Doe v. University of Miami et al

Filing 42

ORDER Denying 24 Motion to Remand to State Court Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 12/27/2012. (jw)

U NI
TED STA TES DISTR I C O URT
CT
SO UTH ERN DI
STR I O F FLO RI A
CT
D
CA SE N O .1 23933- V- l G
2C1 K N

MI
CHA EL J ES ATTEA ,
AM
Pl i if
a ntf,

UN I
VERSI OF M I I( I
TY
AM M LLER
SCHOOL OF M EDI NE) A CAREER
CI ,
COUN SELI G CEN TER ,I , d/ a
N
NC , b/ /
PHY SI AN ' D EVELOPM EN T PROGRAM ,
CI
S
LAW REN CE HARM ON ,PH D . &
,
A SSOCI
ATES,P. . LA W REN CE HA RM O N,
A,
ROBERT HERN AN DEZ,M . . M ARK
D ,

O'
CONNELL, . ,
M D.GONZALO QUESADA,
M . , A.GONZALO QUES
D. P. ,
ADA,
and A NA CA M PO,M . .
D,

Def nt .
enda s
/
OR DER D ENY I G M O TI N TO R EM AND TO STA TE CO UR T
N
O

TH I M ATTER com es bef e t Cour upon Pl ntf s M oton t Re and t
S
or he
t
ai i f
i o m
o

S a eCo r ( # ,fld No mbe 2 201 TheCo r i bre e on t m at r lyo
t t u t DE 24) ie ve r 9, 2.
u t s i f d he te . r
t r onsdicus ed bel Pl ntf M oton i deni
he eas
s s
ow, ai ifs
i s
ed.
Pl ntf orgi l fl t s cas i t 11 h J ci Cicui Cour f M i m i
ai if i naly ied hi
e n he t udi al r t
t or a Da Count a l gi vi a i
de
y, le ng ol tons of f al a s a e l w .2 Pl ntf s r
eder nd t t a
ai i f e ved m os
t

'De e da sfld aRe p ns ( /:1 o De e e 1 , 2. an ifsRe y( #37 wa fld
f n nt i
e
s o e DE / ) n c mb r 2 201 Plitf' pl DE ) s ie
1
Dece ber24.
m

2Pli ifsfvec un Co an ( #1 1 alg s vi a i softeAme ia wihDia lte Ac of
antf' i -o t mplit DE - ) le e : olton
h
rc ns t s biiis t
1 9 ( u t1 a teRe a l ainAc o 1 7 ( nt1) b e c o fdu aydu is( n 11;
9 0 Co n ) nd h h bii to t f 9 4 Cou 1; r a h f i cir te Cou t 1)
t
b e c o c ta ta i tDe e da UM ( n l ;a bra hofc ta ta is De e da t
r a h f onr c gans f n nt
Cou t V) nd e c
onr c gan t f n ns

Def nt on Oct
enda s
ober 4,201 Def
2; endant M ar O '
k Connel was s ved on Oct r 8,
l
er
obe

2 2, a d t e t Que a De e da t we e no s r e u i Nov mbe 5, 201
01 n h wo
s da f n n s r t e v d ntl
e r
2.

De e n s tld No ie o Re va ( #1 o Ocobe 3 2 1 a s ri f e a
fnda t se
tc f mo l DE ) n t r 0, 0 2, s e tng ed r l

q si n j id ci n un r 28 U. C.j 1 31 The No ie ofRe va al g d t ta l
ue to urs ito de
S.
3 .
tc
mo l le e ha l
Def nda scons nt t r m ova .H ow e ,D ef nda A Ca e Couns i Cent r a
e nt
e ed o e
l
ver
e nt
r er
elng
e nd
t H a m on D ef nda s di not sgn t N otce of Rem ovalnor di t fl t r own
he r
e nt d
i he
i
d hey ie hei

n tc o r mo l t e Que a a De e nt wee n tc ule b t o he De e a t
o ie f e va ; h
s d fnda s r o ons t d y he t r f nd n s

a di no j i t e flng. ( N ovem ber 9, 2 2,De e a t A Ca e r Co ns lng
nd d t o n h ii 3 )n
01
f nd n
r e u ei
Ce t r a t Ha mo De e a s fld No ie ofCo e tt Re o l( #8 a d
n e nd he r n f nd nt ie
tc
ns n o m va DE ) n

No i e o J i r( #9; /1 ) t Que a De e n s fld Notc o Co e tt
tc s f onde DE DE / 0 ; he s da fnda t ie
ie f ns n o

Re va ( # )a No ie ofJ nd r( # o De e e 4,201 Pl itf n w
mo l DE 25 nd tc
oi e DE 26) n c mb r
2. an if o
s ks r m and alegi t t Def nt ' r ovalw as untm el beca e i w as not fl d
ee e
l ng ha
enda s em
i y
us t
ie
w ihi t ry daysoft fr tD ef nda bei s r on O c obe 4,2012.
t n hit
he i s
e nt ng e ved
t r
The f r r ovalsat e i t be srcty i e r ed.Shamrock O i & Gas Cor
ede al em
t ut s o
t i l nt m et
l
p.

