Chanel, Inc. v. The Partnership Or Unincorporated Association Doing Business As Purse Valley et al
Filing
135
ORDER GRANTING IN PART PLAINTIFF'S MOTION 131 FOR ENTRY OFFINAL DEFAULT JUDGMENT AGAINST THE PURSE VALLEY DEFENDANT. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 1/31/2014. (sk)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .1: 2- v- 45- TZ/ M ON TON
1 c 227 SEl S1
CH AN EL, C .
m ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.
TH E PARIN ERSH I OR
P
UNI
NCOH OM TED ASSOCI ON
ATI
DOI BUSI
NG
NESS A S PURSE VALLEY
c al,
f .
De e
f ndant.
s
ORDER GM NTI G I PART PLAI FF' M OTI FO R ENTRY OF
N N
NTI S
ON
FI
NAL DEFAULT JUDGM ENT AGAI ST TH E PURSE VALLEY DEFENDANT
N
TH I M A TTER i bef e t Cour upon Pl i tf s Fo t M oton f Enty of Fi l
S
s or he
t
a n if
ur h
i or r
na
Dea l J g n ( 1 1 . Pli tf,Ch n l I c Cç n l o ç an if' mo e f rfn l
fut ud me t DE 3 1 anif a e, n . cha e' r s itf ) v s o ia
' pl
d f utj d me t a an tt Pu s Valy Dee a t te Pa te s i Or Unic mo ae
e a l u g n g is he re le
fnd n , h rn rhp
n o r td
Asocain doi busne sasPureValey (d fndan )f alege vi ai oft Ln m
s ito ng i s
s l ç e f' or l d oltons he nha
De
Ac,c fe a 1 U. C.jj 111 111 11 ,a 11 a .AsDefnda hasfie t a r
t odiid t 5 S.
4, 6, 21 nd 25()
e nt ald o ppea,
pl a orot r s def t sa ton,a g ve t doc e a y evi nc s
ed
he wie end hi c i nd i n he um nt r
de e ubmit i s ppo t
ted n u r
of is moton, t Cour s l gr nt Pli ifs M oton f Fi l Def ul J m e i pa t
t
i he
t ha l a
antf '
i or na
a t udg nt n r.
Pli ifs e a a r of$528, 000. f De enda ' wilu us ofism a ks Thoug
antf e ks n wa d
000, 00 or f nts lf l e t r .
h
t De enda ' us w as w ilul a a a d i e s ofha fa bilon dola s i unr s bl Fo
he f
nts e
lf , n w r s xce s
l
li
l r s ea ona e. r
r a onss to be o t Cour awa ds$ 752, 00 i da a .
es
e ut l w, he
t r 4, 000. n m ges
1
.
FA CTU AL A N D PR O C ED UR AL BA CK G R O U ND
Cha ,I .(( nel' i acomorton dul or ani d unde t l oft Stt of
nel nc çCha ' s
)
ai
y g ze
r he aws he ae
N e Y or w ih is prnci l pl c of busne s i t Unie St t s l a e a N i W es 57 h
w
k t t i pa a e
i s n he
t d a e oc t d t ne
t t
Sre, w Yo k Ne Yo k 1 01 . Ame d dCo an g 6a j 3 . Ch n li e g g d i
te t Ne r , w r 0 9 ( n e mpli t DE t j) a e s n a e n
t pr
he omoton,diti i a s e i Unie St t i e sa e c
i
srbuton, nd al n
t d aes nt rt t omm e ce ofhi qua iy goods
r
gh lt
undert Chane M aks ( clrton ofAdre Ha Sibar i Suppo tofPl nifsEx
he
l r . De aai
inne hn s ro n
r
aitf
Pa t Ap iainf rEn r o Te o a yRe tann Or e a d P ei n r Ij n to Cslh
re plc to o ty f mp rr sr iig d r n r l ay n u cinl ln n
mi
De l' ! 4, ( 8 9 . Ch n li,a d a a1tme r lv n heeo h sb e t eo e o a1
c .) ! 5 DE - 1) a e s n t 1 i s ee a t rt a e n, h wn r f 1
'
rg si a t t f l ng Fe r ly r se edta
i ht n nd o he olowi
de a l egit r r dema ks
r :
T
ra mar
de k
CH AN EL
Regi raton
st i
Number
0
61 1
2, 69
,
Regi raton
st i
Dat
e
Cl se lGoods
as ts/
Se e be 1
pt m r 3,
1
955
I 01 -N e kl e
C 4
c ac s
CH AN EL
0, 035
626,
CH AN EL
0, 1
902, 90
N ovem be 1 j (j sr e e s Pi ,a Eani
1 r 0, c ) 4
970
ac l t , ns nd
ngs
CH AN EL
0, 5, 39
91 1
J
une 1 1
5, 971 I 025 - W om e sShoes
C
n'
CH AN EL
0
955,
074
,
1
241,
264
,
M a 1,1
y
956 I 01 - W o e sH a
C 8
m n' ndba
gs
-
M ac 1
r h 3,
1
973
I 01 - W a c s
C 4
t he
I 025 - Suis J c t ,Ski t,
C
t , a ke s
rs
Dr s ,Pa s B l e ,Tuni s
es es nt , ous s
c,
Sw e e s Ca di ns Tee shi t,
at r , r ga , - r s
June 7,1983 C
a s Coa s Ra n- t ,J c t
pe , t , i coa s a ke s
M ade ofFe t r ,Sha l ,Sc r es
a he s
w s av ,
Shoes and Boot
,
s
1Pl i if sEx Par e A pplca i n f r Te po a y Resr i ng Or a Pr lm i r
a ntf
t
i to o m r r
t a ni
der nd e i na y
Ij ncin,o eh rwihs p o t ge h bt a dde lr to saei o p rtdh r i b
nu to t g te t u p ri x i i n ca ai n r nc r o ae e en y
n
s
r ernc (heû iain frTe r r Re tai ngOr r'.( 8.
