Humphrey v. U.S. Department of Homeland Security et al

Filing 4

ORDER DISMISSING CASE and DENYING ALL PENDING MOTIONS AS MOOT. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/22/2012.(mmd)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI T COU RT FOR THE
C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vi i

Cas Num be 1 23759- V- 0% N0
e
r: 2C1 M
KENNETH D.
HUM PHREY,e al,
/ .
Pli if ,
antfs
VS.

JANET NAPO LI
TAN O, Sec et y
r ar
De rme ofHomelnd Sec iy,
pa t nt
a
urt
Def nt
enda .
/

ORDER DI I NG CASE AND DENYI ALL PENDI M OTI
SM SSI
NG
NG
ONS AS M OOT
-

THI CAUSE c
S
amebef et Cour upon as s ee m i ton oft r or . Fort
or he
t
ua pont xa na i
he ec d
he
r as s tf t be o ,hi c ei DI I
e ons e orh l w t s as s SM SSED .Addii ly, a1pe ngm otonsar DENI
tona l 1 ndi
i
e
ED
A S M OO T.

l hsi o mapa pe i c mplitt ePlitf atmpst alg RI camsa an t h
n i nf r
u rs o an ,h an if te t o le e CO li g is t e
Unied St t De rme ofHom elnd Se urt . I r di t m a a lga i i Pl i ifs
t
aes pa t nt
a
c iy n ea ng he ny le tons n antf
c
ompli ,t Cour c
ant he
t annotdice n af der lRI c us ofa ton.
s r e a CO a e c i

Un e 2 U. C. 1 5e ( )B)i, c u tth ld s s teLn o mapa pe i a to )a
d r 8 S. j 91 ()2 ( ()a o r ç al imis h if r
s
u rs cin t
a tm ei t cou tdee m i t t. .hea ton ...i fi ouso m a ii .' Acc di t t
ny i f he r tr nes ha . t c i
s rvol
r lc ous ' or ng o he
Unie St t Supr me Cour,aco pl nti fi ous' r i lc a a guabl ba i i lw or
td aes
e
t
m ai s rvol ' e t a ks n r
whe
e ss n a
i f t' Neiz e v Wilams, U . 31 , 325( 989) dicusi dimis sunder or rs to
n ac .
' t k . li
490 S. 9
1 ( s sng s sal
f me ecin

1 5d) whih co ane t s me lngua a cure scton 1 15( ( ( (). A co tma
91 ( , c nti d he a a ge s rnt e i 9 e)2)B)i)
ur y
dimiscl msunders ton 1 5()2)B)i wheet cli r ton a i s a ymeil s
s s ai
eci 91 e ( ( () r he ams es
n ndiputbl rtes
l ga t or ora ecomprs off cua con e i t ta e cea l bas es . 1 a 327.
e l he y r
ied a t l t ntons ha r l ry el s d. t

I Ne tke t Supr m eCour pr de s ve a e mpl soffi o orm ai i cai .
n iz , he
e
t ovi d e r l xa e
rvol us
lcous l ms

W he e t defndanti cl ry i mune fo s t orwher t pl ntf alegesi rnge e ofa
r he e
s ea l m
r m ui,
e he ai if l
nfi m nt
lga i er s whih obvi l doe note s,he t cl m i f
e l nt e t c
ousy s
xit t n he ai s oundedonani s t bl m e il s
ndipu a y rte s
lgalt or I a 327. Cl ms de alng f nt tc ordel i
e he y. d. t
ai
t ii a asi
usonals na i fti o t f t ly
ce ros i nt he ac ua l

ba ees caeg y.l a 3 28.Fi ly, hi Cour alo no est tapr s pl i ifmus begi n
s l s t or d. t 27na l t s
t s t ha
o e antf
t
ve

g e trle yi pla n h rc mpan .Han sv Ke n r 4 4U. 51 ( 97 )
r ae e wa n e dig e o lit ie . r e , 0 S. 9 1 2 .

M id u o t s p icpe , h Co r p o e d t e laePlitf si f r pa pe i
n f l f he e rn ils t e u t r c e s o vau t anif n o ma u rs
c pl i . Pl ntf com pl ntcont nsa lt ofa l ga i aga ns t Gove nm ent M uc of
om a nt ai ifs
ai
ai
iany le tons i t he
r
.
h

t c
he ompl nti i ohe enta ev a t a c r ulr vi i i difc tt fnd ale i t
ai s nc r
nd en fer a ef e ew t s fi ul o i
lgatons hat

s
uppor ac eofa ton u rt c vi RI sa ut Pli ifscompli i fi ousunde 28
t aus
c i nde he i l CO tt e. antf
ant s rvol
r

U. C. 1 5 e( )B)i b c u eid e n t o ti 'nag a eba i i 1w o i fc . Netk ,
S. j 91 ()2 ( () e a s t o s o c n an ' r u bl ss n a r n a t' i e
a
' z
490 U . a 327. Afe r vi ng t e ie c
S. t
tr e ewi he ntr ompli ,t Cour concudest tt cli s a e
ant he
t
l
ha he am r
i s a y me ils .Ac di y,ti
ndiput bl rte s cor ngl i s
ADJUDGED t tt s ca e i DI I
ha hi s s SM SSED ,a a lpendi motons a e DENI AS
nd 1
ng
i
r
ED
M OOT. Thi c e i CLOSED.
s as s

o xEx oo uoic-b--ui sli,ipp--ot-,o2
o x =s - h---t - r-d t- yf-b-21.
-i --h
.-

FEDE
.
0
UN I D STATES D I
T
STRI J G E
CT UD
Copispr de t
e ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d

-

2-