Centeno v. I & C Earthmovers Corp. et al
Filing
166
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 109 Motion for Imposition of Liquidated Damages; denying 137 Motion to Amend/Correct ; granting in part and denying in part 139 Motion for Sanctions. Signed by Magistrate Judge John J. O'Sullivan on 2/3/2014. (mkr)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SO UTHERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
Case No.1: CV12- 23097- '
O SULLI N
VA
I
CONSENTJ
OMA R DEL CARM EN VALLE CENTENO ,
NESTO R JO SE M EJI OBANDO ,and aI
A
I
o her smi l st t un 29 U. C. 6( ,
t si ly i i
ar ua on der
S. 21 B)
Pl ntl
ai i
VS.
I EARTHM OVERS CO R P. LEONEL
&c
,
GARC I and CARLOS M .GARCI ,
A
A
Def
endant
s
/
O RDER
THI MATTER i bef e t Cour on t Pl ntfs'Moton f I posii of
S
s or he
t he ai if
i or m
ton
Lqui ed Damag ( # 1 1 / 8 1 ) t e De endan ' Mo i f Remii o
i dat
es DE 09, 0 1 / 3 , h f
t t or
s on
tt f
t ur
Damag I op l Awar f Tr el me ( 1 1 / / 3)an t
es mpr er
y
ded or av Ti DE# 37, 2 26 1
d he
Def dans' t f Sanci s an Ator y Fees( 1 1 27 1 . s
en t Mo i or
on
ton d t ne
DE# 39, 2/ / 3) The e
m otons ar addr
i
e
essed bel
ow.
ANALYSI
S
1.
De endanh 'Moton f Sanc i and A/or Fee ( 13 12 2 1
f
i or
tons
ney s DE# 9, / 7/ 3)
On Ocober1 201 f lwi a t r - ti ,hej yr ed a v diti
t
7, 3, ol ng h ee day r t ur each
o
al
er c n
f v oft e pl ntf an agai tt e de en t See Ver c For ( 1 8,
a or h ai is d
f
ns h f dan s.
dit m DE# 0
1 / 8 1 ) As p tofi v dit t j ya d pl n i Ne t J e Me i Oba
0 1 / 3 . ar t er c, he ur war ait f s or os j
s
f
a
ndo
( er n fer' j '$ 3 0 i u ai ov t wages Th de end s a k,n er
h eia t $ i ) 45,60.0 n np d eri
Me a'
me
. e f ant s it
al t att e Cour ex cs i i er tpo i or t puns Mr Mei f f s y
i h h
a,
t er ie t nh en wer n der o ih . ja or alel
s
t tf ng atdeposii and atti t he was unem pl
es iyi
ton
ral hat
oyed f t m ont aferhe was
or wo
hs t
f e b t e de en t . Def dan s Mo i f San t s andAtor ey F (
i d y h f dan s See en t ' ton or c i
r
on
t n ees DE#
1 ,1 / / 3)
39 2 27 1 .
Atti Mr Me i f s y t t i t the ha b unempl e f t mon h
ral . j alel es ied ha
a
f
d een
oy d or wo
ts
aferhe was fr by t def
t
ied
he endant
s:
Q.
Di yourIe change afert s frng?
d
i
f
t hi ii
Di you l sl
d
ose eep?
Di i afectyourf i Ie i any ot way t you woul wantt t l he
dt f
am l i n
y f
her
hat
d
o elt
j r abou ?
uy
t
Ofcour i i a taum a t f t you have been fr afer
se t s r
o eel hat
ied t
wor ng seven year al
ki
s, mostei y s ata com pany,and you ar
ght ear
e
afeced bec s a t t t I
f t
au e, fer ha , was wih aj f G o m on hs.
t out ob or
t
Q.
How di you f durng t
d
eel i hose t m ont
wo
hs?
A.
Thatr l - Im ean,you even I sl
eal
y
ose eep.You ar stessed.
e r
Pr em s wih t f i To know t on Frdays,atI ,Iused
obl
t he am l
y.
hat
i
east
t send m oney t m y m om ,and my chi en,and Icoul tdo
o
o
l
dr
dn'
t f G o m ont Ieven have a daught w ho was atendi
hat or
hs.
er
t ng
col
l and Ihad t have herwihdr fom col
ege
o
t aw r
l
ege.
Q.
How di t m ak you f ?
d hat
e
eel
A.
