Baquero v. Lancet Indemnity Risk Retention Group, Inc. et al

Filing 86

ORDER denying 74 75 Cross-Motions for Reconsideration. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/17/2013. (err)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
C as N um ber 12e
: 24105- l - O REN O
C V M

ELI BAQUERO,
AS
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

LAN CET I D EM I TY RI
N
N
SK RETEN TI N
O
GRO UP,I C .
N
Dee
f ndant
.

ORDER DENYI CROSS- OTI NS FOR RECONSI
NG
M
O
DEM TI
ON
Thi c us comesbef r t Cour on t Pa te ' os - otonsf Re onsde a i On
s a e
o e he
t he ri s Cr s M i or c i r ton.
Se e r1 201 t Cour denidbo ht Pl ntf sandt De e
pt mbe 7, 3,he
t e t he ai if
he f ndan ' M otonsf Sum ma y
ts i or
r
J
udgm e . Se e r23, 3, antf fld isM otonf Re
nt On pt mbe
201 Pli if ie t
i or consde ai , Se e r24,
i r ton'
on pt mbe
t Def ntdi t s m e. et rpa t ha de
he enda d he a N ihe ry s monsr e t tt i motonsa e c itntwih
tatd ha he r i
r ons se
t
t e i tpup os sofm oto f r c i ai Thus t Cour her by DENI bot Pa te '
he xplci
e
i ns or e onsder ton.
, he
t e
ES h ri s
M otonsf Rec i r ton.
i or onsde a i
1.Anal s
ysi

' pur eofam oton f r onsde ai i t co r c ma f te r soflw orf tor
'
The pos
i or ec i r ton s o r e t nies ror
a
ac
t pr e ne ydicove e evi ncc.Z. M arne I . .
o es nt wl s r d de ' K. i , nc v M/vAr hi ts, 08F. pp. 561 1
'
c ge i 8
Su 1 , 563

( D. a.1 (ii Har c Cor v Zl ni i779F. 906,909( Ci.1 ) M otonsf
S. Fl 992) ctng s o p. . ot ck,
2d
3d r 985). i or
r c i r ton a ea opraewhe e, ore
e onsde a i r ppr i t
r f xampl ,t Cour ha pae l miunde sood apa t
e he
t s tnty s
rt
ry,
whe e t r i a i er ni c
r he e s n nt ve ng hange i contoli l w ort f t of a ca e,or w he e t r i
n
r lng a
he ac s
s
r he e s

ma ietn u tc S ei.Co gn n v Untdstts 1 9 W L 41 4 2,t 2( D. a Ma 1 ,
nfs ij sie. e d, mpa o i . i a e , 9 7
'
e
6 8 a * S. Fl . y 3
1 .
997)
' m oton f r c i r ton s d not us d a a ve cl t pr s nt ho ii sa ia e
'
A
i or e ons de a i houl
be e s hi e o e e aut r te va l bl

a t tmeoft fr tde sonort r ie aea g e spr ousy ma .'Z. M ar ne I v M/
t he i
he is cii
o et r t r um nt evi l de ' K. i , nc. . V
Ar hi i,8 F.Supp.a 1
c gets 08
t 563.l t i M otonsf Re onsde ai , bot pari s t i l
n her
i or c i r ton
h tes ubsantaly

rp a t eag me t te Co r rj ce i i Or e d n n s mma yj d me t Ho v r te
e e t h r u n s h u t ee td n t d r e yig u r u g n . we e, h
s
pa te now ialc z u ri , em bol t t toft i a gum e . Ast a gument, a t, nd
ris
t i i e, nde lne or
den he ex he r r
nt
he r
sfcsa
l w r m ai t s m e,t Cour ' de s on i notaf e t d by t s r newed pl as l d,'ii a
a e n he a
he
ts ci i s
fce
he e e
e . ndee 't s n
g

i r rus of t motont rc i rt a kt Cour t rt nk wha t Cour ..ale dy
mpope e j he i o e onsde o s he
t o ehi
t he
t . ra
t
houghtt ough- r gh l orw r y.'I ( u t gAb v t eBetI c v Me Bo a n nRo hn
hr
i ty
ongl 'd q oi
n o e h l n . . l h n a o g,
,

I . 99F. D.99,l ( D.Va.1 .
nc, R.
01 E.
983)
N e r he es , one ar e t t m ert a es i i Def nda ' ate pt t co l t
ve t l s
gum nt ha
is ddr sng s
e nts t m
o nta e

