r o h e itis o h o p 1 u jc man
Na sf rtep r s sd srbe i Pa a rp 8 if a;
me o h u po e e c i d n r g a h , nr
8. TheRe sr r s l i medit l a ss i c ngi t Re sr rofr c d f rt Gr up
gita s ha l m
a ey s it n ha ng he gita
e or o he o

1 S be t manNa s e c p iga s c d mann me whih s c Re itasha e
1 u jc Do i me , x e tn ny u h o i a s c u h g sr r v
bee notfe i wrtng by t Pli ifha be n orwilbe dim is d fom t sa ton,
n iid n ii
he antf ve e
l
s s e r hi c i

t ah li a c u twih aRe ita ofPli ifsc o i (h ç w Re ita' To
o odng c o n t
gsrr
antf h osng te ç
Ne
gsrr).
t e e t Re sr r do not as it i c ngi t Re sr of Re o d f r t
he xt nt he gita s
ss n ha ng he gitrs
c r o he

d manst r terr s ci c n r lwihn o e () b sn s d y o rc ito t s
o i mde h i e pe t o to ti n 1 u ie s a f e ep f hi
ve
S c nd TRO,t tp-e ld man (
eo
he o lve o i TLD)Re itis ( r tera miitao s fr te
g sre o h i d n srtr) o h

Gr u 1 Su j c Do i Nn s wi i fv ( )b i s d y o r c i to t i S c n
o p 1 be t man me , t n i e 5 usne s a s f e ep f hs e o d
h
TRO,s l u d t t e Re ita o r c r f r te Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na s
hal p ae h gsrr f e o d o h o p 1 u jc man me ,
e ptng a s h dom an na whih s h Reg sre ha be notfed i wrtng by
xce i ny uc
i mes c uc
itis ve en ii n ii
t Pl ntf ha be n orwilbe dimi s d fom t s a ton, t t N ew Regi t ar A s a
he ai if ve e
l
s s e r hi c i o he
sr .
mat r of lw,t s Se ond TRO s lno l r a y t a De e nt or a s i t
te
a hi c
hal
onge ppl o ny f nda
s oc aed
do an nn edim is fom t saci n.Upon t c nge oft Reg sr rofr cor f
m i m
s s ed ' hi to
r
he ha
he
ita
e d or

t Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Nn s t Ne Re itr wilman an a c s t t e
he o p 1 u j c man me , he w gsr l iti c e s o h
Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na si tu tf rt Co r d rn t p n n yof h sa to
o p 1 u j c man me n r s o he u t u ig he e de c t i cin.
Addii ly,t Ne Re sr r s l i me a ey i tt e a t mpo a y 302 dom an
tonal he w
gita hal m dit l nsiut
e rr
i

n me rd rcin whih wila tmaial r dr c a y v strt t Gr u 1 S b e t
a e ie to
c l uo tc ly e ie t n iio o he o p 1 u j c
Doman Na s t t f lwi Unior
i
me o he olo ng
fm

Res c Loc tr (: '
oure
ao :
URL*
)

ht :/e i otc c gg e /nde ht whe eo c e of t Fis Am e
l /s w nr i e.oe s p i x. ml
r n opi s
he r t
nded

8

Co pl i a a1ot rdoc nt on fl i t s a to a e d s a
m ant nd 1 he
ume s ie n hi ci n r iplyed.Ale a i l , t
t m tve y he

Ne Re ita ma u daet Do i Na Sy tm (DNS' d t i m an ansfrte
w gsrr y p t he man me se ç
ç ' aa t iti o h
)

Gr u 1 Su j c Do i Na s whc l k ted manna st teP a d e s swh r
o p 1 b e t man me , ih i h o i me o h
n
d rse ee
t i as oc aed
her
s it

we ies a e hose ,
bst
r
td

t
o

NSI. EDI
M
ATEM PLE.
NET

a
nd

NSZ. EDI
M
ATEM PLE.
NET,whih wil ca e t do an na
c
l us he m i
mes t r s ve t t
o e ol o he
we ie whe eco esoft Co ant Fis Am e d Compli , Summ o es Se ond
bst
r pi
he mpli , rt
nde
a nt
ns , c
TRO, a al ot r doc e s o fl i t s a ton a e dipl ye . A f e t N e
nd 1 he
um nt n ie n hi c i r s a d t r he w

Re ita ha efce t sc a eteGr u 1 S b e tDo i Na ss al eplc do
gsrr s fe td hi h ng h o p 1 u j c man me h l b a e n
Loc saus pr ve i t m odii to ordelton oft do a nsby t Re sr or
k t t , e ntng he
fcai n
ei
he m i
he gitar
D ef nda s 1 -322;
e nt 78

