Streib v. United States of America
Filing
7
ORDER granting 4 Defendant's Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/12/2013. (err)
Streib v. United States of America
Doc. 7
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 20455- V- ORENO
e
r: 3CI M
J CK STREI ,
A
B
Pl ntf,
ai if
VS.
UN I
TED STA TES OF AM ERI ,
CA
De e nt
f nda .
ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI I
NG
S
ON
SM SS
THI CAUSE c mebefr t Cour uponDee nt M otont DimisComplit( E.
S
a
oe he
t
fnda ' i o s s
s
an D.
No.4) fldonM a 3. 3.
,ie
y 201
THE COURT hasc i r d t moton,es e, nd t pe tne pori oft r co d,
onsde e he i r pons a he ri nt tons he e r
a be ngot r s f l advie i t pr m ie ,i i
nd i
he wie uly
s d n he e s s t s
ADJUDGED t tt m o i i GRANTED .
ha he ton s
1 Backgr
.
ound
Th sc s aie u d rt eFe ea To t amsAc, U. C. 1 4 b a d2 U. C. j
i a e rs s n e h d r l r Cli
t28 S. j 3 6() n 8 S. j
2671268 ('
- 0'
FTCA'.Pli ifalege y fl on J y 28,2011whie i t c eoft Vee a
' antf l dl el ul
)
l n he ar he tr ns
Ad n srto h s ia d et t en gi e c o aho pi l mpo e wh ij rdhm whi hewa
miitain o pt l u o h e lg n e f s t e ly e o n u e i
a
l
e
s
eng ng i physca t r py.
agi n
i l he a
Pl i i ff l d hi s ton Fe uary 6.201 Def nda ' e ie cont nton f isM o i t
a ntf ie s ui
br
3. e nts ntr
e i or t
ton o
Dimis i t tPl i ifs s twas tld t lt a t ba r d by t St t e of Li ia i
s s s ha antf ui
ie oo a e nd hus re
he aut
m ttons.
De e ntpr en sevi ncet tt VA s ntisfnalno i ofde a ofc am onAprl1 201
f nda es t de
ha he
e t i
tce
ni l l i
i 2. 3,
Dockets.Justia.com
t tt no i e wa dei r d on Aprl1 2013,a t tt USPS r t ne a c ima i of
ha he tc
s lve e
i 6.
nd ha he
e ur d onfr ton
Cerii d M ai Dei r on Aprl23. 2.Pl ntf sCouns a guest t whiehedi r e vea
tfe
l lve y
i 201 ai if
el r
ha , l
d ec i n
e o add es e t hi on t tdae,t l te i i pe ti d t a he at ne on a he
nvelpe r s d o m
ha t he et r nsde rane o not r tor y
not r
ma t . n s
ter l uppor ofisM oton, enda ha s it d t de a l te ,hece tfe mai r t n
t t
i Def nt s ubm te he nil et r t
ri d l eur
c r an a fda t sa i t tt lte wa pr ryaddr s ed, it t c r te ope, nd
a d, d fi vis ttng ha he et r s ope l
e s put n o he orec nvel a
ma ld.nr pons Pl ntf ha s
ie l es e, ai if s ubmit a tdavhssai t t whiet e l wa r c ve
ted fi
t tng ha , l he nveope s e ei d,
t denillte wasnoti t e opea e s d t Def nda ' Couns l
he
a e tr
n he nvel
ddr s e o e nts
e.
I . e Anal i
I L gal
ys s
' Unie Sttsi g neal i
'
The td ae s e rly mmunefom s t i i s j c t s tonl i ofrasihas
r ui;t s ub e t o ui y ns a t
wave iss r gni
i d t oveei mmuniy.Compagnoniv UniedSt e l F. 1369,1 n. ( 1hCi.
t
. t ats, 73 3d
370 2 1 t r
1 . Fe r lTor Cl msActc ttt almie wai rofs r gni
999)The de a t ai
onsiues i td ve oveei mmuniy. li v
t Phil .
