INTERCOL JV CORPORATION et al v. BAL HARBOUR QUARZO, LLC et al

Filing 105

ORDER Denying 103 Stipulated Motion for Entry of Stipulated Confidentiality Order. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/18/2015. (jw)

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STR I C O URT
CT
SO UTH ERN DISTR I O F FLO R I
CT
DA
M I IDI I O N
AM
V SI

CA SE N O. 1 24449- V -1m 6
2C1 1
VI
CTORI G I
A RALD O a V I
nd CTORI
A
GI LDO,
M
Pl ntf s
ai if ,

BAL HARBOUR QUARZ0,
LLC, UAN G.
J
ARCI A ,CARLO S M AH ECHA ,SYNERGY
L
CAPI
TAL G RO UP,LLC,OA DEVELOPM ENTS,
I ,LUN A D EV ELOPM ENTS GROUP,LLC,
NC.
Def ndant .
e
s
/

ORDER DENYI STI
NG
PULATED M OTI FOR ENTRY OF STI
ON
PULATED
CO NFI EN TI LI O RD ER
D
A TY
TH I CA U SE com e bef e t Cour upon t pari s' Stpul t M oton f
S
s or he
t
he
te
i a ed
i or

En r of Stpult d Co i e tal y Or r (h û oto ' ( 1 3) fld Au s 1
ty
i a e nfd n i i de t e i in' DE 0 , ie
t
M
)
gu t 4,
2 5 The en,t pa te s bmitd a pr s d Stpult d Confd n i l y Or r (
01 . r i he ris u te
opo e i a e
i e tai
t de DE
1 - ) whih t y woul h ve g e n dic e y a o h r p oc e ng d i g t i
03 1, c he
d a ov r s ov r nd t e r e di s urn h s
ltgaton.
ii i
A fe a r vi w oft pari M oton a pr
tr e e
he tes'
i nd opos d or ,t Courtfndst t
e der he
i
hat he
pari ha ofer no com peli bas s t ove t n t Cour' l
tes ve f ed
lng
i o
rur he
ts ong- t ng prnci e
sandi
i pl

a pr tc of m ai ai ng Cour pr eedi and docum e s as publc.t-he Fede al
nd ac i e
nt ni
t oc ngs
nt
i ûl
r

J c ar has ze ousy pr ec ed t rghtofal cii ens t f ee,ope a publc ti l .'
udi i y
al l ot t he i
1 tz
o r
n nd
i r a s'

Dor man v Gl z r No.0 2 ,2 4 W L 1 8 ,a #1( D.Fl .M a .1 20 4)
s
. ae ,
3- 2861 00
368 66 t S. a r 0, 0 ,

Ope j iil o e dngsaer tdi çgl p i i et tusiec n ts vvebe id
n udca pr c e i r ooe n : he rncpl ha j tc a no ur i hn
t
w a l of s l ,'a i lt (
ls
ience' nd n she Angl Am ercan ditus f s r t t i s''She
oi
sr t or ec e ral .' ppar v.
d

sfx l,38 U, 33 3 (96 ( o i I r Olv r 3
a wel 4 S. 3, 49 1 6) qu tng n e ie , 33U. 25 268 (948)
S. 7,
1 ).
Exce i r r i t
pt n a e nsances i i t rght of e r A m e i an t s t publc' bus nes
, t s he i
ve y
r c o ee he
i s i s

c nd tdi a o nfr m.Un e t spr
o uce n n pe o u 1 d r hi ecedent j iild ume saeprs tv l
, ud ca oc
nt r e umpiey
avaiabl t t publc but m a be s ed i t rghtt a s i out ei
l e o he
i
y
eal f he i
o cces s w ghed by ot
her
hi
gher i er t f i non- s os e.See Ni v.Warner Comm c' ,I ,435 U .
nt es s avorng
dicl ur
xon
ns nc.
S.

5 9,6 ( 97 ) Thi Cou tha b oa dic ei n i e l tng s h a m o i n.I r
8 02 1 8 . s r s r d s r to n vaua i uc
to n e
Alx e Gr t Co.Lii ,8 0 F.d 35 35 ( 1h Ci.1 7) l s s ha b e
e and r ant :
t
tg. 2 2 2, 7 1 t r 98 . l e ve e n
ca
cl ed on r e oc i w her f e
os
ar cas ons
e, or xampl dicl ur of cerai i or aton w oul
e, s os e
t n nf m i
d
t ea en natonal s iy or pl ce an i vi
hr t
i
ecurt
a
ndi dual i gr physcal dange .'D or m an,
n ave
i
r'
s
2004 W L 1368866,at*2.