Plitf ma e trt eGr u 1 Su j c Do i Na sit Go g esW e ma trTo l
anif y n e h o p 1 b e t man me n o o l ' b se o s
a ca ela r die ton oft domai t tha be n e e e t r by De e nt 178
nd nc ny e r c i
he
ns ha ve e nt r d he e
f nda s
-

3 whih r die t ta t t t c e f t o r tons t a ne do an na a
22
c e r c r fk o he ountrei pe ai
o
w m i me nd

t r by e de t pr sonsoft sOr r
he e va he ovi i
hi de ;

1 Ea h De e nts l pr e vec e ofa1t rco put rflsr ai t t us ofa
0. c
f nda hal es r opi s 1 hei m e ie eltng o he e ny

o t e Gr u 1 Su j c Do i Na s a d s altk a1se s n c sa y t rtiv
f h o p 1 be t man me n h l a e 1 tp e e sr o ere e
c mp trflsrlt t t eu eo t eGr u 1 Su j c Do i Na st tma h ve
o u e ie eai o h s f h o p 1 b e t man me ha y a
ng
be n dee e bef r t e r oft sOr r
e lt d o e he nty hi de ;
11 Thi Sec
. s ond TRO s l r ma n i efe tuntlt dae f t he rng on t Se nd
hal e i n f c
i he t or he a i
he co

M oin frPrlmi ayIj n t n stf rhbeo o u tl u h frhe dae a s t yt
to o ei n r nu ci e o t lw, r ni s c u t r ts s e b he
o
Cour or s i a ed t by t pa te ,butunde no c r um s a s s l tls Se ond TRO
t tpul t o
he r i s
r
ic t nce ha l li c

rman i efe tf mo et n fure n ( 4)da fo t daeoft sOr r
e i n f c or r ha o te 1 ys rm he t hi de ;

9

1 Th s S c nd TRO s ala py t t Gr u 1 Su jc Do i Na s a d a y oh r
2. i e o
h l p l o he o p 1 b e t man me n n t e
dom an na e pr ry br htt t Cou tsa tnton by s r a fda twhih verfes
i m s ope l oug o he
r ' te i
wo n fi vi
c
ii
s h ne dom an na
uc w
i mes a e beng us d by De e nt 178 - 3 f t pur e of
r i
e
f nda
22 or he pos
c e f ii t Guc i M aks a i s i tts aci a o t ary c
ount retng he
c
r t s ue n li ton nd/ r mf il ompei wih
tng t
Guc on t W ord W i W e ori co c i wih s r h e ner ulspa ;
ci he
l de b n nne ton t ea c ngi es t ges

1 . u s a t o 1 U. C. 1 1 ()5 ( , anifs almananisp e iusyp tdb n
3 P ru n t 5 S. j 1 6 d ()D) Plitf h l iti t r vo l ose o d
i t e a u tofOn Hu d e Th u a d Dol r a d Ze o Ce t ( 0 ,0 .0 ,m
n h mo n
e n rd o sn
l s n r n s $1 00 00 ) s
a
pa e of da a t w hi h D ef nda s 1 - 322 m a be e il f a w r
ym nt
m ges o
c
e nt 78
y
ntted or
ongf l
u

ij n to o r srit
n u cin r etan ;
1 A he rngi s tbe or t sCo ti t Unie Stt sCou t el a e a 400Norh
4.
a i s e f e hi ur n he t d a e
rhous oc t d t
t
M imiAve ,M im i Fl i 331 Co toom 13- on M a 31, 201 a 2: p. .
a
nue n , orda 28, urr
1,
y
2, t 00 m ,
ora s h ot rtm et tt sCou tde m sa o it a whih tm eDe e nt 1 t uc he i ha hi
r e ppr pra e, t c i
f nda s 78
322 a lora ot rafec e pe s m a c le t a opt a e s oft s Or r
nc/ ny he f t d r ons y ha l nge he ppr i t ne s hi de

a movet dis vet s m ea a whih tm et Cour wilhe a gu e on
nd
o s ol he a nd t c i he
t l ar r m nt

Plitf rq e tdprlmi r ij n t n;
anifs e u se ei nay nu ci
o
1 Pli if s l s r c e of t Co ant Fis Ame d Compl i , Se ond
5. antf ha l e ve opi s
he mpli , rt
nde
ant c

Applcai f TRO,a t sSe nd TRO a a1o he pla ngsa doc e son 5l
i ton or
nd hi co
nd 1 t r e di
nd um nt
e
i t sa ton on De e nt 1 -3 by e ala de c i d a
n hi c i
f nda s 78 22
m i s s rbe bovea by posi co es
nd
tng pi
of t Se nd Applc ton f TRO a t s Se ond TRO on t we ie l a e a
he co
i ai or
nd hi c
he bst oc t d t

hhp:/e nr otc c ggsp /ndex. lwihi f t eg ( )hour ofc r oft
/swi ie.oY e i h% t n ory-iht 48
s ontol he

