Building Empowerment By Stopping Trafficking Inc. v. Jacobo et al
Filing
30
ORDER granting 15 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 9/27/2013. (err)
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORJ
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 23925- V- OI ENO
e
r: 2CI M t
BUI N G EM POW ERM ENT BY STOPPI
LDI
NG
TRAFFI NG,I ,
CKI
NC.
Pl ntf ,
ai if
ESTHER J
ACOBO an M ARY CAGLE,
d
D e e nt
f nda .
O RDER G RANTI M OTI N TO DI I
NG
O
SM SS
Pl ntf, l ngEmpowe
ai ifBuidi
nnent St ngTrfiki I . '
by oppi afc ng,nc ('
BEST',saFl i no
' i orda n)
pr i c por tont tpr des / bonol lr pr e ai a c tfe lf coa hi s wiest
oft or a i ha ovi rr
ega e es nt ton nd erii d ie c ng el c o
vitm so s xtafc ng.BEST a s pr de tani s r c t fr t es
c i f e r fi ki
l o ovi s r i ng e vies o is r ponde s lw e or e e ,
r ,a nf c m nt
Iwy r a dj dg s BES d srst o e a l g tr s f h s f rsx ta fc i v ci .
a es n u e .
T e ie o p n on -em a e ou e o e rfikng itms
Def nda , t rJ cobo,i t Re o lM ana rf t Sout n Re on f t De rme of
e nt Eshe a
s he gi na
ge or he
her gi or he pa t nt
Chidrna Fa les(' '. enda M ayCa ei t saewi die t f t De rme
l e nd mii '
DCF' Def nt r gl s he tt de rcor or he pat nt
)
ofChidr n a Fa le . Pl i tf t c
l e nd mii s a n ips wo- ountco pl i a lgesa vi a i ofPl i ifsci l
m ant le
olton
antf
vi
rght unde 42U. C.j1 bec us iwa iwasde i oft alge rg t pat wiht
i s r
S. 983 a e t s t
prved he le d ihto rner t he
De rmentofChidr n a Fa iis The Pli ifalo brngsasa ecli f de a ton.
pa t
l e nd m le .
antf s i
tt a m or f ma i
Pl ntf a l gest D e e nt ast s r s s ofa a r y ofchid wela e s i est
ai if le
hat f nda s he upe vi or
n ra
l
f r enzc o
c l e a
hidr n ndyounga t,lega l ondii
duls il lyc tonedt De rme ' consde atonof
he pa t nts
i r i
BESTaSas r i e
e vc
pr de on iswilngnes t wor wih KrsiHous anon- ofte iy t tpr dess r i st
ovi r t li
so
k t it
e,
pr i ntt ha ovi e vce o
s xua l ab e yout i M im i Fl i l addii Pl ntf cai sDe e nt s e f s a
e ly us d
h n a , orda. n
ton, ai if l m
f nda s pr ad ale nd
f ndant s ea f s a
s pr d ale nd
s xualy a edyo hi M i , orda.I a ton, a n ifc am sDe e
e l bus
ut n ami Fl i n ddii Pli tf l i
de a aor sae e sr ga di BEST' pr sde ,Li J.Suli n,i a e f tt unde ne
f m t y t tm nt e r ng
S e i nt nda
lva n n for o
nni
BEST a dicour geus ofBEST' s l c s.
nd s a
e
S ewi e
TheCour hol t t heCompli f ist esa ih a c tt i vi ai a t t he
t ds ha t
ant a l o t bls ny onsiutonal ol ton nd ha t
Defnda saee ildt Qualfe l
e nt r ntte o
iid mmuniy. rf e,CountIi dimis d. Cour f t
t Theeor
s s se The
t urher
d cie t e e cs s p lme tlu idito o e tesaecam i Co n 1 a dtee o eds se
e l so x rie u pe n aj rs cin v rh tt li n u t1 n h r f r imiss
n
t tcoun a wel, t lavet fl i sa ec ti a oprat
ha
t s l wih e
o ie n t t our f ppr i e.
