Tober et al v. Transamerica Life Insurance Company

Filing 19

ORDER Remanding Case to State Court and Denying Plaintiffs' Request for Attorney's Fees; granting 4 Motion to Remand to State Court; denying 4 Motion for Attorney Fees; The Clerk of Court is directed to remand this cause to the Eleventh Judicial Circuit in and for Miami-Dade County, FL. This case is closed. All pending motions not otherwise ruled upon are denied as moot. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 6/25/2012. (ral)

UNITED STA TES D I
STRI C O URT
CT
SO UTH ERN DISTRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
CA SE N O .12216l3- V- TZ/ M ON TON
Cl SEl Sl
CYNTHI TOBER,i vi l and,
A
ndi dualy
I I TO BER,i vi l
RV N
ndi dualy,
Pl ntf s
ai if ,
VS.

TRAN SA M ERI LI I SUM N CE
CA FE N
COM PAN Y,fk/ TM N SAM ERI
/ a
CA
OCCI EN TAL LI m SURAN CE
D
FE
COM PAN Y,

Def
endant.
/

O R DER REM ANDING CA SE TO STA TE C O URT AND DENYING PLAINTI
FFS'
REO UEST FO R ATTO RN EY ' FEES
S
THIS M ATTER cam ebef e t Courtupon Pl ntfs'M oton t Rem and and f Recover of
or he
ai if
i o
or
y

Atore sFee .DE41Uponarviw o t moto pa r a t NotceofRemo a d ume s
t n y' s ( .
e e fhe in pes nd he i
val nd oc nt
a t c d t e o, f nda tha n m e isb de ofs
ta he her t De e n s ot t t ur n howi b apr ponde a e o t e d nc t t
ng, y e
r nc f he vi e e, ha

t eamou i c tove s e e ds$7 000. ex usv ofi e e t ndc t.The e or ,h Cour wil
h
ntn on r ry xc e
5, 00, cl ie ntr s a oss
r f e te
t l
r m an hi a tonba kt s a ec t Addii l , heCou t il ny Pl n if 'r que t oral ne s
e dt s c i
c o t t our.
tonaly t
r w l de
ai tf s e s f tor y'
f
ees.
L BACK G R OU ND

Thidiput rs ou ofpl nif' amstatherl t m c ei urnc iyts ua e
s s eaies t aitfscli h t i ong-er ar ns a epolc tns rnc
i
p iy' r quie De e an t pa f c r t y r c vea a a sse lvig f ciiy i l ng s le
olc ' e r s f nd t o y or a e he e ei t n s itd i n a lt ncudi kild
)

c r prvi dbylc ns dprcial s a me pr paai byac ri dnurtonit ( 11a
ae o de
ie e a tc nures nd al e rton
e tfe tii s.DE - t

6-) Pl ntfsmaiti t t en nt e c dt i urnc iybyfiigt rmipa nt Ld)
8. ai if nan ha Def da bra he he ns a epolc aln o e t yme . 1 .

Pl i tf s who a e 87 ye r oI a 91 y a s ol r s tvel w e e a it t t a s se Ivi
a n if ,
r
a s d nd
e r d e pec i y, r dm ted o he s it d i ng

fclyonNov mbe 1 2011a dc rntyr i ter.( 12a l3- .
a ii
t
e r 2,
n ure l esde h e DE - t , 51
On M ar 20,2012,Pl ntf sf l a I s ti Cicui Courti and f M i iD ade Count
ch
ai if ied aw ui n r t
n
or am y
ass tng t Def
eri hat endantbr
eached t i ur
he ns ance polcy by f lng t m akepaym ent f Pl ntf s car
i
aii o
s or ai if ' e

a t a sse Ivi fclt ( l 1a 5-1 Th eatrDef da tmel r mo dt c s t fdea
the sitd i ng a iiy.DE - t 8. er fe, en nti y e ve he a e o e rl
c r ont gr ndt tt patesaedi rean t a nti c r erye e $7 00 g 1
ou t he ou ha he ri r ves d he mou n ontov s xc eds 5, 0.DE
a l6q Dee ntmaiti t ta a uai a l i ico ldesa ihe t tbae o Pl ntfs
t - . fnda
nans ha n ct ral naysst mpie tbls s ha sd n ai if'

