Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Doctor Diabetic Supply, LLC et al

Filing 193

ORDER denying 162 Motion to Dismiss; denying 163 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 12/10/2014. (ar2)

U NI
TED STATES D I
STRI C OURT
CT
SO U TH ERN D I
STRICT O F FLO RI A
D
Cas N o.12e
22330- V- TZ
Cl SE1
PH YSI A N S H EA LTH SOU RCE,I C.
CI
N ,
Pl ntf,
ai if

DO CTO R DI
ABETI SUPPLY,LLC;
C
GEO RGE T.H EI
SEL;DD S H O LDI S,I C.
NG N ;
and SAN ARE,LLC,
Def ndant
e
s.

O RDER D ENYI M OTI
NG
ONSTO D I I
SM SS

Thi ma t ri be or t Co to De e nt' oto t dimis( 1 2 1 3,
s te s f e he ur n fnda s m ins o s s DE- 6 , 6 1

whih a guet tt c s i m oo be a eDee nt s r d ofe sofudgm e unde
c r ha he a e s t c us f nda s e ve f r j
nt
r
Rul 68t tpr de Pl ntf w ih t f lr lefs
e ha ovi
ai if t he ul e i oughti t Com pl nt even t
n he
ai ,
hough
Pl ntf di notacc ptt eofer .The El
ai if d
e hes f s
event Cic thass nc r ed t '
h r ui
i e ul hat '
a

pl i ifsi vi lcam i no mo e b a una c ptd Rul 6 o f ro j
antf' ndi dua l i s t ot d y n c e e
e 8 fe f udgme .
nt'
'
S enr. c n esL. , s No. 3 1 41 , lp o a 2 ( 1 h Ci. c 1 2 1 ) As
ti Buca e r P.Ca e
1 - 5 7 si p. t 3 1 t r De . , 0 4 .

Dee nt c nc de Sti i dipo ii o t i motonst dimis ( :, 1 7 1 ,
f nda s o e , en s s stve n her i o s s ., tDE- 8 , 91
S
1 2.Ac or ngl i i he e
9 ) c di y, t s r by
O RDERED t
hat

1 De e nt Sa r ' a DDSSm oto t dim is( 1 2 i DENI
) fnda s na e s nd
'
in o s s DE- 6 J s
ED.
2 Dee nt He s lsa DDS Ho di ' o i t dim is( 1 3 i
) f nda s ie' nd
l ngs m ton o s s DE- 6 J s
D EN I .
ED

ooxEAxo oroErEo i imiFlrda t s lo
k t nv a , o i ,hi
,

.

g

yofoe e r 2 4.
c mbe, 01

-

PATRI A A .SEI
CI
TZ

UNI
TED STATES DI CT J
STRI UDGE