Cruz v. United States of America

Filing 31

ORDER granting 10 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 1/31/2013. (tkn)

Download PDF
UNI TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR THE CT SO UTHERN D I STRI O F FLO RI CT DA M i m iD i s on a vi i C as N um be 1 21 8- I - O R ENO e r: 2- 51 C V M MI CHAEL CRUZ, Pl i if a ntf , VS. THE UNI TED STATES OF AM ERI CA, De e f ndant . / O R DER G M NTI G M O T I N FO R SU M M A R Y JUD G M EN T N O THI CAUSE c S ame be or t Cour upon Def ntUnie St t ofAm e i sM oton f e he t enda td a es rca' i f rSlmmay J o l r udgmen ( E.No.1 ,fl on November8.2012. I flng t moton,t t D. 0) ied n ii he i he gove n e tc e t tPl ntf M iha Cr ca r m n ont nds ha ai if c el uz nnotesabls hi m e c lne i enc cli t ih s di a glg e am unde Fl i 1 w be a eheha f l t pr r orda a c us s aied o oduc awine st e t bls t sanda d ofc r For e t s o sa ih he t r a e. t f l ng r as ,t s Cour a ee w ih t gove n e a g a s is m oto f sl m a y he olowi e ons hi t gr s t he r m nt nd r nt t i n or lm r ' J me . udg nt 1 FACTUAL BACKGROUND . W hiea f r li t i t cusod oft Bur a ofPrs a t Fe a De e i l ede a nma e n he t y he e u ions t he der l t nton Ce tri M imiFlrd , litf Cr zs fee a e eij r i Fe r ay2 0 OnFe r ay n e n a , o ia P an if u u frd n y n u y n b u r 0 9. bu r 11 2009,Cr r por e a dec e s i vi i i hi l f e . The f l i day, r c ve a , uz e t d r a e n s on n s e t ye olow ng he e ei d n opt tye m fo Dr W arnK.Gr s .Gr sdignosdCr zwihama a ij yt t omer xa r m . re os .Dr os a e u t culr nur ha c us d t de r as i vi i a r c m e a e he c e e n son nd e om nded t tCr r ce ve a t olow up' opht l ol ha uz e i d l f ' ha m ogy e l to va ua i n. Ove t f l wi we ks Cr z r pe t dl r que t d t Bur a t s he et s r he olo ng e , u e a e y e se he e u o c dul hi e l to Unf t t l Cr z di nots e a oph hal ogituntlJ 23, va uai n. oruna ey, u d e n t mol s i une 2009,o rf l ve otr mont a t Dr Gr ssr f ral Thephyscin c hs fer . os ' e e r . i a onduc i t se l ton di gnos Cr a tng hi va ua i a ed uz s ha ng ar tna deac vi e i l t hmen a r ere Cr t Dr M . a t nd ef r d uz o . Br ndon Pa r t ar tna s ge a rot, e i l ur on t Ba com Pam e Eyel tt ei M i mi On J y 2,2009,Dr Pa r tc l d t tCr z s l r nsiut n a . ul . rot onc ude ha u r quie s ge y, c her ceved o J y 1 2009. Ye ,de piet s ge y, u pr s nty e r d ur r whi h e i n ul 3, t s t he ur r Cr z e e l s f r f om a a m os c pl t l sofvi i i hi l te uf e s r n l t om e e os son n s ef ye. On Aprl23, 2,Cr z fl t pr en c i 201 u ied he es t ompli a ns De e ant gai t f ndan Unie St t sof t td ae Amerc u t Fe r Tor Cl msAct(t ia nder he deal t ai ç FTCA' , l ngt tt Bur uofPrs was ' alegi ha he ea ) ions ne i en i f lngt tm ey r f Cnz t an opht l ogitpurua t Dr Gr s s glg t n aii o i l e er z o ha mol s s nt o . os ' i t c i .Folowi t ans rfom t gove n nsm tons l ng he we r he r ment t sCour is d iss he i or r ,hi t s ue t c dulng de on J 28,201 s ti Oc obe 25,201 ast de dlnet c une 2 e tng t r 2 he a i o omplt dic yandNovembe e e s over r 8 2 2a ted a l ef rfl moinsf rml r u g n . , 01 s h e di o ii n ng to o mmayj d me t Acc