A.Oualte l muniv
i dm
i
t
The q lfe i muniy de e em a ber s d a a e s on am oton t dim is and
uaii d m
t f ns y aie nd ddr s ed
i o s s,
wilbegr t d i t c pli Sf l t al get vi ai ofac e ry e tbls d consiu i
l
an e f he om a nt kais o le he olton
l a l sa ihe
tt tonal
rght' Smihv Sigeman,322F. l 1 ( 1hCi.2003)( i Wilamsv Al St e
i . t . e l
'
3d 290,294 1 t r
quotng li . a. at
Uni. 1 2F. 11 11 ( 1h Ci.2003).Thedocrnepr e t goverme ofiil s di
v, 0 3d 79, 82 1 t r
)
ti otcs
n nt fcas ue n
t ri vi c pa ii asl a t i conduc doe no vi a ek e ry esabls saut y
hei ndi dual a ctes ong s he r
t s t olt f a l t ihed t t or
cl
orc tt i rght ofwhih aras bl pe s woul have110w1. I ( i Haro v
onsiutonal i s
c e ona e ron
d
1, 15 d. quotng lw .
1 '
Fiz r d, U. 8 81 (98 ) s' pur eoft si
tge al 457 S. 00, 8 1 2).S-he pos hi mmuniyi t al g nme
f
t s o low over nt
ofi i l t c ry outt rdic e i r duteswihoutt f a ofperonalla lt orha as i
tc as o a r
hei s r tona y i
t
he e r
s
ibiiy
r sng
ltg ton. Viyar v lon, 1F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.
iiai ' n d .Wis 31 3d 340, 346 1 t r 2002)( i Le v Fe r o,28
'
quotng e . r ar 4
y 'he anl ncompe e ort ewho knowi y
t nt hos
ngl
F. 11 11 ( 1hCi. 2).Onl kt pli y i
3d 88, 94 1 t r 200 )
vo aet lw'aes b e tt la ii Ch se v S r s 2 8F.d 1 1 ,1 2 ( 1hCi. 0 )
ilt he a ' r u j c o ib ly. e s r . pa k , 4 3 l 7 1 2 1 t r 2 01
t
( i Male v.Brggs 475U. 3 3 1( 98 )
quotng ly
i ,
S. 35, 4 1 6).
1 We eDee
. r fndant ac iq wihi t s peqft rdicr i ar aut iv?
s tn t n he co
hei s eton v hort
.
To es a i h a qua ii d i m uniy def ns ,( he publc of i i m us tr tpr t the
t bls
lfe m
t
e e i
t
i f c al t i s ove ha
wa a tng wihi t s opeofhi dic e i r a ho iy whe t alege y wr ula t
s ci
t n he c
s s r tona y ut rt
n he l dl ongf c s
oc ure 'Viyar 311F. a 1 ( i Lee, F. a 11 ) kToa twihi t s ope
c rd. n d,
'
3d t 346 quotng
284 3d t 94).i c t n he c
ofdicrtonaya hort mea t t'heacinswee( )unde tke purua t t
s ei r ut iy ns ha t to
r 1
ra n s nt o he
p ro ma c o gh o fca'ld te a d( ) t i t es o eo ( s a t rt ' Cole v
ef r n e f t e fiils u is n 2 wihn h c p f hi! uho i ' lir .
y.'
Dikis 477F. 1 1 n.1( 1hCi.2007)( i Len v Wi r 51F. 1
c n on,
3d 306, 308
1t r
quotng z . nbu n, 3d 540,
1 45( 1hCi.1 )
5 1 t r 995).
