UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. Secretary Department of Corrections et al

Filing 756

ORDER granting in part 753 Motion to Vacate And Terminate Injunction. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 1/9/2019. See attached document for full details. (vmz)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O U RT
C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
C A SE N O .1 22958- I - TZ
2C V SEI
UN I
TED STA TES OF AM ER I ,
CA
Pl nt f ,
ai i f
VS.

SECRETARY,
FLORI DEM RTMENT QF col crl
DA
c r oxs

a dFLOmD: DEP
n
ARTMENToycolu crl
t roNs,
D e e nt .
f nda s

O RD ER G R AN TI G I PA R T M O TI N TO V A CA TE A N D TE RM I A TE
N N
O
N
I JU N CTI N
N
O

THI M ATTER i be o èt Cour u t pa te 'J ntM oton t Vac t t sCour'
S
s f r he
t pon he ris oi
i o
a e hi
ts

Or e a d Te naeOusa dngIj n to ( 7 3 .Th pa t ss e t v c t teCo r'
d r n nni t ttn i n u ci n DE 5 j e ri e k o a ae h u ts
e
Fi l u g n a dPe n n Ijmcin e tr do Aug t1 , 01 ( 5 ) whc ()
na J d me t n nna e t nt to ne e n us 2 2 5 DE 48, ih 1
deca e t tDe e ntspolc ofde ngkos rm e st prs r wih snc r r i i
lr d ha f nda ' iy
nyi
he al o ione s t i e e elg ous

beif voae t ReiiusLa Us a dI siui n lz dPe s nsAc o 2 0 ( UI ; 2
les iltd he lg o nd e n n t to aie r o
t
t f 0 0 RL PA) ()
de l e t tc ran pori nsofDe e nt pr pos pl f rofe i kos rm e l t
car d ha e ti
to
f nda s' o ed an o f rng he a s o

prs nesas v oae RIUI I n ( )e trdt ePe ma e t nu to Th Ij ncin
io r lo i ltd , PA;a d 3 n ee h r n n Ij ncin. e nu to
o de e De e nt t pr dekos rme st al prs r wih asnce er lgi bassf
r r d f nda s o ovi
he al o l ione s t i r e i ous i or

ke pigko h r e j i dDee d n sfo e f r igt epo t n o t i p a t a teCo r h d
e n s e , n one fn a t r m n o cn h ri s f her ln h t h u t a
o
de a edi vi ai n o RLUI a s tup polc e a pr dur sf re or i t
clr n olto f
PA, nd e
ii s nd oce e o nf c ng he

lj n to W hi ii no e trl ce rfo t e pate ' to ,ta p a st the se t
nu cin. l t s t niey la r m h ris moi n i p e r ha t y e k o
e
v c t t e tr o d r no j t h p rine tbihngt Pe ma e tljmci n Und rte
a ae he n ie r e , tus t e o t sa ls i he r n n n t to . e h
o
l
specik aly, t Cour f
t l he
t ound t tDef
ha
endant zer t er ncepolc t pe centnze,and r es
s' o ol a
iy, en r
l
ul
whih r oved prs r fom t pr a w ihouta oppol t t c e tr
c em
ione s r he ogr m t
n
tuniy o ont s emovalvi at RLUI
ol ed
PA.

P io Liiain Reo m Ac I LRAI 1 U. C.j3 2 ,hepa t saee t ldt tr n to
rs n tg to f r t P
, 8 S.
6 6 t ri r ni e o e miain
e
t

o t eIj ncin.Ho v r t eCo u d cie t va aet e tr o d r
f h nu to
we e ,h t. e ln s o c t he n ie r e .
t
Th PLRA sae t a Gina ycvia to wihrs e tt p io c n iin i whc
e
tts h t l l n i l cin t e p c o rs n o dto s n ih
g
pr pe tver le i o de ed,s h r le s lbetr na eupon t m o i o a y pa t 't
os c i ei f s r r uc ei f hal e mi bl
he ton f n ry' wo

ye r a trt Cou thasgrntdt pr peci rle 18U. C.j3626( ( ) Unde j
as fe he r
a e he os tve eif
S.
b)1 .
r