di y,t go nme s r d Cr zwih isfr tr que tf pr or ngl he ver nt e ve u t t is e s or oduci n a isfr t to nd t s s tofi e r t i so J 29,201 The ei e r t re i l e nt rogaore n une 2. s nt roga o is ncuded ar ques f re r e t o xpe t w ines di c os es Cr t r afe f l d hi r pons s on Aug t 1 201 t o w e ks a t t t s s l ur . uz he e t r ie s es e us 5, 2, w e fer he dueda e l r s ns t t r que tf e twines dic os es Cr z sa e S t . n e po e o he e s or xper t s s l ur , u t t d:t undee m i d tr ne a t stme. Cr z a s i ntfe Dr Paro t hi te tng physca wih knowl t hi i ' u lo de ii d . r t as s r a i ' i in t edgeofhi s 1 lrl nJ l es. M tc pa i e r di c os e f om Cr z, he gove n e r t ne an e r i i tng xpe t s l ur s r u t r m nt e ai d xpe t opht mol s,Dr W iln E.Smi y.Thegove mnen lt rs heduld a i pe nt hal ogit . lim dd r t ae c e n nde nde me c levaua i ofCr z byDr Sm i dia l ton u . ddy. AtCr z' de ii on Oc obe 21 201 t u s poston t r , 2, he gove nme i r whe he Cr zha r t ne an e r. Addii l upon Cnl sr que tf r nt nquied t r u d eai d xpe t tonaly, z' e s or Dr Smi sr por, hegove nme i or . ddy' e tt r nt nf med Cr z t i woul notcala e r wine sa u hat t d l n xpe t t s t til a t r f ewoul notpr eDr Smi y' r por, fCr hi e fdi notr t n a ra , nd he e or d oduc . dd s e ti uz ms l d e ai n e r .Cr a s m e i d a t de ii t the woul s e l a fo t Cour t e e xpe t uz lo ntone t he poston ha d e k e ve r m he t o xtnd t dic r de dlne. he s ove y a i On Ocober23,201 Cr notfedt gove n e t theha ye t r ceve t t 2, uz ii he r m nt ha d t o e i he gove nme ' i ta dicl tr spuruantt Fe r lRul ofCi lPr edur 26.The r nts nii l s osze s o de a e vi oc e gove nme i e a ey s ntt m t Cr o itng a menton ofDr Sm i a Cr ha not r nt mm dit l e he o uz, m ti ny i . ddy s uz d r t ne a e r.Thedic os esf rhe a knowl d t tDr Gr steae Cr a a eai d n xpe t s l ur u t r c edge ha . os r td uz s n op ome rs .The go r ntne rr eve r c pr a dic os esfom Cr t tit ve nme ve ec i d e i oc l s l ur r uz. On Ocober25,201 bot pa te tl amoton f e e i ofpr tilde dlnes Tha t 2, h ri s sed i or xt nson era a i . t moton i c t d t tt pa te woul e ge i expe tdic y t fne s a y, but di not i ndi a e ha he ris d nga n r s over l ce s r ' i ' d ot m i e i ntf an expe t J ntM o .f Ext nson ofPr t i D ea i s at2,ECF N o.7. Thi he s de iy r . oi t or e i e ral dlne , s Cour de e t m o i onN o mbe 5,201 Cons ue l t pa tesi pe ntyagr e t t nid he ton ve r 2. eq nty,he ri nde nde l e d o c ompl t a1 nec s a y dicove y. ee l e s r s r Th g v r me tfld t ep e e tmo in f rs mma yj d me to No e e 8 2 2, e o e n n ie h rs n to o u r u g n n v mb r , 01 lr l pr di a e upon Cr sf iur t dic os a e r t e t bls c us ton.Onewee lt r a gey e c t d uz' al e o s l e n xpe t o sa ih a a i k ae onNo vembe 1 201 Cr f t frttmedicl e a expe twines ,Dr Aln M . l t As r 6, 2, uz or he is i s os d n r t s . a Siber. t sCou t notgr nt d lav t Cr t dicos a ex r pos- s r t gove n e fl d hi r had a e e e o uz o s l e n pe t tdicove y, he r m nt ie a i ta moto t srkeDr Sibe t a e r wine s Cr t n fld ar pons t t moton n nii l i n o ti . l r as n xpe t t s . uz he ie es e o he i on D