Em otonal t ' som et ng t r l m oves you w hen you have
i l hats
y,
hi hat eal
y
a sal y,and t you cannotr ve any m oney,you f r l
ar
hen
ecei
eel eal
y
bad.
***
Q.
Durng t
i hose t m ont aferyou wer fr wer you I ng f
wo
hs t
e ied, e
ooki or
wor
k?
A.
Obvou y. woul go ou t Iokf aj
i sl I d
t o o or ob.
Q.
You fnal f
i l ound one aboutG o m ont aAeryou wer fr
y
hs
e ied,
rght
i ?
A.
Yes.
***
2
A.
l we cal at fom Sept ber when Iwas fr untl oday,Ido
f
cul e r
em ,
ied, it
have a l
oss.
Q.
How m uch i t I
s hat oss?
A.
Onl t G o mont s t I s w ihoutaj I woul be
y he
h hat wa t
ob.t
d
$8, Two mont w ihoutwor
000.
hs t
k.
***
Q.
I I had been payi you t overi e t t owed you
f &C
ng
he
tm hat hey
com par t whatyou wer m aki t
ed o
e
ng oday,do you know how m uch
addii
tonaleconom i I t woul have been f you?
c oss hat
d
or
A.
AtI tlwoul have $26, ofI
eas
d
800 oss.
Q.
Can you r
epeatt num ber
hat
?
$2 8 The G o m ont w ihouta j an fom Sep emb t
6,00.
hs t
ob d r
t er o
Oct
obermaki $1I
ng ess.
Q.
That t num bert y have cal at
' he
s
hat ou
cul ed?
Yes.
Tral an r ( 1 a 78,8 8 112 1 )(
i Tr sc i DE# 29 t
pt
0, 4, / 4/ 3 emph i adde . hi depost
ass
d) At s
ion
i
on Dec er20,
emb
2013,ol wig ti , . jat t i t athi sar d e wi
f l n ralMr Me i es ied h s t t at t
o
f
h
Sou h t n wasSep ember25, 2. Dep ion ( 1 - at7,1 1 1 .Mr
t easer
t
201 See ost DE# 60 2
i
/ 4/ 4) .
Mei wa f e fom t s empl ment t t e def dan son Sept b 20, 2. e
j s i d r hi
a
r
oy
wi h
h
en t
em er 201 Se
Tr Tr c it( 1 a 71 77,112 1 ) Th Mr Mei s ti t t y t the
i ans rp DE# 29 t ,
al
/ 4/ 3 . us, . ja' rales i
mon ha
was unem pl
oyed f t m ont afert def
or wo
hs t he endant fr hi i f se.
s ied m s al
W hen t e i bad f t conducti t cour oft I i i t coul be
her s
aih
n he
se he igaton hat
t
d
adequat y sanctoned undert r es,t Coud or narl shoul r y on t r es
el
i
he ul he
di i
y
d el
he ul
r hert t i entpoweroft Cour,buti i t i or ed di eton oft
at han he nher
he
t
f n he nf m
scr i
he
Cour,neiherst ut norr es ar up t t
t t
at e
ul
e
o ask,t Coud m ay saf y r y on i i ent
he
el el
t nher
s
3
po . amb sv.NASCO,Ic. 501 U. 32,50 ( 991 . Cou s iher tp
wer Ch er
n .
S.
1 ) The d' n en ower
i der edfom t n 'o mana I s own a f r so a t achev t or eryan
s i r he eed '
v
t
ge i l
t
fai
s s o i e he d l d
ex ediousdipo t ofc s 'I at ( er ct ton an quo at mars
p t
i
s sion a es. d. 49 i nal i i s d t i
i
'
nt
a
on k
omied) Th ' d' i er tp
t . e'
t
Cou s nh en owers l be e cied wi c tonand i
houd
xer s
t au i
h
t
s
i
nvocaton r r a fndi ofbad f t 'Kor
i equies i ng
aih.
' nhauserv.Com m ' ofSoc.Sec. 685 F.
r
,
3d
1 4,1 7 ( t Ci. 2 . ee alo Bar esv.Dal 1 F.d 1 2, 21 ( 1 h Ci.
