Rosenberg v. DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC et al

Filing 308

ORDER denying 299 Motion for Extension of Time to File Rule 50(b) Motion; denying 300 Motion to Treat Rule 50(a) Motion as Timely Rule 50(b) Motion. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/5/2017. (ls)

Download PDF
UN I TED STATES DISTRI T C O URT C SO UTH ER N DISTR I T O F FLO R I C DA CA SE N O .l CV 2- 22275 SEI - TZ M A URY RO SEN BERG, Pl ntf, ai if V S. DVlRECEI BLES,X I ,LLC etal, VA V . Def endant s. / O RD ER DENYI RULE S BJ RELA TED M OTI NS NG OI O THI M A TTER i bef e t Courton Def S s or he endant Renewed M oton f Enl gem entof s' i or ar Ti t FieRul 50( Moton g 299 a Dee ns Moto t Tra Mac 6,201 Rul me o l e b) i DE ) nd fnda t' in o e t rh 3 e 5 a Moi asTi yRul 50b)Moton( 30 .Pl nifhasrs edt ea hmoi ( 0() ton mel e ( i DE 01 aitf epond o c ton DES 3 & 3021a Dee ansha rple ( 3 & 3 .Fort ras dic s db o t 01 , nd fnd t ve e id DES 03 041 he e ons s use elw,he m otonsar deni i e ed. BA CKG ROU ND I 2 0, a ntf ie a a er a y co pl n i t U . Ba u c Cou tu r 11U . C. n 01 Pl i iffl d n dv s r m ai t n he S. nkr pt y r nde S. j30 i.I 2 2,hi Cou t t e t rfrnc t t Ba uptyCo t dpr e de t til 3()l n 01 t s r wihdrw he eee e o he nkr c ur an oc e d o ra onPl ntf' j303()2)cai .g 1 ) Theti wa biurae it ala lt phas a a ai ifs i( l ms DE 0. ral s f c td no ibiiy e nd da ge phae.( 1 1Att c cl i oft la lt pha e Dee nt mad anorlRul ma s s DE 08. he on uson he ibiiy s , fnda s e a e 'l U sc j3 () r vd s l 03ip o ie : I t c tdimis apettonunde t ss tonot rt n oncons ntofalpe ii r a t de or f he our s ses ii r hi eci he ha e l ttone s nd he bt , a dited bo d e n t ieterg tojd me tu d rti s b eto ,h c ut yga t u g n n fh e tr o s o wav h ih t u g n n e hs u scin te o r ma rn j d me t ( )a an t h p tto e sa d i f v ro t ed b o f r 1 g is t e e i n r n n a o f h e t r o i ( c t; r A) oss o ( ra o a l atre ' fe ; r B) e s n be ton ys e s o ( )a an t n p tt ne t tfldt ep tto i b df ih f r 2 g is a y e io r ha i h eiin n a at , o i e ( a yda g spo i tl c u e b sc fln ; r A) n ma e rxmaey a s d y u h i g o i ( p ni v da g s B) u t e ma e . i 50a moi (iibiiymoto ',agui t tPli iffie t prveba fih.TheCou t nid () ton ila lt in' r ng ha antf ald o o d at ) r de e t moina t j yrt ne aveditf Plitf o la lt g 1 .Att c l inoft he to nd he ur eur d r c or anif n ibiiy.DE 8l1 he oncuso he d mag sphae,Dttn t fldas on Rul 50()moton(t ma smoi ', r ui t tt a e s f dans ie ec d e a i d ge ton' a g ng ha he da ) e de edi nots ppol a awadf pu tved g .DE 1 1TheCour d e t moi vi nc d u ' n r or nii ama es ( 94. t t enid he ton ( 1 1 a t j ya de Pli if$11 milo i c nstr da ge an $5miloni DE 96, nd he ur war d antf .2 lin n ompe aoy ma s d li n p ntv d ma e . DE l 8)Fn lu g n wa e trdo M ac 1 , 01 . DE 2 81 u i e a g s g 9 . ia j d me t s nee n rh 4 2 3 r 0 , i OnAprll1 201 - 28da a t fnalud nt Dee nt fldaRul 5 b)moi , i , 3 ys fer i j gme - fnda s ie e 0( ton agui t tt e de edi n s por afndi ofba fihora a r ofpuniieda e .( r ng ha he vi nc d ot up t i ng d at n wad tv mag s DE 22 1Pl ntf edt srket motonb a eiwa fldousdet l da flngpei u r 0. ai ifmov o ti he i ec us t s ie ti he 4- y ii rod nde t Ban u c Ru1s2( 223.l rs e,Dee ansfldamotonfra e e i oftmet he krpty e . DE ) n epons fnd t ie i o n xtnson i o tl pos-ral i .