Rie r sc or t knowldgewih Dr Hos enJ
t ca e' op a e
e
t .
s i ouka ' r onal
rspe s knowldge De e nti core t
e . f nda s r c
t tcor or tons a tt o
ha
p ai
c hr ugh t i a nt a e pl s. Se D i c r Pr p.& Ca .I .Co.
he r ge s nd m oyee
e s ove o
s ns

Le ngtnl . 664F. zd1 1 ( D. a 2009)Kno e ofage sc nbei e
xi o ns Co.
supp. 296, 301 S. Fl.
. wldge
nt a mputd
t t c or ton. e i Howe r Def nda a tmpt t i r uncon r r i lp o ii t
o he op ai Se d.
ve , e nt te s o nve t
tove sa r postons o

i r si eboundsDee n'agume sca bei eprtdi wowa ( )ha t knowldg
mpemisbl
. fnda ts r nt n ntr ee nt
ys:1 t the
e e
of o ag t f r a c o a i ea be i put d t a he a nt or( t tc portons ha
ne en o
op r ton n
m e o not r ge ,
2) ha or ai
ve

kno edget tc n bei
wl
ha a
mput t i vi uas. Net roft s ar c r ti t c e oft sca e.
ed o ndi d l ihe he e e orec n he ont xt hi s
The gitoft a gum e t tDef nda r at t z
s
he r
nt ha
e nt epe s h oughoutisbrefng docu e si t t
t ii
m nt s ha ,
be us t Novembe 20a De m b 1 l te swe es ntt Riecar a r c vedbyRiecar ,
ca e he
r nd ce er 5 et r r e o t e nd e ei
t e
Rieca e ha knowldge oft potntalcli s whe Riecar fle ou t St eme ofNo
t r d
e
he e i am
n t e ild t he at nt
Know n Cl i s and t , t car m adem ir e ent tonst r m ove t sc ai f om c r .
am ,
hus Rie e
s epr s a i hat e
d hi l m r
ove age
Thef
unda e al l ofD e e
m nt faw
f ndan ' l c r dm a i t tR ieca e di nots gn t St t m e of
ts ogi al oa p s ha t r d
i he a e nt
N o Know n Cl i s D r J
a m , . oukardi Thef c sa pr s nt d t t Cour a et ts e
d.
a t s e e e o he
t r ha om body a Rieca e
t t r

sgne f t lte s a t tt l te swe enota es e t Dr J
i d or he e tr , nd ha he et r r
ddr s d o . ouka ,butwer addr s e t
r
e
esd o
postons he hed.Howe ,Dr J
ii
l
ver . ouka has r pe t dl t tfe t the di no s t lte s
r
e a e y esii d ha
d t ee he e tr .
-

2-

Re r ngt Stt m e ofNoKnownCli s t onl per on
ga di he a e nt
am he y s
,

,

i vi orc por e, w ho coul
ndi dual or at
d

m a a r pr e a i ata lwasD r J
ke e es nt ton l
. ouka .
r Thi c l i i i via eba e ont el
s onc uson s ne t bl s d h angua of
ge
t Stt men . I e t Stt m e i r pl t wihlngua h
he a e t nde d,he a e nt s e ee t a
get
at anonl c tu aspe ti ng
c
ybe onsr ed
ra ni

t a i vi .I begi ' y sgna u e bel confr st t
o n ndi dual t ns ' i t r ow
M
im ha ...'Thesgna ur i notofRiecar
'
i t es
t e

,

i i ofDr J
ts
. ouka . l ed,Rie r asa cor a e e iy i not
r nde
t ca e
por t ntt s
mentoned on t doc e .
i
he um nt
Furhe , c sae e a is be nswih t
t r ea h t tm nt t s ue gi
t h
e ' . St t me 1 be ns' ha no known
' ' a e nt gi ' ve
1'
I
l s sorcl i s 'andsa e
os e
am y '
t t ment 2, 3, nd 4be n ' ha nok
s
a
gi ' ve nowl
I
edge

'Thus t sCou t a dr w
'
,hi
rcn a

.

noot erc uson ot t n t onl knowldgebei s
h oncl i her ha he y
e
ng oughti t tdoc e wasDr
n ha
um nt

.

J
ouka '
rs

know l dge. l La e haddesr awa r nt f f c souti
e
f nc t
ied
ra y or a t sd

eofDr J rss j tvek edge
.ouka' ubeci nowl ,

i coul ha p a ed t i s awa . I ed,La tkne how do dr f s h asa
t d ve hr s hem n uch
y nde
nce
w
a t uc
tt

em ent as
,

sa e t5r ds' ysgnat ebel c im st t. . p
tt men ea ' i ur ow onfr ha
M

lj p irp o e so a la ii c rirh s
n o ro r fs in lib ly are a
t

REFUSED c r ge f , orDECLI
ove a or
NED t a e a r tofa me c i de ,t r tofcli
o cc pt epor
dial nci nt h ea
am
lte ofi e s a a r e r s tnotc orator y c r c
et r nt nt nd dve s e ul ie
t ne onta t
.

