Brea Fernandez et al v. Xpress Painting Corp. et al
Filing
18
ORDER granting 8 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/16/2012. (tkn)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRJ C OU RT FOR TH E
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D
M i iD i s on
am
vi i
C a e N um be 1 21738- V - O REN O
s
r: 2CI M
I
SM EL BREA FERN AN D EZ, G U STA V O
I LESI S, YU N I R CARRERO REI A ,a
G
A
O
N
nd
HEI Y V A LDES,
D
Pl i i f ,
a ntf s
VS.
XPRESS PA I TI G CORP. nd GON ZALO H .
N N
a
GARCI
A,
De e n s
f nda t .
/
O R DER G M N TI G PLA I TI
N
N FFS'M O TION T O D I I
SM SS
THI CAUSE c be or heCour upo Pl i if ' otont Dim isCount r l m Fie
S
ame f et
t n antfs M i o s s
e cai l d
b Dee nt ( E.No.8) tl onJune22.201 Pli if lr lBraFenande Gusa
y fnda s D.
, ied
2. antfs sae e r
z, tvo
l e i s Yuni Ca r r Re na a He dyVadesbr
gl sa ,
or re o i , nd i
l
oughts ta i tDef nda sXpr s Pantng
ui ga ns
e nt
es i i
Coporton a Gonz oH.Gaci f vi ai oft FarLa St r Ac ($
r ai nd
al
r a or oltons he i bor andads t é
FLSA') l
'. n
r po e t br a h ofco r c c e c ai s a l ge by D e e nt ,Pl i if t l d t sm oto t
es ns o e c
nt a t ount r l m le d
f nda s a nt fs i e hi
in o
ds s tec u trli f rlc o s be tmatrj rs ito .Thi Co r a r e t a i lc
imis h o n ecams o a k f u j c te u idcin
s u t ge s h t t a ks
s b e t te jlid ci no e t ec u trli a dtee o eg a t P an if' to t ds s.
u j c matrt s ito v r h o n ecams n h r f r rn s litfs mo in o imis
r
1 FA CTU A L BAC K G R O UN D
.
Pl i if Fe a z,l e i , na a V a de a l ge t tt i e pl ye ,Def nt
a ntfs m nde gl s as Rei , nd l s le ha he r m o r
enda s
X pr s Pa ntng Cor a i a Gonza o G a c a de e t m pr r o ri e co pe a i f
es i i
por ton nd
l r i , ni d he
ope ve tm
m ns ton or
w or
kwee l
ks onge t n f t ho s They a gue t tt sde a wasw ilula i e i lon t
r ha or y ur .
r
ha hi ni l
lf nd nt ntona
he
pa tofDe e nt,a wa c e nty unlwf unde t FLSA.l r pons t Pl i if '
r
f nda s nd s ons que l a ul
r he
n es e o antfs
c pli ,De e
om ant f ndan sdenid t a lga i ,r ie afima i de e est ti l
t
e he le tons a s d fr tve f ns ha ncuded ar ques
e t
f s tof ag ns Pli tfs da a sf ralm oni owe by Pli if t Def nda s a fl
or e- f ai t a n if ' m ge o 1
es d
a ntfs o e nt , nd ied
c t r am sa i tPl ntfsI esa a Vades l pa tc a ,t c mt cai saleg t
oun e cli gans ai if gl i s nd l . n riul r he ot er l m l e wo
c u t o b e c o c n rc a do ec u o u j s e cmzn .
o n s f r a h f o ta t n n o nt f nu t mi l e t
Reg r ng t c e ca msa i tI e is De e nt c end t t durng t
a di he ountr li ga ns gl sa , f nda s ont ha , i he
e o
mpl ymentr l to hi l l sa r quese Xpr s Pantng t pr dehi wih fna a
e ai ns p, g e is e t d
e s i i o ovi m t i ncil
a ssa et hep hi m a e mee .Xpr s Pai i a e d andpr ded l e iswih t
s it nc o l m ke nds
t
e s ntng gr e
ovi gl sa t wo
l t a i $3,02. aswel asa ailnetc tf l e is' wief a ov s sti
oans ot lng 3 00
l n ri ike or gl sa s f or n erea rp.
l e i ha ye t pa of t l
glsas s t o y f he oansorr mbur eXpr s Pai i f rt ailnetc .
ei
s
e s ntng o he ri iket
Si ia l ,durng he tm e a a em pl e,Val s a ke X pr s Pai i t gua ant e her
m lry
i
ri s n
oye
de s d
e s ntng o r e
m o hl r ntpay
nt y e
ment t he lndl dass t wasf i fna i lditculi s l an e f tt
s o r a or
he oo
acng i nc a fi te . n
for o
a s s V a des X pr s Pai i c e ed t t r
s i t l , e s ntng ons nt o he eque tan guar nt d he r . H ow e r
s d
a ee r ent
ve ,
f l i Val s' s pa a i f om X pr s Pa ntng,Va de c as pa ng r nti M a c 201
olow ng de s e r ton r
es i i
l s e ed yi e n r h
2.