25 25 11h r 201 ) s
,
s
n
t 58 3 21 1 4 1 t r
on,
1
998)(Th k t unl kn ( c s i er tp
' e ey o oc ig t oud' nh en oweri a fn n ofba f t n.n
he)
s idig
d ai ) l
h.
exer si is i entpower t Cour tm ustcom pl wih t m andat ofdue
ci ng t nher
, he
t'
d
y t he
es
pr
ocess,bot i det m i ng t t r sie bad f t exi s and i assessi f '
h n er ni hat he equi t
aih st
n
ng ees.'
'
By n v. zh , F. d 10 11 ( 1 h Ci.
r e Ne at 261 3 75, 06 1 t r 2001 ( t Ch
) cing amber ,501 U. at
i
s
S.
50 .
)
Th Coud r j t Mr Me i s ex ana in t the i a si e c s r c i worer
e
eec s . j
a' pl to ha s mpl on tu t
on k
and t hi i
hat s naccur e t i ony was due t conf on,m i ak ora f t mem or
at estm
o
usi
st e
auly
y.
See Pl ntf' Response i Opposii t Def
ai ifs
n
ton o
endant M oton f Sanctons and
s' i or
i
Ator ey F ( 1 at7 8,17 1 . e ti qu t i no so f a t at
t n ees DE# 43 - / / 4) The ven n es i s t ong go h
on
Mr Me i woud h e di i t r alng i. eov , e wasabl t t s i i de aia
. ja l av f cul ec l t Mor er h
f y
i
e o e ty n t l t
f
ti ast o h ev st tt pl e sh y be or orafert i t p id. . j s
r
al o t er ent ha ook ac odl f e
t hs i er Mr Me i
me o
a'
f se t i ony was al notdue t conf on orm i ake.He t ii specii l t
al estm
so
o
usi
st
estfed
fcal hat
y
he was unabl t send m oney t hi m ot and chi en f t m ont and t hi
e o
o s
her
l
dr or wo
hs
hat s
dau t wa f c t wi dr w fom c lge asa r l o Mr Me i sun lymen .
gh er s ored o t a r ol
h
e
esut f . j
a' empo
t
See Tr Tr c it( 1 a 78,1 / 4/ 3) Th e i no i c ton i t e tans r t
i ans rp DE# 29 t
al
1 2 1 . er s ndia i n h r c i
p
t atMr Me i wasc f s ordi n tun s an t qu t .I f c , e r t dl
h
. ja
on u ed
d o dert d he es i n a t h epea e y
on
and consi enty t ii t t s t m ont perod ofunem pl ent The specii t wih
st l estfed o hi woh
i
oym
.
fci t
y
4
whih Mr Me i r on t t qu t p ed byhi c s c er ng hi
c . j esp ded o he es i os
a
ons
s oun el onc ni s
unem pl entconvi
oym
nces t Cour t hi r
he
t hat s esponses wer delber e and i ended t
e i at
nt
o
mil t ej y
sead h ur .
Th Cour fn b cearand c vi ig evdenc t atMr Mei I t t j r
e
t ids y l
on ncn i e h
. j i o he u y
a ed
when he t ii t he was unem pl
estfed hat
oyed f t m ont aferhe was fr by t
or wo
hs t
ied
he
de end t See Tr Tr s it( 1 a 78, 8 1124/ 3) s a. .Me i s
f an s.
i an cr DE# 29 t 80, 4, / 1 , upr Mr j
al
p
a'
mi
sconductcons iut bad f t and i sanctonabl undert Coud' i entpower
tt es
aih
s
i
e
he
s nher
.
l f ,'he i entpower docti i m ostofen i ed wher a pady com m is
n act ' nher
t
s
rne s
t nvok
e
t
p j yorde to s ordocor evdenc 'Qan um Commcn Cor v. arBr d. lc.
erur
sry
t s i e.
' t
's p. St oa , n ,
473 F.Sup 2 1
p. d 249,1 ( D. a.20 )( i ton omied) Th Cour f erfn
269 S. Fl 07 ct i s t . e
a
t
t udh ids
t at he ap opr e s c i f Mr Me i sm ic
h t
pr i an t or . ja' s ondu ti t STRI M r Me i s a d
at
on
c so
KE . j war
a'
f r al i of$50, f pastand f ur ment pai and suferng.The def
or et i on
at
000 or
ut e
al n
f i l
endant
s
ar al entted t an awar ofator s f butonl as i r at t t flng oft
e so il o
d
t ney' ees
y t el es o he i
i
he
Def dan s Mo i f Sanci s an Ator eyFees ( 1 1 27 1 . I iher t
en t ' t or
on
ton d t n
DE# 39, 2/ / 3) 'l n en
l
power m us be exer sed w ih r r ntand di eton .... prm ar aspectoft
s
t
ci
t estai
scr i
A i y
hat
di eton i t abit t f on an appr i e sanctona Cham ber 501 U. at44
scr i s he ly o ashi
i
oprat
i '
'
s,
S,
(n er al i i omied) The Cou t le er s i dic e i an d t e
it n ct on t .