,

'Eve y ot rsatm e t tLa et
' r he t e nt ha nc

r quiedDr J
e r
. ouka t a fr wa c he i t explctl
r o fim s ouc d n he
i i angua ofhi pe s
ge
s r onalk
nowl
edge

Thus
,
La e i i ore ti a gui t thi peronalk
nc t s nc r c n r ng ha s s
nowldge i notr e nt W hie Lanceti corr ct
e
s
elva .
l
s e
.

t tDr J
ha . ouka ' a tonsbi Rie r i doe nott n f l t tDr
rs c i
nd t ca e t s
he olow ha
,

.

J
ouka aut ai a l knew
r om tc ly

o De mbe 29 s t ng t tot rpe e wihi Rie r mi ha known
n ce r ome hi ha he opl t n t ca e ght ve

.

The c e ct d by Def ntdo not r qui
as s ie
enda
e
r a dif entr ul. l Cor gi l . Co. v
e
fer es t n
e s ns
.
M c l t epolc c ai d an e l i wher t polcydi nota y t ' ny cli
colum, h
iy ont ne
xcuson
e he i d
ppl o '
a
am aii
r s ng
outofa a t e r , omisono pes
ny c , r or
si r ronalij r occ ngprort t efe tvedat oft spolcy
n uy uni i o he fci
e hi i
i a I ur a t e f c i da e kne
f ny ns ed t he f e tve t
w
orc d have r as
oul
e onabl f e e n t ts h ac
y or s e ha uc t
,

er ,
ror

o sino p ro a ij r mih b e p ce t b teb ssof cl m orsui
miso r es n ln u y g t e x e td o e h a i a ai
t

' Cor gi I . Co.
'
e s ns

.

v M c l ,96l F.supp.1572, 1 ( . Fl 1 . nt tc e
. colum
575 M D. a. 997) l ha as

,

t c tent r s m ar
he our e ed um
y

j d me t nfv ro teplitf is r rwh h dgie d endantam al actce i ur ncepolcy
u g n i a o f h anif n u e o a v n ef
pr i ns a
i

f d e nts1w fr . d a 1 4. i t t flngofam apr tc s ta prort t e f c i
or ef nda ' a im I t 57 Pror o he ii
l aci e ui nd i o he fe tve
da eoft polc a as ocit a t 51: hadm it n am e f t fl pr di i t pos i lt
t
he iy, n s a e t he 71
te
mo or he ie e ctng he sbiiy
ofa m a pr tc s t 1 a 1
l ac i e ui. d. t 579.
The pa t ra i s c ai ed he ne s w t m e or ndum . d
rne t s ue l m
ver a he m a
l
The Cour hel t t 'ti al o i r l van w he he M ccolum hi s l kne of a pos i e c a m o
t d ha ' s s r e e t
i
t r
l
m ef w
sbl l i r
e kne ofJ
ven w
ohns s m e or ndum .
on' m a
The l ngua oft e us on cont i d w ihi Pl ntf
a
ge he xcl i
a ne t n ai ifs
polc e i il sat st tc r w il e uded i an i ur d unde t polcy kne orc d
i y xplc ty t e ha ove age l be xcl
f y ns e
r he i
w
oul
ha r as bl f e e n a pos i e c ai . l l t c e a ba , he l ngua dif ss t nta l
ve e ona y or s e
s bl l m ' d n he as t r t a
'
ge f er ubs a i ly
f om t i M ccolu . s gni t St t m en , t s a em e ' own expr s t nns Dr J
r hat n
l m By i ng he a e t but he t t nt s
e s e , . ouka
r
onl confr ed t t he hi s f had 'no know l dge or i or a i r l tng t a M ED I
y
im
ha
m el
l
e
nf m ton e a i o
CAL

I DENTwhihc dras bl rs ti cai 'a ' knowldgeofANY REQUEST FOR
NCI
c oul e ona y e ul n l ms' nd i
no
e
M ED I L RECORD S whi h m i tr ul i a c ai .
CA
c
gh es t n l m '
'
Si ia l D e e
m l ry, f ndant nt t Bar t v O k ec
poi s o ne t . e hobe H o p.f t pr nc pl t ta pr ry
e s or he i i e ha
ope l
m aie l te was r c ve I t tca e a cl i a f l d a m e c m a pr tc a ton a ns t
ld et r
e ei d. n ha s , a m nt ie
di al l ac i e c i gai t he