Such r r occ i a e notpr enti t above-t ed a i whi h a ies outof
a e as ons r
es n he
syl cton, c r s
a aleged Ponzis
n l
chem e.Though t publc has no Fis A m e
he
i
rt
ndm entr ghtof ac s t
i
ces o
pr ti di over m at r al,t pari m us s
e ral sc y
e i s he tes
t how good ca e f apr ec i or r I r
us or ot tve de . n e

Alxande Gr ('Co.L ii ,820 F. at357.W hie t M oton is fm a no efor
e
r ant :
t
tg.
2d
l he
i t el kes
f t

t j tf is e r t Co r c n gla fom a r viw o t pr pos d S iult d
o usiy t nty, he u t a e n r
e e f he o e tp ae
lThe St t of Fl i , i 1
ae
orda n 967,ens i
hrned t s e prnci e by pas a of Fl i s
he am
i pl
s ge
orda'
Gove nm e i Suns ne Law ,t expansve s ope ofwhi was confr ed by t sJ
r nt n
hi
he
i c
ch
im
hi udge

i Be n v Ci o imiBe c (np ihe o nin) af' 231 So.2d 8 7 ( a 3
n r s . t fM a
y
a h, u ubls d pi o , f d
4 F1. d
DCA 1 70 , i dic r d b 2 So. d 38( a 1 )
9 ) wrt s ha ge y 45 2
Fl . 971 .

Confdentalt Or t t pa te a e conc ned ce t n dicove y r
i i iy der hat he ri s r
er
rai s
r eques s Sm a
t t y

r quie dicl ur of i or a i a
e r
s os e
nf m ton nd pr
oduc i of docum e s com pr i i
ton
nt
om sng
c
onsde i c
ntal omm e ci , pr i t y, tade s e , per onnel and/
r al
opre ar
r
ecr t
s
or fna al
i nci
i or a i ' See D E 1 1 a 1.Thes s ee ng s a em ent a e i ufi ent t s
nf m ton.'
03- t
e w pi t t
s r ns fci
o how

good caus f t pum os ofa pr e i or .
e or he
es
ot ctve der

l a dii ,t e pa te elce t s e ( nd de e d)r le i a publcy o r t d
n d ton h ri s e t d o e k a
f n e if n
i l pe ae
f um ,nam el t Unied St t D iti tCour f t Sout n D iti of Fl i The
or
y he
t
a es sr c
t or he
her s rct
orda.
pr eedi hel i f al and sat court a e ope t publc obse va i by a
oc ngs d n eder
t e
s r
n o
i
r ton
ny
i er t d pary.Pur ua t LocalRul 5. f t Sout r D iti t ofFl i abs
nt es e
t
s nt o
e 4 or he
he n s rc
or da, ent

s mee ta di r n e f sc e y t j di a a t pef r ds ul b op nt publc
o xror nay e d or e rc ,he u cil cs rome ho d e e o i
s r i .2
c utny

The Co r tn t tt pa t sha no s o g d c us t j tf t e rde ie
u t s ds ha he ri ve t h wn oo a e o usiy h i sr
e
f s r cy.Ther or t Courtc
or ec e
ef e, he
annot a doe not a ove t enty ofa si a ed
, nd
s , ppr
he r
tpul t
conidentalt or r.
i iy de

2 ûunl s ot r i e pr ded by l , Cour r e, or Cour or , pr
i es he w s ovi
aw
t ul
t der ocee ngs i t
di
n he
Unie St t D it i Cour ar publc and Cour flngs a e m a t r ofpublc r cor '
t d a es srct
t e
i
t ii
r
te s
i e d.'

S. Fl . R.54( )
D. a L. . a .
3

A cc di y, i i O R DERED, ADJU DG ED and DECR EED t t t pa tes'
or ngl t s
ha he ri

Stpu ae M oto f rEnty o Stpu ae Co e taiy Or e ( 1 3)be a d t e
i lt d
in o
r f i lt d nsd n i l
t d r DE 0
,n h
s e i,her D EN I .
am s eby
ED

DO N E and O RD ER ED i Cham be satt J esLawr
n
r
he am
ence K i Fe alJ tce
ng der us i

Buidi and U nie St t D it i Courhous M i i Fl i t s 18t day ofAugus ,
l ng
t d a es srct
t e, am , orda, hi h
t
201
5.

J M ES LA W
NCE K I G
N
I
TED STA TES DI
STRI
CT D GE
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF ORI
CT
DA
Cc:A 1 couns lofRec d
1
e
or