Gr u 1 S be tDo i Na s b i c n e t t e Co r v a te Ne Re ita '
o p 1 u j c man me eng ha g d o h u t i h w g srrs
hol ng a ount a s h notc s gi n s l be de m e good a s fc e s r i e
di cc , nd uc
i e o ve hal
e d
nd ufi i nt e v c
t r of Pl i i fs l contnue t pr de notc oft s pr ee ngs a c e oft
he e . a ntf ha l
i
o ovi
i e he e oc di
nd opi s he

10

doc nt on Il i t s m a tr t De e nt 1 - 322 by r a l upda i t
ume s
ie n hi
te o f nda s 78
egulry
tng he
we ie l t a htp:/e i o i .oe ggs p /nde ht l or by ot r m e ns
bst ocaed t t /s w nr tcec
e i x. m
he
a
r s bl c c ae t gi notce whi h a e pe m itd by t Cour. A ny r ponse or
ea ona y alul td o ve i
c r r te
he
t
es

o p sto t Plitf s Se o d M oin f rPr l n r Ij n to mu tbe fld a d
p o iin o anif c n
to o ei a y n u cin s
mi
ie n
s r ed on Pl i ifsc
ev
antf ouns lprort t hea i s tf M a 31, 201 a fl d wih t
e i o he rng e or y
2, nd ie t he
Co t a o wih Pr ofSe vi ,on orbe o e M a 29,2 . Pli ifs l fl a
ur, l ng t oof
r ce
fr
y
012 antf hal ie ny
Re y M e o a
pl
m r ndum on orbe or M a 31 201 The a
f e y , 2.
bove da e m a be r vi e upo
ts y
e sd n
si a i by a1pa te a a ova oft sCou t Def nda s 1 -322 a ehe e on
tpulton
1 ris nd ppr l hi
r.
e nt 78
r r by
notc t tf iur t a a a t hea i m a r s ti t i
i e ha a l e o ppe r t he rng y e ul n he mposton ofa pr i na y
ii
elmi r

ij n to a an t h m p ru n t 1 U. C. 1 1 ( )a dFe . Ci . 6 .
n u cin g is t e u s a t o 5 S. j 1 6 d n d R. v P. 5
DONE ANl ORDERED i c mbe sa M im i Fl i , ti T
D
n hs r t a , orda h p

4
.

C
C'

o M a , 01
f y 2 2.

*

MI
CHM L M OORE
TED STATES DI
STRI J GE
CT UD

A 1 co e ofr cor
1 uns l e d

11

SC H ED U LE R H
A
DEFEN DA N TS BY D EFEN DA N T NU M BER A ND SU BJECT DO M M N NA M ES
Dee
f ndant#
1
78
1
79
1
80
181
1
82
1
83
1
84
1
85
1
86
1
87
1
88
1
89
1
90
1
91
1
92
1
93
1
94
1
95
1
96
1
97
1
98
1
99
200
201
202
203
20
4
205
206
207
208
209
21
0
211
21
2
21
3
21
4
21
5
21
6
21
7
21
8

D om ai N am e
n
36oknoc f .
kof scom
sl he ha ba sc
c a nd
.om
sl
knoc f . m
kofsco
aaccess
o ow .
com
aite a hi co
ltl f s on. m
l or ba .om
m e c
a e lc ba sc
r ia
.om
itbur .
ts
com
ba ba . z
bi
ba oute f c o . t
lta t ne
ba oute onlne . t
lt i sne
ba oute s a t y ne
l t f c ol t
ba oute s i . t
l t onlne ne
ba s r lca s
- e i - ho i .om
n c
ba s r lca -ho . g
-e i s s or
be t e om
ls nc
be a hie. t
t l ne
bu ba s ltc
oute .om
bu c a cconlne.om
he
i i c
bu ucc w a l t . om
i le s c
bu o ba .
or
buyt ba sor
o
.
bu o ha ba . t
nd gs ne
bu - o - e lc .
t r i asor
bu a c ho .r
t hs o
ca e s c
s ba . om
c sor
ba .
c a c be t- l.om
he
ci ls malsc
c a c ons l .om
he
ci aesc
c
hea c oute onlne.
ci l t i or
c
hea c - ho . om
cis c
c
hea c s
ciho i . m
n co
c
hea ur e di c
s s s ountc
. om
chea s l
un assess er.
al com
c ot s a l a e c
l he m ls l . om
coa h tr es
c l s 4che . m
a co
c i bl . om
urous ue c
de i a i
s tonbel. m
tco
de i e cl r nce i c
s r ea a onlne.om
de i e ha ba s hea e tco
s r nd
c
s. m
dicount cc- sne
s
- iba . t
12

