Wi-LAN USA, Inc. et al v. Apple Inc.
Filing
54
ORDER GRANTING 39 Defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 4/2/2013. (rg1)
I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Cas No.1 c 2431 - M
e
2- v8 KM
W iLAN USA,I an W iLAN,I C.
NC. d N
Pli if ,
antfs
VS
.
A PPLE l C .
N ,
De e nt
f nda .
/
ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M O TION TO TRANSFER VENUE
NG
S
THI CAUSE ca be or t Cour upon Def nda ' Re we M oton t Tr nser
S
me f e he
t
e nts ne d
i o a f
Ve u t t eUn td Sae DititCo r f rt S uhen Ditito Caio a( No. 9 .
n e o h ie tts src u t o he o t r src f l mi ECF
f
3)
Pli t f fld aM e r n u i Op o iin ( No 4 )a d Dee d n fld a Re l (
ani s i
f e
mo a d m n p sto ECF . 9 n fn a t ie
py ECF
No 5 ) Th M oi n i n w rp f rrve UPON CONS DERATI o te M oin,te
. 3 . e to s o ie o e iw.
I
ON f h
to h
Re po e a Re y,t pe tne pori nsoft Re or and beng ohe wie f ly a s d i
s ns nd pl he ri nt to
he c d,
i t r s u l dvie n
t pr m ies t sCou te e st f l ng Or r
he e s ,hi
r nt r he olowi
de .
1.
BA C K G R O U ND 1
I De mber201 W iLAN fl d s tagans Appl f pa e i rnge e c e ni
n ce
2 ie ui i t
e or t nt nfi m nt onc r ng
U. Pa e Nos 8315, a 8, 0
S. t nt . , 640 nd 311,40. The pa e sr ae t o t m ehodsa s t m sf
t nt elt ç he t
t
nd yse or
ta m ison of muli e m odult d sg s ove wie e s newor ,a pa ng s zce da a
r ns s i
tpl
a e i nal
r r l s t ks nd cki olr
t
pac t i o ta pori pac t wih fa e a i ' M e .i Opp. a 2. W iLAN hast
ke s nt r ns tng kes t r gm ntton.
' m n
,t
wo
r aed a tonspe ng i t sCou t one fl d agans HTC Co por ton a HTC Ame ia,a
elt c i
ndi n hi
r,
ie
i t
r ai nd
rc nd
1Thef t heen aet nfom De e ntsRe we M oint TrnserVe ( No. ;
acs ri r ake r
f nda ' ne d to o a f nue ECF 39)
Pli if'M e a l i Opposton( No.49) a Deenda ' Repl ( No.53)
antfs morndtm n
ii ECF
; nd f nts y ECF
.
t ot r fld agans Sira W iees Am e i a I
he he ie
i t er
rl s
rc , nc. Thes aci c
e tons once n t s m e pae s
r he a
tnt
wih smia a lga i ofi rnge e .
t i lr le tons nfi m nt
W iLAN ,I i a co por to i t i elecualpr ry de l e a lc i
nc. s
r ai n n he nt l t
ope t veopm nt nd iensng
i ty he dqua tr i Ota Ont i W iLAN USA ,a wholy owne i r c s i a y
ndusr a re ed n twa, aro. l
d ndie t ubsdi r
o W iLAN,i a Fl i c por ton wih isU . hea
f s
orda or a i
t t S. dqua tr i M i mi W iLAN USA wm
re s n a . s
i om or td i Fl i i De mber2011 Def nda Appl i ba e i Cupe tno,Ca ionza
nc
ae n orda n ce
.
e nt
e s sd n
ri
lf i,
i t Norhe n Dititof Caior a. Appl has r t i l tons i t Sou he n Dititof
n he
t r
src
lf ni
e
e a l ocai
n he
t r
src
Fl i Qualomm,a de lpe oftc ogy i iae i t e pae s i ba e i Sa
orda.
c
veo r e hnol mplc td n hes tnt, s s d n n
Digo,Ca ior a,n t Sout r DititofCaiom i
e
lf ni i he
he n src
lf a.
