Louis Vuitton Malletier, S.A. v. 100wholesale.com et al
Filing
55
ORDER GRANTING 43 Second Ex Parte MOTION for Temporary Restraining Order and Memorandum of Law in Support Thereof filed by Louis Vuitton Malletier, S.A., ORDER REFERRING MOTION: 43 Second MOTION for Preliminary Injunction and Memorandum of Law in Support Thereof. Motions referred to Andrea M. Simonton Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 8/6/2012. (cqs) Modified Text on 8/8/2012 (ra).
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.1 21 C1 SEI SI ONTON
2- 778- V- TZ/ M
LOUI VUI
S
TTON M ALLETI S. ,
ER, A.
Pli iâ
antf
VS.
I
OOW HOLESA LE.
COM ,e al,
t .
Def nda s
e nt .
/
ORDER GR ANTI SECOND TEM PORARY RESTRAI NG ORDER FX #WA FF
NG
NI
AND REFERRI M OTI FO R PR ELI I R Y I UN C TI N TO M A GI
NG
ON
M NA
NJ
O
STR ATE
JU DG E
-
-
TH I CAUSE c
S
ame be or t Cour on Pl ntf Se
f e he
t
ai ifs cond Ex Pa t Applc ton f
re
ia i or
En r o Te o ay Re tan n Or e a dPrlmiay lj n to (h d c n Ap lc to f r
ty f mp rr sr ii g d r n ei n r nu cin te ç o d p iain o
se
Te o ay Re tanngOr e' a an tDee d n s3 2- 7 1p ru n t 1 U.. j 1 1 a d
mp rr sr ii
d r' g is fn a t 8 6 4, u s a t o 5 SC. 1 6 n
)
Fe R.Ci P. f al dvi ai oft La
d. v. 65, or lege oltons he nham Ac,1 U. C.jj111 a 11 ( a
t 5 S.
4, nd 25a) nd
( )g 43 .Be a e Plitf h s s ts d te r q ie n sf rte is a c o a tmp rr
d DE- ) c us an if a aife h e urme t o h su n e f e o a y
r sr ni or r t Cour wilg a Pli ifs Se ond Applc to f Tempor y Resr i ng
e tai ng de , he
t l r nt antf' c
ia i n or
ar
tani
Or e ( 4 )f r h r a o sds u sdb lw.
d r DE- 3 o t e e s n ic se eo
1
.
FACTUAL BACK GROUNDZ
Pli if m a a t es pr ot ,diti e ,and s ls i i e sa e c
antf
nuf c ur , om es srbut s
el n nt r tt omm e c
r e,
'De enda s382- a e t Pa t r hi a Uni r aed As oc ai i ntfed on
f nt
674 r he rne s ps nd nco por t
s i tons de ii
Sc
hedul t ' her t
e û ' e o.
A
2Th fcu l c g o n i tke fo Plitf sS c n Ame d d Co an (e46 , c nd
e a t a ba k r u d s a n r m an if e o d
n e mplit d - ) Se o
A pplc to f r Te por y R e t a ni Or r a s
i a i n o m ar
s r i ng de , nd uppo tng e de i r s
r i vi nta y ubm i s o .Pl n i f
s i ns ai tf
fld d l ai and exhi t a xed t r o i s ppor of is Sec
ie ecar tons
bis nne
he et n u
t
t
ond Applc ton f
ia i or
Te
mpor r Re tai ng Or r The de a ai ns a e aval bl i t doc t a t f l ng
a y sr ni
de .
clr to r
ia e n he
ke t he olowi
e tis De lrto o Nioa Li a kn ( 4 - 1 De lr t n o S e he M .Ga fg n (
nre : ca ai n f k ly v d i DE 3 1, ca ai f tp n
o
f a DE
43- ,a De aai ofM aei M a o ( 43- .
221 nd clrton
lre ggi DE 251
icu ig wihn ti j d ca d src, lxu y g o s u d r mulil fd r l rg see
n ldn t i h s u iil itit u r o d n e
tpe e eal e itrd
y
ta e r s ( e De lr t n o Nioa Lia ki i S p r ofP an ifs S c n Ex Pa t
rd mak . S e caai f k ly v d n n u po t litf e o d
o
re
Ap lc to f rEnr o Te oa y Re tann Or e a d P ei n r Ij n to rLia ki
p iain o ty f mp r r sri ig d r n r lmia y nu cin s v d n
De 1'! 4 5.
c .) ! - )
'
Pl i if i t r git ed o r of t f l ng tade r on t Prnci l
antf s he e ser wne
he olowi r ma ks
he i pa
Re itrof h UntdS ae Pae ta dTrd mak Ofs e(het ui Vui o M ak ' :
gse t e ie tts tn n a e r tc t ç s t n r s'
Lo
t
)
T
r mar
ade k
Regi t at o Regi t aton
sr in
sr i
Number
0
297, 4
59
,
LOUI VUI
S
TTON
1
045, 2
93
,
151 8
, 9, 28
Dat
e
Cl se )/RelvantGoods
asts
e
S
I 1 -t
C 8 nmks va ie ,ta lngba ,s c s
, ls s r vei
gs athel,
e e r
pt mbe
20 1
ha xe
ho
e o ugga ha
b tbo sand s e boxesus d f rl ge, nd
, 932
a ,a poc t
gs nd kebooks
.
Aug t1
us 0,
,
1
976
I 1 -l ge a l di ha
C 8 ugga nd a es ndbags
.
J
I 1 -tunks vai e , r vei bags s t hel,
C 8 r , ls s ta lng
, ac s
a lll 1 h
rta' 0,
y
1
989
a bo and s boxesus d f l age ha
t xes
hoe
e or ugg , nd
ba ,a poc t
gs nd kebooks
.
1938,
v1 e , C 4 j wer wac s a d ta o s
mb
808 No e995r28 I 1 - e ly, the , n srpsf rm it
,
wa c .
t hes
T
r
ademar
k
Re sr i Re sr i
git aton
git aton
Numbe
r
Dat
e
Cl se)/Ree Goods
as ts
lvant
I 1 -wa c a sr psf m i twa c s
C 4
t hes nd ta or s t he .
I 1 -ca aoguesf t i l agea ta
C 6 tl
eaurng ugg
nd r vel
ac s i ,
c es ores bags s all t goods and
, m l eaher
,
g me s no eboo ,a t ogi ,a pa
ar nt ; t ks n hol es nd mphlt
es
r f ni t ta l ca e r ;tl phonei xes
e e ng o r ve; l nda s e e
nde ;
f unt i pe , lpoi pe ,ni ,c r f
o an ns bal nt ns bs ove s or
pocke a de k di is and c ckbook hol r .
t nd s are ,
he
de s
LOUI VUI
S
TTON
1990,
, 760
I 18 -tunks t a i t u ;s t as ;
C
r
; r velng r nks uic es
ta lng ba ;l
r ve i
gs uggag ga ntba f ta ;
e; nne
gs or r vel
A
ha boxesf ta l s bagsf ta ;
t
or r ve ; hoe
or r vel
V 9966, um br la ;a m alc r ir ; uc a ks
VUX
1
e ls ni
a re s r ks c ;
have s c ; e t rort xtl s
r a ks l a he
e ie hoppi ba ;
ng gs
bea h bags ha
c
; ndbags va t c ess d e y;
; niy as ol mpt
atac c e ;t ebags ta s t l;cl ch
t he as s ot
, r vel aches ut
bags bref s ;wa lt ;poc twal t c e t
; i ca es le s
ke les; r di
ca d ca es busne sc r c s s biland c r
r s ; i s ad a e ; l
ad
hol r ;c kbook hol r ;ke c s s c nge
de s hec
de s y a e ; ha
pur es bre c e-ypeporf i .
s ; if as t
tolos
I 24 -ta lblnkes
C
r ve n t
I 25-s rs s t hit;pol s rs T- hit;
C
hit; weas rs o hit; s rs
h a we rj c t;is bet; h wl; c r e .
e d a ;a kes te ; ls s a s s a v s
3
T
rademar
k
Regit aton Regit aton
sr i
sr i
Num ber
Dae
t
Cl se)/Ree Goods
as ts
lvant
I 1 -goodsma ofpr i met s na el
C 4
de
ecous al, m y,
so o
h e nmme t, m a na pnsj wer ,
n s o me tl i ;e ly
2, 77 8
1 , 28
nnme y, i ,e rrngs c fi ,b a elt,
l rngs a i , uflnks r c e s
c ms ne klce ;hor ogial i tu e s
har , c a s ol c nsr m nt,
sr psf wa c , t hesandwrs- thes
ta or t hes wa c
itwac ,
and c s sf wa c .
a e or t hes
I 18-goodsmadeofl a he ori iai of
C
e t r m t tons
la he a enoti l d i o he cl s s na y,
et r r
ncude n t r as e , mel
bo smad fom l t ;tunks vaies
xe
e r eaher r , ls ,
ta i bags l ge f ta l g m e ba
r velng
, ugga or r ve , ar nt gs
Aug t4, f ta , niy ca e s d e pt nzks cks
us
or r vel va t s s ol m y, c a ,
1
998
ha bags be h bags s
nd
, ac
, hoppi ba ,s de
ng gs houl r
ba ,at c c es bre ca e ,a fne la he
gs ta he as , i f s s nd i e t r
goods nn ey,pocke wale s pures la he
, m l
t lt , s , e t r
ke hol r ,b i sc r c s s c lng c r
y de s usnes a d a e , ali a d
c es a c e tca d c e , umbr l .
as , nd r di r as s and
elas
I 25-cl hi a under r na ey,
C
ot ng nd
wea , m l
s a e s s rs s t,wa sc t , ai oa s
we t r , hit, uis it oa s r nc t ,
s it, o t, u lv r, r u e s d e s sj c es
krs c as p lo e s to s r, r se ,a k t,
s wl ,sol s s he f we r s a ve ,ne kte ,
ha s t e , as s or a , c r s c is
po ke s r ,gl ,bels s ks bah r be ,
c t qua es oves t, oc , t o s
s , t , s nda s
hoes boo s and a l .
4
T
ra mark
de
Regi raton Regi rat on
st i
st i
Number
Dat
e
Cl ses /RelvantGoods
ast ) e
I 01 -goodsma ofpr ci me a s na ey,
C 4
de
e ous t l , m l
s eo n me t, r a n a pisj wer ,
ho r n ns o n me tl n ,e ly
na ey,rng ,bel buc es e rrngs c fi ,
m l i s t kl , a i , uflnks
br cee s c r s nec ac ,hor ogial
a lt , ha m , kl es ol c
i tu nt,sr psf wa c ,wache ,a
nsr me s ta or t hes t s nd
wrs- t hes and c esf wa c .
itwa c ,
as or t hes
.
2, 81 753
1 ,
I 1 -g
C 8 oodsm a ofla he o i t tonsof
de e t r r mia i
la he a eno i l
e t r r t ncuded i ot rc a s , me y,
n he l s es nn l
bo smadefom l t ;tunks vaies
xe
r eaher r , ls ,
ta i bags l gef ta ,ga me bags
r velng
, ugga or r vel r nt
Augus 18, h rta l va t c ess d e y,r ks c ,
f r ve , niy as ol mpt uc a ks
o
1 t
998
and ba ,be ch ba ,s
gs a
gs hoppi bags s de
ng
, houl r
bags at heca e ,bref as ,a fnel ahe
, tac
s s i c es nd i e t r
goods na ey, ke w alt ,pur e ,la he
, m l poc t le s s s e t r
ke hol r ,busnes c r c es calng c r
y de s i s a d as , li a d
ca e ,c e tc r c es andumbr l .
s s r di a d as ,
elas
I 25-c ot ng a unde wea ,nn ey,
C
l hi nd
r r m l
s t r ,s r s s t ,w a scoa s r nc t ,
wea e s hi t , uis i t t , ai oa s
s it, o t, ul v r,r usr, r se ,a k t,
krs c a s p lo es to e s d e s sj c es
L us uT o p l
o lv lT x u s
2
3 ,8
783 8
,
s w l ,s ol ,s hesf w e ,s r ,ne ktes
ha s t es as
or ar ca ves c i ,
poc s r s gl ve , ls s ks bah r s
ket qua e , o s be t, oc , t obe ,
s ,boot,a s ndal
hoes
s nd a s.
