Veliz v. Princess Cruise Lines Ltd.
Filing
22
ORDER Denying 20 Motion for Sanctions. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 10/22/2013. (jw)
UN I
TED STA TES DISTRICT C O UR T
SO U TH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO R I
CT
DA
M I IDI I O N
AM
V SI
CA SE N O .1 cv2- 22626- LK
J
KENI VELI as co- s
A
Z,
per onal
rprs natv o hee t eo
e e e t ie ft sat f
Elv Ant o Or pez D i
is oni o e az
Pl i if
antf,
PRI CESS CRU I LI ES,LTD .
N
SE N
dbaPRI
// NCESSCRUI ES af r i
S , o egn
cor
poraton,
i
Def nda .
e nt
/
ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT' M OTI FOR SANCTI
NG
:
ON
QNS
TH I M ATTER com es bef e t Cour upon D ef nt s M oton f Sa tons
S
or he
t
enda '
i or nc i
a is Pli if Ve i a Hi Co ns lRe a dng Dic ve y Ab e ( E.2 ,fl d
gan t antf lz nd s u e g r i
s o r us s D. 0) ie
M a c 18,201 Pl ntf di nottl a r pons t t s M oton,asr r unde Local
rh
3. ai if d
se es
e o hi
i
equied
r
Rul 7.( )( iur t s r e a o posng me r n m oflw wihi 1 d y ofs r ie
e 1c Fal e o e v n p i
mo a du
a t n 4 a s e vc
o a m oi n ma be de me s fii n c us f g a tn t m o i n by de a t.
f
to
y
e d u fce t a e or r n i g he to
ful)
Howeve , upon r ew of t r or and ca e ul consde a i t Cour tnds t
r
evi
he ec d
rf
i r ton, he
ts
he
M oton s d be deni
i houl
ed.
L BA CK G R O UN D
Thi cas a i e f om actons i t Pa fc O cea i M ar 201 On M ar 1
s e rs s r
i n he cii
n n
ch, 2.
ch 0,
201 a gr ofbide s a r D e e
2, oup
r r boa d f ndants s p St Pri s obs ved a s al boati
' hi ar nce s er
m l
n
dites . One oft bider t phot a oft boa and al t t s p' s af At
sr s
he r s ook
ogr phs he t
ered he hi s t f
.
t s e tm e,Elvs Ant o O r ze D i w as a Pana ani n fs m a a d t
he am i
i
oni
ope
az
m a iher n boar he
Fft e t as lboa whihha ls po ra wa a rf i tePa ii Diza d o
yc n, mal t c d o t we nd s d it n h cfc. a n ne
oh rEs r npa sd a ybeo et Fft e twa rs ue b as pna dDua t P.
te hema s e wa fr he yc n s e c d y hi me
re r
Adr a Vas
in
quezw ast s e s vi
he ol ur vor.
For a tm e, i was t
i
t
hought t t t boat t St Prnc s bider s was t
ha he
he ar i es r s aw
he
Fft e t t bid r ha pr vi dt me awi t phog a t yt k a beive
yc n;he r e s d o de he di t he trphs he oo nd le d
h
t phot t s
he
os o how t ûs m en' or . Pl ntf ,as t co- s
he her
s deal ai if
he per onalr pr se atve of
e e nt i
Di z' esat al w ih V as z a ot s r a e t t dece d fs r en,each
a s t e, ong t
que nd her elt d o he
sae i he m
i vi ly s d D ef
ndi dua l ue
endantf f l e t r s
or aiur o e cue. The i t ntcas was t ed on J y 17,
ns a
e
sl
ul
2 2 ( E.1 . I De e r2 2 a trmuli e de ii ns t bide s r la d t
01 D. ) n c mbe 01 , fe
tpl posto , he r r e e ve wo
ot phot ofa boa pr ng t had be m it ken a t one t y phot aphed on
her
os
t ovi hey
en s a
nd he
he
ogr
Mac 1 ,2 1 wa no t F#bc n a wasa t ly amuc lr rboa. Th bid r
rh 0 0 2 s t he
e t nd
cual
h a ge t e r es
alo c r t t r t tm ony a s d t tt had nots a
s orec ed hei es i
nd ai ha hey
een nyone s gnalng f hel
i i or p
fom t ves el
r he s .
