JMA, Inc. et al v. Biotronik SE & Co. KG

Filing 44

ORDER granting 31 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction; Dismissing Defendant Biotronik SE & Co. from this case. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 4/4/2013. (ls)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.1 CV2- 23466- TZ/ M ONTON
SEI Sl
J A,l , ta .
M
NC-e l,
Pl ntfs
ai if ,

BI
OTRONI SE & CO.KG .e a .
K
, t 1,

De e nt ,
f nda s
/
ORDER GR ANTI M OTI TO DI I FOR LACK OF PERSONAL
NG
ON
SM SS
JURI CTI
SDI ON

Thi m at ri bef et Cou ton Def nda Bi r ni SE & Co.sM oton t Dimi sf
s te s or he
r
e nt oto k
'
i o s s or

La kofPe s lJ iditon( 31 .Thi acin aiesfom t alege brac ofs l
c
rona urs ci DE- 1 s to rs r he l d e h aes
r pr en a i ag ee
e es t tve r ment,whih gr nt Pli if J eph La dul ,La dul l ,Sc t
s
c a ed a ntfs os
pa a pa a, nc. ot
M a hion,a J A,l e l i rght t s l c t n me c de c i ade i d ar aof
t s nd M
nc. xc usve i s o el erai dial vi es n
fne e
s h Fl i Pli if a lget tDe enda sbr ac d t a ee nt by al wi ohe st
out orda. antfs le ha f nt e he he gr me s
lo ng t r o
s lt de ce wihi t s m ea eaa by tr i tng t a e nt .D e e ntBi r k SE
el he vi s t n he n
r nd e m na i he gr eme s
f nda
otoni

& Co ( or nk S , Ge a c mp n , e k t d s s t ecamsa an tte f rlc o
.Bito i E) a nn n o a y s e s o imis h li g i s h m o a k f

pes na j rs cin.Pli tfsh v rs o d d ( 3 )a d Bi to i S tldarpl ( 4 J
ro lu idito anif a e e p n e DE- 9 n or nk E ie e y DE- 0 .
Be us Bi r k SE doe notf lwihi Fl i sl a m sa ut Bi r ni SE' moton i
ca e otoni
s
al t n orda' ong- r tt e, oto k s i s
ga e
r nt d.

1 M at ri Fac s
.
e al t l
The Par i s
te

PlitfsJ sphLa d a( pa ul)a d S otM ahio ( ah s n)aeidiiu l
anif o e
pa ul La d a n c t t s n M tio r n vd as
l h fcsaetk nfo t ec mpan ( 1 , n e so h nv s idc td
' e a t r a e r m h o lit DE- j u ls t e ie n iae .
r

whor i i M im iDa Co t Fl rda.Pl ntf La dul ,I i a a nita i y
esde n a - de un y, o i
ai if pa a nc.s n dmi sr tvel
nc.
he n c nc. nd
h oi l
dis vedFl i c por to J A,l ,Sout r Pa e,l ,a ACL ofSout Fl rda, nc.
s ol
orda or ai n. M

. ude dia C.I ( . ude s nnes a or ai
a ea lFl i c por tons.St J M e c lS. , nc.St J )i aM i ot c porton.
r l orda or a i
De e
f ndantBi r k SE i a Ge m a c por i wih isprncpalpl c o busne si
otoni
s
r n or aton t t i i
ae f i s n
Be ln,Ge m a Bi r k,I .i a Or gon c o a i n wih isprncpa pl c ofbusne si
ri
r ny. otoni nc s n e
om r to t t i i l a e
i s n

La Os g , e o .Ac o dngt t es z De lr to o S s n eBen L 31 1,
ke we o Or g n c r i o h wo. caai n f u n n r t DE- - )
n
s it d by Bi r k SE i s
ubm te
otoni
n uppor ofismoton,Bi r ni I a Bi toni SE a es se
t t
i
oto k, nc. nd o r k
r it r
co ni o d by t s mepa e , S Hol ng 1 SE,aGe ny c
mpa es wne
he n
r nt M
di 1
nna ompany.Ac r ng t t
co di o he
Be n De l r ton,Bi r ni SE doesnoto r t c
r t c a ai
oto k
pe ae, onduc ,e ge i orc r yon busne si
t nga n, a r
i s n

Fl i a i i no r se e o lce e t do busnes i Fl i Addii ly,a cor ng t
orda nd t s t egit r d r i ns d o
i s n orda.
tona l c di o
Be nt Bi r k SE do no e r s a ope atonalc r ove Bi r k,I . t t
r , otoni
es t xe cie ny r i
ontol r otoni nc, he wo
co pa esd nots r anyof e sordie t s a e h ope a e a aditnc e iy.The Be nt
m ni o
ha e
fc r
r c or , nd ac
r t s s si t ntt
r
De l ai f t rsa e t tBi r k SE manuf c ur r a s l ca di cr l ma ge nt
car ton urhe tt s ha otoni
a t e s nd els r a hyt
un na me

pr s( vi s fo isofs e i Gema t iscusomes i udi Bi rnok,l a
oduct de ce) r m t lc s n r ny o t t r,ncl ng oti nc. nd,
t ,t r ltons p be we n Bi toni SE andBitoni l i t tofbuye a s lr
hus he ea i hi t e o r k
o r k, nc. s ha
r nd ele .