The a lga i i t scompli e t bls t tJ c and Ca e a ehi lve DCF
le tons n hi
ant sa ih ha a obo
gl r gh-e l
ofi i l l i a r fom t f eoft c
fc as. t s ppa ent r he ac
he ompli t tDe e nt wer a i wihi t i
ant ha f nda s e ctng t n her
dic e i r a hort whe t y metwih Pl i ifa lsene t BEST' r ques t pa t r
s r tona y ut iy
n he
t antf nd it d o
S e t o rne
wiht De rm e .Thede son t r r t tBEST bewilngt pa t rwih KrsiHous
t he pa t nt
cii o equie ha
li o rne t it
e
i o isf c onet tf lswihi t Def nda s e c i f ton. Ta ng t a lga i i
s n t ae
ha al t n he e nt ' xe utve unc i
ki he le tons n
t lghtmos f a e t t Pli if t Cour fndst tDef nt we e a tng wihi t r
he i
t avor bl o he antf, he
t i ha
enda s r c i
t n hei
di c e i r a hort
s r tona y ut iy.
J. Do t ale i s e t ih anv cons iuto vi atons?
he l gaton s abls
tt i nal ol i
Onc t publc ofi a esa ihest ts wasac i wihi hi dic etonal a hort
e he
i tcil t bls ha he
tng t n s s r i y ut iy,
t bur n s hst t pl ntf t de onsr t t qualfe i uniy i nota oprae.Fis,
he de hi o he ai if o m ta e hat ii d mm t s
ppr i t r t
t Cour mus deer ne whet rt a lgatons i tue, t bls a c tt i lvi aton.
he
t t t mi
he he le i , f r esa ih ons iutona ol i
Rehb r v Paul 611F. 8 838- (l1hCi.201 . l t r i avi ai ofa
e g . k,
3d 28, 39 t r 0) f hee s olton
c tt i lrghtunde t pl ntf sve son oft f t t ne s nta se i t as
onsiutona i
r he ai if r i
he acs,he xt eque il t p s o k
whehert rg wasclary e t ihe l
t he i ht
e l sabls d. d
a. DuePr s Cl msî
oce s ai
BEST a lgesi peri ntpa tt tDef nda shavedenid BEST' pr e ala
le n tne
r ha
e nt
e
S oc dur nd
s t ntveduepr e srght unde t Fouree h Ame
ubsa i
oc s i s
r he
t nt
ndme sbe aus De e ntCa e t d
nt c e f nda
gl ol
BEST t tDCF woul notc i rBEST a aparne f rDCF a as r i epr de f vi tm s
ha
d
ons de
s
t ro
s e v c ovi r or ci
ofs x ta fc ng unl s BEST wor w ih Kr s iH ous c or sis p ogr m t one appr
e r f i ki
es
ks t i t
e, onf m t r a o
oved
by KrsiHous ,a i ts tone ' KrsiHous die t Tr Novi ki Addii l
it
e nd s sanc i d'by it
e r c or udy
c .
tonaly,
Pl i ifa l st tDef ntJ cobo S ondii d' D CF' cons de a i of BEST asa s r i
a ntf lege ha
enda a
k
c
tone '
S
i r ton
e v ce
pr vi ron BEST' wilngne st wor wih KrsiHous TheCour agr eswih t
o de
S li s o k t it
e.
t e
t he
Def nda st tt s alegai nsdonots fc t e tbls aco tt tonal pr t ctd pr t
e nt ha he e l to
ufi e o sa ih
nsiu i ly- o e e opery
i er s . Si pl t r i no f der ly pr e e r ghtt t r ne ' w ih D CF or t be a s vi ent e t m y, he e s e a l ot ct d i o s t r' t
pa
o
er c
pr de f D CF.
ovi r or
The DuePr es Clus pr e t agans de i tonsof lbe t orpr ry.H u e v
oc s a e ot c s i t prva i
i ry
ope t
nt r .
Fl iaPar et Pr i Comm ',674F. 847,848( 1h Ci.1 .Sl s tntve
ord
ol : obaton
t
n
2d
1 t r 982) i' ubsa i
-he
c
ompone oft DuePr es Cl epr e st erght t ta e 'undame a , t ti,rght
nt he
oc s aus otct hos i s ha r f
ntl' ha s i s
t a e Sm plci i t c e ofor r d lbe t ''M c n y v Pat 20 F. 1
hat r i i t n he onc pt
de e i r y.' Ki ne . e,
3d 550,1
556
(11h Ci.1 4)( i Palov Conneciut 302U. 31 325(1 .lFunda nt rght
t r 99 quotng k .
tc ,
S. 9,
937) i
me al i s
ar t e c e t d by t Cons iuton. Sander v H e y Cn/ ,GJ. 48 Fed.App' 395,398
e hos r a e
he
tt i '
'
s . nr
y.