e em be 5,201 i w hi h he i c t d t tD r Pa r tw oul t s iy t t Cnz woul have c r 2 n c ndi a e ha . r ot d e tf ha z d r c r d s eofhi vii ha t Bur a r f re hi i atm el m n r l a ton, uzfld e ove e om s son d he e u e e r d m n i y nne . n ddii Cr ie an tc o fl gd c me t i o p sto otemoi nfrs mmayj d me t nDe e e 7, 01 oie fii o u ns n p o iint h to o u r u g n o c mb r 2 2 n c ani decar i fom bot Dr Gr s a Dr Pa r ta s ri t t Bur u' dely onti ng l atons r h . os nd . rot s e tng hat he ea s a c rbut dt Cr svii l s Thegove nme s e ntyfl das co motononDec mbe onti e o uz' son os . r nt ubs que l ie e nd i e r 11 201 t pr l Dr Gr sa Dr Pa r tfo ofe i e r opi ons Thi Co tgr nt , 2 o ecude . os nd . rot r m f rng xpe t ni . s ur a ed bot oft gove n tsm otonsonJ h he r men ' i anua y22, 3, e l ng Cr fom usng t physc a r 201 pr cudi uz r i he ii ns ase r wines e .Se Or rGr ntngM ott Sti Expe tW ine sa M o .o Sti De l . nd xpe t t s s e de a i .o rke r t s nd t t rke c s a ExcudeExpe tOps,ECF No. l r . 30. Th g ven n no manan i ismoin f rs mmay j dg n t tCnl c n o e o r me t w itis n t t o u r u me t ha z a n t o esa ihhi cli f me c lne i nc asFl i lw r quie e r t si tbls s am or di a glge e orda a e r s xpe t e tmonyt deer net o t mi he sa r ofc r i s h c es nce Cr c nnotpr e a e r t deer net sa r of t nda d a e n uc as .Si uz a oduc n xpe t o t mi he t nda d c r ,h g v r me t o tn t a i i e t ldt j d me t samatrof a Al nmt ey te a e t e o e n n c n e ds h t t s ni e o u g n a t te lw. t i l,h e v gove n nt a g s t i ca r me r ue hat t nnotbe la e f a ne i nc a ti a e t Dr Gr s as t ibl or ny glge e trbutbl o . os he physca acedasan i pende con r c orouti t s ope oft FTCA . i in t nde nt ta t sde he c he I I LEG A L STA ND AR D I. A c u t halg a t tn r j d me ti th mo a ts o t t h r i n g n n o r s l r n su may u g n f û e v n h ws ha t ee s o e uie t d s uea t a ymae ilfc a dtemo a ti e t ldt j g n a ama tro lw. Fe R. ip t s o n tra a t n h v n s ni e o ud me t s t f a ' d. t e ' Ci P. 6 a .Co s q e ty t emo n S e r teiiil ep nsblt o if r n tedsrc v. 5 () n e u n l,h va tç as h nta r s o i ii f n o mig h itit b y c toft ba i f ismoton,a i ntf ng t epori ofShepl a ngs de ii ns our he ss or t i nd de iyi hos tons t e di , posto , a we st i e r t i ,a ad isonson tl ,t t rwih t afi vis i a 'whih i ns r o ntroga ores nd m s i ie oge he t he fda t , f ny, c t be ive de le s monsr t t a e ofage ne is ofma e i f c . Se Cel e Cor v ta e he bs nce nui s ue t ral a t' e otx p. . ' Car t, 7 U.. 7 3 3( 9 6 .W h r ap rytal t ma eas wigs fce t oe tb ih tet 4 7 S 31 , 2 1 8 ) ee at t is o k ho n ufiin t sa ls f t e s e e ofa e em e e s nta t t tpa t sca e a on w hi t tpa t w ilbe rt he xit nc n l nt s e i l o ha ry' s , nd ch ha ry l a he bu de ofpr a ti l't pl i l ngua ofRul 56 C a t st en r ofs m a y r n oof t r a , he a n a ' ge e t nda e he t y m um r 1 I r pons Cr z c ede t tt govenm e i no labl f Dr G r ssa tons butonl bec us Dr r nt s t i e or . os ' c i , n es e, u onc s ha he y a e . Gr sdi no a tne i l Rat r Cr zaserst tt gover ntsalege ne i ntbe vi oc r atr os d t c glgenty. he, u s t ha he mne ' l d