( 231)TheCour d e t moi t srke c udi t tDefnda t 5e tti motons DE . t enid he ton o ti , oncl ng ha e ns tm el fl w ihi t Feder Rul 28- flng peri and deni asm ootDef i y ied t n he al es' day ii od, ed endant moton s' i f e tnsono tme ( 25 )Th t Cour ga e Def da s Rul 50b)moi an rdu ed or xe i f i .DE 9. en,he t rntd en nt' e ( ton d e c Pl nifsa r t $360, i co aitf' wad o 000 n mpen aor da ge .( 27 & 273. st y ma s DES 2 ) Ona alteElve t Cic trvere t sCour' orergrntngt Rul 50( moi ppe ,h e nh rui e sd hi ts d a i he e b) ton. The CourtofAppeal hel t t Bankr cy Rul appl t al casesarii underTil 11and s d hat he upt es yo l sng te ta Dee a s Rul 5 b)moto wasuni yun rFed. Ban .P. 5c . en r v. 1 h t fnd nt' e 0( in tmel de R. kr 90l () Ros beg DV Re eiablsZ f1C,81 F.d 1 ( lhCi. 6) Th Cour ofAppeasrman dt c e c v e WK 8 3 283 1 t r 201 . e t l e de he as wihisrctonst ri tt t $6.2milonj ya d. t n tu i o ensae he 1 li ur war DI SCU SSI ON Def endant now r s enew t rm oton f an ext on oftm e t t e pos-ri m otons hei i or ensi i o 5l tt al i , ar ng t t runtm el Glng wasbas on 6excus e negl .' Coursem pl a f - ac ort t gui hat hei i y i ed ç abl ect' t oy our f t es t fnde usbl ne e t ()t rs ofprj c t t ohe pat ( t lngt ofted a a o i xc a e glc: 1 he ik eudie o he t r ry;2) he e h h ely nd 2Fed. R. n r P. 01 ()po d s Rue5 F d R. v P. p le i c ssa dp o e dn , x e tt t n Ba k . 9 5 c rvie : l 0 e . Ci. a pis n a e n r c e igse cp ha a y rn we moinfr u g n o rq etfran w til h lbetldn ltrta 1 d ysa rh e tyo e e d to o j d me t r e u s o e ra s al ie o ae h n 4 a he te nr f j d me t u g n. i p tnilmpato j diil r c e ig ;3 tera o frted ly a d( ) eh rtemo a t t oe ta i c n u ca p o e dn s ( ) h e s n o h ea ; n 4 wh te h v n s a t d i goo f ih. Pi e l .Se vi e Co.F.Br wi k As oci e Lt P 'hi 507 U . 380, c e n d at one r nv r c s uns c s at s d. s p, S. 3 - ( 993 . 95 96 1 ) Howe r t Elve h Cic tha hel asamat roflw,t ta ç to ne s ve , he e nt r ui s d, te a ha n % t r y' a m iunder t ng oft pl n l s sandi he ai anguage ofa r e cannotcons iut excusabl negl such t a ul tt e e ect hat pa t i r i ve oft c equ nc off ii t c pl w ih a s a u or d dlne 'Adv c ry s ele d he ons e es a lng o om y t t t t y ea i .' an ed Esi igS tm,l .v Ri y,1 F.d996, - ( 1hCi.l 97)(ef i t fnde cusbl tmatn yse nc . ne 30 3 99899 1 t r 9 r usng o i x a e negl ti an ator sif l e t r ew ort appr at t r evantr es w hi cl l i cat ec n t ney' laiur o evi o eci e he el ul , ch eary ndi e t tapat ha tnda fom tee tyof ud ntt tl .. pos-ralmoi ' .Hee, ha ry s e ys r h nr j gme o 5e . tti tons' r ) Def endant concede t t m it s hat hey sakenl beleved t Ci lRul 28- f lng perod appled. y i he vi es' day ii i i Unf t t y,s m iunder t ngsoft l cannotbe excus e negl .Ri y 1 F. at oruna el uch s sandi he aw abl ect ne 30 3d 99899. Def endant a t ptt ditnguih Ri y,ar ng t t hol ng i lm ied t s tem o s i s ne gui hat he di s i t o m iunder t ngsoficl I ' whiet i t cas i ved t m i s sandi i ear aw ' l he nsant e nvol he sapplcaton ofit o set of i i iw s pot i l applcabl r es.'H ow ever t El entaly i e ul ' , he event Cicui m ade cl t t S l n l h r t ear hat he s ai anguage of p t f alr es bankr