, 4
x.
(11h Ci. 2) TheSande sCour e ane t as tntveduepr es cli i notvibl
t r201 .
r
t xpli d hat ubsa i
oc s am s
ae
whe i i pr dia e on a non-e sai de i ton ofasat- a eda de i d pr ry
n t s e c td
lgil tve prva i
t e gr nt nd fne ope t
lThe Cour i a a e t t i is Res
t s w r ha , n t
pons t Def nts M oton t Di m i s Pl ntf
eo
enda '
i o s s , ai i f
s a est t' tdoesnoto
t t ha '
i
ppos de e
e f ndan s a gum e s w ih r pec t t due pr es ale tons
t' r
nt t es t o he
oc s l ga i
i t com pl nt'The Cour w ilne r he es a es t due pr s a gum en s t tap ri
n he
ai .'
t l ve t l s ddr s he
oce s r
t ha pea n
t Com pl i .
he
a nt
r g . d. il si s e n w he e t pl i ifa l gest tt gove n e ,a tng i a noni ht 1 i - s o ve
-hi
r he a ntf le
ha he
r m nt c i n
lgiltvec pa iy,a t d a bir rl a ir tona l ' 1 The El nt Cic tclrfe t t
e sa i a ct c e r ta iy nd rai ly. d.
'
eve h r ui a ii d ha
c rss d tea s tntvedue pr es cai sS ediatd on a a bir r and ir tonal
ou t houl r t ubsa i
oc s l m é c e
pr
n r ta y
ra i
de i ton ofapr ry i e e t'a apr e alduepr s cai .I Pl ntf scl m t i
prva i
ope t nt r s' s oc dur
oce s l m d ai if ai hat t
c d notparne wih DCF i t sc e, fi exit a al i e c l t t- oner ed i
oul
t r t
n hi as i t ss t l, s xa ty ha
oot n
pr e a d pr e s Havi f
oc dur l ue oc s .
ng ound t tPli tf ca
ha a n if nnotesa ih as t ntvedue pr es
t bls ubsa i
oc s
c a m ,t Co te m i t scl m i t c e ofpr e aldue pr s .
l i he ur xa nes hi ai n he ont xt
oc dur
oce s
il a s s i acli ba e on a al ge de a ofp o dur lduepr e s a coul m us
in s e sng am s d
n le d ni l r ce a
oc s ,
'
t
t
frtde i e whe he t c
is c d
t r he ompli ng pa t hasbee de i d ofa c tt i ly pr ece
ani
ry
n prve
onsiutona l ot td
lbe t orpr ry i e es .Abs nts h de i i t r c n be no de alofdue pr e s ''
i ry
ope t nt r t
e uc prvaton, he e a
ni
oc s .
Ec n mi De eo n Cop. fDa Co ny I . . te h i 78 F.d 9 2 9 3 5 ( 1hCi.
o o c v lpme t r o de u t nc v S ir em, 2 2 5 , 5 - 4 1 t r
1 .l t r i ade i ton,heCour mus t n de i i t saepr de t pr es t t
986) f hee s prvai t
t t he cde f he tt ovi d he oc s ha
wasdue. 1 78 F. a 955.
J. 2 2d t
TheCour mus de e mi i Pli tf sa lga i s tc t esa ih apr ry i e e t
t t t r ne f a n if le tons ufs e o t bls
ope t ntr s.