ps
Unie St e 260F. 1 6,1 8( 1h Ci. ) Stt esoflmiai i i t t Ditit
td ats,
3d 31 31 1 t r 2001 . aut
i ttons mplcae he src
Co r' s b e tmatr u idcin, ndc u t d n t v t s be tmatr u idcint h a a
u t u j c te j rs ito a o rs o o ha e he u jc te j rs ito o e r
s
cli t ti br
a m ha s ought trt e r tonoft r l ntsaut oflmia i Compa
afe he xpia i
he eeva t t e i t tons.
gnoni Unie
v. td
St e , 1 F. a 1
ats 73 3d t 370 n. ai r of s r i i muniy mus be src l c t u d,a
2.W ve s
ove egn m
t
t
tity onsr e nd
a g tesmus bers vedi fvorofi
mbiuii
t e ol n a
mmuniy.fanev Pe 518U. l 1 ( 996)
t
. na,
S. 87, 92 1 .
' t r cai a i t heUniedSt t ss l f r rba r unl si i pr e e i wrtng
' o t l m gans t
A
t a e halbe o eve red es t s es nt d n ii
t t a o i t Fede a a nc wihi t ye r ahe s h cai ac r sorunl sa toni beg
o he ppr prae
r l ge y t n wo a s r uc l m c ue
es ci s un
wihi sx mont a rt da eofm alng,b c tfe orr gitr d mai, notc offna de a
tn i
hs he he t
ii y erii d e se e
l of ie i l nil
oft cam byt a nc t whihiwaspes ntd. 28U. C. 2401b) The11hCic hasnot
he li
he ge y o c t
r ee '
' S. j
( .
t ruh
s r y hed whehert whe he t sx- ont cl k f flng aCompl i be nsu m a lng
qua el l
t he
t r he i m h oc or ii
ant gi pon ii
ofade albyt gove m e age y,a sa e i t sa ut orupon r ceptbyt Pl ntf,a
ni
he
m nt nc s t t d n he tt e,
e i
he ai if nd
t sa
hi ppea st beam a trofs
r o
te
omem i c uson.Compar Phil v.Unie St e 260 F.
nor onf i
e li
ps
td ats,
3d
a 1 7('iti undiput t tunde scin 2 ( ...helws tmus bec
t 31 ' ) s s ed ha
(
r e to 401b) t a ui t omme edwihi
nc
tn
sxmo t satrh r c it f fn l g n yd cso ')(mp a i a d d wihHil . ie tts
i nh fe te e ep o a i a a e c e iin' e h ss d e ) t lv Un tdsa e ,
l
296Fe Ap 921 921( 1h Ci.
d. px. ,
1 t r 2008)(d dititcou tdi notce rye rb fndi t tt
'he src r d
t
lal r y i ng ha he
fnaldenilofcam lte wasmaie on Febnzr 7,2007'.Coursi t Sout m Dititof
i
a
li etr
ld
ay
'
)
t n he
he
src
Fl i ha ge r l beg c i fom t da eofm a lng. , g. Wilamsv. uel r 201
orda ve ne aly un ountng r he t
ii See e. , li
M le , 2
W L3764895a * ( D. a. 2)( orno, .( s si cai fldmor t nsxmont afe
t 2 S. Fl 201 M e J) dimisng l m ie
e ha i
hs tr
daeofmaii a u i l ; l ov Unie ats2011W L902624a *2( D. a. 1 (
t
lng s ntmey)Peus . tdst e ,
t S. Fl 201 )Cohn,
J.(' BOP deni Pli ifsa nitai cl m onJ y 2,2009,i alte t wass tt
)'
The
ed antf dmi sr tve ai
ul
n etr hat
en o
Pl n ifby c rii mai o J y 7,2009... ai ift e or had sx m ont fom J y 7,2009
aitf
e tfed l n ul
Pl ntf her f e
i
hs r
ul
t b ighstr cams'.
o rn i o t li '
)
A c s mu tb ds se i t eCo r d tr n st ti lc ss be tmatrj rs ito
a e s e imis d f h u t eemie ha t a k u j c te u id ci n.
Fe R. v. Rs 1 ( )1 , 2 h ( ) A p ryma c alng s b e tmatr u id ci nb et e
d. Ci P. . 2 b ( ) 1 ( )3 . a t y h l e u j c te j rs ito y ih r
e
'a al or'a t l' ta .