lf e ca y a t rcli d be ft,t a
ie xpe tnc nd hei ame neis he mounti c to ry e e $7 00 (J..
n onrve s xc eds 5, 0. . J
J
Addii l Def
tonaly, endantass st t pot i am ountofator sf Pl ntf swillkel i
ert hat he ental
t ney' ees ai if l i y ncur

t oug s
hr h ummayj gme a tilas e e dst a unti conr ry. g#..Pli if sek
r ud nt nd ra lo xc e he mo n toves f l antfs e
r ma o t eg oun t tt a
e nd n h r d ha he moun i c tov r yd no e e d$75,00a ofhed t ofr moval
t n on r e s oes t xc e
0 s t ae e
,

i usveo at ne sfe .( 4) Pl nif d notdipuetatt patesaedi re.g#..
ncl i f tor y' e s DE . aitfs o
s t h he ri r ves f 1
11 D I USSI N
1. SC
O
4.Le St
gal andar
d

a

Puru tt 28U. C.j l 2() fder dititc t ha orgi l urs ci ofalci l
s an o
S.
33 a, e al src ours ve i na j iditon l vi
a tonsbewe ciie ofdif r ntsatswher t amou i c to s e e $75,
ci
t en tz ns
fe e t e
e he
nt n on r very xc eds
000. Se
e

Mo rs v Alsat I m.Co.228F. 1 ,1 ( lhCi. ) Thepat ivokigt Couts
r ion . lt e nde
,
3d 255 261 1 t r2000.
ry n n he r'

j iditonha t bur no esa ihi s j c mat j rs ci Wheet a nti c toves
urs ci she de f tbls ng ube t teru iditon. r he mou n onr ry
i nots fed i t com pl nt t r ovi part m us es ablsh by apr
s
pecii n he
ai , he em ng y
t t i
eponder
ance oft evi
he dence

t ttea ti c r erye e stej idito mi mum.Roev Mihei N Am.I .61
ha h moun n ontov s xc ed h urs cinal ni
. c ln
, nc, 3
F.d 1
3 058,1 62 ( 1h Ci.201 ) The Elve t Cicui a horz a c tt ma ras bl
0 1t r
0.
e n h r t ut ies our o ke e ona e
deductonsand i er
i
nf encesdw hen a r ovi def
d
em ng endantm akess fcf ualalegatonses abls ng
pecii act
l i
t i hi

j rs cin't tica sppor wihevi nc Pr tav Kole C,pPl aI I .608F.d7 75
u idito 'ha t n u t t de e. ek . tr ' az L nc,
/
.
3 44, 4
2

( 1h Ci.201 . Whe t j idito a t i notfcaly a rntfom t c ait
1 t r 0)
n he urs cinal moun s
a i l ppae r he ompl n,
ûdlfnda t mayad tt ro afda t, clrto ,orohe doc me tton't etbls ta
t ee ns
l
mi hei wn fi vis de aains t r u nai 'o sa ih h t
r ovali pr . 1 at755.A ny doubtr di t appr i enessofr ovalm ustbe r ol
em
s oper d.
egar ng he
oprat
em
es ved

a ai ta c ptngrmo j rs ci a i fvo ofrma Ale v Chrse ry, 7F.d 1 0,
g ns c e i e valu iditon nd n a r e nd. ln . itnbe r 32 3 29
1 ( 1hCi.2 ; a ov US. rwa ,Ic.2 U. DitLEXI 6681 2008W L 39 0,
293 1 t r 003)f z . Ai ys n , 008 S. s.
S
4,
2643
a *l( D. a. 26,20 .
t S. Fl Aug.
08)
Ad ton l t Elve hCic tha ma cla t t(a c tsa y i o t amou -ndii aly,he e nt rui s de e r ha ( J our' nalss f he
(
nti
contover y r r entf es on how m uch i i contover y att tm e ofr oval not l er.'
r s equiem
ocus
sn
r s
he i
em
,
at '

