Pruco Life Insurance Company v. Richardson et al

Filing 36

Order Granting Defendant U.S. Bank's Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/20/2013. (vds)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT

S
OUTHE DITRIT04F ORI
RN S C
L DA
MimiDi soh
a
vii

Cas Num be 1 24441 C1 M ORENO
e
r: 2- VPRUCO LI I
FE NSURANCE COM PANY,
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

U S BAN K , S SECURI ES I
A
TI NTERM EDI
ARY ;
GAR Y A . CHA RD SON ; FE BRO KEM G E
RI
LI

;

EQUI GROUP,
TY
LLC;a J
nd OHN DOES 1 0,
-1

r
i
1

Dee d n s
fn a t.

!

ORDER GM NTI DEFENDANT U
NG

i ,
S.
BANK S M OTI TO DI I
ON
SM SS

.

THI CAUSE c mebeor t Cour uponU. Ba N. 'M otont DimisCountIof
S
a
f e he
t
S. nk, A.
S i o s s
t Co pl nt Fort r s s toutbel ,U . Bn sM oton i GR AN TED .
he m ai .
he ea ons e
ow
S. nk?
i s
i

1 Ba kg o
. c r und

j
:

Th s sa a to f r caaoyj d me t nwhc Pli tf Pr c LieI u a c Co a y
i i n ci n o de lrtr u g n i ih anif u o f ns r n e mp n
i
!

(t uc 's ksadecartont tt lf i trnc poltisaeil alwa rngc rcsa ae
ç o' ee
Pr )
l ai ha wo ie nsla e i e r leg gei onta t nd r
v d ab i tof l c ofi tr e i e es a i e i
oi
nii or a k nslabl ntr t t nc pton.i
A.TheAle d '
lge '
STOL1'Sc me
' he
i

l Se e be of2005, alndGuida i t Pli ifPr coLieI lr nc Compa f
n ptm r
Ros i
l ppled o antf u f nsza e
ny or

t $5milonlf i urnc polcis(he' l Polci '.
wo
li ie ns a e i e t ' d i ts' Compl! 1 Thea iai na d
Gui
)
. .
pplc tons me

i
i

M s Guid' da e a t prmaybe ii y.Exs B & C a 2;Compl!41. codi t t
. l s ughtr s he i r nefcar
.
t
.
Ac r ng o he

Co lithwee, . i 'duhewa nvrhItu itne bnf ir oteplis
mpan,o vrMsGul s agtr s eet)renedd eeiay fh oie.
d
c
c
I

lse d P uocams teGul Poiisweep rh sds ta te c udltrbes l o te
n ta , rc li ,h id lce r uc ai o h t h y o l ae od n h
i
:

s onda y ma ke t a i t wih no i tr bl i e e ti M s Guid' lf wha Pnlo c lsa
ec
r r t o n nvesor t
nsla e nt r s n .
l s ie: t c a l
!

' tangerore e lf i lr nc ' '
'r
STOLI' c m e. A c or ng t t eCom pl nt t ar hiect
's he
i c di o h
s
- int d ie nsza e'or '
ai , he c t
of t s s he e wa Pr o' own a nt Def nt Gh y Ri ha ds Pr o a l es t t M r
hi c m
s uc s
ge , enda Ir c r on. uc leg ha
.

lihad o wo k di c nc r wi De e d n LieBr k r g Eq t Gr u a d sv r l n a d
tc r s n r e n o et t fn a t f o p a e ui o p n e e a u n me
h
y
d
:
ee nt (ol Does1 1 )t pr def s i or tonlo eni whowoul uli t yfna e
fnda s J m
- 0 o ovi ale nf mai c nc r ng
d tmael i nc

!
a be
nd
1
nei fo t Guid Polces Pr o cai M s. l wa ne r i ve i t pr s of
tt r m he l
i i . uc l ms
Ggid s ve nvol d n he oce s
1
i

compltng t lf i ur ncea i tons s sg d t doc e safe beng ofer d 'r e lf
e i he ie ns a
pplcai ; he ine hk um nt tr i f e ' e ie
f
1
i

i s rnc 'o s meoh rb n fti rt r f rp o ii V rsg au e
n u a e' r o te e ei n eu n o r vdng in t r .
i

Pnlois e teGui P lce o Oco e 21 20 5 c r n t teCo an, ohMr
c su d h
l o iis n tb r , 0 .Ac odig o h mplitb t .
d

