Rosenberg v. DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC et al

Filing 316

ORDER denying 310 Motion to Stay Execution of Judgment Pending Appeal and Pending Ruling on Motion for Mutual Judgment Satisfaction. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 5/15/2017. (ls)

U NI
TED STATES DISTRICT CO UR T
SO UTH ER N DISTRICT O F FLO RI A
D
CA SE N O.l CV2- 22275- TZ
SEl

M A URY RO SEN BERG ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
VS.

DV IRECEI BLES,X I ,LLC etaI,
VA
V
.
Def
endant
s.
/

O RD ER DEN YING M O TI N FOR STAY
O
TH I M ATTER i bef e t Courton Def
S
s or he
endant M oton f St ofExecuton of
s' i or ay
i

J gme Pe ngApp l( 31 .Uponrvi oft M oi Pl ntf' Res ns ( 31 ,
ud nt ndi
ea DE 01
e ew he ton, ai ifs po e DE 41

Dee nt'Re y( 3l ,a t rc d,t Coutfndst tDee ntU. Ba i note ild
fnda s pl DE 5J nd he e or he r i ha fnda S. nk s ntte
t asa unde 1 U. C. 91 NorwilheCour e rieisdicei t ga asa wih
o ty
r 2 S. j .
lt
t xecs t srton o rnt ty tout

rquii U. Ba t p tb un rFe R.Ci P. d .
e rng S. nk o os ond de d. v. 62()
BA CKGROUN D

l 2010,Pl ntf fl an adver ar com pl nti t U . Bankr c Courtunder 11U . C.
n
ai if ied
s y
ai n he S.
upt y
S.

j303i. sCou t t e t rfrnc t t Ba r c Co ta t c eprce de t til
() Thi r wihdrw he eee e o he nkupty ur nd he as o e d o ra.

( 1 1Thej ya redPl nif$11 miloni co
DE 0.
ur wad aitf .2 li n mpen aor da esa $5miloni
s t y mag nd
li n

pu tveda e .( 1 )Fi j dgme wase ee onM ac 1 201 ( 208.
nii mag s DE 98. nalu nt
ntrd
rh 4, 3.DE 1
OnAprl1l 20l - 28da atrfnalu nt Dee nsfl amoi f j me
i , 3
ys fe i j dgme - fnda t ied ton or udg nt
a amatroflw (MOL) ( 220.Pli ifmov dt srket motonbe aueiwasfld
s te a J
.DE ) antf e o ti he i c s t ie
ousdet 1 da flngpei un rt Ba u cyRuls g 223. l rs e, fn nt fld
ti he 4- y ii rod de he nkrpt
e .DE
) n epons Dee da s ie
amoinf a e ensonoftmet fl p tti motonsa notceofa al( 231)Th
to or n xt i
i o 5e os-ral i nd i
ppe .DE . e
Cour de e t m oton t s rk co udi t tDef nda stm el fl d w ihi t Ci lRul s
t ni d he
i o t i e, ncl ng ha
e nt i y i e t n he vi e '

28-a flngpe id,a d nidasmo Dee ns motonfre ensonoftme ( 259.Th
d y ii ro nd e e
ot fnda t' i o xt i
i . DE ) en,
t eCou t a e De e nt'J OL moton a rduc d Pli ifsa r t $3 0 i
h
r gr ntd f nda s M
i nd e e antf' wa d o 60,00 n

c enst yda ge .( 27 & 273.
omp aor ma s DES 2
)
O n a al t El ve t Cic tr ve s d t sCou tsor ergr ntng t J OL m o i The
ppe , he e n h r ui e r e hi
r' d
a i he M
ton.
Cour ofApptal htl t t Bankr cy Rul appl t al casesarii underTil 11and t
t
s d hat he
upt
es
yo l
sng
te
hat

Def da s motonwa u i l u rFe R.Ba .P. 1 () Ro e r v. 1Rec iabe
en nt' i s ntmey nde d.
nkr 90 5c . s nbeg DV ev ls
A7K ffC, 8F. 1 3( lhCi.201 .TheCour o Appe srma dt c ewih
81 3d 28 1 t r 6)
tf
al e nde he as t

isrcin t risaete$ .2mil nj r a r ThsCo r risae tej r v r ito Ma
ntu to s o en tt h 6 1 lo uy wad. i u t en ttd h uy edc n y
i
5,201 ( 3 1Si t e l,t Cou t ni Def da s rn dmotonfre e i of
7.DE 09. mulan ousy he r de ed en nt' e ewe
i o xtnson
tmet fl pos-ra moton .( 3 1
i o ie ttil i s DE 08.
DI
SCUSSI
ON

