Aerosoft GMBH v. John Does 1-50
Filing
6
ORDER Granting 4 Motion for Leave to Serve Third Party Subpoenas Prior to the Rule 26(f) Conference Subject to a Protective Order. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/16/2012. (lbc)
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STR I T C O U RT
C
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CA SE NO.1 21 C1 SE1 Sl ONTON
2- 489- V- TZ/ M
AER O SO FT GM BH ,
Pl n i f
ai tf ,
V.
JOHN DOES 150,
Def nda s
e nt .
/
ORDER GRANTI G PLAI FF' M OTI FOR LEAVE TO SERVE THI PARTY
N
NTI S
ON
RD
SUBPO ENAS PRI TO THE RULE 26( CONFERENCE SUBJECT TO A
OR
:
PROTECTI ORDER
VE
THI M ATTER i be or t Co t n Pl i ifsM otonf Le vet Se v Thid Pa t
S
s f e he ur upo antf
i or a o r e r ry
S b o na P irt Rue2 ( Co ee c ( 4 i t i lws i algn die ta dc nrb tr
u p e s ro o l 6 9 nfrn e DE- ) n hs a ut l ig rc n o tiuo y
e
c i i rnge tconc r ngt downl di a s rngofavi o ga tte f r X .
opyrght nfi men
e ni he
oa ng nd ha i
de me il d s bus '
Ai
'
Pli ifseksla t s vel e SeviePr de sCtSPs' wihs
antf e e ve o er ntmet r c ovi r I ' t ubpoena puruan oFe rl
)
s s tt dea
Ru e of Ci l Pr e e 45 i or r t o a n t i tf ng i or a i f t s c i r l
l
vi oc dur
n de o bt i he den iyi nf m ton or he ubs rbe s
asocitd wih I er tPrt a e s s(tP a ese ' . Spe ii ly,Pl ntf r quesst
s ae t nt ne oocol ddrs e ( ddr ss'
1
)
cfcal ai if e t he
s c i r 'names a e s s,t e
ubs rbe s
, ddr s e elphone numbe s e mai a es es a M edi Ac s Contol
r , - l ddr s , nd
a ce s
r
a r s esi or rt s r et De e nt wih pr e s
dd e s n de o e v he f nda s t oc s .
Ha n rviwe t eCo lit n t ls o I a d e s satc e t eeo( I DE- - )
vig e e d h mpan a d he it f P d r se ta h d h rt DE- , 1 1
I s c i ri t pe s whoha anag e
A ubs rbe s he ron
s
r emen wih t l t us l e ne s r ce.
t t he SP o e ntr t evi
andPl nifsM oi a a c
aitf' ton nd c ompa ngafdavi( 4, 5 1 ,heCourwil a t Moton.
nyi fi tDE- DE- - jt
t lgrnthe i z
Howe r t Co twilis a pr e tve or r Pur ua tt Fe r Rul ofCi lPr d e
ve , he ur l s ue
ot c i
de . s n o de al e
vi oce ur
26()1,dhecourma f goodc us ,suea or rt pr tc apa t orperonfom annoya e,
c( )t
t
t y,or
a e is n de o oe t ry
s r
nc
e ba r s m e , pr s i orunduebur nore pe e. He e t Cour fndsgoodca et is
m ra s nt op e son,
de
x ns ' r ,he
'
ti
us o s ue
a pr e tve o de be a e t s c i r as ocit d wih t I a es es i ntfed i t
ot ci r r c us he ubs rbe s s a e
t he P ddr s de ii n he
Compl i m a notbet i vi swho il a l do oa d a s r t vi ga
ant y
he ndi dual
leg ly wnl de nd ha ed he deo me. Thi
s
i be us whe m uli e c
s ca e
n
tpl omput r c me tt t I t r tt ough ar e ,he m a s r a I
e s or c o he n e ne hr
out r t y y ha e n P
addr s .A ss h, l t r i asngl s c i rf t I addr s ,
es
uc whie he e s i e ubs rbe or he P
e s nume ouspe em a us t
r
opl y e he
c
omput r t tc
e s ha onne tt t l e ne t ough t r e t thast tI a e s Thi co dbet
c o he nt r t hr
he out r ha
ha P ddr s . s ul
he
c ei abusnes ,
as n
i s hous hol a rm e buidi orador t y. l f t onec tr c nty t
e d, pa t nt l ng,
mior n ac ,
our e e l ook
j dca n tc o te fc t a 61p r e to U. h me n w ha ewiee sa c s . S eI r
u iil oie f h a t h t e c n f S. o s o v r ls c e s e n e
BiT r e t utFim Co yrgh Ik ige n Ca e ,2 2 U. Dit LEXI 61 4 a * - 1
t o r n Ad l l p i t n n me t s s 01 S. s.