I 18-goodsm a ofl t rori ia i of
C
de eahe
m ttons
l ahernoti ude i ot rc a s ,
et
ncl d n he l s es name y,
l
boxesofl t prnci ly us d f ta l
eaher i pa l e or r ve
pur e , r nks va ies ta lngba ,
pos s t u , ls , r vei
gs
A ugus 22, ta i s t f cont i ng cos e i a
t
r velng e s or
a ni
m tcs nd
2()
)0 jwer , rucksacks handbags beach bags,
(
e ly
,
,
s ppi ba ,s ul rba ,brefca e ,
ho ng gs ho de gs i s s
pouc ,fnel t rgoodsnn y,poc t
hes i eahe
mel
ke
walet,pures ke c es busne sc r ca es
l s s , y as , i s a d s ,
c e tc d c es a c li c r ca e .
r di ar as , nd a lng a d s s
I 25 -Cl hi nn ey,s a e s s rs
C
ot ng, m l we t r , hit,
s a s rs pol s rs ts rs s t , it oa s
we thit, o hit, - hit, uis wa sc t,
r i t ,s r s c t ,pulove s tous r ,
a ncoa s kit , oa s
l r,r e s
;
23 165 Jn 2,00poestsquarespockethatlschiefe,ests
,6,9 ue 72 0 dckesjcet,hwl,ndkersavsneki ,
rse,aks, sa ssoe,crsquarcfor
e
w e r gl ,te ,bels ba hi s t , hoe ,
a , oves i s t , t ng uis s s
boot a s ndal , ha s
s nd a s and t .
5
T
r
ademar
k
R e s raton R e s r i
gi t i
gi t aton
Numbe
r
2, , 8
42161
Da e
t
Cl se)/Ree Goods
as ts
lvant
I 01 -Goodsma ofl ahe ori ia i of
C 8
de e t r m ttons
l ahe noti l
et r
ncuded i ot rcls es na y
n he a s , mel
J
vals ,ta lngba ,tavei s sf
ies r vei
gs r lng et or
a lr 16,
nta y
jj
2001
co an ng o me i , ndba ,s ppi bags
nt
os tcs ha
gs ho ng
,
s de bags bre ca es pouc ;fne lahe
houl r
, if s ,
hes i e t r
goods na y,poc twale s pur es key c e ,
, mel
ke
lt , s ,
as s
busnes c r ca e ,c edi c r ca e .
i s ad s s r t ad s s
I 1 -J wer i l ng rngs bel buc e of
C 4 e ly nc udi i , t kl s
pr c ousm eal,e r i ,c flnks br c e s
ei
t s a rngs uf i , a elt ,
c r , ooche ,nec ac s tepi ,
hn ms br
s
kl e , i ns
or ment pi ,a m e lons hor ogi l
na
al ns nd dali ; ol ca
a c ono erci tu e sa a r t ,
nd hr m ti nsr m nt nd ppa aus
nn el w a c s w a c c e a c oc ;
m y, t he , t h as s nd l ks
nu c ac r ofpr ci m ea s c ndlsi ksof
t r ke s
e ous tl ; a e tc
p e i u measj wer b x so p e iu
rco s tl,e ly o e f r co s
m e as
t l.
*
2, 1
773, 07
I 18:Tr velbags ta ba madeofl aher
C
a
, r vel gs
et ;
l getunksa va ie ,ga m e bagsf
ugga r
nd ls s r nt
or
ta ,va t c ess d e y;r c a ,
r vel niy- as ol mpt u ks cks
s d ba ,ha
houl er gs ndbags at c - s ,
; ta he ca es
O
bre c es dr w srng pouc s poc twale s
i f as , a ti
he , ke
lt ,
c obe 1
t r 4,
2003
pur e ,umbr l , i s ca d c e m a of
ss
elas busne s r as s de
lahe orofi ia i la he , e tc r ca e
et r
m tton e t r cr di a d s s
m a ofl t rorofi ia i l t r c li
de eahe
m t ton eahe ; a lng
ca d c e madeofl a he orofi t ton
r as s
et r
mia i
l ahe ;ke hol r madeofl ahe orof
e t r y de s
et r
i iato l a he .
m t in e t r
I 25 -Cl t ng,name y,unde wea ,s a e s
C
o hi
l
r r we t r ,
s rs T- hit,s t , ir bels, c r es
hit, s rs uis hose y, t s a v ,
ne k tes s wl,wa sc t ,s rs r i at,
c i , ha s it oa s kit, anco s
o ec as s p nd r,r usr ,e n , ulves
v ro t, us e es to e sj a s p lo r,
fo k ,a k t, n e g o e , rs go e ,
r c s jc es witr l v s d e s lv s
tg t, o k , ahngs is b t r be , jma ,
ih s s c s b t i ut, ah o s pan s
ni dr s ,s t ,pocke s r ;hi el d
ght es es hors
t qua es ghhe e
s , ow- l s s s ndal, s a
hoes l heeed hoe , a s boot , nd
slppers
i
.
0
.
.
30390 Dezljr,Is9-pcce,ugassadsetce
,2,3 cmb 6 o 0 Set lssnlse,n pcal
eje Ce
t
; as a
.
3, ,
051 235
J nua y 24, I 09 -Spec a es s
a r
C
t cl , ungl s es a s t c e
a s , nd pec a l
2006
cases.
6
The Loui Vuit M aksa e us d i c
s ton r r e n onne ton w ih t man acur a diti i ofgoods
ci
t he
uf t e nd srbuton
i t ec tg re ie tfe a ov . Se Lia kn De l !4 s ealoCe tfc tso Re itain
n h ae o is d n iid b e ( e v d i c. ; e s rii ae f gsrto s
f r h Lo sVuto M ak atc e a Co ost Ex bt t t eLi a ki De l)
o t e ui itn r s ta h d s mp ie hiiA o h v d n c.
Defnda s 38 6 t oug t l ene we ies o r tng unde t do an
e nt 2- 74, hr h he nt r t bst pe ai
r he m i
n me ie tfe o S he ue C 'h rt (h ç o p 1 S b e t Doman Na s' h v
n s d niid n c d l I eeo te s u 1 u j c
A'
Gr
i me ', a e
)
a rie pr
dve ts d, omot of e e f s e a o s d,a las,handba , wal s s ,bet ,
ed, f r d or al, nd/ r ol t e t
gs
let, hoes ls
s av s s n lse , wac e , a jwer b aig wh t Plitf h s d tr n d t b
c r e , u ga s s th s nd e ly e rn
a an if a eemi e o e
c e f is i rngeme s r pr tons a or col a e i t tons of t Loui Vuit
ountr et , nfi
nt , e oduc i , nd/
or bl mia i
he
s
ton
Maks ( e Li d i De l! 1 - 5)
r .S e va kn c. ! 2 1 .
Alhough e h De e ntm a notc a i rngee h Loui Vuit M a k f
t
ac
f nda
y
opy nd nfi
ac
s ton r or
e c cae y of goo pr e t d, Pl i if ha s itd s fce e de e s
a h tgor
ds ot c e
antf s ubm te ufi int vi nc howi ea h
ng c
Dee a th sifi g d, tla t o eo mo eo teLo i Vuto M ak . S eLia k nDe l
fnd n a n rn e a e s, n r r f h u s i n r s ( e v d i c .
t
! 1 1 . Dee d n s3 2 6 4 ae n tn w, rh v t y e e b e a t o ie o lc nsd t
! 2- 5) f n a t 8 - 7 r o o no a e he v r e n, u h rz d r ie e o
us r pr e,or m a c mt ret ,r pr tons an or c o a e i ia i of t Loui
e, e oduc
ke ot e f is e oduc i , d/ ol r bl m ttons
he
s
Vuto M ak . S eLia knDe l!9)
itn r s ( e v d i c. .
5.
Pl i ifr t i I si tve Cons t nt,a lce e prva e i si tve tr ,
antf e aned nve tgai
ula s i ns d i t nve tgai sm
t i si t t s e of c e f i ve sons of Pl ntf pr uc s by De e nt 382o nve tga e he al
ountr et r i
ai ips od t
f nda s
674.
( e Lia ki De l ! 1 De lrto o M ae i M a go i S p r o P an ifs S c nd Ex
S e v d n c. 0; caain f lre g i n u po t f litf e o
Pa t Appiain gM a go De 1' ! 3) l J n 2 2 a d J y 2 2 M ae i M a g o
re
l to s g i c .J . n u e 01 n ul 01 , lre g i
c
ç
'
($ a go',a e o e o Iv siaie Co s la t,p a e o d r frt p rha eo tr e
t g i' n mply e f n e t tv n utns lc d r es o he u c s f h e
M
)
g
wal s e h bea i a l s one oft tade ks a is i t s a ton t ough t I e ne
let, ac
rng t ea t
he r mar t s ue n hi c i hr
he nt r t
we sts o rtn u d r te Gr u 1 S be t Do i Nn s Iuiv to e ia u.o
b i peaig n e h o p 1 u j c man me o s uit nr pl a c m,
e
c
7
I ui - t onre i as o
o s vui t
plc . rg,
a Iuivuit nr plc ac m . ( e M a g o De l ! 4 a
nd o s to e ia .o S e g i
c.
nd
Co
mpost Exhi tA atc t rt )
ie bi ta hed heeo.
6.
The ea tr Pl i ifs r e e a i r viw e a vi ual i pe t d t we
r fe , antf epr s nttvt e e d nd s ly ns c e he b
pag lsi , i l ng i
e itngs ncudi mage , f t ie s be rng Pl i ifs ta m a ks pur ha e by
s or he t m
ai
antf r de r
c sd
M a o a deer i t ie s t be no g ne ve sons of Pl i ifs pr t . ( e
ggi nd t m ned he t m o
n- enui
ri
antf
oduc s Se
Lia kn De l ! 1 . Ad iin ly Plitf rp e e tt erv e d a dviu l is e tdt
v d i c. 2) dto al, an ifs e r s n ai e iwe n s al n p ce he
v
y
ie s be rng Pl i ifs ta m a ks ofe e f s l t o h t l e net we ies ope a i
tm
ai
antf r de r
f r d or ae hr ug he nt r
bst
r tng
u d rte rlva tGr u 1 S be tDo i Na s a d tr n d t e p o u t t b n nn e h ee n o p 1 u j c man me , nd eemie h r d cs o e o
g n i v rin o Plitf sp o u t.S eLi d i De l! 1 - 5)
e une eso s f an if r d cs (e va kn c. ! 3 1 .
l.
I
LEG A L STA N DA R D
l o d rt o ti atmp rr r srii o d r apa t mus d mo srt $ 1 gh r i)a
n r e o b an e o ay e tanng r e , ry t e n tae ç ) t e e s
(
s b tn illk lh o o s c e so t eme is ()t tirp rbl ij r wil s fee i t
u sa ta ieio d f u c s n h rt; 2 ha re aa e n u y l be u frd f he
rle i n tg a td ( )t t hetr ae dij r o t ih t eham t r le wo l ifito
tif s o rn e ; 3 ha t h etne nu y u weg s h r he eif ud n lc n
t non- nt a ( t tt e r oft rle woul s r t publci ees. Sc av c
he mova ; nd 4) ha ht nty he eif
d eve he i ntr t' hi o x.