I.
l
LEGAL STANDARD
Tie 2 U.. j 1 0 ( ) p o i e ta çfo te c n e in e o te p ris a d
t 8 SC. 4 4 a r v d s h t t j r h o v ne c f h a t n
l
l
e
win se ,i te i ee t ofj tc ,a dsrc c r ma ta se a y cvi a to t a y oh r
t e s s n h ntr ss usie itit ou t y rn fr n i l cin o n te
dititordi son whe e i mi ha be n br ug ort any dititordi son t whih al
src
vii
r t ght ve e o ht o
src
vi i o
c l
pa te haveco e e ' 28U. C,j1 a.
ris
ns ntd.'
S.
404()
Thesa r f tanse unde j 1 a gi br dicei t t ti c qand a
tndad or r fr r 404() ves oad s rton o he ral our
til c ts de son wil be ov t ne onl f r a e of dicr ton. M a on v.Sm ihklne
ra our' cii
l
erur d y o bus
s ei
s
t i
Be hn Clni lLabs 1 F.Supp.2d 1
ec m i ca
es
ho i
355,1 ( D.Fl 2001. Congr s aut rzed
358 S. a. )
., 46
c t t ta f rt ve ofa c s i o de t avoi Innec s a y i
ours o r nse he nue
ae n r ro
d l e s r nconve e e t t ltga s
ni nc o he ii nt ,
winese ,a t publc, t c e v tme e r a mone Se t. a 1
t s s nd he i and o ons r e i , ne gy, nd
y. e t t 359.
k
Theq si ofwhehe t ta frvenuei ve at pr edi r J Thefrt
ueton
t r o rnse
nvol s wo- ong nquiy. .
Z
is
pr hol t tt at nmtve ve ç tbe one i whi t aci coul orgi ly have
ong ds ha he le i
nue ç
mus
n
ch he ton
d i na l
bee br
n oughtby t pl néf ' I The s c pr i ve a eeme - e e
he ai f ' d.
e ond ong nvol s n l ntby- l mentana yss
l i.
I r quiesCourst ç l e prvae a publc f cor ... t de e m i whe he ta f r i
te r
t o i anc i t nd
ba
i a t s ' o t r ne
'
t r r ns e s
j tfe l
usi d. d.
i
11
1.
DI
SCUSSI
ON
The a
bove-t e a ton c d ha be fl d i t Sout m Diti t of Ca ior a.
syld c i oul ve en ie n he
he
src
lf ni
Ap ei s be tt p ro l mid ci n i S. Ca . c us tto f r frs l o s lsa c s d
pl s u j c o e s na j s ito n D. l be a e t fe s o ae r el c u e
i
p o u t i ta d src,a d t rf r h s s f in c n a t t e tb ih j rs cin tee'
r d cs n h t itit n heeo e a u t e t o tcs o sa ls u idito h r .
k
'
M o .t Trns,a 6. Theeo e ta se i pemisbl p o i e ta ta se i j siid a
to a .t
rf r , rn fr s r si e r v d d h t r n f r s u tfe s
e nce by a a yssofpublc a prva ef ct s
vi d
n nal i
i nd i t a or .
I M a ue v.Co v r ysCo . 43 F.d 1 3 ( 1 Ci.2 05 ,t Elv nh Cic i
n n l
n ec
m , 0 3 1 2 1 1 r 0 ) he e e t rut
l td a n mb ro p b i a d p iaef co sr lv n t d tr n wheh rta f ri j tfe
i e u e f u lc n rv t a tr ee a t o eemie te rnse s usiid
s
t rj 1 0 ( ) Th s f co sicu e
mde 4 4 a. e e a tr n ld :
()t e c n e in e o te wi e ss ( )te lc to o r lva td cz ns
1 h o v ne c f h t se ; 2 h o ai n f ee n o l t
n
me
a dt er ltv e s o a c s t s u c so pr o ;( )t ec n e e eo t e
n h eaie a e f c e s o o re f o f 3 h o v ninc f h
p ris () t e lc s o o eaie fcs () t a albit o p o e s t
ate ; 4 h o u f p rtv a t; 5 he v i l y f r c s o
a i
c mp lte atn a c o u lng win se ;( )t r ltv me n o te
o e h te d n e f nwil
i
t e s s 6 he eaie a s f h
p ris ( ) a f r m' fmiirt wi t e g venn lw; () te weg t
at ; 7
e
o u s a laiy t h o r ig a 8 h
h
ih
a c r e apanifsc oieo f r m; n ( )tilefce ya dteitrss
c o d d li tf' h c f o u a d 9 ra fiinc n h ne e t
o j tc , a e o t ett lyo t cru tn e .