3 2 ( )3 , c u t yno tr naep o pe t er le i i fn t tS r s e tv rle
6 6 b ( ) a o r ma t e mi t r s ci eif f t ds ha ç o p ci e eif
v
p
r m ansnec s ar t c r cta c r nta o ng vi l ton oft Fede a rght' TheEl ve h
e i
e s y o ore
ure nd ngoi
oai
he
rl i '
e nt
Cic tha he dt tç Gtr e a ong ng'vi a i i avi ai t te ssa t tm et
r ui s l ha 1 clr nt nd oi
a
olton s ol ton ha xit t he i he

dsrc c u t o d cst ej3 2 1 3 i u r , n no apoe ta f t ev oain. Ca o v
itit o r c n u t h 6 64 ) nq iy a d t tn il uur i lto ? s n .
9(
'
S c ige , 31F.d7 7 7 4( 1h Ci. 0 0 .Th s te ei n t ( t rn a d o ong'
e kn r 2 3 7 , 8 1 t r 2 0 ) u ,h r s o a i l e t n ng i '
cr
vi ai n i t r i onl apot nta f , e n alkelhood of a f t evi a i I a 783.
ol to f he e s y
e i l or or ve i i
, u ur olton. d t
De e
f ndan m a nti ,a t Gover ntcmc s t tt r i no c r nta o ng
t i a ns nd he
nme c ur , ha he e s
ure nd ngoi
vi a i Gi n t tneihe sdea guest tt r i a c r e a ongoi vi a i a t r i
olton. ve ha t r i r
ha he e s u r nt nd
ng olton nd he e s

no r c devi nc t t co r r a m o et n t yea sha pas e sncet e r oft
e or
de e o he nta y, nd r ha wo r ve s d i he nty he

Pe ma n Ij n to t eM oin t Te mi t t eIjmcini g a td.
r ne t nu cin,h to o r nae h nt to s r ne
W h l t eCou t ltr n t tePema e tIjmcin i wil o v c t tee t e
ie h
r wil e miae h r n n nl to ,t l n t a ae h ni
r
or r The pa te ha gi n t Cour no r a o t vac t t tD e l r t l J
de .
r i s ve ve he
t e s n o a e ha c a a o y udgm e pori
nt ton

oft or r The PLRA onl add e s t r nai ofpr pe tver i for r d by t Co t i
he de .
y r s es e mi ton
os ci ele de e
he ur; t
doesnota es ot rf
ddr s he onns ofr le Fur he ,whie D e e nt 'c r ntR e i i D i
ei f
t r
l f nda s ur e
lg ous et
Pr n polc s a est ti G st polc oft D e r m e ofCor e i nst a l d i a esa
ogr m
i y t t ha t i he i y he pa t nt
i
r cto o fbr nm t
r as bl o
e ona e ppor u ' t obs r e t i r lg ous di tpr f r nc s ...w ihi t cons r i s o
t niy o e v he r e i i
t
e eee e
t n he
t a nt f

budge lmia i a ... e ury 't polc doe notr cog z t tt De rm e of
t i t tons nd s c i 'he i y s
e nie ha he pa t nt
Core tonsha al alr ponsbiiyt do s Se DE 75 3 a 2.Gi n t tt de a a i
r ci
s eg es i lt o
o. e
3- t
ve ha he clr tons
2

ma i t Decar t y J
de n he
l aor udgme pori n oft Cour' o de r m an ac ur t sa e
nt to
he
ts r r e i c a e tt ment oft
s he
lw,al t pa te ha nota gue ot l ie t Cour wilno va t t spori oft
a rd he ris ve
r d hew s , he
t l t cae hi
ton he

Au us 1 , 01 Fna J d me t n Pe ma e tIjmcin.
g t 2 2 5 i l u g n a d r n n nt to
A c or ng y,i i
c di l t s
.

ORDERED t tt pà te J ntM oto t Va at t sCour' Or ra Te mi t
ha he ri s' oi
i n o c e hi
ts de nd r nae

Ousa d n Ij n to ( 7 3 i GRANTED i p r a dDENI i p r:
ttn i g nu cin DE 5 ) s
n at n
ED n a t
a Th M oi nt Temi t Ou sa dngIj ncin i GRANTED.The
) e to o r nae ttn i nu to s
Pema e tIj n to i teCo r' Au u t1 , 1 Fia J d me ta d
r n n n u cin n h u ts g s 2 20 5 n l u g n n
Pe n n Ij n to i TERMI
nna e t nu cin'
s
NATED.
b Th M oi nt Va aei DENI
) e to o c t s
ED.

JG

oo ado ostoiMimipoiahsF dyoJ ur 21.
xs n R l n a ,'r ti
s
ld
a f as 09
#

t

PA TRI A .SE1 Z
CI
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD
CC*

A1 Cot e ofRe or
1 ms l
c d

3