De rme ofVeea sAfar (' '. netv Oke chobe Hos ,283F. 1 1 4 ( 1b
pat nt
trn' fis ' )Bar t . e
VA'
e y
3d 232, 23 1 t
Ci.
r2002)Thecl ma s ntaf m t t VA aswa rquie a t VA pr dedafda t fom
.
ai nt e or o he
s e r d, nd he
ovi fi vis r

e oye sai t the hadnotrc ve i.d. t1 - TheCour notdt tig c t oul
mpl es ttng ha t y
e ei d tI a 23536.
t e ha ka) our c d
n r l on t ba e as e ton ofone m em be oft ofi e t tt m a lw a notr ce ved,s nc t
ot e y
he r s r i
r he fc ha he i s
e i
i e he
m a l m i ha bee r ce ve by a he . l a 1 .The 11h Cicui f t not t t t
i ght ve n e i d
not r' d. t 241
'
t r t urher ed ha he

û t sf iur t unco ra ie ,whi h i waspr um e t ha r e ve doesno mea t ti
û y' al e o
par
ve n t m
c t
es d o ve ec i d,
t n ha t
ne r r c ve t ie and doe notr butt pr um p i n of de i r ' 1 D e enda us s t s
ve e ei d he t m
s
e
he es t o
lve y. d. f
'
nt e hi
l ng get s
a ua o uppor isa g e t t t
tt r um nt ha Riecar r c ve he l te s a husRiecar ha know l dge
e e ei dt e t r , ndt
t
e d
e

oft r quess f medi lr c ds Agan,t si nott pr r a l i.The St t ntofNo
he e t or
ca e or . i hi s
he ope nayss
aeme
Know n Cl i sa ke s el f t e s gne ' per ona know l dg w ih r s c t al s a e en sexc pt
a m s d ol y or h i r s s l
e e t e pe t o 1 t t m t
e
s a e e 5.
t t m nt Thus i i no e
, t s t nough t tt r i a r buta epr s pton t tR ieca e r c ve t
ha he e s e t bl e um i ha t r e ei d he
4-

-

lte s i mus be s
e tr , t t hown t tDr J
ha . oukarkne oft l t r whe he sgne t St tm e ofNo
w
he ete s
n
i d he ae nt
Know n Cl i s
am .

Si l l i GRG Tr s ,nc v, rai Unde wrtr at o ', 96So. 922( a. s.
miary,n
anp.I . Cet n
r ie s Llyds 8
2d
Fl Dit

CtAp 2 0 )tec u t p eds mmayj d me t eet ei u a ea pl aina k dt- sa y
. p. 0 5 ,h o r u h l u r u g n wh r h ns rnc p i to s e sl n
c
la
i ur wihi t pas 5 ye sr us t r w orca eled i ur ncet a i nt' a t i ur
ns er t n he t ar ef ed o ene
nc l ns a
o pplca , nd he ns ed
'

a we e $ '
ns r d ; when i hada t knowl dgeofapr vi ca ela i G#G Tr s , So.d
No'
t
c ual
e
e ous nc lton.
an p.896 2
9 Agai t tc e i ditng s bl fom t c s a ba ,whe e t St tm entofN o Known
23.
n, ha as s si uiha e r he a e t r
r he ae
Cl i sw a e i il lm ie by is own t nnst Dr J
am
s xplc ty i t d
t
e
o . ouka ' pe s
r s r onalknow l dge
e .
II.Concl on
usi

TH I CA USE c m e be or t Cour upon t Pl ntf a D e e nts M otons f
S
a
f e he
t
he ai ips nd f nda '
i
or

Re onsde ai ( E.No.75 and 76) fl onSe e ber23.201 a Septm ber24.201
c i r ton D.
, ied
ptm
3 nd
e
3,
rs ci l
e pe tve y.

THE COURT ha c i r dt motons r s ns , ndt
s onsde e he i , e po es a hepe tne
ri ntpori oft e or
tons her c d,
a be ng ot r ie f l a s d i t pr i es i i
nd i
he w s uly dvi e n he em s , t s
ADJU D G ED t tt m oto a e D EN I .
ha he
i ns r
ED

DON E AN D O RD ERED i Cham be sa M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
r t a , or da hi

da ofO c obe ,201
y
t r
3.
/VYR
. WO
V

'

L

' . '' .
'.

.

*Y '
.''- 1' ' D

FED I A .M O REN O
CO
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d