Fl i saelw dei t paameesofaPlitf spr ry i ees unde j1
orda tt a tnes he r tr
anif ope t ntr t r 983.Ke We t
y s
Ha b rDe . r v Ci o y Fe fFI.9 7F.d7 3 7 7( 1h Ci. 9 ) A u iae a
r ou v Cop. . t fKe y, a, 8 2 2 , 2 1 t r 1 93 . nltr l
y
i e e ti s c i agove nm e con r c doe notcr a eapr t i e es e il t
nt r s n e urng
r nt ta t s
et
opery nt r t ntted o
p o e u a d ep o e su d rFlrdalw.# ' i o Cm/. a t, n . . p 'o i r nt
rcd rl u res n e oi a
s pf r y He Ih I c v De t fchl e t
h
d
Famiis, So. 11 ,1l ( a. hDCA 201 (s la ha noe tt i l
le 93 3d 91 93 Fl 4t
2) d
appelnt s onsiutonaly
pr t c e pr ry i e es i a c r c w hi h w a notawar d t i.' ; o g nt o tt
o e t d ope t nt r t n ont a t c
s
de o t ' Bd fRe e s fsa e
)
Cole sv 20t 408U. 5 5 77( 97 (1 ha apr ry i ees i abe i,apes
lge . h,
S. 64, 76- 1 2) t
To ve ope t ntr t n nett ron
cla l m us ha mor t n a a ta tne d orde ief i. H e m us ha m or t n a
e ry
t ve e ha n bsr c e
sr or t
t ve
e ha
S aue .Unv o Fl.Col geo r ig v S ae De ' o a t, 1 S 2 5 2 5 4( a
ttts i. fs. a l fNusn . t t, p t fHe lh 8 2 o. d 7 , 7 Fl.
e
.
2 DCA 2002)
d
.
M i uloft s prnci es t Cour r e s Pl i if s a l ga i . The c pl ntdoes
ndf
he e i pl , he
t evi w
a ntf le tons
om ai
note n a lget tBEST a id f acon r c wih DCF a t tDef nt denid a
ve le ha
pple or
ta t t
nd ha
enda s
e n
a i a i ora bi t c r c w ih D CF. A l i a l ge i t tBEST r ques e a a i ton
pplc ton
d o ont a t t
l t le s s ha
e
t d n pplca i
f m,a t ta oft dae oft c pl nthad no r ceved one.The ot a lga i onl
or nd ha s he t
he om ai
te i
her le tons y
esabls t tt De e
t ih ha he f ndan ss i t tBEST woul ne d t wor wih KrsiHo e. W ihout
t ad ha
d e o
k t it us
t
m or t Cour c nno fnd t s ale tonss fci ntt e t bls a cons iut ona l pr e t d
e, he
t a t i he e l ga i
ufi e o s a i h
tt i ly ot c e
pr ry i e e tora vi a i ofPl ntf spr dur ld pr es .
ope t nt r s
ol ton
ai i f oce a ue oc s
b Fist e e Cl m
. r Am ndm nt ai
Pli ifsFis Amendme cai i c
antf
rt
nt l m s onvol e a notc e ry saed.Pe ha ,t
ut d nd
lal tt
r ps he
Pl i ifi a t m ptng t m a a c ai offe s ch r ala i l s t s a e s h a cl i ,
a ntf s te i o ke l m
r e pee et i ton. f o, o t t uc
am
BEST mus pl diss e wa ( )c tt i l pr e td;( t defnda ' r t it y
t ea t pe ch s 1 onsiutonaly otce 2) he e nts ealaor
c dud a rey afde t pr e tds ec a ( t r i aca a conne onbewee t
on
dve sl fe d he otce pe h; nd 3) hee s us l
di t n he
r t la or a i a t a
e a i t y ctons nd he dver e e f c on s e h. Be t v H e i 423 F. 1
s f e t pe c
nne t . ndr x,
3d 247,1
250
( 1hCi.2005)Tostsyt s ondpr oft sts ' pl ntf s fr a rea i it
1t r
. aif he ec
ong hi e t' ai if ufes dves cton f he
A
de enda ' al ge y r t it y c
f nt le dl e ala or onduc woul lkey detra pe s ofor nar fr
s
t
di l e
r on
di y imnes fom
sr
t e r i e ofFis A m e
he xe c s
rt
ndm e r ght . I a 1 4.