' ci ' ' c ua 'a tcks
f
' f
Fa ilatc c aln es be tmatr u idcin b s d o tealg to si te
ca ta ks h le g u j c te j rs ito a e n h l ain n h
e
c
ompli , nd t diti tc t a t a lga i a tue i de di whe he t
ant a he src our t kes he le tons s r n ci ng
t ro
g a tte mo i n.F cu latc s c aln e s b e tmatrJ rs ito i fc,
rn h
to a ta ta k h l g u j c te ' id ci n n a t
e
u
ir peci oft pladi l r s vi a f c ua at c t diti cour m a
res tve he e ngs. n e ol ng a t l ta k, he srct
t y
1 Defnda c r cl noe i isRe yBre,t spasa fom Phil i dit The
As e nt ore ty ts n t pl if hi sge r
ll s ca.
ps
Phil sde son c
li cii once ne whe he Geor asr newalsa ut a i d t ac am br tunde
p
r d
t r
gi' e
tt e pple o l i ough
r
t e FTCA . li v Unie St e 26 F. a 1 7.I Phil Pl i ifa itdl br ght
h
Philps . td ats, 0 3d t 31 n li
ps, antf dm te y ou
he cai a trt expia i ofsx m ont ,bu a g t tt Geor ar ne lsaut ope a e
r l m fe he
r ton i
hs t r ued ha he
gi e wa t t e r t d
t e end he tm ef flng acli I a 1 l The 1lh Cicui hed t tGeor asr ne
o xt
r i or ii
a m. d t 3 8
t r t l ha
gi' e wal
saut wa no a i a et extnd t FTCA lm iai pe i 1 at1 9.
t t e s t pplc bl o e he
i t tons rod. d. 31
-
3-
c i re rnsce de e s h a t si
onsde xti i vi nc uc s e tmony a a fda t .
nd fi vis
a ua
Mo rs n v arwa Co p. 3 3 F.d 9 ,9 4 n. ( 1h.Ci.2 0 ) 'I t f ce ofa f ct l
r io .dp z r s 2 3 20 2 5 1 t r 0 3 . 'n he a
c aln et s b e tmatrj rs ito t ebud n i o t eplitf t p o e ta j rs ito
h le g o u j c te u id ci n, h r e s n h anif o r v h t uidcin
e ss'OS11 . Unie ats 285F. 947, ( 1hCi 2002)(ii Thoms v Gas l, 5
xit.
' nc v. tdst e ,
3d 951 1 t r.
ctng
on . kil31
U. 4 2 4 (9 2 . he s b e t te j rs ito i f c dwi f cu l ta k 'hetil o r
S. 4 , 46 1 4 ) W n u j c matr u id ci n s a e t a ta atc ,' ra c u t
h
t
i fe t wei t e de e a s ts y is l a t t e se ofispowe t he rt c s '
s r e o gh he vi nc nd a if t ef s o he xitnce t
r o a he a e.
'
Lawr nc v Du ar, 9F. 1 15 ( 1hCi.1 .'ns tnopr umpi tuhf nes
e e . nb 91 2d 525, 29 1 t r 990) ' hor, es tve rt ul s
l
at c t pl ntf sale tons, nd t e se eofdipu e m a e i f c swilnotpr c udet
ta hes o ai if lga i a he xit nc
s t d t ral a t l
e l he
til o r fo e au tn frisl t emeiso j rs ito a cams'I
ra c u tr m v lai g o tef h rt f u idcin l li . d.
'
l t i t tc e,t De t tofVe e a Afaisdr fe a fnalno i ofde a of
n he nsan as he parmen
t r ns f r a td i
tce
nil
cai on Aprl1 201 l s ntalterb c tfe m a lt t Pli tf o t tdae,a t lte
lm
i 2, 3. t e
e t y erii d i o he a n if n ha t nd he et r
wa r ceve on Aprl1 201 Pli tf se iea gumen a i tdi mi s li t tt lte i t
se i d
i 6, 3. a n if ntr r
t ga ns s s a s ha he et r n he
e ope s ntt Pl ntf s Couns lwas no i f c t lte de ng Pli ifscli ,buta
nvel
e o ai if
e
t n a t he et r nyi
antf
a ms
n
unr aedlte oa unr a e pa t ha wa a ci nt lyputi ot wr e ope. ai ifr t
elt et rt n elt d ryt t s c de al
nt he ong nvel Pl ntf ess
t e ie weghtofis a gumen on t 11h Cicui' us oft wo d 'ec i d'i Phil t
he ntr i
t r
t he t r ts e he r ' e ve ' n li o
r
ps
d tr n wh n t co k b gnsn n ig o te saue o l tto su e j 4 ( ) Be a s
ee mie e he lc e i z nn n h tt t f i ai n nd r 2 01b . c u e
mi
Pli tf ne r c ve t de a ofc am s he a gue ,t c oc neve sa t Ass h,Pl i if
a n if ver e ei d he nil l i , r s he l k
r t red. uc
antf
fldhi cli a beng ' e dde e ' r28U. C. 2675(
ie s am s i de me nid'unde
S. j
$.