U. Bank seekst confr t t ar entted t an aut atc s ay on t executon of
S.
o
i m hat hey e il o
om i t
he
i

j d me t n e 1 U. C. 91 e to 91b r c u t fo is n a atc me t re e uin
u g n u d r 2 S. j .S cin a s o rs rm suig n ta h n o x c to
a i tanai ba p irt fna j
gans tonal nk ro o i ludgme t Th pa te a e ta çi ludgme t'o pur es
n. e ris gre h t sna j
f
n'fr pos
ofSeci 91me nsaj dgme tt ti noI rs j c t rves lormo fc to onap alSe
ton
a u n ha s onge ube t o e ra
diiain
pe . e
Unie Sttsv femaie,8 F. 387, (t Ci.1 7) U. Ba kar st tfna j men
td ae .
r 26 2d 390 5h r 98 . S. n gue ha i ludg t
hasnotyetbeen r
eached becaus t or denyi Def
e he der
ng endant r
s' enew ed m oton f an ext on i
i or
ensi s

silo a a.TheCo tdia res Fi j
tl n ppe l
ur s ge . naludgme ti t sc s wa enee o Machl 201
n n hi ae s trd n r 4, 3.
Dee da sdi nota a t j dgme twihi 1 da a rquie byFed. Ba kr P. 2()
fn nt d ppe lhe u n t n 4 ys s e rd
R. n . 800 a.
No weeDeen nt ga edane e i ont tmet a alt j me tlTheeor,h
r r f da s rnt
xtnson he i o ppe he udg n. rf e te
j dgme tb ca ti l'orpur e ofSe ton91onMac 28 201 U. Ba i note ildt
u n e me s na'f
f
poss ci
rh , 3. S. nk s ntte o
an aut atc say.
om i t
U . Bank alo r
S.
s eques st s Cour exer se is dicr i t gr a s ay w ihouta
t hi
t
ci t s eton o ant t
t

s s
uper edeasbond. How ever t Cour w ildeclne t do s The pur e ofa super
, he
t l
i o
o.
pos
sedeasbond i t
so
lDee d n ' moi nf a e e i oftmebas d onexc a ene ec w a denid a moot ( 25 1 Mo e v r
e
us bl gl t s
e s
. DE
fn a ts to or n xtnson i
9 . ro e,
ha t Cour r ac t mert oft moton,t extnsonwoul ha bee de e unde Adv dEstmatn
d he
t e hed he is he i he e i
d ve n nid
r ance
i ig

S se lc v Rie 1 0F.d9 6 9 ( lhCi.l 9 )wh r teElv nhCi uth l a amatro lw,ta
y tm, n . . ny 3 3 9 , 98 1t r 9 7, ee h e e t r i ed, s te f a h t
c
a û tor y' m iunde sa ngoft pl n lngua ofar eca
n ç t ne s s rt ndi
a
he ai a ge
ul nnotc tt eexc a enegl t'
onsiut
us bl
ec.'

p e ev tej d me tce i rsrg t p n iga p a. plrGr v Plnig ( Re Co,n . .
rs re h u g n rdt ' ihs e dn p e lPo a o e a t f f .I c v
o
n
Bac Hale Star,Ic.6 F. 11 11 ( hCi.1 )(iA1s pere a b i aprvie
he sy u t n , 00 2d 89, 91 5t r 979 i( u s de s ond s i lge

e e dt t j gme de ora aprc ofi editngt valdiyo a orert pa mo y.)2
xtnde o he ud nt bt s ie ntr ci he i t f n d o y ne '.
'
Thebur ni ont udg tdebo- u. Ba - t obe tv yde taeteras fra
de s hej men tr s. nk o j ciel monsrt h e ons o
de rur fom t us lrquie ntofaf lsc iys red sbond.d.( ani ta af l
pat e r he ua e rme
ul e urt upes ea
1 expli ng h t ul

s c rys p re e sb n it ei s a rq ie n '.I t i c s, S Ba kp o ie n o j cie
e u i u es d a o d s h v u l e urme f) n hs a e U.. n rvd s o be tv
t
u
r on t wai t bond r r ent N ordoesU . Bank oferPl ntf any f m ofsubs iut
eas o ve he
equiem .
S.
f ai if
or
tt e

s c rt lse d U. Ba ksrse i tn n il b lyt p ytej d me t Ho v r teb n '
e u i n ta , S. n te s s t i a ca a ii o a h u g n. we e,h a ks
y.
s
t
a lt t pa i n a s t i n r a o on isow n t w a v t s r e sbond.
bii o y s ot ufk e t e s n
y
t
o i e he upe s dea

Accor ngl i i
di y, t s
ORDERED THAT

De e da s M o i f St y ofExec ton o J dgm e Pe ng Appe a Pe ng Rulng
f n nt ' ton or a
ui f u
nt ndi
al nd ndi
i

o Motonf Muua J dgme tSaifci ( 31 i DENI
n i or t l u
n tsa ton DE 01 s
ED.

DONEAND ORDERED i MimiFlr a t s/ V a o Ma , 01 .
n a , oi ,hi 1
d
y f y2 7

PA TRI I A .S TZ
A
UN I
TED STA TES D STRI JUD GE
C

c
c:

Cou e ofRe or
ns l
c d

2l Bo n rv Ci o i h r , 61y.d 1 61 07& 1 0 ( 1hci.1 81 (nb n )teElv nhCic i
n n e . t fprt a d 6 ' 20 ,2
y
c
2
2 9 1 t r 9 ) e a c ,h e e t rut
a e a bi ngpr ede t decsonsoft Fi Cicuir ndeedprort Oc obe l 1 l
doptd s ndi ec nt he ii
he ih r t e r
i o t r , 98 .