Iih rs na dLieBrk rg Eq iyGru rc ie s! fc n c mmiso su o t is n e
lc ad o n f o ea e ut o p e ev d !niia t o sin p n he sua c
g
:

oft polces Thepolce na dt Ros i GuidFa l I ur elrvoc bl Tnzta t
he ii .
iis me he alnd l miy ns anc re a e s s he
!

rcodowne a be fcir ofheGuidPolces Acc yi t t Compl ntt GuidTr t
e r
r nd nei ay t
l ii . or! ng o he
ai ,he l uswas
f
onne t lt rf c lt t t s eoft bene i a i e es i t polc e t s conda yi sor .l
d o a e a iiae he al he
fcil ntr t n he ii s o e
r nve t s n

a t lt Pr coa lges M s Guidhadnoi ve e i i f ma i of hetus ori t elc i
c ua iy, u le , . l
nvol m nt n he or ton t r t n he e ton
:
i

oft tuse W elsFa goBa N. Pr coe nt l delve e t polci t t tuseea t
he r t e, l r
nk, A. u ve ualy i r d he i es o he r t nd o
!

M r Ri ha ds
. c r on.

#. y n o e u
Pa me t fpr mims
Shorl t r afe , u o r c ve i ta pr m i !a e st alng ove $700,000 f rbot
ty he e tr Pr c e ei d niil e um p ym nt ot i
i
r
o
h
Guid Polc e . Some t ye r l tr Pr o r e ve a c nge ofowne s p a be t ir
l
ii s
wo a s ae , uc ec i dl ha
r hi nd nek a y
'

rq et c a i teo e a db neiir o teGu# Poiist Dee d n U. Ba k a
e u s, h ngng h wn r n e tcay f h l l e o fn a t S. n , s
d c
!

sc rte itnne ir .P u oa po e terq etdo !e a db neiir c a g i Fe rayo
euiisne day r c p rv d h e u se v r n e fcay h n e n b ur f
1

2 0 Ac odn t Pnlo t sc a g o o es i 'o kplc i c l cinwi tesl o te
0 8. c rig o c ,hi h n e f wn rhp ' o a e n ometo t h ae fh
t
h
I
q
i

be fca i e e ti t GuidPo i e t a i sorwih no i ur bl i e es i M s Guid' lf '
ne il nt r s n he l lcis o n nve t
t
ns a e nt r t n . l s ie.
'

I

Mo

i

r ta $ milo i ttl r mims v b e p i f th p lce .Pn c camsta ds o ey
e h n 2 lin n o a p e u ha e e n ad o te oiis zo li h t ic v r
i

i t sc e woul r vea t tno oft pr m i pa m e s we e m a b M s Guid. Thos
n hi as
d e l ha ne he e um y nt r
de y .
l
e
:

pr mi pa m e s ha r ule i c
e um y nt ve es t d n omm ison pa nt i exc s of $200, 00 t M r
si
yme s n es
000. o .

Ri r onand$1 000. t LieBr rgeEquiyUr
chads
20, 00 o f okea
t !oup.
C Thel t M oton
nsant i
Pr c br ht hi a tons e ngadeca ai hy t Guid Polci a evoi Spect al ,
u o oug t s ci e ki
lr tont t he l
i es r d.
ik ly

Co n lo te Co lits e saj d me td cai g ta t Gul Poiisaev i a i t
u t f h mp an e k u g n e lrn h t he i l e r o d b nio
d c
i
!

bec us t y lc a i ur bl i t r ta t ri pt, n.Pr o alo c am st i i e ild t
a e he a ked n ns a e n e es t hei nce i
b
uc s l i hat t s ntte o
r t i t pr m i pa ent .
e a n he e um ym s

U. Bakh smo e t ds s Co t1o t jo n st tifist saeacam u o
S. n a v d o imis un n he ru d ha t al o tt li p n
whihr l f a b g a tda dt t h c mpan s o l V ds se wihprj iea a an th
c ei c n e rn e n ha t e o lit h u d imisd t eudc s g i s te
e
ba U. Ba a s r quesst r t oft pr mi si ha pad. n s
nk. S. nk lo e t he eum
he e um t s i l uppor, . Ba a g s
tU S. nk r ue

t tCount1sba r Fl i ' 'nc esa lt saut 'Fl Sttj627. )a byt t ye r
ha
i redby ordas' ont tbiiy tt e'( a. a.
i
455 nd he wo- a
i ont sa lt pr son c aned i bot oft Guid Polces s cond, ha Co mtli ba r d by
nc e t biiy ovii ont i n h he l i i ; e
t t t
s re
i

ag n r l ttt o l tto s( a S a. 9 1 4 )1 ;h r ,h t ni sla l itr s d de s a
e ea sau e f i ain Fl. tt j 5.13 49) tid t a a n t be n ee t i xit t
mi
r
.