S es 31 U. 1 1 -0 61 S.Ct 8 ( 9 ) s el Cor v Am.Ho
he t, 3 S. 00, 08 9,
. 68 1 41 ;Ru s l p. .
me
As u an e Co ,2 F.d 1 40 ( 1h Ci. 1 .
s r c . 64 3 0 1 t r 200 ) Unde 28 U. C.j 1 ( ,a n tc o
r
S.
446 b) o i e f
r m ovalm us be fl wihi t ry days of t def ndantr ei ng a copy ofpl adi
e
t
ied t n hit
he e
ec vi
e ngs

t ta er mo b e ûl u n miy r er q r st talde e nt c ns n t a dj n a
ha r e va l . s- na i t ul e uie ha l fnda s o e t o n oi
-he
notce ofr m ovali or f i t be ef e i ' Baie v.Jans Phar
i
e
n der or . o
t
f ctve.' ly
sen
maceutca,I .
i nc ,

Ph iin' De eo ntPr r m,La e c Hamo a Go aoQue a ( un V) Pl ntf'
ysca s v lpme og a
wr n e r n, nd nz l
sda Co t . ai ifs
Compl ntlssbot CountI a CountV s at y askcountl .'
ai it h
V nd
epar el
s
V'
3Def dant Res et t i t M oton s aes:(l t NotceofRe oval t Uni st
m
en s' pons o he nsant i t t tn he i
ver iy
, he

De e d nt mitke y sae t tt Qu s d Dee a t co e tdt rmo lAtt tmeo t e
f n a s sa nl ttd ha he e a a fnd n s ns ne o e va . he i f h
Notc couns f t Uni siy De endant beleved t taI r ni def
ie,
el or he ver t f
s i
ha l emai ng endant wer r ese ed by
s e epr nt

c ns l o t eHamon De e a t. ( /31 p. n.1 .
ou e f r h r
f nd ns' DE / , 3, )
'

5 6 F.d 1 02,1 07 ( 1h Ci.2 ) To ca iy ho t c lult t e lmiai nspe i d
3 3 2
2 1 t r 008 . lrf w o ac ae h i tto
'
ro
when m uli e def
tpl
endant a e s ve at dif ent tm es Congr s e ded t Feder
s r er d
f er
i ,
es na
he
al

Cour sJ i di ton a V enue Cl rfca i A c of2011 Pub. w . o.112- 1 St t
t ur s c i nd
a ii ton t
,
La N
63, 25 a

75 Th lw a e d Se to 1 6( t sa e t f d f nd nt a e s r e a d fe e t
8. e a m nde ci n 44 b) o tt : i e e a s r e v d t if r n
l
tm es,a a l t r s ved def
i
nd a e - er
endanttl a notce ofr oval a ca ler s r def nda
ies
i
tm
, ny r i - e ved e nt
m a cons t t r ovaleven t
y
ent o he em
hough t ea le - er def nda di notpr vi l
hat ri r s ved e nt d
e ousy

i tae o c ns n t r mo l'28 U. C.j 1 46( ( ( .Thi c ng i f d r l1w
niit r o e t o e va .
'
S.
4 b)2)C) s ha e n e e a a
was cons sentw ih t El ve h Cicui' hol ng i Baie v.Jans Pharmaceutc
it
t he e nt r ts di n
ly
sen
i a,
I .t tt t ry- lm ia i pe i f r m ova begi t r upon s vi of t
nc ha he hit day i t tons rod or e
l
ns o un
er ce he

l t s r def nda .536 F. 1
as- e ved e nt
3d 202.Skem ovalby t l t s r d def
s
l
he as- e ve
bndanti pr
s operi
f
al def nda s cons t r m oval eve i t l t s r def
1 e nt
ent o e
, n f he as- e ved endanttm el r m oves t
i y e
he
c e a t t e r i of t pr vi l s rved def
as fer he xpiaton
he e ousy e
endants t ry- y wi
' hit da
ndow t
o

r mo 'J e v Co
e ve. on s , mmon alh La Til I .Co , 9 F. p' 8 ,81 ( 1h Ci.
'
we t nd te ns . 45 Ap x 08 0 1 t r

201 .
2)
I t abo s yl a i a 1D ef nda spr ry s r d t r notce ofr m oval
n he ve- t ed cton, l
e nt ope l e ve hei i
e
w ihi t ry da oft l ts ved D ef ntr ei ng t Com pl nt The l s- er ed
t n hit ys he as- er
enda ec vi he
ai .
a ts v

De e n s Gon ao Que a a a Go z l Que a , M . , P. , we e s r d o
fnda t,
zl
s d nd n a o
s da D. A. r e ve n
N ove be 5, 2012. A cc di y, D e e
m r
or ngl
f ndant had untl D ec ber 5, 201 f a 1
s
i
em
2 or 1

De e a t t c ns ntt r mo l On t td t , n t Qu s daDe e n stld t er
f nd n s o o e o e va . ha a e whe he e a
f nda t se h i

Notce of Cons t Rem oval D ef nda s w er unani ous i r m ovi t t s Court4
i
ent o
, e nt
e
m
n e
ng o hi
.

