Baquero v. Lancet Indemnity Risk Retention Group, Inc. et al

Filing 146

ORDER granting in part 140 Motion for Attorneys' Fees and Non-Taxable Costs. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/17/2015.(mmd)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRJ COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i
C as N um be 1 241 Cl - O R EN O
e
r: 2- 05- V M

ELI BAQUERO,
AS
Pli if
a ntf,
VS.

LANCET W DEM I
NTY RI
SK RETEN TI
ON
GRO UP,l C .
N ,
D e e nt
f nda .

O RD ER G M N TI G I PAR T D EFEN D AN T' M O TI N FO R A TTO R N EY S'FE ES
N N
S
O
A N D N O N - U BLE CO ST S
TA

THI CAUSE ca bef e t Cour upon Def nda La tl
S
me or he
t
e nt nce ndemniy Rik Re e i
t s t nton

Gr u Ic' M o inf r t r e ' Fe sa
o p n .s to o Ato n y s e ndNo Ta a eCoss D. NO 1 0 ,ie o Fe ua y
n- x bl t ( E. . 4 ) fld n br r
6.2015.
THE CO UR T ha c i e t m oton a t pe tne por i oft r c d, a be ng
s onsder d he
i nd he r i nt tons he e or nd i

ot r s f l a s i t pr mies i i
he wie uly dvied n he e s , t s
A DJU D G ED t tt m o i i G R AN TED i pa tass tf t be ow .
ha he ton s
n r
e or h l

Def nda La e l m niy RikRe e i Gr up, nc. ma et ofe so j g n t te
e nt nc t nde t s t nton o l
d wo fr fud me to h
Pli ifpurua oFl i St t e768. whihi a iabl ass t ntvelw f Erepup os .
antf s ntt orda aut
79, c s pplc e ubsa i a or i
es
SeeJo s v Unie paceA li e LLC , F. 1306, 1 (1 t Ci.
ne . t ds
lanc ,
494 3d
309 1h r2007 .Defnda i no
) e nts w

s e ngt r c r$202,25. i a t ne sf e a $6, 87 i nont xa ecoss
e ki o e ove
8 25 n tor y' e s nd 270. n
a bl t

.

Thetrtofe of udgme t tLa e ma waso J 1 2013fr$1501a t sco
ss fr j
ntha nc t de
n une 7,
o , nd he e nd
wa o Aprl22, 4f r$80,00.Pli ifrjce bohofe sasu- e ona egi nt theas
s n i 201 o
1
antf ee td t fr
as bl ve ha

t pe s lr pr e a i ofhi wie' e t t wass ki t r ove $2,500, on a Coblnt
he r ona e es nt tve
s f s sa e
ee ng o ec r
000
e z
a r e nther a he wih Sout Fl i Ur ntCa eCentr Thepolcylm i on Lanc tspolc
g e me
ec d t
h orda ge
r
e.
i i t
e ' iy

wa $1 000.
s 00,

Th j r i t sc s f u dDe e d n wa no l bl a til ndt Plitf ddn t e o e
e u y n hi ae o n fn a t s t i e tra a he an if i o rc v r
a
a m oni f om La tundert Cobl nt a r m e . Th o frof u g n s se stf rhi
ny
es r
nce
he
e z g ee nt e fe j d me t y tm e o t n

Fl i Stt ej768. pr dest ti adef nt lkeLa e , kesa ofe of udgmen t t
orda aut
79 ovi ha f enda ,i nc t ma n fr j
t ha
t pli ifdoe notac ep wihi 3 da , i t pl i ift r c r not ng ora a o
he antf
s
c t t n 0 ys and f he antf hen e ove s hi
n m unt
a l a t25 l st nt ofe , hede e nti e il dt a a r oft ato ne sf esa c t
t e s % es ha he f r t
f nda s ntte o n wa d he tr y' e nd oss

ic re a trt o frwa ma e Th o fro j d me t tt t d e , o v r c n anap o iin
n u r d fe he fe s d . e fe fu g n saue o s h we e , o ti r vso
a l ng t Cour t di alow a a a d whe t cour de e nes i is di c e i t ta of e
lowi he
to s l n w r
n he
t t nni , n t s r ton, ha n f r

wa notmadei goodfih.j768. 7)*, a.Sttl
s
n
at
794 ( Fl a.

