Rosenberg v. DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC et al

Filing 308

ORDER denying 299 Motion for Extension of Time to File Rule 50(b) Motion; denying 300 Motion to Treat Rule 50(a) Motion as Timely Rule 50(b) Motion. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/5/2017. (ls)

UN I
TED STATES DISTRI T C O URT
C
SO UTH ER N DISTR I T O F FLO R I
C
DA
CA SE N O .l CV 2- 22275 SEI
- TZ

M A URY RO SEN BERG,
Pl ntf,
ai if
V S.

DVlRECEI BLES,X I ,LLC etal,
VA
V
.
Def
endant
s.
/

O RD ER DENYI RULE S BJ RELA TED M OTI NS
NG
OI O
THI M A TTER i bef e t Courton Def
S
s or he
endant Renewed M oton f Enl gem entof
s'
i or ar

Ti t FieRul 50( Moton g 299 a Dee ns Moto t Tra Mac 6,201 Rul
me o l e b) i DE ) nd fnda t' in o e t rh
3 e

5 a Moi asTi yRul 50b)Moton( 30 .Pl nifhasrs edt ea hmoi (
0() ton
mel e (
i DE 01 aitf
epond o c ton DES
3 & 3021a Dee ansha rple ( 3 & 3 .Fort ras dic s db o t
01
, nd fnd t ve e id DES 03 041
he e ons s use elw,he
m otonsar deni
i
e
ed.
BA CKG ROU ND

I 2 0, a ntf ie a a er a y co pl n i t U . Ba u c Cou tu r 11U . C.
n 01 Pl i iffl d n dv s r m ai t n he S. nkr pt y
r nde
S.

j30 i.I 2 2,hi Cou t t e t rfrnc t t Ba uptyCo t dpr e de t til
3()l n 01 t s r wihdrw he eee e o he nkr c ur an oc e d o ra

onPl ntf' j303()2)cai .g 1 ) Theti wa biurae it ala lt phas a a
ai ifs
i( l ms DE 0.
ral s f c td no ibiiy e nd
da ge phae.( 1 1Att c cl i oft la lt pha e Dee nt mad anorlRul
ma s s DE 08. he on uson he ibiiy s , fnda s e
a e

'l U sc j3 () r vd s
l
03ip o ie :
I t c tdimis apettonunde t ss tonot rt n oncons ntofalpe ii r a t de or
f he our s ses
ii
r hi eci he ha
e
l ttone s nd he bt ,

a dited bo d e n t ieterg tojd me tu d rti s b eto ,h c ut yga t u g n
n fh e tr o s o wav h ih t u g n n e hs u scin te o r ma rn j d me t
( )a an t h p tto e sa d i f v ro t ed b o f r
1 g is t e e i n r n n a o f h e t r o
i

( c t; r
A) oss o
( ra o a l atre ' fe ; r
B) e s n be ton ys e s o
( )a an t n p tt ne t tfldt ep tto i b df ih f r
2 g is a y e io r ha i h eiin n a at , o
i
e

( a yda g spo i tl c u e b sc fln ; r
A) n ma e rxmaey a s d y u h i g o
i
( p ni v da g s
B) u t e ma e .
i

50a moi (iibiiymoto ',agui t tPli iffie t prveba fih.TheCou t nid
() ton ila lt
in' r ng ha antf ald o o d at
)
r de e

t moina t j yrt ne aveditf Plitf o la lt g 1 .Att c l inoft
he to nd he ur eur d r c or anif n ibiiy.DE 8l1 he oncuso he
d mag sphae,Dttn t fldas on Rul 50()moton(t ma smoi ', r ui t tt
a e s f dans ie ec d e a
i d ge ton' a g ng ha he
da
)
e de edi nots ppol a awadf pu tved g .DE 1 1TheCour d e t moi
vi nc d
u ' n r or nii ama es ( 94.
t
t enid he ton

( 1 1 a t j ya de Pli if$11 milo i c nstr da ge an $5miloni
DE 96, nd he ur war d antf .2 lin n ompe aoy ma s d
li n

p ntv d ma e . DE l 8)Fn lu g n wa e trdo M ac 1 , 01 . DE 2 81
u i e a g s g 9 . ia j d me t s nee n rh 4 2 3 r 0 ,
i
OnAprll1 201 - 28da a t fnalud nt Dee nt fldaRul 5 b)moi ,
i , 3
ys fer i j gme - fnda s ie
e 0( ton
agui t tt e de edi n s por afndi ofba fihora a r ofpuniieda e .(
r ng ha he vi nc d ot up t i ng
d at n wad
tv mag s DE
22 1Pl ntf edt srket motonb a eiwa fldousdet l da flngpei u r
0. ai ifmov o ti he i ec us t s ie ti he 4- y ii rod nde