Prt ,608F. a 751 Sir n k v Tr out Fi ci Cor , 6F. 945, ( lhCi. 0)
eka
3d t ; e mis i . ans h nan al p.21 3d
949 1 t r200 .
As a gener rul f ur pot i beneft m ay not be t
al e, ut e ental
is
aken i o consi aton i det m i ng t
nt
der i n er ni he
am ounti cont over y w hen a pl ntf s
n
r s
ai if eekst r
o ecoverunpai beneft underan i urancepolcy and
d
is
ns
i

do no c le et vai t oft polc Se Tr ee 'ls anc Co. Gr n l 1 4F. 950
es t halng he ldiy he iy. e av lrs n ur e v. eefed, 5 2d ,
952( t Ci.l . Thus t a
5h r 946)1
,he moun i c to ryi no t fc val oftepolcybu onl t
t n onrves s t he a e ue h i t y he
dam agesact l i red att tm eofr oval Si ai v. at Farm M ut
ualy ncur
he i
em
. ncl r St e
ualAut obieI
om l nsur.Co.
,

20l W L27
1
46823 a *2( D. a J ne1 20l1 (iigTr elr'Is anc Ct.1 F. a 9 )
, t M. Fl. u 4, ) ctn av e s n ur e ?, 54 2d t 52).
#.Moto rRe nd
info ma
Her Pl n if 'da ge a t tme ofr valdi note e d $75,00. The a nti
e, aitfs ma s t he i
emo
d
xc e
0
mou n
c t ov r y i nots cii d i t Co pl i a t r o e, he bur n i on Def da t e t bls i
on r e s s
pe fe n he m a nt nd, he ef r t
de s
en nt o s a ih t
by apr
eponder
ance oft evi
he dence. Roe, 613 F. at1062. l s
z
3d
n upportofr oval Def
em
, endantf ed an
il

' El ent Cic thasa pt , a bi ng pr ede ,decsonsoft Fit Cicui ha d downpro
The ev h r ui
do ed s ndi ec nt ii
he fh r t nde
ir

t Oco e 1 1 81 Bo n rv Prc a d 6 F.d 1 0 ( 1hCi. 98 )
o tb r , 9 . n e . ih r , 6l 2 2 6 1 t r 1 1.
z eCo an alg sta çthsi a ato f rd ma e i e c s o Fite Th u a d( 50 0
Th mplit le e h tt li s n cin o a g s n x e s f fe n o sn $1 ,0 )
l
Dolr bu ls ta S v nyFieTh u a d( 7 ,0 )Dol r a o ted t o ti fl ge l ieo atre s
las te s h n e e t- v o s n $ 50 0 l s s f h ae f hs in xcusv f ton y '
a
i
fe ,neeta dc sswi rse tt e c panif'DE 1 la 5 !1.
e s itrs n ot t ep c o a h lit . ( - t , 1
h
f'

act i anal i andestm at t i Pl ntf Cynt aToberlvesherexpec ed lf expect
uaral yss
i es hat f ai if
hi
i
t ie
ancyoft ee
hr

y r,heva u ofhe c am f b eft unde t i ur nc polc c c ae a ar eof$1 0pe da
ea s t l e
r l i or en is
r he ns a e iy, alultd t at
0 r y,

i$11 02179, xcusveofat ne sfe .DE l2a 3- .Dee n esi tst tiPlitf r n
s 4, . e l i
tor y' e s ( - t 41 fnda t tmae ha f aniflwi
Tober lves hi expec ed lf expect
i
s
t ie
ancy of 3. year t val ofhi cl m f beneft undert
9
s, he ue
s ai or
is
he

i ua epolc cac ae a art of$1 pe da ,i $1 082.2, xcusveofator y' fe .Ld.
ns rnc iy, lultd t ae
00 r y s 40, 9 e l i
t ne s e s l
a 4- 1 Thus Defnda mant nsta tea
t 5.
, e nt i ai h t h moun i c rverywihrs tt bohPli if i
t n onto s t epec o t antfs s
$25 1 71( 1 0 .9+$1 08 9 ,wela e$75, .
4,04. $1 4,217
40, 2.2) l bov
000
Def
endants cont i t t am ount i cont overs i cal at based on Pl ntf s'lf
'
enton hat he
n
r
y s cul ed
ai if ie
expect
ancy i t oft val oft cl m satt tm e ofr ovali w ihoutm ert l i wel- etl
nsead he ue he ai
he i
em
s t
i. t s ls ted
t t am ounti contover i det m i att tm eofr oval notl er.Pret 608 F. at751,
hat he
n
r sy s er ned he i
em
, at
ka,
3d
*

Tr ee ' I s r ce Co. 1 4 F.d a 95 ;Sige v Bank sLfe ( Cas t Co. 2011U. Dit
av lr s n u an
,5 2 t 2 e l.
er / f ual
'
y ,
S. s.