t tmet i urncec rc wa ma (ha ofM sGuid'daug e ,oa Guid) a f t t t
he i he ns a onta t s de t t
. l s htr J n l ; nd,ourh,ha
Pr o' r que t or t i t ne l $2m ilon dola si pr i ale ypad ont polc s ul
uc s e s t e an he ary
li
l r n em ums r ad i he iy ho d
besrc n be us underFl rdalw,i apolc i r ci d orvoi a i ur rmus plc t
tike ca e,
oi a f
iy s es nde
ded, n ns e
t a e he

iuebc iteae oio tenue wsnbjeh eetedtot plyTe
n r aknh sm psi h i r ai eo tefcv a fh oi.h
sd
tn s d
r fi e e c
I
isnmoinrltsnyoC utote o ln,Iiite nyct asrdaa sU..
nt t t ea olt onIfh C mpa tY tsh ol omtset gi t S
a o e
i
e n
!
5

i

Bank.
l
i

Pr cohassr c ur d iscli a ns U. Ba 4sa ac i s e ng ade a a i t tt
u
tu t e t am gai t S. nk ' n ton e ki
,
clr ton ha he
I

polcis a e voi ab i to f l c ofi ur bl i e es i t rt n voi bl due t fa
ie r
d
nii or a k ns a e nt r t- he ha
r
a
da e
o r ud. Thi
s
i

dsicin i n tbl, sFlrd 1w hod t tu tme/ camst a poiisaev ia l d et
itn to s oa e a o ia a ls ha ni l li h t l e r od b e u o
c
faud ae pr bie by t i ont tbiiy ca e. The is bef e t Cour i whet rt
r r ohi td he nc esa lt lus
sue or he
ts
he he
l
:

!

ic netblt ca s i teGul Poiisas a pist prhbt uo'u tmeycamsh th
n o tsa ii lu e n h i l e lo p le ô o iiPrc s ni l li ta te
y
d c
l

Polcisa ev dabi to.TheCour hol t ts hcl n sa eba r dbyt i ont t biiyclus .
i e r oi nii
t ds ha uc aii r r e
he nc esa lt a e
i

Thi hol es cilytu i t sca e i w hi h t c a m i tt polc i voi ab i to due t l k
s ds pe a l r e n hi s n c he l i t he i y s d
ha
nii
o ac
,
;

ofi tr bl i er s i uli ael ta a e t a ca m offa
nsla e nt e t s tm t y r ce bl o li
r ud.
1 Di
11. scussi
on
:

Cot Ifist saeacai asamatroflw bet us Pr odi notchalnget valdiy
mt al o tt l m
te a
a e uc d
le he i t
;

oft Guid Polc e be or t e r ton oft t ye r ç nc e t biiy' pe i Fl rda'
he l
ii s f e he xpiai
he wo- a d ont sa lt ' rod. o i s
i
i ont sa lt sa ut m a t t t 1nslanc c r c scon ai ac a es ti f t at y r
nc e t biiy tt e ndaes ha a1i tr e onta t t n l us e tng orh wo- ea
pe i a t whi h t vai t oft c r c ca
rod fer c he ldiy he onta t nnotbe k lng
hale ed:

Eve yi ur ncecon r c s l pr det tt polc s l bei ont t bl afe i ha be n
r ns a
ta t ha l ovi ha he i y ha l nc esa e tr t s e
i

i f red rn t lftmeo t ei u e frap ro o 2y asfo isd t o is e c p
n o c u ig he iei f h ns rd o es d f e r r m t ae fsue x e t

(Jfrn n a me t f rmimsa de e ta t o to o teis rr (1a t po so s
1 o o p y n o pe u n xcp,thJ pin fh n ue,2 so rviin
r ai t be is i e nt of dia lt a a t pr sons whih g a addii l
eltve o neft n ve
s biiy nd . o ovii
s
c r nt
tona
i tr nces c fc ly a ns de t byac de o?ac i nt m e ns
nsla
pe ii a l gai t a h
ci nt i c de al a .