glge ha or cured fe Dr Gr smadehi r er . Fort ras sae bel t Cou tdoesnotnee t addr st sis . os s efral he e ons ttd ow, he r do es hi sue. j d me t'1 . t3 2 u g n. d a 2 . ' 1 1 DI 1 . SCUSSI ON I ismo inf rs mmayj d me tt g v r me tag e p i rl ta Flrd lw n t to o u r u g n,he o e n n r u s rmaiy h t o ia a r quiese tt tm o i or rt esabls bot t sa r ofc r a ca ai n i medial e r xper esi ny n de o t ih h he t nda d a e nd us to n c ne i enc c e .Bec us Cnz f l t dicl e potnta e twines esbef r t Co ts glg e as s a e z aied o s os e il xper t s o e he ur' dic r de dlneandt r f r c nnote t bls e s tale e nt ofhi m e c neg i nc s ove y a i he e o e n sa ih s en i l me s s dial lge e cam,heg v r me tu g steCo r t g a ts mmayj d me t M o e ve,h g ven n li t o en n r e h u to rn u r u g n . r o r te o r me t mait nst tt medialr c dsofe edby Cr zdo no esabls c us ton. I t a t n ai ha he c e or fr u t t ih a ai nse d, he go r ntcai st tt r c dslc a e de eesa ihi t tt tm i ofmedialc r ve nme l m ha he e or a k ny vi nc t bls ng ha he i ng c ae wm u ra o a l o t thetmigc u e Cr zsij r AsCnz i tust bet e tb ih s n e s n be r ha t i n a s d u ' nu y. z s h ma l o sa ls e s nil lme t o h scam,h g ve n rq e t e tyo s mmayj g n i isfv r s e ta ee n s f i li te o mme t e u ss n r f u r ud me t n t a o . I a we i t gove n n ns rng he r mentsmoton,Cr con e t tt 1w doesnotr quiehi ' i uz t nds ha he a e r m t ha a e r t pr e hi c e.Rel ng on anumbe f de a dititc t ii o ve n xpe t o es nt s as yi r e r l src our dec sons icu igBr wnv Be t o s 1 9F. D. 5( D. a 1 9 ) h a g e t a te tn n ldn o . s Fo d , 6 R. 38 N. Al. 9 6 , e r u s h t raig p y iinsaen t rae a e pe t o s b e tt t e p r d sl s r rq ie n so Rue h sca r o te td s x rs r u j c o he x e t ico u e e ur me t f l 2 ()2 ( i te o fro i in drcl a q rdtr ug t ete t n o t ep an if Th s 6 a( )B) f h y fe p no s ie ty c uie h o h h r ame t f h litf. i r e, a s rs applese n i t opi o ofe ed c e n c us ton a sa r ofca e. ul he s e t, i ve f he ni ns f r onc r a a i nd t nda d r Ac or ngl snc Dr Pa r ta quie hi opi on diecl t oug hi te t e a di gnoss c di y, i e . rot c r d s ni r ty hr h s r a m nt nd a i ofCr ,Cr i it t them a us t se de t esa ih hi m e c lne i nc cai . uz uz nsss ha y e hi vi nce o t bls s di a glge e l m 2 Fi ly, u saest tt me c lr c dsa t t tmony ofDr Pa r t c tmt s tcint nal Cr z tt ha he di a e or nd he esi . ro' onsi e ufi e t media evi ncet pr e a is ofm ae i lf tf til c l de o es nt n s ue t ra ac or ra . 2 A lho , cr onl a t ugh uz y dvocae f t us ofDr Paro tst si ts or he e . r t' etmonyi hi r pons t Cour pr ume n s es e,he t es s t thi a gu e sa yequ l t Dr Gr s' t tm ony. ha s r m nt ppl aly o . os s esi I a l ng acli br htunde t FTCA,af de alc tt pplest l oft sae n nayzi am oug r he e r our t i he aw a he t t wh r tealg dtr o c re ' a e tv Uni dstts 1 Fe Ap x 8 , 3 ( 1hCi. ee h le e o t c u rd. mb r . t ae , 98 d. p' 35 8 8 1 t r 'f e 2006) ( saeacl m f ne i nc unde Fl i lw,apli ifmus alget tt . t tt ai or glge e To r orda a antf t le ha he de e ntowedt pl i ifadut ofca e t tt de e f nda he antf y r , ha he f ndantbr ac d t td y,a t tt