Rosenberg v. DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC et al

Filing 332

ORDER denying 318 Motion for Relief From Judgment as to Punitive Damages Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 60(b)(6). Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 7/31/2017. (vmz)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOU TH ER N DISTRI T O F FLO RIDA
C
CA SE N O .12- CV 22275-SEI
TZ
M AU RY RO SEN BERG,
Pl ntf,
ai if
DVIRECEI
VABLES,XI LLC etal,
V,
.
De e da s
f n nt .

/
O RDER DENY I G RULE 60( ( M OTI N
N
b) 6)
O

THI MATTER i b or t Cou t Dee nt'Rul 60()6)Motong 31 j Upon
S
s ef e he r on fnda s e b(
i DE 8 .

rviw ofteMoi Pl ntf Repons g 327,Dee nt'Re y( 3281a t rc d,
ee
h ton, ai ips s e DE 1 fnda s pl DE
, nd he e or
t Cou ti t tr ifun rRul 60b)6 i no warne be a eDee nswave tei d
he r fnds ha ele de e ( () s t ra td c us fnda t i d h r ue

prc sar n whe t yuntmel fl tei motonf j me asamatroflw.
o es gume t n he i y ied h r i or udg nt
te a
BA CKG ROU ND
l 201 Pl ntf fl an adver y com pl nti t U. Bankr cy Cour under 1l U . C.
n 0, ai if ied
sar
ai n he S.
upt
t
S.

j3 i. sCour wih e t rf e cet t Bankupc Cour a t c s poc d t ti .
03()Thi
t tdrw he eern o he
r ty
t nd he a e r ee ed o ral

g 1 1Thej ya redPli ifsl1 miloni co ns t yda ge a $5miloni
DE 0.
ur wad antf .2 li n mpe aor ma s nd
li n
pu tv da ge .g 1 jFi ludgme twasenee o Marh 1 201 g 208.
niie ma s DE 98. na j
n
trd n c 4, 3. DE 1

0nAprl11 20l - 28da atrfna j dgme - Dee ansfldamoi f j gme
i , 3
ys fe i l u nt fnd t ie
ton or ud nt
a amatrofIw (MOL) g 220.Defnda sague i t i moto t ttee de ewa
s te a J
.DE 1 e nt r d n her in ha h vi nc s
i ufi entt s
ns fci o uppor an aw ar ofpunii dam agesand t tt am ountofpunii dam ages. as
t
d
tve
ha he
tve
w
uncons iutonaly exces ve.1 Pl ntf m oved t s rket m oton becaus i wasfl out i t
tt i l
si d. ai if
o t i he i
et
ied sde he

l d yGlngpero und t Ba upc Ruls g 2 1TheCour c l dt tDefnda s
4-a i
id er he nkr ty e .DE 23.
t oncude ha e nt'
motonwa tmel un rt Ci lRuls 28-a flngpei ( 25 a ga e temoto
i s i y de he vi e ' d y ii rod DE 91 nd rntd h
in,

rducngPli ipsa r t $360, i c mpe aor da ge .( 272& 273.
e i antf wad o
000 n o ns t y ma s DES
1
On appeal t El
, he event Cicui r s t sCour ' or gr i t JM OL moton. The
h r t ever ed hi
ts der antng he
i
Cour ofA ppeal hel t t Bankr c Rul appl t al cas arsi underTil 11and t t
t
s d hat he
upt y es
y o 1 es i ng
te
ha

Dee a s J
fnd nt' MOLmotonwasuni yund Fe R. r P. 5c . enb r v DV1
i
tmel er d. Bank . 90l () Ros eg .

Re ev e T.K fLC,81 F. 1 ( lhCi. 6 .TheCo t Appe srma dtec s
c iabls J
8 3d 283 1 t r20l )
ur of
al e nde h ae

wihi tucinst r nsaet $6.2milo ur a r Thi Cou tei ttdt ur vediton
t nsr to o ei tt he 1 linj y wad. s r r nsae hej y r c
Ma 5,2 7.( 309.
y 01 DE )
DI
SCU SSI
ON

Defnda t se rlefpurua t Fe r Rul 60()6)fom t sCou ts Orerr nsaig
e ns e k ei s nto deal e b( r hi r' d ei ttn

tej r vedit Rul 60( ( moto mus de taet tt cicumsan saes fcinl
h uy r c. e b)6) ins t monsrt ha he r t ce r ufi e ty
e ror nayt warntr if Can v Bak r 435F. 1 37,1 ( 1hCi. 6) Ev t n,
xta di r o ra ele. o . e ,
3d 3 342 1 t r 200 . en he
whtt t grantt r
her o
he equesed r i i a m aterf t dit i cour ' s
t elef s
t or he s rct
ts ound dicr ton. d.
s ei 1
Def
endant ar t t r nsat punii dam agesawar i uncons iutonaly exces ve
s gue hat he ei t ed
tve
d s
tt i l
si

a t tt Co tsf l e t r vi t a d vi a esdu pr es . Howev r D e e a sr i e
nd ha he ur ' aiur o e ew he war ol t
e oc s
e , f nd nt a s d
t s ver s e chalenge t t punii dam ages awar i t rJM OL m oton.The El
hi y am
l
o he
tve
d n hei
i
event Cicui
h r t

hedt tt moi wa untmel unde Fe R. nkrP. 5( a s oul ha b nd ni
l ha he ton s i y
r d. Ba . 901 c) nd h d ve ee e ed.

Theeor,Dee nswave t i o t t f j calr e oftea dwhe t yf ldt
rf e fnda t i d her pporuniy or udii eviw h war n he aie o
tmel r set i ue i t rJ OL m oton.Becaus Def
i y ai he ss n hei M
i
e endant f l t tm el chalenge t
s aied o i y
l
he

puniieda ge a r n e ror naycic tnc e s t j tf rle unde Rul 6 b)6 .
tv ma s wad, o xta di r rumsa es xit o usiy eif r e 0( ()
Accor ngl i i
di y, t s
ORDERED THA T

Dee ans Rul 60b)6 Moto ( 31 i DENI
fnd t' e ( () in DE 8) s
ED.

DONEAND ORDERED i MimiFoiati V/ yo Jl 2 7.
n a , lrd ,hs Wta f uy, 01
-

h

PAT Cl A .SEI Z
A
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI JUD GE
CT

Couns ofRecor
el
d