Gordils et al v. Ocean Drive Limousines, Inc. et al

Filing 175

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 126 Motion in Limine. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 10/2/2014. (jw)

U NI )STATES D I
TEI
STRICT CO U RT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRICT O F FLO RI A
D
M I M I DI I O N
A
V SI

CA SE NO .1224358- v- l
c K NG
J G ORD I FRANCI
OE
LS,
SCO F AM OS,
L
(
BEYM AR SAB OGAL,RI
DER
M ORALES,PEDRO P.SO SA ,and a1
1
ot sm iary st ed,
her i l l iuat
Pl i if ,
antfs

OCEA N D RI LI OU SI ES,I .
VE M
N
NC ,
OCEA N D RI LI OUSI ES,I .
VE M
N
NC
SO .FLA . RI
, CHARD BEN NETTI a
, nd
M ELI
SSA BEN NETTI i vi l
, ndi dualy,
Def nt .
enda s
/

O RD ER G R AN TI G I PAR T PLAI TI
N N
N FFS'M O TI N I LI I f E 126)
O N M NE D
TH I CAU SE c es bef e t Cour upon Pl ntfs'Aprl 4,201 M oton i
S
om
or he
t
ai i f
i
4,
i n

Li n ( 1 ) The Cour i f l bref on t m ater lUpon r viw o t e r c d
mie DE 26
t s uly i ed
he
t .
e e f h e or
.

and afe ca ef consde aton, t Cour concl
tr r ul
i r i he
t
udes t Pl ntfs' M èton i Li i
hat ai if
i n m ne
s d be gr ed i par and de ed i par.
houl
ant n t
ni n t

Thi i a a to a ii tn rt FarLa orS a r sAc ($
s s n c in rsng l de he i b tnda d t i
FLSA' , U. C.
' 29 S.
)
j201e s q.l t i M oto i Li i ,Pli if m o t pr i ta y r f r nc a til
t e n her in n m ne antfs ve o oh bi n e e e e t ra
t ator
o t neys'f sand coss,lqui ed da a ,and Pl ntf t r ur .
ee
t i dat
m ges
ai ifs' ax et ns

1Def nt fl a Res
enda s ied
pons on Aprl21 201 ( 1 ) Pli tfsfld aRe y on
e
i ,
4 DE 46 . an if ie
pl

Aprl2 2 4 ( 1 0) a s te a dii na b i fn o J y 21 201 ( 1 3)
i 4, 01 DE 5 , nd ubmitd d to l rei g n ul , 4 DE 6 .

I
s

Ator vs Fe sand co t
t ne ' e
ss
Def ndant cont nd t tt y s
e
s
e ha he houl be a e t r ert a t neys'f s i cl i
d
bl o ef o tor
ee n os ng

agu n Glq e oug e d nc i prsntd a til'( 1 )(ii Pal v Sa
r me t sif n h vie e s e e e t ra. DE 46 ctng ma . #
'
Hu rc eShut r,I c , 0 - 291 - V- S, 1W L 60 073( D. a Oc . 4,
r ian
te s n . No. 7. 3 Cl AM 201
2
30
S. Fl . t 2
2011) Butt r i no l g lba i f r r f ri t at r y ' f e a c ss a til
).
he e s
e a ss o e e rng o to ne s e s nd o t t ra .
A tor
t neys' f es a coss ar pos-ral i s f t Cour hat do not r a e t a
e nd
t e
tt i s ues or he
tt
el t o ny

q si o fc frtej r t a we. e2 U. C.j21 b)Addto ly,heElve h
ueton f a t o h u y o ns r Se 9 S.
6( . iinal t e nt
Cic i' c re tpatr j r i tu to rmo d isr cins o atr y fe a
ruts u rn ten uy nsr cins e ve n tu to n tone s' e s nd
cossw hi had pr ousy been i l
t
ch
evi l
nc uded.Ther or Pal a,on w hi Def nda sr y,i
ef e m
ch
e nt el s
i pplc e.Thatcour alowed t def nt t r e t ator
na i abl
t l
he enda s o ef r o t neys'f a cos s S y
ees nd t s
onl

