Tiffany (NJ), LLC v. 925jewelrymax.com et al

Filing 34

FINAL DEFAULT JUDGMENT and PERMANENT INJUNCTION AGAINST DEFENDANTS, in favor of Plaintiff against 925jewelrymax.com, 998trade.com, axues.net, bavot.com, cartierjewelrywholesaler.com, chinashoesuppliers.com, chinawholesale1688.com, eccoly.com, first cheapsale.com, good5a.com, goodsaaa.com, heidoudou.net, infashion2012.com, jewelleryforgirls.com, jewelry-1st.com, joyas-baratas.com, mallreplica.com, nvrengui.com, shoesbuychina.com, shoescitytrade.com, shop4necklace.com, shop4tiffany.com, styleitself.com, tiffanycanadasale.com, tiffanycojewelryau.com, tiffanyjewelryoutletu.org, wholesalejewelry2012.com, wholesaletiffanyjewellery.com Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 3/28/2013. (cqs)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CASE NO.1 2351 - V- TZ/ M ONTON
28 Cl SE1 SI

TI FANY @ J,
F
) LLC,
Pli tf,
a n if
VS.

9ZSJ ELRYM AX .
EW
COM , tal,
e .
De e nt .
f nda s
FI
NAL DEFA ULT JUDGM ENT AND PERM ANENT I
NJUNCTI
ON
AGAI
NST DEFENDANTS
Pur ua t Fe r RulsofCi lPr dur 58,t sCour' Or ron Pli if sM oton
s nt o de al e
vi oce e
hi
ts de
a ntf
i

f rEnty ofFi Def tJ m e Aga ns Def nda s 128,a f r good ca e s
o
r
nal aul udg nt i t e nt nd o
us hown,i i
ts
he e
r by

ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t t De a t J
ha
f ul udgment i he eby e er d i f r o
s r
nt e n avo f

Pli if Tifn @ J ,LLC,wih is p icp lpa e o b sn s lc td a 1 S l a W a ,
antf, fa y )
t t rn ia lc f u i e s o ae t 5 y v n y
Pasp a , Ne J re 0 0 4 (pli t f o trfa y', a ans Dee a t 128 t e
rip ny w es y 7 5 f aùi ' r s if n ' g i t fnd n s - , h
l
f
l
Pate s i o Unn o p rtd As o it ns ie tfe o Sc d l I 'h r t (ol ciey
rn rhps r ic r o ae s cai d n iid n he u e I e eo c le tv l
o
A'
d e nt') a f l :
l nda s', s olows
Def

()
1

Pema e t nu t Reif
r n n lj nci le :
ve

De enda sa t rofi e s age s s r a s e oye s a at ne ,a a lpe s
f nt nd hei fc r , nt , e v nt , mpl e nd tor ys nd 1 rons
a tng i c
c i n once t a pa tci ton wih Def nt a e he e pe
r nd ri pai
t
enda s r r by nnane l r tane and
nty esr i d

e j ie fo
non d r m:
a.

m a ac u i orca i t be ma acur i ri a rii or
nuf t rng
usng o
nuf t ed, mpo tng, dve tsng,
pr o i diti i
om tng, srbutng, s li or ofe i t s l c e f i a
elng
f rng o el ount ret nd
i rngi goods be rng Pl i ifsta m a ks i ntfe i Pa a a 1
nfi ng
ai
antf r de r de i d n r gr ph 7

o t eCo an (h tlfa yM ak ';
f h mplit te d- fn r s)
-i

b.

usng t Tif ny M ar i co c i wih t s l ofa una horz d
i he f a
ks n nne ton t he ae
ny ut i e
goods
;

C.

usng a l
i ny ogo,a orl youtwhi h m a be c e a e t f s l a rie
nd/ a
c
y
alult d o ale y dve ts
t s r c or pr t of De e
he e vies
oduc s
f ndant ofe e f r s l or s d vi t
s f r d o ae
ol a he

domai name i ntfe on Sc
n
s de iid
hedul ( ' heet ( lci l t
e W ' r o cole tvey he
t u j c Do i Na s' a d o a y oh rwe ieo b sn s , sb ig
t be t man me ' n /r n t e bst r u ie s a en
s
)
s o e by,a ho ied by,e r e by,o i any wa as oc ae wih
pons r d
ut rz
ndo s d
rn
y s i td t
Pl i if
antf ;
f lel r pr s ntng t m s ve a be ng c mece wih Pl i if t ough
a s y e e e i he el s s i or t d t antf, hr
s o s p ora s a i
pons r hi
s ociton;

e.

e
ngagng i a a whi h i lkey t f l e y ca e m e r oft ta
i n ny ct c s i l o a s l us
mbe s he r de
a or of t pur hasng publc t b i a goods o s r i es of
nd/
he
c i
i o eleve ny
r e vc