ef e e t s c to o mpo ay sr ni de ' DE )
Appl
)
2
T
r mar
ade k
CHANEL
R e s ra i
gi t t on
Numbe
r
1241 265
,
,
1
271 8
, 76
1
I 01 -Lea herG oods nam e y,
C 8
t
l
J y 9,1
ul
985 H
andba
gs
501 898
,
-
Nove be 1 I 009 - Sungl s s
m
1 r , C
988
as e
1
D e em be 1
c
r 9,
1
989
I 01 - W a c a Cl ks
C 4
t hes nd oc
571 787
,
,
1
65 252
4,
,
CH AN EL
Aug t30, I 01 - Cos um e J w e r
us
C 4
t
e ly
1
988
I 025
C
Bels
t
151 757
0,
,
CHA N EL
ar h 27,
c
1 4
98
I 025- Cl hi -Na el Coa s
C
ot ng
m y, t,
D r s es Bl e ,Ra nc t ,Suis
e s , ous s i oa s t ,
Skit, r ga ,Swe t r ,Pan s
rs Ca di ns
aes
t,
J c s Bl e s Sha s Has a
a ket, az r , wl, t, nd
Shoes
347,
677
,
CHANEL
I 0 - Suis J c t,Skit,
C 25
t, a kes rs
Dr s s Pa s Bl es Tuni ,
es e , nt , ous ,
cs
Swe e s Ca di ns Te shit,
atr , r ga , e- rs
J 7,1
une 983 C
a s Coa s Rai co s Ja ke s
pe , t , n- at , c t
M adeofFe t r ,Sha s Sc r e ,
ahe s
wl , a v s
Shoes a Boo s
, nd
t
J nua y 1
a r 5, I 01 -Leahe GoodsNa ey,
C 8
t r
- m l
1
985
Ha
ndbags
,
1
Cl selGoods
as ts/
31 511
4,
,
CHA N EL
Dat
e
M
,
1
Re sr i
gi t aton
1
733,
051
,
A ugus 20,
t
j
1
991
I 009 - Sung a s
C
s es
I 018 -Le t rG oods na e y,
C
a he
; m l
Ha
ndbags W a l t , a lBa ,
, le s Tr ve gs
N ove be 1 Lugg ,Busnes and Cr di Ca d
m r 7,
age
i s
e t r
1
992
C as ,Cha Ptr es Tot B a ,
es
nge ls , e gs
Cos e i Ba Sol Em p y,a
m tc gs d
t nd
G a m entBagsf Tr vel
r
or a
3
T
r mar
ade k
R egi rat on
st i
Number
Cl ses/
ast lGoods
73 822
4,
559,
772
Apr l9, 2
i 200
,
2
Dat
e
I 018 -Le t rG oods na e y,
C
a he
; m l
N ove be 24, Ha
ndba ,W a lt ,Tr velBa ,
gs le s a
gs
m r
1 2
99
Lugga Busne sCa d Cas s
ge, i s r
e,
ChangePur e , e Ba ,a
s s Tot gs nd
Cos i Ba Sol Em pt
metc gs d
y
1
J1
2
R egi t on
s rati
,
I 01 -r m e e s na e y, a c s
C 4 'i pi ce ; m l W t he ,
a Pa t The eof
nd r s r
3, 934
025,
D e m be 1
ce r 3, c (j
jg
2005
I
u a s ags
nt
3, 936
025,
D e m be 1
ce r 3, c ((9
)j
2005
1
sungl s s
as e
-
-
CHA NEL
3, 33, 39
1 1
A ugus 22,
t
dw
2006
I 01 -J w ely a
C 4 e r n
ac
t hes
CHA N EL
3
A ugus 29,
t
2006
I 009 - St gl s e
C
m ass
1 695
34,
,
4
074,
269
,
I 009-Pr e tveCover f rPora e
C
ot c i
so
tbl
D e e be 20, El toni D e ce ,H a
cm r
ec r c vi s ndhe d Di t l
l gia
2011
D
e c , r ona Comput r ,a Cel
vi es Pe s l
e s nd l
Phones
.
( t n l aks' wh c aerg see o tePrncp l g se o t eUni d S ae Pae t
t ç e M r ' ih r e itrd n h i ia Re itr f h
he cha
)
t tts tn
e
a Tr ma k Ofi a a e us d i c
nd ade r fce nd r e n onneci wih t manuf c ur a diti i ofhi
ton t he
a t e nd srbuton
gh
quaiygoodsi t c tgore i ntfeda
lt
n he ae is de ii bove.( hn Dec. 4 ( 8 9 ;s ealoUnie Stts
Hn
l! DE - 1 e s
td ae
Tr mak Regitai of t Cha M aks a is Ci ne Tr mar Re sr to '
ade r
srtons he nel r t s ue cha l ade k gitains'
)
atc a Co
ta hed s mpost Exhi tA t t Ham Dec.( 8- 01
ie bi o he l
l DE 1 )
As s t f t m or f l i Pli ips Ex Pare Applc to f r Enty of Te
e orh
e uly n a ntf
t
ia i n o
r
mpor r
ay
Retanng Or e a d P ei n r Ij n to ( 8 a d Plitf Fx Pa t Ap iain f r
srii
d r n r lmia y n u ci n DE j n anirs
re pl to o
c
4
Or e Re tann t eTr n fro AsesTidt t Co n efii gOp rto ( 412 a d t
d r sr iig h a se f s t e o he u tretn eain DE ), n j
w
De l r ton of Cha ' r pr e a i Adre Ha Siba r tl d i s
caai
nels e es nt tve
i nne hn s ro ie n uppor of Pl ntf s
t
ai if
Applcai f Te a yRetai ngOr r( 8- ,Defnda i pr i s li ofe i
i ton or mporr sr ni de DE 91 e nt s omotng, elng, frng
f rs l a diti i goods be rng cou e f isofPli if stade r wihi t sJ cal
o ae nd srbutng
ai
ntr et
antf' r ma ks t n hi udii
Ditit t ough va i f ly i e a tve c
src hr
rous u l nt r c i omm e c a I e ne we ies i ntfe on Sc dul
r i l nt r t bst de ii d
he e
I 'h rt (h t u j c Do i Nn s' i dr c c nrve to o Ch ne' rg t. ( ewe
W ' eeo t e û b e t man me ' n ie t o ta nin f a ls ih s3 Se b
s
)
pa pr n out f om ea h of t D e e nts w e ies s i D e enda ' ad r iem e s a
ge i t s r
c
he f nda ' bs t how ng f
nt s ve ts nt nd
ofe s t s l countr et Cha b a d pr t a tc d as Compost Exhi t A t t
f r o el
ef i
nel r nde oducs ta he
ie
bi
o he
Ap iain f rTe rr Retann Or e g 8 1 ( ee fe ,ç f n a tsW e ie ' )As
pl to o mpo ay sr iig d r DE -) h r atr ç e d n ' bstsl.