l o p sto t t mo in, pa uah ss b t d as r de lrto r 3 - 1 i
n p o iin o he to La d l a u mit wo n ca ai n DE- 9 1 ,n
e
whi h he sa e t thebele st tt de c we em a acur i pa ti Or on by s
c
tt s ha
ive ha he vies r nuf t ed n r n eg
ome
Bi toni e iy.Howe r t de c shes d we e c s d,fnihe a sa
o r k ntt
ve ,he vi e
ol r a e i s d, nd t mped i Ge ny by
n nna

Bi r ni SE. Acc di t La dul , be i ed t thewa a i pe n s l s
oto k
or ng o pa a he lev ha
s n nde nde t a e
r pr e t tveofa Bi r k en iyt ta t l manuf c ur d t de c a t thewa
e es n a i
ny otoni tt ha cualy
a t e he vi es nd ha
s
wor ng f rt be ftofBi r k SE,a wel asBi r k, nc.Furhe ,La
ki o he ne i
otoni
s l
otoni I
t r padul r c i d
a e e ve
co muni a i die ty fom Bi r k SE,s cik a l am e or ndum a
m
c tons r c l r
otoni
pe t ly
m a
nnouncng a Orgi l
i n i na

2

Eq pme M a a t eAgr e e bet e Bi r k SE and ac
ui nt nuf c ur
e m nt we n otoni
ompe io .Acc di t
tt r
or ng o
La dul ,hea s r c ve a s e a r die l fom Bi r k SE.A ddii ly, pa a
pa a
l o e ei d als wa d r cty r
otoni
tonal La dul
saest Bi rnok SE eiheri ta e ora ove bu t f hi tni o y,r l as ofne
t t hat oti
t niit d ppr d dges or s e t r e e es
w
pr t , f lows p a e aton pr amsf hi trior
oduc s and el hi nd duc i
ogr
or s e rt y.
The R e e e at v Agr e e s
pr s nt i e
e m nt

I Aug t2009, otoni l .a Pli if Lapadul,J A , nc. a M ahion e e e
n
us
Bi r k, nc nd a ntf s
a M l , nd t s ntr d
i o a Aut i d SaesRe r s nttve Agr eme ,e f c i Augus 1,
nt n horze l
p e e ai
e nt fe tve
t 2009 a s he e t
nd c dul d o

expie o M a c 31 201 Prort t tBi r k,l a La dul a J. La dul I
r n r h , 5. i o ha otoni nc. nd pa a nd A. pa a, nc.
e e e i o a I pende Repr s nttv A g e m e ,e f c i J
nt r d nt n nde
nt
e e a i e r e nt fe tve anua y 1 2006 an s tt
r ,
d e o
e r on Dec mbe 31 201
xpie
e r , 5.

Unde t eRe es nt i A g e nt ,La dul La
r hes pr e atve r eme s pa a, padul
a,

I , M A, nc.and M ahion ag ee t m a ke a s l Bitoni de ce i ce t n de i d
nc.J
I ,
t s
r d o r t nd el o r k vi s n rai fne
a ea ofs h Fl i ,t t excuson ofal ot pr t an s v c .I r ur Bi toni
r s out orda o he l i
l her oduc s d er i es n et n, o r k,
l pr m ie La dul La
nc. o s d pa a, padul I ,J A , nc. a M ahion t tt y woul havee usve
a, nc. M I , nd t s ha he
d
xcl i
rg st s lBi r k deviesi t ea ea .TheRe e e t tveAgr men sde i t t r
i ht o el otoni
c n hos r s
pr s n a i
ee t fne he e m
t oto k'a Bi r k, nc. The ei no r f r nc t Bi toni SE i t Re e e a i
' r ni ' s otoni l 2
Bi
r s eee e o or k
n he pr s nt tve
Ag e me s3
r e nt .
TheCl ms
ai
Some i ea trt 2009Re e e ai Ag ee twa sgne Pl ntfsla ne t t
tm fe he
pr s nttve r men s i d, ai if e r d ha

2 Re e e a i Ag ee nt ha be fl unde s a a DE- The d i ton i
The pr s nttve r me s ve en ied
r e l t 20.
efnii s
on t fr tpageoftxtofbot Agr m e s
he is
e
h
ee nt .
3 t
Alhough Pli if a gue t tt Agr e e sdo notd s e n be we n dif r ntBi r k
antf s r
ha he e m nt
i c r t e fe e
otoni

e iisg 38a 8J a saed,t Agre nt defnet t m k otoni 'ome nBi rmi
ntte DE- t , s tt he e me s i he er l r k't a otc k,
Bi
I The e or a y r f r nc t SBi r k' i t Re es t tveAgr eme si ar f r et
nc. r f e, n e e e e o l otoni ' n he pr en a i
e nt s e e enc o
Bi r k,I ,nota he Bi toni en tt
otoni nc.
not r o r k iiy.