nt i s' d. t 25
'
The aleg tons do nots fce t es a i h t t ee pr Benne tt t N ot ng i t
l ai
uf i o t bls he hr - ong
t es .
hi n he
Com pl n s a e Def nt t of i i a i a i tBEST bec us ofis vi w s A tm os , he
ai t t t s enda s ook fc al cton ga ns
a e t e .
tt
a l ga i sa e t D e e
le tons t t hat f ndant e ged i a ds e r'c m pa gn a i tisPr s dent w hi h had
s nga
n sm a ' a i ga ns t e i , c
ac li e f tofbl ng BEST' publcco m e ton t is ofwhe he s x ta fc ng
hilng fec
ocki
S
i m n
he s ue
t r e r fi ki
-
6-
Compli satsDe e
ant t e f ndan st ofi a a ton a ns BEST b a eofisvi . m os, he
t ook fcil c i gai t
ec us
t ews At t t
ale tonssaet tDef nt e
lga i t t ha
enda s ngage i a ' m e r' a pa gn a ns isPr i nt whih ha
d n û a 'c m i gai t t esde , c d
s
a chilng e f c ofbl ki BEST' publc c m e On t i s ofwhet s t a f c ng
li f e t
oc ng
S
i om nt he s ue
her ex r f i ki
vitmss d ber e e ed b pr bono c
c i houl
epr s nt y o
ouns lo by anon- tonwy s e t d by KrsiHous
e r
at
elc e
it
e.
Atm os , a ntf s a esD e e
t Pl i if t t
f ndant s ntoutt o em aisdi a e i w ih BEST' dphios
s e
w
l s gr e ng t
S û l ophy.
'
'
Ce t i y, he e ale tonsdo notes a ih Def nt ac ed i a r t i t y w a t adve s l
r a nl t s l ga i
t bls
enda s t n e ala or
yo
r ey
afec pr ec e s ec N o do t s alega i es a ih a c us c m e ton be we t
f t ot t d pe h. r he e l tons t bls
a al or c i
t en he
r t la or a ton a t a
e a i t y c i nd he dver e e f c on s e h asr r d b Benne t Thus Pl ntf ha
s f e t pe c
equie y
t.
, ai if s
f l d t sa e a c ai f 1 t
aie o t t l m or s
l i alo w el- e te t tt s vi a def ns ofqualf e i m uniy,i i us be obvi
ts s
ls tl d ha o ur ve
e e
ii d m
t tt t
m
ous
t e r ra ona epes i ghedee ts plcet ghedee
o vey e s bl ron n t fndan 'l a hat t fndantsc
' onduct woul vi ae
l d olt
fde a l ' Be e dv Olon,84F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.l .Theei noc et t
e r law. aurgar . s
'
3d 402, 404 1 t r 996)
r s as ha
Pl ntf co d i ntf t w oul putDef nt on notc t tt cont s oft re a l
ai if ul de iy hat
d
enda s
i e ha he
ent
hei m is
w oul S i l de e a per on ofor na y fr ne s fom t e r s ofFis A m endm e rght .
d i ke y t r
l
s
di r im s r he xe ci e
rt
nt i s'
'
Benne t 423 F. a 1
t,
3d t 250.
Ha ng f
vi ound t Pl i if s a l ga i f i t es a ih any c tt i
he a ntf le tons a l o t bls
ons iutonalvi a i oft
ol ton he
Fis Am e e ,t Cour fnds t Def nda sar e il d t qua i e i m uniy.
rt
ndm nt he
t i he
e nt e ntte o lt d m
i
t
c 11 h Am e e I univ
. t
ndm nt mm t
De enda s ha f t ra gued t y a e pr ec ed f om s tu rt 11 h a e
f
nt ve ur he r
he r ot t r
ui nde he t m ndm e .