f usie b s d n h oai f he ic msa c s
t
l a 11 n. No sng ef t i dipostve, c t ha dif r d i t weghta f de t
d. t 35 1.
i l acor s s ii and ours ve fe e n he i for d o
ea h i vi lf c or Compa eCelulr son Te h. Teec
c ndi dua a t .
r
l a vii
c & l omm s.L. v. le Cop . 508F.
. P. Alt l
,
S p 2 1 8 1 8 ( D.Fl.2 0 ) (v laig sx fco s t NI SM Co .v.Ti
u p. d 1 6, 1 9 S. a 0 7 e au tn i a t r)wih S
p
me
W a n r l c, 0 - 2 6 4 2 0 W L 5 7 8 a * ( D. a Fe 2 ,2 0 )(v lai
r e. n .No. 7 CV- 0 2 , 0 8
40 5 , t 2 S. Fl. b. 5 0 8 e au t
ng
s ve fco s. Ass ve a f t sose i y overa wih onea t r t sCour wilsrvet
e n a tr)
e r l acor tnsbl
lp t
nohe , hi
t l ti o
a yz ea h f c ori a mA
nal e c a t n
nnermos t l ed t t i t ntdiput
t aior o he nsa s e.
1 TheConve e oft W ine s s
.
ni nce he t s e
Ap l c ne d t a çh mao i o n n p dy win se a e lc td mu h moe
pe o tn s h t t e j rt f o - a
y
t e s s r o ae
c
r
c
onve e l t SD Ca t n SD Fl ' M ot t Tr . a 8. Thi i l
ni nty o
1 ha
a.'
. o ans, t
s ncudeswines e c
t s s onne e t
ctd o
çhid pat c pma r Quacomm . . .t s ir of t a cus d tc ogy
t r ry hi ke
t
l
he upple
he c e e hnol
I
d.
t ii l a l s t e of t sx i nt r of t pa e s i s t and t a tr y t t
t tonaly, t ea t hr e
Add
he i nve o s
he t nt-n- ui
he to ne ha
pr e e t paent i s thav r sde si SD Ca .... I
os cutd he t s n ui e e i nce n
l
' d.
'
W iLAN poi soutt ta num be oft i nt s lve out i t S. Ca . i Te s
nt
ha
r he nve or i
sde he D. l, n xa ,
M a s c e t,I r e a Chi M e . n Opp. a 1 1 Fort e wines es W iLAN a gues
s a hus ts sa l nd na. m i
, t 3- 4.
hes t s , r ,
Sa Digo i notmor conve e t M i mi I a 1 W iLAN alo diput st r e nc of
n e s
e
nint han n . d. t 4. s s e he elva e
t l ai ofQualomm' hea rest t sltgai I W iLAN poi so t tAppl
he oc ton
c
s dqua tr o hi ii ton. d. nt ut ha
e,
notQuacomm,ma a ur t pr t,Appl ha noti iid ke Qualomm wine s
l
nufct es he oducs
e s
dentfe y
c
t ses
l ae i S. Ca. ndt ti a ton Quac
oc td n D. la ha n ddii
lomm hasofiesa os t county.1
fc cr s he
r d.