e he ha ut nd ha he b e c c u e teplitf t s fe d ma e . fe sv Ci o t Pee s u g, 6 F.d 1 6 ra h a s d h an if o u fr a g s' wi . t fs . tr b r 2 0 3 2 0, ' y 1 6 ( 1hCi. 0 ) I me ia map a tc c ss Flrd 1w sae ta çhecama ts al 2 2 1 t r 2 01 . n dc l lrcie a e , o ia a tts h t s li n h l t ha t bur n ofpr ng by t g e t rwe gh ofe de et tt ale d a i oft he lh ve he de ovi he r a e i t vi nc ha he l ge ctons he at c r pr d r pr s nt d abr c oft pr va lng pr e sona sa r ofc r f rt the lh a e ovi er e e e e ea h he e ii of s i l t nda d a e o ha at c r p o ie . Fl. tt An j7 6 1 2( 01 ) ae r v d r' a Sa . n. 6 .0 2 2 . ' tGe rly,hesa dofc r i me c mal a tc c e ( rFl i lwli d neal t tndar ae n dial prcie ass unde orda a s deemi dt o he r tsi tr ne hr ug xpe tetmony. fambe t 1 Fe App' a 839(ii Pat v Th ele, ' ' r, 98 d. x t ctng e . r k l 6 S 2 2 8 2 ( a 1 9 ) T r e v S lia , 0 S 2 1 6 ,1 68( a Dit CtAp 61 o. d 7 , 81 F1. 9 5 ; o rs . ulv n 9 3 o. d 0 4 0 F1. s. . p. 20 5) l tuh, lrd 1w g neal difv r s mmayj d me ti me c lmap a tc c ss 0 ). n r t F oi a a e rly sa o s u r u g n n dia lrcie a e çunl s i c be c us ve y s ç es t an oncl i l hown t tt non- ova ca ha he m nt nnotof erpr t s f oof o uppor t i t he r poston. Whe l rv Uniedst e No.1: c 001 M P- 2007 U. Dit LEXI 82521 ii ' ' e e . t ats, 03-v- 40- AK, S. s . S , a * ( D. a No . , 0 7 (iigMc y v Ho f itr 43 So 2 9 9 9 0( a DitCt t 4 N. Fl. v 6 2 0 ) ctn co . fmese , 5 . d 8 , 9 Fl. s. . Ap .1 8 ).S mmayj d me t stusa p o it t nywh ntemo i gpat c ncu iey p 9 3 ) u r u g n i h p r prae s l e h v n ry o lsv l o de onsr t t tt nonm taes ha he movi pa t i una et pr e a e twho wilt tf t tt ng ry s bl o oduc n xper l esiy ha he dee n wa neglgent' I a *5(ii Hol v Talot,1 So.2d40,44-46( a.1 ) fnda t s i . d t ctng l . c t 91 ' Fl 966 ; Wilamsv. Nel442So. 269,271( a Dit CtApp.1 ) li Mc i, 2d F1. s. . 983). Si e t gove nm enthasc us vel dem ons r t d i t s c e t tCr i una e t nc he r oncl i y ta e n hi as ha uz s bl o pr oduc an expe t ho w il esi y t t g r e ' aleg ne i nc t Cour gr nt t e rw l t tf o he ove nm nt s l ed glge e, he t a s he mo inf rs mmayj d me t Ast ec s 1w id c ts F o ialw rq ie e p r t si n to o u r u g n . h ae a n iae , l rd a e u rs x e te t y mo t e t bls t sanda d ofc r i m e ca mal a tcec es SeeLambe ,1 Fed.App' a o sa ih he t r a e n di l pr c i as . rt 98 x t 8 Be a eCr zdi not andno c 39. c us u d , w annot pr e a e r wine s he c nnote tbls a , oduc n xpe t t s , n sa ih n e s nil lme to hi cam a t u c n o s r i amoinf rs mmayj d me t S e s e ta ee n f s li nd h s n n t u vve to o u r u g n . e Fàee e ,2007 U . D i t LEX I 82521 a *5. /r S. s . S ,t Furhe m or ,Cr m ii e pr t t c s l w u whi h her i s t r e uz snt r e s he a e a pon c ele .Thedec sonss h a ii uc s Br wn m e ey sa et tate tng physca who ofe sa opi on pr lr d diecl fom o r l tt ha r a i i in f r n ni oc ze r ty r te t n i n ts be tt t es e ii e pet ico u esae n se u r tdi Ru e rame t s o u j c o h p cfc x r d s ls r ttme t n me ae n l 26 a()B)f rçean d' x rs S eBr wn,1 9F. D. t3 8(l ate tn ph iin ()2 ( o s tie 'e pet. e o r 6 R. a 8 tf r ai g ysca $ a q ie t eo