21
9
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
25
2
253
25
4
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263

dic handba d.om
s ount
c
dot r ndba s or
e ha
.
e
ba ucc .om
ic
e a ms . om
l sc
e ux 4u. m
l
co
e o a wac .
n' ke t hescom
e ui ie . t
x stba ne
f r ndba s .om
aiha
sc
f ke ls .om
a betsc
f ke c i ls . m
a
cbet sco
f nt c . m
a ac co
f r he e s l . om
o c a r a ec
a a a ndba sc
l xyiha
.om
i ut c
Rc e.om
l ba ucc s o e.om
o l it r c
oi ndba .om
nha
c
ooddes e ha
i r ndba sc
.om
oods i sc
busnes .om
o-e lc ha
r ia- ndba scom
.
guc ba s e lt . m
ci aloute sco
ucc ha
i ndba s scom
ho .
c ha
ci ndba s e lc s c
r i a . om
uc oute - ea a .om
ci l tcl r ncec
c oute es a e c
ci l t s l . om
uc i t e es a e . om
c ou l t s l s c
c oute - ac o sc
ci l t f t . om
uc i lt c .om
coute cic
cc- ute - c - ndba sco
io lt ciha
. m
c iou l mal.
c - tet lcom
ccoute onlne c
i lt i 4.om
cc- lt i - .om
ioute onlne sc
uc oute o i so e. o
ci lt nlne t r i
nf
c oute a t .om
ci l r c
c oute - al s . om
ci l t s e s c
uc i oute - a e s or com
c - l ts l - t e.
c oute s i s .net
ci l t onlne ho
c i l t o e.
c oute v
com
cc r 1c 201 com
i e i a 2.
c ie lc ba s nd sc
cr i a ha ba .om
cc s e l tco
i al oute . m
cc s l s oute . om
i a e s l tc
cc s l t al s com
i oute s e .
uc s or bu .
ci t e com
c s mcom
ci z
ha
ndba - s c
ba e.om
13

264
265
266
267
268
269
27
0
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282

ha
ndba - s ne
ba e. t
ha
ndba s ea a oute . m
cl r nce l tco
ha
ndba slf s l .om
-ie t ec
hbos a. .n
t or c
hi -e lc ha
r ia- ndba sco
.
hi - lca ha
r i s ndba sne
. t
ihe ha
c a ndba sc
.om
i alr de t e. m
de ta sor co
i c oute s e.
t ci ltal com
kis
s wom e ac .om
nw thesc
knoc f s hea .om
kof ba c
c
knoc f nlnec
kofo i .om
l s tonba s e dysco
ouivuit
e . m
l uix it
o s tonwac s o e c
the f = n.om
l i lne. m
uxuresi co
l ywa c o . om
uxur t hc
c
ne f kew a c s c
w a
t he . om
ne c onlne a ec
w ci i s l .om
ne s l -r ndscom
w t e te .

23
8

n les s he a t n i.o
f re c a uhe tcc m
j

28
4
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
30
4
305
306
307
308

onlne ou on.om
i
c
oute s c i a e. t
l t c s l ne
ue nha ba . m
e nd co
r lc wathe .
e ia8 c scom
r lc l l r nc c
e i avcea a e.om
r lc s . om
e i a sc
r lc wa c s im .om
e i a t he fr c
r lc wa c onlne. m
e i a t h- i co
s a o i nd sc
e s naha ba .om
s l al . m
elm lsco
s f l
ho oruxu c ot s c
l he . om
s knoc fc
ho
kof om
s lke ot n . om
ho i cl hi c
sa e heln. t
tnl
i ne
s or nv .
t e com
t nks
ha ho e s c
r . om
t de i r e lc co
he sgner i a. m
tw ba sco
i
. m
t one. m
obee co
t - encom
o bu
t l s it hea .om
o oui vu tonc
c
t - e lca. z
o r i bi
ta
r deke .
m com
ta nlnes s c
r deo i hoe . om
u c i ndba sne
k c ha
. t
1
4

309
31
0
311
31
2
31
3
31
4
31
5
31
6
317
318
31
9
320
321
322

uk- t hessor .om
wa c - t ec
us c i l t a e c
a c oute s l . om
us cc oute - al c
a
i l t s e. om
us bhasc
ml t.om
vi - ndba s.
ha
or
vo e s e.
ba al com
wac s e r . z
the c ntebi
wache c .om
t so c
wac s nt rs .om
the e e iec
wa c s i co.om
t he onlne c
w e roi r sc
a t m es .om
whols l fc
e a e om
y ha
our ndba s it . m
fsco
z
vba .om
c

15