Thi Cour ma consde t a nt ges of t ta f r e r gi a a whol a t
s
t y
i r he dva a
he r ns e e e on s
e nd he
a l i i no lmie t t ltr bo
nayss s t i t d o he ie al unda i oft ta f r f r m . See I r TS Te h USA
res he r nse ee o u
n e
c
Co . 551F. 1 5 1 ( d.Ci.2008 (onsderng t a ia lt ofe de ne rt
m,
3d 31 , 321 Fe r
) c i i he valbiiy vi nce a he
ta see dsrc, o j s i t ed src isl Se as Co s-o co s S o e . n . W o c
rn fre itit n t u t n h itit teg. e lo m tt - m t tr s l c v. ma kBo r. Ic,5 4 F. S p . 7 1 7 4 ( M in. 1 8 )(1 h Ar a s s v n e wo d b
we s n . 9
u p 3 , 3 D. n 9 4 çT) e k n a e u ul e
(
c n iea l s p ro t M in s t ...(sl h g e ts n mb ro win se i t i a to
o sd r by u e ir o n e oa
a lt e r ae t u e f t e s s n hs cin
l
r i i Ar ns s Furhe ,t e wine s swho do no lvei M i ot r i i sa e whi h
esde n ka a . t r hos t s e
t i n nnes a esde n tt s c
ar c i r l cos rt Ar ns s...)
e onsdeaby l e o ka a '.
'
He e,s
r ome potntalwine s i t sc s r i i Ca iom i et ri i o o sdeof
e i t s es n hi a e esde n lf a, ihe nsde r ut i
S. Cal A numbe of ot wines es a e dipe s d a r s t county a t word.
D. .
r
her t s r s r e c os he
r nd he
l
H o e r no po e i l w ines e a e l a ed i S. . F1 , t St t of Fl i , or t gr a e
w ve ,
t nta t s s r oc t n D
a. he a e
or da
he e t r
4
s her r on. Gi t s dipmiy,hol ng t sltg ton i Ca ior a ge r ly a i S.
out n egi
ven hi s t
di hi ii a i n lf ni ne a l nd n D.
Ca .mor s cik al woul be mor c
l
e pe t ly
d
e onve e f t wines est n hol ng t sltga i i
nint or he t s ha
di hi ii ton n
Fl i The e or t sf c orf vor ta f ri t aci n.
orda. r f e, hi a t a s r ns e rng he to
2. The Loc ton ofRel van D oc z en s
ai
e t
tm t
Appl a g t t S. Ca .t s cl e t t s m c of r e nt docz e s' M ot t
e r ues ha D. l % os r o he o e
i
elva
lm nt .
'
.o
Tr ns, at 7. W iLAN poi s out t t
a .
nt
hat ç e wil pr 'ma y pr
Appl
l esl bl oduce is doc nt
t
ume s
e e toni a l i t sca e, nd i wilbeno m o e bur ns
l cr c ly n hi s a t l
r
de ome f i t do s i t c er mai i
or t o
o f he as e ns n
Fl i ' M em.i Opp. 1 Appl c e t tû s r i t sca e wili t bl r r
orda.
'
n
, 1.
e ont nds ha i cove y n hi s l nevia y equie
di
t pr to ofs ce c ..and f r s trt r a ons ..s h e de mus be physcal
he oduci n
our ode .
o ecliy e s
. uc vi nce
t
i ly
ta pore a vi we on s c a c putrt r i l . Re y,a 1
r ns td nd e d
pe i l om e e m na s' pl t 0.
'
l i lkey t tt bul oft doctme pr
t s i l ha he k he
l nt oducton wilbe elctoni . 4l a word wih
i
l
e r c fn
l t
f x ma hi s c mac nes e l o m i s ppi and mobie phonest tca s a a
a
c ne , opy
hi , mai, ve ght hi ng,
l
ha n c n nd
s nd doc nt ,t physc l l to of doc
e
ume s he
i a ocai n
umen s i ir l va .' M ir phe i LLC v.
t s re e nt'
c os rx
Bic mp t ls l c. s No 1 - 8 81 , 01 W L 24 7 4 a * ( D. a J n. 5 2 2 .