c
De
s h, Def nda i t a tve, c c o , a dom i nt f c be nd t pr m oto
uc
e nt s he c i
ons i us nd
na
or e hi
he o i n,
a ri e e ,dit i i s l ,a of e i f s e ofha
dve ts m nt s rbuton, a e nd f rng or al
ndbags w ale s s s boo s be t ,
, l t , hoe , t , ls
s n lse ,wac e ,c t mej wer icu ig n c a e ,b a ees e rig a d rn s a d
u ga s s th s osu e ly, n ldn e klc s rc lt, arn s n ig , n
pr t c i co r f pora e e e to c de c t tbea c e f t a c usngl sm ia
o e tve ve s or tbl l cr ni vi es ha
r ount rei nd onf i y i lr
i ttons of t Cha l M aks (he ç
miai
he ne
r t s
count fi Goods' t ough t f ly i ea tve
eret
' hr
)
he ul ntrci
c mme ca we ie o e ai u d rSu j c Do i Na s ( n e Co lit! 6 1 ,
o ril bsts p rt n e be t man me . Ame d d mp an ! - 7
ng
2 - 4,4 - ,5 - 9 s e as Ham De l ! 9 1 ;De lrto o Erc Ro ae i S p o to
74 9 51 6 5 ; e lo l c. ! - 5 caain f i s lr n u p r f
Plitf' Ap lc t n f rTe o ay Re tanngOr e ( ee fe ,i s lrDe l' ( 8 1 )
anifs p iai o mp rr sr ii
o
d r h r atr ç ae c .) DE - 3 ;
Ro
'
D e l r ton of St phe M . Gaf n i Su r of Pl ntf ' A pplc i n f r Te po a y
caai
e n
fga n ppo t
ai i f s
i ato o
m rr
Re tann Or e ( ra tr t fia De 1' ! 2 3 ( 8 1 1 s eas ac a t u l n te
sr iig d r hee fe ,s fg n c.) ! , DE - 2 ; e lo h r o ti g h
Ga
'
ni
Re sr nt a A dm i sr tve a Cont c i or a i i ntted on t W H OI dom ai
gi t a nd
ni ta i
nd
a t nf m ton de ii
he
S
n
2 Pl ntf s Ex Par e Applca i f Or r Res r i ng t Tr ns e of A s e s Ti d t t
ai i f
t
i ton or de
t a ni he a f r
s t e o he
Countreii Ope a i t t r wih s pori e bis and de a ato a e i or aed
e f tng
r ton, oge he t up tng xhi t
clr i ns r nc por t
heenbyr frnce(het ght Applc tonf Ase Resr nf'.( 41.
ri
eee t i h
Ei
iai or st tai ) DE 1
3 Pl i tf s St t m e t of Fa t r r ng is r g s a D e enda ' i rngi a tvii s a e
a n if
ae ns
c s ega di t i ht nd f
nt s nf i ng c i te r
outi d i t Ame d Compl nti Paag a 27- ( 61and i Pli ifsApplc i
lne n he
nde
ai n r r phs 44 DE
n antf'
iaton
f Te ar Retani Or r( 8 andaei or ae he enbyr frnc
or mpor y sri ng de DE )
r nc portd r i
eee e.
r gsrto r c r f r t e S be t Do i Nmne atc e a Co ost Ex ii A t
e itain e o ds o h u j c man
s ta h d s mp ie hbt o
Plitf' Ap lc to f rTe o ay RetanigOr e ( 84 .
an ifs p iain o mp rr sri n d r DE - 1)
Pli ifrt ne Erc Ros l ($ a1r',a ofie of AED I siai ,I ,a
antf eai d i
aer çRos e ' n fc r
)
nvetg tons nc.
lc ns d prvae i si tve fnn, t i tga e t s pe t d s e of c e f i Cha
i e e i t nve tgai i
o nvesi t he us c e als
ountr et
nel
b a d dp o u t b t eDee da t ( e Ham De l ! 1 Ro ae De l! 3.Roslra c se
r n e r d cs y h fn n . S e l c . 0; s lr c. ) ae c e sd
t re ()o t eI tr e we stso e a d o e ae b Dee a te itn u d rt e S be t
h e 3 f h n en t b i wn d n p rtd y fnd n x sig n e h u j c
e
ir plca . o nd i i d he
D om ai N a e , i ls le co, pur e valey. s a, and basc e i sc a fnalze t
n
m s ptr eva l y.
s- l a i 4
pur ha e of a par ofbale si r ,a pr e tve c r f a pora e el toni de c a a
c s
i
lt lppe s
ot ci ove or
tbl ecr c vie, nd
wa ltfo e h we ie r pe tvel - ea h be rng c e f is ofa l s one oft Cha l
le r m ac
bst es c i y
c a i ount ret
t ea t
he
ne
M ak a is i ti a to ( e Ro ae De l ! 4 9 a d Co o ieEx ii B a tc e t
r s t sue n h s cin. Se s lr c. ! - n mp st hbt ta h d o
Pli ifsApplc ton f r Te ay Resri ng Or r ( 82 tlough DE 8- . Roslr
antf
iai o mporr
tani
de DE
lr
31)
ae
fnalze pa
i i d ymen f t Cha br nde goodshe pur has by VI c r a w a pr de
t or he
nel a d
c ed
SA a d nd s ovi d
w ih t f l i pa e pr es or da a f t r s c i buys i s va l y. o t he olow ng ym nt oc s
t or he e pe tve
: pur e le c
M ARKETI
NG I
NC or pr onlne pa t bal son s Ve tr c r ; ptr e va ly. i
o
i
rs l t
pa ntle a ds zs - le asa
htpi/
t /wwm pfs p.om;a basc e iasco - THAI
cho c
nd ir plc .
EPAY -htpiwwm t e y.om.( e
t/
/
haipa c
Se
=
i)
d
The de al d we pa lsi and i
t ie
b ge itngs
mage of t Cha l br d bale si r ,
s
he
ne ande
lt lppe s
pr e i c rf a por a e el ctoni de c ,and wale pur s d by R os e vi t I e ne
ot ctve ove or
t bl e r c vi e
l t cha e
al r a he nt r t
we sts o rtn u e t e Su j c Do i Na s pu s v le c ,p revalya i,a d
b ie peaig nd r h be t man me ,i re aly.o u s - le .sa n
basc e i s c w e e r e e by Cha ls r pr e a i A dr e
i r plca . o, r evi w d
ne ' e es nt tve,
i nne H a Si ba r w ho
hn s r o,
dee ned t pr t purhas t be non- nui ,una ho ied Chane pr t.( hn
tnni he oducs c ed o
ge ne ut rz
l oducs Ha
Dec.! 11 1 1 ) M s Ham Sibar as rvi
l ! -2, 5.