Co e nty,Xpr sPa ntng r m a ns la e f t unpai r ntf om M a c t ough M ay 201
ns que l
es i i e i i bl or he
d e r
r h hr
2.
De e ant a guet tl esa a Vadesha br a he s pa a eco r ct wih Xpr s
f nd s r ha gl i s nd l
ve e c d e r t nta s t
es
Pantng.Namey,l e i hasbr ac hi ag e m e t pa o ft l nsa Va de has
i i
l glsas
e hed s r e nt o y f he oa nd l s
br ac d he a e m e t r i bur eXpr s Pantng f t r ntpay e s Addii l
e he r gr e nt o em s
e s i i or he e
m nt .
tonaly,
Dee d n sag eta t eb neisrti db I lsa a dVad sc nsiuel u te rc me t
fn a t r u h t h e ft eane y g eis n l e o tt t mj s n ih n .
Pli if fl amotont dimis prs ma yunderRul 1 b)1,c lngi t
antfs ied
i o s s, e u bl
e 2( ()l hale ng he
Thoug Pl ntfs'm o i t dim issaest tii c le ngDefnda s c e cam sunde Rul 41
h ai if
ton o s s tt ha t s halngi
e nt' ountr li
r e
( s saso Acins, anif aeo l c net gt Co r' sb etmatr uidito o e tec u trli .
Dimisl f to ) Plitfs r ny o tsi he u ts uj c t jrs cin v r h o necams
n
e
Panif tu l l men t tl aRue1 ()l moinfrlc o sbe t te u idit nrt e t nu d r
litfs h s i y a to 5e l 2b () to o ak f uj c matrjrs ci ah rha n e
ke
o
Rul 4l.
e
Co r' s b e tmatr u idito o e Dee d n s c u tr li .l pa t ua ,h yag et a
u ts u j c te j rs ci n v r fn a t' o n ecams n ri lr te r u h t
c
teCo r c r te ecs s p e na j rs ito o rtesae1w b e c e o c nr c a d
h u t amo x rie u plme tl u idcin ve h tt a ra h s f o ta t n
u j t mi h n c u trli b c u ete d n taieo to t esmeAril llc s o
nus e c me t o ne cams e a s h y o o rs u f h a
tce l a e r
co r r y ast o i nalFLSA c a m s
nt ove s
he r gi
li .
l . L EG AL STA ND A R D
I
A fca j rs ito a c aln eu d rRue 1 ( ) 1 o clswh ntemoi nt d s s
a il u idcin l h le g n e l 2 b ( ) c t
r e h to o imis
ç c e t te(o lits v rino j rs ito al-inic n fcsa tu a da r se ter
s c ps h c mpan 'j eso f u idcin ly sg i a t a t s r e n dd e s s h i
a
s tce y. Valntnv Hos Bela Vit 254F.d 358,363( s Ci. ) Fors hfcil
ufi inc ' e i . p. l sa,
'
3
1t r 2001 .
uc a a
a t c ,a c twill onl a t c pl i an w ilt $ 1oft a l atonsi t
ta ks our l ook y t he om a nt d l ake ç
a1 he leg i
n he
c mplita tu t d tn n wh t e a(a t)h sa e u tl alg dab ssfrs b e t te
o an s r e o ee uie eh r p ry a d q aey l e a i o u j c matr
e
j rs cin. Fo v M o rsJu trAs o s, 0 - 0 8 - Vu idito ' x . ri pi s c .No. 5 8 6 9 C1 MA
'
e
, 0 U. Dit
20 7 S. s.
LEXI 7088 at* ( D. a.Se . ,2007)(ii fawr nc v Dunbar 91 F. 1 25,
S
4, 6 S. Fl pt21
ctng
e e.