t Ban u c Ru1s2( 223.l rs e,Dee ansfldamotonfra e e i oftmet
he krpty e . DE ) n epons fnd t ie
i o n xtnson i o
tl pos-ral i .( 231)TheCour d e t moi t srke c udi t tDefnda t
5e tti motons DE .
t enid he ton o ti , oncl ng ha e ns
tm el fl w ihi t Feder Rul 28- flng peri and deni asm ootDef
i y ied t n he
al es' day ii
od,
ed
endant moton
s' i

f e tnsono tme ( 25 )Th t Cour ga e Def da s Rul 50b)moi an rdu ed
or xe i f i .DE 9. en,he
t rntd en nt' e (
ton d e c
Pl nifsa r t $360, i co
aitf' wad o
000 n mpen aor da ge .( 27 & 273.
st y ma s DES 2
)
Ona alteElve t Cic trvere t sCour' orergrntngt Rul 50( moi
ppe ,h e nh rui e sd hi
ts d a i he e b) ton.
The CourtofAppeal hel t t Bankr cy Rul appl t al casesarii underTil 11and
s d hat he
upt
es
yo l
sng
te

ta Dee a s Rul 5 b)moto wasuni yun rFed. Ban .P. 5c . en r v. 1
h t fnd nt' e 0(
in
tmel de
R. kr 90l () Ros beg DV
Re eiablsZ f1C,81 F.d 1 ( lhCi. 6) Th Cour ofAppeasrman dt c e
c v e WK
8 3 283 1 t r 201 . e
t
l e de he as

wihisrctonst ri tt t $6.2milonj ya d.
t n tu i o ensae he 1 li ur war
DI
SCU SSI
ON
Def
endant now r
s
enew t rm oton f an ext on oftm e t t e pos-ri m otons
hei
i or
ensi
i o 5l
tt al i ,
ar ng t t runtm el Glng wasbas on 6excus e negl .' Coursem pl a f - ac ort t
gui hat hei i y i
ed
ç
abl
ect'
t
oy our f t es

t fnde usbl ne e t ()t rs ofprj c t t ohe pat ( t lngt ofted a a
o i xc a e glc: 1 he ik eudie o he t r ry;2) he e h h ely nd
2Fed. R. n r P. 01 ()po d s Rue5 F d R. v P. p le i c ssa dp o e dn , x e tt t n
Ba k . 9 5 c rvie : l 0 e . Ci. a pis n a e n r c e igse cp ha a y

rn we moinfr u g n o rq etfran w til h lbetldn ltrta 1 d ysa rh e tyo
e e d to o j d me t r e u s o e ra s al ie o ae h n 4 a he te nr f
j d me t
u g n.

i p tnilmpato j diil r c e ig ;3 tera o frted ly a d( ) eh rtemo a t
t oe ta i c n u ca p o e dn s ( ) h e s n o h ea ; n 4 wh te h v n
s
a t d i goo f ih. Pi e l .Se vi e Co.F.Br wi k As oci e Lt P 'hi 507 U . 380,
c e n d at
one r nv r c s
uns c s at s d. s p,
S.

3 - ( 993 .
95 96 1 ) Howe r t Elve h Cic tha hel asamat roflw,t ta ç to ne s
ve , he e nt r ui s d,
te a ha n % t r y'
a
m iunder t ng oft pl n l
s
sandi
he ai anguage ofa r e cannotcons iut excusabl negl such t a
ul
tt e
e
ect
hat

pa t i r i ve oft c equ nc off ii t c pl w ih a s a u or d dlne 'Adv c
ry s ele d he ons e es a lng o om y t t t t y ea i .' an ed

Esi igS tm,l .v Ri y,1 F.d996, - ( 1hCi.l 97)(ef i t fnde cusbl
tmatn yse nc . ne 30 3
99899 1 t r 9 r usng o i x a e
negl ti an ator sif l e t r ew ort appr at t r evantr es w hi cl l i cat
ec n
t ney' laiur o evi
o
eci e he el
ul , ch eary ndi e

t tapat ha tnda fom tee tyof ud ntt tl .. pos-ralmoi ' .Hee,
ha ry s e ys r h nr j gme o 5e . tti tons' r
)
Def
endant concede t t m it
s
hat hey sakenl beleved t Ci lRul 28- f lng perod appled.
y i
he vi es' day ii
i
i
Unf t t y,s m iunder t ngsoft l cannotbe excus e negl .Ri y 1 F. at
oruna el uch s
sandi
he aw
abl
ect ne 30 3d
99899.

Def
endant a t ptt ditnguih Ri y,ar ng t t hol ng i lm ied t
s tem o s i s ne gui hat he di s i t o
m iunder t ngsoficl I ' whiet i t cas i ved t m i
s
sandi
i ear aw ' l he nsant e nvol he sapplcaton ofit o set of
i i
iw
s
pot i l applcabl r es.'H ow ever t El
entaly
i e ul '
, he event Cicui m ade cl t t S l n l
h r t
ear hat he s ai anguage of
p
t f alr es bankr cy and ci lpr
he eder ul -of
upt
vi ocedur -requiesapplcaton oft Feder Bankr cy
e
r
i i
he
al
upt

Rulsi t scae. Ros nb r 81 F. a 1 ( assa ed . v teu mbi
e n hi s ' e eg, 8 3d t 287 emph i dd ) Gien h na guous
'
I
anguage oft f alr es Ri y applest t scas The m oton i deni
he eder ul , ne
i o hi e.
i s
ed.