Bi r k wass lng co pone sofisde c t ot de cec
otoni
eli
m
nt
t vies o her vi ompa e who s d t i
ni s
ol he r
pr t wih t Bi r k c
oduc s t he otoni omponent wihi t a ea a sg d t Pl ntfs t ,i rng ng
s t n he r s s i ne o ai if , hus nfi i
on t exc usviy gr nt i t Re es nt tveAgr e e s Ad tona l Bi r ni I a s
he l i t a ed n he pr e ai
e m nt. dii ly, oto k, nc. lo

r move c ti a e fom t ar asa sgne t Lapa a, pa a, nc,J A , nc.
e
d era n r as r he e s i d o
dul La dul l . M I and
M ahion i t Re e e ai A g ee nt .Asar ul,La dul ,La ul I , M A, nc.
t s n he pr s nt tve r me s
es t pa a pad a, nc.J
l ,
a M ahion beg n e orng pos i eempl
nd t s
a xpl i
sbl
oyme wih Pl ntf St J
nt t ai if . ude.I r pons
n es e,
Bi to k,I t r nae t Re es n a i Agr e e s whih 1d t t flng oft saci n.
o r ni nc. e mi t d he pr e t tve e m nt , c e o he ii
hi to

Pli if 'f urc
antfs o ountco pl i al ge onec am f br a h ofconta and t e cai ss e ng
m ant le s
l i or e c
r ct
hr e l m e ki

d ca ao yj d me .
e lr tr u g nt
l St
I. andar f Per o Juridi ton
d or s nal
s ci

W h nc nsd rn amoint d s s f rlc o p ro a j rs ito , d src c u t
e o i eig
to o imis o a k f es n lu id ci n a itit o r
mus frtdeer ne whet ra pli ifhasesa ihed aprm af ci ca eofpe s l
t is t mi
he
a ntf
t bls
i a e s
r ona

j rs ito Ab a o v Wat s y Co,1 2F. p' 2 , 75( 1hCi. 0 5 .l ma i
u id cin. r ms n . lDine . 3 Ap x 73 2 1 t r 2 0 ) n kng
t sdee na i t dititco tmus ac p t pli ifsa lga i astue, e s
hi tnni ton, he src ur
t ce t he a ntf le tons r unl s
c r dit d by de e
onta c e
f ndantsa fda t. I i tra pli ifhase t bls d aprma f c ec e
' fi vis d û e
Af
a ntf
sa ihe
i a i as

f r midito a dt d fn n h sflda fd vt c ne tn j rs cin,hepan ifb as
o j s cin n he ee da t a ie fi a is o tsig u idito t litf e r

tebud no pr vn s fiin j rs ito b a d vt o oh rs r sa e ns' 1 a 2 6
h r e f o ig u fce t u idcin y y a i r te wo n ttme t. d. t 7
s
'
(mpha i a ) I t pli ifsc anta s ri e de c lc wiht
e ss dded . f he antf ompli nd uppo tng vi nce onfit t he
de enda ' a fda t ,hec t us c tu a1r a ona ei e enc i f voro t pli if
f nts fi vis t our m t onsr e l e s bl nf r es n a
f he a ntf .

M ee e rl Mee v SunI enatonalHotl,Lt ,288F. 1 1 ( t Ci.
ir x e. ir . ntr i
es d.
3d 264, 269 11h r 2002)
.

Tod tnniewh t e i h sp ro a j rs ito t Co r mu t o du t t - r
ee n eh r t a e s n l u idcin,he u t s c n c a wopa t
iq iy.Fis, t t ee n ij rs ito e ssu d rFlrd ' ln a sau e Flrd
n u r rti mus d tnnie f u id cin xit n e o i as o g-nn ttt , oia
4

Sttt j4 1 3.S c n ,h Co r mu tdeemiewh t e e e csn j rs itono rte
aue 8.9 e o d te u t s tr n eh r x riig u id ci ve h
de e nt c
f nda s omporswih t DuePr es Cl e. fic ar l v. ove ad 544 F. 1
t t he
oc s aus
c i delo f l y
3d 280,

1 3(11h Ci.2008) Thi i as at pa tdee mi in.TheCour mus detr newhehe
28 t r
. s s lo wo- r tr nato
t t emi
t r
t de e nt had s fce m i mum c a t wih Fl i a whe he m ant na eoft
he f nda s
ufi int ni
ont c s t orda nd
t r i e nc
he

s i i Flrd d e n t fe érdio a n to soffi pa a ds b tn il u tc . I a
ut n o ia o s o o fnd la t n l o in ar ly n u sa ta j sie' d t
t i
'
1 4.
28