Plitf fld aNoieofVoun ay Dimis lwihPrj c o M ac 1 ,201
an if ie
tc ' l tr s sa t eudie n rh 8 3
( E.21 . Th s m e d y,De e a tsld t sM o i n f Sa to , De e da s ys
D. ) e a
a
f nd n e hi to or nci ns
f n nt a
Pl ntf ha conceal e dence centalt t ltgaton;s it f s a m i l ng
ai if s
ed vi
r o he ii i
ubm ted al e nd seadi
Res
pons t I er oga ores Reque t f Pr
es o nt r t i ,
s s or oducton,and Re
i
quess f A dm i i
t or
ssons;
pr frd fi luso j ci ;a fi d ino a eoffcsltrprve t ha be n
ofe e rvoo b e tons nd egne g rnc
a t ae o n o ve e
known,
D ef nda s a est tisprvat i tga orf
e nt t t ha t i e nves i t ound vi
deost ke by t D uart P
a n
he
e '
wh nirsue t Fft e .Dee d n camst tPlitf k w a uthevi osa d
e t e c d he yc nt fn a t li ha anif ne bo t de n
ha copi oft m beca e V as z,t l s vi ,ga a copy t Pl i ifs ty
d
es he
us
que he one ur vor ve
o a ntf hor l
afe hi r cue. I I e r t i and Requess f Pr
tr s es
n nt r oga ores
t or oducton, ef nda as
i D e nt ked
Pl ntf t i iy a1 evi nce s
ai if o dentt 1 de
upportng t cont i t t boa t pas enger
i he
enton hat he t he s
s
s w wa t Fft e , ut anifddno p o d t vie .
a s he yc ntb Plitf i t r vie he d os
A fe Def
t r endanthad t vi ,D ef
he deos
endantas d Pl ntf t a i t vi os
ke ai i f o dm t he de
weea he tca dde ce t Fft e ta i a ae a t tmeiwa a it
r ut n i n pitd he yc n s t ppe rd t he i t s drf.
Def
endantcl i st tPl ntf had copi s oft vi
a m ha ai if
e
he deosand ha s t ,butt t
d een hem
ha
Pl ntf e
ai if vaded a werng t ques i by s ng t ti l
ns i he
tons
ayi ha t acked s fci ntknow l dge
ufi e
e
aboutt a hentc t a ac ac oft vi
he ut i iy nd cur y he deos. D ef ndantc r t rzest e as
e
ha ac e i hes
he aiur o s os he deos
krv o obe to . D ef ntst t t because oft f l e t di cl e t vi
i iolus j cins' enda a es hat
f
'
D e endantha t s c f t m a i ur e coss i r ur ng t Ec
f
d o ear h or he nd nc r d t n et ni o uadort t ke a
o a
D e ar ton fom t r cui boa s a i t t vi
cl a i r he es ng t t tng hat he deosar a hentc and porr t
e ut i
tay he
Fft e ta i a pe r d o t eda i wa r s ue
yc n s t p a e n h y t s e c d.
The Cour not t sm iart bet ee t s cas a Cas No.12- vt es he i l iy w n hi
e nd
e
c 22022- LK ;
J
bot cas s i ve t s e f t lbas sa i ve sm ia c esofac i The cas
h e nvol he am ac ua
i nd nvol i l r aus
ton.
es
we e c ns i a e i t e lwe r o old t d n h o rnumb r d c s i Aug t201 ( 2- 20 D. 22) l
ee a e n
us
2 1 2 22 E. . n
1 22022 D ef nda fl a M oton f Sa tons A gai tPl ntf A dr a V as
2e nt ied
i or nc i
ns ai if
in
quez a
nd
Hi Cou e Re r ng Dic e y Abus s ( E. 1 ) Alho i t i tnt c s
s ns l ga di
s ov r
e D. 01 . t ugh n he nsa a e
Pl ntf i a r es a i oft es a e ofone oft de ed ts r an wher i 1
ai if s epr ent tve he t t
he ceas s he m
eas n 2-
c 22 2 Plitf Va q z wa te s e s vvi ts e ma ofte Fft e ,ma
v- 02 anif s ue s h ol ur i ng s h r n h
yc nt ny
poi s i t M otonsover a
nt n he
i
l p.