'
r lSc ndlrv Sc av 403 F. 1 1 -26 ( 1h Ci.2005) s aloLe Staus & Co.
e hi e . hi o,
3d 223, 225
1t r
; ee s vi r s
v Su rs I tl T a ig I c,51 F.3 9 2 9 5 ( 1h Ci. 1 95 (p li te ts t a
. n ie n ' r dn n .
.
d 8 , 8 1 t r 9 ) a pyng h e t o
p ei n r ij n to i aLa ha Ac c s) Addto al, c ur ma o l is eatmp rr
r l ay nu cin n n m t a e . iin ly a o t y n y su e o ay
mi
r tani o derwihoutno ie t t a r epa t orisat r y i:
esr i ng r
t
tc o he dve s ry t to ne f
( s cii fcsi a afi vi oraveii compli ce ry s t ti dit a
A) pe fc a t n n fda t
rfed
ant lal how ha mme ae nd
irp r beij r ,ls , rd ma ewilrs tt temo a b f r t ea v rep ry c n
re a a l n u y o s o n g l eul o h v nt eo e h d e s a t a
b he r i o p sto ln ( te mo a ts atr e c riis i wrtn a yef rs
e ad n p o iin a dl B) h
v n ' to n y e t e n iig n fo t
f
ma t gi notc a t r a onswhyi s dnotber uie
de o ve i e nd he e s
t houl
eq r d.
FE R. V. 65( .Exparetmporr r tani o desGho dbersrde t s r i t i
D. CI P. b)
t e ay esri ng r r f ul e ti d o e vng her
s
un e lig p mo eo p e evngt sau q a d p e e tn irpaa l h r j s s lnga
d ryn u s f r s r i he tts uo n r v n ig re rb e a m u t o o s
8
i ne es a y t hol a he rng a no l e . Gr y Goos Foods I c v Br t eho d o
s c sr o d
a i nd
ong r' lnn
'
e
, n . .
oh r o f
Te mse s( AuoTr c Drv r Lo a No 7 o a iaCny ec, 5U. 4 , 9( 9 4 .
a tr f t u k ie s c l . 0 fAlmed l, /. 41 S. 23 43 1 7 )
11
1.
A NA LY SI
S
The de a a i Pli ifs itd i s
clr tons antf ubm tt n uppor ofis Se
t t cond Applc ton f Te r r
i ai or mpo a y
Re tani Or rs
sr i ng de uppor t f l ng c usonsoflw :
t he olowi oncl i
a
A.
Pli ifha a ve y sr ng pr biiy ofpr ng atti lt tc um e sar lke y
antf s
r to
oba lt
ovi
ra ha ons r e i l
t be c us by Def nda s 38 674' a rieme ,pr
o
onf ed
e nt 2- s dve ts nt omoton,s l ,ofe f s l a or
i
a e fr or ae, nd/
d srb to o h nd g , les s e , et, c r e , u g as s wac s j wer a d rltd
itiu in f a ba s walt, ho s b ls s a v s s n lse , the , e ly, n eae
goods be rng c e f t , r pr tons a or c o a e i iai of t Loui Vuit
a i ount reis e oduc i , nd/ olr bl m ttons
he
s
ton
M aks a t t t pr
r , nd ha he oducs De e
t
f ndant 382s
674 a e s lng a pr otng a e c pi of
r eli nd om i r o es
Pl ntf' pr t t bea c es of t Loui Vuit M a ks on ha
ai ifs oduc s hat r opi
he
s
ton r
ndba ,wale s s ,
gs
lt , hoes
b l , c r e , u ga ss wac e , n e ly
et s av s s n lse , th s a djwer .
s
B.
Be us oft i rng nt of t Loui Vuit M a ks Pl ntf i lkey t
ca e
he nfi eme
he
s
ton
r , ai if s i l o
s fe i daea d irpaa l ij r i atmp rr r sr ii o d ri n tg a td. tce ry
ufr mme it n re r be n u y f e o ay e tanng r e s o r ne l lal
a a sfom t f l ng s ik f t,ass f t i Pli ifsSe
ppe r r he olowi pect acs
et orh n a ntf
cond Am e d Compl i ,
nde
ant
Se ond Applc ton f Te
c
ia i or mpor r Re tani Or r a a ompa ng decar tons on fl
a y sr i ng de , nd cc
nyi
l ai
ie,
ta i dit a dirp r bel s d ma e a ij r wilrs l t Plitf a dt c ns mes
h t mme ae n re aa l os, n g , nd nu y l e ut o an if n o o u r
be o e Def nda s 382- c n be he r i opposton unl s Pli tf s r s f p pare
fr
e nt
674 a
ad n
ii
es a n if eque t or x
t
r lefi g ant
ei s r ed:
1.
De e nt 38 674 o n orcontolI e ne webst busne s s a a e
f nda s 2w
r nt r t
ie i s e nd r
ea h pa t of a il ga e e rs w hi h ad ri es pr o e ,of er f s e,a s ls a l a t
c
r
n le l nt m i e
c ve ts , om t s f s or al nd e l t e s
h n b g , les s o s bet, c r e , u lse , th s a dj wer be rn c u tret n
a d a s walt, h e , ls sa v s s nga s s wac e , n e ly a ig o n efi a d
i rng ngta m a ksi vi a i ofPli ifsrg s
nfi i r de r n olton
a ntf i ht ;
9
2.
The e i good c us t be i ve t t m or co e f i a i rng ng
r s
a e o le ha
e unt r e t nd nf i i
pr ucsbe rng Pli ifsta mar wila a i t ma ke pl c t tc um e sa e lkey
od t a i
antf r de ks l ppe r n he r t a e; ha ons r r i l
t be m il c us d,a dia nt d by t qualt oft s pr t ;and t tPli ifma
o
sed, onf e nd s ppoi e
he
iy he e oduc s
ha a ntf y
s f r l s of s e f is ge ne pr ucs a an unna ur l e oson of t l gii t
ufe os
als or t nui
od t nd
t a r i
he e tma e
m a keplcei whih i ope aes a
r t a n c t r t ; nd
Ther i good c e t bele t t i Pli if pr e ds on notc t
e s
aus o ive ha f a ntf oc e
ie o
De e nt 382- 4 on t s Se nd Applc to f Te
f nda s
67
hi co
ia i n or mpor r Resr i ng Or r Def nda s
ay
tani
de ,
e nt
38 - 7 c n e sl a d q ik y ta se t e rg srto f rma y o t Gx u 1 S be t
2 6 4 a a iy n uc l r n fr h e itains o n f he o p 1 u j c
Dom an Na ,or m odiy r itai daa and c e ,c nge hoss nd r r c ta fc t
i
mes
f eg sr ton t
ontnt ha
t ,a edie t r fi o
ot rwe ie , he e t ri Pl i ifsa lt t o an m e ngf r le .
he bst s t r by hwa tng antf biiy o bt i ani ul e if
C.
Thebaa e ofpo e ilhar t Def nda s38 674 i r tani t i ta i
lnc
t nta m o
e nt 2n esr i ng her r de n
cou e f i a i rngi br nded goods i a t mpor r r tani or r i is d i f r
nt ret nd nfi ng a
f e
a y esr i ng de s s ue s a
out ghe by t pot nta ha m t Pli if isr put i n,a good ilasam a a t e a
wei d
he e i l r o a ntf, t e ato nd
w l
nuf c ur r nd
diti orofqualt pr
srbut
iy oduc si s h r i i no is d;a
t f uc elef s t s ue nd
D.
The publc i e e tf vor is e oft tm por r r sr i ng or ri or rt
i ntr s a s s uanc
he e
a y e tani
de n de o
pr ec Pl i ifs ta m a k i e ess a pr e t publc fom beng de r d by t
ot t antf r de r ntr t nd otct he
i r
i
faude
he
pal i of ofco e f tg
m ng f
unt rei oodsa ge negoodsofPli if
s nui
antf .
I
V.
CONCLUSI
ON
Fort f e ngr as ,i i
he or goi e ons t s
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t t Pl ntf s Sec
ha ai if
ond Applc i n f r Te
iato o
mpor r
ay
Retai ngOr rf aTe ar Retani Or ri hee GRANTED ( 43 asf l :
sr ni de or mpor y sri ng de s rby
DE- ) olows
1
0
Ea h Def nda 38 674,is ofi e s diecor , empl s a nt,s i a i ,
c
e nt 2t fc r , r t s
oyee , ge s ubsdi res
diti or ,a a 1pe s i a tve c er orpm ii ton wih a De e
srbut s nd l r ons n ci onc t
cpai
t ny f ndantha ng no i
vi
tce
oft sOr ra ehe e t mpor rl r taned:
hi de r r by e
a iy esr i
a. Fr ma acurng,i
om
nuf t i mpori a rii pr otng,ofe i t s l,
tng, dve tsng, om i
f rng o el
s li diti tng, ta f ri an pr t be rng t Loui Vuit
elng, srbu i or r ns e rng y oduc s a i he
s ton
M ar ,or a c usngl smia tade a ks o he t n t e a ua l
ks
ny onf i y i lr r m r , t r ha hos ct ly
ma acur o diti e byPl i if a
nuf t ed r srbut d
antf ; nd
Fr
om s c ei
e r tng, c nc alng, desr ng, s lng of, ta f ri or
o e i
toyi
eli
f r ns e rng,
ohe ied s o ig o :()a y p o u t,n tma u a tl d o dsrb td
t m s ip sn f i n r d cs o n f ct e r itiue
r
by Pl ntf be rng t Lo s Vuitn M a ks or a c usngl sm ia
ai if a i he ui
to
r , ny onf i y i lr
ta e r s o (i a y e ie c rltngt te ma ufcu e i o tto ,
r d ma k ; r i n v d n e eai o h n a tr , mp rain
)
s l ofe f s l diti i or ta f r of a pr t bea i t
ae, f r or ae, srbuton, r ns e
ny oduc s rng he
Loui Vuit M a ks ora c usngl sm ia tade a ks
s ton r , ny onf i y i l r r m r .
