Zarco Marine Group, LLC v. Westerbeke Corporation

Filing 21

ORDER Granting 11 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 11/7/2013. (jw)

Download PDF
UN I TED STATES D I STR I CO UR T CT SO UTH ERN DI STRICT O F FLO RI A D M I I DI I O N AM V SI CA SE N O .13- 20082cvJLK ZARCO M A RI E GROUP,LLC, N Pl ntf , ai i f W ESTERBEKE CORPOM TI , ON D ef nda . e nt / ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DISM I NG S ON SS TH I CAU SE com es bef e t Cour upon D ef nts M oton t D im i s S or he t enda ' i o s s t uly i ed Ame e Compli ( E.11 fld Ap i 29 201 The m ater has been f l bref l nd d ant D. ) ie rl , 3. . The Co r tn t M oin s oul be g a td wih utprj c frf i e t sae a u t l ds he to h d rn e to eudie o al o tt ur caus ofacton. e i A com pl ntm us cont n s ta pl n sat e soft gr ai t ai hor nd ai t em nt he ounds f t cour ' or he ts j rs ci n,oft c us ofa to a o t r le s gh . d.R.Ci P.8 a . Und r u idi to he a e ci n, nd f he e if ou t Fe v. ( ) e t hei e he ght ned pl adi s a e ng t ndar s t f t by t Stpr e Cour i Bel At. Cor v ds e orh he l em tn l l p. T mbe 55 U. 5 ( 7 a As rh vI al 5 6U. 66 ( 01 ,heemus be wo ly, 0 S. 44 200 ) nd hc o qb , 5 S. 2 2 0) t r t i no h fcst saeacam t r le ta i plusbl o (he fc 'o t c ant k ug a t o tt li o eif h t s a i e n t ) a e' f he ompli . e Twom bly, 550 U. at 570. A pl i i fm us pl ad s ici nt f t t s e S. a ntf t e uf e ac s o how r i and elef 'Plitf fld aRe p ei Op iin t teM o i onM a 1 , 3( E.1 )a d De e a tflda an if ie s ons n posto o h ton y 6 201 D. 3 n f nd n ie Re yonJ e 11 201 ( E.1 ) pl un , 3 D. 8 . t or t l s and concl i .a f m ul c r t ton oft el ent ofa caus of i e han abel m usons.. or ai ecia i he em s e acton w ilnotdo.' d. i l '1 The Am e nded Com pl ntf ist pr de t Cour w ih s fc e f t M any of ai a l o ovi he t t uf i i nt ac s. t a s tons m ade ar concl or One s ence pr des m uli e exam pl s,$ or he s eri e us y. ent ovi tpl e $ On aboutSe em be 2011,Pl i ipsprnci ,Robe' Zar a t m pt t s a tt For ul pt r antf i pal l t co, te ed o t r he m a Gene a or utlzi t s e pr r t , ii ng he am ocedur f whi he ha becom e a t ed and e or ch d ccus om f lo ng t e i sr to p o de f i t e Ope aorsM a ua . D. 8 ! . How i o lwi h n tuci ns r vi d or n h r t ' n l' E. 45 ' s Rober Zar a pr nci ? W ha pr t co i pal t ocedur di he f l ? How di he becom e es d olow d ac t ed w ih t se pr edur ? H ow di he f l t M anual Si iarconcl or cus om t he oc es d olow he ? m l us y a t eadba e s a em ent a e f nd hr r tt s r ound t oughoutt A m e hr he nded Com pl nt Si pl satng ai . m y t i t teve s occur e orc tonswer s ts ha nt rd ondii e a i sed f l s toft pl ng r r e s. als hor he eadi equiem nt Fac s need t be gi t o ven t t t l a s or ha e l t y. Pl di ea ngs lke, ûpl ntf notfe i ç ai i f ii d W e t r e a / r isAu ho i e De lrs n o o mo e o c sons a / f r ly se b ke nd o t t rz d ae t )o ne r r c a i , nd or o ma l notfed W es e beke ofW eser ii tr t beke' f l e t tm el r pai t For ul Ge at ,'ar s aiur o i y e r he m a ner or' e s f l of cavea s and l cki i det is t t t Cour c o ul t a ng n a l ha he t annot f l t s or t olow he t y o un rtndt c i ofe n salge D. 8T . desa he han ve t le d. E. 41 A ddii ly, t Court ca tona l he nnot anal wheher or not t Fi Y ea Li ied yze t he ve- r m t W a r y a i s t t above-t e ac i be us i uf i e f ct ha bee aleged r ant pple o he syl d ton ca e ns fcint a s ve n l r di t ge at ' exi t e. The gene at w a m a by D ef nda ,a D el a e egar ng he ner or s senc r or s de e nt aw r com pany,a ca e t be ow ned by Pl ntf whe Pl i if pur has d a boatequi nd m o ai if n a ntf c e pped w ih t gener or The ge at s pat f om cr i t Pl ntf ow ner hi i t he at . ner or' h r eaton o ai ifs s p s unknow n. Thus t Cour ca , he t nnotc r nty de e m i t a i biiy of t W ar a y ur e l t r ne he pplca lt he r nt t Pl ntf ale tons Pl ntf underyi a es e i concl i t t w a r y o ai ifs l ga i . ai ifs l ng nd s ntal us on hat he r ant w a i f ce on w ha ever dat t gene a or alegedl s opped f toni pr ry i s n or t e he rt l y t unc i ng ope l s i ufi ent ns fci . Accor ngl afe a c ef r vi w of t r cor and t Cour bei ot r s di y, t r ar ul e e he e d he t ng he wi e f l advi e i i O RD ER ED and A DJUD G ED and DECR EED t t D ef ndants uly s d, t s ha e ' M o i t Dimis( E 1 ) b ,a t s me i,he e y GRANTED. Th Ame d ton o s s D. 1 e nd he a s r b e nde Co ant( E.8)i DI I mpli D. s SM SSED wihoutpr j c . Pli tf ha t it ( ) d ys t e udie a n if s h ry 30 a f om t dat oft sOr t fl a Se r he e hi der o ie cond Am e nded Com pl nt ai . D O NE and O R DERED i c ber att Ja esLawr nce K i Fe alJ tce n ham s he m e ng der us i Buidi and Unied St t Court e,M i m i Fl i t s 7t day ofN ove ber 201 l ng t a es hous a , orda hi h m , 3. / e . y ; : ' . . cc: A l Couns ofRecor l el d .' z c k ' y' Es LA W RENCE K UN I TED STA TES DI ST CT J GE UD SOU THERN DI STRI OF FLORI A CT D

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?