l f t t M otons ar a m os i ntcal s ve s e m i
n ac , he
i
e l t de i , a
om
nor dif r es a
fe enc
nd
a tonala gum e sm ade agai tPl ntf V a
ddii
r
nt
ns ai if squez w hi h a e notm a aga ns Pl i if
c r
de i t a ntf
V ei
lz. For exa pl bot M otons t
m e, h
i
ake is w ih r pectve Pl i if ' ac i
s ue t es i
a ntf s tons
s ro di vi ooft Fft e 'r sue i o mainr gadn pantngo t sdeo
u run ng de he yc nts e c ,nfr to e r ig i i n he i f
t Fqbc n,a d Dee n ' prvae ive tg tr rtr i t Pa ma t l ae t
he
e t n fnda ts i t n siao eu nng o na o oc t he
D uar e V ca ai Bot M otons s k Pl ntf s a couns s be or r t r m bur e
t
pt n.
h
i
ee ai if nd
el
de ed o ei
s
Def ntf al coss r l ed t i tgaton oft vi o oft r c 1 Pl ntf s and
enda or 1 t e at o nves i i
he de
he es ue , ai i f
couns s be or r d t r m bur e D ef nda f a 1cos s i ured i s ng couns t
el
de e o ei
s
e nt or 1
t nc r n endi
el o
Pa a t de e Pl ntf Vas
nam o pos ai i f
quez w ihout t be i of t pot i l i pea ng
t
he neft
he entaly m chi
vi
deo,and t tcouns be s i
ha
el anctoned t de erf ur conduc .
o t ut e
t
I 1 22022, M agit a e J
n 2sr t udge G a ber i s
r
s ued a Re t a Rec m enda i
por nd
om
ton,
whih t s Co ta fr d i pa ton Oc o r 1 ,2 3 ( E.1 3) M a sr t J g
c hi ur fime n r
t be 5 01 D. 3 . gitae ud e
500
ai if
Gab rrc mme de dimis lwih prj ie a a s ncton of $2, on Pl ntf
r e e o n d s sa t eudc nd a i
Vaq zsdo si a fr in c un e.Thi Co tore e adimis lwi prj c
s ue ' me tc nd o eg o s l
s ur d r d s s a t eudie
h
bu,u n o j cin b tepate ,ddno i esncin o c unsl TheCou tnoe
t po be to y h ris i t mpos a to n o e.
r ts
M a sr eJ
gitat udge G a berdi notr
r
d
ecom m e m one ar s nctonsagai tt pary i t
nd
t y a i
ns he t n hat
case.
1The Cour as umest r
t s
he eques i t i t M oton p 1 t Pl ntf Vas
t n he nsant i
4 hat ai if quez and hi couns be
s
el
s toned i aEcopy and pas e'eroron Def ntspar. The Cour r dst M oton t as f
anc i
s s
t' r
enda ' t
t ea he
i o k or
s nc i agai tPl ntf Velz and hi couns .
a tons ns ai if i
s
el
4
I .LEGA L STAND AR D
I
Def
enda m oves t Cour t t ke ad i pur ua t t Feder lRul of Ci l
nt
he
to a
on
s nt o he
a
es
vi
Pr c du e 28U. C. 9 a / rt Co tsihe e tpo r
o e r,
S. j1 27, nd o he ur' n r n we .
Read as a whol t Fede al Rul of Ci l Pr edur r r pari a
e, he
r
es
vi oc
e equie
tes nd
atr ys t a twih ho sy. Rul 26 e r q r spa te t s p e n o c rc
tone o c t net
e ( ) e uie ris o u plme t r ore t
r POnS t i e
eS
eS o nt nrga or e , K S
t is
POnS t r
eS o eque t f pr
s s Or oduc i a r pons t
ton, nd es
es o
r
eques s f a i sons i a tm e y m a r i t pari l r t t r s
t or dm s i
n i l
nne f he
tes ea ns hat he e pons w a
e s
i om pl t f i r t(i s e m at ralr pe ' and i t addii
nc
e e or ncor ec tn om
e i es ct'
f he
tonali or a i has
nf m ton
no ohe wie be n ma e k wn t t o he pa te . Rul 26 g i s s a d y o
t tr s e
d no o he t r ris
t ( ) mpo e
ut n
a t neyst s gn onl l gal pr ,and ade t dicover r pons The Rul s per i
tor
o i
y e , oper
qua e s
y es
es.