(
2)
Eac Deenda 382- isofkes die t s e oye ,a nt,s i ais
h f nt 674, t f r, r cor, mpl es ge s ubsdire ,
diti o s a al pe s i a tve c
srbut r , nd 1 r ons n c i once torpa tci ton wih a De e ntha ng notce
r
ri pa i
t ny f nda
vi
i
of t s Or r s l i e a ey dic i t us of t Loui Vuit M a ks or a
hi
de hal mm dit l s ontnue he e
he
s
ton
r ,
ny
c usngl sm iar ta m a ks on or i conne ton wih al I e e webst s owned a
onf i y i l r de r ,
n
ci
t 1 ntm t
ie
nd
o r t or c r l d by t m,i l ng t I e ne we ie o r tng undert Gr p 1
pe aed, ontole
he ncudi he nt r t bst s pe a i
he ou 1
S be t manNa s
u j c Do i me ;
(
3)
Ea h Defnda 382- isofkes die t s e oye ,a nt,s i a is
c
e nt 674, t t r, rcor, mpl es ge s ubsdire ,
diti or ,a a1pe s i aci c e torpa tcpa i wih a De e ntha ng no i
srbut s nd 1 rons n tve onc r
ri i ton t ny f nda
vi
tce
of t s Or r s l i e ael dic i ue t us of t Lo s V uit M a ks or a
hi de hal mm di t y s ontn he e
he ui
ton
r ,
ny
c usngl sm ia ta m a ks wihi domai na e e e i ns m e a ags or ot m ar s
onf i y i lr r de r
t n
n m xt nso , t t
her
ker
wihn we ies u c c d ,fo u eo a y we p g (n ldn a t t l o a y we p g )
ti bst o re o e r m s n n b a e icu ig s he i e f n b a e ,
t
a a ri i lnks t ot r webst , fom s ar h e nes da a s s or c che m e or a
ny dve tsng i
o he
ies r
e c ngi ' t ba e
a
m y, nd
a ot r f m of us of s h t r s whi h i vii e t a c
ny he or
e
uc e m
c s sbl o omput r us r or s r es t die
e e
e v o r ct
co t r s r hest webst r se ed by,owned,oro r t d by e h De enda , i l ng
mpu e ea c
o
ies egitr
pe a e
ac
f nt nc udi
t el tme we ie o eaigu d r h Gr u 1 S be t manNn s
h n e t bsts p rtn n e t e o p 1 u j c Do i me ;
()
4
Ea h Dee da ts alno ta se o es i o t Gr u 1 Su j c Do i
c fn n h l t r n fr wn rhp f he o p 1 be t man
Na e durng t pe nc oft sAci oruntlf t Or roft Cour;
m s i he nde y hi ton,
i urher de
he
t
()
5
Th d mann meRe itasf rt Gr u 1 S be t manNa sa ed rce
eo i a
gsrr o he o p 1 u j c Do i me r ie td
t ta f r t Pl n if s c
o r nse o aitf ouns l f de i wih t s Cou t doma n na c tfc t s f t
e , or post t hi
r,
i me erii a e or he
Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na s
o p 1 u j c man me ;
()
6
Up n P an ifsrq s,hep i c p o eto s r ief ra y Gr u 1 S b e t
o litf t ue t t rva y r tci n evc o n o p 1 u j c
Dom an Na e f r whi h t Regita us s s prva pr tci s r i t c ea t
i
m s o
c he
sr nt t uch i cy ot ton e vce o onc l he
Re sr ntsi ntt a c ac i or a i a eor r d t dic os t Pl ntf t tue i nttes
gita ' de iy nd ont t nf m ton r de e o s l e o ai if he r de ii
a c a ti or ton oft eRegitan s
nd ont c nf ma i
hos
sr t ;
()
7
Up n e ty o t i Or e ,P an ifs l prvieac py o t e Or e bye i t
o nr f hs d r litf hal o d o f h d r mal o
t er gsr ro rc r f re c o t eGr u 1 S b e tDo i Nn s s t a t er gsrro
h e ita f e o d o a h f h o p 1 u j c man me , o h t h e ita f
r c r o e c o t eGr u 1 S be tDo i Nn sma ,i t r , o iy e c r gsrn o t e
e o d f a h f h o p 1 u j c man me y n u n n tf a h e ita t f h
Or r a pr de no i oft l ki oft domai nn t t r gita ofr c d.Afe
de nd ovi
tce he oc ng
he
n me o he e sr nt e or
tr
pr di s h notc t t r sr r s t domai nn
ovi ng uc
i e o he egita s o he
n mes ma be l cke Pl ntf s l as
y
o d, ai if hal lo
p o i n tc a dac p o t i Or e t tergsr n o e c S b e t manNa v ae i
r vde oie n o y f hs d r o h e ita t f a h u j c Do i me i mal
t t e la es pr de a pa toft do a n r gitai da a f ea h oft Gr 1
o he mai ddr s ovi d s r
he m i e sr ton t or c
he oup 1
Su j c Do i Nn si niidi t eSe o dAp lc to frTe o ayRe tanngOr e . f
be t man me de tfe n h c n p iain o mp rr sr ii d r I
a e i a d e swa n tprvie a p r o t ed man rg srto d t f raSu j c Do i
n mal d r s s o o d d s a t f h o i e itain aa o
be t man
N am e,Pl i if s l pr vi notc a a copy of t s Or t t ope a or of t l e ne
a ntf ha l o de i e nd
hi der o he
rt s
he nt r t
webst svi a e la es a oronlne s ison f m spr de on t l e
ie a n mai ddr s nd/
i ubm s i or
ovi d
he ntnwtwe ies
bst
o eaigu d rs c Gr u 1 Su j c Do i Na s Afe f ry-ih ( )ho sha eea s d
p rtn n e u h o p 1 b e t man me . tr o t eg t 48 ur v lp e
1
2
a t t e lng of t s Or er t t r sr r of r or and t r gita s Pl i if s l
fer he maii
hi d o he egita s
ec d
he e sr nt , antf hal
p o i e ac p o t i Or e t t er g sre f rt e Gr u 1 S be tDo i Na sf rt e
r v d o y f hs d r o h e itis o h o p 1 u j c man me o h
p r o e d s rb di Paa rph8 i#a
u p s s e cie n r ga ,n ;
()
8
Th d man n me Re itas f r t e Gr u 1 Su j c Do i Na s s al
e o i n
g srr o h o p 1 be t man me h l
i d aey a ss i c a gn t eRe ita o r c r f rt Gr u 1 Su jc Do i Na s
mme it l sit n h n ig h g sr r f e o d o he o p 1 be t man me ,
e e i a s h domai na e whi h s
xc ptng ny uc
n m s
c uch Re sr r ha bee notfe i wrtng by
gita s ve
n ii d n ii
Pl ntf ha bee orwilbedimis d fom t saci , t a hol ng a ountw ih a Re sr rof
ai if ve n
l
s s e r hi ton o
di cc
t
gita
Plitf c o i (h ç w Re ita' . t et tn t Re ita sd n ta ss i c ngng
an ifs h osng t e d
Ne gsrr' To h xe t he gsrr o o sit n ha i
)
t eRe itaso Re o d frt e d mansu d rt i r s e t c n r lwihn o e( )bu ie s
h gsrr f c r o h o i n e her ep ci o to ti n 1 sn s
ve
d yofr c ito t i Or e,tetp-e e d man (
a
e ep f h s d r h o lv l o i TLD)Re itis( rt era miitao s f r
gsre o h i d n srtr) o
t eGr u 1 Su jc Do i Na s wihn fv ( )b sn s d y o r c i o t i Or e , h l,
h o p 1 be t man me , ti ie 5 u ie s a s f e ept f h s d r s al
c a eo a ss i c a gng t eRe ita o rc r f rt Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na s
h ng r sit n h n i , h gsrr f e o d o he o p 1 u j c man me ,
e e i a s h do an nn es whih s h Regiti ha be notfed i wrtng by
xc ptng ny uc
m i m
c uc
sres ve en i
n ii
Pl i ifha be n orwilbedim is d f o t sa ton,t ahol ng a oun wih aReg sr rof
antf ve e
l
s s e r m hi c i o
di cc t t
ita
Plitf c o ig (h ç w Re ita '. a matro lw,hi Or e s aln ln e a pl
an ifs h osn te t
Ne gsrr' As
)
te f a t s d r h l o o g r p y
t a De e n o a s it d do an nn e d s is d fom t sa ton.
o ny f nda t r s oc ae m i m im s e r hi c i Upon t c ngeoft
he ha
he
Re ita ofrc r f rt e Gr u 1 S be tDo i Na s t Ne Re ita wilmanan
g srr e od o h o p 1 u j c man me , he w g sr r l iti
a c s t t eGr u 1 S b e tDo i Na si tu tf rt Co r d rn t tpe d n yofti
c e s o h o p 1 u j c man me n r s o he u t u i g h n e c h s
aci Addii ly,t Ne Re sr r s l i e aey i tt e a t m por r 302 dom an
ton.
tona l he w
gita hal mm dit l nsiut
e
ay
i
n rd rcin whc wila t maial r dr c a y vst rt t e Gr u 1 Su j c Do i
mne e ie to ih l u o tc l e ie t n iio o h o p 1 be t man
y
Na
mes
t
o
t
he
f l ng
olowi
Unior
fm
Res ce
our
ht p:/ e i
t /s N nanotce c /vm s rp/nde ht l whe e
i . om l e i x. m
r on c es
opi
Loc t
aor
(1 ,)
ç '
UR1 '
t Se
he
cond A m e ed
nd
Compl i ,Se ond Te
ant c
mpor r Resr i ng Or r a a lot rdoc e son fl i t s a to
a y tani
de , nd l he
um nt
ie n hi ci n
13
aed s ly d Ale aiey t eNe Re ita ma u aet Do i Nn Sy tm ($ '
r ipa e . tm tv l, h w gsrr y pd t he man me se ç
DNS'
)
d t i manansfrt eGr u 1 Su jc Do i Na s wh c l ted mann me t t eI
aa t iti o h o p 1 be t man me , ih i h o i a s o h P
nk
a e s wher t i a s i t wt ie a e hose t NSIM EDI TEM PLE.
ddr s es
t he r s oc aed bst s r
t d, o
.
A
NET a
nd
N SZ. EDI
M
ATEM PLE. ET, c wilc us t domai nn e t r s vet t we iewhe e
N
whi h l a e he
n m s o e ol o he bst
r
c esoft Sec Amende Compl i ,Sec Te por r Resr i ng Or r a al o he
opi
he ond
d
ant
ond m a y
tani
de , nd l t r
doc nt on fl i t sa ton a e diplyed. Afe t Ne Re sr hasefe t t sc
ume s ie n hi c i r s a
t r he w gitar
f ced hi hange
t eGr u 1 S b e tDo i Na ss l b plc do Lo k saus p e e tn t emo i ain
h o p 1 u j c man me hal e a e n c tt , r v n ig h dfc to
ord e i oft do a nsby t New RegitarorDef nda s38 67
elton he m i
he
sr
e nt 2- 4.
()
9
Plitf ma e e t eGr u 1 S b e tDo i Na sit Go ge sW e ma tr
an if y ntr h o p 1 u j c man me no o l' b se
Tool a c ela r r ton oft dom anst ha be e e e t r by De e n s382s nd anc ny edieci
he
i hat ve en nt r d he e
f nda t
67 whih r diec ta fc t t c e f i ope ato t a ne dom an nn e orwe ie a
4
c e r t r f o he ountr et r i ns o
w
i m
bst nd
t r by e
he e vadet pr sonsoft sOr r
he ovii
hi de ;
( 0) Ea hDee nt38 674s l prs r ec esofa1 c
1
c fnda 2- hal e e v opi
1 omputrfl r ltngt t
e es eai o he
us o a y o t eGr p 1 S be tDo i Na sa d s altk a1se sn c say t rtive
e f n f h ou 1 u j c man me n h l a e l tp e e sr o ere
c mp trflsr ltn t t e u e o t e Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na st a ma h v b e
o u e ie eaig o h s f h o p 1 u j c man me h t y a e e n
delt be or t e r oft sOr r
eed f e he nty hi de ;
Thi Sec Te por r Resr ni Or rs lr m an i efe tuntlt d e f
s ond m a y
tai ng de hal e i n f c
i he at or
teh aig o t eM oin f rP ei n r lj n to s tf rh b l w,o t i s h f rh rd ts
h e rn n h t o r l ay nu cin e o t eo r mtl uc u te ae
o
mi
ass tby t Cour orsi aed t by t pa te ;
e
he
t tpult o he ri s
( 2 Th sSe o Te o a y Retanig Or e s ala py t t Gr u 1 Su j c
1)
i c nd mp r r sri n d r h l p l o he o p 1 b e t
Dom ai N a es as oci t d w e ies a a ot rdom a n na e a webs t pr pery br
n m , s ae
bs t , nd ny he
i m s nd
ies o l ought
t t Co tsate ton and ve i d by s n a fda twhih ve ii s ne domai na
o he ur ' t n i
rfe
wor fi vi
c rfes uch w
n mes
14
a e beng us d by De e
r i
e
f ndan s382- f t pum os ofc e f ii t Loui Vuit M a ks
t
674 or he
e ount retng he
s ton r
a is i t sac i a o unf ry co pe i wih Pl ntf on t W ord W i
t s ue n hi ton nd/ r ail m tng t ai if he
l de;
( 3 Pu s a tt 1 U. C.j 1 1 ( )5 ( ,Plitf s almanan is p e o sy
1)
ru n o 5 S.