. l s ro lo e ewed a viual i pe td Dee nts
nd s ly ns ce fnda '
4TheI ene we ieope ai undert Sub e tDomanNamepure- le asaa omaial
ntr t bst rtng
he j c
i
s valy. i ut tc ly
r diec s a f w a dst t I e tw e ie ope a i unde t dom ai nn e pur e le . t
e r t nd or r o he nt nw
bs t
r tng
r he
n m
s va l ys ne .
Ros e ' purha ewasc ee t o t pure lysne we ie. Se Ros lrDe . 6.
alrs c s
ompltd hr ugh he svale . t bst ( e ae cl! )
6
W e ie ,a we laspi t e ofie bea i t Cha lM m'sof e e f s l by De enda
bst s s l
cur s t ms rng he
ne
k f r d or a e
f nt
vi isI tr e we ie o eaigu d rteS b e t manNa s a dlk wied tr n dt e
a t n en t bsts p rtn n e h u j c Do i me , n ie s eemie h
p o u t ween tg n i Ch n l o d .S eHa n De l!( 3 1 ( 8 9 .
r d cs r o e une a e g o s ( e h c. ! 1 - 5 DE - 2)
On Nove r 1 201 Pli tf fld isEx Pare Apple ton f Or rResr i ng t
mbe , 2, a n if ie t
t
ia i or de
tani he
Trnse ofAsesTi t t Countretng Opeai g 41. On Novembe 7,201 t
a fr
st ed o he
e fii
rton. DE )
r
2,he
Cour e ee a Or rgr ni Pli ifsApplcai f Ase Re tai (iedunde s l,a
t ntrd n de a tng antf
i ton or st sr nt tl
r ea) nd
rfre P an ifs Ap iai n f rPrlmi r Ij n to t t Ho o a e M a itae J d e
eer d litf
pl to o ei nay nu cin o he n rbl g srt u g
c
Andr a M .Si on. M a sr t Si
e
mont
gitae mont is d a Re ta Re omm e ton on No mbe
on sue
por nd c
ndai
ve r
1 ,2 2,r c mme ig t a Plitf s Ap iain f r Prlmiay lj ncin s o l b
9 01 e o ndn h t an if
pl to o ei n r nu to h ud e
c
g a e E 601 a t sCour r iid,afimed,a a e t smeo Nove r21 201
r ntd DE , nd hi
t atfe tr
nd doptd he a n
mbe , 2.
( 6.
DE 31
The Or r gr ntng Pli ifs Applc ton f As e Re tai a s eque
de
a i
antf
ia i
or s t sr nt nd ubs nt
P ei n r Ij n to e j n d i e a i,De e d n a d a y a d alfn nca i ttto t)
r l ay nu cin noie , ntr la fn a t n n n l l a il nsi in s
mi
u
r s o i e frta sern f n si t t e s me fn nca isiuin la c u ts a a y o t e
ep nsbl o rn fri g u d no h a ia il n ttto a c o nt) s n f h
i ntfe ba a cot sfo ta fni diposngot ors rtng a mone soc ,bonds
de i d nk c mt r m rnse ng, s i l ecei ny
y, t ks
,
r l o pe s na pr pe t or ot r as e s of Def ndan o o he wi e pa ng or t a f r i a
ea r r o l o ry,
he s t
e
t r t r s yi
r ns e r ng ny
mo
ney,s oc ,bonds r a or pe s l pr r y,or ot r as e s t D e e nt or i o or ou of
t ks
, el
r ona ope t
he s t o f nda , nt
t
an ac ount as ocatd wih orutlz d by any oft Def nt The Or ra s r r d t
y c s s ie t
ii e
he enda .
de lo equie he
fn n ili ttto t)t p o ie Plitf sc u e a sae n rfe tn a y a c u t a te
ia ca nsi in s o r vd an if o nsl ttme t elcig n c o n s t h
u
fn n il isiuint) s be tt t i Or e a t e d la a t o a y a s t c n an d
ia ca n tt t s u j c o h s d r nd h o lr momt f n ses o tie
o
t r n. El von, l a Fis D a a pa e pr es o s f r t Pur e Valey Def nda ,
he ei
a
nc. nd r t t , ym nt oc s r o he
s
l
e nt
c ple w ih t r quie e s of t Cour ' Or r , a r t a ned f
om i d t he e r m nt
he
ts de s nd es r i
unds i t n o of
n he m unt
$5, 00a $88, 33,r peci l ( eDe lrtonofStphe M .Gat ani Su tof
909. nd
370. es tvey. Se caai
e n
fig n ppor
P an ifsMo in f rEnr o Fia De a l J dg n Ag i tDee d n rd fia De l i
litf' to o ty f n l f ut u me t ans fn a t Gafg n c. n
S p o t f ' !2,ie h r wi )
u p r o FDJ' ( tld e e t
I
h.
O n N ove be 1,201 Pl i iff l is M o i f Or r A u ho i i A le a e Se v c
m r
2, a ntf ied t
ton or de
t r z ng t m t r i e
o Pr c s ( 4 J wh c te Co r g a td o No e e 7 2 2. f 4 ) Pt s a tt te
f o e s DE 3 , ih h u t rn e n v mb r , 01 DE 4. l u n o h
r
Cour' Or r Pl i if s r ed De e ntwih is Summ o a a copy oft Co pl i a
ts de , antf e v
f nda
t t
ns nd
he m ant nd
Amende Complit vi eecr c mal (i- i' s r ce o Nove r 1 201 (
d
an a l toni i d mal' evi n
e
)
mbe 2, 2. See
Gafga Dec.i Suppor ofFDJ! 3. Plitf fl t Pr ofSe vceast Defnda o
fi n l n
t
) anif ied he oof
ri
o e nt n
No mbe l 2013.( 511
ve r 3,
DE .
Pli iffld isRe s f Clr sEnty ofDeful on Marh 11 2013.g 85 .On
antf ie t que t or ek' r
at
c ,
DE )
M ac 1 201 t Clr of Com',purua t Rul 55( oft Fe r Rul of Ci l
rh 2, 3, he ek
t s nt o e a) he deal es
vi
Pr e le e e e de a ta i t De e nt f f iur t a
oc dtr , nt r d f ul ga ns f nda or a l e o ppea ,pl d,or o he wie de e
r ea
t r s f nd
t sacin.g 8 1Todae Deenda ha nots ug t va t t deful orot r s a a
hi to DE 6.
t, f nt s
o ht o cae he a t he wie ppe r
a def t s a ton.Pl ntf now m o s t Cour t gr ntDe a tFi lJ m e a i t
nd end hi c i
ai if
ve he
to a
f ul na udg nt ga ns
De e nt
f nda .
l.