Un e Flrd ' ln -nn sau e ac u t yh v g n r lu idito o e ad fn a t
d r o i as o g a ttt, o r ma a e e ea j rs cin v r ee d n

o s e ii j rs ito A c u t a g n rl u idit no e ad fn a t ftepes n i
r p cfc u idcin. o r h s e e a j rs ci v r ee d n i h ro s
o
t n a e i s b tnil n n t s ltda tvt wi i E o i l' Fl. tt j48 1 3 2 .
s g g d n u sa ta a d o io ae ciiy t n Flrda. a S a. .9 4 )
e
h
'
%subsa i a notiolt d aci t 'm e nsi ontnuousa s t tc g r busnes
l tntal nd
s a e tviy' a l i
c
nd ysema i ene al i s

ds . a
e i d 739 2d 7, 20 F1 4t
z
c ac'wih Fl i Woo v Nov CompanisBel eLt , So. 61 6 ( a. h
ont t' t orda.

DCA 1 9 )(iai no te ) S e ii j rs ito aie wh n itrai, d f n n b e c e
9 9 ctto mitd . p cfc u id ci n rss e ,n e l a ee da t r a h s
a
aco r c i Fl i by f lng t pe f m a t r quie by t c r tt bepe f nne i
nta t n orda aii o ror c s e r d he ontac o
ro d n

Fo i a Fl. tt j481 3 1( ) o b o rtn , o d cigo c n n o ab i s v n u ei
lrd , a S a. .9 ( )g , r y peai g c n u tn r a yi g n usne s e t r n
Flrd , a S a. 4 .9 ( )a.Sp cfcj rs ito o l e it i t c us o a to aie
o ia Fl. tt j 8 1 3 1() e ii uid cin ny x ss f he a e f ci n rs s
fom t br c oroutoft busne sopeatons Fl Stt j48.93.
r he ea h
he i s r i . a. a. 1

Th DueP o e sClus p o iistee ecs o p ro a j rs ito o e an n e ie t
e
r c s a e r hb t h x r ie f es n l u idcin v r o r sd n
de e ntunl shi c a twih t sae i s ch t thehasi ai wa ni 't hem a be
f nda
es s ont c t he t t s u ha
' r r ng' hat
f
y

s be tt s i te e Lica d lo 5 4F.d a 1 4.Th sr q ie n ha b e me i a
u j c o ut h r . c ir el , 4 3 t 28
i e ur me t s e n t f
de e ntha i pos l diec e ' saci te atr i nt oft f m and t ltgai a ies
f nda
sç
pur ey r t d'hi tvii s esde s he onl
he ii ton rs
o oft ea tvii s I
ut hos c i te . d.

Eve i t sr quieme i me ,ac tm us t n dee mi i
n f hi e r nt s t our
t he tr ne f

mai e nc oft s ti t f r c
ntna e he ui n he o um ompo t wih tadii lnotonsoff rpl and s t nta
rs t r tona i
ai ay
ubsa i l

5

j sie I .l ma n ti d tr n to , c r ma c nsde s v rlfco s i l dngShe
u t . d n kig hs eemiain a ou t y o i r e ea a t r,ncu i û
c
t
bud n o t ed fn a t l iaigi t f r m,hef r m' itrs i aj dc tn t
r e n h e e d n of i g tn n he o u t o u s n eet n d u iaig he
t

d s ue t ep an ifsitrs i o tii gc n e in a efcier le a dt j d ca
ip t,h litf ne et n b an n o v n e t nd fe tv eif n he u iil
s t m ' i e es i r s vi t diput ' 1
yse s ntr t n e ol ng he s e-' d.
1 1 Anayss
1.
l i
Bi r k SE movest dim isPl i if c
otoni
o s s antfs' ompl i be a ePli if ca
ant c us antfs nnote t bls
sa ih

ete g n rl rs e i c u idito o e i.Bito i SE ag e ta t Co r d e n t v
i r e ea o p c t j rs cin v r t or nk r u s h the u t o s o ha e
h
i

p ro a j rs ito o e ip ru n t Flrd ' l ga m sauea d e e i i dd, x rii g
es n l u idcin v r t u s a t o o ia s on -r ttt n , v n f t i e ecsn
p ro a j rs ito o e Bito i SE wo l o fndd pr c s .Ass tf rhb l wsh Co r
e s n lu id ci n v r or nk
ud fe ue o e s
e o t eo t e u t
d e n t a pes n l u idcin o e Bi to i S un e Flrd ' l n -r sau e Th ,
o s o h ve ro a j rs ito v r or nk E d r o ia s o g am ttt . us
t Cour ne d nota e sBi r k SE' duepr e sa g e s
he
t e
ddr s otoni
s
oc s r um nt .
A. Pli tfsHa NotEsa ihe Gene a J idi ton Ov Bi r k SE
a n if ve
t bls d
r l urs ci
er otoni

