JMA, Inc. et al v. Biotronik SE & Co. KG

Filing 174

ORDER denying 155 Motion to Strike Defendant Biotronik's Purported Lost Profit Expert Damages Analysis. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 9/18/2014. (ls)

UN I
TED STA TES D I I CO URT
STR CT
SOU THERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CASE N O.1 CV2- 23466- TZ/
SEl TURNOFF
J A ,l C . e a .
M
N , t l,
Pl i i f ,
a ntf s

BI
OTRONI SE & CO. ,e a .
K
KG. t l,
Def nda s
e nt .
/
O R DE R D EN YI G M O T I N TO ST RI E D AM A G ES AN A LY SI
N
O
K
S

Thi materi be or t Cour onPl i if 'M oton t Sti Def ntBi r ni s
s t s f e he
t
antfs
i o rke enda
oto k'

P po tdLo tP ok Ex r Da g sAnay i ( 1 5 .Plitfss e t srk ao epa e
u re s r f pe t ma e
lss DE- 5 ) an if e k o ti e n g
d c n t a Dee d n ' 3 b ( )rp ee ttv d s rb d a a S xp r a ay i'd rngh s
o ume t h t fn a ts 0()6 e r sn aie e c ie s n s et n lss' u i i
e
d poston.Theonepag doc e i a s
e ii
e um nt s umm a y oft l tpr i da a s
r
he os oft m ges oughtby Bi r ni
oto k.

Pl ntfsse t srket doclme onf l ounds: )i i a untmeye r rpor;2)i i
ai if e k o ti he l nt our gr
(1 t s n i l xpe te t( t s

s e ultv ;3 isprj dieo t ih a yprbaiev l eu d rFe e a Rueof ie c 4 3;
p c ai e ( ) t eu c u weg s n o tv au n e d rl l Evd n e 0
a ( ii i
nd 4) t s nadmisbl unde Fe r Rul ofEvi nc 1
si e
r deal e
de e 006.Ha ngc i rdt
vi onsdee he
a gume s t Cour wilde t moton wih la t r ie t ls ar m e a n prort
r
nt , he
t l ny he i
t e ve o a s he a t gu nt gai i o
ti .
ral

Thedocu e i nota untm ey e tr por be a e i waspr par d i hous b
m nt s
n i l xper e t c us t
e e n- e y

Bitoni no a e r.Se DE- 55- a 63: - M eeybec us Bitoni s30( (
or k, t n xpet e I 3 t 2123. rl a e or k' b)6)
r pr s nt tve m a ha ca l d i a d pe ta l i ' doesnotm a i s unde t Fe r
e e e ai
y ve le t n s r na ys s '
ex
ke t uch
r he de al

l' m e andum ofl w s it d wih t moton onl r s st eegr
'he mor
I
a ubm te t he i
y aie hr
oundsbu t
t he
C ntoduc i ' o t m oton r i e t a tonalgr und t tt doc enti a u i e y e r
d r
l
ton' t he
i a s s he ddii
o
ha he um
s n ntm l xpe t
di c os e.
s l ur

Rul ofCi lPr e e. Thus t sa gum e i pur l s m an i and i nota bass t sr ke t
es
vi oc dur
, hi r
nt s e y e tcs
s
i o ti he
doc e .
um nt

Pl ntfs a gu e t tt doc nti s c ai a s f l .Los pr isbas d onpas
ai if ' r m nt ha he ume s pe ul tve lo ais
t oft e
t
p oft i a a ce e me f e tbls ng da a sunde bot Or
r is s n c pt d ans or sa ihi
m ge
r h egon a Fl i l w.See
nd orda a

C@ o g n v Mo a o,1 P.d 5 4, 48( . p. 0 0 ,Rie Brd Cop. . rc n
fEu e e . n c 7 3 4 5 Or Ap 2 0 ) v r ige r v Ame ia
*
So Ve u e E re Ame i HomeDe elpme Cor ,1 So. 648,650( a. h DCA
max ntr s ' l rcan
x
v o nt p. 8 3d
F1 4t

2 0 ) I wil tej bo tej r t d tr newh te tee ie c s b t db Bito i i
0 9. t lbe h o f h u y o eemi
eh r h vd n e u mit y or nk s
e
s fc e t esa ih isda a s
uf int o t bls t m ge .

P an if tidagu e a p a st b s e n t srk a1o t r tt e ie c , o j s
litfs hr r tn nt p e r o e e kig o ti e 1 ls p oss vd n e n t u t
t ssngl doc e ,a a gue t ts h e de e s dbesrc n bec us i co d lad t
hi i e um nt nd r s ha uc vi nc houl
tike
a e t ul e o

t uns
he uppored i e e e o ca a i bewee La dul a M ahion' de rur a t dr
t nf r nc f us ton t n pa a nd t s s pa t e nd he op
i Bi r k' pr is Howe ,s a i er nc i notne s a iy uns
n otoni s oft .
ver uch n nf e e s
ce s rl
uppored a Bi r k
t nd otoni

ma h v a dto a e i e c t e tbihc us t n.Th s t ep eu ied e n to t iht
y a e d iin l v d n e o sa l a ai
s
o
u ,h rj dc o s o uweg he
pr tve vaue o t l tpr ise de e.
oba i
l f he os oft vi nc

Pli tfs tna a g me t sb s bo Fe ea Rueo Evd nc 1 06 wh c rqur sta
anif'i l r u n i a e n d rl l f ie e 0 , ih e ie h t
a1 s
1 uppori docum e a i f a s m a y m us be pr e e t t ot r s de Pl i i f as e t
tng
nt ton or um r
t
es nt d o he he i . a ntf s s r

t tce t n doc
ha rai
ument i t twa us d t pr
aton ha s e o oducet doc
he umenthasnotbe n pr e t
e oduc d o
t m ; e rng t tt docu e be s rc n. l s
he r quii ha he
m nt t i ke n uppor oft i a gum e t tD e enda has
t he r r
nt ha f
nt

n0 pr e a1 t s
t oduc d 1 he uppori docume ai Pli if havepr s nt d apo ton ofa
tng
nt ton, antf s
ee e
ri
de ii ta c i i whi h c
poston r ns rpt n
c ouns li dic sngt s
e s s us i he uppori doc e ai a
tng um ntton nd
Bitoni sc
o r k' ouns lsaest thedoe n' t nk t tt c tofgoodss d i or a i wa
e t t ha
s t hi ha he os
ol nf m ton s
pr duc d t Pl i if ,buthe woul c c Thus i i notcea t t s ppori
o e o antfs
d he k.
,t s
l r hat he u
tng

doc e a i wa notpr
um ntton s
oduce Fu t r Bi toni ha notdiecl r po d t t sa gument
d. rhe , o r k s
r ty es nde o hi r
.

Th s teCo r wil tsrk t ed c me tf r r s so s mmayj g n b t l
u ,h u t lno tie h o u n o pupo e f u r ud me t u wil
r o i risr lng,upon moton, or ti .Ac or ngl i i
ec nsde t u i
i bef e ral c di y, t s
ORDERED t tPli if M oton t Sti Def nda Bi r k' Pur re Los Pr i
ha antfs' i o rke e nt otoni s po td t oft

Ex e t ma e Anay i ( 1 5 i DE ED.
p r Da g s lss DE- 5 ) s NI

DONE a dORDERED i MimiFl i ,t s /8 dyo Se tmb r201
n
n a , orda hi
a f pe e, 4.
e

-

PATRI A A .SEI
CI
TZ
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U

c
c:

Al Couns lofRe or
l
e
c d