1 6 d ( )D) an if h l iti t rviu l
p se b ndi t en t o Te Th usndDo lr a d Zeo Ce t ( 00 .0 , sp y n of
o td o n h momt f n o a
la s n r n s $1 ,000 ) a a me t
d ma e t wh c Dee d n s3 2 6 4 ma b e t ld fra wr n f lij n to o r sr it
a g s o ih f n a t 8 - 7 y e ni e o
t
o g u n u cin r e tan ,
durng t pe ncy oft saci o untlf t rOr roft Cour;
i he nde
hi ton, r i urhe de
he
t
(4) Th Plitf sSe o d Mo in f rPr l n r Ij n to ( 4 )i r fn' t
1
e an if c n
to o ei a y n u cin DE- 3 s ee e o
mi
d
t Honor bl Andr M .Si on on,Unie Stt s M a sr t J e. A he i i s tbe o e
he
a e
ea
m t
td ae
gita e udg
ar ng s e f r
M ag sr t J
itae udge Andr M .Si on on i t Unie Stt Courhous l a e a 301 Norh
ea
m t n he t d a es
t e oc t d t
t
t
M i miAvenue M im i Fl i 331 8t Fl or on Augus 16, 2012,at2: p. ,o a s h
a
, n , orda 28, h o
00 m. r t uc
ot rtme t tt sCou tde m sa oprae, whi h tmeDef nda s382- a ora o he
he i ha hi
r e
ppr i t at c i
e nt
674 nd/ ny t r
a f c e per o ma c lng t a pr it nes oft sOr era m ovet di s vet s m e
fe t d s ns y hale e he p opra e s hi d nd
o s ol he a
a da whc tmeteCo r wil e rag n o Plitf rq e tdp ei n r ij n to
n t ih i h u t l h a rume t n an ifs e u se r l a y nu cin;
mi
( 5 Pli ifs l s r ecopisoft Se nd Applc ton f Te r r Resr ni
1 ) antf hal e v
e he co
iai or mpo ay tai ng
Or ra t sOr rand a1ot pla ngsa doc
de nd hi de
1 her e di
nd ument o tl i t sa ton on Def nt
s n qe n hi c i
enda s
38 674 by ema l a des rbed a
2i s ci
bove a by posi c e of t Se
nd
tng opis
he cond Applc ton f
ia i or
Te
mpor r
ay
Re ta ni
sr i ng
Or r an
de
d
t s
hi
Or r
de
on
t
he
we ie
bst
l ae
oc t d
a
t
htp:/e i
t /s a nenotc . l er i ht wihi f t eght( hour ofcontoloft
iecom/vms p/ndex. ml t n ory-i 48)
s
r
he
Gr u 1 S b e tDo i Na sb ig c n e t t e Co tvi t eNe Re ita ' h dn
o p 1 u j c man me en ha g d o h ur a h w gsrrs olig
a c ,a s h notce s gi n s lbe dee
c ount nd uc
i o ve hal
med go a s fcents r c t r of Pl n if
od nd ufi i e vi e he e . aitf
s l c i t pr deno ie oft e pr ee ngsa c e oft doc e son tl i t s
ha l ontnue o ovi
tc
hes oc di
nd opi s he um nt
ie n hi
m at r t
te o
De e nt 38 674 by r gul l upda i
f nda s
2e ary
tng t
he webst l a e a
ie oc t d t
15
ht p:/ e i
t /s a nenotc c /vm s r i x.ht lorby o he m e nsr as bl c c atd t gi
i e. om l e p/nde m
t r a e ona y alul e o ve
notc whi h i pe m itd by t Cour.
ie c s r te
he
t
( 6 An r s n e o o sto t Plitf
1)
y e po s r ppo ii n o an ifsM o in f r Prl n r Ij n to
to o ei ay n u cin
mi
mus be sld a s ve o Pl n ifs c
t
e nd er d n aitf ouns lb Augus 1 , 2012,whih i f t eiht( )
e y
t 4
c s ory- g 48
ho sprort t he rng s tf Augus 1 , 201 a fl d wih t Cour,a ong wih Pr of
ur i o he a i e or
t 6
2, nd ie t he
t l
t oof
Se vie.Pli ifs l tl a Re y M emor
r c antf ha l le ny pl
andum on orbe or Augus 15, 201 The a
f e
t
2.
bove
da e ma ber s d upon si a i b a lpa tesa a o oft sCour. D ef
ts y
evie
tpulton y l ri nd ppr val hi
t endant 382s
674 ar her by o no it t f iur t a ar att he i m ay re ul i t i poston
e t n tc hat a l t o ppe
he arng
s t n he m ii
o a pr lmi r i un to a ans t e pur ua tt 1 U. C.j 1 1 ( ) Fe R.Ci P.
f ei na y nj c in g i t h m
s n o 5 S.
1 6 d , d.
v.
65,a t sC our ' i
nd hi
t s nher ntaut iy.
e
hor t
7
+
DONEAN OR RE ica esnMi ,lratif dyo A gs 21 a
D DE D n hmbri a Foi ,hs a f uut 02 t
mi d
,
J. '
0
.
1
,
&
/
/
N
PATRI A A.SEl Z
CI '
X
Unie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge
cc:
J
udge Si o on
m nt
A1 Couns ofRe or
l
el
c d
1
6
SC H ED ULE A
DEFENDANTS BY NUM BER AND SUBJECT DOM A I NAM ES
N
De e
f ndantN um be
r
Defnda 38
e nt 2
Defnda 38
e nt 2
Defnda 38
e nt 2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
D e e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt382
f nda
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
Dee
f ndan 382
t
D e e nt382
f nda
D e e nt382
f nda
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
D e e nt382
f nda
Dom ai N am e
n
1 ove. t
854l ne
aouivuit no lt . t
l s to ute sne
aouivuit ute so g
l s tono lt .r
outetouivuit ne
l l s tonn. t
oute l s tonn.r
ltouivuit o g
a a l uivuit c
s c o s ton.om
a a oc l s to rne
s c heouivuit nf . t
s oc ouivuit rne
ac hel s tonf. t
s oc l s tonf. g
ac he ouivuit ror
s oc l s ton- cec
ac he ouivuit gr .om
a a oc ouivuit rco
s c hel s tonf . m
s oc l s tonfr cec
ac he ouivuit r .om
be toui vuit noute 4u. om
sl s to
lt c
besl s to lt ne
touivuit noute 4u. t
bol c
vn.om
bore vdonna. z
sl
bi
bore vdonne.om
sl
c
c a ouivui noutet or
he pl s lo l 4u. g
che pl s ûonoutet ne
a ouivui
l 4u. t
dico toui v tono lt .om
s u l s uit ute sc
dico l s tono lt . t
s untouivuit ute sne
dico l s it no lt .r
s untouia to ute so g
hr d gsouivuit
ba l s tonoute sco
lt . m
handba l s tonoute sne
gsouivuit
lt . t
hr dba l s it
gsouia tonoute sor
lt . g
handba l s it
gsouia tonoute c
lû.om
hand gsouivuit
ba l s tonoute ne
lû. t
luivuit
o s tonquik. t
c ne
l nvv c
e . om
l ui vuit
o s tonoute tnet
lt.
loui vuit
l s tonoute sne
lt. t
l uiv ton gs lt4u.
o s uit ba oute t com
l uiv ton gs lt4u. t
o s uit ba oute t ne
l uivuit nba oute t or
o s to gs l t4u. g
17
De e
f ndan 38
t 2
De e nt382
f nda
Def nt38
enda
2
Defnda 38
e nt 2
Defnda 38
e nt 2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
Defnda 38
e nt 2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e nt382
f nda
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
De enda 382
f nt
Def nt382
enda
De enda 382
f nt
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e n 38
f nda t 2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt382
f nda
Def nda 382
e nt
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
De enda 382
f nt
De e nt38
f nda
2
D e e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e n 38
f nda t 2
De e
f ndan 38
t 2
l s tonba outeu. g
ouivuit gs l t or
l s to gs lt .com
ouivuit nba oute us
l s it gs lt .net
ouivu tonba oute us
l s ûonbor e lt .om
ouivui
s oute ac
l s tonbor e lt .or
ouivuit
s oute a g
l s lonbor e lt . g
ouivui
s oute sor
l s tonboreoutel.o
ouivuit
s l cm
l s tonboreoutet. t
ouivuit
s l tne
l s ûonboreoutet.om
ouivui
s l sc
l s uit nboreoutet. t
ouiv to
s l sne
l s tonbor eo ltne
ouivuit
s ute . t
l s tonbor e lt.om
ouivuit
s oute ic
l s tonbor e ld. g
ouivuit
s oute or
l s tonbor esne
ouivuit
s . t
l s tonbr slc
ouivuit a i.om
l uivuit br sl .om
o s ton a isc
l s to ndba - .om
ouivuit nha
gs hotc
l uiv ûoA a
o s ui
ndba oute4u.
gs l t net
l s to r dba oute4u. g
ouivuit A
gs l t or
l s it and gs te u.om
ouiu toA
ba ou lt c
l l .
ove vsnet
l s tonoutd4usor
ouivuit
l
. g
l s tonbags lt c
ouivuit
oute4u.om
l s lonoute onlne4u. g
ouivui
lt i
or
l s tonouteonlneic
ouivuit
lt i .om
l uivuit
o s tonoute onlnes c
lt i 4u.om
l s it
ouiu tonoute o i 4u. g
lt nlnes or
l s lonoute s l c
ouivui
lt ae4u.om
l s to te s l4u. t
ouivuit nou lt ae ne
l s to lt ae or
ouivuitnoute s l4u. g
l s to ute s l ne
ouivuit no lt aee. t
l s to ute s l sor
ouivuit no lt aes . g
l s tonoute s a e. g
ouivuit
lt s l or
l yl s ton4u. t
uxur ouivuit
ne
l yl s ton4u. g
uxur oui vuit
or
l yl s ton4uscom
uxur ouivuit
.
l yl s ton4usne
uxur ouivuit
. t
l yl s it
uxur ouivutonoute ac
lt .om
l
uxul l s tonoute ane
ouivuit
lt . t
18
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
Def nda 382
e nt
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
Def nt382
enda
Def nt38
enda
2
De enda 382
f nt
De enda 382
f nt
De enda 382
f nt
De enda 382
f nt
De enda 382
f nt
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De enda 38
f nt 2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
D e e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
De e nt38
f nda
2
D e e nt38
f nda
2
l
uxul l s tono lt sor
ouivuit ute s . g
l
uxuv l s it
ouiu tonoute s c
lts.om
lxo l s tonoute s ne
u
ouivuit
lts. t
lba s e. t
v gs al ne
m l s tonoute .
ouivuit
ltcom
m l s tonoute .
ouivuit
ltnet
ml s tonoute . g
ouivuit
l tor
outebagsor
lt . g
r plc l s vuit ne
e ia-oui- ton. t
r plc l s lonoute .
e ia-ouivui
ltcom
s c ouiv ton4u.om
a l s uit
c
s c ouivuit
a l s ton4u. t
ne
s c o s ton4u. g
a l uivuit
or
s c o s tonn.om
a l uivuit c
s l uivuit m . t
ac o s tol ne
s l uivuit or
ac o s tonn. g
s l uivu tonane
ac o s it . t
s l uivu tonaor
ac o s it . g
s -ouivuit nn.om
ac l s to c
s -ouivuit nn.
ac l s to net
s -ouivuto o g
ac l s itnn.r
s souivutonfrc
ac l s it r .om
s souia it rscom
ac l s tonpa i.
s souivutonpa i. t
ac l s it rsne
s souivuit rsor
ac l s tonpa i . g
s souivuit .om
ac l s tonsc
s s l s it .om
ac -ouivutonsc
s s l s tonsne
ac -ouivuit . t
s souivuit . g
ac l s tonsor
s s l s tonsor
ac -ouivuit . g
s s l s tor . m
ac -ouivuit m co
s s l s tonsbi
ac -ouivuit . z
s csouivuit . t
a l s tonsne
s cs l s ton. z
a -ouivuit bi
l s tonba oute s . g
ouivuit gs ltsor
l .om
voutc
l gs l sor
vba outet. g
aouivutonoute . g
l s it
ltor
l s tonba oute tor
oui vuit gs l t. g
19
Dee
f ndant382
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndant382
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e
f ndan 382
t
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
De e nt382
f nda
Def nda 382
e nt
Def nda 382
e nt
Def nt382
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
s edyl l tcom
pe voute .