LEXI 1 76, t*3( D. a. v.1 , 1.TheCour h cac ae t vaueoft cai a t
S 500 a S. Fl No 8 201 )
t as lultd he l
he l ms the
tm eofr ovalbas on t r evantf sagr t by t par i Speci l t par i agr t ;
i
em
ed he el
act eed o he tes.
scaly, he tes ee hat

()Pl ntfscai $1 pe da i be isunde hei ur epolc ( Pli if' amsaes be t
a ai if l m 00 r y n neft
rt ns anc iy;b) antfs cli r u jc
t atnda elmi tonpei '()Pli if weeadmit t t asse lvi fclt onNo mbe
o e - y i nai rod, c antfs r
F
ted o he sitd i ng a iiy
ve r
1 20lla ()t c ewasrmov dt fdea cout i27, l .Ass h,acorngi tetn- y
2, ; nd d he as
e e o e rl rAprl 20 l
uc f t i n h e da
elm i i perod,hecl m perod f hepur eofdet m i ngt am ounti contover yatt tm e
i naton i t ai
i ort
pos
er ni he
n
r s he i
ofr ovali fom N ovem berzz,20114untlAprl27,2012. A t al l58dayspass f om N ovem ber
em
sr
i
i
ot of
ed r

22,201 t oug Aprl27,2 1 Theeor,t a ti c r ryatt tmeo e alwa
1 hr h i
01 . rf e he moun n ontoves he i fr mov s
3 i ur nc polc pr desf a l dayelm i to perod, whih i t numbe ofda att sar of
The ns a e iy ovi or oi nain i
c s he
r
ys he t t

e c n sn h mesa n e dt q ai frb n t .DE 11a 1 1 Un e tep lc a is ei ti c s, n e
ah urig o ty ede o u ly o e eks ( - t 7. d rh oiy tsu n hs a e o c
f
Pl n if saye i anuri homef mo et nt days t y qualfedf rbe isa ar t of$1 pe da
aitfs t d n
sng
or r ha en
,he
ii o neft t ae
00 r y.

4 ai if wer adm itd t t a ssed lvi f lt onN ove be 1 ,2011 A ss h,f t i i t tnpl ntfs e
te o he s it i ng aciiy
m r2
.
uc acorng n he e
da elm i tonpe i durngwhih Pl ntfswe eno enild t havebe ft pad u rt i ur nc polc t
y i nai
rod i
c ai if r t tte o
ne is i nde he ns a e iy, he
cl m pe i be onN ove be 22, 1
ai rod gan
m r 201 .

$1 80 ( 0 x1 da ) Plitf frat al $31600frbot Pli if. Thia
5, 0 $1 0 58 ys per anif o ot of , o h antfss s moun doe not
t s
e e $ 0
xce d 75,00.
H ow ever, ef
D endantalo arguest heator sf Pl ntf sw illkel i
s
hatt t ney' ees ai if l i y ncurpur ngt s
sui hi

c s t o s mmayj dgme a ti soul b i ud di c c ai t a unti c to ry.
ae hrugh u r u nt nd ral h d e ncl e n alultng he mo n onrves
S he gener r e i t ator
T
al ul s hat t neysf do notcountt ar t am ounti contover y unl t ar
ees
ow ds he
n
r s
ess hey e
alowed f by sat eorcontact' Federat ut l Co.v. cKi
l
or t ut
r .'
edM ual ns.
M nnonM ot s, LC, F. 805,
or L 329 3d

8 n.4( 1hCi.200 .Wihr pe tt t cai hee,Fl i Iw per t Pl nif t rc r
08,
1 t r 3) t es c o he l ms r orda a
mis aitfs o e ove
ras bl at n sfesi t yprval s eFl Stt j627. butt is e i wheher f t
e ona e torey' e f he e i, e a. a.
428, he su s t , or he
pur
posesofdet m i ngt am ounti contover y, he ator sf i r asoft dat ofr oval
er ni he
n
r s t t ney' ees ncur ed
he e em

s oul b i cl ed ora I t r a ona e a t n y' f est oug ti l The e i co lc i c e l w
h d e n ud
l of he e s bl tor e s e hr h r a .
r s nfi tng as a

onteis Se Lotdr idl P..v Cr atv Compou ,LLC, 0W L204488 a * ( D.
h sue. e t Fre an4 A . e ie
nds
201
9, t 4 S.