ii n t a a etes b e to t etsi n dr cl t r u hte t n o t e c urd h pn o s h t r h u j c f h e tmo y ie ty h o g r ame t f h pli if t te tng physca û a antf, he r a i i in c nnotbe f c d t fl awrten r por r quied byRul or e o ie it e t e r e 26a ()B)' (u tn Saa v UntdSa e ,1 5F. D. , 3( . N. 1 9 () Th s ( )2 ( .'q o ig ls . ie tts 6 R. 31 3 W D. Y. 9 59 . e e ' ca e donotsaet ts te tng physcanss fcet esa ih t elm e sofm e ca ss t t ha uch r a i ii ufi o t bls he e nt di l m apr tcede piet f c t tt y a enote rs l ed,a t cour a l aci s t he a t ha he r xpe t. nde s he t cknowldge i e d n Br own, uc teai physcinsma e silbec i e a ç r t i d' e rsnot s h r tng ia y ven tl onsder d s ç non-e a ne ' xpe t s be tt Rul 2 ()2 ( .I (Tot ee tn t a t ete tn p y iint si so l a t t e u jc o e 6 a( )B) d & h x e t h t h r aig h sca e tfe ny s o h ca ea team e ofhi/ rpa int t physc a i nott bec i e a s ci l r t ne r nd r t nt she te , he ii n s o onsder d pe aly eai d e tnot t t ndi t tt wines ma ofe opi on t tm on unde Fed.R.Evi 702, xper wihsa ng ha he t s y f r ni esi y r d. 7 3a d7 5. (u tn Wr ahv UntdSa e ,1 F. D. 48 4 9( Ka 1 9 :)3 I s m, 0 n 0 5 q o ig e t . ie tts 61 R. 4 , 4 D. n. 9 5 . n u ' t ug ate tngph i a ofe i a opi on a uie diecl fom team e m a no ha t ho h r a i yscin frng n ni cq r d r ty r r t nt y t ve o s b taiean d' x e t e o t nd rRue2 ( )2 ( ,hsr l d e n talw teplitf u mi l tie 'e p r rp r u e l 6 a ()B) t i ue o s o l h an if r o 3 l s h ac e, t pa t pr s ntngt physcinwoul silnee t s i a expe ts m m a yas n uc as he ry e e i he ia d tl d o ubm t n r u r rq ie byRul 2 ()2( .S eFe R. v. 2 ()2( .Th Co r a de sdt sdsicina ln t i is e urd e 6 a( )C) e d. Ci P. 6 a( )C) e ut d rse hi itn to te gh n t or prcl ng Cr zfom usng hi physcinsase t.Se Or rGr i M o . oSti Expe tW i s a der e udi u r i s ia xpers e de antng t t rke r me s nd M ott Sti Decs a Excl Expe tOps 7-8,ECFNo. .o rke l. nd ude r . 30. pr s n i t wine st cr um ve Fl rda' r quie e ofa e tt e t bls t sa r e e tng he t s o ic nt o i s e r m nt n xper o sa ih he t nda d o ca ei med c lmapr c ie c s s f r n i a l a tc a e . Des t Fl i sr uie e tt tCr zpr s n a e r wines t esa ih t pie orda' eq r m n ha u e e t n xpe t t s o t bls he sa r ofc r i hi m e c neg i ncecai , u f ie t di c os an e r wines be or t nda d a e n s dial lge l m Cr z al d o s l e xpe t t s f e t dic r de i a i now pr cude fo doi s SeeOr Gr ntng M ot t Sti he s ove y adlne nd s e l d rm ng o. der a i . o rke Expe t ines a M ot t Sti De s a Excl Expe t . ECF N o.30. Cons que l r W t s nd . o rke cl. nd ude r Ops, e nty, t eCo r g a t s mmayj d me ti fv ro t eg v r me t h u t rn s u r u g n n a o f h o en n . I . CO N C LU SI N V O Fort a he bover s ,i i ea ons t s ADJUDGED t tDe enda Unie Stt sofAm e i ' M oton f Summ a y J m e ha f nt t d a e rca s i or r udg nt ( E.No.1 ,fldonNo mbe 8.201 i GRANTED. D. 0) ie ve r 2, s > DONE AND ORDERED i Chmnbe sa M i , orda t s n r t ami Fl i , hi da ofJ nua y,201 y a r 3. FE RI A . OREN O CO UNI TED STATES DI STRI J CT UDGE Co espr de t pi ovi d o: Co e ofR e or uns l c d

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?