at
t
r wi x cie t s r ton d eny h
l
s
def
endant r
s' eques s f addii
t or
tonalr i and f sanctons underFeder Rul ofCi l
el
ef
or
i
al e
vi
Pr
ocedur 37.
e
1I t rm oton, t def
n hei
i he endanssat t asas t Mr Mei '
t t e hat
anci
on, . ja ' d bebared
shoul
r
f om an awar ofdam ages f back wages,em otonal
r
d
or
i dam ages,and fontw ages. The i e o
r
'
'
ssu f
f on wages and back w ages w as r ved b t e pari i a pari s tem ent See Joi t
r t
esol
y h
t n
es
t etl
al
.
n
Stt Repod ( # 1 at2,127 1 . Cour hasr e andappr t ts t
aus
DE 62
/ / 4) The
t
eviwed
oved ha etl t
emen.
See Or Appr ngSetl
der ovi
t
ementAgr
eement( 165,130/4) The$9, f I tback
DE#
/ 1 .
020 oros
wagesawar b t j yt Mr Mejawasnegotat byt pari t $5, andwi notbe
ded y he ur o . i
i ed he tes o 300
l
l
di t bed by t s Coud.
s ur
hi
5
2.
Pl nt/s'Moton f I
ai i
i or mposii ofLi da ed Damages ( # 1 1 1 / )
ton
qui t
DE 09, 0/ 8 13
The pl ntfs seek t r
ai i
f
o ecoverI dat dam ages agai tt def
i
qui ed
ns he endant
s
pur an t 2 U. C. 21 b) See Pl n i s Mo i f I osion ofLi da ed
su t o 6 S. j 6( .
ait f ' ton or mp t
f
i
qui t
Da es ( # 1 a 1,1 / 8 1 ) W i r pec t pl n i OmarDeI menVal
mag DE 09 t 0 1 / 3 . t es t o ait f
h
f
Car
l
e
Ceneno, h pl n is s ek at al d o $90, 0 ( 45, i unp d o edi pls
t t e ait f e
f
ot awar f 72 $ 360 n ai v me u
$ 3 i l da ed damag ) I a 2. i r pe tt pl n i Me i t e pl n is
45,60 n i t
qui
es .d. t W t es c o ait f j h ait f
h
f
a,
f
i t ls
nial ough a t al war o $1 7 ( 45, 60 i un d o eri pl $9,202i
iy
t ot a d f 58,60 $ 3 n pai v t
me us 0 n
ba wag pls $5 38 i t ali i t d d
ck es, u 4, 0 n ot I da e amagespls $5 000 f r t iton .d.
qu
u 0, or e al i ) I
a
The def
endant oppose t r i r
s
he el equest i pad,
ef
ed,.
q
because t cl m t have
hey ai hey
.
satsfed t rbur ofpr ng good f t t baran i posii ofI dat dam ages.
i i hei den
ovi
aih o
m
ton i
qui ed
See De en ts)Res ons i Oppo t t Plit f Mo i f Lquda e Dama
f dan l ' p e n
sion o an i ' ton or i i t d
i
fs
ges
( 1 a 1 1 26 1 ,
DE# 38 t , 2/ / 3)
The appl e l i welest i
i
cabl aw s l abl
shed.' em pl erwho vi at t pr si
'
Any
oy
ol es he ovi ons
ofs c i 206 I nmum wa )ors t 20 Iv t wage )oft i t l sh l e
et
on
mii
ges eci 7 o eri
on
me
s hs ie alb
t
l e t t em pl
i
abl o he
oyee orem pl
oyees afect i t am ountoft runpai m i m um
f ed n he
hei
d ni
wages,ort runpai ovedi e com pensaton,as t case m ay be,and i an
hei
d
m
i
he
n
addional
t equal
i
amoun a I da ed dama . 29 U. C.j 21 b)(
tsi t
qui
ges'
'
S.