Fl. tt j6 74 5 BohGul P iisc nantef l wi ic n e tbi t ca s :
a Sa. 2 .5 . t id ol e o ti h ol ng n o tsa l y lu e
c
o
i

j
Count1 oft c pli conai ale i t tM r Ri' ds LieBr ageEquiy Gr and
1 he om ant t ns lgatons ha . har on, f oker
t oup,
ot r madega en m ir es nttonsr ga di t tuepu pos f t GuidPolcis,hes c ofprm im s
hes
udul t sepr e ai e r ng he r
r
or he l
i e t our e
e u
f t Guid Polcesa M s Guid' i om e aset a ne worh,wih t i en i t Pr cowoul r y o
or he l
ii nd . l s nc , s s nd t t t he nt ton hat u
d el n
t em ir pr s nttonswhe is ngt GuidPolces CountII le t s s m em ir pr s nt i w ee
hos se e e ai
n sui he l
ii .
I lges he e a
se e e atons r
ne i nt CountI alege t tt faud en a orne i ntmir pr entto amount t aci lc pia
glge .
V l s ha he r ul t nd/ glge
s es ains
ed o vi ons rcy
a ns Pr co.CountV c ai abr c ofconr c cl m a ns r Rihads
gai t u
ont ns ea h- - ta t ai gai t . c r on.
I
1
i

i
i
:

Exc pta wesaei t ne s nt nc wewilnptc e tt sconta a tri ha be n i
e s
t t n he xt e e e,
l
ont s hi
r ct fe t s e n

fred r gtenue 'lei frwoyasl teisedt. eecpin ae()
oc ui h Isrdsi t o t erf h su aeTh xet s r:1
n
f me
jm
o
non- y ntofe ug prmi t pa t rqtie c ge ;a ( a cha i t
pa me
no h e um o y he e p rd har s nd 2) ny nge n he

cnrctarqi suapoaadht ud rae ulblyFrn sc cag,
ot t teur orp rvln tawolYcesori it.oayuh hne
ah
e
ai

wewilnotcon es t cha a t i ha bee i e f tf t ye r durngt lf i eof
l
t t he nge fer t s n nlfec or wo a s i he ietm
t l tr
he nsled.
Com pl Exs K & L a 5.
. .
t

The i ont t biiy caus wor t t m ut adva age oft i ur ra t i ur d,
nc esa lt l e
ks o he
ual
nt
he ns e nd he ns e
gvi t i ur d agua a ya i te
i ng he ns e
r nt ga ns xpensveltgai 4 gi ngt c
i ii ton nd vi he ompa y ar s bl tm e
n ea ona e i
r
d e n n or
a do p rtmiyt as erai whet rt i ur ncecontactshoul r m ai i f ce Al tt Lf I s
n p o t t o c t n he he ns a
l ae e n .
s
.

Co. v M ilr 424 F. 111 111 ( 1h Ci.2005 . Fl i pr c nt ha i e eed
. le ,
3d
3, 5 1 t r
) orda e ede
s ntmrt
I
i
i
nc e t biiy caus a a ol eba st eforsbyt i ur rt r ci t polc a trt ye r
ont sa lt l es s bs ut r o f t he ns e o es nd he iy fe wo a s

f a ot rr as t n t ari a e e e i i t sa ut d.l e t Fl i Supr me
or ny he e on ha he tcult d xc ptons n he tt e.I nde d,he orda
e

Co r h sl e d j6 74 5t asaueo lmi to s 1 . t1 1 (iigPr c I s Co o
u t a i ne 2 .5 o tt t f i t in . d a 1 5 ctn u o n . .fAm. .
k
a
v
Pr s t 1 So.875,878( a.1937)
ecot, 76
F1
).
Thi de f c o s a u e oflm ia i a i r r vs oft ba i f t c le a t t
s a t ttt
i t tons pples ega dl s he s s or he ha l nge s o he

vai iy oft polc i l ng i c e i whih i i al ge t tt i ur d led ort to he
ldt
he iy, nc udi n as s n
c t s le d ha he ns e i
ha t r

i e i lo s i o mirpr s nttonsweema whe a yi f hepolc Se i (ii
ntntona misons r se e e ai
r de n ppl ng ort
iy. e d.ctng

Ba k r S c L4'I s So . .Ka , 8 F.d8 0 8 -)( 1hCi. g g t se r sn ai na t
n es e . / n . c v ne 8 5 2 2 , 212 1 t r l 8 lmir p e e tto s o
:
ie tt o i u e ) Gr at . teI s Co v Po c r , 6 So 2 5 5 5 6( a 4h2 0 )fa da
d n iy fns rd ; e S L / n . . . r a o 8 9 . d 8 , 8 F1. t 0 4 (ru s
'

t f c o i u e sd ah ; u ma v Mu . foma aI s Co, 81S 2 7 7, 5 - 3( a 3
o a t f ns r d' e t) Ka f n . t o
h n . .6 o. 4 4 7 0 5 F1. d
DCA l g ln n ds l t eo p ee itn c n iin )Di a ov Na 1Fou d Lf I s Co, 51
g 6 t o - icosl f r- xsig o dto s; Fr nc . t
r
n e n . .5
:

S 2 5 , 3 ( a 3 DCA1 8 )fi r t dsls pro me c lrame t n hsoy; u o
o. d 35 5 6 Fl. d
9 9(a1 e o ico e sr dia tet n a d itr)Pr c
u
!
I
.