, 9 2d 5
1 28 ( 1h Ci.1
5 -29 1 t r 990:.l t pr e a ton,Pl ntfs j iditonalc lng c tt esa
n he esnt ci ai if 'urs ci
hale e onsiut
f i a tc ast y donotc l e t ve a iyofDefnda s c e cli s The Co t
acal ta k he
haleng he r ct
e nt ' ount r am .
ur
t r or ac e st tut oft c e ca msf pur e oft smoton.
he ef e c pt he r h he ountr li or pos s hi
i
Un e 28U. C.j1 6 () wh naf d rldsrc c u t so iia jzidcini a y
dr
S.
3 7 a, e e ea itit o r ha rgn ll s ito n n
r
cvl cin,h c u tthal a es p e na j rs ito o e al t e camsta aes
i ia to t e o r S lh v u plme tl uidcin v r 1o h r li h t r o
s
rltdt camsi t ea to wi ns c o ii lu idcinta t yf nn p r o t es me
eae o li n h cin t u h rgna j rs ito h t he o a t f h n
hi
ca eorc r ryunde Ari e11oft UniedStt Co tt i ' 28U. C.j1 a .
s ontove s
r tcl I he t aes nsiuton.
'
S. 367()
Th S p e Co r ha itr rtdt i l a eo c nr v ry'e uie n t C o f r u idcin
e u r me u t s nep ee hs ç s r o to e s 'r q rme t o d n e j rs ito
c
c
o r s e e a cl i st ta i e f om a û om m on nuc e ofo r tve f t i c
ve uppl m nt l a m ha rs r
c
l us pe a i ac ' n onne ton
ci
wih af de a cli .'Pr x,LLC v Per zDiti Fr s ,I .N o.09t e r l am ' ome
. e sr b. e no nc,
22285- VC1
-
3-
M ORENO, 0U.. s.
201 S Dit LEXI 9 67 , t* 4( D. a S pt 1 2 0 ( u tn UntdM ie
S 0 7 a 3 S. Fl. e . , 01 ) q o ig i
e n
Wo k r o
r es fAm. . b s 38 U. 71 ,2 2 ( 9 6 ) na ay i s p e na j rs cin
v Gi b , 3 S. 57 4- 5 1 6 ).l n lzng u plme tl uidito
is s t El ve h Cic ti pa tculrhasl
sue , he e nt r ui n ri a
ooked t whehe t sae cai stsnvol t
o
t r he t t l m di ve he
s me wine s , es nt ton oft s e de e,a de e mi ton oft s m e, v y
a
t s es pr e a i
he ame vi nc nd t r nai
he a or er
smia ,a s'a t fderlcli .'I ( i Pal rv Hos Aut o
i lr fct s he e a ams' d quotng me . p. h. fRandolhCW/ ,22
p
y.
F. 1 1 -64( 1hCi.199 .
3d 559, 563 - 1 t r 4)
1 1 DI
1 . SCUSSI
ON
S p e n a Ju id ci nov rDee d n s' u tr l i
u plme t l rs ito e f n a t Co ne cams
Pl i if m ant i t tDe enda s'sae l cou e cli sr quie dif r nte e
antfs i an ha f nt t t aw
ntr am e r fe e l ment of
s
pr b ed o f t e iel ditnctfom t unde l ngf r lcai s M or ove ,Pl i if
oof as n ac s ntr y si r he
ryi ede a l m .
e r antfs
a guet tt sae 1w c am swoul dom i t ove an obs r t f r c am si t Cour
r ha he t t a l i
d
na e r d cu e he ede al l i f he
t
weet e ecs j rs it no e te
r o x rie u idci v r h m.
o
I r s ns Def nt a gue t tt i c e cl msa et Clp-i oft coi '
n e po e, enda s z
ha her ountr ai r he t i s de he n'of
t
Panif' A camssn eteb e c so c nrc a du j s e c me a o eo to
litfs FLS li ic h r a he f o ta t n n u t mi h nt r s u f
I esa ' a Va de ' e pl
gl i s s nd l s s m oyme r lto hi wihXpr sPantng.l e Def nt
nt e ai ns ps t
es i i
nde d, enda s
c e t tt c
ont nd ha he ount r l i sw ili ve m uch oft s m e e de e, he s e w ine s , nd
e c am
l nvol
he a
vi nc t am
t s es a
a uli t de e mi ton o sm ia f c s Def nt alo de a rs t tt sae cai
n tma e t r nai n i l r a t . enda s s ny ny ik ha he t t l ms
wildom i t ove orobs ur t f de a cli s
l
na e r
c e he e r l am .