o o ai e . n .Ca e . 1CV- 0 3 2 2
b
3 6 , t 3 S. Fl. a 2 , 01 )
ç n lghtoft bm de a pa t m ovi f ta f rbe r ,a e a s
ç i
l
he
n
ry
ng or r ns e a s bs nt howi by t m o ng pa t
ng
he vi
ry
t t conta y,t sCour c i r t l a i ofr l va docl t a t r ltve ea e of
o he
r r hi
t onsde s he oc ton
e e nt lmen s nd he ea i
s
a c s t s c ofpr a non-acon' 1 I t abs e ofmor s cii i c tons t
c es o our es
oof
f t ' d. n he enc
e pe fc ndia i hat
c i r bl doc e pr ton wilt ke pl c on c putrt r na sa notelc r c l
onsde a e um nt oduc i
l a
ae
om e e mi l nd
e tonialy,
t l ton oft r l ntdocu e s doe not f vor et r ge a c l ton. Thi Cour
he ocai
he eeva
m nt
s
a
ihe ogr phi oca i
s
t
t r f e de e m i st s f c ort be ne r .
he e or t r ne hi a t o
utal
3. Conve e e t t Pa tes
ni nc o he r i
Appl c t nds t t S. Ca .i t m or conv e f t f Appl,as Appl i
e on e
ha D. l s he
e
enint orz or
m
e
e s
he dqua tr d i Norhe n Calf ni a t e de and docz e s i t s ma tr wilbe
a
re e n
t r
ior a nd he vi nce
lm nt n hi
te l
l aed i et rS. .Ca .orge r l i t St t ofCalf i M ot t Tr ns. a 6- Appl
oc t n ihe D
l
ne aly n he a e
iom a.
. o a , t 7.
e
f t rco e t tt tno wine s ordoc nt ar pr s nti S. .Fl .and t tW iLAN '
urhe nt nds ha ha
t s es
ume s e e e n D a
ha S
ofie s a diecor a e l ae i Ca
fc r nd r t s r oc td n nada and notFl i J. a 7. W iLAN diagee ,
orda. ., t
1
J
s r s
i ca i t t<
ndi tng ha ç e' al d bur n ofltg tng i Fl i woul beequa l f tb W iLAN
Appl s lege
de
ii a i n orda
d
ly el y i i we e f ce t ltga e i Ca ionza ..' M e .i Opp. a 1 Thi Cour ûndst twhie i
f t r or d o ii t n lf i ..' m n
, t 2. s
t
ha
l t
woul be s tntaly mor dit ul f Appl t ltgae i M i mia oppos d t Sa Digo,i
d
ubsa i l
e fk t or
e o ii t n n s
e o n e t
woul notbe s t ntal m or ditc tf W iLAN t ltgae i Sa Digo ms o
d
ubsa ily
e fi ul or o ii t n n e
ppos t
ed o
M imi W iLAN ha ve y f w r s i Fl i c pa e t Appl s sr ng r s i Caio ni
a . s r e oot n orda om r d o
e' to oot n lf r a.
The ef e,hi f ct f vo sta f r
r or t s a or a r r ns e .
4.The Loc ofOpe a i Fa t
us
r tve c s
ç ( l ee t e o eaie fcsu d ryng t e c u e o a to dd n to cz wihn te
$ W h r h p rtv a t n e li h a s f cin i o c l t i h
t
r
f um c e by t Pli if t c ce off um i e ild t l s consde a i '' M ot ol
or
hos n
he a ntf, he hoi
or s ntte o e s
i r ton.'
or a
M obiiv.I v.Mir of Co p. 804 F.Su 2d 1 , 1 ( D.F a 2 1 (uoig
lt nc.
cos t r ,
pp.
271 276 S. l . 0l ) q tn
Wi
ndme e Com .v.Remi t Pr . I . 61 F.Su 8,1 ( D. a 1 8 :. Hee Ap e
r
nz on odsm nc, 7
pp. 0 S. Fl. 9 5
r , pl
c ends t t lhe c nt r of gr viy of t a us d a tviy i l a e i SD Ca ,whe e t
ont
ha t
t e e
a t
he cc e c i t s oc t d n
l
r he
r s a c desg m a ke i a s l sdec sonsr a e t t a cus pr t and tc ogy
e e r h, i n, r tng, nd a e
ii
elt d o he c ed oduc s
e hnol
oc r e ' M ot t Tr . at9. W iLAN c e t tt r e z h,desg a de l pm e
cu r d.'