Is Co o vRh d i e, 8 S 2 6 9( a 3 DçA l 3 t se rsnain a t h at
n . .fAm. . o rgu z 2 5 o. d 8 F1. d
g7 lmirpee tto s so e l
h
l

i
i

!

a dme c l itr ) Th Co r wil o ce t e c p ins oF o ialw o v i is rn ep lce
n dia hso y . e u t ln t rae x e to t lrd a r o d n u a c oiis
ab i to i a mn rt twoul u r net i en ofi Fl i lgi lt ea t pr c ie i
nii n
nne ha
d nde mi he nt t t
he orda e saur nd he a tc n
1
Fl i c t . K ane 885 F.2d a 8
orda our s
,
t 22.
.

!

P u o is e t e Gu l Poiisi Oco e 2 0$ b tdi n tc n e tt i v l t t i
r c su d h id lce n t b r 0 u d o o ts her ai y mtl
di

De e e 20 2, r ta sv ny a sfo ted t o is a ea dmo et nfv y asa trhe
c mb r 1 mo e h n e e e r r m h ae f pu nc n r ha i e e r fe t
1
I

e prto o teic netblt p ro . Durn tos sve y as Pnlo c l ce pe u
x iain f h n o tsa ii eid
y
ig h i e n e r, c ol td rmim
e

!
!
pa m e son t Guid Polcis Bec us Pnz di no .ont tt valdiy oft Guid Polces
y nt
he l
i e.
a e co d tc es he i t
he l
ii
wihi t ye r of is nc , a c le t t e Pdlces i pr hi t d by Pr o' e es
t n wo a s
s ua e
hal nge o hes
ii s o bie
uc s xpr s
r pr s nt tons i ea h Polc s i ont t biiy cl us
e e e ai n c
i y' nc es a lt a e.

Pr c a g t thei nt sa lt clus doesnbt ppl bec us i i s ki ade l r to
u o r ues ha t nco e t biiy a e
a y a e t s ee ng c a ai n
i

t tt Polciswer v d ab i to bas d on a lc ofi :ur bl i t r ta i e i Se D. 1
ha he i e
e oi
nii e
a k ns a e n e es t nc pton. e E. 7

a 5,7- Theeor Pr oagues t i nt t lt clus ne rwe i oefe t1 Howe r
t 9. rf e, uc r ,he nco esabiiy i e ve nt nt f c.d.
ve ,
'

t s Co thol t tt i nt sa lt clus a i swih e lf c t cli t tt Guid
hi ur ds ha he nco e tbiiy a e pple t qua or e o a ms ha he l
ï

Polc esw e e voi ab i to.
ii
r
d
nii

;

Co rsaedvd do teis eo wh t e a i cin etb l yca ea pist b racam
u t r iie n h su f eh r n n h tsa ii lus p le o a li
t
t t c t a ti v d ab i to.
ha a on r c s oi
nii

Co rs olwigt emaoit viw h l t a ic n e tbl yca e
u tf l n h j j y e o d h tn o tsa it lus s
o
i
i
;

ha noefc whe eapolc i v d abi tof lckofi urbl i ee t Pru Lf:I .Co.v
ve fe t r
iy s oi nii or a
ns a e ntrs. co / ns
'
.

Br s e , 1 - 0 0 ,2 1W L 1 40 6 a n. ( . il.J n 7 201 lctn 7 W il tn o
a n r No. 0 8 8 4 01
3 5 t 5 SD.F a a . , ltiig
li o n
s
Co ta t j 1 5 n.2 ( 01 ). l c nr s,c u t f lo ng t e mi o iy v e h d ta
nrcs 7:, 3 2 0 ) n o tat o rs olwi h n rt iw ol h t
i ont sa lt l us ba i ur nc c
nc e t biiyc a es r ns a e ompanis cli r ga di t va i t ofns a epolcesz
e ' a ms e r ng he ldiy i ur nc i i .
I

z orda a a st f l t mi iy viw bas d ont f l ng satm e b t
Fl i ppe r o olow he nort e
eI
he olowi t e nt y he

i ont ssrl y uuse Apelçlhecl sodqens nnacestnt vniapoft opolcn
T i Ditct clroi çpaher-etrihoftuiturjr laeivlildiylainoi yor
hr a it tf t sh he l he si # e ats o hevag p i t f
d
Co
:o
o t che a
nc e t bii a s whe t am
!
-

6-

I

l

I

.

