Zarco Marine Group, LLC v. Westerbeke Corporation

Filing 21

ORDER Granting 11 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 11/7/2013. (jw)

UN I
TED STATES D I
STR I CO UR T
CT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRICT O F FLO RI A
D
M I I DI I O N
AM
V SI
CA SE N O .13- 20082cvJLK

ZARCO M A RI E GROUP,LLC,
N
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

W ESTERBEKE CORPOM TI ,
ON
D ef nda .
e nt
/

ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DISM I
NG
S
ON
SS
TH I CAU SE com es bef e t Cour upon D ef nts M oton t D im i s
S
or he
t
enda '
i o s s
t
uly i ed
Ame e Compli ( E.11 fld Ap i 29 201 The m ater has been f l bref l
nd d
ant D. ) ie rl , 3.
.

The Co r tn t M oin s oul be g a td wih utprj c frf i e t sae a
u t l ds he to h d
rn e to eudie o al o tt
ur
caus ofacton.
e
i

A com pl ntm us cont n s ta pl n sat e soft gr
ai
t
ai hor nd ai t em nt
he ounds f t cour '
or he
ts

j rs ci n,oft c us ofa to a o t r le s gh . d.R.Ci P.8 a . Und r
u idi to
he a e ci n, nd f he e if ou t Fe
v. ( )
e
t hei e
he ght ned pl adi s a
e ng t ndar s t f t by t Stpr e Cour i Bel At. Cor v
ds e orh
he l em
tn
l l
p.

T mbe 55 U. 5 ( 7 a As rh vI al 5 6U. 66 ( 01 ,heemus be
wo ly, 0 S. 44 200 ) nd hc o qb , 5 S. 2 2 0) t r
t
i no h fcst saeacam t r le ta i plusbl o (he fc 'o t c ant
k ug a t o tt li o eif h t s a i e n t ) a e' f he ompli .
e
Twom bly, 550 U. at 570. A pl i i fm us pl ad s ici nt f t t s
e
S.
a ntf
t e uf e ac s o how r i and
elef

'Plitf fld aRe p ei Op iin t teM o i onM a 1 , 3( E.1 )a d De e a tflda
an if ie
s ons n posto o h ton
y 6 201 D. 3 n f nd n ie
Re yonJ e 11 201 ( E.1 )
pl un , 3 D. 8 .

t or t l s and concl i .a f m ul c r t ton oft el ent ofa caus of
i e han abel
m
usons.. or ai ecia i
he em s
e
acton w ilnotdo.' d.
i
l
'1

The Am e
nded Com pl ntf ist pr de t Cour w ih s fc e f t M any of
ai a l o ovi he
t t uf i i nt ac s.
t a s tons m ade ar concl or One s ence pr des m uli e exam pl s,$ or
he s eri
e
us y.
ent
ovi
tpl
e $
On

aboutSe em be 2011,Pl i ipsprnci ,Robe' Zar a t m pt t s a tt For ul
pt
r
antf
i pal
l
t co, te ed o t r he m a
Gene a or utlzi t s e pr
r t , ii ng he am
ocedur f whi he ha becom e a t ed and
e or
ch
d
ccus om

f lo ng t e i sr to p o de f i t e Ope aorsM a ua . D. 8 ! . How i
o lwi h n tuci ns r vi d or n h
r t ' n l' E. 45
'
s
Rober Zar a pr nci ? W ha pr
t co
i pal
t ocedur di he f l ? How di he becom e
es d
olow
d
ac t ed w ih t se pr edur ? H ow di he f l t M anual Si iarconcl or
cus om
t he
oc es
d
olow he
? m l
us y
a t eadba e s a em ent a e f
nd hr
r tt
s r ound t oughoutt A m e
hr
he
nded Com pl nt Si pl satng
ai . m y t i

t teve s occur e orc tonswer s ts
ha
nt
rd
ondii
e a i sed f l s toft pl ng r r e s.
als hor
he eadi equiem nt
Fac s need t be gi
t
o
ven t t t l a s or
ha e l
t y. Pl di
ea ngs lke, ûpl ntf notfe
i
ç ai i f ii d

W e t r e a / r isAu ho i e De lrs n o o mo e o c sons a / f r ly
se b ke nd o t t rz d ae t )o ne r r c a i , nd or o ma l
notfed W es e beke ofW eser
ii
tr
t beke' f l e t tm el r pai t For ul Ge at ,'ar
s aiur o i y e r he m a ner or' e
s f l of cavea s and l cki i det is t t t Cour c
o ul
t
a ng n
a l ha he
t annot f l t s or t
olow he t y o

un rtndt c i ofe n salge D. 8T .
desa he han ve t le d. E. 41
A ddii ly, t Court ca
tona l he
nnot anal wheher or not t Fi Y ea Li ied
yze
t
he ve- r m t

W a r y a i s t t above-t e ac i be us i uf i e f ct ha bee aleged
r ant pple o he
syl d ton ca e ns fcint a s ve n l
r di t ge at ' exi t e. The gene at w a m a by D ef nda ,a D el a e
egar ng he ner or s senc
r or s de
e nt
aw r
com pany,a ca e t be ow ned by Pl ntf whe Pl i if pur has d a boatequi
nd m o
ai if
n a ntf
c e
pped

w ih t gener or The ge at s pat f om cr i t Pl ntf ow ner hi i
t he
at .
ner or'
h r
eaton o ai ifs
s p s
unknow n. Thus t Cour ca
, he
t nnotc r nty de e m i t a i biiy of t W ar a y
ur e l t r ne he pplca lt
he
r nt

t Pl ntf ale tons Pl ntf underyi a es e i concl i t t w a r y
o ai ifs l ga i . ai ifs
l ng nd s ntal
us on hat he r ant
w a i f ce on w ha ever dat t gene a or alegedl s opped f toni pr ry i
s n or
t
e he
rt
l
y t
unc i ng ope l s
i ufi ent
ns fci .

Accor ngl afe a c ef r vi w of t r cor and t Cour bei ot r s
di y, t r ar ul e e
he e d
he
t ng he wi e
f l advi e i i O RD ER ED and A DJUD G ED and DECR EED t t D ef ndants
uly
s d, t s
ha
e
'

M o i t Dimis( E 1 ) b ,a t s me i,he e y GRANTED. Th Ame d
ton o s s D. 1 e nd he a s r b
e
nde
Co ant( E.8)i DI I
mpli D.
s SM SSED wihoutpr j c . Pli tf ha t it ( ) d ys
t
e udie a n if s h ry 30 a
f om t dat oft sOr t fl a Se
r he e hi der o ie
cond Am e
nded Com pl nt
ai .
D O NE and O R DERED i c ber att Ja esLawr nce K i Fe alJ tce
n ham s he m
e
ng der us i

Buidi and Unied St t Court e,M i m i Fl i t s 7t day ofN ove ber 201
l ng
t
a es
hous
a , orda hi h
m , 3.

/
e
.
y
;
:

'
.

.

cc:

A l Couns ofRecor
l
el
d

.'

z
c

k
'

y'

Es LA W RENCE K
UN I
TED STA TES DI
ST CT J GE
UD
SOU THERN DI
STRI OF FLORI A
CT
D