Bito kSE a s rsta Plitfsc r te tbls g n r lu idcin o e ibe a ei
or ni
se t h t an if amo sa ih e ea j rs ito v r t c us t
i note ge i s t nta aci t wihi Fl i a t aci nso Bi toni I .c
s
nga d n ubsa i l tviy t n orda nd he to f o r k, nc anno be
t
ati ed t Bi r k SE.W hie Pli if 'c
trbut o otoni
l antfs ompl i a lgest tBi toni SE i t pa e of
ant le ha o r k
s he r nt
Bi toni I and,a s h,die t d a contole Bi toni l ' c
o r k, nc.
s uc r c e nd
r ld o r k, nc.s onduc ,Bi r k SE ha
t otoni
s
s bm it d t Be ntDeearto t te t bls st tBi r k SE a Bi r k,l a e sse
u te he r
l ai n ha sa i he ha otoni
nd otoni nc. r itr
c
ompa e ,bot owne by M S Hol ng1 SE.Furhe m or ,t Be ntDeca ai e t bls s
nis h
d
di 1
t r e he r
lr ton sa ihe
t tBi toni SE doe note r s a o r tonalc r ofa na ur wha s ve ove
ha or k
s
xe cie ny pe a i
ontol ny t e
toe r r
Bitoni I ,t c
o r k, nc. he ompa e do no s r ofi r ordie or ,a none ofBi r k l '
ni s
t ha e fce s
r ct s nd
otoni nc.s
e pl esa epad by Bi toni SE orvi eve s Thus Bitoni SE a guest tbec us i i
m oye r i
or k
c r a.
, or k
r
ha
a e ts

n te g g di s b tn ila tvt i Fl rd ,heCo r d e n th v g n r lu idcino e i.
o n a e n u sa ta cii n o ia t
y
u t o s o a e e ea j rs ito v r t
6

Whi Plitfs c mplitalg dg n rl u idcine it p ru n t FlrdaS au e
l an if' o an l e e ea j rs it xss u s a t o o i ttt
e
e
o
j48.934 ,i r pons t t moton, antfssat t tt ydonotha s fcintdic r
1 2) n es e o he i Pli if t e ha he
ve ufi e s ovey
t deenui t ext ofBi r k SE' a tvii i Fl rda.Cons que ty, ai if havenot
o t ne he ent
otoni
s ci tes n o i
e n l Pl ntfs

me t i b r e of sa ls i gg n rl u id cin o e Bito i SE.
ther u d n e tbih n e ea j rs ito v r o r nk
B. antfsHa No Esa ihe Specf J rs c i Ove Bi r k SE
Pl i if ve t tbls d
ik u iditon
r otoni

Bito i S as manan ta P an if c n o etb ihs cfcj rs ito o e i
or nk E lo i tis h t litfs a n t sa ls pe i u idcin v r t
b sdo FlrdaStt t j481 3 1( )o j48 1 3 1( ) Pu s a tt j4 1 3 1() Bito i
a e n o i aue .9 4 )a r .9 ( )g . ru n o 8.9 ( )a , or nk

S wo l b s be to s e i j rs ito i i o rts c n u t, ng g si o c riso a
E u d e u jc t p cic u idci n f t peae , o d cs e a e n, r are n
busne sorbusnes ve ur i t sae ofFl i orhasa ofs e o age y i t sat of
i s
i s nt e n he t t
orda
n tc r nc n he t e

Flrd .Pu s n t j4 1 3 1( ) Bito i S wo db s be t os cfcj rs cini i
o ia rua t o 8.9 ( )g , or n k E ul e u j c t pe i u idit f t
o
b ea hesa c nta ti Fl i by f ii t peronn a t r quie byt c r ctt bepe f me
r c
o r c n orda a lng o f
c s e r d he onta o
ror d
i Fl i Bi r k SE as e t t t r i no e de e t ti wasope ai abusne si
n orda. otoni
s rs hat he e s vi nc ha t
r tng
i s n

Fl rdaort ti be he a c r cti Fl i
oi
ha t ac d onta n orda.
i TheCour D oe NotHav Pe s
.
t s
e r onalJurs c i Pur uantt Fl i St ut
iditon s
o orda at e

f 4 . 9 ()g
8 1 3 1 ()
The o y c r t a is he ea e t Repr s nt i Agr ment. Howe r Bi r i
nl ontac s t s ue r r he
e e atve ee
s
ve , oton k