.

I
!

I (ingfic l Lf'd An u i Co o i v Be n ti , 9 N. S 3 9 2 0 W L 1 1 46 , t
d ct n on / r n n t .fN : . r sen 8 0 Y.. 6 , 0 9
i
e
y
92 8a
i
* ( Y. u Ct2 9) Flrd lw e rc sb t t p bl poiyt a p o bt a is r n e
4 N. S p. . 00 ). o ia a mb a e o h h u i lc h t r hiis n n u a c
c
co pa fom c e tng t polc afe t i ont sa iiype i a t publc polc t ta
m ny r
ont si he iy tr he nc e t lt rod nd he
i i y ha n

i urbl i eeti nec s ayf a i urncepolc t evai i t frtplc 1 (ii Fl
ns a e ntrs s e s r or n ns a
iy o
ld n he is a e. d. ctng a.

Sa. 67441;l.ttj674 5.Netepr ctsbnigcs1wrqiigtiCor
ttj 2.0()FaSa. 2 .5) i r at j idn aea eurn hs ut
h y e
I

t r c ieonepolcyove t ot , ha e t rp
o e onc l
i
r he her nor s ihe

pr s nt t Cour wih a e de eof
e e ed he
t t ny vi nc

l il tve i e r ga di i nt t lt pe i a 1 c ofi tr bl i e es cli .
eg sai nt nt e r ng nco esabiiy rods nd k nsla e nt r t a ms3
The publc polc unde l ng t i ont t bii sa ut weihs i f vor of ba rng a
i
iy
ryi he nc esa l tt e
g n a
ri n
i ur rsa tmpt t c le apolc outi t sa u or perod,e n whe t i ur rca ms
ns e ' te s o ha lnge
i y sde he tt y i ve
n he ns e li

ta tepoiyiv i biio TheCo ro Ap e lo #e Yoka t a ay e tep bi p lc
h th l s oda nt .
c
i
u t f p as f ! w r pl n lzd h u lc oiy
y
i

weg igi fv ro c nrcua tn ly wh n a is irc aln e apoiyb sd o lc of
ihn n a o f o tat l iai e n n ue h le g s lc ae n ak
t
I

)

.

i ur bl i e es i a STOLIcont xta t rt i ont t iiy pe i hasexpied.I Ne Engl d
ns a e nt r t n
e f e he nc es a lt rod
r
n w
an
I
I
I
whe he i r a e t lm ia i ofc r ge. l i r l t o t f
t r t el t s o i t tons ove a
f t e a es he onne i i ba r d;i t t l te
r t s r e f o he a t r

ii not''PaulRev r ffeI .Cov Damu ,Ec e,R s nt andMar hal,M D. 864So.
t s .'
e e / ns
'
.
s k r e hal
s l
,
2d
442,444( a. DCA zoo3lemphassadde .Howe r noFl i c t se esl
Fl 3d
t
i
d)
v , orda our ha xpr sy
a d e s dwh te Flrd f lo t mi o i o mao t viw.
d r se eh r o ia o lws he n rt r j r y e
y
3
'd i
U . Ba r leson t El ve h Cic ts e s n i M ilr f t pr poston t t
S. nk e i
he e nt r ui
c i n le or he o ii ha

.

Pnz o m a notc le t G uid Polc e ,e n t ug Pr co c ai st y a e voi ab i to.
c
y
ha l nge he l
i i s ve ho
u l m he r
d
nii
Se D. 1 a 8.I M il r t El nt Cic thed t t i ont t biiyclus ba r d t
e E. 5 t n le , he eve h r ui l h he nc esa lt a e re he
i ur nc c
ns a e ompa sc l
ny' halenget t polc eve t
o he i y, n houg i wa a lgedt ta i pose
t s le
ha n m tr

q

s itd t i ta m e c le ua i Se M ilr 4241 3d a 111 Rhodrgue 285 So.2d
ubm te he niil dia val ton. e le , F. t 6;
i z,

è

a609 (odn ta, hra isrrsli rle jte aii o teisrne oiy
t 8-0 hlightw ee n nue'ca ea soh vl t fh ntac pl ,
m t
dy
z
c