i t i cl i a gum e a lm ied t t i tuc i ' Pal 2011 W L 6030073,a
n he r os ng r
nt nd i t o he nsr ton.' ma,
t
*1. The i tuc i has changed. Ther i no l
ns r ton
e s
onge a bass, not e n i cl i
r ny
i
ve n os ng

agu n,t r frt at ne s fe a c t t t j r Digma v Car Shil US
r me t o ee o tor y ' e s nd oss o he uy. n n . t ed A,
LLC,1 - 08 C1 201 WL .35 35 ( D. a J l 3,201 )( r e i d f n a t i
2 20 8- V, 3
3 38 S. Fl . u y
3 o d rng e e d n s n
a FLSA c s no t r frt at r ys fe a c t a ti l;Ta a v Fl rd Clane ,
n
a e t o e e o to ne ' e s nd oss t ra) pi , o ia e x
I c,No. 9 21 69 C1 ECF No.1 ( D . a M a . , 3)( a ) Thepa te mus
n . 0 - 5 - V,
'
26 S. Fl . r 27 201 s me .
ris t

n trfrt atr y 'fe a c t beor t j r
o e e o tone s e s nd oss f e he u y.
I
L

Li dat d Da e
qui e mae s
Under t FLSA ,Pl ntf s ar e il t lqui e dam ages i D ef
he
ai i f e ntted o i dat d
f endant di
s d

no a ti g odfih. e 29U. C.j26 I aj r fnd t tDee da sa tdwiluly
t c n o at S e
S.
0. f u y i s ha fn nt ce lf l,
t n t Cour m us a a d lqui e da a i a a ountequalt t com pe at y
he he
t
t w r i dat d m ges n n m
o he
ns or
2

d ma s a r d,whc d bls t ttld ma e a r Ala e Pe e v Safo da ge wade
ih ou e he oa a g s wad. v r z r z . n r
Ora Ke ne Cl b l . 51 F.d 1 5 , 1 6 ( 1h Ci.2008 .df e wilule s o
lndo n l u , nc, 5 3 1 0 1 6 1 t r
) s' lf n s r
-h

g odfih q sin i a wee frtb tej r . . ndte i t r i av r itf rte
o at ueto s ns rd s y h uy . a h n, f hee s e dc o h
e oy e a an b tej get d tr newhehe t a r lqui td d ma s' 11h
mpl e , g i y h ud o eemi
t r o wad i dae a ge . t
'
Ci .Ci l Pate n J y I sr to j 4.4 c .I. ( 01 ) ( ii g Mo gan v Fa l
r vi t r ur n tuci ns
1 mt IB. 2 3 ctn
r
. mi
y

Dola St e ,I . 551F. 1 1 2 ( 1h Ci. 008 )
l r or s nc
3d 233, 28 1 t r 2 ).

Ar me t ma b d t tej r a u goo f ih o wilul s s t tt
gu ns y ema e o h u y bo t d at r lf ne s o ha he
j y' fn ngont tis eoffc ma fr t b ssf aCo tsa r n lq d td
ur s idi
ha su
a t y om he a i or ur' wadig iuiae
da ages;butt e i no l
m
her s egalbasi t alow pari t r ert lqui t dam agesbe or
so l
tes o ef o i da ed
f e

tej r Se Digma ,2 3 W J 3 538 ,a #1(r eig dee nt i a FLS c s
h uy. e n n 01 L 3 35 t o d rn fnda s n n A a e
no t r f rt lq dae d ma e a ti l;T pi,N o. - 5 - V,ECF No.1 ,p.
t o e e o i ui t d a g s t ra) a a
09 21 69 C1
26 2
(a ) Pal 2011 W ' 60 07 a #1 ( a ) Fu t r o e i c ul b u ul
s me ; ma,
L 30 3, t
s me . rhe m r , t o d e nd y

prj ca- wihnopr baievau - f t j r t he rt tPlitfsma bea r d
eudiil t
o tv le or he uy o a ha anif y wade
d be d ma e i tej y fndst tDee nt a td wiluly.The pate mus no
ou l a g s f h ur i ha fnda s ce lf l
ris t t
rlrt lq dae da g sbeo et j y.
ek o iui td ma e fr he ur
1 1. Tax R e urns
1
t