. o ans,
ont nds ha he es a c
i n nd ve o nt
t pl c i Cu ri notSa Di go. M e .i Opp. a 1 W iLAN alo poi soutt tt
ook a e n pe tno,
n e
m n
, t 2. s
nt
ha he
a c e i tu e a ii s i t s i t nce ar t Appl pr
c us d nsr m nt lte n hi nsa
e he
e oducs nott c
t,
he omponen pr t ,
t oduc s
a i i t rf eirlva t tQualomm i ba e i Sa Digo.l a 1
nd t s heeor ree nt ha
c
s s d n n e d. t 3.
W hehe i Sa Di o orCupe tno,i i a e t tt ope ai f c sa i s i t s
t r n n eg
ri t s ppar nt ha he r tve a t t s ue n hi
ltg i t plce ne l e ie y i Calf ni W iLAN c nnotpoi t any a tviy i t s
iiaton ook a
ary ntr l n ior a. a
nt o
c i t n hi
c s t tt pl c i Fl i W hie t r i s e dit
a e ha ook a e n orda.
l he e s om
sance bewe n N orhe n a Sout r
t e
t r nd
he n
Ca ior a, t e l ai a e muc c os r t ea h ot r t n Fl i i t a
lf ni hes oc tons r
h l e o c he ha
orda s o nywher i
e n
Calf ni The e or t sf c orwe g i f vo ofta f r
ior a. r f e, hi a t
i hs n a r r ns e .
5.Ava l lt ofPr s
iabiiy
oces
Appl c t ndst tt unde l ng t c ogy a is i t sma tri mmmf t r d by
e on e
ha he
ryi e hnol
t s ue n hi te s
ac u e
at r pa t Quac
hid ry, lomm,a t tt st hnol y i i r aedi o Appl pr t. M ot t
nd ha hi ec og s ncopor t nt
e oducs
.o
Trns,a 9. f ac mm wi l l s p l t ep i r t c ia win se ta wiltsiy a
a . t ç lo
ou
l i y u py h rma y e hnc l t e s s h t l etf t
l ke
til' J S. Calc n c
ra. . D. . a ompelQuacomm winese t a a t t tf whieS. Fl.c no .
'Z
l
t s s o ppe r o esiy l D. a an t
Se L- l a ton,S. Cal hass
e da n ddii
D. .
ubpoenapowe o rt pr e i at ney a muli e
r ve he oscutng tor
nd tpl
i ntr whieS F1 ha s
nve o s l C
SD a s ubpoe powe ove noneoft non- t wine s s' J .t9-0.
na
r r
he pary t s e . #aa 1
'
W iLAN a g st tç
r ue ha t e ha notpr e e a evi ncet tt wines e l atd i
Appl s
es nt d ny de
ha he t s s oc e n
Caior aa e a t ly unwilng t ta lt Fl i t t tf 'ort tt rt tmony c nnotbe
lf ni r c ual
li o r ve o orda o esiy' ha hei esi
a
o frd tr ug d po iin tsi n . Me .i Op ,a 1 - 2. E clu t g n r l ta se
fee ho h e sto etmo y
m n p. t 1 1 ç o rs e eal r n f r
l
y
c s s whe i po tnt wine s c n no be compe ld t t tf i t f u ,but c d be
ae
n m ra
t s es a
t
le o esiy n he or m
oul
s bpo e i t ta f r e c t' Comm e calSol nt Cor v. be t M u . ns. ,371F.
u ena d n he r ns e e our.
'
ri
ve s p. Li ry t I Co.
S p .2 7 2 0 ( D. Y.1 7 ) Hee S. Ca.i te prfr be v n f rt e e e cs o
u p 4 , 5 S. N. 9 4 . r , D. l s h eea l e ue o h x r ie f
s
ubpoe powe ove t r pa t w ines e . The ef e t sf t rf vor ta f .
na
r r hid ry t s s
r or , hi ac o a s r nser
TheRe ai M e nsoft Pari
l tve a
he tes
Bo h pa te i t si t nc a el r cor ae e ii .The e or t sf c o i ne ta .
t ri s n hi nsa e r a ge por t nttes
r f e,hi a t r s u r l
7.A For ' Fn la iy wih t Gove i La
um s miirt t he
m ng w
Pa e c esa egove nedby f de allw andbo h ditit a ef m iirwih f de al
t nt as r
r
e r a
t src s r a la t e r
pa e l . Thi f t i neu r .