I t atr tve Dee nsmovet Co tt te tt i s ondRul 50()moin- fld
n he lenai , fnda t
he ur o ra her ec
e a to ie
onMac 6,2 3i rgadst da ge- a atmel rne Rul 50()motonatc ngte
rh 0l n e r o ma s s i y e wed e b
i ta ki h
e d c onla lt Defn nt'frtRul 50a moto atc dt s cen ofe d cet
vien e ibiiy. e da s is e () in ta ke he um i cy vien o
pov ba fih;h rsc Rul 50()moi ma asmia at ko t evi nc t a r
r e d at tei e ond e a ton de i lr tac n he de e o wad
punii dam ages. Def
tve
endant ar t snce t sam e atack w asm ade i bot m otons,t
s gue hat i he
t
n h
i
he

pur
poseofRul 50 i f f l 3 However,Def
e s ul5led.
endant ar ess i l as ng t Cour t di egar
s e entaly ki he
t o sr d

3Th p r o eo fln ap ev ritRul 5 ()moinbeo efl gapotv r it l 5 ()moini t e sr
e up s f i g r-edc e 0 a to fr ii
i
n
s- edc Rue 0b t s o nu e
o
t to
ha pposng c e i nott m bus d ors ndbag 'wih a a gumen t tisevi ncewa i um cintaleris
i ouns l s
ç
a
he
a
ged' t n r
t ha t de
s ns
e t t

t o lt t a d e ss c is fiin is Do v Cee rt Cr ie , n . 3 4 F.d 8 1 9 3 ( lh Ci. 0 4)
o ae o d r s u h n u f e ce . e . lb i us s l c, 9 3 9 , 0 1 t r 2 0 .
c
y

t El
he event Cicui' m andat
h r ts
e.

Thedititc tmayno de aefom t a pelaec r' ma t Wh lrv Ci o
src our
t vit r he p lt ou ts ndae. eee . t f
y
Plas Gr , F. 1 1 0n. ( 1hCi.1 ) Thedititco tmus i e nti t
e ant ove 746 2d 437, 44 2 1 t r 984 .
src ur t mplme i h
bo
t e l tt a s rtoft m a t t ki i o a c
h e t r nd pii he nda e a ng nt c ountt a la e c tsopi on,a t e
ht ppe l t our ' ni nd h

crumsan esiembrc .' ambi v Baie 7 F. 111 l 1 (1 t Ci.1 (ntral
ic t c t a es'Pi no . ly, 57 2d 2, 1 9 1h r 985) i en
ctto o te . l a ton, t h onr man t dititco tma a e sis esû t
ia ins mit d) n ddii alhoug
e d he src ur y ddr s s u d
no
dipos ofon appeal i i bound t f l t appelat cour ' hol ng,bot expr sed and
s ed
,t s
o olow he
le
ts di
h
es

i ple ' 1 He e t c talis a r s by t e Cour ofA p al w a t tm e i sof
m i d. d. r , he en r s ue dd es ed h
'
t
pe s s he i lnes

Defnda t acua Rul 5 b)moi Fu t r t CourofAppe l e pr sl rco z dt tis
e ns t l e 0(
ton. rhe ,he
t
as x esy e gnie ha t
hol ngprv t t sCour fom c i rn t meisofDee a s Rul 50b)moi
di e ens hi
t r onsde ig he rt
fnd nt' e (
ton.
Ros be g,81 F. d a 1
en r
8 3 t 290. On r m a t e Cour c nno c ng t pr ed al sor oft e c s
e nd, h
t a t ha e he oc ur hit y h a e
ort e na u e ofDe e an s flngsi a wa t tdir g dst c e m an t oft e Cour of
h tr
f nd t ' i i n
y ha s e ar he l ar da e h
t
Appe s De e an s m o i i de e A c or ngl i i
al. f nd t ' ton s ni d. c di y, t s
ORDERED TH AT

Defnda t'Moto f Enl g men o Ti t FieRul 50( Moto ( 2991an
e ns
in or are t f me o l e b) in DE
d
Motont Tra Rul 50a Moto a Ti l Rul 5 b)Moi ( 300 aeDENI
i o e t e () in s mey e 0(
ton DE 1 r
ED.

DONEAND ORDE Di MimiFoiati X dyo Ma, 07
RE n a , lr ,hs V a f y 2 1
d
*

PA TRI I A . I
A
T
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI JUD GE
CT

cc:

Couns ofRecor
el
d