Dee a t ofe e frs l o s dv at eSu j c Do i Nn sa do
fnd ns f rd o ae r ol i h b e t man me n / r

any ot we ie orbusnes a e i a wa e
her bst
i s r n ny y ndor e by,a oved by,
sd
ppr
a oras oc aedw ih Pli if
nd/ s i t
t a ntf;
usng a r o ton,c nt re t c
i ny epr duci
ou e f i, opy,or c o a e i t ton of t
ol r bl miai
he
Tif ny M a ks i c
fa
r n onnec i wih t publciy, pr
ton t he
it
omoton, s l or
i
ae,

a v riig o a y g o s l b Dee a t va te S b e t Do i
d e t n f n o ds od y fnd ns i h u j c man
s
Na
mesa / any ot we ie orbusne s i udi wihoutlmiai
nd or
her bst
i s , ncl ng, t
i t ton,

j wer i cu i g b a ees ne ka e , pe d n s e rig a rn s
e ly, n ld n r c lt, c lc s n a t, arn s nd ig ,
wathe cot ng a es ores na ey,c ti a ke hol r ,and g h
c s, l hi cc s i , m l uflnks nd y de s
i
boxe ,be rngt Tif ny M a ks;
s a i he fa
r

g.

afi ng,a yng,a xi or usng i c
fxi
ppl i
nne ng
i n onneci wih t s l of a
ton t he a e
ny
g ds a f s des rpton or r pr e a i i l ng wor or o he
oo , ale
ci i
e es nt ton, nc udi
ds
t r
s bol t ndi t f ley de crbe orr pr s ntg
ym s e ng o a s l s i
e e e oodsofe e f s e or
f r d or al

s l b De e d n s vi t e S b e t Do i Na s a / r a oh r
od y fn a t a h u j c man me ndo ny te
we ie o busnes ,asbeng t e ofPl i ifo i a wa e
bst r i s
i hos
antf r n ny y ndor e by
sd
Pl i if
antf;
h.

ot r s unf il c
he wie ary ompe i wih Pl i if
tng t antf ;
e f ci a sgnme sort a f r ,f mi ne e ii ora s a i or
f e tng s i
nt
r nse s or ng w nttes s ocitons
utlz ng a ot r de ce f r t pur e o c r um ve i oro her s
iii ny he vi o he pos f ic
ntng
t wie
a di t pr bii s f t a
voi ng he ohi tons et orh bove and
;
usng oft Tif ny M a ks ora c usngy sm ia ta m a ks wihi
i
he fa
r , ny onf i l i l r r de r , t n
dom an na ee e i ,m ea a orohe m a ker wihi we ie s c
i m xt nsons tt gs t r r s t n bst our e

c fo us on a web ge(ncudi ast tteofa we pa )
ode, rm e ny pa i l ng he il
ny b ge ,
a a rii lnkst ohe we ies fom s a c e nes da a e or
ny dve tsng i
o t r bst , r
e r h ngi ' t bas s
c hem e y,a a ot rf m ofus ofs h t
ac
mor nd ny he or
e uc ennswhi h i vii e t
c s sbl o
a co putr us r or s w e t die t co put s r he t we ies
m e
e
e s o r c m er ea c s o
bst
r git e by,owne or ope a e by De e nt,i l ng t l e ne
e ser d
d,
rtd
f nda s ncudi he nt r t

we stso e ai u e al fteS b e tDo i Na s
b i p rtng nd r 1o h u j c man me .
e

Addii lEquia eRele :
tona
t bl
if

(
2)
a.

I o d rt gv p a tc lef c t t Pe n n lj n to ,t e S be t
n r e o i e r ci a fe t o he nna e t n u cin h u j c
Dom an Na e ar her by or r d t be i m e i t l ta f re by
i
m s e
e
de e o
m d a e y r ns e r d
De e nt,t i a sgne a or s c s s i i er s ortte a t
f nda s her s i es nd/ uc es or n nt e t il , nd he
Regita st Pli tf co r . t e e t c r ntRe sr r do not
sr r o a n ips ntol To he xt nt he ure
gita s
f c lt t t ta f roft do an na t Pl ntf sc r wihi fve
a iiae he r ns e
he m i mes o ai if ontol t n i

( )da so r c ito t i j d me t teRe itiss alwihnt it ( 0
5 y f e ep f h s u g n ,h gsre h l, t i hry 3 )
d y ,c n eteRe ita o Re o d f rt S b e tDo i Na st a
a s ha g h gsrr f c r o he u j c man me o

Re ita o Plitf s c o sn a d ta Re ita s alta se t
gsrr f anif h o ij, n h t gsrr h l rnfr he
b.