t nt aw
s ac or s t al
7
8.TheW ei Ac or d Pl n if 'Choi eofFor m
ght c de aitfs
c
u
tç hepl i ifs c ce off u s d no be dit bed unl s i i cea l out g d
tr
antf hoi
or m houl t
sur
e s t s l ry weihe
b oh rc n ieains' Ro i o v. n mac & BilP. , 4F.d2 3 2 0( 1hCi.1 9 )
y te o sd rto .' bns n Gir r o ls C.7 3 5 , 6 1 t r 9 6
'
( u tn Ho l v Ta n r 6 0 F.d 61 61 (t Ci.Uni B 1 81 Ho v r ls
q oi g wel . n e , 5 2 0, 6 5h r t 9 :. we e , e s
c i r ton i due whe t oper tve f c sdi no oc uri Pl ntf c c off u . Se
onsde ai s
n he
ai a t d t c n ai ifs hoie or m
e
M as 1 F.Supp.2d a 1
on, 46
t 360. N o oft o r tve f c si t si t e oc ur e i S.
ne he pe a i a t n hi nsnnc c r d n D.
Fl Rahe ,t ope a i f c s occ r d i Ca io ni ,at
a. t r he r tve a t
ure n lf r a lhough notne es a iy i S. Ca .
c s rl n D. l
M ot.t Tr ,at 11.
o ans.
Appl as c e Fl i i no a t ly W iLAN USA' home f um . M ot t Tr ns,
e lo ont nds orda s t c ua l S
or
.o a .
a 1 11 W iLAN,t pa en c
t 0- . he r t ompa of W iLAN USA,i bas d i Ca
ny
s e n nada a W iLAN
nd -
US Sç r sn ei Flrd a p ast b smpl a atfc o ltg to ' 1 .a 1 (iains
A' ç e e c n o ia p e r o e i y n ria t f iiain. d t 1 ctto
p
'
omitd) W iLAN a t t tisde son- ki t bas is l i Fl i t i o ac ot
te . dmis ha t cii ma ng o e tef n orda ook nt c mt
ç e a dititc t t ta ekno e a econc r ngpa e m a tr ,pm ii t i t pae
s der l src ours ha r
f
wl dge bl
e ni
t nt te s
c pae n he tnt
pltp o r m,a d man an a e p di d d c e c mpae t oh rjlid ci n . M e i
i r ga n
o
iti n x e t o k t o rd o t e t s ito s'
e
r
' m. n
Opp.a 7.W iLAN' onl Fl i e oye i apaen at ne J a 4,8.AsW iLAN USA
,t
S y orda mpl e s t t tor y. Z t
l ppe r t ha be c e e s ey f t pur e offlng c e i t Sout r Dititof
t a s o ve en r atd ol l or he pos
a
ii as s n he
he n src
Fl rda't r i çl s t n pe s sve r s t de ta f r .
o i ' he e s ses ha
rua i ea on o ny r ns e
W ila USA.l v.
-- n
,
nc.
Alae- c n US I .No.1 - 2 5 8 2 3W L 3 8 8 , t* ( D. a J n. 9.2 3
c tlLu e t A nc,
2 CV- 3 6 , 01
5 3 5 a 5 S. Fl. a 2 , 01 )
( nyi t moton t ta f f l ng a c i rto of alt f t s . Gi n t s
de ng he i o r nser olowi
onsde ain
l he acor) ve hee
cic sanc s ltl wei s dbe gi n t t Pl i ifschoi off m .
r um t e , ite ght houl
ve o he antf
ce onz
9.Tra Efi e a t I t r t ofJ tc
il fcincy nd he n e ess usi e
Appl c ends t t ta f r t S. Ca . i i t publc i e e t bec us of l a
e ont
ha r nse o D. l s n he
i ntr s
a e
oc l
con ci a l a it r s. M ot t Tr ns,a 11. M ea
ne tons nd oc l n e e t
.o a . t
nwhie,C Fl ha ltl f cual
l I
SD a s ite a t
8
c
onne ton t t ca ms a ns Appl o he t n t s l of a c ed pr t i t ditit'
c i o he li gai t
e t r ha he a e
c us
oduc s n he src .