S 4 7, t 8* 3
( D. . M a 1 201 ( de and Re ta Re omme ton)(i ng t tt c ci
E. N Y. y , 2) Or r
por nd c
ndai fndi ha he onne ton
bewe nt s ci ra c i i rnge i i e sngl tnuous .Si lry,o c
t e he ubs rbe nd opyrght nfi r s ncra i y e
) mial ne ompuer
t
m a be us d by muli e pe e. Thus whiet c putrhasa sngl I a es e c tm e i
y
e
tpl opl
s l he om e
i e P ddr s a h i t
c
onne t t t l e ne ,a one s c i r m uli e peo e may us t tc
c s o he nt r t nd
ubs rbe , tpl
pl
e ha omput r Thus t
e.
, he
s crbe sa eno ne s a iy t i vi l who i rng t co i t
ubs i r r t ce s rl he ndi duas
nfi ed he pyrgh .
Ac r ngl due t t rs of f l e i ii a i of i rnge s a pr e tve or r i
co di y,
o he ik
a s denttc ton
nf i r ,
ot c i
de s
2 we e, t epa t saermid dta F d rl l o CiiPr c d r 2 ()2 p o ie ta d fn a t
Ho v r h ri r e n e h t e e a Rue f vl o e ue 0 a() r vd s h t ee d ns
e
ma be on di o ea to i a yrg t orl firse)o t ftesmeta s cin, cure c , rsre o
y j ie n n cin f n ih t ei s ils u o h a rn a t o c rn e o eis f
e a
o
ta acinsoroc r esandan que tonof1w orfctcomm ont aldefnda swila iei t a ton.'The
rns to
curenc
y si
a
a
o l e nt l rs n he c i '
Co r wil o a de sa ti tme wh te teDee d nsaep o el on da s o teI a de ssma b
ut ln t d rs, ths i , eh r h fn a t r r p ryj ie s ome f h P d rse y e
o e b asn l Dee d n, c wo l rn e teis eo j id r o a t tos Dee d ns Ho v r fr
wn d y ige fn a twhih ud e d rh su fon e mo t s o h e fn a t. we e,o
oh rDee a t,h Co rma c nsd ra altrd t, ih ru o moino s as ne wh te j id ri p o r
te fnd ns te u t y o ie ,t ae ae ete p n to r u po t, eh r on e s rpe
ba e ont f tt tt s bs i r we epr enti t s r ondifr ntdaysa atdif enttmesi ca i
s d he ac ha he u crbe s r es n he wa m
fe e
nd
fer i ndi tng
t t ymaynotha s rd t vi o ga wih e chot r.
hat he
ve hae he de me t a he
ne e s r t per i t J hn Doe De e nt a t I t cha lng t s
c s a y o m t he o
f nda s nd he SPS o le e he ubpoe s be or
na f e
i ntf ngi or toni pr de t Pl ntf a ort adviet Cour t tt yi e t pr e d
de iyi nf ma i s ovi d o ai if nd/ o
s he
tha he nt nd o oc e
ano
nymousy.Alhough t Coul r c ni es t tt rs of emba r s m e a s a e wih
l
t
he
. e og z ha he ik
t
r a s nt s ocit d t
al ge y ilga l down oa ng a s rnga vi o ga ei nota l
le dl le ly
l di nd ha i
de m s
naogoust t rs i tte i
o he ik den ii d n
ca esi vi por r ph s e eg. gialSi,I v.
s nvol ng nog a y, e . . Di t n nc. John Doe l- 7 201 U . Dit LEXI
s 1 <, 2 S. s.
S
1 0 a *8*1 ( D. Y.a u r 3 2 2 ,hep oe tv o d ri n c sa yd et t ei rcs
08 3,t - 1 S. N. J n ay 0, 01 )t r tci e r e s e e sr u o h mp e ie
m a rus d t i ntf al ge i rnge st ough I a es e Lasl Pl n ifma onl obt i
nne e o de iy le d nfi r hr
P ddr s s. ty, aitf y y an
t s c i r ' na e , a e s ,a M e a Ac s Contol add e s s a Pli if ha no
he ubs rbe s m s ddr s es nd
di
ce s
r
r s e s antf s t
a tc a e whyine ds hes c i r 'elphonenum be sa e ala es es Acc di y,
ri ult d
t e t ubs rbe s t e
r nd m i ddr s . or ngl upon
r vi w ,i i
e e ts
ORDERED t tPli ifsM otonf Le vet Se veThid Pa t Subpoe sPrort Rul
ha antf '
i or a o r
r ry
na i o e
2 4 Co ee c ( 4 i GRANTED;
6 9 nfrn e DE- 1 s
I I FURTHER ORDERED t t antf m a i e ae ys r Rul 45s
TS
ha pl i if y mm di tl e ve e ubpoe s whi h
na , c
a elmie t t f l ng c e i sofe ttesand i or ai
r i t d o he olowi atgore
n ii
nf m ton:
F o l tr e S r iePr vdes l Ps ie tfe i hbiAt teCo litDE- -1 n
r m nen t e vc o i r (S ) d n iid nEx i t o h mp an ( 1 1 a d
a o he I i ntfe a apr de ofl t r ts r i est oneoft J hnDoeDe e nt
ny t r SP de ii d s ovi r n e ne e v c o
he o
f nda s
i rs e t a s
n e pons o
ubpoe or a a r ul of ongoi BiTorent a tviy m onio i
na
s es t
ng t r
ci t
t rng:
i or to s fce t ieniy e h Defnda , s i ly name c r (
nf main ufiint o d tf ac
e nt pecûcal
, ur ent and
per
manent addr s and M edi Acc s Co r addre s Thes
)
es,
a e s ntol
s.