S b e tDo i Na st Plitf;
u jc man me o anlf
Upo Plitf r q s,h tp lv ld man (
n an ifs e uet t e o e e o i TLD)Rt ity f re c o
gsr o a h f
t e Su j c Do i Na s wi n tit ( 0 d ys o r c it o t s
h b e t man me , t hry 3 ) a f e ep f hi
hi
Or e ,s al a eteSu j c Do i Nn so Re ityHod sau f r
d r h l plc h be t man me n gsr l tts o
t lf oft c r ntr sr to t r m ovi t m fom t TLD z
he ie he ur e egitai n, hus e
ng he r he
one

flsman an db t eRe ity whc ln t eS b e tDo i Nn st
ie itie y h g sr ih ik h u j c man me o
t I a es e wher t a s a e we ie ar hose a
he P ddr s s
e he s ocit d bst s e t d; nd
Upon Pli tf r ues,t I e ne Co por ton f rAs i
a n ifs eq t he nt r t r a i o sgnedN a a
mes nd

Nu e s(1 NN' s al a eala to sn c s ayt e u et a tet p
mb r 1CA( ' h ltk l cin e e s r o ns r h t h o
:
)
lv l o i Re ity rs o sbefrt eSu j c Do i Na sta se s
e e d man g sr e p n il o h be t man me r n f r
a d o d sblst S b e tDo i Na s
n /r ia e he u j c man me .
Stt or da ag :
a ut y m es

a.

St t or dama s of $81 000. i f vor of Pl i if a a i t
a ut y
ge
0, 00 n a
antf nd gans

De e da t l2 pu s a to 1 U.. j 1 1 ()j itya ds v rly f r
fn ns - 8 ru n t 5 SC. 1 7 c ,on l n e eal , o
whih lte c i is
c e xe uton s ue;

b.

1 7d ,
St t or dama i f vo ofPli tf pur ua t 1 U. C.j 1 1 ( )
a ut y
ges n a r
a n if s nt o 5 S.
a e dee mi t be:
r tr ned o
$10, 00 a i tDe e nta s. t f rwhi h 1 te c i i s
000. gans f nda xue ne , o
c e xe uton s ue;
i. $1 000. a ns Def ndan ba .om , f whi h l t e c i
i 0, 00 gai t e t votc
or
c e xe uton
is ,
s ue'

ii $1 000. a ns De e nt ec y.om , f whih lt e cuton
i. 0, 00 gai t f nda
col c
or
c e xe i
is ;
s ue

i $1 ,0 0 a ans Dee d n jwer l tc m, f r whih lt
v. 00 0.0 g i t fn a t e ly- s.o
o
c e
exe i i s
cuton s ue;

v. $30, 00 agans Def nt s
000.
i t
enda
hop4tf a c , f whih l
if ny.om or
c et
e uton is
xec i s ue;

$1 000. a i t De e
0, 00 ga ns f ndant tfanyc na a e. m , f r whi l
if a dms l co o
ch et
e cuton i s
xe i s ue;

vi. $1 0 0.0 a ans De e d nttfa y o e ly u.o f r wh c lt
i 0s0 0 g i t fn a ifn c j wer a c m, o ih e
e c i is
xe uton s ue;

v i. $1 ,0 .0 a an tDee d n tfa ye ly ult .r ,f rwh c 1t
ii 00 00 g is f n a t ifn jwer o teuo g o ih e
e c i is and
xe uton sue;

i $1 ,0 .0 a ans Dee da t wh ls ltfa ye ley.o fr
x. 00 00 g i t fn n
o e aeifn j welr c m; o
whi lte c i is
ch e xe uton s ue.

(
4)

Co t o S i: 7 0.0i f v ro Plitf a d a ans De e d n s128p ru n
ss f ut $ 0 0 n a o f an if n g i t fn a t - u s a t

t 1 U. C. 1 1 ()j it a ds v rly,o whc lt x c to is e
o 5 S. j 1 7 a ,onl n e eal f r ih e e e u in su .
y
Al f
l unds c rnty r tai d by Pa l I (û yPa1' r ltd t t Pa l
ure l esr ne
ypa, nc. ç
Pa ' eae o he ypa
)

acu t
co n

r cpe t:
e iins

tfa y a d s l@g i.o
ifn c na a ae mal m,
c

cn s e g u ng 8 g i.o
l g h n h a 8 @ mal m,
i
c
a mi d n.o
d n@a mi c m,
lo i go jwer l k i.o
o k n fre lyY r l m,
ma c
z u ig 6 mal o
h me l 6 @g i. m,
c

wu u o gl gl mal o
yo y n g @g i. m,
c

sleg iwer a o.n,
i rzse lv@yho c
v
o mg nc h o.o c
ks o @ya o c m.n,

fv ra s t i.o
a oime@homal m,
c
c yd @h t i.o
n ia omal m,
c

i x8 3 3 a oc m.n j h o o8 @homal o
mt o o @v ho .o c , o ns n z3 t i. m,
c
ta ta g g @c i.om,
inin 6 6 mal
c