Be a s t si af cu l ta ko s b e t t r u idcin ii Plitf sb r e t p o e
c u e hi s a ta at c n u j c mat j rs ito ,ts anif u d n o r v
e
j iditone ss notheDee ntsbur nt pr t tidoe notOS1l . Unie ats 285
urs ci xit, t fnda ' de o ove ha t s . nc v. tdst e ,
F. a 951.To s ppo tis poston,Pli if ha pr ded t afi vi ofis a t ne a is
3d t
u r t
ii
antf s ovi
he fda t t tor y nd t
at ne ss c e a y.I i undiput d t tal core ponde fom t VA t Pli ifwa s ntt
tor y' e r t r t s
s e ha l r s
nce r he
o a ntf s e o
Pl i ifsat e De e nthasas pr de a fdavis l hasa afi vh fom Gar Slm me
antf tom y. f nda
lo ovi d fi t .t
n fda r
y e
ns
who sa e he dr td t lte de ng t c am a f wa ded i t t tc di t De y
tts
afe he e tr nyi he l i nd or r
t o or oor naor we
J on f fna pr es i De e ntpr de De y J on' a tda tsatngt theputt
ohns or i l oc sng. f nda ovi d we ohns s fi vi t i ha
he
lte de ng Pl ntf cai i ot e opea es e t Pl i ifsa t
etr nyi ai ips l m nt he nvel
ddr s d o antf tonwy. Unie St ts
The t d ae
ha a s s
s lo ubmit a c oft l te de ng Stei scl m ,a copy of c rii m alr cept
ted opy
he et r nyi
r b' ai
e tted i e i
s
howi t tt e ope wa pr pe l addr s ed,a a c of t r t n s
ng ha he nvel
s o ry
es
nd opy
he e ur howi t tt
ng ha he
e opewa delver d.
nvel
s i e
l
mporan l Pl i ifhas notp ovi d e n a r ctd c
t ty, antf
r de ve
eda e opy oft lte i s ppos dl
he et r t u
e y
r c i dfom t VA r sngt pos i lt t tam it kewasm a Raher Pl ntf sat e ha
e e ve r he
aii he sbiiy ha
sa
de. t , ai if tom y s
sae 'thi fl neve rviwss hmatr,ne rr dst maei norma sac ofsme
ttd ' l s i'
g
m
r e e uc tes ve ea he tral
ke opy a ,
buti t ad i e a ey put t ma e i li a e opean f wadsi t t pr
nse mm dit l
s he t ra n n nvel
d or r t o he operr c pint'
ei e .
'
Plitf s nieag me t e ksot r teb r e o e tbihigs b e t te j rs ito
anip e t r u n s e t u n h u d n f sa ls n u j c matru id cin
r
on ishe Unde t r e Pli ifes e ,t i e i f ato n a pa te whoar l s
t ad.