l ti c s ,t frto fro j g n o $15 1wa n mi a a d g v n t tt i c s
n h s a e he is fe f ud me t f ,0 s o n l n i e ha h s a e
s r v ds mma y ud me t n t co e e so q sinso fc,h Co re ecs sis icein
uvie u r j g n a d he l s n s f ueto f a tte u t x r ie t d s rto
t fn ta t efrto fro j d me t sn tag o f i o fr Th r i n q e to h we e ,n
o id h t h is fe f u g n wa o o d at fe . ee s o u sin, o v r i
h
te Co r' ve t a t s c n o fro j d me to $ 0 1 0 wa ma e i g o fih a d i
h u ts iw h t he e o d fe f u g n f 8 ,0 s d n o d at n s
lu e to 7b o t eo fro j d me tsau ep o i e t a wh nd tnnii t e
s bscin () f h fe f u g n ttt r v d s h t e ee nng h
r as blne sofan at ne sf e a r t c tca e ua esx c ie i
e ona e s
tor y' e s wa d, he our n val t i rt ra:
1.he t n a r m e i orlc ofme i i t c am
t he ppa ent rt a k
rt n he l i
2. he n be a na ur ofof e sm ade
t um r nd t e
fr
3.t cl e s ofquesi off c a lw a is
he os ne s
tons a t nd a t s ue
4.whe he t peron m a ngt ofe ha unr s bl r us t f r s i or ai
t r he s
ki he f r d ea ona y ef ed o u nih nf m ton
neces y t eval e t r onabl
sar o
uat he eas
enessoft of er
he f
5.whe he t s twa i t naur ofa t tc s pr e i quesi off rr c ng
t r he ui s n he t e
es a e es ntng
tons a -ea hi
i ra ea f tng no ri s
mpo tnc feci
npa te
6. hea
t mountofaddii ldea cos a e ns t ofer woul beexpe t d t i
tona ly t nd xpe e he f or
d
c e o ncuri t
f he
ltga i n i pr onged.
ii to s ol

r s bl gi n t pr ed a posur oft ca e. TheCour t r f efndst s cond ofe of
ea ona e ve he oc ur l t e he s
t he e or i he e
fr

j d me t svai .
u g n wa ld
Plitf ag e ta e nit eCo r fn t eo fro j dg n wa ma ei g o fi t e
anif r u sh t ve f h u tids h fe fu me t s d n o d at h
h,
r la e atc e t t eo fro j d me ta iu u l i ld dLa c tsa e t.Plitf cams
ee s s ta h d o h fe f u g n mbg o sy ncu e n e' g ns anif li
t l
he angua woul ne es a iy i l Stve De by. Pl i if e a m s t es a e ha a s pa a e
ge
d c s rl ncude e n m
a ntf l i he t t s e r t
c a m f neglge e a i tSt ve Dem by f hi r ei c pl tng t i ur nc a i a i . The
l i or
i nc ga ns e n
or s ol n om e i he ns a e pplc ton

pa te diput whehe De
ri s s e
t r mby, hei ur ncebr r wasLa e ' age . M r De
t ns a
oke ,
nc ts nt
. mby c a ii d a
l rfe t
tilt thewasa ag ntoft i ur da Dr J uka t sii dt tM r De bywa hi br r The
ra ha
n e
he ns e nd . o r e tfe ha . m
s s oke .
Cour doe notfnd t r i a a guiy i t r e es a t he t t Def ndants ofe of
t s
i he e s n mbi t n he elas tac d o he
e
' fr

j g n t two l v i t eef c o t o fro j d me tu d rFlrd lw.
ud me t ha u d od h fe t f he fe f u g n n e o ia a
Fi ly, a n ifa g f a 40% r duc i i ato ne sf sa r st boa d. The Cour
nal Pli tf r ues or
e ton n t r y' ee c os he r
t

dia r e s har duc i i wa r nt a fndst r t ofDe e tsco e a $325and$235
s g e s uc e ton s r a ed nd i he a es
f ndan ' uns l t
r a o bl f a l3 ye r a 7- r l w ye .The Cour doe ,how e r lm i t tm e f a e a
e s na e or
- a nd yea a r
t s
ve , i t he i r m nd