e
mt
s n tonsf rf iur t pr ry c nd tdic e y.Se eg. d. Ci P. 7( ) 3 d
a c i o al e o ope l o uc s ov r
e . Fe R. v. 3 c , 7( )
Und r28 USC j 1 27, n at r y who u r a o b y a ve to l muli i s
e
9 a to ne
n e s na l nd xai usy tple
t pr di m ay be r r t pa t exce c t ,expens and ator y' f
he ocee ngs
equied o y he
ss os s
es,
t ne s ees
r a o bl i c re a ar s toft ec nd t nor rt a r a j 1 s nci n,ç1
e s na y n u r d s e ul h o uc .l de o wa d
927 a to ( )
(
t at r y mus e ga ei u r a o a ea ve a i c uc,( t tc nd tmus
he to ne
t n g n n e s n bl nd x tous ond t 2) ha o uc
t
h v muli idt p oc e i s a ( )t a un o s nci nsmus be raûna il
a e tple he r e d ng , nd 3 he mo t f a to
t a
nca
nexust t exc spr edi .' nhartv fam arAdve ii Co. 523 Fe Appx.
o he es oce ngs'Bar
rts ng
,
d.
6 , ( 1h Ci. 01 )( uo i Pee s n v BM 1Reï t is 1 F.d 1 ,1 96
35 638 1 t r 2 3 q tng tr o .
l acore , 24 3 386 3
( 1h Ci.99 ) C at r e e ga e i un e s a ea ve a i usc nd twhe t e
1 t r1 7). û to n y n g s n r a on bl nd x to o uc
An
nh
c nd ti $oe r giust ti i t n a un t b d f ih.' 1 ( tngNo e u v
o uc s s g e o ha t s a t mo t o a at ' d. quo i
'
r ls .
De y' I .628F.d 1 ,1 2 ( 1h Ci. l li tr a ct tonso te .i d
nn s nc,
,
3 270 28 1 t r20 o tn e n l ia i mitd) s
Ba
fihi a o j ciesa dadt ti sts dwhe a at ne kn ngyorr c e sy
at s n be tv tn r ha s aise
n n tor y owi l e klsl
puru safi o c am. Pe rv fe s 6 F.d 1 06 1 4 ( 1h Ci. 0 .
s e rvolus li ' e . wi, 06 3 3 , 31 1 t r 201 )
'
Fede alc t ha an i r ntpowert s i w he pa i ora t neyshave
r ours ve nhe e
o ancton
n rtes tor
h r dt j iilp oc s . amb r vNASCO, nc,5 U. 3 4647( 991 .$
ame he udca r e s Ch es
I . 01 S. 2, - 1 ) $
The
key t unl ki a cour ' i r ntpoweri a sndi ofbad f t 'Barnes vD alon,1
o oc ng
ts nhe e
s
ng
aih.'
t
58
F. 1 2( 1h Ci.1 98 .( pa t . d mo tae b d f ih b dea ng o dir ptng
3d 21 1 t r 9 ) $ ry . e nsr ts a at y lyi r su i
A
.
t ltga i orham pe i e or e ofa cour or r'l r Sunshi Jr St e ,I ,
he ii ton
rng nf cem nt
t de .' n e
ne . or s nc.
45 F.d 1 1 1 4 ( 1h Ci. 6 t otn Byr e vNe ha , 1F.d 1 75 1 1 ( 1h
6 3 29 , 30 1 t r zoo lqu ig n
z t 26 3 0 , 2 4 1 t
Ci. ool tn e na ct to o te ) : c us oft i ve ypo e y,i e e po r
r z lit r l iai ns mit d .d a e he r r t nc nh r nt we s
Be
mus bee r ie wihr sr ita d s r to 'Ch
t xe c s d t e tan nd ic ei n. ambe s 5 U. a 44 ( 991 .
'
r , 01 S. t 1 )
1 1 A NA LYSIS
1.
a. The Vi
deos
Dee
f ndant diput Pl i ifs Ans e s t I e r t i a Res
s es a ntf
w r o nt r oga or es nd
pons t
es o
Requess f Pr
t or oduc i
tons. D ef nt does not ata is I e r ores but i t
enda
t ch t nt r ogat i ,
n he
M oton c r t rzes t t i r
i ha ac e i ha t equesed çal e dence t s
t l l vi
hat uppors t cont i t t
t he
enton hat he
boatobs r by pas e r on t St Pri s w as t boatV as z w as adr f on.'
