Rosenberg v. DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC et al

Filing 54

ORDER Granting Defendants' Request to Exclude Evidence of Loss Life Insurance Value re 46 Memorandum, filed by U.S. Bank, N.A., DVI Funding, LLC, Jane Fox, DVI Receivables, XIV, LLC, DVI Receivables, XVI, LLC, DVI Receivables, XIX, LLC, DVI Receivables, XVII, LLC, Lyon Financial Services, Inc., DVI Receivables, XVIII, LLC Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/26/2012. (ail)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I T O F FL O R I A
C
D
CA SE N O .1 CV 2- 22275- TZ
SEI

M AURY ROSENBERG ,
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.

DVIRECEI
VABLES, V,LLC e al,
XI
t .
De enda s
f nt .
/

O RDER GM NTI DEFENDANTS'REOUEST TO EXCLUDE EVI
NG
DENCE O F LOSS
L I I SU R AN CE V AL UE
FE N

THI M ATTER c
S
amebe or t Cour uponDe e nt ' e tt e udee denc ofl s
f e he
t
f nda s r ques o xcl
vi e os

oflf i ur ncevauebe us Pl i iflc s a ngt r co rt eda esa wilbet a e
ie ns a
l
ca e antf a ks t ndi o e ve hes mag nd l m bl

t p o ep o maec u ain.DE 4 1 Plitf o o e t moi na man ansta t esau oy
o r v r xi t a s to ( 6 . an if pp s s he to nd iti h t h tttr
lng of11U. C.j303()2)a pr e nti t f dea de c lci a c ume rght
a uage
S.
i( nd ec de n he e rl bt ole ton nd ons r i s

c ne t e misr c v r o ls o lf i u a c vau i t i c s . DE 3 1 Up nr ve o t e
o tx p r t e o ey f o s f ie ns r n e le n hs a e ( 4 . o e iw f h
de iin ta crpta expe trpor ofRihadNewma ( 51 1 1 1 ,t Cour wilgan
posto rns i nd
r e t c r
n DE - - 03) he
t l r t
De e nt 'moton t e l e de e of l s oflf i ur e val bec us Pl ntf lc
f nda s
i o xcude vi nc
os
ie ns anc
ue a e ai if a ks
sa ngt r co rt eda es
tndi o e ve hes mag .
Pl ntf as e t t tasa r s toft tlng oft i unt r peii neihe he nort
ai if s rs ha
e ul he ii
he nvol a y tton, t r
he

Dougl Ros nbe g200 Tr s (çheTr f'c da f dt co r atr polc onPl ntf t t
as e r 4 u t ç
t us l oul for o nvet e m iy
ai if ha
c ni d a$5m ilon de t be t t ape m a ntuni r allf polc I t d,t Tnltcoul o y
a e
li a h nek o r ne
ve s ie iy. nsea he s
d nl
afor t c r $2m ilon oft nn c r get pe m a ntuni r a lf c r a a l d t
f d o onve t
li
e ove a o r ne
ve s l ie ove age nd lowe he
r m ani $3 m ilon ofc r ge t l ps As a r ul,Pl i ifas e t,r yi on t Ne n
e i ng
li
ove a o a e.
es t antf s rs el ng
he wma
de ii ta c i a r por, ha t l st t G e gf m iy'i t dif r nc be we nt
poston r ns rpt nd e tt t he os o he û nber a l ' s he fe e e t e he
Ros

c tofo ani $3m ilo oflf i ur nc cove a t oug c
os bt i ng
li n ie ns a e
r ge hr h onver i a t c tofbuyi $3
son nd he os
ng

milo i n w tr c v rg t d y.DE 46 .Astepat sa ea r,h Co r r c n l r ldt a
l n n e em o e a e o a (
i
2 h ri r wae te u t e e ty ue h t
e
Pl ntf cn
ai if nnotr ove da esal dl s t ne by t r pari ,i l ng t Tr t a ma
ec r mag lege y usai d
hid tes ncudi he us, nd y

rc v ro y frh so ij re . DE 49 .Th Co r f u dt a Plitf i n ih rt Tr se n r
e o e nl o i wn nu is (
1 e u t o n h t an if s et e he u te o
ab nei ir o t Tr s.l a 5 .Thelf i u a c p lc a is i o db t Tnlt ( 5 e fcay fhe u t Ld. t )
ie ns rn e o iy tsue s wne y he s.DE 1
1a 414 ,7 ) I fc, . wma tsiidt a t Tr s ma eted cso n t oc n r t e
t - 3 5 . n a t Mr Ne n e tfe h t he u t d h e iin o t o vet h
e t ep lc t p r n n u i es liec vea e ( 51 1a 3 - 9 .Ad iin l ,h Tr s pa s
ni o iy o ema e t n v ra l o rg . DE - t 8 3 2 dto al t e ut y
r
f
y
t pr umsont polc a i t be iir Ld. t41421 s h,ti t Tr tha s frd
he emi
he iy nd s he nefcay.l a - .As uc i s he ust t ufee
a al ge da a fom l s of lf i ur nc val i ba f ih a pr ma e c us ar
ny le d m ges r
os
ie ns a e ue f d a t nd oxi t a e e
esa ihed. Ac or ngl Pl ntf l kssa ngt r co rf l soflf i ur nc vaueast e
t bls l c di y, ai if ac tndi o e ve or os
ie ns a e l
hos
dnma ,i pr
ges f oven,we es t i byt Tr t Upon r vi i i
r usaned he us.
e ew, t s
O RD ERED TH A T

De e nt'r ques t e udeevi nc ofl soflf i ur nc val i GRANTED .
f nda s e t o xcl
de e os
ie ns a e ue s

7D

,

DONEAND ORDERED a MimiFlrd ,hi X 1 d yo Oco e, 01 .
t a , oia t s
a f tb r2 2
.-

K

PA TRI A A .SE TZ
CI
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D G E
CT U

cc:

Couns lofRe or
e
c d

1 h Tr s i n t p ryt ti lws t n cn o b j ie a i ino aç e tr u d rl U. C. 3 3 i
T e ut s o a at o hs a uia d a n t e on d s ts t f bo' n e 1 S. j 0 ()
d '
be aus t i t a ype ii wasnottl agans i.
c e he nvolmtr tton
ied i t t