s edy voute .
pe l ltnet
s edy voute . g
pe l ltor
cl s tonoute . m
ouivuit
ltco
cl s it
ouivutonoute . t
ltne
cl s tonoute . g
ouivuit
ltor
s cso s it rne
a l uivu tonf. t
s csl s it n-r nc c
a -ouiu to fa e.om
s ac l s tonf . t
s souivuit rne
s ac l s tonf . g
s souivuit ror
s csouivuit nfa.om
a l s to r c
l s lo ltt es or
ouivui noute sor 4u. g
l ltt e .r
voute sor so g
t uic
ns .om
a hopke com
s
y.
ba t m .om
gsea c
be ltm ec
lsi .om
e t e co
sor cc. m
ge
mpac
kage.om
c
hoott c
ld.om
Dee d n 3 3
fn a t 8
jvo tc m
a o.o
Def nt383
enda
D ef nt383
enda
D ef nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
Def nt383
enda
D e enda 383
f
nt
De e nt383
f nda
D e enda 383
f
nt
De enda 38
f nt 4
De enda 385
f nt
l a a.om
vpl z c
ka p.
va com
l vo . om
a otc
l
vowne .om
rc
l t e .om
vsor ccc
mobe t.om
lsc
mvnt com
o.
qoc c
opy.om
poc c
opy.om
ba ons l.om
gs elc
tgotc
e .om
tade s sc
r ba e .om
br ndbas .om
a
esc
t e c
uol e.om
wa c ag.om
t hes c
wa esor c
t t e. om
zol ouiu i
zl s lonoute s e. m
ltal co
77ba .om
gsc
20
D e e nt386
f nda
D e e nt387
f nda
De e nt388
f nda
Def nda 389
e nt
Def nt390
enda
Def nt391
enda
Def nt392
enda
Def nt392
enda
Def nt392
enda
De enda 392
f nt
De enda 39
f nt 2
De e nt39
f nda
2
De e nt393
f nda
De e nt39
f nda
4
De e nt395
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De enda 396
f nt
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
D e enda 396
f
nt
De enda 396
f nt
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De enda 396
f nt
De enda 396
f nt
D e e nt396
f nda
De e nt396
f nda
De enda 396
f nt
De enda 397
f nt
De e nt398
f nda
8 hs o e. om
t tr c
a toui vuit c
cha l s ton.om
a i gh.om
lhi c
a l r .om
lhe bagsc
a o s scom
m ur ac .
a hen i l s lonof i st c
ut tcouivui
fcalie.om
a hen i l s ûonoutezol ne
ut tcouivui
lt z. t
a he i ouivuit
ut ntcl s tonoute4u. t
lt ne
c a ut i l s lonoute z.om
he pa hentcouivui
lt c
l s it
ouivutonbels l ne
ta e. t
l s i
ouiu lonof al
sci webstzu.om
ie c
l s tonpur es l t . t
ouivuit
s outeusne
a fghtng.
zai i com
ba di c
gs g.om
ba fghtcom
gs
.
ba f of i l bst c
gsor fc awe ie.om
l s tonoute s e t ae.om
ouivuit
ltgr a s l c
ba o lt i s p.om
gs ute onlne ho c
ba s
gs hopoute .
ltus
be tvtmescom
sl i .
c or ul t r . om
ol f s o es c
f r a l s ton.om
o m louivuit c
l s tonbelm alc
ouivuit
t l.om
l s tonc i nso ec
ouivuit onsg t r .om
l s tonl age fcil e ie.
ouivuit ugg of aw bst com
l s it
ouia tonoute o i ie.om
lt nlnest c
of i l uivuit tm esc
scalo s ton i .om
dic luivuit t e lcom
s ounto s tonsor mal.
l s ltt r nlnes p.
ouioute so eo i ho com
l s tonc i nwe ie.om
ouivuit onsg bst c
l s tonl age lco
ouivuit ugg mal. m
l s tonoute s e alcom
ouivuit
ltalm l.
outes orouivuit ba c
lt f l s tons g.om
goodhr dbagsorouivuit c
f l s ton.om
l s it ndba ki
oui vu tonha
g ndom . om
c
l s toV a
ouivuit ndba ki
gs ndom . m
co
l s tonpur es one.om
ouivuit
s z c
ba -r nc .om
gs fa ellc
ba o i buy.om
gs nlne c
21
De e
f ndant399
De e
f ndant400
Dee
f ndant400
De e
f ndant401
De e
f ndan 401
t
De e
f ndan 401
t
De e
f ndan 401
t
De e
f ndan 402
t
De e
f ndan 403
t
De e
f ndan 403
t
De e
f ndan 404
t
De e nt404
f nda
Def nda 404
e nt
Def nda 404
e nt
Def nda 404
e nt
Def nda 404
e nt
Def nda 404
e nt
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
Def nt404
enda
De enda 40
f nt 4
De enda 40
f nt 4
De enda 405
f nt
Def nt406
enda
Def nt407
enda
Def nt408
enda
De enda 409
f nt
De enda 41
f nt 0
De enda 41
f nt 1
D e e nt411
f nda
De enda 411
f nt
D e enda 41
f
nt 1
De enda 411
f nt
De enda 41
f nt 1
ba - ltonlne ae.om
gsoute - i s l c
ba r y.om
gsa c
buy
bags ay. om
r c
bagswa c r plc ne
- t h-e ia. t
bagswa c r plc o g
- t h-e ia.r
hand g- s or
ba ba e. g
r plc ba 88.om
e ia- gs c
besf ndi ndbagsc
te ha
.om
beshandba zs e.om
t
gs al c
r plc ha
e ia ndbagsa c
- u.om
boutques l.om
i malsc
l s to ou ltc
ouivuit nl te .om
t ut n i ouivuit c
hea he tcl s ton.om
bye o s i uteonlne.om
l uiu uono lt i c
bye o s uit usc
l ui v ton .om
a he tcouivuit O r dba s e.om
ut n il s to
gs al c
dr a l s lono lt i c
e m ouivui ute onlne.om
dr a l yl s ton.om
e m uxur ouivuit c
goodl s tonba m alc
ouivuit gs l.om
besl uivuit a
to s toO ndbags lt .
oute scom
besl uivuit hoe .
to s tons scom
besl uivuit pures ute .om
to s ton s o ltc
besl uivuit
to s tonpures ute sc
s o lt .om
boutque s .om
i s hopsc
l s tonone g.om
ouivuit
ba c
l s tonoute of a s c
ouivuit
lt fcilhop.om
l s i
ouiu ûonoute of a s .om
lt fcilhopsc
besl uivuit
to s tonma lc
l.om
l s tonm aloute .om
ouivuit
l- ltc
be to s tonma tc
sl uivuit
r.om
bnbet .om
lsc
bol sco
ot . m
borel io.
s vst com
outebor evst c
l t s l io.om
l s tona tym m - ne
oui vui t r s
us. t
l s tona tym mzol com
ouivuit rs
z.
l s tona tym m - a. t
oui vuit r s
us ne
l s it rs us net
ouivutona ty- a.
l s ton- usr laor
ouivuit a tai . g
22
Defnda 41
e nt 1
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
De e
f ndant411
De e
f ndant411
De e
f ndan 411
t
De e
f ndan 411
t
l s ton-usr la vi com
ouivuit a tai - p.
l s ton- usr la- i c
ouivuit a tai onlne.om
l s ton- usr i vi ne
ouivuit a tala- p. t
l s tonba onlne c
ouivuit gs i uk.om
l s ton- ana or
ouivuit c da. g
l s tonc nada s sc
ouivuit a
pur e .om
l s tonouteca da.
ouivuit
lt na net
luivuit de a k. t
o s ton- nm r ne
l uivuit de ak.om
o s ton- nm r c
Dee d n 41
fn a t 1
Dee d n 41
fn a t 1
luiv itn ultj c m
o s uto o t -p.o
e
luiv to o t tj ne
o s ui n ul -p. t
t
e
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
De e nt411
f nda
Def nda 411
e nt
Def nda 411
e nt
Def nda 411
e nt
D ef nt41
enda
2
Def nda 41
e nt 2
Def nt41
enda
3
D ef nt41
enda
3
Def nt41
enda
4
Def nt41
enda
5
Def nt41
enda
6
D ef nt41
enda
7
Def nt41
enda
7
Def nt41
enda
8
l s to te - a ne
ouivuit nou ltplza. t
l s to te - a c
ouivuit nou ltplza.om
l s to te ukzol ne
ouivuit nou lt
z. t
l s to te uc ol or
ouivuit nou lt
z. g
l s to uki
ouivuitn- ngdom . m
co
ukl rs m m . m
va ty co
ukl rs m m . t
va ty ne
bow e or co
nc p. m
of ve que tc
e r s.om
buyc pl s tononlne.om
hea ouivuit
i c
buyc pl s tononlne. t
hea oui vuit
i ne
buy-ouivuit
l s tonhandba .om
gsc
buyl s to% and gs hea c
ouivuit
ba c p.om
c neoute ho .om
ha l lt tc
c pbe t s or . om
hea ls t e c
c pbet sor . t
hea ls t ene
c pc ba c
hea ool g.om
Dee d n 41
fn a t 8
Dee d n 41
fn a t 8
whoe aee ly a sc m
ls ljwer b g .o
whoe aee ly a s .r
ls ljwer b g so g
De enda 41
f nt 9
De enda 420
f nt
Def nt420
enda
Def nt421
enda
D e enda 422
f
nt
De enda 423
f nt
Def nt423
enda
De enda 42
f nt 4
D e enda 42
f
nt 4
c pde i r ndba sc
hea sgne ha
gs .om
c p- ndbag- te .om
hea ha
ou ltc
r plc -ouivuit ons l c
e ia l s ton- ae.om
c pha
hea ndbagse i sc
r plca .om
c pha
hea ndbagsr c
tade.om
c pk kofha bagsne
hea noc f nd
. t
c pk kofha bagso g
hea noc f nd
.r
c a ouivuit
he pl s ton7o.om
c
c a oui vuit o.om
he pl s ton8 c
23
Def nda 424
e nt
Def nda 425
e nt
Def nda 426
e nt
Def nt427
enda
Def nt428
enda
Def nt429
enda
Def nt429
enda
Def nt430
enda
D ef nt431
enda
Def nt432
enda
Def nt433
enda
Def nt434
enda
Def nt43
enda
4
De enda 43
f nt 4
De enda 435
f nt
De enda 436
f nt
De enda 437
f nt
De enda 437
f nt
De enda 437
f nt
De enda 437
f nt
De enda 437
f nt
De enda 438
f nt
De enda 439
f nt
De enda 440
f nt
De enda 441
f nt
De enda 442
f nt
De enda 443
f nt
De enda 44
f nt 4
De enda 445
f nt
De enda 446
f nt
De enda 447
f nt
De enda 447
f nt
De enda 448
f nt
D e enda 449
f
nt
De e nt449
f nda
De enda 449
f nt
D e enda 450
f
nt
De e nt451
f nda
D e enda 451
f
nt
c a ouivuit zo. m
he pl s tonus co
c a ouivuit ae.om
he pl s tones l c
c pl s it andba oute sor c
hea ouia toA
gs l tt e.om
f s onhandba zol c
a hi
gs z.om
c pl
hea vbags i co
onlne. m
c pl ndba .