SE i no apa t t et roft Re es nt tveAgr e e s.Thus Bi r k SE mai ai t t
s t ry o ihe
he pr e ai
e m nt
, otoni
nt ns ha

i c n o b s be t oj rs it npu s a t o j4 1 3 1( ) P anif a g et ta at r t a n t e u jc t u idci ru n t 8.9 ( )g . litfs r u ha s hid
o
pa t be i i yoft Re es nttveAgr eme s Bi toni SE ha a oblga i no t hi r
ry nefcar
he pr e a i
e nts o r k
d n i ton t o nde
Pl i if 'abiiy t pe f m unde t Re es nt tveAg e ment. Thus Pl i if s e t bas
antfs lt o r or
r he pr e ai
re
s
, antfs e k o e

j rs ito o t efc t a Bito i S i atid-a t b n t a yofac nr c t a wa t b
u id ci n n h a t h t or nk E s hr p ry e ekir
o ta t h t s o e
pe f me i Fl i Pl i if , we r ha f l t ct t a bi ng c e1 w t twoul
ror d n orda. antfs ho ve , ve aied o ie o ny ndi as a ha
d

7

s
uppor isp oposton t tbengat r pa t bene a y t a c r c i s ic e ton iso t
tt r
ii ha i
hid- ry
fcir o onta t s uf i n
t wn o

e tbls p ro a j rs ito o r h tb n f ay.
sa ih es n l u idcin ve t a e ekir
Furhe ,i i no c e rt tBi r k SE i a t r pa t benet i yoft Repr s n a i
t r t s t l a ha otoni
s hid- ry
k ar
he
e e t tve
Agr e
e ment. l or rt ha at r pa t be fc a yt c ta tngpa tesm us e es an
s n de o ve hid- ry ne i r he on r c i
ri
t xpr s
i e t prma iy a die tybe ftt t r pa t Ve orHo pial v. ueCr sBl
nt nt o i rl nd r c l ne i he hid- ry. nc
s t s Bl
os ue

Shedo o eIln 1 F.d67 , 0( 1hCi. 9 9 .Th r i n e i e eta Plitfs
il fRh d sa d, 69 3 7 68 1 t r 1 9 ) e e s o v d nc h t anif
a dBito i I c itn dt prma i a d dr cl b nhtBito k S wh nt e e trd
n or nksn .n e de o i rl n ie t e e or ni E e h y ne e
y
y
i o t Re es nt tveAgr e e s Ac or ngt t Be ntDe l r ton, otoni SE s d
nt he pr e a i
e m nt . c di o he r
c a a i Bi r k
ol
de c t Bi toni l Pli tfst n s d t deviesasr pr ent i ofBi r k, nc
vies o o r k, ne. a n if he ol he
c
e es atves
otoni l .
The e i no e d et ta bene i pa s die ty t Bi r k SE a ar ul oft
r s
vi enc ha ny
ft s ed r c l o otoni
s es t he
Re e e ai Agr me s Gi n t r ltons psbet n t pa te ,t s y t tBi r k
pr s nttve et nt . ve he ea i hi
wee he ri s o a ha otoni

SE wa at r pa t be ii r oft Re e e atveAgr eme swoul ma e r
s hid- ry nefc a y he pr s nt i
e nt
d ke ve y
ma a t e ofagood t t r pa t be fcir ofa c r c sbe we n a i pende
nuf cur r
he hid- ry nei a y ny onta t t e n nde
nt

diti oroft tgood and iss l pe e.Thede i ii oft r pary be fca y i nott t
srbut
ha
t aes opl
fn ton hid- t nei ir s
ha
br d.To s
oa
uppor t i postont tBi r k SE i at r pa t be t il Pli if poi t
t her ii ha otoni
s hid- ry nek ay, antfs nt o
lngua i t Re e e ai Ag ee
a
ge n he pr s nt tve r ment whih r f st pr duc sm a a t e by Bi to k
s c e er o o t nuf c ur d
o r ni

a tse appr d a r l s byBi toni Howe r t Re es t tveAgr e e ssa e
nd e t d, ove nd eea ed
or k.
ve , he pr en a i
e m nt tt
t tS oto k'r f r t Bi r k,I , Bi toni SE. Co eq nty, he e i i uf e
ha l r ni ' e e s o otoni nc.not o r k
Bi
ns ue l t r s ns fcint
e de t esa ih t tBi r k SE i at r pa t be kir oft Repr s nt tve
vi nce o t bls ha otoni
s hid- ry nef a y he
e e ai

Ag e ment. Acc di y, ai if havef ie t me t rbur n o e t bls ng pe s
re
s
or ngl Pl ntfs
a ld o et hei de f sa ihi
r onal

j rs ito o e Bito i SE p ru n t FlrdaStt t j481 3 1( )
u idcin v r or n k
u s a to o i aue .9 ()g .

8

i. The Cour Doe Not ePe s
i
t s
Hav r onalJurs c i Pur uantt Fl ri St ut
iditon s
o o da at e

j4 .9 ()a
' 8 l 3 1 ()
Plitfsas a sr t a teCo r h sp ro a j rs ito o e Bito i SE b sd o
anif lo se th t h u t a es n l u idcin v r o rn k a e n
.