e ved
s nge s
he ar nces
he
que
it '
I is Re s s f Pr
n t
que t or oduc i Def nda sought e denc s
ton,
e nt
vi e uppor i Pl ntf s
tng ai if
alegatons m ade i t Com pl nt or s
l i
n he
ai
uppori t t boa t bide s obse ved was
tng hat he
t he r r
r
t Fft e . E. - 20- A tc nial c re tr a ngofDefnda ' rquet do s
he yc ntD. 206, 7. e h c ly o rc e di
e nts e ss e
notr quie Pl ntf t i ntf t r cue vi
e r ai if o de iy he es
deos.The vi doesnota ualy s
deo
ct l uppor t
t he
c n e in i t e Compli t tt St Prnc n f ie t r s u t Fftc nt Th ,
o tnto n h
ant ha he ar i e a ld o e c e he y e . us
t Cour fnds no t hni f ul wih Pl ntf and couns ' r pons t t Ans er
he
ti
ec cal a t t ai ifs
els es
es o he
w s
t l erogat i ort Fis a Sec Requess f Pr
o nt r ores he r t nd ond
t or oducton.
i
H oweve ,i i cl t tany r s vi
r t s ear ha
e cue deos ar c ii t t s cas gi t tt
e rtcal o hi
e, ven ha he
c s hi e o t Fft e ben te b tt bideso eve l o d rt deemie
a e ng s n he yc nt ig h oa he r r bsr d. n r e o tr n
whih bo twa s e a vie s wi te Fft e ts c ndton ao t tme i
c a s e n, d o ho ng h
yc n ' o ii r und he i n
que ton i obvi l hel ul Thus Pl ntf s d ha r al t vi i or r t
si s
ous y pf .
, ai if houl ve eve ed he deo n de o
s
peed t r sol i oft sca e.
he e uton hi s
l ged r f al t aut i at t
e us o
hentc e he
D ef nda al o t kes is w ih Pl ntf s ale
e nt s a
s ue t ai if
vi
deos i Res
n
pons t Reques s f A dm is on. The r
es o
t or
si
equess post t Pl ntf s
t
ied o ai if ought
i or to rltn t t Fft e a t bo tsc ndton o t d y i wa r sue
nf main eaig o he yc nt nd he a' o ii n he a t s e c d.
Pl i if w as not on t boatt t da D . 20- Eve i Pl ntf had copi s of t
a ntf
he
ha y. E. 8.
n f ai if
e
he
vi
deos,s h pos es i w oul not i pa t know l
uc
s son
d
m r
edge about w ha t ac acy of t
t he cur
he
vie Pli ifVei wa no pes nal o t Fft e o t tda a a s rs i
d o. antf lz s t ro l n he yc nt n ha y nd se t n
y
e nt es s
act
r pons t Pl ntf had bee unabl t de e Vas
es
e hat ai if
n
e o pos
quez. Def nda pr ent no f s
s
edge of t ve se . Pl i i f
he s l
a ntf
as t why Pl ntf Velz s d have per onal know l
o
ai if
i houl
a t m pt d t r pond t t r
te e o es
o he equess buts m pl l ked t know l
t,
i y ac
he
edge t gi D ef nda
o ve
e nt
t i or a i s
he nf m ton ought Pl ntf r pons , t , wer adequa e. A c di y,
.
ai ips es
es hus
e
t
cor ngl
Pl i ifs couns l ac ed a opra el i pr pa i a s gni t docum e s.
a ntf
e
t
ppr i t y n e rng nd i ng he
nt
Def nts a gum ent aboutwhatVasque l e adm it d i de ii do noti i at
enda ' r
s
z at r
te n pos ton
mplc e
Pl i ifVelz.
a ntf
i
D ef nda a gue t ta a hea i on A ugus 8,201 Pl ntf counse s a ed he
e nt r s ha t
rng
t
2 ai ips
l tt
kne not ng a
w
hi boutt vi
he deos a w asuna ar ast wha t y s ed. D ef nda
nd
w e o
t he how
e nt
fndst sunbe i bl becaus Pl ntf ha copi s oft vi o att tm e. The Cour
i hi
leva e
e ai if d
e
he de
he i
t
not t ti t c num berunderw hi h D ef ntha il t sM oton,1 c 22626,
es ha n he ase
c
enda
s ed hi
i
2- vt r i no A ugus 8,201 hea i
he e s
t
2 rng.Thus t Cour as um esD ef
, he
t s
enda r er t t
nt ef s o he
Aug t8 201 he rng i 1 - v- 02 Thi c s n
us , 2 a i n 2 c 22 2. s a e umbe ( 2-v- 26 i no pa to
r 1 c 2 26) s t r f
t mi t s( 2-v- 02 D , 21 a M ih e Ket Ro e t I, antf slse
he nu e 1 c 22 2 E. ) nd c a l ih b rs I Pli if it d
ator i 1 cvt ney n 2- 22626 w asnotatt hearng.A tans rptoft hea i i not
he
i
r ci
he rng s
a t hed t t sM oton.Eve s) i s em sr ona et)t Cour t tany ator y,
tac
o hi
i
n (, t e
eas bl ( he
t ha
t ne
w het Pl ntf V elz' orot r ie,w oul nee tm e t r e t vi
her ai if i s
he w s
d d i o eviw he deosbef e
or
r a ki on t m . A ss h,any sa em entdenyi c m enton t vi i not
em r ng
he
uc
tt
ng om
he deo s
s i bl
anctona e.