'

a g d t polc wa v d ab i to,t c teq td t i poserde e et afa de e e,
r ue he iy s oi
nii he our uae h m t f ns o r ud f ns
t r by cas iyi i asvoi lt c am r t rt n a v i ab i to cli . Se i a 111
he e l sf ng t
dabiiy l i ahe ha
d
nii am
e d. t 7;

r

t tcai i bardbyani ontsa lt clus) Alho ght i urnc c
ha l m s re
nc etbiiy a e . t
he ns a e ompanyi Milr
n le

Pr oLfeI .Co.v Br ne No.1 80804,2011W L 3
uc / ns
'
. as r,
04056a FN 5( D.Fl.J n.7,2011.
t
S. a a
)
The Cour t ndst tt M il r c e i i pplc e be a s t co tdi no de de w he he t
ti
ha he le as s na i abl c e he ur d t ci
t r he
i ont t biiy saut ba r d untme ycli st tapol y i v d ab i to,i t d a di t
nc esa lt t t e r e
i l am ha
i s oi
nii nsea voi ng he
is by cas iyi t pl ntf scli asonet tt p lc wa voi e.
s ue
l sf ng he ai if a m
ha he iy s dabl
I

k
)
,
.

!
-

7-

:
;
I

:
'
.

I

7
t

)
.
E
j

7
(

.
'

I

I

Mu. feI s Co v Ca u o,h c u t edt a p sa eo t eic n e tbii p ro p e e tdte
tL n . . . r s te o r h l h t a s g f h n o tsa lt e id r v ne h
y
pli ifi ur rfom brngi a a tona i tispolc ol , e ki ade a atont tiwa not
antf ns e r
i ng n c i ga ns t iy der s e ng clr i ha t s
oblgaedt pa lf i ur ncebe ft be us t def a ha noi ur bl i e es i t lf of
i t o y ie ns a
ne is ca e he en nt d ns a e nt r t n he ie
1
,

t ed c d n .5 E,42 0( 9 9 .Thec u te s n pt a teis rb eitr s sauerq ie
h e e e t 35N. 2 7 1 8 )
o r ra o e h th n u a l n ee t ttt e ur s
1
-

t th poiy od rh v a is rbeitrs i telf o d cd n o l a tetmetec nrc
ha te l h le a e n n ua l neetn h ii f e e e t ny th i h o tat
c
!
i

wa ma e t rq iee d n eo i u a l itr s a ti lt d t c udn t nyi os a u d e
s d ;o e ur vie c f ns rb e ne et th s ae ae o l o o l mp e n n u
!

bur n on t polc de but a s nm c e tI t polc consde a i unde l ng
de
he
iyhol r
lo
ountr ö he
iy
i r tons
ryi

i on esa lt r quie nt . The de ede cons nt t t polc s i s nce a t i ur r
nc t tbiiy e r me s
c nt
e edto he iy' s ua
nd he ns e
i

ac pe tea piaino tesrn t o terprsnasns o tie i i.Iteisle d u td
c etd h p l to n h te gh fh e ee tto c nan d n t fh nt r o be
c
r

ted fn a t itrs,h b re rse o it iv si/ei atmeyma n r rg r tematr
h ee d n' neette ud n etd n to n etg n i l n e o inoeh te
s
!
i

a ispei.I quiy ma be a de a t publc pùr e unde l ng t i ur e i eet
t t rl ne t y voi d, nd he
i : pos
ryi he ns abl ntrs

rq ie n i e ne ,yarlwhc e c ua e teSsrroiv siaetei ua eitrs
e urme tmplme tdb ue ih n o rg sh I ue t n etg t h nsrbl neet
n
I

o isp lc h lespo l wi i tet -erp rl .Su h ivetg to wo l n to l
f t oiy od r rmpt t n h woy a eid c n siains ud o ny
y h
i

ei nt$ gr g'otcsuwold spo titeeyfr eigte oi bhn te
l a t ei ' nr tbt ud oo rmpl,hrb ut r h ply eidh
mi ewa n c a
/
hn
c
i

pr sonst t sa ut I TheFl i i ont sa lt sa ut i ba e o t s m epublcpolc
ovii o he t t e. d
orda nc e tbiiy t t e s s d n he a
i iy
i
COI CO S.
K

i

I c es i whi h polces a e voi bl f fa Fl i lw clary dit t t t
n as n
c
ii r
da e or r vd, orda a
e l c aes hat he
(

ic netblt sauesre t ba teis rsatm/st c neth poiyatrtet -er
n o tsa iiy ttt ev s o rh nme' te ! o o tste l fe h woy a
c
p ro h se pr d a d s rb da o e Sot o s o l $eic n e tblt ca e i t eGui
e id a x ie , s e cie b v . o h ud n o tsa iiy lus s n h l
d
i