l c s swh r aF A cam s r e a t eu d ryn b ssf ro ii l u idcin t s
n ae ee LS li e v s s h n e lig a i o rgna j rs ito ,hi
Cour hasge r l be n r l t ntt fnd t taddii na s a e l w c r c o t tcl i s f m
t
ne aly e e uc a o i ha
to l t t a ont a t r or a m or
pa4oft s me d as o c r r y'ast f de alcai . Re e l t Cour hel t ta
l he a t e r ontove s ' he e r l m
c
c nty, he
t d ha
c nt r l i tl d by e pl r t r c err ntf housng pr de t em pl ee on t
ou e c a m i e
m oye s o e ov e or
i
ovi d o
oy s he
-
4-
busne spr s di notars outofa c
i s emies d
ie
omm on nuc e ofoper tvef ti c
l us
ai ac n onne i wih t
cton t he
e pl ee unde l ng FLSA c a m s Se Vale il v Re ac Tr ck Re r ,I . N o.09m oy s'
ryi
l i . e l s lo . m a u
pai s nc ,
8O7I CI M ARRA/OHNSON,
4- VJ
2009U. Dit LEXI 11301 ( D.Fl De 3,2009) l
S. s.
S
5 S. a. c.
.n
t tc e,t Cour not d t t wines e a e de e woul dif rgr tybet e t
ha as he
t e hat he t s s nd vi nc
d fe eal we n he
cli sa c e cli s Thepli ife pl eswoul ofe evi nc r a i t hour
am nd ountr am .
antf m oye
d f r de e eltng o
s
wor d a payr eved whiet de e nte pl r woul s
ke nd
ec i
l he f nda m oye s
d ubmi e de e t esabls t
t vi nc o t ih he
exitncea br ac ofa or la e m e b we n t pa tes Se /@ at* M or ove , he
se
nd e h n a gr e nt et e he ri . e t
5.
e rt
camsddn tdeyo ie tc l cinso tep risa d g ud r q iespaaep o ft
li i o t l n d n ia a t
r
o f h a t n wo l) e ur e rt r o o
e
de
monsr t t al ge y ww ngf c
ta e he le dl
' onduct' I l e t Cour f
ul
.' d nde d, he
t ound t t onl f c or
hat he y a t
t tt cli ss r i c mon wa t exitnc ofage r lempl ere oy
ha he am ha ed n om
s he se e
ne a
oy - mpl ee
rlt ns i an x slo atnu td'o a e rieo s p lme a j rs ito Se ï (iig
eai hp, e u ç o t ae 'f r n xecs f u p e ntl u id cin. e t ctn
o
t e
f
L v Ihiman, F. 7 ,7 ( Ci.1
yon . ' s 45 3d 58 62 3d r 995:.
V
Lie s ,h Co r d cie t e ecs s p e na j rs ito i aF A c s
k wie te u t e ln d o x r ie u plme tlu idcin n LS a e
i vi c
nvol ng ount r l i st ts
e c a m ha oughtunpai r ntf o a i pe ntc r c orwho r nt a
d e r m n nde nde ont a t
e ed
r i enc f om t de e ntem pl r . Se N e s v CK Nel on I . N o. 61 6- Ves d e r he f nda
oye s e l on .
s , nc , 07- 41 Cl
MARRA,2008U. Dit LEXI 435 ( D.Fl J 2, ) Agant Co tsrs e t
S. s.
S 44 S. a. une 2008 . i he ur te s d he
e de ir ditncto be we n t cai sast pl ntfswoul s ek t esabls hour wor d
vi nta y si i ns t e he l m
he ai if
d e o t ih
s ke
a pa r c ve whiet def nda swoul srvet pr alndl d/e tr l to hi Se
nd y e ei d l he e nt
d ti o ove a or t nan e ai ns p. e
i a 5-6.