I
LEG A L STAN D AR D
F d rlRueo Cii Pr c d r 5 ( )2 a t o ie ac u tt e tra d fulj dg n
e ea l f v l o e u e 5 b ( ) u h rz s o r o n e ea t u me t
a i tapr ry s r ed de e nt who,lke De e nt her f ie t fl atmel r ponsve
gans
ope l e v
f nda ,
i
f nda s e, al d o ie i y es i
plad ng.By s h a de a t a lofPl i ifswe lpl d ale tonsi t Compli a e dee e
e i
uc
f ul, 1
antf ' l- e l ga i n he
a nt r
m d
a mitd Se Bu h n nv Bo n 8 0F.d3 9 3 ( 1hCi.1 8 ) Peme Ex e s I c v
d te . e c a a . wma , 2 2 5 , 61 1 t r 9 7 ; t d pr s, n . .
Med scom,336 F.Supp.2d 1 3, 1 7 ( D.Fl 2004) l t admitd fcs i t
pot.
21 21 S. a.
. f he
te a t n he
Compli e t bls la lt t n t Cour m us de e mi a o it dn
ant sa ih i biiy, he he
t t t r ne ppr pra e mage .W he e a lt
s
r 1 he
es e i le de i on r c d,an e de ir hea i on da a s i no r quie See SEC v
s nta vi nce s
e or
vi nta y rng
m ge s t e r d.
.
Smyt 420 F. 1
h,
3d 225, 1 n.1 ( 1h Ci.2005) (t e 55( () s a of e de ta y
232
3 1t r
t
Rul b)2 pe ks
vi nir
8
hea i i a pe m isve t ne . ..W e ha hed t t no s h hea i i r uie whe e a1
rngs n
r si o
ve l ha
uc
rng s eq r d
r 1
e s nile ie c i ara y o rc r ' ( iainso te ) s ealo Peme Ex e s 3 6 F.
s e ta vd n e s le d f e o d.) ctto mitd ; e s t d pr s , 3
'
S p 2 a 1 2 (n eig d futj g n ,p r n n ij n to a d sauo y d g si a
u p. d t 2 3 e trn e a l ud me t ema e t n u cin n tt tr mna e n
Ln m Ac ca e wiho a he rng) I t s c e,a heai o da gesi unne esay a
nhn
t s t ut ai . n hi as
rng n ma s
c sr s
Pl i if s ks saut r dn a s a ha s itd de a ld de l tons wih a c
antf ee t t o y m ge nd s ubm te t ie
c ra i
t c ompa ng
nyi
doc e a y e de e i s
um nt z vi nc n uppor ofisda age r que t
t t m s e s.
11
1.
A.
LI BILITY
A
T radem ark I ri
nf ngem ent
Th alg to si Plitf sAme e Co ant i c nu cin wih rc r e ie c ,
e le ain n anif
nd d mpli , n o j n to t e o d vd n e
s
uppor afndi ofla lt a i tDe e ntf ta mak i rnge nt ç( o prvai o a
t i ng ibiiy gans f nda or rde r nfi me . 1T) e l n
ta mak i rnge ntcli a pli ifmus de tae t t( ) ismak hasprort (
rde r nfi me am
antf
t monsrt ha 1 t r
i iy; 2)
defnda us d ismar i c
e nt e t k n ommece ( t c e j a ( dee ntsmak i lkey t
r wihout ons nt; nd 3) fnda ' r s i l o
ca ec umerco uson.' t d Ex e s 336F.Supp. a 1 7- (ii I 'Co meis
us ons
nf i 'Peme pr s ,
2d t 21 18 ctng nt1 s tc
Exc ,I .v Ga di He t d:Be y I . 303 F. 1 ( 1h Ci.2002)a Fr hln
h. nc . par s a1h
aut nc,
3d 243 1 t r
nd e ig
Entr,I .v I 1Seec Gr p,I . 1 F. 1 ( 1h Ci.1 ) Pli ifha esa ihed
e nc . nt l t ou nc, 92 3d 330 1 t r 999). antf s tbls
e h oft s ee nt be a e:( )Pli ifsownes p a r gitai oft ta maksa
ac
he e lme s c us 1 antf
rhi nd e srton he rde r t
is p e e e De e d n ' ifigng c n u t( n e Co lit! 3 ;Ha n De l ! 4 ;( )
sue rc d f n a ts n rn i o d c Ame d d mpan 7 h c. ) 2
D e e nt a r i e of e e f s l a or s d goods be r ng Pl ntf s m a ks i i e sa e
f nda dve ts d, f r d or a e nd/ ol
ai
ai if
r n nt r t t
c
ommec wihoutPli ifsc e ( nde Compli ! 49;s e alo Ha De .! 9 1
re t
antf' ons nt Ame d
ant
e s hn cl ! - 5
a d Co o i Ex ii B atc e t e eo ( 8 1 1 Ro ae c.! 4 9 a Co st
n
mp st hbt ta h d h r t DE - 1 ; s lrDe l ! - nd mpo ie
e
Exhi tB t Pli ifsApplcain f Te ay Re tai ngOr r( 8- t oughDE 8- ;
bi o antf
i to or mporr sr ni
de DE 2 hr
31
s ge r l De e nts W ebst a tche as Com post Exhi tA t Pl i ifs Applc ton
ee ne al
y f nda '
ies ta d
ie
bi
o antf
ia i
frTe ay Re tai ng Or r ( 8- 1,and ()t mar usd on t goodsDee t
o mporr sr ni
de DE 1)
.
3 he ks e
he
fndan
9
ad rie ofe ed f r s l a or s d a e s sm ia t Pl ntf s m a ks t t c um e
ve ts d, f r o a e nd/ ol r o i lr o ai if
r ha ons r
c n u ini lk l ( n e Co li t !3 5 ) s eas Ha n De l ! 9 1 a d Co o ie
o f so s i ey.Ame d d mpan ! 7, 0 ; e lo h c. ! - 5 n mp st
Ex ii B atc e t t e Ha n De l;Ro ae De l ! 4- a d Co ost Exhbt B t
hbt ta h d o h h
c. s lr c. ! 9 n
mp ie ii o
Pli ifs Applc ton f Te r r Resr i ng Or r s e ge r l De e nts W e ie
antf
ia i or mpo a y
tani
de ; e ne al
y f nda '
bst s
at he asCompost Exhi tA t Pli ifsApplcai f Te ay Re tani Or r)
tac d
ie bi o antf
i ton or mporr sri ng de.