6( empha sadd ;
si edl
s alo Rodr z v Far St es Gr er .lca 51 F. 1
ee s
i
aue . m or
oc v n , 8 3d 259,1 2 ( t Ci 2008 .
27 11 h r
.
)
Ii i
t s mpodan t no e t at'al emply who s st a oi I dat damag b s
to t h ' n
I
o er
eek o v d i
qui ed
es ear
t bur
he
den ofpr ng t is vi aton was bot i good f t and pr cat upon such
ovi hat t ol i
hn
aih
edi ed
r
easonabl gr
e ounds t i woul be unf rt i pose upon hi m or t a
hat t
d
ai o m
m
e han
com pensat y ver c . Dvbach v.St e ofFl Dent ofCor. 942 F. 1562,1566
or
dit'
'
at
a.
.
r,
2d
2see f not 1,suor
oot e
a
.
6
( t Ci 1 ) Her t ej ys ic l f nd 'th tt e d en s ei erkn w or
11h r 991 . e, h ur pecf al ou 'l a h ef dant t
.
i y
l
h e
s owed r kes di egar f t e ma t of et eri I c c du t pr bt b
h
ec l s sr d or h
ter wh h t si) on c was ohii y
s
ed
t e Fai Lab St dar Ac . See Ver c For ( 1 a 2,1 / 8 1 ) A 'ur '
h
r or an ds t'
'
dit m DE# 08 t 0 1 / 3 . j ys
fndi ofwif ness deprves t di rctcour ofany di eton t r
i ng
lul
l
i he sti
t
scr i o educe I dat
i
qui ed
damages based on is own fndi ofgood f t 'Al ez Per v.Sanf d- rando
t
i ng
aih. var
'
ez
or o l
Kenn Cl Ic. 51 F. 11 0,1 66 ( t Ci.2 ) Th pl n i sar en ied t
el ub. n , 5 3d 5 1 11 h r 008 . e ait f e t l o
f
t
I da ed dama on alcai wi t e ex ep i o t e $9,203a ded t Mr Me i
i t
qui
ges
I l ms t h c ton f h
h
0
war o . j
a
f l back wages on hi r al i cl m .
or ost
s et i on ai
at
3.
Def
endants M oton f Rem i t ofDam ages I pr
'
i or
hiur
m opery Aw ar
l
ded f
or
Tr Ti e ( 13 12 26 1
avel m DE# 7, / / 3)
Th d en sf
e ef dant udhers t r e t e amoun awar byt e j r at r on
eek o educ h
t
ded h u y ti
al
t e gr dst t ( )t e pl n i sf ld t es a i t ren iemen t tav tme
h oun ha : 1 h aitf ai o t bl hei t l t o r eli
f e
sh
t
un t e lw; 2)Mr Me i wi dr hi cai f ta el i i i en i y an ( M r
der h a ( . j t ew s l m or r v t n t tr
a h
me s
et d 3) .
Me i admied he wa n en iedt tav t a t 201 See De endan ' Mot f
ja
t
t
s ot t l o r el i fer 0.
t
me
f
t
s i or
on
Rem ii o Damag I op l Awar ed f Tr v Ti ( 1 at12,1 / 6/ 3)
tt f
t ur
es mpr er
y
d or a el me DE# 37 - 2 2 1 .
The El ent Cicui has hel t a Coud m ustgr a '
ev h r t
d hat
ant ' ti orr itt when t
new ral em tiur
he
awar ex ee t e maxmu l io a r onabl r e wi nwhc t ej yma
d c ds h
i m i t f eas
m
e ang t
hi ih h ur y
pr eryop at 'W arenv.For Mo orCr di Co.693 F.d 1 73,1 ( 1h Ci
op l er e.
r
d t et ,
2 3
380 1 t r
.
1 ) Th El en h Ci i alo f lwst 'un
982 . e ev t r t s ol
cu
o he ' damen al i i e . . h t e f cf
t pr pl . t at h a t
nc
fnderdet m i t quant ofdam ages i ci lcases. Hawkes v.Ayer 537 F.
i
er nes he
um
n vi
'
'
s,
2d
3As not above, t s am ountwas nego i ed an r
ed
hi
tat
d educ byt pari t $5,
ed he t o 300.
es
SeeSetl tAgr
temen eement( 1 1,1/ 1 .TheCourwi notl daet sr ed
DE# 62- 27/4)
t l i t hi educ
l qui
amount.