nt
' to 1 3 pr de a f de alf u t r m e m a de i tonsofci llbe te ,bu i doe
Sec i n 98 ovi s e r or m o e dy ny prva i
vi i ri s t t s
notpr de a f r f um f ltga s who s ek a r m e aga ns a St t f ale
ovi
ede al or or ii nt
e
e dy i t a e or l ged
de i tonsofci llbe tes The El ven h Am e
prva i
vi i ri .
e t
ndm e bar s s t unl st St t ha
nt s uch uis es he a e s
wav di i nt . Wi v M ihi nDe . fs aePoie 4 U. 5 , 6( 9 9 .' i e a
ie t mmu iy' l . c ga pto t t lc , 91 S. 8 6 1 8 ) ' t r
s
' l
Ne h
saenorisofi asa ngi t rofi a c pacte ae' s 'unde j 1 'I a 71.
tt
t tcil di n hei tcil a iis r ' ons' r 983. d. t A
per
'
na r e e i e ssunderEx Pare Y
row xc pton xit
t oung t t' ti pe m isf de a e t t e e ti
ha ' rne r t e r l ours o nt ran
doc
s t a i tsaeofi e ss e ngpr pe ie e t bl r le t e c i ng vi ai of
uis gans t t tc r e ki
os ctv quia e e if o nd ontnui
oltons
fd r la 'Mce d v Ga. pt o mmu i He t 2 F.d 1 5 ,1 5 ( lhCi.
e ea lw. ln on , De . fco nt al 61 3 2 2 2 6 1 t r
'
y
h,
2001;ExPareYoun 209U. 1 ( 908 .
)
t
g,
S. 23 1 )
TheCompl nti ose i y sr t e agans t De e
ai s t nsbl tuc ur d i t he f ndant i t i i vi l
s n he r ndi dua
c pa t I ed, he Fl i D e rm e ofChidr a Fa ii s i nota pa t t t s t
a ciy. nde t
or da pa t nt
l en nd m le s
ry o he ui.
N e r he e s Cou 1 oft Com pl nti a i t' e nt J cobo a D CF' A s
ve t l s , nt 1 he
ai s ga ns ' nda s a
Def
nd
'
.
de onsr td i t abovea yss Pli ifhasf ld t aleg c
m tae n he
nal i, antf
aie o l e onductt vi a e f de allw .
hat olt s e r a
Thus i f lsouti oft e e i unde Ex Par e Youn Ther f e, hee e t tPl i ifs
, t al sde he xc pton
r
t
g.
e or t xt nt ha antf
Compl i i agans t DCF o a i tDe enda si t i ofi i lca iy, i i ba r d by t
ant s i t he
r gans f nt n her fc a pact t s r e
he
11 h A m e en .
t
ndm t
B . a e La De a a i Cl m
St t w f m ton ai
Ha ngf
vi oundt tt Dee nt ha qualfe i
ha he fnda s ve iid mmuniyf Pli ifsj1 cams
t or antf 983 li ,
t eCo r d cie t e ecs s p e na j rs i o u d r28U. C. 1 6 o e P an if
h u t e l s o x rie u plme t lu id di n n e
n
S. j 3 7 v r litf s
sae1 defmai cams 28U. C.j l c( ; eg.Rane v Alsat I .Co.370F.d
tt aw a ton li .
S.
367()3) See .
y . lt e ns ,
3
1 1 89( 1hCi.
086, 088- 1 t r 2004)
.
I .Concl on
V
usi
Fort above r as ,t Cour f ndst tD e enda s ha qua ii d i m uniy, and t
he
e ons he
t i ha f
nt d
lfe m
t
hat
Pl i iff ied t s a e a cl i f vi a i ofdue pr e s orf Fis A m endm en r t la i .
a ntf a l o t t
a m or ol tons
oc s
or r t
t e a i ton
Def ndant M oton t D i m i si her by G RAN TED .
e
'
s
i o s s s e
Z
T ' ofSept r,
da
y
embe
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a M im i Fl i ,t
n
mbe s t a , orda hi
201
3.
'
.
.r
'
A
RI A . O REN O
CO M
I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi sp ovi d t
e r de o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?