Fl Apr21 201 ( di ta at ne fe g neae atrr val ann ce tdj iditont t
a. . , 0) hol ng h t tor y e s e rtd fe emo c ot rae urs ci ha
waslc ngathetmeofrmova)Rogatnsyv Meto ianLfèI s r Co.2009U. DitLEXI
a ki t i
e
l;
i k . rpolt / n u . ,
S. s.
S

1 40 a ( D. a Oc. 200 (a )(ii Walemye v Norhwe tr Mut lLfels r Co.
00 2, t S. Fl. t26, 9) s me ctng t r . t se n ua
nu. ,
20 WL 41
07
9663,a * ( . Fl.Fe 2,2007) butc Hal v Am.Se .I .Co.20 U. Dit
t 2 M D. a b.
); f l .
c ns , 09 S. s.
LEXI 642 ( D.Fl J .23, )(sumi t taras bl a unto alat ne sfe ae
S 23 S. a. ul 2009 a s ng ha e ona e mo f l tor y' e s r
icl ed i t a
n ud n he moun i c to ryl.
t n on r ve s )
I t i t case,t Cour need notr
n he nsant
he
t
eacht sisue becauseDef
hi s
endanthasnotm etisbur
t den

of e t bls n by a pr pon r nc o t e e de e t a ou of r s bl a t ne s f e t a
s a i hi g,
e de a e f h vi nc , he m nt ea ona e tor y' e s h t
Pl n if 'c
ai tfs ouns lw ili uri t s c s pr e t ti l The e de e De e n f l d c e ni g
e l nc f hi a e oce ds o r a .
vi nc
f nda t ie onc r n

s parisdo notaddr swhehe i i a opraef Pl ntfst a e et rcli i or t r ch
The te
es
t r t s ppr it or ai if o ggr gat hei ams n der o ea

tej rs ito a mi mu Whi ia per ta a ge ainij siidh r b cu etep riss e t e fre
h uidcin l ni m. l t p as h t g rg to s utfe ee e a s h ate e k o no c
e
t rrght underasngl i ur ncepolc t Cour nee notdecdet sis a r m a i r quiede whe
hei i s
i e ns a
iy, he
t d
i hi sue s e nd s e r ven n
e ua i t a ounti contove s i t a e t
val tng he m
n
r ry n he ggr gae.

ator sf consit ofa decl a i f om Enr que Ar a ltgaton part i t M i iofi of
t ney' ees
ss
ar ton r
i
ana, ii i
ner n he am fce
J den Bur LLP,es i a i t am ountoff Pl ntfs'counselw ili
or
t
tm tng he
ees ai if
l ncurltgatng t s cas and
ii i hi e,
exhi t t et s fcaly prntout fom Pl ntf s'couns ' fr webst a m oton f ator s
bis her o, pecii l i - s r
ai if
els im
ie,
i or t ney'
f fl by Pl ntfs'couns i a cl acton,and an or gr i i part an awar of f t
ees ied
ai if
el n
ass i
der antng, n
,
d ees o

Pl n if 'cou eli t cl s ac i
ai tfs
ns n he as ton. Howe r t e de i r val ofM r Ar a' a fda t i
ve , he vi nta y ue
. an s fi vi s
ques i
tonabl gi is s f er ng nat e as M r.Ar s fr r es s t Def
e ven t el-s vi
ur
ana' i m epr ent he endanti t s cas
n hi e.
M or
eover M r. r ssat ent i t afi tast Pl ntf s'couns ' houry r t and t num ber
, A ana' t em s n he fdavi o ai if
els
l ae
he
ofhour he can expectt expend ltgatngt scas ar s
s
o
ii i hi e e pecul i andconcl or Fi l D ef
atve
us y. naly, endant
f l t poi t f aw ar i cas t ar si iart t i antcas t asss t Courti det m i ng
ais o nt o ee
ds n es hat e m l o he nst
e o it he
n er ni
t r onabl houry r e and t am ountofhour Pl ntf s'counselcan expectt expend.
he eas
e
l at
he
s ai if
o
6