B.
Fal e D e i i ofO r gi
s
s gnaton
in
Pl ntf algesf s de i tonofoi nunde j43()oft Lanha Ac,1 U. C.j
ai if le ale sgnai
lgi
r
a he
m t 5 S.
1 2 () Th t e to p o d sa f l ws
1 5 a . a s cin r vie s ol :
o
Any pe s who,on ori c
r on
n onneci n wih a goodsors vies o a c a ne
to t ny
er c , r ny onti r
f goods us s i c
or
, e n omm e c any wor t r ,nn e s m bol or de c orany
re
d, e m
m , y
,
vi e,
c
ombi ton t r , or a f s de i ton of orgi f s or m il di
na i he eof
ny ale sgna i
i n, ale
sea ng
de c i i of f t or f l e orm i l adi r pr ent ton of f t w hi h
s rpton ac , a s
s e ng e es a i
ac , c -
( i l eyt c u ec nf so o t c u emitk , r od c iea t te
A) s i l o a s o u in, r o a s sa e o t e ev s o h
k
a f la i c
f ii ton, onnec i or a s a i of s pe s w ih a t r pe s
ton, s oci ton
uch r on t no he r on,
ora t t org n,s or hi ora ovalofhi orhe goods s r i s
s o he i i pons s p, ppr
s
r
, e vce ,
orc m e ci la tvii by a he pe s or
om r a c i tes
not r r on,
( i c mme ca a v rii o p o to ,mir p e e t t n tl ,
B) n o r il d e tsng r r moi n se rs n s he at e
r
c r t rs i s qualte , or ge a c orgi of hi or he or a her
ha ac e i tc ,
ii s
ogr phi i n
s
r
not
pe s sgoods s vc ,orcommer i ac i tes s l bela ei a cvi
r on'
, er ies
cal tvii , ha l ibl n i l
a ton by a pe s n w ho be i ves t t he or s i or i lke y t be
ci
ny r o
le
ha
he s
s i l o
da age by s h a .
m d
uc ct
1 U. C.jl1 a( )
5 S.
25()1 .
Th s me s to fcs alwi Pli tf t p e alu d r j 1 1 1()wilrs l i
e a e f a t l ng anif o r v i n e
o
1 4( )a l e ut n
rc r unde j 11 Se Babbi El s,38 F. a 11 1( 1h Ci.1
e ovey
r 25. e
t ec .
3d t 8 1 t r 994)(ii Mar hon
ctng at
Mf Co.v Ene lt Pr .Cor ,767 F. 21 21 ( h Ci.1 :9se al Cl r l .v
g.
. rie ods p.
2d 4, 7 5t r 985 e so aiol nc .
Save Wa I s,I . 21 U. P. 459,469- ( D.Fl 1 .tlhi i bec us Se ton
- y ndu . nc, 0 S. Q.
70 S. a. 980) t- s s a e ci
11 ( )i br rt n Se ton 111 i t ti covesf s a rii ordes i i whehe or
25 a s oade ha ci
4 n ha t r ale dve tsng
crpton t r
noti i vesta maki rnge nt'Babbi Elc .38F. a 1181(ii Siv r t Entr.
t nvol rde r nfi me .
'
t e s, 3d t
ctng le sar es,
10
f c v Ad y, 3 F. u p. 6( D. . 1 2 Aswihta e r i rn e n cams tets
n . . a 5 7 S p 23 S. N Y. 98 :.
t r d mak nfig me t li ,h e t
f la lt f f s desg i oforgi unde j43( i as t t rt publci lkeyt be
or ibiiy or ale inaton
in
r
a) s lo ç he he i s i l o
whe
d eve o co us by t sm ia iy oft m a ksatis ' Fw/ Pe os I .v.Taco Cabana,
ec i d r nf ed
he i lrt
he r
s ue.
'
s , nc
l ,505
nc.
763, 780, 11
2
Ct 2753, 763( 2) As dic s d a ve Pli if has
.
199 .
s use bo , antf
s fc e ty s
ufi i n l hown t r i a sr
he e s tong lke i
i lhood of c uson t t ars s be us of t us by
onf i ha i e ca e
he e
Dee d n o te Cha e M aks Th ,Plitf i e t ld t d fu tj g n o is fle
fn a t f h
n l r . us an if s ni e o ea l ud me t n t as
t
de i ton oforgi cai .
sgna i
in lm
I .
V
I JUN C TI E R ELIEF
N
V
Plitf i e tte t te r q se ij n tv r l fpzs a tt 1 U. C.j 1 1 ,1
an if s n ild o h e uetd n u cie ei t u n o 5 S.
e r
16 7
U. C. j 5 2 a d 28 U. C j 6 () A panif s e ig a pema e t ij n to mu t
S.
0, n
S. 1 51a .
litf e kn
r n n n u cin s
d mo srt t a ( )i h ss fe e a irpaa l ij r ( )r me isa lw,s c a mo eay
e n tae h t 1 t a u fr d n re rb e nu y; 2 e d e t a u h s n tr
d ma e ,a ei d q aet c mp n ae f rt tij r ;()c n ie ig t b ln e o h r hp
a g s r na e u t o o e s t o ha n u y 3 o sd rn he aa c f ads i
bewe n pl ntf a dee nt ar medyi eq t i warntd;a ( t tt publci ees
t e ai if nd fnda , e
n uiy s ra e nd 4) ha he i ntr t
wo l n tbedse v d b ap r n n ij n t n. S ee y I c v M e c c a ge L C,5 7
ud o
isr e y ema e t nu ci
o e Ba , n . . r Ex h n , L 4
U.. 8 , 91( 0 6 .