hea vha
gsus
f vorouivuit nba .om
a l s to gsc
c pl ndba ou ltne
hea vha
gs te . t
onlne l t . g
i oute bagsor
c pr plc ha
hea e ia ndba usc
gs .om
c psouivuit ne
hea l s ton. t
c a t e ta zol c
he psor sr de z.om
c a t e ta
he psor sr de888.om
c
vi o s ton.om
pl uivuit c
c nao i ae. t
hi nlnes l ne
c nas pbr ndsc
hi ho a .om
cas i lo s it
l sca luia tonbuy.om
c
l tr ct co
va ta you. m
l n sprc t e.om
vi be t iesor c
l eai e i c
vr lablonlne.om
malf hi v.om
las onl c
c e ial s ton. m
nr plc ouivuit co
c opwhol ae.
nt
es l com
c c pur esor he p.
oa hs s f c a com
c uxur bi
opyl y. z
c e ia ac scom
opyr plc w t he .
c itng.om
rsi c
c ee. m
vc co
c o com
vto.
de i
sgnbag al c
4s e.om
de i rmia i hr dbagsco
sgne i t ton. m
dic l s tonoute4u. m
s ountouivuit
lt co
de i r c r s u.
sgne s a ve z bz
di c
s ountoui vuit a e .
l s tons l scom
euxur vbr nd.om
l yl a c
r plc l uggag
e ia vl
ezol c
z.om
di c
s ountvl s i t n. o
l ouivu to c m
e yt ndba .om
as oha
gsc
e yt ndba s c
as oha
gs . om
24
Def nt452
enda
Def nt453
enda
Def nt454
enda
Def nt455
enda
Def nt456
enda
De enda 457
f nt
De enda 458
f nt
De enda 459
f nt
De enda 460
f nt
De enda 461
f nt
De enda 462
f nt
De enda 463
f nt
De enda 46
f nt 4
De enda 465
f nt
De enda 466
f nt
D e enda 467
f
nt
De enda 468
f nt
De enda 468
f nt
De enda 469
f nt
De enda 470
f nt
De enda 471
f nt
D e enda 472
f
nt
De enda 473
f nt
De e nt47
f nda
4
De enda 475
f nt
De enda 475
f nt
Def nt476
enda
De enda 477
f nt
De enda 477
f nt
De enda 478
f nt
De enda 478
f nt
Def nt479
enda
Def nt479
enda
Def nt479
enda
Def nt480
enda
Def nt481
enda
Def nt482
enda
Def nt483
enda
Def nt484
enda
e zu. m
bags co
e ouivuit gsc
bayl s tonba .om
e nwa c s. t
de t he ne
eouivuitns e. m
l s to al co
euxur ba o ltc
l y gs ute .om
euxur n.
l yo com
euxur o
l ytp4ba co
g. m
f c or coa ho ltt e.
a t y c ute sor com
f ke i ne . t
a desg rne
f ke
a knoc f ndba c
kofha
gs.om
f e o s tons l s e .om
A l uivuit ung a s sc
f ke c c pu s . t
a s oa hs r esne
f s onl nd gsc
a hi vha ba .om
fst
a twooute .om
l tc
fouivuit
l s tonoute .om
ltc
fanc vs or co
r el t e. m
fanc acouivu to com
r es l s it n.
l s tonst of e f.om
ouivuit ie fcilrc
fs couivuit acne
r a l s tons . t
gewa c s ountc
t t hdic .om
goodc na
hi whols l c
e ae.om
goods c
coa hhand g.om
ba c
ha
ndbag.
vc
ha
ndbagso svuitn.r
l ui- to o g
ha
ndbags lt nlnesc
oute o i .om
ha
ndbags lt nlnesne
oute o i . t
ha
ndbagso u.
t yo com
he ve ma ke sne
a n- r t . t
he ven- r t . g
a ma ke sor
hi or plca ha
gh- e i - ndbagsco
. m
hi qr plca ha
gh- e i - ndbagsco
. m
hi es e ungl s s.om
whol als as e c
t
opwhol ali c
es e n.om
whols l s a s sn.om
e a e ungls e i c
hot tr uxur com
pore ol y.
hotha
s ndbagsc
.om
i kofha
knoc f ndba .om
gsc
iouivuit gsc
l s tonba .om
i pie ba .om
ns r d4 gsc
25
Dee
f ndan 484
t
De e
f ndan 485
t
De e
f ndan 486
t
De e nt487
f nda
De e nt488
f nda
Def nt488
enda
Def nt489
enda
Def nt490
enda
Def nt491
enda
Def nt492
enda
Def nt493
enda
De enda 49
f nt 4
De enda 495
f nt
De enda 495
f nt
De enda 495
f nt
De enda 495
f nt
De e nt495
f nda
De e nt495
f nda
De e nt496
f nda
De e nt497
f nda
De e nt497
f nda
De e nt497
f nda
De e nt497
f nda
De e nt498
f nda
De e nt499
f nda
De e nt500
f nda
De e nt501
f nda
De e nt501
f nda
De e nt50
f nda
2
De e nt503
f nda
De e nt50
f nda
4
De e nt505
f nda
De e nt506
f nda
De e nt507
f nda
D e e nt507
f nda
De e nt507
f nda
De e nt508
f nda
De e nt508
f nda
De e nt509
f nda
m onog n c a c
r m he p. om
kno kof- nlne.
c fo i com
l dysi l .
a fe dscom
lnk-v. m
i l co
lous to al com
i vuit ns e.
l s tons e co
ouivuit alu. m
l
obagsco
. m
l e ton. t
oui vuit ne
l s a e.u
ouibags l s
l s c
ouigo.om
l s c
ouiok.om
l s a pas rco
ouis c che . m
l s t aeo lt c
ouivuions l ute uk.om
r plc l s tonl
e ia ouivuit uggag .om
eusc
r plc l s tonl
e ia ouivuit uggag ac
eus .om
rplc l s i aeusc
e i a ouiu lons l .om
r plc l s tons l a.
e ia ouivuit aeus com
rplc souivuit
e i a l s tonuk.om
c
l s tonzol
ouivuit
zbagsc
.om
l s tonba a co
ouivuit gs b. m
l s tonbags he pes.
ouivuit
c a tcom
l s tonha
ouivuit ndba ab.om
gs c
l lt o.
voutepr com
l s tonba el.om
ouivuit gs lc
l s tonba onlne .om
ouivuit gs i sc
l s it gs aelne
ouivutonba ons l . t
l s it gs ae- a.om
ouiu tonba s l us c
l s tonba s l us ne
ouivuit gs ae- a. t
l svui ba -t e. m
oui- ûon- gssor co
l s tonba - ac
ouivuit gs us .om
l s tonbr i. g
ouivuit aslor
l s tonc ponlne.om
ouivuit hea i c
l s ton- he poute .om
ouivuit c a l tc
l s toncl .om
ouivuit ublc
l s toncl c
oui vuit ub4.om
l s toncl c
ouivuit ub8.om
l svuit f - hea co
oui- ton-orc p. m
l svuit f - ae.
oui- ton-ors l com
l s it or hea ne
ouivutonf c pon. t
26
De e n 51
f nda t 0
De enda 511
f nt
De e nt51
f nda
2
De enda 51
f nt 2
De e nt513
f nda
De enda 51
f nt 4
Def nt51
enda
4
Def nt51
enda
4
De e nt51
f nda
4
Def nt51
enda
4
De e
f ndan 51
t 5
Def nda 51
e nt 6
De e
f ndan 51
t 6
De e
f ndant51
7
De e
f ndan 51
t 8
De e nt51
f nda
9
De e
f ndant520
De e nt521
f nda
De e nt521
f nda
De e nt522
f nda
De e nt523
f nda
De e nt5
f nda 24
Def nt525
enda
De e nt525
f nda
De e nt526
f nda
D ef nt526
enda
Def nda 526
e nt
De e nt526
f nda
De e nt526
f nda
De e n 527
f nda t
De e nt527
f nda
De e nt528
f nda
De e n 529
f nda t
De e n 530
f nda t
D e e nt530
f nda
D e e nt531
f nda
De e nt532
f nda
Defnda 53
e nt 2
Def n nt53
e da
2
luivuit ndbags
o s tonha
zolz. t
ne
l s toA a ba - a ne
ouivuit nd gsche p. t
l s toA a
ouivuit ndba che ps l c
gs a a e.om
l s donche phandba s e.
ouivui
a
gs al com
l s toA u dba -or s e.om
ouivuit
gs f -al c
l s ûoA u d gs ae z. g
ouivui
ba ons lzol or
l s doA u dba ons e us o g
ouivui
gs al- a.r
l s it a ba us
ouiu toA nd gs azol ne
z. t
l s to ha
ouivuit n- ndba usne
gs . t
l s toA a ba ons l t r ne
ouivuit nd gs aeso e. t
l uiv ton ndba s c.
o s uit ha
gs a com
l s vuit ha bags a.
ouis tons nd us us
l uivuit ha
o s ton ndbags a.
us us
l s ton-t y. t
ouivuit ial ne
lui- to u oc f - gsc
o svuit n- kofs ba .om
l s tonl
ouivuit uggage
bagsc
.om
l s tonl acor ne
ouivuit vf t y. t
l s i
ouiu lonm o r moute .om
nog a
ltc
l a t e.om
vus sor c
l s tonnz.u
ouivuit
e
l s tonof i outes z.om
ouivuit scal ltzol c
l s ûonof i l bst us
ouivui
ûc awe ie.
vuit hoponlne ae a c n.
tons
i s lt s he com
l s tono i ka e c
ouivuit nlne uf n.om
l s tononlne c
ouivuit
i n.om
l s to
ouivuit nonlne or
i n. g
l s to te - .om
ouivuit nou ltmic
l s tonlne - ute .om
ouivuit i s o ltc
l s ui
ouiv ûonoutet mal. t
l us lne
l s vuit onlne hop.om
oui- ton- i s c
l s vui onlne hop. g
oui- lon- i s or
l s ton- i - t e.
ouivuit onlne sor com
l s tonoutezol c
ouivuit
l t 4.om
l s toA a
ouivuit ndba - usr la. m
gs a tai co
l s tono l t a t ala. t
oui vuit ute - us r i ne
l s tonoute a c
oui vuit
l t x. om
l s to te ba a. t
ouivuit nou lt gs ne
l s tono lt gs c
ouivuit uteba n.om
l ivuit te ba c da.
ou s tonou lt gs ana com
27
Dee
f ndan 533
t
De e
f ndan 534
t
De e
f ndan 535
t
De e
f ndan 535
t
De e
f ndan 536
t
De e
f ndan 537
t
De e
f ndan 538
t
De e
f ndan 538
t
De e
f ndan 539
t
De e nt540
f nda
De e nt541
f nda
De e
f ndan 542
t
De e
f ndan 543
t
De e
f ndan 544
t
De e nt545
f nda
De e
f ndan 545
t
De e
f ndan 545
t
De e nt546
f nda
De e nt547
f nda
De e
f ndan 547
t
Def ndan 547
e
t
D ef nda 548
e nt
Def nt548
enda
Def nt549
enda
Def nt549
enda
Def nda 550
e nt
Def nt551
enda
Def nt552
enda
Def nt553
enda
Def nt553
enda
D ef nt553
enda
Def nda 553
e nt
Def nda 553
e nt
De e nt554
f nda
Def nt555
enda
Def nt556
enda
De e nt557
f nda
Def nda 558
e nt
Def nda 559
e nt
l ui vuit
o s tonoute cou us
l t pon.
luivuit
o s tonoutef u.
ltor com
luis lo ute hr dbagsne
o s vui no lt
. t
luivuit ou l - d gs ne
o s ton- tethr ba z. t
luivuit
o s tonoute l.om
ltic
luivuit
o s tonoute l ve .
lto rus
l uiuztonoute pur e. m
o s it
lt s co
bags hoppi zone.om
s
ng
c
l uivuit
o s tonoute s l .om
lt aesc
l uivuit te s g.om
o s tonou lt ba c
l uiu i
o s ûonoute st onlne.om
lt ie i c
l uivuit o l sor co
o s ton- utett e.