Rem ovalw ast n ef ec i
he f tve.
A s cont a y s
r r uppor f hi poston, Pl ntf cies t t e ca
t or s
ii
ai if t o hre
ses f t
or he

pr
oposton t tt t ry- y lm ia i pe i be n t r w he t fr t Def
ii ha he hi t da i t tons r od ga o un
n he is
endant

wa sr e . e( # p. (ii Dib lv S. Tr c ig Co, 2F.S pp. d 1 1 ,
s ev d Se DE 24, 2) ctng e e . B. u kn .26
u 2 39
1 2 ( . Fl.200 ;Smi v He t Ct.o a e t y I . 25 F.S pp.2d 1 3
32 M D. a 3) t . alh r fL k 7r, nc, 2
h
u
36
( . Fl .20 ) Na h v Po tnb r 931
M D. a 03 ) t e . te e g,

Su p. 8 2, 8 ( . Fl 1 2.
p 2 25 M D. a. 9959

H oweve , t e ca es a e i pplc e as t
r hes
s
r na i abl
hey w er deci
e
ded unde t fr t s r
r he is- e ved
de e ntr e.Thi Courtnow mus appl t l t s rve def ndantr e i acc da
f nda ul
s
t
y he as - e d e
ul n or nce

wih t El nt Cic t s2008 hol ng i Baie a r enty a e d f de allw
t he eve h r ui'
di n ly nd ec l m nde e r a

.

A c di y, afer ca ef consi aton, i i O RD ER ED, AD JU D GED, and
cor ngl
t
r bl
der i
t s

DECREED t tPli tf sM o i nt Re a t S a eCo t( #24 be a i he e
ha an if
to o m nd o t t ur DE ) , nd s r by,
D ENIED .

DO NE AN D O RD ER ED i Cha ber a t J es La r e K i Fede a
n
m s t he am
w enc
ng
rl
J tce Buidi a Unied St t Courhous , M i m i Fl i t s 27t da of
us i
l ng nd
t
a es
t e
a , or da, hi
h y
D e m be ,201
ce r
2.

r

AM ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STATES DI
STRI J GE
CT UD
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF FLORI
CT
D
4Def
endant Uni st ofM i i Roler Her ndez, M ar O '
s ver iy
am , n t na
k Connel,and Ana Campo f l t r
l
ied hei
NotceofRemovalOc ober30,201 . Def
i
t
2
endant A Car rCouns i Cent Lawr
s
ee
elng
er,
ence Har on, and
m
Lawr nceHar on,Ph. & Ass aes, P. ,fl t rN otce ofCons t Rem ovalon Novem ber9
e
m
D.
ocit
A. ied hei i
ent o
201 .
2
,

.
'

Cc:

Couns l rPl nt
efo ai W
M ar ow eJay Bl
l
ake
M a l J.Bl
r owe
ake
2255 Gl desRd,Suie 324a
t
A
Boca Ra on,FL 33431
t
305- 3379
670Fa 670x:
3380

Emal mj a @belo t ne
i: blke ls uh. t
Co e fo De e nt
uns l r f nda s
Er cD avi I i f
i
d scof
I i fRa t & K oeni ber
s cof ga z
gs g
1 Brc lAvenue
200 ikel
Suie 1
t 900
M i i FL 331
am ,
31
3053733232
Fa 305- 3233
x:
373-

Emal liof@ ilw.o
i:sc f ra c m
Ter a R agat
es
z
l i of Ragat & K oeni ber
sc f
z
gs g
1 Brckel A venue
200 i l
Suie 1
t 900
M i m i FL 331
a ,
31
305- 3232
373Fa 373x:
3233

EmalRa az ilw.o
i: g t@ ra c m
Sus V i ni W arner
an rgi a
I i of Raga z & Koe gs r
sc f
t
ni be g
1 Brcke lAvenue
200 i l
Suie 1
t 900
M i m i FL 331
a ,
31
305- 3232
373Fax:[phone]

Emalwan r ilw.o
i: r e@ ra c m
John W .M aur
o
Bilng Cochr Lyl M aur & Ra s PA
li
an es
o
m ey,

SunTr tCent r 6t foor
us
e, h l
51 Ea tLasOl Bl
5 s
as vd.
For La r e,FL 33301
t ude dal
95 764- 50
4- 71
Fa 954- 7279
x:
764-

Emalj
i:wm@ bcmrc m
l .o
Trac A.M iche l
y
t l
Col ,Sc t& K i s ne,P. .
e ot
sa
A
9150 Sout D a and Bl
h del
vd.
1 h Fl
4t oor
M i m i FL 331
a ,
57
786- 268 6441
Fa 305- 2294
x:
373-

Emalta y. thel c ke lc
i:rc mic l@ s lga.om

6