d. t
Ta ng al ofD e e
ki
1
f ndant a l ga i a t u f pul esoft sm oton,D e e
s' le tons s r e or pos
hi
i
f ndan s
t'
c e cai r s m bl t tpeofc am spr entd i Vale il a Nelon t t Cour ha
ount r l ms e e e he y
li
es e n l slo nd s hat he
t s
pr vi l de m e nott be pa toft s m e A ri e 11c s orc r r y a a unde l ng
e ous y e d
o
r
he a
tcl l a e ont ove s s n
r yi
-
5-
FLSA cai . Thee d ea wine st tmony dif rs t ntaly be we t f r la
lm
vi enc nd t s esi
fe ubsa i l t en he ede a nd
l a n if l f r oof he l r
ri
sa el w cli spr e e he e. W hiePli tf swilofe pr oft ntmbe ofove tm e
tt a am es nt d r
hour wo ked a a
s r
nd mountofun i wa owe De e nt wils i i pende e de e
pad ges d, f nda s l ubm t nde
nt vi nc
ofc r c st tXpr s Pantng e e e i o wih Va de a l esa . I f c , he e i no
onta t ha
e s i i nt r d nt t l s nd gl i s n a t t r s
i c ton i De e n s'a wert tt s c r c sc tt ea hi mor t a r e e s
ndia i n f nda t ns
ha he e onta t onsiut nyt ng
e han g e m nt
en iel s pa ae fom t empl
tr y e r t r he
oymentr l tons p. l d,t onl c
e ai hi ndee he y onneci t e
ton hes
c e cli sa a t ha wih Pl i if FLSA cai si t f ctt tt pa te e e e i o
ountr am ppe r o ve t antfs'
l m s he a ha he ri s ntr d nt
t eag e m e sdurngt tmeofan e oy e r ltons p.Ast Cou the d i bot
hes r e nt i he i
mpl m nt ea i hi
he
r l n h
Vale il a Nes t pr s nc ofage r e oye - mpl er a i hi al i Soo
l slo nd lon, he e e e
ne al mpl re oye eltons p one s t
t
atn ae 'o an x sfrafd r l itit ou toe ries p lme a j rs ito .
te u td' f e u o e ea dsrc c r t xecs u p e ntlu id ci n
Se Vale lo,
e l sil 2009 U . Di t LEX I 11 01 at* Nel on,2008 U . D i t LEX I 435 at
S. s .
S 3 5, 5; s
S. s .
S
44,
# Asars l,hi Cou t a n s be t te j rs ito o e De e d n s c u ecams
6.
e u tt s r h s o u j c matr u idcin v r fn a t' o ntr li .
B.Dee d ns'f lma ieDee s o e- f
f n a t A fr tv f n e fs to f
De e
f ndan sf rhe i itt tr quii t cou e cli st bebr hti sa ecou twil
t u t r nss ha e rng he nt r am o
oug n tt
r l
rs li ad na o j dca e o o , o v ne e f in s , n c mi .Aspat ft s
e utn e il f u iil c n my c n e inc , ar e s a d o t
y
r o hi
a gume ,Def nda snot t tbe aus t y ha r s d a afimatvede e e ofs tof,t y
r
nt
e nt e ha c e he ve aie n fr i
f ns
e - f he
wilbepr s ntngt s me e de eoft br ac sofc r ti f de a c uta pa to t t
l
e e i he a
vi nc
he e he
ontac n e r l ot ' s r f ha
de e e r ar l s ofhow t s Cou tr l on t m oton t d s i s
f ns eg d e s
hi
r u es he
i o im s .
Prorc e lw ha s sedt tpe s i c mtr l m sf s tof m a pr e
i as a
s ugge t ha nni sve ot e cai or e - f y oc ed
d s ietelc o a id p nd n b sso j rs ito i c rani tn e wh r t e
e pt h a k f n n e e e t a i f u idcin n eti nsa c s ee h
co e c am i i e pos d def nsvel t r duc apl ntf sr ove y r t rt n t pr de
unt r l i s ntr e
e i y o e e ai if ec r ahe ha o ovi
a fr tver i .Se Vale il 2009 U . Dit LEXI 11301 a *8.I t FLSA c e ,
fima i elef e lslo,
S. s.
S
5, t
n he
ont xt
-
6-
howe e , heEl ve h Cic tha plce c ran lm ison t us oft safima i de e e.
vrt
e nt r ui s a d e ti i t
he e hi fr tve f ns
Fo l i f r e Fit Cicui pr c de on t m a t r t s Co tr ce l af i med t ts - f
low ng o m r fh r t e e nt he te , hi ur e nty fr
ha etof s
a e i ppr i t i FLSA c e w he e t y r ul i s m i m um w a pay e st t
r na opr a e n
as s
r he es t n ub- ni
ge m nt o he
e o e.Seei a *9(ii Br nnanv. r 491F. 1 4( hCi.1 ,ov r edon
mplye
d. t ctng e
Hea d,
2d , 5t r 974) erul
ot rgr
he ounds M c au i v.Ri andShoeCo.486U. 1 ( 988:; e aloLo zv
, L ghln chl
,
S. 28 1
s e s pe .
fe A. aDit butonSers,LLC No.1 CV- 847- NG,201 U. Dit LEXI 1 35,a
g. Se sri i
v.