Polciss r et ba Pr c st nl veied a tmpt t s ve tt clus by c a sf i t fa
i e e v o r u o' hi y l te s o u r he a es
l s iyng he r ud
a l ge y c m it d ag ns i asnake t a k ofi ur bl i e es . l a STO LIcont xt a l k of
le dl om te ai t t
ddc
l
ns a nt r t' n
'
e , ac

i ur bl i e e tmaynotbedi dedfom t faudt t a e i,Fl i co t ha ma i ce r
ns a e ntr s
vi r he r ha c t d t orda urs ve de t la
-

8-

!

i

t ta i ur rm a notc le apolc bas d on fa outi t saut yperod. Thi Cour
ha n ns e y
hal nge
iy e
ru
sde he t t or
i
s
t
hol t twhehe t fa r nde st polc voi
ds ha
t r he r ud e r he iy dabl orvoi ab i to i i ns nta ;t s
d
nii s nco eque i l hi
hol e pe al tu i t s c e, whe e Pr o' l c of i ur e i e es cai i uli t l
ds s cily r e n hi as
r uc s a k
ns abl nt r t l m s tma ey
ta a et fa
r ce bl o r ud.

The pur e oft sa ut i t pr de t i r d wih c rant whie sm ula ousy
pos
he tt e s o ovi he ns e t e ti y
l i t ne l
pr vi ngt i ur rwih a opporuniyt dicove fa a ns i. Se M ilr 424 F. d a 111
o di he ns e t n
t t o s r r u gai t t e le ,
3 t 5.

Alo n Pr c t c ne tt e Gu l Poiisa trsv n y aswo l r s l i a u d s r e
lwig u o o o ts h id l e fe e t e r u d e ut n n n e e v d
c
!
'

j

wnfl t iurnwu pcaudeuejot plyoewosoeet
i ath n rad ol lennubrnpnh oc lr hi tvnh
dlo e se
da
d
e ihd, n e
o i na pr le oft Polces U .S. nk woul ha o r c tuc apas t whih i wasnota
rgi l octr r he i i .
Ba
d ve e onsr t
to c t
pa t Pr coha t ye r t a c ran t a lged fa comm it d agans i; o pe mi Pr ot
ry. u
d wo a s o s e ti he le
r ud
te
i t t t r t uc o
c es t Polc e now me ey be aus t fa a l dl r nde e t Polcesvoi ab i to
ont t he ii s
r l c e he r ud leg y e r d he i i
d
nii
r t rt n voi bl woul def a t pur eoft sa t .
ahe ha
da e
d e t he pos
he t t e
Bec us Pr co di notbrng t s a ton t c e tt va i t oft Guid Polc e untl
a e u
d
i hi ci o ont he ldiy he l
ii s i

De mbe 1 201 mor t n fveye sahe t t y a i ont t biiype i e r d, Count
ce r 7, 2, e ha i
ar
r he wo- r nc esa lt rod xpie
li ba r dasam a troflw a t f l t sa eacai pon whi h r le ca begr ntd.4 Pr
s re
te a nd hus ais o tt l m
c ei f n
a e
uco
i note il t c e tt vai t oft Guid Polces Ac di y, i i
s
ntted o ont s he ldiy he l
ii
cor ngl t s
I

I
1
l

4Be us CountIi dim is pur ua t t i nt t biiys aut / a e, t Cour
ca e
s s s ed s nt o he nc esa lt tt eclus he
t
doe notr a h t is soft a i a lt oft ge r lsa ut oflm ia i , t exit nceof
s
e c he s ue
he pplc biiy he ne tt e i t tons he se
a i ur bl i e e t o Pr o' e il e t t pr m i s
n ns a e nt r s , r uc s nttem nt o he e u .

-

9-

'

t

ADJ
UDGED t tU. Bn sm o i t dimi Count1oft co pl i i GRAN TED .
ha S. nk' ton o s s
he m ant s

h
I
DONE AND ORDERED i Cha be sa M i Fl i , t s
n
m r t ami orda hi

da ofAug t 201
y
us, 3.
...*
.. *
.
'
.''
'
k
,'
.
. .;.
.

i

.
.. -

sr

-

g
.>r
,
f. y
r
.

.

w- -ee'

e

a

..
,.
- .

FE ERI A. o' NO
C
M '
UN TED STATES D I
STRI J D G E
CT U

Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:

i
l

Couns ofRe r
el
co d

1
I
i
I
1

I
I

I

I

I
I
I
i
l

-

10-