JMA, Inc. et al v. Biotronik SE & Co. KG

Filing 211

AMENDED ORDER re 210 Order on Damages. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 11/24/2014. (ai00)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI C OU RT
CT
SO U TH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D
CA SE N O .1 CV 2- 23466- TZ/ RN O FF
SE1 TU
J A ,I C . e a .
M
N , t 1,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s

BI
OTRO N I SE & CO . G . etal,
K
K , .
Def nda s
e nt .
/
A M EN D ED IO R D ER O N DA M A G E S

Thi matrca beor t Cour ont paris brei o da sg 1 1 a
s te me f e he
t he te ' ifng n mage DE- 92, 95 nd
1 . Theis befr t Cou ti wha tpeofda ge Bi r kma s kf isbr a hof
961
sue o e he r s t y
ma s otoni y ee or t e c
c r tc a m sa ist r i i e f r e cl i . The br a ofc r c c ai i g
ontac l i nd t o tous nt r e enc a m
e ch
ont a t l m s over d by
ne

Or on l w,whiet t tousi e f r ncec am i gove nedby Fl i l w. Durng dic r
eg a
l he ori nt re e
li s
r
orda a
i
s ove y,
Bi r k f l t pr e t doc nt s
otoni aied o oduc he ume s uppori isc tofgoodss d.Thus t Cour,
tng t os
ol
,he
tby
proror r ha he d t tBi r k m a notpr s nte de ofis l tpr is be aus t cos of
i de , s l ha otoni y
e e vi nce t os of t c e he t
go s d i ne s ar t a l tpr is c c a i Be aus t t pe ofda a s r c
ods ol s ce s y o os oft al ul ton. c e he y s
m ge e over bl i
a en

c r c a i t ta edif e ,t Cour wiladd e sea h s par t y.
onta t nd n or r fer nt he
t l r s c e ael

Br a ho n r c Da ge
e c fco ta t ma s
Bi t oni sbr ac ofc r c c ai alege t e dif r br c oft c r c s
o r k' e h
ont a t l m l s hr e f e ent ea hes he ont a t

bewe nt pa te ( )br c oft tr of ye r pr son;( brac oft c i talt
t e he ris: 1 ea h he e m- - as ovii 2) e h he onfdeni iy
a ta s c espr son'a ( brac oft pr songove ni s rpr e ai s Und
nd rde e r t ovii , nd 3) e h he ovii
r ng ub-e esnttve . er
Or gon l w ,da a i a e s i el m e ofan br c ofco r c cl i . M oi v H e s
e
a
m ges s n s ental e nt
y ea h
nt a t a m
ni . we ,
l hi O r rc r t a t
' s de or ec s ypog a c e r i t f not i t or gi Or on Dam a
T
r phi r or n he oot e n he i nal der
ges

g 21 )
DE- 0 .

763P. 41 41 ( .
2d 4, 7 Or App.1 ) Theda seeme c beme eihe b a t lda ge
988 .
mage l nt an
t t r y cua ma s

o n mia d ma e .S h f rv Fr s r 2 0P.d 1 0 2 ( .1 5 ) Bito i s u h t
r o n l a g s c a e . a e , 9 2 9 , 08 Or 9 5 . o r nk o g t o
e t bls isa t lda
sa ih t c ua mage t ough l tpr i s
s hr
os ott .Howe r aspr vi l sa e s h dn a
ve ,
e ousy t t d, uc m ges
c nnotbe r c e he e be a e ofBi r k' f l et pr
a
e over d r c us
otoni s aiur o oducedurng dic r t c tof
i
s ove y he os
goodss d doc e a i Thus Bi r ni s br a ofc r c da age a e lm ie t nom i l
ol
um nt ton.
, ot o k' e ch
ont a t m s r i t d o
na
da ag .
m es

T riu l tre e c Wi Co r c
o to s n ef r n e t nta t
h
B i t oni st r i i e f r e cl i aleg t tSt J t tousy i t r e ed wih
o r k' o tous nt r e enc a m l es ha . ude or i l n e f r
t
Bi r k' c r c sw ih t Sal s Re es a i . A s a r ul,Bi r k s ekst r co ris
otoni s ont a t t he e pr ent tves
es t ot oni e
o e ve t

l trve .Ac r ngt t Resae nt( ond)ofTors j774A t e t sofda ge
os e nues co di o he ttme Sec
t,
hre ype
ma s
a e r co r bl w he t r ha be n at tous i er e e
r e ve a e
n he e s e or i nt f r nce:

( t pec a yl soft be isoft c r tort pr peci rlton'
a) he unir os he neft he ontac he os tve eai ,
( co equq ill s f whi t i e frncei alga c us a
b) ns nta oses or ch he ntree s e l a e; nd

( e i dites ora t lha t rputton,i t yaer s bl t bee t
c) motonal sr s cua nn o e ai f he r ea ona y o xpeced
t r s tfom t i er e e .
o e ul r he nt f r nce

Thefr ti t e vae ofl tne pr is Aspr ousy saed,duet isf l r t pr e,
is s he qui lnt os t ott.
evi l t t
o t aiu e o oduc
Bitoni m a no s e l tne pr is Thet r e i dites orhar t r putton,
o r k y t e k os t oft .
hid, motonal sr s
m o e a i has
no be n pl d a Bi t oni hasno m ade a s a e e s i c tng t ti i e t s k s h
t e e nd o r k
t
ny t t m nt ndi a i ha t nt nds o ee uc
da ag . Bi t oni does how e ,s k c e
m es o r k
,
ver ee ons quenta da ag i t f m ofl tr ve
i l m es n he or
os e nues
.
U nde Fl i l w ,s h c eque i ldam a m a be r cove abl i l galy ca ed by t
r orda a uc ons
nta
ges y
e
r e f e l us
he

t riusitre c .S ePo y E pr s Co re Cop. fFlrd v Zi r 47 S 2 1 1 ,
o to n efmn e e n x e s u ir r o o ia . mme , 5 o. d 3 6
1 7( DCA 1 .Furhe , ord:1w doesnotal t r oveyofnomi da ge f
31 2
985) t r Fl i a
low he ec r
nal ma s or

2

t tousi t r e enc I r alA -jly Cr s Li ,LLC v.Wet rD1/ Fr e I . 987 So.
ori
n e f r e. mpe i o c / uie ne
inaue / e , nc ,
y

2d706,708( a 4t DCA 2008) Cons que l Bi r ni ma pr s ntevi eofisl t
F1. h
. e nty, oto k y e e
denc t os
r ve
e nuest es a ih is dn a s f St J s a l ge t tous i er e e
o t bls t m ge or . ude' le d ori
nt f r nce. H ow e r a
ve , ny

dn e a d c nnotbeunce t n,s c ai ,orhy he i lz
mag war a
rai pe ul tve
pot tca .
A c di y,i i
cor ngl t s
ORD ERED t t
ha :

1.Bi toni m a onl s e nom i lda a sf isbr c ofc r tcli .
or k y y e k
na m ge or t ea h
ontac a ms
Co e nty,t pa te 'pr pos i tuc i s d i l a i t uc i on nom i
ns que l he ri s o ed ns r tons houl nc ude n ns r ton
nal
da a s
m ge .
2. Bi t oni m a s k l tr nue f ris t tous i e f r e cl i t t ext ntt tt
o r k y ee os eve
o t or i nt r e enc a m o he e ha he
da a s l galy c e by t t tous i e f r nc a e a c r a na e wih r s bl c r a nt
m ge e l aus d
he or i nt r e e e r s e t i bl t ea ona e e t i y.

3.Th p ris p o o e u yi tu t nss alnc po aet h l n si ti o d r
e a t ' r p s dj r nsr ci h l i o rt he odig n h s r e .
e
o

a oxoe e 01.
Doxsa dORDERED i MimiFlrd ,hi X V dy f vmbr2 4
n
n a , oia t s
,

*

PA TR I I A .SEI
A
TZ
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D G E
CT U
A 1 Co elofRe d
l uns
cor

2Th Co r noe t thep ris p o o e j r i sr cin ddn tu etef ltx o
e u t t s ha t a t ' r p s d u y n tu to s i o s h ul e t f
e
Fl i StndadCi lJ yI t ci 408. ('eDE- 99a 56- 1l t pa te 'n nde
orda a r vi ur nsnzton 5.ke
s
1 t 57. f he ris me d
p o o e j r isr cinsd n tu et ef l tx ,h ys udb prp r dt d sus ti a te
r p s d u y n tu to o o s h u le tt e ho l e e ae o ic s h s t h
c r c ee
ha ge onf r nce.
3