b Pantngont Si o heFeyc nt
. ii
he de ft
e
Dee n as mo s f sncinsb c us Plitf o j ce t Re u ss f
fnda t lo ve br a to e a e anif b e td o q e t or
Admiso rg r ng ie tfig maks o t Ffbc nt Plitf rs nd d wih
s ins e adi d niyn
r n he
e . anif e po e t
lnghy o j ci s t t s rq ss As sae a ve Plitf Vei wa n o t
e t b e ton o he e e uet.
ttd bo , anif lz s ot n he
Fft e td rngt M ac 201 o d a a t eCo tha n r a o t fn t tPli if
yc n u i he r h 2 r e l nd h ur s o e s n o id ha antf
V elz has per onal know l
i
s
edge of t boa ' appea a
he
ts
r nce. Pl ntf Velz and couns
ai if
i
el
r ponded t t bes ofPl ntf sknow l
es
o he t
ai if
edge.Thus t Cour w ilnoti pose s nc i
, he
t l
m
a tons
f t e r pons
or hes es
es,
8
I CO N CLUSIO N
V.
I s ,t Court fnds Pl ntf s d ha bee m or f t
n um he
i
ai if houl ve
n
e orhcom i wih t
ng t he
e senc of t r c vi
xit e
he es ue deo. How e , on bal
ver
ance,s nc i ar unnec s y i t s
a tons e
es ar n hi
c s . The c s ha ar a y be n vol trl dimis d wih p eudie Plitf
ac
a e s le d e
unaiy s se t rj c . an ifs
r pons t di c r r
es
es o s ove y eques s do not vi a e t Feder Rul of Ci l Pr
t
ol t he
al
es
vi ocedur
e.
Un r j 1 27 t a ov a l i s owsc un e ha go g o s f b le n i t
de 9 , he b e nayss h
o s l d od r und or ei vig n he
c se of ac i t ken a t Cour fnds not ng e egi
our
ton a
nd he
ti
hi gr ous. The Cour de i t
t clnes o
e r s is di c e i t i pos s nctons unde is i r ntpow er neiherPl ntf nor
xe cie t s r ton o m e a i
r t nhe e
s; t
ai if
couns ha del yed or dir e ltga i t t e e whi woul pe m i s
el ve a
s upt d ii ton o he xt nt ch
d r t uch a
n
exer s The e a e i ufi ent a l tons i t s M oton and on t r cor as a whol
ci e.
r r ns fci
lega i
n hi
i
he e d
e
t t ac i ofPl ntf ofPl ntf couns w a r s tons
hat he tons
ai i f
ai ifs
el r ant anc i .
A c di y,afer a ca ef r viw of t r d a t Cour ot
cor ngl
t
r ul e e
he ecor nd he
t hem i bei
se ng
a s i t pr m ies i i O RD ER ED, A DJUD G ED and DECR EED t
dvi ed n he e s , t s
hat
Def
endants M oton f Sa tons a ns Pl i i f V elz a H i Couns Regar ng
'
i or nc i
gai t a ntf
i nd s
el
di
Dic e y Ab e ( E.20 b a d t s mei h r b DENI
s ov r us s D. ) e n he a s e e y
ED.
DO NE AN D O R DERED i c
n hamber at t J es Lawr nce K i Fe r
s
he am
e
ng de al
t d t t s rho e M a , o i , hi
y f t r
J ltc Buidi a Unie S a e Cou t us , im i Fl rda t s f 2 da o Ocobe ,
tsi e l ng nd
201
3.
ES LA W RENCE K I
N
I
TED STATES DI
ST CT J GE
UD
SOUTHERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?