ll dl g@g i.o
ii 8 mal m,
n
c

y p eh@g i.o d ynx e @g i.o lyng ol malc m, 4 8 4 6 .0
y v a mal m, a i znu malc m, u i 6 @g i.o 61 7 31 @::cm,
c
y s n e gl 8 q.o
ehu f n 6 @q c m,

s i a z 4 omal o
hpio z @h t i. m,
c

lwer d sc a sr la c i.o
' ly e in u tai@ malc m,
e
i v mv a ho s p i so elc i.o
l e fs in ho pnu tr o mal m,
o
c

li in a@v h o.o
aqa ku i a o c m,
tiws v mal o
oe k @g i. m,
c
src eg3 @ g i.o
tik r 6 mal m,
c

o e n wid ws omal o
p nic n o @h t i. m, 1 2 5 8 5 @g .0
c
9 0 6 9 6 gc m, k trna ee @c i.o
aei h ln malc m, a d
n
cz y g i.o a d a y oh rr ltd a c u t o te s me c so rs o t rs e tv
iy p@ mal m, n n te eae c o n s f h a u tmet) f he e p cie
c
Pa la ount aet bei
ypa cc , r o mmeditl ( t n5 busnes da )ta fredt Pli ifi pa ta
aey wihi
i s ys rnser o antf n ril

stsa to o t emo tr j d me te tr dh r i. y ls al r viet Plitf a tetme
aifcin f h nea y u g n n ee een Pa pa h lp o d o anif t h i
t f a er e ed,abrak
he unds r elas
e downr lctngt ()t a f r sri d i t smatr (i t
efe i he i otl unds etane n hi te ; i) he

t a c r ba ks r u ,a / ta a ton r ve s s de t d f o t f
ot l ha ge c , ef nds nd or r ns c i e r al duc e r m he undsr sr i pro
e taned i r

t rlas a (i)t t alf ndsrl s dt t Pl ntf.
o ee e; nd ii he ot u eea e o he ai if
()
6

l ees fom t daet saci wa fld s l ac r e a t l lrt Se 28
ntr t r he t hi ton s ie hal c u t he ega ae. e

U. C.j1
S. 961.
Thebond pose byPl i ifi t a ountof$1 000. i or r t ber e e
td
antf n he m
0, 00 s de ed o elas d
()
7
by t Clr
he e k.
DONE AND ORDERED i M im i Fl i t s 28 da ofM a c 201
n a , orda, hi
y
r h, 3.

#

e

PATRI A A .SE TZ
CI
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
C*
C.

A l Co e ofRe r
1 uns l
co d

5

SCH EDULE i '
$
A'
DEFENDANTS BY NUM BER ND SUBJECT DO M AI NAM ES
N
De endant
f
Number De e
f ndantNam e

1

g j wer ma c m
zse ly x.o

2
3
3
4
4

998 r dec
ta .om
a sne
xue . t
tfanybi co
if
z. m
ba .om
votc
e tfa c
cif ny.om

5
5

c dire ly o eae .o
a ej wer wh ls lrc m
mo ee ly.o
d j wer c m

6
7

c nas upple sc
hi hoes i r .om
c na l s l 688.om
hi who e ael c

8
8
8
9
9
1
0
1
0
11
1
2
1
3

ec ol com
c y.
o c rircom
ver a te .
tfa
if nygood. m
co
fr t he ps e. m
sc a al co
f le i a lco
ulr plc mal. m
goodsa. om
c
whol s e r de c
e alta 3a.om
goods a. m
aa co
he doudou. t
i
ne
i a hi
nf s onzol c
z.om

1
4
1
5

j welr f r il.o
e le y o grsc m
jwer ltc m
e ly-s.o

1
5

whol s e if ny-l tc
e altfa
s.om

1
6
1
6

j y sb rtsc m
o a - a aa .o
rplc sj y sc m
e ia -o a .o

17
1
8
1
9
20
21
22
22

ma le ia.om
lr plc c
nvr ng .om
e uic
s buyc na.om
hoes hi c
s s t r de.
hoe ciyta com
s
hop4ne klc c
c a e.om
s
hop4tfa co
if ny. m
tfa ndcoe ni c
if nya
a ng.om

22
23
24

tfa an obr e e . m
if ny dc ac ltco
sylis l om
t e tefc
tfa ana s e. m
if nyc da al co

2
5
2
6
2
7
28

tfa y o e ly u.o
if n cj wer a c m
tfa ye ly ult o g
ifn jwer o teu.r
wh ls lj wer zol .o
o eaee ly zc m
whoe aeif ye l r .o
ls ltfr jwel yc m
e

7