S383 20)
He e, t wel- e a l to and r c d e de e de
r he
lpl d legai ns
e or vi nc
monsr e t t Pli tf has
tat ha a n if
deve ope goodw il a o t c um i publc w hi h woul be under i i D e e nt i
l d
l m ng he ons ng
i
c
d
m ned f f nda s
notpr bie fom f t ri rnge e .Def nda ' c e f i pr t wilc e t ir pa a e
ohi t d r urhe nfi m nt
e nts ountr et oduc s l r a e r e r bl
har a c us on, pari ul ry be us t co t r ei pr
m nd onf i
tc a l ca e he un e f t oduc s bea i ntca m a ki s a
t
r de i l r ng s
Pl ntf ' ge ne m er ha s , a a e not m anuf c ur d t Cha ls qualt s a r .
ai i fs nui
c ndi e nd r
at e o
ne '
iy t nda ds
Fu t nnor D ef nda w il u l i rnged t Chmw lM a ks and c i d t do s eve a t
r he
e, e nt lf ly nf i
he
r
ontnue o
o n fer
s r i oft Am e d Com pl i i t s m a t r u
e v ce he
nde
a nt n hi
te pon i. Suc w il u conduc dem ons r t s a
t
h lf l
t
ta e
lke i
i lhood t tDef ntwoul c i t har Pl i ifsta m a ksi t Cour dec i d t
ha
enda
d ontnue o m antf r de r f he
t lne o
11
is ea ij n to Peme Ex e s 3 6 F.S p 2 1 2223 (n ei p r n n ijmcin
su n n u cin. t d prs , 3
u p. d 2 - e trng e ma e t nt to
u d r1 U. C. 1 1 t p e e tf rh rifi e n o f d rlypr tce ta e r )
n e 5 S. j 1 6 o rv n u te n rng me t f e eal- oe td r d maks.
D AM A G ES
A.
St ut y D am agesf t Us ofC ount r ei M ar
at or
or he e
ef t
ks
I a ca e i vi t us of c e f i m a ks i c
n
s nvol ng he e
ount r e t r n onnec i n w ih a s e,oferng f
to
t
al f i or
s e,o diti i ofg ,1 U. C.j1117c)pr dest tapli ifma el ta a r of
al r srbuton oods 5 S.
( ovi ha antf y ec n wad
sau oy d ma e a a y tme b f r fn lj d me ti r n ee i t sl o no ls ta
tttr a g s t n i eo e ia u g n s e d r d n he t f t e s h n
m
$1000. a no mor t n $200, 00 pe c e f i ma k pe t ofgood. I a ton,i
, 00 nd t e ha
000. r ount ret r r ype
n ddii f
t Cour fnds t t Def nda ' c eretng aci we e w11 1 i m a i pos da a
he
ti
ha
e nts ount f ii
tons r 11 , t y m e m ges
a ve t ma mum lmi up t $2, 000. pe ma k per t of good. 1 U. C. j
bo he xi
i t
o 000, 00 r r
ype
5 S.
1 1 ()2 . sauo ydn g a r i a pr p it i ac s wh r t d f n a t sd futd.
1 7 c () A tt tr ma e wad s p o rae n a e e e he ee d n ha ea le
Se Peme Ex e s,336 F.Supp 2d a 1 9- Ptrua t 15 U. C.j 111 c,Pli if
e t d prs
t 21 22. zs nt o
S.
7() antf
elc st r c ra a r ofsat or damag a t Countloft Ame d Compli t
e t o e ove n wa d t ut y
es s o
he
nde
an .
TheCour haswi dicrto t s a amountofsautr dn ges I at1 9(ii
t
de s ein o et n
tt o y ma . d 21 ctng
Ca l/ me Co ' Cop.v Newo k Pr d,I . 9 2 F.d 8 9 8 2 ( 1h Ci. 1 9 )
b eHo
mmcn r . t r o nc, 0 2 2 , 5 1 t r 9 0
(o cu ig t tt e c u ts d sr t n i sti t e a u to c py ih d ma e i t de
c n ldn ha h o r' icei n et h mo n f o rg t a g s s s ,
o
ng
wi
c tai donl byt s cfe ma maa mi mal)
onsr ne y he pe iid xi nd ni ' .Congr se tdasaut yda ge
es nace tt or ma s
r medy i ta m a k count f tng ca e ,be us evi nc of a de e nts pr s i s h
e
n r de r
ereii
s s ca e de e
f nda ' oft n uc
c es i al t i sbl t a c ran. Se eg. S.REP.NO. 1 1 pt V() ( 995
as s mos mposi e o s e ti
e .,
04- 77, . 7 1 )
( s usi pur es ofLa m Ac saut y da es) Thi ca e i no e pton. Si e
dic sng pos
nha
t tt or mag .. s s s
xce i
nc
Def ntha r f s d t pa tci t i t s ltga i Pl ntf hasbe n de i oft a lt t
enda
s e u e o r i pa e n hi ii ton, ai if
e prved he biiy o
o a n di c r f om i.
bt i s ove y r t
12
$ fndi of wilul i rnge e - oltve c
t i ng
A
lf nfi m ntvi a i onduc t t t de e
t ha he f ndant kne t be
w o
i r p ra d d n i ba fihj tfe a a r o h ihe e d ma e ...'Ch n lI c v
mp o e n o e n d at -usii s n wa d f eg tn d a g s . a e, n . .
'
IainAcie a o o ia I c,9 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( 1h Ci .9 1 . M a i m sauo y
tl
a t we r fFl rd , n . 31 2 4 2 4 6 1 t r 1 9 ) x mu tt tr
v
da ag a r a e pa tc a l a o i t f r tade a k i rnge nt t t i ma ke y
m es wa d r
riulry ppr prae o r m r nfi me ha s r dl
e rgo so i ohe iee e to a. e eg.Mir sf Cop. .Go d n No 10 CV- 9 4
g e iu r s t m s xc p in lSe , . , c o o t r v r o , . :&- 2 3 W SD,2007W L 1 45 6 ( D.Ga.M a 24,2007)(i- Cour beivest tsaut y da
5 21 N.
y
çl
-he
t le ha tt or mage
ma mumss dbers r edf c s sofnotbl s peorpa tc al e egi conduc.)
xi
houl e e v or a e
a e co
riulry gr ous
t'
'
Pl ntf s e t m a mum sa ut y dn a f wilulc
ai if e ks he xi
tt or m ges or lf onduc,$2, 000. pe
t 000, 00 r
m ak c
r ount r e t d. The Co t i e r i e of is s a ut r di c e i de lnes t a a d t
e f ie
ur , n xe c s
t t t o y s r ton, c i
o w r he
a oun Cha l s ks Chane ha pr de sr
m t
ne ee .
l s ovi d tong,undiput e de t t De e nt ha
s ed vi nce ha
f nda
s
e
ngage i w il u c
d n lf l onduc . D e e ntkne i w a w iluly i rngi t Cha lM a ks a i
t
f nda
w t s lf l nf i ng he
ne
r , nd t
e
ngage i c
d n omput rf a by hac ng i t l ii a e we ies f t pur e of r die tng
e r ud
ki n o egtm t bst or he pos
e r ci
c ume st we ie s li goodsbe rng t Cha M a ks Howeve , hef ct asaleg do
ons r o bst s e lng
a i he
nel r .