r he ul antf pous s he nc ntves or t r eys nd ris
e es
t ndii nti m a gi t rc est blm et s nderwoul i r as dr tc l I Pl ntf s
ha lge n na ng hei as o a he e
d nc e e ama ialy. f ai if
r ewe ei f r notonl woul t govemm e ha t pr t ti dr fedade ale t , ld
ul r n o ce,
y
d he
l nt ve o ove ha t a t
ni lter maie
i by c rii m a l a t tt mai wa delver d,i woul ha t pr t tt gove me
t e tfed i, nd ha he l s i e t
d ve o ove ha he
m nt
e ly e whod a tdt eltesa dp t h m i t e eo saec mp tn a t er o sa dta
mpo e s
rfe h etr n u t e n he nv lpe r o ee t th ij b n h t
1 m al a i a uprghtctze l ed,i ' di tge t lte ' we e gi n t t ls
he im n s n i
ii n. nde f ' dn' t he et r' r ve he aimani
l
c
te t n Plitfwa t, ohn s o t f ie d c me tn t elte'j u n yfo g v r me t
rame t an if n s n t ig h ro avd o o u ni g h etr o r e r m o e n n
s
prntrt c am a ' ha woul s tsy t gove m e ' bur n. a n ifsa gum e i s i ,
i e o l i nts nds
d ai f he
m nts de Pli tf r
nt s pecous
a t s Cou tc r gi i c ede .
nd hi
r a mot ve t r nce
Fi ly, antf ha ciedt Fit Cic t s st s
na l Pli if s t wo fh r uica e o uppor isposton, ari zv.Unie
tt
ii M tne
td
St e 7 F. 694(t Ci.1 a Fl yv.Unie St e 138F. 1 ( hCi.1 . s
ats, 28 2d
5h r 984) nd or
td ats,
3d 57 5t r 998) Thi
Cour frtnot t t ast s de sonsca a trt 5 h Cic ts i,he a enotbi ngon t s
t is es ha , he e cii
me fe he t r ui plt t y r
ndi
hi
Co r. e Bo n rv Ci o ih r , 61F.d1 0 1 09( 1hCi. 9 )Ho v rt tee tn
u tS e n e . t fprc a d 6 2 2 6, 2 1 t r 1 81 . we e ,o h xe t
y
t tt e c s s a e r e t t y acualy har Pl i ifs poston.M ari z,i r l ntpa t
ha hes a e r elvan , he t l
m antf
ii
tne n eeva
r,
c e e t lnguag r quie f al t fom t go r ntt gi apl ntf s fc e no i
onc m d he a
e e r d or eter r he ve nme o ve ai if ufi i nt tce
t tiscli wasbeng de eda t cl khadsare t r M ari zv Uniedst e ,7 F.
ha t a m
i
ni nd he oc
t td o un. tne . t ats 28 2d
a 698.l Fl y,t 5 h Cic t dee mi t tacua no i e wa not s tcentt be n t
t
n or he t r ui tr ned ha t l tc
s
ufi i o gi he
lmia i cl k;r t rt de a lte mus be ' e 'or' l 'n a c danc wiht saut
i t tons oc ahe he nil et r t ' nt' ' ed'i c or e t he t t e.
s
mai
Fl y v.Unie St e ,1 F. a 1 N o r doese t roft e c esaddr s t bur of
or
td at s 38 3d t 60. whe e
ihe
hes as
e s he den
pr t go nme mus s t ti ' l 'hedocumen nort srnge wihwhi c t
oof he ver nt t how ha t ' ed't
mai
t
he ti ncy t
ch ours
s d m a t gove n e pr ve t tPl i if ' e ei d't deni lte .Thus t s ca e
houl
ke he
r m nt o ha antf ' c ve ' he
r
al e t r
, he e s s
pr deno s
ovi
uppor f Pli ifsco e i .
t or a ntf
nt ntons
111.C oncl on
usi
Fort r s sa e a
he ea ons t t d bove,t sCour he e GRANTS De e ntsM oton t Dimis
hi
t r by
f nda '
i o s s
Co ant The Compl i wa tl d a trt sxmpli .
ant s i e fe he i mont wi
h ndow a ia et aPl i ifafe s
va lbl o
antf tr he
rc i e atn lode o d n a u de t eF
e ev s i a r r f e il n r h TCA. u ,h sCo r lc ss b e t te j rs ito
Th s t i u ta k u j c matr u id cin
ove t i c s Pl n ifsCompli ti he eb DI I
r h s a e. aitf
a n s r y SM SSED W I PREJ CE.
TH
UDI
DO A O DE E ic a est a Fl ida,t X dyoA gs 21.
NE ND R R D n hmbraMi or hi a f uut 03
mi
,
,
FED
CO A . REN O
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi pr dedt
es ovi o:
Couns ofRec d
el
or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?