Ass tf t ab e,hecai swe ev ue a $316 asoft edaeofr mov .De e a ha
e orh ov t l m
r al d t ,00
h t e al f nd nt s
f l t m eetisbur ofesabls ng t am ountofator sf Pl ntf couns can r onabl
aied o
t den
t ihi he
l ney' ees ai ifs
el
eas
y

e c t i urltg tngt sc e Thust Cou t lrma dt sc et saeco tf lc ofs j c
xpe to nc iiai hi as. ,he rwile n hi as o tt ur ora k ube t

matr u iditon.
te j rs ci
C.M olnfo Ator y' Fe s
to r t ne s e
l teiMoto f Re nd, ai if alose at ne sfe .( 4a 9 1 .Th Co t l
n h r in or ma Pl ntfs s e k tor y' e s DE t - 01 e urwil
deny Pl ntfs'r
ai if eques .An awar ofator sf i di etonar See I CO USA,I v.Til I
t
d
t ney' ees s scr i y.
M
nc. te ns.

Co o n . 7 9F. u p. 3 2 l 2 ( . Fl.1 9 ) Th r i n b ssf rteCo rt fn ta
. fMin, 2 S p 1 2 , 3 4 M D. a 9 0 . ee s o a i o h u to id h t
Def
endantact unr onabl or i bad f t i r ovi t scas par i arl gi t cont cti
ed eas
y n
aih n em ng hi e, tcul y ven he
li n
aut iy concem i het
hort
ngw herpos -em ovalator sf s dbei uded i det m i ngt am ount
tr
t ney' ees houl
ncl
n er ni he

6 udgeCohn' or e g a tnga t ne sfest Pl ntfs'c eli a t c e whih i a e bit
J
s d r r n i tor y' e o ai if ouns n noher as , c s n xhi t o
M r Ar na' deca ai i nothel ulbe us i conc nsacls aci t t o isf e,r r d ca sc e t
. a s lr ton,s
pf ca e t er
a s ton ha, n t ac equie ls ouns l o
s
pendmor tmeltga i t Plitfs couns lwils
e i ii tng han an if'
e l pendon t i tntc e
he nsa as .

6

i contover y. Thus Pl ntf s'm oton t r and i deni t t ext i s
n
r s
, ai if
i o em
s
ed o he ent t eeksator sf and
t ney' ees
cOs s
t.

1 1.CO NCLU SI N
1
O
Fort r
he easonss f t above,D ef
et orh
endanthasf l t es abls by a pr
aied o t i h,
eponder
ance oft
he

e d c t tt a unti co r rye ee $75,00,e l ieofi e es a c t. e e or ,
vien e,ha he mo n ntove s xc ds 0 xcusv
ntr t nd oss Th r f e
t Cour w ilr and t scase back t t El
he
t l em
hi
o he event J ci Cicui i and f M i iDade Count
h udi al r t n
or am y.
Accor ngl i i
di y, t s
ORD ERED t
hat

()Pl nif'Moi f Re nda f Re veyofAtor y' Fee ( 4)i GRANTED
1 aitfs ton or ma nd or co r
t ne s s DE s
s el ast Pl ntf sr
ol y o ai if' eques f r and. l i DEN I ast Pl ntf s'r
t or em
ts
ED
o ai if eques f ator sf
t or t ney' ees
and cos s.
t

( TheClr ofCour i DI
2)
ek
ts RECTED t r
o emandt sc s t t Elve hJ di a Cic ti
hi au e o he e nt u cil rui n
and f M i iDade Count Fl i
or am y, orda.

()Thi CASE I CLOSED.
3 s
S
( Alpe ngmoi no ohe wier eduponar DENI ASM OOT.
4) l ndi
tons t t r s ul
e
ED
P

DONEAND ORDERED i MimiFlrd ,hsW V d yo Jn , 01 .
n a , oiati
a fu e2 2
<

PATRI A A . EI Z
CI
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI JUD GE
CT
cc:

Honor e A ndr M .Si ont
abl
ea
m on

A1 couns ofr d
l
el ecor