Flrd S auej4 .9 ( )a b c u eBito i S drcl itrce wihPli tf La d l a
o ia tt t 8 l 3 1() e a s or n k E ie t n ea td t anif pa u a s
y
a me be ofiss l f c Thus Pl ntfsar ue t tLa dul wa Bi r k SE' a nt
m r t aes or e.
, ai if g ha pa a s otoni
s ge ,

whc wo l s be t or nk S t p ro a j rs ito W hl Pli if a ec re th ta
ih ud u j c Bi to i E o e s n l u idcin. i ant s r o rc ta n
e
f
a e tsa to c ns be th pi cpa t j rs it n, anif ha ep ee tdn e ie eta
g n ' cins a u j c te rn i lo u idci Plitfs v r s ne o vd nc h t
o
La
padul wasa ag ofBi r k SE.
a
n ent
otoni

Fis,t Re es nt tveAgr e e sa ebe we n Pl ntfsand Bi r k, nc.Se
r t he pr e ai
e m nt r t e ai if
otoni I
cond,
t s ndi o ame o a
he e ng f
m bouta a ee ntbe we Bi r k SE a ano he devi
n gr me
t en otoni
nd t r
ce
ma a ur rt s l r pr e a i swho s dBi r ni SE' pr tdoesnotesa ih t
nuf ct e o a es e es nttve
ol oto k
s oduc
tbls he
e se e ofa a nc r ltons p;nordoe t r eptofas l sa d.I or rt e t bls a
xit nc
n ge y ea i hi
s he ec i
a e war n de o sa ih n

a nc r ai hi Pli if woul ha t esa iht e ee t ()ac
ge y eltons p antfs d ve o tbls hre lmens: 1 knowldgme byt
e
nt he

p icp lh thea e twi a t o h m, 2 tea e tsa c p a c o t eu etkn a d ()
rn ia ta t g n l c f r i ( ) h g n ' c e tn e f h nd ra ig, n 3
l
c r b t prncpalove t a i oft a nt Gol c dtv Hol
ontol y he i i
r he ctons he ge . ds hmi . man, So. 422,
571 2d

42 n. ( a.1 .Thee denc r i upon b Pl ntfsdoesnote tbls t e se ofa
4 5 Fl 990)
vi e eled
y ai if
sa ih he xitnce n
ag yr ltons p bewe n La dul a Bi r k SE. Pli if havenotpoi e t a
enc ea i hi t e pa a nd otoni
a ntf s
nt d o ny
e de et tBi r k SE ha c r ove Lapa a' a tons Thus i Pli tfsca
vi nc ha otoni
d ontol r
dul s c i .
, f a n if nnot
e t bls t tLa dul wa an a nto Bi r k SE,t y ca tesa ih t tBi r ni SE
sa ih ha pa a s ge f otoni
he nno t bls ha oto k
wa ope a i c
s r tng, onduci enga ng i o ca r i on abusnes vd ur i Fl i
tng,
gi n, r ry ng
i s nt e n orda.

Co s q e ty teCo l d e n t a ep ro a j rs ito p ru n t Flrd Sauej
n e u n l,h u' o s o h v es n l u id cin u s a t o o ia tt t
t
48.93( ().
1 1)a

C.TheCour W ilNotGr ntJu i d ci lDicove y
t l
a
rs i tona s r

Pl ntfsr que tt t i t Co ti r l t ntt de t moton t dimi s i s d
ai if e s ha ,f he ur s euca o ny he i o s s , t houl

g a tPlitfsj rs it na d s o e y Plitfs ho v rha eno s t u wha d s o eyt e
rn an if u id ci l ic v r . an if, we e, v t e o t t ic v r h y
o
s e ; n ta ,he ag et t' f r to rve ldd rn . .u idcin ld sov r c ud
e k i se d t y r u ha çn o main e ae u ig . j rs ito a ic e y o l
i
r ve lpos i ea to loralenai e am s'a i to orbo h De e nt .Pl ntfs
e a
sbl ddii na
t r tve l i ' gans ne
t f nda s ai if

f rhe s g e t h tl d iin l ratr aiet e re ( fl bltlmiht u fc a ar s l o
u t r u g s t a ç dto a o len tv h o is o i i y g s ra e s e ut f
a
a i

j rs ito l ic v r ' Dee d n so po ea yj rs ito a d so e ybe a s s c
u id cina d s o ey. fn a t p s n u idcin l ic v r c u e u h
'
dic r woul a oun t afs ng e dii
s ove y
d m t o i hi xpe ton.