'
L ,a 1 W iLAN c n e d t a t u iile o o wilb b s s r e b d n i te
4 t 2. o tn s h t t d ca c n my l e e t e v d y e yng h
jl
M oton' be us t smia a tons a e as pe ng i t s diti t whi h çi ve t s
i ' ca e wo i lr c i
r lo ndi n hi src , c çnvol he nme
paen sa s t nta l smia is sofi rnge nta i ldiy,a m a be c oldae
t t nd ubsa ily i l r s ue
nf i me nd nvai t nd y
ons i td
wih t s a ton. M ot i Opp. a 9. Appl poi s o i r s e t tmotons t ta f rt
t hi c i '
'
.n
,t
e nt ut n e pons ha
i o r nse o
S. Ca .
D. l havebe fld i bot oft s ca esa wel. Re y,a 5.ç c us t e c e a e i
en ie n h he e s s l pl t ç a e hes as s r n
Be
t i e ri s sag a m a a s be ta f red Fr m SD Fl t SD Cal i woul bepr maur t
her a le t t es nd y l o r nse r
o
ao
,t
d
e t eo
asumet tt c ess dbekep i SD Fl andc oldaed. J Bec us t ec e ha
s
ha he as houl
tn
a
ons i t ' #= a e hes ass ve
'
t pos i lt o beng c olda e i eiherditit t sf t i ne ta .
he sbiiy f i ons i t d n t
src , hi acor s u r l
**+
l c n l in, e ii wh te t ta frac s iv l smo et nj t aligfco s
n o cuso d cdng eh r o rnse a e n ove r ha us tlyn a tr.
Thi Cour,howe r fndst tt t alt ofcr um sanc m a ta f rt mos a opra e
s
t
ve , i
ha he ot iy
ic t es ke r ns e he
t ppr it
dee m i ton. W hie i i notpe f c l c e rt t Sa Di go i t pe f c f u t hos t s
tr nai
l ts
re ty l a ha n e s he r e t or m o t hi
ltgai i Calf ni ,i i a
ii ton n ior a t s bunda l cla t ta Caiom i f u i f rm o e optm a t n a
nty e r ha
lf a or m s a
r
i l ha
Fl i f u . Se Coa tt coas St es I v.W om a korda or m
e
s-o- t or s nc.
c Bowe s l ,594 F.
r . nc.
supp.a 734
t
( nsdei t a t esoft tanse e r gi a awhol) l a ton,i tlsi fnc
co i rng he dvanag
he r fr e e on s
e . n ddii n ii nsn e,
ltl weght s d be gve t t Pli tf c c of f u . A ta f r t t Sout r
ite i
houl
i n o he a n ips hoie
or m
r nse o he
he n
Ditit of Caior a woul be mor c
src
lf ni
d
e onve e f t pa te a wine s a i i t
ni nt or he ri s nd t s es nd s n he
itr sso j tc .Se 28U. C. 1 0 ()
nee t f usie e
S. j 4 4 a .
11
1.
Conc uson
l i
Bas on t f eg ng,i i
ed he or oi t s
i o a f r nue
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t t De e nts Re wed M oton t Tr nse Ve
ha
f nda ' ne
( No 3 )i GRANTED. TheClr o Co r i drce t TRANS
ECF . 9 s
e k f u t s ie td o
FER t i a to t te
h s cin o h
Un td Stt sDititCo tf t Sout r DititofCa iom i . I i f rhe
ie ae src ur or he
he n src
lf a t s u t r
ORDERED AND ADJ
UDGED t tt Clr of Cour i die t d t CLOSE t sca e.
ha he e k
t s r ce o
hi s
A1 pe ng motonsa eDENI AS M OOT.
1 ndi
i
r
ED
DONEAND ORDE D i Chmb r aMimiFoiatiz d yo Api 2 1 .
RE n a es t a , lrd,hs
a f r,0 3
l
K . I AEL M O ORE
M CH
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI JUDGE
CT
c Al c ms ofr co d
c: l ot el e r
1
0
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?