rt a s
l ed
n t u tf i o ig t e sau o y ma i m. Th e tn a d d rto o De e d n ' we st
o j siy mp sn h ttt r xmu
e x e t n u ain f fn a ts b ie
ha ng i unknown a i i uncl ar ba e on t r or e de ,how t hac ng af e t d t
cki s
nd t s
e , sd
he ec d vi nce
he ki
f c e he
t r pa t w e ie owne s5 Though t l c ofe de e ast e e a dtr ton i a ti a e
hi d- r y bs t
r.
he a k
vi nc
o xt nt nd la i s trbut bl
t De e nts non- ri i ton i dic r Pli if has not pr ded a vi tm-m pa t
o f nda '
pa tcpa i n s ove y, antf
ovi
ny ci i c
e de fom t e vi tmsofwhom Pl i ifwasa r s h a t So he n DititofN e
vi nce r hos ci
antf
wa e, uc s he ut r src
w
Y o k Cour I e pr t r Of i a M AR C, I . A s s h, t r or doe not s
r
t nt r e e s fce nd
nc
uc he ec d
s
uppo t t t
r ha
Def nts c
enda ' onduc w a r nt t s a ut y m a m um .
t r a s he t t or
xi
H ow e r D e e nts us oft r pa t w e iesi agg a tng. Chane has s
ve , f nda ' e hid- ry bs t s r va i
l
uggesed
t
e s w he e a t Cour ha a e t tt a opra e s a ut y a a d i t nor a ca e i
l e r , nd he
t s gr ed, ha he ppr i t t t or w r n he m l s s
5pli ifhasalege t whent r pa te a eno ii t y s ei e t c r tvea ton, butot rtm e t
antf
l d hat
hid- ris r tfed he om tm s ake oreci ci
he i s hey
donot ng.
hi
13
$ ,0 0 p rmakc u tretd.Ch ne I c v7 re ta db g .o No. :2 c 2 0 7 P ,
60 0.0 e r o n efie
a l n . .pef ch n a sc m, 1 1 -v 2 5 - AS
DE 207, 1 (s nelr pe tul s sst Co tc dsa t t abas i oft
p.4. ç
cha es cf ly ugget he ur oul tr wih
elne he
sa u or a r of$1000. te e i t r fe tDef nda s wilul s ,a t n doubl t
tt t y wa d
, 00, r bl t o e l c
e nt ' lf ne s nd he
e he
pr tf t pur eofdeernce.) Defnda ' us oft r parywe ie warnt te e
oduc or he pos
tre '
' e nts e hid- t bsts ra s r bl
da a so rt no m a c e.Ther s two d be$1 000. pe Cha M a k countreied
m ge ve he r l as
e ul ul
8, 00 r nel r
ef t
( pe t ofgoodss d(2 -ha gs walt,s s boot,bels s ase ,wac s
22) r ype
ol 1
ndba , les hoe , s t, ungl s s the ,
ne klc ,br ees e rngs rngs a pr eci co r f pora eel toni de c ) f a
c a es ac lt, ari , i , nd ot tve ves or tbl ecr c vies, or
t a a r a ountof$4, 2, 00.
ot l wa d m
75 000.
V l.
CO N C LU SIO N
Fort r as s a e a
he e ons t t d bove,i i he e
t s r by
ORD ERED THA T
Pli ifs M oi f Enty of Fi lDeful J
antf
ton or r
na
a t udgme ( 1 1i GRANTED.The
nt DE 31 s
Cour s l c ure l e e Fi De a tJ
t hal onc r nty nt r nal f ul udgme a ns De e
nt gai t f ndant
.
DO AND ORDERE i MimiFoiatiJ/ a o
NE
D n a , lrd,hs Rdy f
,04
2 1.
@ r '.
PA TR I A A . TZ
CI
SEI
UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
C*
C.
A 1 Couns lofRec d
l
e
or
14
SCH ED U LE $A '
i '
SU BJE CT D O M AI NA M E S
N
1 1 4s oc c
. 85 t k. om
2. baga i s i c
holc onlne.om
3. bags ac or co
f t y.
4. bagsuc ic
l c . om
5. bags co
oho. m
6. bags e i . o
r plca c
7. basc r plc ne
i -e ia. t
8. basc e ia gsc
i r plc ba .o
9. bas c e i asco
i r plc .
1 besha
0. t ndyba co
g. m
1 . i j wesbz
1 ct e l.i
y
1 ear com
2. pho.
1 eptr e l c
3. ls valey. o
1 e s valey. o.
4. pur e l c uk
1 e s valey. om
5. pur e l c
16. hopvic
es
. om
1 es ba . o
7. pot gs c
1 f hi pi ks c
8. as on c . o
1 f hi e i a
9. as onr plc bagsas a
.i
20. kpur e co
gee
s z.
21 handba m a a. o
.
gs m i
nf
22. ghr plc cc
hi e i a.
23. ohic
hi .om
2 ia hi cksco
4. f s onpi .
25.i e
ge kpur esco
s .
26.i s le c
pur eva l y.o
27.i s le c
pur eva l y.om
28.ie i a
r plc handba . o
gs c
29.it r ha
s a s ndba c
gs.o
3 .e sc b g .
0 j sia a sme
31j wer sgc m
.e ly i .o
3 kuoute . om
2.
l tc
33. hm oda. om .
pos
c co
34.prof t e.
icom net
35. z s valey. s a
plr e l a i
36. ls - l a i
ptr e valey. s a
37. z s - l c
plr e valey. om
38.purs l com .
evaley. co
39.ptrs l hk
l evaley.
40.ptrs l or
l evaley. g
41.ptrs valey. g
l e- l or
42. s valeyhk. om
pur e l
c
43. s valeysne
pur e l . t
44. e r t co
r diec l.
45. e r co
r dix.
46. e w.
r dr co
47. e i gui c
r plca de.o
48. e i potne
r plca . t
49. e i t h. g
r plca ouc or
50. e i a le ne
r plc va l y. t
51.sot com
up.
5 s bagsas a
2. pot . i
53.s bagsco
pot .
5 s bagshk
4. pot .
55. pot . g
s bagsor
5 s bag c
6. pot z. o
57.sa ha
t r ndba . o
gs s
58. t r ha
s a s ndbagsco
.
5 s r t r nd gs c
9. upe s a ha ba . o
60. a adi s c
t l e . om
61 tw s or . om
. i t ec
62.upoox.
com
63.
vobbov.om
c
64. w- s va ly.om
ww pur e le c
65.
yodue. m
co
16
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?