Pl ntf s m ove t exc ude a r er
ai if
o l
ny ef ence t Pl ntf s paym e or nonpaym e of
o ai if '
nt
nt
f ali
eder ncom e t xes a r ques t Def
a , nd e
t hat endant be t e t ques i Pl ntf s atal
s
mabl o
ton ai if
l

rg r ngtei txe , ss c q sini woul b prj diila ir lv ntDee nt
e adi h r a s a u h ue to ng
d e eu ca nd ree a . fnda s
r pond t t Pl ntfs' t x r ur r a e t a varet of da a
es
ha ai if a et ns elt o
iy
m ges i s
s ues, a t
nd hat

r er e t t
ef enc o hem m a bepr rf a va i t ofpur s,i udi i peac ent
y
ope or r e y
pose ncl ng m
hm .
3

The M oton i Li i as t t x r t ns i pr a ur The t x r ur m ay orm a
i n m ne
o a e ur s em t e.
a et ns
y

notbe r e
elvant or adm i sbl f a vare y of r s ,de ndi on how a f w ha
s i e or
it
ea ons pe ng
nd or
t
pur e t a e of e ed or r f r nce a ti .The Cour not t t cera n is ,f
pos hey r f r
e e e d t ral
t es ha
t i s ues or

w hi h t pari ar
c he tes gued t t x r ur m i be r e nt ha s nce bee a es e or
he a et ns ght el va , ve i
n ddr s d
r ol by Or r of t s Cour .Se e. ,O r r G r i i Pa tPl ntf s Rene ed
es ved
de s
hi
t e, g. de antng n r ai if '
w

M o i n f rPa t lSumma y J gme t( 1 , 9 (s di Pl itfst b De e nt'
to o ri
a
r ud n DE 57 p.) tn ng an if o e fnda s
e o e s u e t FLSA) Pl itfs M oto i de e a t t x r t r wiho t
mpl y e nd r he
. an if '
in s ni d s o a eu ns t u

prj diet tepate 'a lt t riea prpraeo j ci sa til
eu c o h ris biiy o as p o it b e ton t ra.
A c di y,upon a c ef r vi w of t r d a t Cour bei ot
cor ngl
ar ul e e
he ecor nd he
t ng henvi e
s
f l advi e i i O R DERED,ADJUD G ED ,and DECR EED t Pl ntf s'Apr l4,
uly
s d, t s
hat ai if
i

201 M o in i Li i ( 1 )be a t s meis r b GRANTED I PART a
4, to n m ne DE 26 , nd he a s he e y
N
nd
D ENI I PART .The pari s m us notr ert ator ys'f s a coss,or lqui e
ED N
te
t
ef o t ne
ee nd t
i dat d

da ge,beo etej r Thepa t s a lt t riea pr p it o j cinsa tila t
ma s fr h u y.
ri ' biiy o as p o rae b e to t ra s o
e
t r t ns i pr e ve
ax e ur s es r d.
D ON E and O RD ERED i Cham ber att J esLawr nce K i Feder J tce
n
s he am
e
ng
al us i

B l ng nd
'uidi a Unie St es Courhous ,M i i Fl i t s2d day ofOct ,201
t d at
t e am , or da, hi
ober
4.

.,*
.'

.
A*

.

XM

*
,
'

c
c:

A l Couns ofRecor
l
el
d
4

J M ES LA W M N CE K I G
N
I
TED STATES D I
STRI J GE
UD
SOU THERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D