ubpoena s lha a
hal ve
c
opy oft s O r at ac d.
hi der t he
I I FURTHER ORDERED t t heI wil ve60da fom t da eofs r ceoft
T S
ha t SPS l ha
ys r he t
e vi
he
Ru e45s
l
ubpoenaupont m t s r J Does1- 0w ihac oft s
he o e ve ohn
5 t opy he ubpoe a ac oft s
na nd opy hi
3
Or r The I m a s l J Does 1 50 us ng any r a ona e m e ns i udi wr te no i
de .
SPS y e' ohn
ve
i
e s bl a , ncl ng i t n tce
s ntt he orhi ls knownaddr s tans it d et rby fr tcls m a l vi ove ni delve y.
e o r
s at
e s r m te ihe
is - a s i or a r ght i r
I I FURTHER ORDERED t tJ
T S
ha ohn Does 1 50 s l ha 30 days fom t dat of
- hal ve
r he e
s r c oft Rul 45 s
e vi e he e ubpoe a t sOr e u n he orhi t fl a m otonswih t sCou t
na nd hi d r po r
m o ie ny i
t hi
r
co e tngt s poe (ncudi amotont quahormodiyt s
ntsi he ub na i l ng
i o s
f he ubpoe )a wel anyr s
na, s las eque t
t ltga e t s
o ii t he ubpoe a
na nonym ous y. The I
l
SP: m a nott n o r t John Doe D e e
y
ur ve he
f ndant
s'
i ntf ng i or at on t Pl ntf be or t e r i oft J0- y pe i Addii l
de i yi nf m i o ai i f f e he xpi aton
he da
r od.
tonaly,
i a D e endantor I fl s a m oton t quas t s
f
f
SP ie
i o
h he ubpoe t I
na, he SP: m ay not t o r a
urn ve ny
i or aton t Pl ntf untlt is havebe n addr s e and t Cour i s :an O r r
nf m i o ai if i he s ue:
e
esd
he
t s ue
de
i t i t I
ns ructng he SPS t r s e i t ni overt r que t d di co r H ow e , i t s
o e um n ur ng
he e s e s ve y.
ver dur ng hi
tm e t I s lpr s rv any s
i , he SPS hal e e e
ubpoe
naed i or aton.
nf m i
I I FU RTH ER ORD ERED t t i t 30T S
ha f he
day pe i l e w ihout a John D oe
r od aps s t
Dee
f ndant or I co es i t s
SP nt t ng he ubpoe t I
na, he SPS s l ha 10 da t pro e t
hal ve
ys o
duc he
i or at on re pons ve t t s
nf m i
s
i o he ubpoe t Pl nt f .
na o ai i f
I I FURTHER ORDERED t ta i or ai dic os t t Pl ntf i r pons t
T S
ha ny nf m ton s l ed o he ai if n es e o
aRul 45s poe m a beus dbyt Pli ifs el f rt pu os of ot tngPli ifsrg s
e ub na y
e
he antf ol y o he m e pr eci
antf i ht
ass tf t i isCo pl nt
e orh n t m ai ;
I SFURTHER ORDERED t tPli ifa t I whor e ve s
TI
ha antf nd he SPS
ec i ubpoe s l c er
nas ha l onf ,
i ne es a y,t r ol a pay e i s s f t i o ton r quesed i t s poe or f
f c s r o es ve ny m nt s ue or he nf nna i e
t n he ub na, or
rs utonofI a ese whih ( aenotc r l byt I ( du iaeI a e s st t
e ol i
P ddr s s c a) r
ontoled he SPS;b) plc t P ddrs e ha
rs ve t t s me i vi l ()ot rI a r sest do notpr de t na a ot
e ol o he a ndi dua; c he P dd e s hat
ovi he me nd her
i or to rquese ofa uni i vi l or( f t I 'i e a c t t noiy is
nf main e td
que ndi dua; d) or he SPS ntm l oss o tf t
4
s bsrbeswh a et es b e to t ei f r to r q e t
u ci r o r h u j c f h n o main e u s;
I I FURTHER ORDERED t ta 1 t tr c ve a s
T S
ha ny SP ha e ei s ubpoenaa eec st c r ef
nd l t o ha g or
t c t ofpr tons l pr d abilng s ma yanda c tr porst ts vea aba i f
he oss
oduci ha l ovi e li um r
ny os e t ha er s ss or
s h bilng s m ma y a a c t cai e by s I Any c t cl me s lb r as
uc li u
r nd ny oss l m d
uch SP.
oss ai d hal e e onabl
e.
DO A O DE E i MimiFoiatiJ N dyo Ma,02
NE ND R R D n a ,lr ,hs Q a f y2 1.
d
PATRI A A.SE Z
CI
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
cc:
Honor bl Andr aM . mont
a e
e
Si
on
A1 c
l ouns lofr c d
e
e or
5
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?