0- 21 Kl
0 S. s.
S 059 t
* 5( . Fl. e . , 01 ) Nes n 2 0 U.. s.
4- SD. a S pt2 2 0 ; lo , 0 8 S DitLEXI 4 5 4, t* .Be a s t LS
S 3 4 a 9 c ue S A
F
de r esa m i m u unc tona pa e a t c m a oft tA c a e nott be vii t d
ce
ni m
ondii l ym nt nd he om nds ha t r
o
ta e
by a em pl r e t rac i a one ort o h t ag nc ofa f de alc t' a s t of i
n
oye , ihe tng l
hr ug he e y
e r our ,' e - f s
pe m i s bl o y whe i w ilnotc e t pl i ifs wag t f l be ow t s a ut y m i m um .
r s i e nl
nt l
aus he a ntf
es o a l l he t t or ni
l at* -1 ( i Br nnan, F. a 4) Thus f e mpl a e oye c dr iet
d 9 0 quotng e
491 2d t .
, or xa e, n mpl r oul as he
af im a i def e ofs - fi a ca e w he e t e pl e r ce ved ove pa entofw a . Se
fr tve ens
etof n
s
r he m oye e i
r ym
ges e
i. t*1 ( ingSige v Cj o Wa o 3 4F.d 8 3( t Ci. 0 3 ) ns hac s ,h st
d a 0 ct n r . / f c , 2 3 l 5h r 2 0 ).l uc a e te ei
y
of w oul onl r duce t o r ym e whie s ilm a n a ni t pl i i f sr ove y of
f
d y e
he ve pa nt l tl i t i ng he a ntf ' ec r
m i m um w a unde FLSA .
ni
ge
r
Tho De e ant sr s t i fii nc ofha ngt fl t sa elw c r c c ams
ugh f nd s te s he ne fc e y
vi o ie he t t a onta t l i
i s a e c tw he t y w oul ale dy ha t pr e t s m e e de i f r lc tt
n t t our
n he
d ra
ve o es nt he a
vi nce n ede a our o
e t bls a s tof, e ede woul i f c ba t def ns i t sc e.Be a e as tof he e
sa ih e - f pr c nt
d n a t r he e e n hi as
c us e- f r
woul r duc Pli if r c r bel t FLSA sa ut y mi m u ,s h a de e ei not
d e e antfs' e ove y ow he
tt or ni m uc
f ns s
a o i t Se Br nnan, F. a 4;Vale ll 2009 U. Dit LEXI 11 5, *1 1;
ppr prae. e e
49l 2d t
lslo,
S. s.
S 301 at 0-1
Nel on,
s 2008 U . Di t LEX I 435 at*1 -11. Thi ca e doe noti ve a s tof aga ns a l
S. s .
S
44,
0
s s
s
nvol
e- f i t r
o
vep a m e ofw a .I t a i D ef nt w e e t pr va lon t rc nt r a m s i w oul
y nt
ges ns e d, f enda s r o e i
hei ou e cl i , t
d
r duc a r c r by Pl i if o t i FLSA cai beow t mi mum wa He e, t
e e ny e ove y
antfs n her
l ms l he ni
ge. nc he
afr tv d fns i i rpe i t sc ne t n t u i src e u d rRu e1 4 1 f r
fimaie ee e s mp o r n hi o tx a d h s s tik n n e l 2 9( ) o
i u fce c a amatro lw.Se Fe R. v. 1 ( 1 .V le il, 0 9U. DitLEXI
ns fiin y s te f a
e d. Ci P. 2 9( ) alslo 2 0 S. s.
,
S
1 3 5 a *1 (iigMir sh Cop. . e s ' Co tr t Re i, n .21 F. D. 81
1 01 , t 1 ctn c o o r v J s es mpues t par I c, 1 R. 6
( . Fl.2002:.
M D. a
I . CO N C LU SI N
V
O
Fo t a
r he bover a ons i i
e s ,t s
ADJUDGED t tPl itfs M o i n t Dimi sCountr l m Fie by De e nt i
ha an if ' to o s s
e cai l d
f nda s s
GRAN TED a t tDe e nt 'a fr ai de e eofs to fi src n f i ufk inc asa
nd ha f nda s fim tve f ns
e - f s tike or ns t e y
m a t rofl w .
te
a
DON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be sa M i m i Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi
da ofA ugus ,201
y
t
2.
FED
CO
REN O
UN I
TED A TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi spr ded t
e ovi
o:
Couns lofRe r
e
co d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?