J idi i ldicove yha be n e ane a f l w s
urs ctona s r s e xpl i d s olo :
i t a c ran t r t oft a lga i orf c s
s o s e ti hetu h he le tons a t

Th pyn sh fsrsino ae sca e ys ito l i n t ve il f a çts i g
u it o r s j r
u deuio eo a s r it np do olu id ci n.t s o a hce or ilh n
ne rp gte j edcif l in v r
l
o
é
e p dto ' nh p st t ic v r wil u ti tee rieo p ro a j rs ito '
x e ii n i o e ha d so e y l s san h xecs f es n l u idcin.
'
Pa k rv Br s Wel n I c, 7 F. u p. d 1 9 ,1 0 ( D. . 00 ) V g v
r e . u h lma , n p3 7 S p 2 2 0 3 5 N. Ga 2 5 ; o t .
Gr e i Hol n LLC, l: -cv I OF,2002W L 534542,a *7( D.
e nmarne dig,
No. 01 -031 -J
t N. Ga.
F b. , 0 2 ( e yn j rs ito a d s o eyb c us t ee d nc t epanif
e 20 2 0 ) d n ig u idcin l ic v r e a e h vit e h litf
S tci t d bei a et a
ç i pa e
an
ng bl o dducei t dic ypr s ' wou d isilha f ie t
n he s over oce s' l ttl ve a ld o

ma eou ap i f cec s o pes n l u idcin'; e as T i e I u .I c v
k t rma a i ae f ro a j rs ito ' s e lo rntc nd s,n . .
)
Pe r Pr mo in l o s, n .3 5F.d 1 7 ,1 8 ( d. r20 5 (t u id ci n l
d e o to a Pr d .I c, 9 3 2 5 2 3 Fe Ci. 0 ) ûl rs ito al
l
dic yi a opra ewhe et e si r c d i tna ua e t s
s over s ppr it
r he xitng e or s i deq t ' o uppor pe s l
t rona

j idcina t p ryd mo srtst a ic ns ppe n is u idito a alg to s
urs ito nd a a t e n tae h t t a u lme t t j rs cin l le ain
t oughdico r ')
hr
s vey. .
'
AtantsHydr ponis I .v I e natona Gr
l i
o
c , nc . ntr i l ower Su y,I . - F.Supp. -,201 W L
s ppl nc ,
2d
3

2 1 2( D. . 01 ) Hee P an if aen ttyn t a c rantetuh o t ej rs ito a
8 0 N. Ga 2 3 . r , litfs r o ri g o s eti h r t f h u idcin l
al gai a s re i t co pl nt The a r nty c
le tons s e td n he m ai . y ppa e l once t tt alegai ofa pa e de ha he l tons
r nt
s i ar r a i hi ar i orec .SeeDE- a 4,n.0. l t d,Pl ntfsa esm pl
ubsdi y eltons p e nc r t
39 t
1 nsea ai if r i y

s ac n fran w b ssf r u idcin n t a e o a yhn p e i t ec mp an .
e rhig o e a i o j rs ito , o b sd n n tig ld n h o lit
Furhe
t nnor t y a s a
e, he lo ppea t be s r hi f po e i la tona c e ofa ton.Thi
ro
ea c ng or t nta ddii l aus s ci
s

10

woul be bydefnii a ' ihi e dii ' TheCour alo not t tPl i if ha not
d ,
i ton, ç s ng xpe ton.
f
'
t s
es ha antfs ve

a f maieys u h j rs ito a d so ey;h yh v no fldamoi s e ig s c o s u h
fi tv l o g t u idcin l ic v r t e a e t ie
r
t e kn u h r o g t
on

asa o t smoi np n i gj rs ito a ds o ey.Co s q e ty Plitfs r q e t o
ty f hi to e d n u idcin l ic v r
n e u n l, anif' e u s f r

j rs ito l ic veyi d ne .Se UntdTe h o o e Cop. . z r 5 6F.d 1 6 ,
u id cina d s o r s e id e ie c n lgis r v Ma e , 5 3 2 0
1 8 - ( 1hCi. 0 )(i igdsrc c u t i n ta u eisds rto b d n ig
2 0 81 1 t r 20 9 fndn itit o r dd o b s t icein y e yn

j rs ito a ds o eywh np an ifddn tfnnal mo ef r u idcina d s o eyb ,
u idcin l ic v r e litf i o o l v o j rs ito l ic v r ut
y
i t a bured t r s i isbref asa at r tvet dim is land whe pl ntf di not
nse d, i he eque t n t i s n le na i o s s a
n ai if d

tkea afr tvese orf
a ny fimai tps onnala tont c
ci o ompe dic y .
l sover)
Acc di l i i
or ngy, t s
ORDERED t tDe enda Bi toni SE & Co.sM oto t Dim isf rLa k ofPe s l
ha f nt o r k
'
in o s s o c
r ona

J rs it n ( 31 i GRANTED. Dee d n Bito kSE & Co i ds se fo t i c s .
u idci DE- ) s
o
fn a t or ni
.s imis d r m h s a e
DONE a ORDERED i M im i Fl i t s
nd
n a , orda, hi
-

V 8dy ofApri,2013.
a
l
k

zee

PATRI A A. E1 Z
CI
UNI
TED STA TES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

Al Couns ofRe or
l
el
c d