7
83 8 ( t Ci.1 76)( ercur . 'ngen ala r ti or r cig aj r '
6, 37 5 h r 9 p
i 4'
aml I er , emi t der edu n u ys
t ur
a d t t ou erI io t pr fi t e a opr t r
war o he t i t f he oo s h ppr i e emed wh e t e j ysdamage
m
a
y er h ur'
awar exceeds t am ountes abl
d
he
t i
shed by t evi
he dence. Gol ei v.M anhatan
' dst n
'
t
Idus .nc , F. 1
n . l . 758 2d 435,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ) I t is an c e, h pl n is
448 1 t r 985 .n he n t t as t e ait f
f
c r t eibur enofpr fast t e amoun ofhour t ywored. eov , h j y
ari h r d
ed
oo
oh
t
s he
k Mor er t e ur
coul have ari att sum s awar t each pl ntf f unpai overi e wihout
d
rved he
ded o
ai if or
d
tm
t
f orng i any tavel i e.Accor ngl t r
act i n
r
tm
di y, he equestf r it uri DENI
or em ti s
t
ED.
CO NCLUSI N
O
Based on t f egoi i i
he or ng, t s
ORDERED AND ADJUDG ED t t Def
hat he
endant M oton f Sanctons and
s' i or
i
Ator eyFees ( 1 1 27 1 i GRANTED i p tand DENI i pad. e
tn
DE# 39, 2/ / 3) s
n ar
ED n
Th
j ysawar of$50,00 f pas an f t e men al ai an s fer on Mr Me i s
ur '
d
0 or t d u ur
t p n d uf i
ng
. j
a'
r alaton cl m i STRI
et i i ai s
CKEN and VACATED.The Cour w i gr ator s f t
t l ant t ney' ees o
l
t def
he endant r at onl t t flng oft sanctons m oton.The def
s el ed y o he i
i
he
i
i
endant shal
s
l
atem ptt r v t am ountofator s f wih t pl ntfs'
t
o esole he
t ney' ees t he ai i counsel l t ar
f
. f hey e
unabl t r ve t m ater t def
e o esol he
t , he endant shal fl t rm oton f ator s f
s
l ie hei
i or t ney' ees
al wih suppori document i no I ert Frday,Febr y 28,2014.I i
ong t
tng
aton
at han i
uar
ts
f
udher
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t t Pl ntfs'Moton f I posii of
hat he ai if
i or m
ton
Li da e Damage ( # 1 1 / 8/ 3)i GRANTED i p tand DENI i p
qui t d
s DE 09, 0 1 1 s
n ar
ED n ad.
4 The El h Cic ti Bonnerv.Ci ofPrchar 661F.2d 1
event rui n
t
v
i d,
206,1 ( t Ci.
207 11h r
1 )( banc ,
981 en
) adopt aspr eden decii o t f merFit Cicuir
ed
ec t sons f he or
fh r t ender prort
ed i o
O ct
ober1,1981.
8
The pl nt#s ar entted t I dat dam ages f t roveri cl m s. t pl ntf
ai i
e il o i
qui ed
or hei
tme ai As o ai i
f
OmarDe1 menVal Cen eno, h Cour wi eneraj dgmen i t e amoun o
Car
l
e t te
t l t u
l
tn h
tf
$9 720 ( 45,60 i unp d o edi pl $45, i I i t d damages . t
0, $ 3 n ai v me us
360 n i da e
qu
) As o
pl n i Me i t e Coud wi ent aj gmenti t e amoun o $9 720 ( 45,60 i
aitf j h
f a,
l er ud
l
nh
t f 0, $ 3 n
unp d ov me pls $ 3 i I dat damag ) I i f t
ai edi u 45,60 n i
qui ed
es .t s urher
ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t t Def
hat he
endants M oton f Rem it urof
'
i or
ti
t
Dam ages I pr
m opery Awar f Tr v Ti (
l
ded or a el me DE# 1 7,1 2 1 )i DENI
3 2/ 6/ 3 s
ED.
n
s
a , or hi d
uar
DONE AND O RDERED i Cham ber atM i i Fl a t s r da ofFebr y,
r
2014.
e
t
JOH .
LI
VAN
UNI
TED STAT S MAG I
STRATE JUDGE
Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
AIcounselofr d
I
ecor
9
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?