a r sfe i u rdo yatrAp i2 2 4-t ed t o tes e ndo fr f u g n . eCo r
wad e snc re nl fe rl 2, 01 h ae fh e o fe o j d me t Th u t
gr nt Def nda la t tl as
a s e nt e ve o ie umm a y oft at r ys f st twoul beco it ntwih t s
r
he to ne ' ee ha
d
nsse
t hi
o de b no lt rt n Apri 1 2015.
r ry
ae ha
l 0.
Purua tt Loca Rul 7. De e ntas s eksc t t ta enon-a bl unde 28U .S. .
s n o
l e 3, f nda lo e
oss ha r
t xa e
r
C

j1 Dee ntrquesst Coure rieisdic ei unde Fl i Stt ej768. t a r
920. fnda e t he
txecs t sr ton r orda aut
79 o wad
non-a bl c t a fndt ecos sr s bl l evi w i D ef nt sr ue t t Cour not s
t xa e os s nd i hos
t ea ona e. nr e ng enda ' eq s , he
t e

t tiale dya r dDee nt$2, 511c t onFe ay 1 201 purua t 28U. C.j
ha t ra wade fnda
863. 11 oss
bnzr 9, 5 s nt o
S.
1920.

TheFl i Su e Cour ha pr de gui i f t t ton ofc t i ci la tons
orda pr me
t s ovi d delnes or he axa i
oss n vi c i ,

whih t sCour fndsi t c i i de i ngt r as blnes oft c t r ques underFl i
c hi
t i nsnztve n e di he e ona e s he os s e t
orda

Stt ej768. Se ton1alowspa te t r ove c t ofta crpt fom c t rngs Se ton
aut
79. ci
l
ris o ec r oss r ns i s r our heai . ci
1 oft g dei salowst Cour t t x r as bl ta c t f wines es Se tonI1d)a
1 he ui lne l
he
t o a e ona e r vel oss or t s . ci l( nd

()oft gui i excudealat ne sta tmea ta lcoss
e he delnes l t tor y' rveli nd rve t.
l t sca e,Def nda i s e ngt r c
n hi s
e nt s e ki o e overnon-a bl c t fom ase ry asAugus 27,
txa e oss r
al
t
201 H a ng f
3. vi ound t tD e e
ha f ndan m a onl r c rf sf om t A pr l ,201 o fr fu g n
t y y e ove ee r he i 22
4 fe o j d me t

da e t Cour lke s lm ist tm e fa t r co rnont xa e c t t t e i ure a t
t , he
t i wie i t he i r me o e ve
a bl oss o hos nc r d fer
Aprl22,201 The Cour excude t r ue t f cossa s it d wih tave f De e n '
i
4.
t l s he eq ss or t s oca e t r l or f nda ts

c u s la p o ie b s cinsIId a d() Th Co r d e no fn t ec s f rtep iaec r
o n e s r vd d y e to 1() n e. e u t o s t id h o t o h rv t a
s r c t ta por t w ine sTam m y Pu f om Ke W es t M i m ii r as
e vi e o r ns t he t s
po r
y
t o a s e onabl unde s c i
e
r e ton

1 oft gui lnes TheCo t he e o edia l t e ns f rt ca s r cee n t
1 he de i .
ur t r f r s lows he xpe e o he r e vi ve hought
he
c tofwines ta li ge r ly c
os
t s r ve s ne al ompe a e The Co ta s fnds i unr a ona e t a a d
ns bl .
ur l o i
t e s bl o w r
De e nta oft cossa s it dwiht Oc obe ti da e, c wa co i da t be s
f nda ny he t s oca e t he t r ral t whih s ntnue t he he t

oft Dee nt TheCour wilho ve,a r ta c i c t purua t s ci IE)oft
he fnda .
t l, we r wa d r nsrpt oss s nt o e ton (
he
Fl i Supr m e Cour gui i f r co the rngs on J
orda
e
t delnes o ur a i
une 24,201 Septm be 3, 2014,
4,
e r

Sep e
t mber1 201 a Se embe 1 201 t t lng$5 26.
0, 4, nd pt
r 7, 4, o ai
08.
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i ,Fl rda, hi
n
m r t ami o i t s

da ofM a ch,201
y
r
5.

FEDE
O A . O NO
M
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STR I J D G E
CT U
Copi provi t
es
ded o:

Couns ofRecor
el
d