l uiv ton c e. g
o s uit pa kag or
l uiv ton s he de.om
o s uit pa c r c
c a vpur ezol c
he pl s z.om
l uivuit purezol ne
o s ton s
z. t
l s ton s zol ne
ouivuit pures z. t
l s ton s -usr la. t
ouivuit puresa tai ne
l s uit pures i net
ouiv ton s onlne.
l uivuit npuresonlne. t
o s to
s - i ne
l uiv ton s - i or
o s uit puresonlne. g
l uivuit pur e- tetor
o s ton s ou l . g
l uiv ton s - lto g
o s uit puresoute .r
l s ton- s vi c
ouivuit pur es p.om
l s to pur es p. t
ouivuit n- s vi ne
l s to e i a c
ouivuit nr plc a.om
l s to e i a u.
ouivuit nr plc a com
l s to e i - . m
ouivuit c plca bagsco
l svuit e i a . t
oui- tonr plc sne
r plc ouivuit . t
e ial s tonsne
l s to sne
ouivuit n- . t
l p l s ton- .om
uxur ouivuit bagsc
nee vha
dl ndbagscom
.
l svuit e i a . g
oui- tonr plc sor
l s to ac m an. t
ouivuit ns a i ne
l s to ac nlgne.om
ouivuit ns e i c
l s to ac he. z
ouivuit ns oc bi
l s to ac ae.om
ouivuit ns s l c
l s to ac onlne. om
ouivuit ns s i c
28
Def nda 560
e nt
Def nt561
enda
Def nt562
enda
Def nda 562
e nt
Def nda 563
e nt
Def nt564
enda
Def nt565
enda
Def nt566
enda
Def nt566
enda
Def nt567
enda
Def nt568
enda
Def nt569
enda
Def nt570
enda
Def nt571
enda
Def nt572
enda
Def nt573
enda
Def nt574
enda
Def nt575
enda
Def nt576
enda
Def nt576
enda
Def nt577
enda
Def nt578
enda
Def nt579
enda
Def nt580
enda
Def nt581
enda
Def nt582
enda
Def nt583
enda
Def nt584
enda
Def nt584
enda
Def nt585
enda
Def nt586
enda
Def nt586
enda
Def nt587
enda
D ef nt587
enda
Def nt588
enda
Def nt589
enda
D e e nt590
f nda
De e nt591
f nda
D ef nt592
enda
l s tons e.
ouivuit al us
l s to alonlne.
ouivuit ns e i com
l s to s e i co
ouivuit n-alonlne. m
s c ouivuit s de. m
a l s ton-ol co
l s to al- a.om
ouivuit ns e us c
l svuit s i
oui- ton-hop.
t
l s to hopofi i .om
ouivuit ns
fcalc
l s to t e rne
ouivuit nsor f . t
l s to t e ror
ouivuitnsor f. g
l s to otoute .om
ouivuit nt e ltc
l s to v.om
ouivuitn- c
l s to ntge.om
ouivuit nvi a c
l vuit ba c
oui ton- g.om
l vuit gsor
oui tonba . g
l vuit ac zol c
oui tons s z.om
l r ha ba .om
ove s nd gsc
l ngguc ihop.
ovi
c s com
l s to bi
uivuit n. z
l eha
ur ndba . t
gsne
l e- ndba . t
ur ha
gsne
l l scom
uxeoui.
l r ouivuit ho c
uxu yl s tons p.om
l yr plca ndba . t
uxur e i ha
gsne
l hoesc
v4s .om
l go ltne
vba ute . t
1
vbags 4.om
185 c
1 gs 2. t
vba 201 ne
l s i npu s wa lti o
ouiu lo r es le .nf
l gs le puresi o
vba wa lt s .nf
l gt ng.
vba hi com
l nd gs l - z. m
vha ba outetzol co
l nd gs l zol or
vha ba outet z. g
l nd gs e i asc
vha ba r plc .om
l l t he al c
voute c aps e. om
l ouivuit ba .om
vl s ton- gsc
l ouivuit al.om
vl s tonde sc
l oui vuit
vl s tononlne c
i . om
l i bagsco
vonlne
. m
l l tuxy. m
voute l co
29
De e nt593
f nda
Def nt593
enda
De e nt593
f nda
De enda 593
f nt
De enda 593
f nt
De enda 59
f nt 4
De e nt594
f nda
Def nt595
enda
De e
f ndan 596
t
Def nda 597
e nt
De e
f ndan 598
t
De e
f ndan 599
t
De e
f ndan 600
t
De e
f ndant601
De e
f ndant601
l l ta ene
voute s l . t
ukl s tonn.om
ouivuit c
ukl ho .
vs pscom
l s to a e ma lco
ouivuit ns l s l. m
usouivuit t e.
l s tonsor nd
l ltal or
voute s e. g
s voute scom
hopl lt .
l oute -t elc
v- ltsor .om
l te s .
vou lt uscom
l r plc bi
v-e i a. z
l ton ndbagsc
vuit ha
.om
l to te onlne.om
vuit nou lt i c
l
vukha
ndba co
g. m
m u c a nc
he pe om
m in .om
l nnsc
Dee da t 0
fn n 6 2
Dee da t 0
fn n 6 2
mv j welr .o
pe l yc m
e
myif n jwer c m
tfa ye ly.o
Defnda 603
e nt
De e nt604
f nda
De en nt605
f da
Defnda 606
e nt
De e nt607
f nda
De e nt608
f nda
Def nt609
enda
De e
f ndan 61
t 0
De e nt611
f nda
De e n 61
f nda t 2
De e
f ndan 61
t 3
De e nt61
f nda
3
De e nt61
f nda
4
De e n 61
f nda t 4
Def nt61
enda
5
De e nt61
f nda
6
D e e nt61
f nda
7
Defnda 61
e nt 8
Defnda 61
e nt 9
De e nt61
f nda
9
De e nt620
f nda
Dee
f ndan 621
t
mxs c.om
c c
myba l c
goutd.om
myc pguc .
hea
cicom
myha
ppyba .om
gsc
ne -v.om
tl c
nyl uivuit lsc
o s tonbet .om
ohtmesco
i .m
okayuwi c
n.om
ol nd.om
ha c
o i che pha
nlne a ndbag.
com
or souivu do l wel .
l s i noutet lscom
our l s to te zo c
souivuit nou lt ne.om
o ltoui- ton.om
utel svuit c
o lt l svuit ne
ute soui- ton. t
outel svuit ne
ltoui- ton. t
poou .om
tc
popha
ndbags ns l c
o a e.om
pr e sona l s it com
of s i louia ton.
r m ie s csc
e s - a .om
r s a - z.
emies cszol com
r plc gsn.om
e iaba i c
r i a ba us c
eplc - gs . om
30
Def nt622
enda
Def nt623
enda
Def nt624
enda
Def nt625
enda
Def nt626
enda
Def nt627
enda
Def nt628
enda
Def nt629
enda
Def nt630
enda
Def nt630
enda
Def nt631
enda
Def nt632
enda
Def nt633
enda
Def nt634
enda
Def nt635
enda
Def nt636
enda
Def nt637
enda
Def nt637
enda
Def nt638
enda
Def nt638
enda
Def nt639
enda
D ef nt640
enda
Def nt641
enda
Def nt641
enda
Def nt642
enda
Def nt643
enda
D ef nt644
enda
D ef nt645
enda
Def nt646
enda
Def nt646
enda
Def nda 646
e nt
Def nda 646
e nt
D e e nt647
f nda
De e
f ndan 648
t
D e e nt648
f nda
De e nt649
f nda
Dee
f ndan 650
t
De e
f ndan 650
t
Dee
f ndan 651
t
r plc br ndso g
e ia a .r
r plc che pl s tonbagsco
e ia a ouivuit
.m
r plc ha
e ia ndba cac
gs .om
r plc ha
e ia ndba soc com
gs t k.
r plc - ndba t e.om
e ia ha
gsor c
r plc ha ba t e.r
e ia nd gsor o g
r plc l s tonl8 c
e ia ouivuit
s4.om
r plc l s tona com
e ia ouivuit u.
r plc l s tonbb.om
e ia ouivuit
c
r plc l s tonl
e ia ouivuit vbag.om
c
r plc l s it ugga oute .om
e ia ouiu tonl ge ltc
r plc l s it
e ia ouiu tonwhol a e.om
es l c
r plc l gs one.om
e ia vba z c
r plc - hoppe.om
e ia s
c
r plc l uivuit hea c
e iaso s tonc p.om
r
mbag.
com
l s to a i o
ouivuit ns cc.nf
s c guccpas ri o
a - i che .
nf
s c l s ton4y. m
a louivuit
co
s cs l s tonf .om
a souivuit rc
s c ouivuit fa ne
a l s ton-r nce. t
s c oui vuit
a l s tonhom m e . om
sc
s cl r nc ndr c
a vfa eve e.om
s cl
a vmag i c
asn.om
s c onogr m . m
am
a co
s c heouivuit pa c rne
a oc l s ton s he . t
s c che 4u. t
a pas r ne
s cs ton. m
a vuit co
fvuit a pas rc
r tons cs che .om
s c itns dyprx.
a vu to pee i com
c z vas voi ne
he mae a e. t
s c to pe dyprx. t
a vuit ns e i ne
s s as e .om
hoe ungl s sc
s obagsco
hopt
. m
s oha ba . om
hopt nd gs c
s
hopyop.om
c
l kye a lcom
uc m l.
sylngba .om
t i gsc
s as e onlne z. t
ungl s s i zol ne
31
De e nt651
f nda
De e nt651
f nda
De e nt651
f nda
De e nt651
f nda
De e nt65
f nda
2
De e nt65
f nda
2
De e nt653
f nda
De e nt65
f nda
4
De e nt655
f nda
De e nt655
f nda
De e nt65
f nda
6
De e nt65
f nda
7
De e nt658
f nda
De e nt658
f nda
De e nt65
f nda
9
De e nt66
f nda
0
De e nt661
f nda
De e nt66
f nda
2
De e nt663
f nda
De e nt66
f nda
4
De e nt66
f nda
4
De e nt665
f nda
De e nt666
f nda
De e nt667
f nda
De e nt668
f nda
De e nt669
f nda
De e nt670
f nda
De e nt671
f nda
De e nt672
f nda
De e nt673
f nda
De e nt674
f nda
us s a s o ltne
a ungl s es ute . t
us s a s o lt .om
a ungl s es ute sc
t l s tonoutesne
he ouivuit
l t. t
usouivuit
l s tonoutezu. t
l t ne
s as hoppi c
ungl s
ng.om
smgl s
t as hoppi ne
ng. t
t s he a as he ho c
a c A ndt c ns p.om
t l s uit gs te . g
he ouiv tonba ou l tor
o lt -ouivuit bagsc
ute s l s ton- .om
t pl s tono lt - a.
o ouivuit ute s us com
t l yha ba c
op-uxur nd g.om
t
opqua iyl s ton.om
lt ouivuit c
t pr plc ha
o e ia ndbags co
buy. m
whol s ec a eplc a
e al he pr i A ndba .om
gsc
t r plc uxur ne
op-e ial y. t
t al s c
ot lypur e.om
t y. m
ouba co
uc a ouivuit
he pl s tonzozo.om
c
l ho s
uxs p.u
euxur l tonscom
l ycoleci .
uk- l r com
euxu y.
ukl s ndba .om
ouiha
gsc
us nd gs te sc
ha ba ou lt .om
usouivuit
l s tonwe ie. t
bst ne
vi hea nd gscom
pc pha ba .
vogue e ae.om
fm l c
vuit ol s c. m
tons des a co
wa c xx.om
t hes c
whols l f b.om
e aeo c
youngha
ndbagsco
. m
z lr plc c
ea-e ia.om
32
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?