cy and ci lpr he eder ul -of upt vi ocedur -requiesapplcaton oft Feder Bankr cy e r i i he al upt Rulsi t scae. Ros nb r 81 F. a 1 ( assa ed . v teu mbi e n hi s ' e eg, 8 3d t 287 emph i dd ) Gien h na guous ' I anguage oft f alr es Ri y applest t scas The m oton i deni he eder ul , ne i o hi e. i s ed. I t atr tve Dee nsmovet Co tt te tt i s ondRul 50()moin- fld n he lenai , fnda t he ur o ra her ec e a to ie onMac 6,2 3i rgadst da ge- a atmel rne Rul 50()motonatc ngte rh 0l n e r o ma s s i y e wed e b i ta ki h e d c onla lt Defn nt'frtRul 50a moto atc dt s cen ofe d cet vien e ibiiy. e da s is e () in ta ke he um i cy vien o pov ba fih;h rsc Rul 50()moi ma asmia at ko t evi nc t a r r e d at tei e ond e a ton de i lr tac n he de e o wad punii dam ages. Def tve endant ar t snce t sam e atack w asm ade i bot m otons,t s gue hat i he t n h i he pur poseofRul 50 i f f l 3 However,Def e s ul5led. endant ar ess i l as ng t Cour t di egar s e entaly ki he t o sr d 3Th p r o eo fln ap ev ritRul 5 ()moinbeo efl gapotv r it l 5 ()moini t e sr e up s f i g r-edc e 0 a to fr ii i n s- edc Rue 0b t s o nu e o t to ha pposng c e i nott m bus d ors ndbag 'wih a a gumen t tisevi ncewa i um cintaleris i ouns l s ç a he a ged' t n r t ha t de s ns e t t t o lt t a d e ss c is fiin is Do v Cee rt Cr ie , n . 3 4 F.d 8 1 9 3 ( lh Ci. 0 4) o ae o d r s u h n u f e ce . e . lb i us s l c, 9 3 9 , 0 1 t r 2 0 . c y t El he event Cicui' m andat h r ts e. Thedititc tmayno de aefom t a pelaec r' ma t Wh lrv Ci o src our t vit r he p lt ou ts ndae. eee . t f y Plas Gr , F. 1 1 0n. ( 1hCi.1 ) Thedititco tmus i e nti t e ant ove 746 2d 437, 44 2 1 t r 984 . src ur t mplme i h bo t e l tt a s rtoft m a t t ki i o a c h e t r nd pii he nda e a ng nt c ountt a la e c tsopi on,a t e ht ppe l t our ' ni nd h crumsan esiembrc .' ambi v Baie 7 F. 111 l 1 (1 t Ci.1 (ntral ic t c t a es'Pi no . ly, 57 2d 2, 1 9 1h r 985) i en ctto o te . l a ton, t h onr man t dititco tma a e sis esû t ia ins mit d) n ddii alhoug e d he src ur y ddr s s u d no dipos ofon appeal i i bound t f l t appelat cour ' hol ng,bot expr sed and s ed ,t s o olow he le ts di h es i ple ' 1 He e t c talis a r s by t e Cour ofA p al w a t tm e i sof m i d. d. r , he en r s ue dd es ed h ' t pe s s he i lnes Defnda t acua Rul 5 b)moi Fu t r t CourofAppe l e pr sl rco z dt tis e ns t l e 0( ton. rhe ,he t as x esy e gnie ha t hol ngprv t t sCour fom c i rn t meisofDee a s Rul 50b)moi di e ens hi t r onsde ig he rt fnd nt' e ( ton. Ros be g,81 F. d a 1 en r 8 3 t 290. On r m a t e Cour c nno c ng t pr ed al sor oft e c s e nd, h t a t ha e he oc ur hit y h a e ort e na u e ofDe e an s flngsi a wa t tdir g dst c e m an t oft e Cour of h tr f nd t ' i i n y ha s e ar he l ar da e h t Appe s De e an s m o i i de e A c or ngl i i al. f nd t ' ton s ni d. c di y, t s ORDERED TH AT Defnda t'Moto f Enl g men o Ti t FieRul 50( Moto ( 2991an e ns in or are t f me o l e b) in DE d Motont Tra Rul 50a Moto a Ti l Rul 5 b)Moi ( 300 aeDENI i o e t e () in s mey e 0( ton DE 1 r ED. DONEAND ORDE Di MimiFoiati X dyo Ma, 07 RE n a , lr ,hs V a f y 2 1 d * PA TRI I A . I A T UN I TED STA TES DI STRI JUD GE CT cc: Couns ofRecor el d

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?